Nail It then Scale It

Nail It then Scale It Plot Summary

Introduction

We've all been there—excitedly launching into a new business idea, investing countless hours building a product we're certain will change the world, only to watch it fall flat when it finally meets the market. It's one of the most painful experiences entrepreneurs face. Why does this happen so often, even to brilliant minds with seemingly perfect execution? The answer lies in a fundamental paradox: the very things we believe lead to entrepreneurial success—passion for our product, dedication to our vision, and following traditional business planning—are often precisely what cause us to fail. But there's a better way forward. By flipping conventional wisdom on its head and adopting an evidence-based approach to innovation, we can dramatically increase our odds of success. This approach isn't about planning and execution—it's about hypothesis testing, customer validation, and intelligently adapting before scaling.

Chapter 1: Identify Monetizable Customer Pain

At the heart of successful entrepreneurship lies a simple truth: customers don't buy products—they buy solutions to their problems. The most successful ventures begin by identifying what's known as a "monetizable pain"—a problem so significant that customers are actively seeking and willing to pay for its solution. Greg Whisenant's story perfectly illustrates this principle. After his apartment building was robbed, Greg joined a neighborhood watch group and began mapping local crimes. Believing this information could empower citizens and police, he developed CrimeReports.com, raised seed capital, and built a beautiful crime-mapping website with an advertising-based revenue model. Despite having what seemed like all the ingredients for success—passion, funding, and technology—Greg found himself stuck with just one customer after years of effort. When forced to reassess, Greg did something counterintuitive: he stopped developing, stopped selling, and started listening. Through structured conversations with full police department buying panels—including chiefs, IT directors, crime analysts, and officers—Greg discovered critical insights. Police departments absolutely refused advertising on the site but would actually pay to share their data. Officers were excited about accessing crime patterns, with one chief noting it previously "took six months to see what happened the day before." IT directors provided crucial feedback about security requirements. Most importantly, Greg realized the value wasn't just in mapping crimes but in providing police with a data dashboard for analyzing patterns. After redesigning his solution based on this feedback, the results were transformative. Within one year, CrimeReports went from one customer to 200 police departments, eventually reaching 2,000 paying customers within three years. The website skyrocketed from the 10-millionth most popular site to the 10-thousandth. Greg's breakthrough came from rigorously validating the actual pain point rather than assuming he already understood it. To identify monetizable pain in your own venture, follow these practical steps: First, write down your hypothesis about what problem you're solving. Then, test it through direct customer conversations—not just friends and family. Pay attention to how quickly potential customers return your calls; a high response rate (ideally over 50%) indicates you've found a significant pain. During these conversations, focus on three key questions: "Do you have this problem?", "Tell me about it," and "Does something like this solve the problem?" Remember that a truly monetizable pain is at least a four or five on a five-point scale—it feels like a shark bite, not a mosquito bite. When you've found it, customers will actively seek solutions, return your calls, and eventually be willing to pay you to solve their problem.

Chapter 2: Test with Virtual Prototypes Before Building

One of the most common and devastating mistakes entrepreneurs make is prematurely building their product. After identifying what seems like a significant customer pain, the natural instinct is to immediately dive into development, invest substantial resources, and create what we believe is the perfect solution. However, this approach almost always leads to wasted time, money, and ultimately, failure. The story of Intuit's Simple Start edition powerfully demonstrates a better approach. In 2004, despite Intuit's dominance in the accounting software market with QuickBooks, research revealed that over 50% of American small businesses didn't use accounting software at all. A team led by Terry Hicks visited over forty small businesses to understand why and encountered immediate hostility. As one business owner bluntly stated, "I don't need no stinkin' accounting!" Rather than assuming they knew the solution, the team created a series of rapid, inexpensive prototypes before committing to full development. Their first prototype—a stripped-down version of QuickBooks—was still rejected by customers. This catalyzing experience revealed their fundamental misunderstanding: what they considered "simple" still involved 125 setup screens and intimidating accounting language. Hicks noted, "It wasn't until we tried and failed with a prototype that the entire team was like 'Okay, now I get it.'" Through several iterations, they radically simplified the product, reducing setup from 125 to just 3 screens and eliminating accounting terminology. The result—QuickBooks: Simple Start Edition—launched in September 2004 and became an immediate success, outselling all other accounting software in the United States except QuickBooks itself. The key insight here is to develop what's called a "minimum feature set" (MFS)—the smallest, most focused set of features that will drive a customer purchase. Think of it as the bull's-eye of a target, representing the core "must-have" elements that solve the customer's pain. Everything else is secondary. This approach requires testing your assumptions with virtual prototypes before building anything concrete. To implement this in your venture, start with simple representations like PowerPoint mockups, paper sketches, or basic wireframes that customers can react to. When showing these to potential customers, structure your conversation around understanding their pain and reactions to your potential solution rather than selling. Record these conversations and analyze them for patterns that reveal what truly matters to customers. The power of this approach isn't just theoretical—it works across industries. ClassTop, an online learning company, initially created a prototype with twenty features they thought universities would want. When they asked how much customers would pay, the answer was a disappointing $200 per month. However, by using the "$100 game" (asking customers how they would allocate $100 across different features), they discovered customers valued just three features, with one feature alone worth $80. By simplifying to these core features, development costs dropped to one-fifth of the original estimate while willingness to pay jumped five-fold to $1,000 per month.

Chapter 3: Validate Your Solution Through Customer Feedback

After developing and testing your minimum feature set through virtual prototypes, the next critical step is validating your actual solution with real customers. This isn't just about asking if people "like" your product—it's about rigorously testing whether your solution truly resolves their pain point and whether they'll pay for it. Mike Cassidy's experience with Ultimate Arena illustrates the importance of honest validation. After selling his previous startup for $532 million, Mike co-founded Ultimate Arena, an online platform where gamers could compete for cash prizes. The initial launch seemed promising, with half a million unique monthly users quickly joining the site. However, when Mike examined the data more closely, he discovered a troubling trend: 50% of new users tried the platform once and never returned. Rather than continuing on his original course, Mike personally called users who had abandoned the platform to understand why. What he discovered was revealing—Ultimate Arena lacked two critical ingredients: a social component and a fighting chance to win. Unlike poker games among friends, Ultimate Arena players found themselves consistently losing to superior opponents—"like having a bully steal your lunch money." Despite pressure from passionate team members who wanted to persist with the original concept, Mike made the difficult decision to pivot. Based on customer feedback, Mike dropped Ultimate Arena and created Xfire—an instant messaging service that allowed gamers to meet online and then play their favorite games together. This solution addressed the social element users craved and became wildly successful, eventually selling to Vivendi for over $100 million. The key wasn't persistence with the original idea but being willing to honestly evaluate customer feedback and change direction. To effectively validate your solution, implement these specific practices: First, conduct structured prototype testing with real customers, ideally bringing your entire team into these conversations. Record and transcribe these meetings to ensure you're capturing actual customer responses rather than what you want to hear. When customers give feedback, focus on identifying patterns across multiple conversations before making changes. If you're having trouble determining which features truly matter, try techniques like the "$100 game" (asking customers how they would allocate $100 across different features) or feature tracking to see which elements customers actually use. Most importantly, ask breakthrough questions that reveal true buying intent: "Would you be willing to prepay for this product?" or "If I gave this to you today, would you implement it system-wide?" Remember that validation isn't complete until customers demonstrate willingness to pay. As one serial innovator stated, "The only valid market survey is a signed purchase order." If customers aren't asking when they can get your product or aren't willing to pay for it by the end of your validation process, something fundamental is wrong with either your solution or your understanding of the pain point.

Chapter 4: Master the Go-to-Market Strategy

Even the most brilliantly designed product will fail without an effective go-to-market strategy. While many entrepreneurs invest heavily in marketing and sales tactics, the most successful ones first take time to deeply understand their customers' buying process and the market infrastructure that influences purchase decisions. Cisco provides a compelling example of this principle in action. By the time of their IPO in 1987, Cisco had already built a valuation of several hundred million dollars—yet they had no professional sales staff, no standard marketing campaign, and didn't purchase advertising until 1992. How did they achieve this? Cisco founders Len Bosack and Sandy Lerner intimately understood both their product and how to reach their customers. Rather than following conventional Silicon Valley wisdom and spending hundreds of thousands on marketing, they leveraged the emerging ARPAnet/Internet to spread word about their routers. This approach aligned perfectly with how their customers discovered and evaluated products, allowing Cisco to turn an average profit of $300,000 per month with minimal marketing expenditure. To master your go-to-market strategy, you must first understand the complete customer buying process—from initial awareness through purchase, use, and eventual disposal of your product. This understanding comes from asking specific questions about how customers become aware of products like yours, where they gather information, and how they make purchase decisions. For example, Intuit's founders initially struggled because they assumed PC magazines would reach their target customers. Only after launching an Apple version did they discover that their true customers were using Apple computers and reading Apple-specific publications. Equally important is mapping the market infrastructure—all the players between you and your customer who influence purchasing decisions. These typically include partners (resellers, content providers), influencers (press, analysts, thought leaders), and advertising/marketing channels. Understanding this ecosystem allows you to develop strategies to leverage these relationships rather than fighting against them. Knowlix, a knowledge management software company, provides an excellent case study. Through customer interviews, they discovered exactly which partners mattered (Remedy, Bendata, Peregrine Systems), what content customers needed (Microsoft and Novell), which industry analysts they trusted (Gartner Group's Bill Keyworth), and which publications they read (Service News and Customer Support Management Magazine). Armed with this knowledge, they focused all their resources on these specific touchpoints rather than broadcasting broadly. The result was achieving number one in name recognition in their space within just 18 months and eventually selling successfully to Peregrine Systems. When implementing your own go-to-market strategy, remember that context matters significantly. The infrastructure for startups often differs dramatically from that of established companies, and changing your target customers means facing an entirely new market infrastructure. Most importantly, while your initial focus should be on understanding rather than selling, you must eventually translate this understanding into closed deals with pilot customers who will validate both your solution and go-to-market approach.

Chapter 5: Develop a Scalable Business Model

After validating your solution and go-to-market strategy, the critical next step is ensuring you have a sustainable, scalable business model. Many startups with promising products fail because they never developed a viable model for generating consistent profit. The contrasting stories of Pets.com and Dogster.com powerfully illustrate this principle. Pets.com, founded in February 1999, raised over $300 million, went public, and failed all within a 21-month period. Their fundamentally flawed business model involved selling merchandise at one-third the price they paid, shipping it for free, and spending millions on advertising (including a $1.2M Super Bowl ad). Despite their brand recognition, the economics were unsustainable. Just a few years later, Ted Rheingold launched Dogster, another pet-focused online venture. When their initial plan to sell pet accessories stumbled, they pivoted to creating a social network for pet owners. By carefully validating their business model and keeping their burn rate extremely low, they achieved profitability within a year and secured advertising clients like Target, Disney, and Holiday Inn—all without significant promotion. To develop a scalable business model, start by leveraging your customer conversations to predict how your business should operate. You've already gathered valuable information about customer needs, buying processes, and price sensitivity—now use this to shape your financial projections. Pay particular attention to key metrics like fixed versus variable costs, margins, customer acquisition costs, and break-even analysis. WebVan, another infamous dot-com failure, demonstrates the dangers of neglecting rigorous financial validation. Despite investing over a billion dollars in infrastructure, WebVan failed to validate fundamental assumptions about their grocery delivery model. They predicted average orders of $103, but actual orders averaged only $81. Customer acquisition cost was $210, and delivery cost $27 per order—all in a business with 1-3% margins. The math simply didn't work. When building your own financial model, focus on keeping costs variable rather than fixed whenever possible, maintaining high gross margins (ideally 50% or higher), and understanding exactly what it costs to acquire each customer. Most importantly, test your model's sensitivity to various scenarios—what happens if things go poorly or even terribly? A robust model should withstand rough conditions. As you launch your product, focus on developing a repeatable business model—one that predictably generates revenue when you invest time and resources. Continue iterating with customers, evolving your offering to better fit their needs, but stay focused on your core value proposition. Many successful companies like Google maintained laser focus on their core offering until it became a multi-billion dollar business before expanding. The key to continued success is establishing a continuous data flow from customers and measuring the right metrics. Create a business dashboard that tracks critical indicators like customer acquisition costs, retention rates, and other variables that provide insight into your business health. Don't be seduced by vanity metrics that look good but miss the point—focus on data that reveals whether your business is truly sustainable and growing.

Chapter 6: Focus and Adapt to Market Context

While the Nail It Then Scale It process applies universally, how you implement it must adapt to your specific market context. Understanding whether you're entering a new or established market dramatically affects your strategy, timing, and approach to growth. The story of YouTube illustrates how market context and timing can be critical success factors. YouTube wasn't the first video sharing site, but it entered the market at the perfect moment—when storage technology costs were dropping dramatically and consumers were increasingly comfortable with uploading and sharing content. In contrast, many electric car ventures, despite having revolutionary technology, have struggled with slow adoption because they failed to account for the market context and consumer readiness. In new markets—those created by disruptive technology serving previously unnoticed or underserved needs—you must move deliberately while moving fast. While new markets offer exciting opportunities, they require educating consumers and changing behaviors, which takes time and resources. Pierre Omidyar's approach with eBay demonstrates this balance. He allowed the concept of online auctions to gradually take hold, only implementing fees and quitting his job when user adoption proved the market was ready. When entering a new market, you must consciously define and shape the category. Since customers are uncomfortable with things that don't "fit" established patterns, successful entrepreneurs define new categories and make them legitimate. This might involve using analogies to established markets (like describing Rhomobile as "the Ruby on Rails of mobile applications") or associating with respected partners who transfer legitimacy to your startup. Also critical in new markets is understanding the ecosystem of substitutes and complements. Substitutes—the old way of doing things—often have vested interests and habits that resist change. Complements are the related components needed for your solution to work properly. For example, the HP Kittyhawk project developed a revolutionary 1.3-inch hard drive for PDAs, but because complementary technologies like handwriting recognition software weren't ready, the market never materialized. In established markets, different principles apply. Speed becomes even more important, as your primary competitive advantage against entrenched players is innovation and execution velocity. Aruba Networks founder Dominic Orr emphasized this point: "If you ask me to distill the formula of success of a small company competing against a big company, it all boils down to one factor: that is speed. Speed of execution, and speed of innovation." Rather than attacking established players head-on, successful entrepreneurs typically either target underserved niches at the edges of the market or move from the low end upward. For example, one software startup initially tried selling to top-tier investment banks like Goldman Sachs and Citigroup without success. By shifting focus to tier-3 customers, they built credibility and experience that eventually allowed them to move upmarket to tier-1 clients. In any market context, cognitive flexibility—the ability to recognize new information and change your worldview accordingly—remains essential. Our research on startups that successfully pivoted revealed that many made dramatic changes to almost every aspect of their business model. The most adaptable entrepreneurs maintained flexible thinking by experiencing different industries or cultures, listening to outsiders, and drawing on multiple analogies to understand their challenges.

Chapter 7: Create Crisis for Clarity and Action

Sometimes the most valuable catalyst for transformation is a good crisis. When properly managed, crisis creates the focus, unity, and creativity needed to drive meaningful change and find a successful path forward. Consider Intuit's early struggles. When their money ran out, a stark crisis emerged that should have killed the company but instead saved it. The team dramatically cut their burn rate—about half the employees left, they returned rental furniture, used empty Quicken boxes topped with plywood for desks, and redesigned packaging to eliminate boxes altogether, cutting costs by 50%. Their bank account dwindled to just $52. This crisis created three crucial benefits that ultimately saved Intuit. First, the lower burn rate bought them extra time—runway that allowed co-founder Tom Proulx to finish the Apple version of Quicken while Scott Cook discovered their critical go-to-market mistake. Rather than selling through PC software retailers as originally planned, they learned their real market was Apple computer users reading Apple-specific publications. Without the crisis-induced focus and extended runway, Intuit would have burned through millions advertising to the wrong audience. The transformation at Ancestry.com (initially MyFamily.com) offers another powerful example. After raising $75 million during the dot-com boom, the company expanded rapidly, acquiring unrelated businesses and building multiple offices. When the bubble burst, the company was burning millions monthly with unfocused priorities. After an emergency $5 million investment, the board demanded immediate changes: replacing the CEO, refocusing entirely on genealogy, reducing staff, spinning off non-core acquisitions, and consolidating offices. Mike Wolfgramm, Ancestry.com's CTO, described the transformation: "We scaled the organization down to a minimum set of key people, 'FOCUS' became the central theme. We shifted from increased page views to increased revenue, from numerous products to exclusively focusing on Ancestry.com." The team began rigorously evaluating every initiative based on customer needs and return on investment. "An amazing thing happened," Wolfgramm noted, "as the months and years went by: we found ourselves doubling revenue every year." Eventually, Ancestry.com went public with a market capitalization approaching $2 billion. Why is crisis so effective? It creates three essential elements needed for transformation: focus, commitment, and time. Focus means laser-targeting the core business and real customer need rather than trying to please everyone. Commitment means leaving pride, opinions, and politics at the door to pursue intellectually honest learning. Time comes from cutting burn rate, which extends runway and allows for multiple experiments rather than just one high-stakes attempt. You don't have to wait for natural crisis to create these conditions. Consider constraining investment into smaller tranches tied to specific milestones, setting artificial deadlines, or visualizing concrete consequences of inaction. Some entrepreneurs self-impose constraints by limiting development time or resources—like Google's practice of prototyping ideas in a day or at most a week. The successful application of the Nail It Then Scale It process ultimately requires these elements—focus, commitment, and time—whether they come from crisis or conscious choice. As Mike Dell observed after a near-death experience at Dell Computer forced fundamental changes to their business model: "We arguably became the best in the world at managing inventory and dealing with technology transitions after that near-death experience."

Summary

The entrepreneurial journey is filled with paradoxes, but perhaps none greater than this: the very qualities we celebrate in entrepreneurs—passion, determination, and vision—often become the very things that lead to failure when misdirected. The path to success isn't found in planning and executing a predetermined strategy, but in systematically testing assumptions, listening deeply to customers, and adapting with intellectual honesty before scaling. As Thomas Edison wisely noted, "I never want to build something that nobody wants to buy." This single principle captures the essence of successful innovation—focusing first on understanding monetizable customer pain, testing with inexpensive prototypes, validating through genuine customer feedback, and only then building a solution worth scaling. Your next entrepreneurial venture begins not with a business plan or fundraising pitch, but with a simple question: what significant problem can I solve that customers will gladly pay to have resolved?

About Author

Loading...

Nathan Furr

Read more

Related Books by Nathan Furr

Loading...

The Upside of Uncertainty

Nathan Furr

A Guide to Finding Possibility in the Unknown

★★★½☆3.8