From Start-Up to Grown-Up

From Start-Up to Grown-Up Plot Summary

Introduction

The journey from founder to CEO is one of the most challenging transitions in business. You started with a brilliant idea, assembled a small team of believers, and created something from nothing. But now, as your company grows, you face a new set of obstacles. Your role is transforming beneath your feet, requiring skills and mindsets you may not have needed when launching your venture. Many founders struggle with this evolution - feeling stretched between the visionary who sees possibilities and the leader who must execute through others. The challenges are both internal and external: managing your psychology while building systems that scale; inspiring teams while establishing accountability; maintaining your founding passion while creating processes that may feel constraining. This transformation isn't optional if you want your company to thrive beyond its start-up phase. By embracing both personal growth and organizational development simultaneously, you can navigate the path from entrepreneurial dreamer to mature business leader without sacrificing what made your vision special in the first place.

Chapter 1: Master Your Mindset: Lead from Self-Awareness

Leadership begins with understanding yourself. As a founder, your company becomes a mirror reflecting your strengths, weaknesses, behaviors, and values - often magnified across your organization. This makes self-awareness not just a personal virtue but a business imperative. At its core, self-awareness means recognizing your natural leadership style, triggers, blind spots, and how others experience your leadership. The story of Ronnie, CEO of a customer data platform, illustrates this perfectly. When asked about her leadership style, she confidently declared, "I'm extremely strategic. I'm always thinking strategically about where we are going, what paths we should pursue." She was certain this was how others perceived her as well. However, when her team was surveyed about words they associated with her leadership, the results revealed "detailed, focused, critical" - but not "strategic." This disconnect between her self-perception and her actual impact created a blind spot in her leadership effectiveness. This gap between intention and impact is common among founders. One CEO discovered his company increasingly mirrored his own shortcomings: "It's eerie how the company looks more and more like me. Sometimes I can have trouble delivering difficult news and I'm often indecisive. Then I watch people have trouble delivering difficult news and being indecisive." Without self-reflection, you unconsciously hire and cultivate people who reflect your own tendencies, rather than those who complement your gaps. Gaining clarity about yourself requires structured reflection. Consider questions like: How do you express yourself to people? Do you lean into conflict or avoid it? How do you handle giving feedback? How much control do you prefer over processes? How do you respond to stress? How do you make decisions? Mapping your tendencies along these dimensions helps identify your default style and where adjustments might benefit your leadership. 360-degree feedback provides another powerful window into your leadership. While potentially uncomfortable, it reveals how others experience your leadership - the impact rather than your intentions. As one CEO discovered during this process, getting candid input can be jarring but transformative. After receiving feedback that he could be aggressive and even bullying, he initially stormed out of the meeting. Forty-five minutes later, he returned: "I took a walk. Then I called my wife. She told me it was all true. Let's look at it again." Embracing feedback creates a foundation for authentic leadership growth. The goal isn't perfection or personality transformation, but developing self-awareness that allows you to adapt your approach, leverage your strengths, and build support systems for your weaknesses. Remember, the work is in you - understanding yourself is the first step toward effectively leading others.

Chapter 2: Build Psychological Safety to Ignite Performance

Psychological safety represents the bedrock of high-performing teams. It's the shared belief that team members won't be punished, rejected, or humiliated for speaking up with ideas, questions, concerns, or mistakes. While this concept sounds straightforward, creating this environment requires deliberate effort from leaders, especially in the high-pressure atmosphere of startups. Consider Suzanne, founder of a networking company facing a massive customer outage. Rather than assigning blame or micromanaging the crisis, she worked alongside her team through the night, bringing in pizza and maintaining a calm, focused demeanor. When team members occasionally snapped under pressure, she would refocus everyone with her mantra: "We have to fix this problem. We can do it. And we will do it." As one employee later reflected, "She kept the wheels on the bus. It was a very daunting problem with a screaming customer and tight timeframe, but she didn't make a single comment about blame. She showed us she had faith in us to deliver, and I think that's why we moved mountains to get it done." Suzanne's approach demonstrates how psychological safety emerges from leadership behavior. Under pressure, founders often revert to explosive criticism or micromanagement. Yet these reactions create precisely the environment where teams perform worst - where fear of judgment inhibits creativity, problem-solving, and collaboration. Creating safety begins with emotional self-regulation. Before reacting to mistakes or setbacks, pause to choose a response rather than having a reaction. Consider using praise strategically - it's a powerful tool that many founders underutilize. One technical CEO tracked positive interactions with employees and discovered that simple check-ins transformed relationships. An employee who had previously feared him began seeking him out for guidance, bringing immense value to both their work. Psychological safety extends to how you handle accountability. When expectations aren't met, address issues directly but constructively. Rather than making someone feel bad when the only point is to make them feel bad, focus on helping them get better. Frame discussions around shared goals and improvement rather than blame and punishment. As one founder discovered after snapping at her marketing head, productive accountability comes from clarifying expectations, understanding obstacles, and collaborating on solutions. Finally, effective delegation supports psychological safety by demonstrating trust. Assess your team members' "will and skill" - their desire and ability to handle responsibilities - then provide appropriate guidance without micromanaging. Delegation isn't simply offloading work; it's matching the right tasks with the right people while providing suitable support. When these elements come together, you create an environment where people bring their full capabilities to work. They speak up when they see problems, collaborate freely across boundaries, and take appropriate risks without fear. This psychological safety becomes your competitive advantage - enabling innovation, resilience, and sustainable performance even through the inevitable challenges of scaling a startup.

Chapter 3: Cultivate Your Culture Intentionally

Culture isn't just something that happens to your company - it's something you actively create, whether consciously or not. As Ben Horowitz writes in "What You Do Is Who You Are," if you don't methodically set your culture, "two-thirds of it will end up being accidental, and the rest will be a mistake." Culture represents the shared assumptions your people use to resolve everyday problems and make decisions that align with your vision. Jon Stein, founder of Betterment, describes his approach to culture using a house metaphor: "Values are the foundation. They're super-important, but you never see them. The best values are ones you don't have to talk about all the time. You just know they're down there, underneath everything." On top of this foundation are the visible elements - regular team meetings, company traditions, communication patterns, and most importantly, the people who embody these values daily. The danger of unintentional culture becomes evident in the story of Shana, who founded a sports and leisurewear brand. Her early employees were friends intensely focused on the brand and customers. As the company grew, this tight-knit group became a clique that didn't welcome newcomers or share information freely. New employees felt excluded and tested against unstated criteria. This "clan culture" transformed into a toxic environment that damaged productivity and teamwork. Shana had to have difficult conversations with her original team, making clear they needed to become more inclusive or leave - a painful but necessary intervention to reshape the culture. Toxic cultures emerge in various forms: "mirror cultures" where everyone emulates the founder's strengths and weaknesses; "polite cultures" where people avoid necessary conflict; "bifurcated cultures" where cofounders seem to run different companies; or "hard-driving cultures" where unrealistic expectations lead to burnout and disengagement. These dysfunctions typically stem not from malicious intent but from unconscious patterns and unexamined assumptions. To intentionally shape your culture, start by clearly articulating your founding story. This narrative communicates your purpose and connects employees to something larger than themselves. For instance, Airbnb prominently features the story of founders Brian Chesky and Joe Gebbia hosting their first guests on airbeds in their living room - a humble beginning that embodies their mission of belonging. Next, define distinctive values that genuinely reflect what matters in your organization. Rather than generic terms like "integrity" or "excellence," look for specific principles that guide decision-making. One Dallas-based robotics company built around three principles: "Our passion combines drive for the business and caring for each other. We see humor as a gateway to intelligence. We celebrate our wins and always seek what's next." These distinctive values permeate hiring, performance conversations, and daily operations. Finally, establish rituals that reinforce your culture. Weekly "Winsdays" celebrate milestones, cross-functional lunch groups build relationships across departments, and unique recognition programs acknowledge contributions. These practices transform abstract values into tangible experiences that shape behavior and strengthen cultural identity. Remember that culture evolves as your company grows. Make room for new perspectives while maintaining your core principles. A thoughtfully cultivated culture becomes your compass through growth, challenges, and change - keeping everyone aligned around what truly matters to your organization.

Chapter 4: Hire Smart and Manage Better

Hiring represents one of the most consequential activities in scaling your startup. Yet most founders approach it haphazardly, often hiring based primarily on "liking" candidates rather than systematically evaluating their fit. This leads to costly mistakes that become increasingly painful as your company grows. Jocelyn, founder of a healthcare startup, experienced this firsthand. She hired doctors with impressive domain expertise but soon discovered a critical problem: "They aren't working together. They also are not great at meeting deadlines for complicated projects, and I constantly have to follow up. They have no management skills at all, and their teams are confused and at cross-purposes. It's like I have the best rowing team in the world, but they are not rowing together." Jocelyn had hired for technical knowledge without assessing the leadership and collaboration skills her company needed. Effective hiring starts with clarity about what you truly need. Before posting a job, define specifically what you want this person to accomplish in their first six months. Create a mental movie of what success looks like - not just generic qualifications but observable behaviors and outcomes. Then gather evidence through structured interviews, reference checks, and online research to assess whether candidates can deliver these results. For Alexi Robichaux, cofounder of BetterUp, values-based hiring is fundamental. "We have six values. Three of them are about peak performance: grit, courage, and craftsmanship. Three honor humanity: empathy, zest, and playfulness." BetterUp assigns "balloons" - interviewers from different departments who focus solely on values and mission fit - and gives them veto power regardless of technical qualifications. This systematic approach ensures cultural alignment while maintaining high standards. Once you've hired successfully, onboarding becomes crucial. Charlie, a fintech CEO, hired Colin as head of product without clarifying their roles. Colin saw himself as a visionary, while Charlie expected him to manage the product team and ensure accountability. Without explicit discussion about responsibilities and expectations, they constantly clashed until Colin left the company - a preventable failure that damaged both the business and their friendship. For successful onboarding, establish clear expectations about priorities, define what success looks like at 30, 60, and 90 days, and help new hires achieve quick, visible wins. A personal operating manual - describing your communication preferences, decision-making style, and working patterns - helps new team members navigate your leadership approach. The flip side of hiring is knowing when to part ways with employees who aren't performing. Most founders delay these decisions far too long. Brian Berger, founder of Mack Weldon, recalls hiring someone with "an unusually ideal profile" despite multiple references warning about their difficult personality. "I thought, 'It will be different this time. I'll be able to manage him.'" The result was predictable - technical competence but toxic behavior that damaged the culture. After painful deliberation, Berger made the difficult decision to terminate the employee. "If you think somebody has to go, the sooner the better. There's never been a situation where that was not the right call." When performance issues arise, address them directly through candid, compassionate feedback focused on specific behaviors and their impact. Give clear direction about needed improvements and establish a timeline for change. Some situations may be salvaged through coaching, reassignment, or bringing in additional leadership, but don't delay inevitable separations that drain your organization's energy and focus. By approaching hiring, onboarding, and performance management systematically, you build the foundation for a team that can execute your vision and scale with your company's growth. The investment in these practices pays dividends through stronger performance, higher retention, and a more resilient organization.

Chapter 5: Implement Systems for Sustainable Growth

As your startup grows beyond its early stages, the informal approaches that worked with a small team begin to break down. What was once handled through casual conversations now requires structured systems and processes. This transition often creates tension - founders who prize flexibility and speed may resist "corporate" infrastructure - but implemented thoughtfully, these systems actually enable greater agility and sustainable growth. Nathan, CEO of an AI startup in New York, learned this lesson after raising $17 million. With funding secured, his team began hiring enthusiastically. First they filled planned roles, then added a data researcher when the product team requested one, then brought on a promising candidate without a specific role, followed by additional hires for sales operations and engineering. Each decision seemed reasonable in isolation, but without systematic budget tracking, they depleted their funding much faster than anticipated. Their next hire? A CFO to implement financial controls. Metrics provide the foundation for operational excellence. Identify key performance indicators specific to your business model and growth stage, then track them consistently through a dashboard. For one logistics company, early metrics focused on successful implementations and customer satisfaction. As they scaled, their metrics evolved to emphasize predictable performance across a larger sales team. By setting clear targets and monitoring progress, they maintained focus while adapting to changing needs. Alongside metrics, implement appropriate systems for collaboration and coordination. This includes technology tools like project management software, customer relationship management platforms, and internal communication channels. Equally important are human systems like the RACI matrix (Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, Informed) that clarifies decision rights and responsibilities. When Sidney, COO of an energy tech startup, discovered salespeople selling discontinued products, he realized their hasty transition to remote work had exposed system gaps: "Everyone kept their records on their own spreadsheet. We used to rely on just telling each other, but I can see that's not working now." Well-structured meetings provide another critical system for alignment. While many founders view meetings skeptically, effective gatherings serve essential purposes: creating shared reality, building relationships, making decisions, and coordinating action. One founder who initially resisted formal executive team meetings discovered they prevented miscommunication and drift in expectations. By establishing clear agendas, focusing on strategic discussions, and ensuring appropriate follow-up, meetings become productive rather than burdensome. Objectives and Key Results (OKRs) offer a powerful framework for goal-setting and accountability. Susan, founder of a community-building platform, struggled to evaluate her VP of marketing's performance without clear targets. After implementing OKRs, both gained clarity about expectations and progress. Rather than relying on subjective impressions, they could discuss concrete metrics and outcomes, transforming their working relationship. The transition to more structured operations requires adaptation from founders. As systems take shape, your role evolves from hands-on doer to architect and orchestrator. This shift can feel uncomfortable but creates the foundation for sustained growth. As one CEO reflected, "When you have goals for the business, everything is better. When we don't have clear goals, we let things slide. I can't talk to people about performance, because I don't have any way to measure it." Implement these systems progressively, involving your team in their design to ensure relevance and buy-in. The goal isn't bureaucracy but rather creating infrastructure that clarifies priorities, enables coordinated action, and provides visibility into performance. With these foundations in place, your organization can scale without sacrificing quality or losing direction.

Chapter 6: Navigate Board Dynamics Successfully

Your board of directors can be either a tremendous asset or a significant source of stress. As one founder observed, "There are two kinds of founders: those that have had issues with their board and those that will have issues with their board." Learning to navigate board dynamics effectively becomes a critical skill for scaling CEOs. Charlie, CEO of an education startup, experienced this firsthand when board member Jesse demanded he step down as CEO. Jesse threatened to withhold further investment and resign from the board if Charlie remained in his position. Understandably shaken, Charlie needed to quickly assess his options while managing his emotional response. Board dynamics often become complicated because directors bring varying personalities, experiences, and approaches to their role. Some common archetypes include: the alpha director who dominates discussions with forceful opinions; the checked-out director who barely engages; the detailed director who drills into minutiae rather than strategy; the micromanager who offers overly prescriptive advice; and the "general-fighting-the-last-battle" who applies solutions from previous companies regardless of relevance. Margot, founder of a gaming company, experienced this last challenge when a board member strongly encouraged her to become more externally focused - speaking at conferences, meeting customers, and building her personal brand. This aligned with Margot's natural preferences, so she eagerly followed his advice. Unfortunately, while she was externally focused, internal operations suffered significantly: product releases were delayed, key employees resigned, and morale plummeted. The advice itself wasn't necessarily wrong, but it failed to account for Margot's specific company needs. Successfully managing your board requires recognizing that, paradoxically, you must lead them even as they oversee you. Start by building individual relationships with each director. Alexa von Tobel, founder of LearnVest, emphasizes this approach: "Taking the time to build genuine relationships goes miles. I had board members that I had some of my most fun meals in my life with. And when we did have hard calls, I always knew how much they cared about me. It never felt personal. It truly was about the business." Prepare thoroughly for board meetings, beginning six weeks in advance. Conduct pre-meeting calls with each director to understand their concerns and preview strategic topics. Send materials at least three days before meetings, and structure the agenda to focus on strategic discussions rather than routine updates. During meetings, establish ground rules like turning off devices to ensure full engagement, and begin with a personal check-in to center everyone on their shared humanity. When challenges arise with specific directors, address them directly but diplomatically. For an overbearing director, you might say: "I appreciate your enthusiasm and intellect, and I know your heart is in the right place. There are times when your voice tends to be the dominant voice in the room. I'm hoping to create a culture where everyone speaks up, and I need your help." Sometimes enlisting another director as an ally can help influence difficult personalities. Throughout these interactions, maintain awareness of your own triggers. Board criticism can activate deep-seated insecurities or defensive responses. Charlie's reaction to Jesse's ultimatum initially stemmed from his difficult relationship with his domineering father and desire for independence. By recognizing this pattern, he could separate his emotional response from the strategic challenge, developing a plan to secure support from other directors while attempting to repair his relationship with Jesse. The board relationship is ultimately a partnership that requires investment, communication, and mutual respect. By approaching it strategically while remaining authentic, you transform potential friction into productive collaboration that strengthens your company's governance and direction.

Chapter 7: Develop Your Cofounder Relationship

The relationship between cofounders resembles a marriage - it can be supportive and energizing or fraught with tension and conflict. Like marriages, these partnerships face unique stresses that test even the strongest bonds, particularly during the intense pressure of building a startup. Sherry, CEO of an online professional networking startup for healthcare professionals, exemplified cofounder tension during a coaching session. When asked about her cofounder Jennifer, her demeanor transformed instantly. She launched into a litany of complaints: Jennifer didn't work as hard, only did what she wanted, played favorites on her team, and didn't challenge herself intellectually. Sherry emphasized that contrary to media reports, the company had been her idea, not an equal collaboration. This resentment represents just one flavor of cofounder conflict. Other common patterns include: growth mismatches where one founder develops skills faster than the other; unclear decision rights leading to confusion and duplication; differing visions about company direction; recognition imbalances where one founder (usually the CEO) receives disproportionate attention; and personal conflicts that escalate under pressure. Michele Romanow, cofounder of Clearco, navigated the particularly complex dynamic of cofounding with her romantic partner: "We took a pretty high-risk move... we were dating for a year at the time, and we decided that we were going to start this thing together." While this created unique challenges around maintaining boundaries between work and personal life, she found that their relationship actually provided deeper understanding: "You get to know this person better than anyone else on the planet, and you get to know what they're really good at... it builds a whole different depth and level of respect when you see someone kill it at work." The foundation for healthy cofounder relationships begins with explicit discussions about expectations, values, and working styles - what might be called a "cofounder prenup." This conversation should cover fundamental questions: Why do you want to create this startup? What are your most important values? How will you divide roles and make decisions? What happens if one of you isn't scaling or wants to leave? Having these discussions early establishes precedent for addressing difficult topics throughout your partnership. Trust forms the bedrock of effective cofounder relationships. Build it through regular informal time together - whether "taco Tuesdays" or monthly theater outings - that creates space for connection beyond immediate business concerns. This investment pays dividends when navigating inevitable conflicts and challenges. Clear role definition prevents confusion and friction. Sean and Connor, cofounders of an energy startup who had served together in the Royal Air Force, found their friendship tested by unclear expectations. Though they'd survived military boot camp together, the pressures of entrepreneurship created explosive conflicts. By explicitly defining decision rights and responsibilities, cofounders can avoid the resentment that builds when boundaries remain ambiguous. Perhaps most importantly, develop the habit of direct communication about difficult topics. Jocelyn and Raj, cofounders of an online marketplace, discovered major misalignment about their goals. Jocelyn wanted to build a disruptive, high-growth business requiring intense commitment, while Raj envisioned a lifestyle business that accommodated his other priorities. They had never discussed these different visions until tensions erupted. Through difficult but necessary conversations, they restructured their roles - Jocelyn remained CEO while Raj took a reduced role that matched his desired involvement. When growth disparities emerge, address them compassionately but directly. Jessie, a product-focused cofounder who excelled at design details, struggled as her consumer app company scaled. The CEO role increasingly required her to hire senior people, manage them strategically, and collaborate with executives - responsibilities she actively resisted. After honest discussion about her true preferences, she transitioned to a board role where she could contribute her product expertise without the management responsibilities she disliked. By approaching your cofounder relationship with intentionality, communication, and mutual respect, you build a partnership capable of weathering the inevitable storms of startup life. Remember that this relationship, like your company itself, requires ongoing investment and attention to thrive.

Summary

The journey from founder to CEO represents one of the most challenging and rewarding transformations in business. Throughout this journey, the fundamental truth remains: leadership begins with self-awareness, extends through creating psychological safety and intentional culture, and matures through implementing systems that enable sustainable growth. As you navigate these transitions, remember what Scott Harrison of Charity: Water discovered: "The biggest learning is sometimes just getting out of the way." True leadership evolves from doing everything yourself to enabling others to perform at their highest level. Your evolution as a leader directly influences your company's ability to scale. The skills that helped you launch your venture differ from those required to lead a growing organization. This doesn't mean abandoning your entrepreneurial spirit but rather complementing it with new capabilities and perspectives. Start today by selecting one area for focused development - perhaps improving how you give feedback, clarifying decision rights with your cofounder, or implementing a simple dashboard to track key metrics. Small, consistent improvements compound over time, transforming both your leadership capacity and your company's potential. The path from start-up to grown-up isn't a straight line, but with intention and persistence, you can build both the leadership and the organization needed to bring your vision fully to life.

About Author

Loading...

Alisa Cohn

Read more