Cold Calling Sucks (And That's Why It Works)

Cold Calling Sucks (And That's Why It Works) Plot Summary

Introduction

Success in sales is determined by your willingness to have uncomfortable conversations. Nowhere is this more evident than in cold calling, where rejection and resistance await on the other end of the line. Most salespeople will do anything to avoid this discomfort, finding endless excuses to postpone picking up the phone. They'll spend hours researching prospects, crafting elaborate emails, or "social selling" – anything but making that call. Yet the very thing that makes cold calling uncomfortable is precisely what makes it effective. While thousands of sales reps flood inboxes with automated emails, few are willing to consistently engage in the discomfort of cold calling. This creates an opportunity for those brave enough to embrace it. When you decide to pick up the phone despite the inevitable challenges, you immediately separate yourself from the competition. Cold emails might help you reach quota, but mastering cold calling will take you to President's Club. The path forward isn't about eliminating the discomfort – it's about embracing it.

Chapter 1: Master the First 60 Seconds

The first minute of a cold call determines whether you'll earn the right to continue the conversation or face immediate rejection. Most calls fail during these crucial opening seconds because salespeople use generic, telemarketer-like openers that immediately categorize them as unwelcome interruptions. The key to breaking through this barrier lies in how you open the call. Brandon Hoffman, a top insurance producer, transformed Armand's cold calling results with a simple pattern break. Instead of opening with "How's your day going?" – which prospects recognize as a telemarketer's line – Brandon suggested leading with social proof: "Hey Bill, we work with a few other partners in the Skadden LA office. Armand from Northwestern, heard my name tossed around?" This context-first approach completely changed the dynamic of the calls. Suddenly, prospects who previously hung up were engaging in conversation. The "Heard The Name Tossed Around" opener works because it establishes you as someone who might work with the prospect's peers, not a random telemarketer they can dismiss without consequence. Similarly effective is the Tailored Permission Opener, which disarms prospects with honesty: "I noticed your recent office expansion. I'm going to be honest, this is a cold call, but it is a well-researched cold call. Can I get 30 seconds to explain why I'm calling, then you can decide if it makes sense to continue?" Both approaches lead with specific context about the prospect before even introducing yourself. This creates what's called a "sit-up moment" where the prospect realizes you've done your homework. The tone is equally important – you must sound like a peer, not a telemarketer. When you master these context-first openers, you earn the right to move past those first 60 seconds and deliver your proposition about the problem you solve. By breaking the pattern of typical cold calls in these opening moments, you transform from an unwelcome interruption into a potential peer with valuable insight. This single shift can take your connection rate from single digits to consistently earning meaningful conversations with decision-makers.

Chapter 2: Craft a Problem-Focused Proposition

Traditional "value propositions" filled with buzzwords like "streamline," "all-in-one platform," and "single source of truth" immediately trigger telemarketer alarms in your prospect's mind. These vague statements fail because they focus on features rather than the pain points your solution addresses. The reality is that your product has no value unless it solves a specific problem your prospect recognizes. Nick discovered this firsthand when a competitor called him about his struggling SuppNow vending machine business. Rather than pitching features, the competitor listed every problem Nick was experiencing with remarkable precision: "Those protein tubs probably get stuck between the elevator and the wall. Misvends because you have to use two slots for one big product. Can't stock more than three units without overloading a shelf." Nick was stunned – it was as if the caller had access to his support logs. Only after establishing this deep problem understanding did the competitor briefly mention his solution: "We redesigned every major vending system in our machines from scratch so that you can actually vend your protein." This approach works because humans are more motivated to eliminate pain than achieve benefits. By describing problems in triggering detail, you transport prospects back to their most frustrating moments, creating a vivid reminder of what they wish they could change. Data shows this problem-focused language is three times more effective than traditional benefit-focused pitches. To craft your own Problem Proposition, first describe the problem in specific, visceral detail using the prospect's language, not sales jargon. Include who feels the problem, specific annoyances, the setting when it happens, and the emotions involved. Then, offer just one sentence about your solution that focuses on your unique differentiator. Finally, use an interest-based call-to-action that validates their interest before asking for a meeting: "My guess is you're all set, but would you be opposed to taking a peek at what that looks like?" When you nail the problem description, you establish yourself as an industry insider who "gets" their business. This approach transforms the entire dynamic of your calls, moving you from pushy salesperson to knowledgeable peer who understands their challenges better than they expected.

Chapter 3: Handle Objections Like Mr. Miyagi

When a stranger from the ASPCA approached Nick at a coffee shop asking, "Sir, do you happen to love animals?" his immediate response was "Nope, I don't!" – despite being an animal lover who had previously donated to animal rescue causes. His real objection wasn't to the cause but to the interruption while he was trying to write. This perfectly illustrates what happens on cold calls: prospects aren't rejecting your product; they're reacting to the unexpected interruption. The first objection you hear is almost always a knee-jerk reaction, not a considered evaluation of your offering. When a prospect says "I'm not interested" or "send me some information," they're essentially saying what Nick said to the fundraiser – anything to make you go away. Most salespeople make the critical mistake of trying to overcome these emotional reactions with logical arguments, which only makes prospects resist more strongly. Instead, handle objections like Mr. Miyagi from Karate Kid – don't counter the punch head-on, but redirect its momentum. This three-step approach transforms objection handling: First, agree with the objection to disarm their defense mechanism. When they say "I have no budget," respond with "I hear ya. Nowadays, it's hard enough to keep your budget, let alone add something new." This agreement pattern-breaks their expectation that you'll argue, instantly lowering their guard. Second, incentivize conversation by asking questions that encourage them to elaborate on their objection: "Just so no one calls you again, is it that you're out of budget for this fiscal year or you get put through the wringer every time you try to buy something?" This gives them a reason to share more information while making them feel understood. Finally, sell the test drive by explaining why they might want to meet even if they don't buy: "I get it. You're probably not gonna buy this thing now. But if budget ever frees up, the people who get it at least have a directional sense of what they'd want. Open to taking a look, so you at least know what's out there?" The tone is critical during this process. You must slow down, especially after hearing an objection. Many sellers speed up and stammer when rejected, which signals inferiority. Instead, pause, laugh lightly to show comfort, and proceed at a measured pace. This balanced approach transforms objections from conversation-enders into pathways to deeper dialogue.

Chapter 4: Break Through Gatekeepers and Voicemails

Working at the USC Ticket Office during a Drake concert, Armand became a professional gatekeeper. His job was twofold: close the gate on strangers and open it for important people. One day, a woman claimed to be Drake's aunt requesting special tickets. Despite his skepticism, something in her confident, almost indignant tone made him put her through – and it turned out she actually was Drake's aunt. This experience revealed the key to bypassing gatekeepers: you need to act like you belong, with a confidence that makes them think, "I better get out of this person's way." Most salespeople make two critical mistakes with gatekeepers: trying to befriend them or treating them like prospects by explaining their product. Neither works because gatekeepers are trained to detect and reject pitches regardless of how compelling they sound. Instead, use the Gatekeeper Triple Bypass approach: first, simply ask to be put through with no company name or small talk – "Hey, could you get me over to Jennifer? It's Nick." Use a gruff, assumptive tone as if you're walking directly to the elevator. If that fails, move to the second bypass by providing just enough context to establish familiarity: "It's about the press release for the new office opening in Rochester. Would you let her know that it's Nick from 30MPC?" Only if pressed further should you reveal what you actually do, using social proof instead of a pitch: "We work with a few other CHROs in the Sequoia portfolio on compensation planning; it's Pave. I sent her a note the other day; mind letting her know it's Armand?" For voicemails, use the Double Tap approach focused on driving email replies rather than callbacks. Your first 15-second voicemail should lead with context and direct them to your email: "Hey Jennifer, saw your company just raised that Series C round from Sequoia. Left you a note about something that might be helpful. It's Nick from 30MPC." If they don't respond, leave a second 30-second voicemail adding social proof to your context. By approaching gatekeepers and voicemails strategically, you dramatically increase your chances of reaching decision-makers. The goal isn't to fight through every barrier but to navigate them efficiently, saving your energy for the conversations that matter. This approach significantly improves your overall connection rate while maintaining your professional reputation.

Chapter 5: Build Your Cold Calling Machine

Kenny was the hardest-working rep on his team, making 400 dials per week, yet he was in last place on the leaderboard with zero meetings booked. The investigation revealed that Kenny had only 10 conversations from those 400 dials because he kept calling bad numbers. Worse, those 10 conversations were with completely unqualified prospects like tiny companies or departments that would never buy. Kenny could have made 4,000 more dials and still booked zero meetings because he was calling the wrong people. The top performers are rarely the ones making the most dials. Instead, they maximize three critical conversion metrics: connect rate (percentage of prospects who answer), set rate (percentage of conversations that become meetings), and show rate (percentage of scheduled meetings that actually occur). Data shows that top quartile performers convert 13 times more meetings than average reps from the same number of dials by optimizing these metrics. To maximize your connect rate, prioritize mobile and direct lines over corporate numbers, mark bad numbers as you dial so you don't waste time redailing them, and rotate your phone numbers to prevent being flagged as spam. For meeting set rates, focus on prospects who actually have the problem you solve by building a tiered list: A-tier prospects have an immediate problem (like a recent funding round or new office opening), B-tier have the problem but no urgent timeline, and C-tier fit your ideal customer profile but show no problem signals. Your daily cold calling routine should be structured to ensure consistent execution. Block your calendar into Green Hours (8am-12pm) for prospecting, Yellow Hours (12-3pm) for customer meetings, and Red Hours (3-6pm) for administrative tasks. Always cold call first thing in the morning when you have the most discipline, and confine email checking to three specific windows per day (8:30am, 12pm, and 3pm) to prevent constant distractions. The most effective cold callers prepare everything the night before: research 60 prospects, find their contact information, and queue them up so you can make 40 dials in your first hour without wasting time. During your dial block, close everything else – no email, no chat, no other browser windows – and maintain momentum between calls. Even after rejection, immediately pick up the phone and dial again. By building these systems around your cold calling, you transform random activity into a predictable, high-output machine. The structure itself eliminates the decision fatigue that plagues most salespeople, turning cold calling from a dreaded task into a consistent, rewarding practice.

Chapter 6: Overcome Call Reluctance Forever

Cold calling reluctance is fundamentally a confidence issue – specifically, the extent to which you believe your inputs will lead to outputs. In other words, do you truly believe that making enough cold calls will result in booked meetings? Many salespeople try to "manufacture" this confidence through excessive preparation: reading more books, writing perfect scripts, researching prospects for hours, or using positive self-talk. While preparation matters, the only way to truly build confidence is through experience. You need to make so many cold calls that rejection no longer affects you emotionally, and your mind makes the concrete connection that 50 dials equals one meeting. The first time a prospect yells at you, you might be shaken. But by the hundredth time, you'll laugh it off because you know with mathematical certainty that another meeting is coming if you keep dialing. This emotional immunity only comes from volume and consistency. The best way to overcome call reluctance is to remove the daily decision of whether to make calls. Sign a contract with yourself to perform the inputs until the outputs become reality. Make calls before doing anything else, make them every single day as part of your routine, and establish consequences if you miss your weekly goal. As one rep did by putting a $100 bill on the table and saying, "Don't give it back to me until I hit my dial commitment for 4 weeks straight." No matter how good you get, cold calling will still involve rude prospects, stonewalling gatekeepers, and countless voicemails. The difference between average performers and top performers isn't that top performers find cold calling easy or enjoyable – it's that they don't allow the discomfort to stop them from making the calls. They understand that when things get tough and others quit, that's precisely when they gain their competitive advantage. As Olympic wrestling coach Dan Gable famously said: "When I'd get tired and want to stop, I'd wonder what my opponent was doing. I'd wonder if he was still working out. When I could see him still working, I'd start pushing myself. When I could see him in the shower, I'd push myself harder." When the calls start to suck, that's exactly when you get ahead of the pack.

Summary

Success in sales comes down to a simple yet profound truth: the more uncomfortable conversations you're willing to have, the more successful you'll become. Cold calling isn't effective because it's enjoyable or easy – it's effective precisely because it's difficult. The discomfort that causes most salespeople to avoid it creates an opportunity for those willing to embrace it consistently. While others hide behind mass emails and "social selling," the cold callers separate themselves by doing what others won't. "You don't have to feel good to get started, but you do need to get started to feel good." This powerful reminder encapsulates the mindset required to overcome call reluctance. The path to mastery doesn't require eliminating the discomfort of cold calling, but rather embracing it as your competitive advantage. When prospects are rude, when gatekeepers block your path, when voicemails pile up – that's precisely when you're earning your place in President's Club. Your next step is simple but not easy: pick up the phone today and make your first ten calls before allowing yourself to do anything else. Break through the initial resistance, and you'll discover the momentum that carries top performers to consistent success. The cold calls are going to suck, but that's exactly why they work.

About Author

Loading...

Armand Farrokh

Read more