Real Self-Care

Real Self-Care Plot Summary

Introduction

Modern wellness culture has sold women a false narrative, promising salvation through juice cleanses, yoga retreats, and expensive self-care products. Yet despite the $4.4 trillion global wellness industry, women are experiencing higher rates of burnout, anxiety, and depression than ever before. This disconnect reveals a fundamental problem: what passes for self-care today is often "faux self-care" – commodified practices that keep us looking outward rather than addressing our deeper needs, ultimately serving to maintain systems that fail women rather than challenging them. The path forward requires distinguishing between these external quick fixes and what constitutes genuine self-care – an internal process centered on four transformative principles: setting boundaries, practicing self-compassion, aligning with personal values, and asserting power. By turning inward and making deliberate choices about how we spend our time and energy, we create a cascade effect that not only improves our individual wellbeing but also influences our relationships, workplaces, and broader social systems. This revolutionary framework shows that real self-care isn't about treating ourselves to temporary escapes but about reclaiming agency in a world that systematically devalues women's time, energy, and autonomy.

Chapter 1: The Illusion of Faux Self-Care in Modern Wellness Culture

The concept of self-care has undergone a radical transformation since its origins. In the 1950s, psychiatrists used the term to describe how institutionalized patients could assert independence through managing their own diets and exercise routines. By the 1970s, self-care had evolved into a political statement when the Black Panther Party embraced it as a means for Black Americans to preserve their humanity amid systemic racism. Audre Lorde captured this revolutionary spirit when she wrote, "Caring for myself is not self-indulgence, it is self-preservation, and that is an act of political warfare." Today's version of self-care bears little resemblance to these empowering roots. With over 60 million Instagram posts tagged #SelfCare featuring everything from beachside yoga to "curative" smoothies, self-care has become indistinguishable from consumption. The wellness industry sells products and practices as solutions to women's problems while ignoring the underlying causes of their distress. This commodified approach creates a sugar high – temporary relief that quickly fades, leaving women feeling worse for failing to "do self-care right." The tyranny of modern self-care not only fails to address women's needs but adds another burden to their already overwhelming to-do lists. Women report feeling guilty for not engaging in enough self-care practices, creating a vicious cycle where the supposed solution becomes yet another source of stress. Meanwhile, meaningful mental health treatment remains financially inaccessible for many, with the wellness industry stepping in to offer poor substitutes. Faux self-care operates as a method rather than a principle – a short-term fix rather than a sustainable solution. Consider Shelby, a new mother struggling with breastfeeding her premature daughter. Her usual self-care activities like exercise only added more pressure as she compared her postpartum body to her pre-pregnancy capabilities. True relief came not from adding more wellness practices but from making the difficult decision to stop breastfeeding – setting a boundary that allowed her to reconnect with herself and her family. Real self-care requires an internal shift, focusing on guiding principles rather than external methods. It involves making sometimes uncomfortable choices that align with our deeper needs and values. While faux self-care offers temporary escape, real self-care brings lasting transformation by addressing the underlying causes of our distress and changing how we relate to ourselves and the world around us.

Chapter 2: Why Women Fall into Escape, Achievement, and Optimization Traps

Women turn to faux self-care through three primary mechanisms, each representing an understandable yet ultimately unsustainable coping strategy. The first approach is escape – using wellness practices as a temporary reprieve from overwhelming responsibilities. Consider Monique, a nurse who periodically splurged on expensive retreats where she was pampered by strangers. These getaways provided momentary relief but never translated into sustainable changes in her daily life. Like many women, Monique used wellness retreats as escape hatches from her relentless caregiving responsibilities, offering brief glimpses of being cared for before returning to her hectic, overscheduled routine. The second trap is achievement-oriented self-care, where women bring the same perfectionistic mindset to wellness that they apply to other areas of life. Sharon, recently laid off from her journalism career, dove into wellness practices with the same laser focus she had used professionally – tracking her running times, documenting her yoga progress, and consuming self-help books voraciously. Yet despite this frenzy of "self-care" activity, she felt isolated and desperate. Sharon's approach wasn't rooted in compassion but in shame, using wellness achievements as another measuring stick for her worth. The third pattern emerges as optimization – the relentless pursuit of efficiency in service of theoretically creating more time for self-care. Anita, a small business owner and mother of three, approached organizing her household with hypercompetence, researching endless productivity tools and outsourcing solutions. Yet even with these time-saving strategies, she never felt complete. The optimization mindset kept her constantly planning and organizing rather than being present with her family or herself, trapped in her prefrontal cortex without accessing the emotional parts of her brain where connection and authenticity reside. These coping mechanisms share a common thread – they keep women spinning on a hamster wheel of external solutions while preventing them from addressing deeper needs. Research shows that well-being is linked to feeling unconditionally loved, comforted when distressed, authentic in relationships, and satisfied with friendships – none of which can be achieved through juice cleanses or productivity apps. When women use faux self-care as a coping mechanism, they remain disconnected from their authentic selves. Faux self-care offers temporary relief through these three mechanisms, but that relief doesn't last because it doesn't challenge the systems that cause women's distress in the first place. Instead, it perpetuates the narrative that women must fix themselves rather than questioning the societal structures that burden them with impossible expectations. This serves capitalistic interests by keeping women focused on individual solutions rather than collective change, distracting them from addressing the root causes of their exhaustion and overwhelm.

Chapter 3: System Failure: The Rigged Game Behind Women's Burnout

Women aren't suffering from a lack of resilience or insufficient self-care practices – they're experiencing the consequences of systemic betrayal. This becomes evident in the story of Mikaleh, a 41-year-old woman who became her father's sole caregiver after her mother passed away. Despite having four adult brothers living nearby, none offered help. Mikaleh worked full-time, raised two teenage daughters, and managed her father's medical needs without questioning why this burden fell solely on her shoulders. Her situation exemplifies how women's time and energy are treated as infinitely exploitable resources. The data confirms this systemic problem: women report higher stress levels than men and are nearly twice as likely to suffer from anxiety and depression. The Bright Horizons 2017 Modern Family Index found that working women are twice as likely to manage household responsibilities and three times more likely to manage children's schedules than their male partners. Following the COVID-19 pandemic, researchers discovered the gender gap in work hours increased by 20 to 50 percent, with women overwhelmingly providing childcare while simultaneously working from home. This imbalance reflects what writer Meg Conley describes as a "multilevel marketing scheme," where motherhood in America promises rewards that never materialize for most women. The system operates like a pyramid, with a few white, well-resourced women at the top and the majority – disproportionately Black, brown, and working-class women – forming the base. Women are sold the false hope that if they keep sacrificing themselves, eventually someone will take care of them. Silvia Federici, a scholar of domestic labor, connects women's struggles to unpaid "reproductive labor" – the endless work of keeping pantries stocked, managing family schedules, and tending to family members' needs. This labor extends to the "mental load" – the cognitive and emotional energy spent anticipating, identifying, deciding upon, and monitoring household needs. Research published in Sex Roles found that bearing a disproportionate mental load correlates with emotional emptiness and lower relationship satisfaction. Beyond the unequal division of labor, women face contradictory cultural expectations that create what Martha Beck calls a "koan" – an unsolvable riddle. Women are expected to excel professionally while being selfless caregivers, to practice self-care while putting everyone else first. These mutually exclusive demands trap women in a no-win situation where guilt becomes inevitable regardless of their choices. The way forward isn't through more individual wellness practices but through recognizing that personal transformation can spark systemic change. This begins with embracing "dialectical thinking" – acknowledging that opposing realities can coexist. For Mikaleh, this meant recognizing she could love her father deeply while admitting she alone couldn't care for him. When she took a mental health leave, set boundaries with her brothers, and advocated for workplace changes, her individual act of real self-care rippled outward to benefit others in her organization. This demonstrates how internal shifts can lead to external transformation, challenging the systems that fail women through small but significant acts of resistance.

Chapter 4: The Four Principles of Authentic Self-Care

Real self-care differs fundamentally from the commodified practices promoted by the wellness industry. While faux self-care offers temporary relief through external activities, real self-care involves an internal process aligned with eudaimonic well-being – living a life of meaning, purpose, and authenticity. Research shows that eudaimonic well-being correlates with improved sleep, longer lifespan, and lower inflammation levels. This form of well-being isn't achieved through fleeting pleasures but through aligning our actions with our deepest values. The four principles of real self-care provide a framework for cultivating eudaimonic well-being. The first principle is setting boundaries and moving past guilt. This involves recognizing that you have choices about how you spend your time and energy, communicating those choices to others, and learning to tolerate the inevitable guilt that follows. Boundaries create the space necessary for all other aspects of real self-care to flourish. The second principle centers on treating yourself with compassion. This means changing how you talk to yourself, moving away from harsh self-criticism and shame-based thinking toward kindness and acceptance. Self-compassion isn't about giving yourself a pep talk but developing a more flexible relationship with your mind and recognizing your common humanity with others who struggle. The third principle focuses on bringing you closer to yourself by identifying and living according to your values. Unlike goals, which are tangible objectives, values describe how you want to interact with the world and what qualities matter most to you. When your actions align with your values, you experience a sense of authenticity and fulfillment – your outsides match your insides. The fourth principle frames real self-care as an assertion of power. By making deliberate choices based on your values rather than external expectations, you reclaim agency from systems designed to keep you small. This principle recognizes that personal transformation can spark systemic change as you begin to interact differently with your relationships, workplace, and community. Consider Clara, a burned-out public school teacher who felt increasingly demoralized by administrative constraints. Through real self-care, she identified agency as a core value – both feeling it herself and supporting it in her students. This insight led her to leave her school and start a tutoring business for students with learning disabilities. This decision required setting boundaries with her school, treating herself with compassion despite feelings of guilt, connecting with her authentic desires, and asserting power by creating a new professional path. These principles work synergistically and iteratively – you'll find yourself circling back to earlier principles as you progress. Real self-care isn't a destination but a lifelong practice that evolves as your circumstances change. Unlike faux self-care, which promises a quick fix, real self-care acknowledges that meaningful change requires ongoing internal work. Though this may seem like yet another burden for already overwhelmed women, the difference lies in its sustainability and transformative potential.

Chapter 5: Setting Boundaries: The Foundation of Genuine Self-Care

Setting boundaries forms the cornerstone of real self-care, creating the space necessary for all other aspects to develop. Many women struggle with this foundational skill, as exemplified by Angela, who consistently prioritized her boyfriend's needs above her own academic commitments. When her boyfriend texted about skipping his responsibility to walk their puppy, Angela immediately rushed to help, rearranging her clinical rotation schedule without questioning whether she should say no. Boundaries exist in the pause between receiving a request and responding to it. This pause allows you to decide whether to say yes, say no, or negotiate an alternative. The challenge isn't in identifying your boundaries but in managing your fear of the backlash that might follow when you communicate them. Women are conditioned to prioritize others' feelings, making boundary-setting particularly difficult. The Real Self-Care Thermometer helps assess your current capacity for setting boundaries. This tool measures how effectively you navigate common scenarios like responding to work requests during vacation, negotiating holiday visits with in-laws, or handling financially demanding situations with friends. Your score places you in one of three zones: Red (chronically overwhelmed, unable to recognize choices), Yellow (aware of boundaries but struggling with guilt), or Green (making thoughtful decisions, feeling agency over your time and energy). Developing boundary-setting skills requires mastering four key techniques. First, learn to put guilt in the background using cognitive defusion strategies that create space between yourself and your thoughts. Rather than viewing guilt as a moral judgment requiring immediate action, recognize it as background noise – a faulty "check engine" light that doesn't need to drive your decisions. Second, silence the killjoys – those whose opinions exert outsized influence on your choices. Separating your needs from others' judgments allows you to make decisions based on what truly matters to you rather than fear of disapproval. Pay attention to how your body responds to different situations; physical sensations often signal whether something feels right or wrong for you. Third, recognize that in any situation, you have three choices: say yes, say no, or negotiate. Negotiation involves asking questions, gathering information, and making requests before deciding. Though this requires additional emotional labor initially, it trains others how to treat you, preventing resentment from building over time. Finally, communicate your boundaries clearly and directly. Avoid wishy-washy language, don't ask for permission, and resist the urge to overexplain. Scripts like "I appreciate you thinking of me for this role, but I'm prioritizing _____ at the moment" or "I'm not free to talk right now" help convey boundaries firmly but respectfully. Setting boundaries is a muscle that strengthens with practice. Start with lower-stakes situations, celebrate small wins, and recognize that setbacks are normal. Over time, you'll develop confidence in your ability to protect your time and energy. Remember that real self-care isn't about selfishness but about creating sustainable ways of engaging with the world that honor your needs alongside others'. By reclaiming ownership of your choices, you lay the groundwork for authentic well-being.

Chapter 6: Self-Compassion: Moving Beyond Martyr Mode and Inner Critics

Self-compassion forms the second principle of real self-care, building upon the foundation of boundary-setting. This principle involves changing how you talk to yourself, replacing harsh criticism with kindness and understanding. Unlike self-esteem, which builds psychological defense through high self-regard, self-compassion develops self-clarity through recognizing your humanity despite your imperfections. Research shows that people who practice self-compassion are more proactive in making positive life changes and experience fewer negative thoughts. Before embracing self-compassion, many women must first break free from Martyr Mode – the tendency to care for everyone else while burning themselves to a crisp. Women receive social approval for self-sacrifice, creating a paradoxical situation where they make themselves smaller yet crave recognition for their suffering. This martyrdom operates on an unspoken expectation: if I extend myself toward others, they should provide praise, support, or attention in return. When these expectations aren't met, resentment builds. Martyr Mode reflects society's conditioning of women to prioritize others' needs, from girls being praised for yielding to peers on the playground to women ordering office birthday cakes and joining unpaid mentorship committees. Women adopt this mode as a defense mechanism against criticism, hoping to control others' reactions by demonstrating self-sacrifice. Breaking free requires giving yourself permission to practice self-compassion – an act that itself demonstrates compassion. Several practical tools help develop self-compassion. First, add "Ouch!" to your vocabulary when you notice harsh self-talk. This simple practice interrupts the automatic criticism that many women have internalized from parents, teachers, or society. For Sonia, a mother who berated herself for sending her children to a babysitter on weekends, recognizing her inner critic as her mother's voice helped her separate from these judgments. Another essential aspect involves distinguishing between guilt and shame. While guilt relates to specific actions ("I feel bad about what I did"), shame encompasses your entire identity ("I am bad"). The antidote to shame-based thinking is adopting a "Good Enough" mentality – accepting your humanity and extending yourself the same compassion you would offer others. This means acknowledging that you're allowed to make mistakes, consider yourself alongside those you care about, and believe that everyone deserves compassion, including you. Self-compassion also requires balancing your inner critic with other voices. Your mind contains multiple perspectives – the optimist with grand plans, the quirky one with unique ideas, the wise woman with gravitas and knowing. Recognizing this diversity prevents any single voice from dominating your internal landscape. Additionally, learning to receive help from others counteracts the tendency to view yourself as an imposition. When someone offers assistance, practice saying yes as an exercise in connection rather than rejecting support out of unworthiness. Rest represents another crucial component of self-compassion. Many women resist rest due to fear that if they finally pause, they might fall apart completely. Embodiment – reconnecting with physical sensations and needs – serves as a prerequisite for meaningful rest. Notice when your body signals hunger, thirst, or fatigue, and give yourself permission to respond appropriately. As Tricia Hersey of the Nap Ministry states, "Being exhausted is not how we're supposed to be navigating this world. It's true trauma." Viewing rest as resistance against oppressive systems transforms it from self-indulgence to radical self-preservation. Through these practices, self-compassion becomes not merely a comfort but a revolutionary act that subverts social structures designed to keep women overburdened and disconnected from themselves. By treating yourself with kindness and respect, you assert that you exist and matter – creating ripple effects that extend far beyond your individual experience.

Chapter 7: Values-Based Living: Building Your Real Self-Care Compass

After establishing boundaries and developing self-compassion, the third principle of real self-care emerges: bringing you closer to yourself through values-based living. This principle helps answer the question many women face once they've identified what they don't want in their lives: "What now?" For Rochelle, who had learned to set boundaries with her demanding family but felt adrift with her newfound time, connecting with her values provided essential direction. Values differ fundamentally from goals. While goals represent tangible objectives like running a marathon or getting a promotion, values describe desired qualities of action – how you want to show up in the world. If goals represent destinations on life's road trip, values determine how it feels to be in the car driving toward them. Are you singing along to your favorite music or white-knuckling through traffic? This distinction matters because faux self-care typically focuses on goals (escaping daily life through a retreat, losing weight through a cleanse) without identifying the values underneath them. Building your values list requires reflection on what truly matters to you, independent of external expectations. Values like authenticity, adventure, creativity, or justice might resonate differently for each person. Several exercises help identify these core values. In the Birthday Dinner exercise, imagining how you would plan a celebration with limited resources reveals priorities and preferences. The "What I Know to Be True for Me" practice prompts reflection on when you feel most like yourself and what situations guarantee your failure, illuminating underlying values. Values become most clear when choosing one quality over another. Kleo, renovating her kitchen with her wife, found herself scrolling Pinterest for inspiration but feeling dead inside. She realized she valued boldness and authenticity over prudence and self-restraint, leading her to select a bright blue kitchen island and patterned tiles that reflected her personality rather than following trends. This clear choice aligned with her values, bringing energy and fulfillment despite potential resale concerns. These values form the foundation of your Real Self-Care Compass – a guide for making decisions aligned with your authentic self. The Compass centers around three elements: WHAT (your goals in different life areas), HOW (the values guiding how you pursue these goals), and WHY (your personal manifesto explaining what feeds and nourishes you). Unlike a rigid North Star, the Compass acknowledges that values shift through different life seasons while providing consistent guidance for decision-making. Values work helps match your "outsides" with your "insides" – ensuring that your external life reflects your internal priorities. This alignment requires recognizing when you're caught in "shoulds" or comparisons to others. Research shows that even two-year-olds change their decision-making based on peer influence, demonstrating how deeply ingrained conformity becomes. Cultivating awareness of your unique values counteracts this tendency, empowering you to make choices that feel authentic rather than prescribed. The Real Self-Care Compass also helps navigate fork-in-the-road moments requiring tough decisions. When facing divergent paths, values provide internal guidance rather than looking outward for answers. Additionally, values help you "digest" accomplishments and experiences, appreciating what you have rather than constantly seeking the next achievement. This capacity to internalize the good allows for genuine satisfaction rather than perpetual striving. By building your Real Self-Care Compass, you develop a sustainable practice that brings you closer to yourself with each decision. This feeling of ownership over your life – of making choices aligned with your authentic desires rather than external expectations – forms the essence of real self-care and creates the foundation for asserting power in larger systems.

Chapter 8: Power and Revolution: How Individual Change Creates Systemic Impact

The fourth principle of real self-care frames it as an assertion of power – reclaiming agency from systems designed to keep women small and using that agency to create ripple effects of change. In a society where women's time, energy, and attention are systematically devalued, choosing to practice real self-care constitutes a revolutionary act with the potential to transform not only individual lives but also relationships, workplaces, and broader social structures. This principle rejects cynicism in favor of hope – not the optimistic belief that everything will be fine, but the grounded understanding that while things may not be okay, you have agency to make them a little better. Hope emerges through four coping skills: problem-solving (taking tangible action), emotion regulation (managing discomfort), activating core identity (connecting with individual or collective identity), and relational coping (engaging with mentors or important people). These skills maintain connection to your power even in challenging circumstances. The path to systemic change begins with embracing "both, and" thinking – the dialectical ability to hold seemingly contradictory realities simultaneously. Like a chess piece that is both a small wooden object and a powerful player that can change the game, women contain multitudes – both constrained by systems and capable of transforming them. This nuanced perspective prevents falling into either helpless victimhood or toxic positivity, creating space for authentic agency. Turning up complexity further strengthens this power. Society tends to flatten women's existence, viewing complexity as threatening. By embracing alternative narratives of your experiences – seeing both challenges and strengths, losses and gains – you resist one-dimensional stories that diminish your agency. This practice of owning your headline reframes experiences from "Burned-Out Moms Gathered in a Field to Scream" to "Nation Abandons Mothers and They've Had Enough," shifting focus from individual failure to systemic betrayal. Individual acts of real self-care create cascading effects, as demonstrated by Lena, a video producer at an exploitative TV station. After practicing boundary-setting, self-compassion, and values clarification, Lena advocated for workplace changes. Her year-long effort resulted not only in getting an assistant but also in new policies benefiting other producers and becoming an ally for younger women at the network. Her individual assertion of power improved conditions for the entire workplace. The ultimate expression of power comes through paying it forward – using privilege gained through real self-care to benefit others with fewer resources. This community care emerges naturally from internal transformation, creating networks of support that challenge inequitable systems. When women with advantages in certain areas (financial resources, citizenship status, educational access) extend those benefits to others, they amplify the revolutionary potential of real self-care. We see this community care exemplified in movements like the Chamber of Mothers, where thousands of women – many past childbearing age – advocated for federal paid leave policies they would never personally use. Their collective action demonstrated how individual transformation can coalesce into powerful demands for systemic change. While specific policy outcomes may vary, the energy and solidarity generated through such movements create lasting impacts at multiple levels. As Audre Lorde reminded us, "Your power is relative, but it is real. And if you do not learn to use it, it will be used against you, and me, and our children." The practice of real self-care acknowledges this truth, embracing the ongoing work of reclaiming power from oppressive systems. By asserting agency through boundary-setting, self-compassion, values-based living, and community care, women participate in a quiet revolution that has the potential to transform not only individual lives but the very structures that have failed them.

Summary

Real self-care emerges as a revolutionary framework that fundamentally redefines how we approach well-being in a world designed to extract women's labor without replenishment. By distinguishing between external quick fixes and the internal process of making difficult, values-aligned choices, this approach offers a sustainable path toward authentic fulfillment. The four principles – setting boundaries, practicing self-compassion, living according to values, and asserting power – work together to create a cascade effect that extends beyond individual transformation to challenge and reshape relationships, workplaces, and social systems. The transformative power of real self-care lies in its recognition that women are not broken and in need of fixing – rather, it's our social fabric that requires repair. This perspective shifts focus from individual deficiency to systemic betrayal, empowering women to hold hope and pain together while taking concrete steps toward change. As women implement these principles in their daily lives, they discover that their individual acts of resistance – saying no to unreasonable demands, treating themselves with kindness, making choices aligned with their values, and using their privilege to benefit others – collectively constitute a quiet revolution with the potential to transform the very systems designed to keep them small. In this way, real self-care becomes not merely a personal practice but a political assertion that women's time, energy, and humanity matter – a radical reclamation of power with far-reaching implications for gender equity and social justice.

About Author

Loading...

Pooja Lakshmin

Dr Pooja Lakshmin, MD, is a board-certified psychiatrist, New York Times contributor and a leading voice at the intersection of mental health and gender, focused on helping women and people from marginalized communities escape the tyranny of self-care. In 2020, Lakshmin founded Gemma - a physician led women's mental health education platform centering impact and equity. She maintains an active private practice, where she treats women struggling with burnout, perfectionism, and disillusionment, as well as clinical conditions like depression and anxiety. Having gone down the rabbit hole of extreme wellness herself, Real Self-Care is her answer to the juice cleanses, the gratitude lists, and the bubble baths - not only to care for ourselves for real but, in turn, to transform our broken culture.

Read more