The Messy Middle

The Messy Middle Plot Summary

Introduction

Imagine standing at the base of a mountain, gazing up at its peak with excitement and determination. The summit represents your goal—a successful business, a completed creative project, or a transformed organization. The first few steps are energizing, filled with possibility. But what happens when you find yourself halfway up, lost in dense fog, unsure if you're still on the right path? This is the messy middle—the long, volatile stretch where bold ventures are truly built or abandoned. It's where enthusiasm fades, doubts multiply, and the path forward becomes increasingly unclear. Yet paradoxically, it's also where the most meaningful work happens. The journey through this messy middle requires two fundamental capacities: endurance and optimization. Endurance helps you survive the inevitable valleys—those moments of doubt, exhaustion, and seemingly insurmountable obstacles. Optimization enables you to capitalize on the peaks—those moments of clarity, momentum, and opportunity. By mastering specific techniques for both enduring the lows and optimizing the highs, you can navigate this challenging terrain with greater confidence and effectiveness. You'll learn to play the long game when others seek immediate validation, to focus your creative energy where it matters most, and to design experiences that captivate from the very first interaction. The messy middle is unavoidable, but with the right mindset and tools, it becomes the forge where your most important work takes shape.

Chapter 1: Netflix vs. Blockbuster: The Power of Playing the Long Game

In 2000, Reed Hastings, the founder of a small DVD-by-mail company called Netflix, flew to Dallas to propose a partnership to Blockbuster CEO John Antioco. His proposal was simple: Netflix would run Blockbuster's brand online, and Blockbuster would promote Netflix in its stores. Antioco, however, wasn't interested. According to Hastings, Blockbuster essentially laughed them out of the room. At the time, Blockbuster was at the height of its power with thousands of retail locations, millions of customers, and a market value of $3 billion. Netflix was just a small startup trying to survive. But Hastings had a vision that extended far beyond the present moment. He saw that digital streaming would eventually replace physical media, even though broadband penetration was minimal at the time. While Blockbuster focused on maximizing short-term profits from late fees and retail sales, Netflix patiently built its subscription model and invested heavily in the streaming technology that wouldn't become viable for years. This patience required tremendous discipline. Netflix had to resist the temptation to optimize for immediate gains and instead focus on where the market was heading, not where it currently was. In 2007, when Netflix finally launched its streaming service, Blockbuster tried to catch up with its own digital offering, but it was too late. The company had optimized for the wrong metrics - store revenue rather than customer experience - and failed to make the necessary investments in digital infrastructure. By 2010, Blockbuster filed for bankruptcy while Netflix continued to grow. The Netflix story illustrates what Belsky calls "playing the long game" - the willingness to make moves that don't map to traditional measures of productivity. As he explains, "The most important things we do in the middle of a journey rarely provide immediate gratification or measurable progress. Rather, they build the foundation for our ultimate success." This principle applies beyond business. Whether you're building a career, creating art, or developing a relationship, the most meaningful progress often happens when you're willing to invest in actions that won't pay off immediately. The patience to endure without constant validation is what separates those who create lasting value from those who optimize only for short-term wins.

Chapter 2: Resourcefulness Over Resources: Skybox's Satellite Revolution

When Dan Berkenstock and Julian Mann decided to build the world's first commercial satellite imaging company in 2009, they faced a seemingly impossible challenge. Traditional satellites cost hundreds of millions of dollars to build and launch. As recent Stanford graduates with limited funding, they had no realistic path to enter the space industry - or so conventional wisdom suggested. Instead of giving up, they embraced their constraints. Working out of a garage in Palo Alto, they wondered: What if we could build a satellite using the same components found in smartphones? These mass-produced parts were cheap, lightweight, and surprisingly powerful. Industry experts scoffed at the idea, insisting that proper satellites required specialized aerospace hardware. Undeterred, the team scrounged parts from electronics stores and online suppliers. They tested their prototypes in vacuum chambers built from modified beer kegs. When they needed specialized testing equipment they couldn't afford, they would show up at Stanford labs after hours and borrow what they needed. Their first satellite prototype was roughly the size of a wine bottle, dramatically smaller than conventional satellites. By 2013, their company Skybox had successfully launched its first satellite, delivering images comparable to systems costing ten times more. Google acquired the company in 2014 for $500 million, validating their resourceful approach to a seemingly insurmountable challenge. "Resourcefulness is the mother of innovation," Belsky observes. "When you have limited resources, you're forced to use your creativity and ingenuity to solve problems. Constraints drive you to question industry assumptions and find unconventional paths forward." This principle appears repeatedly across successful ventures. Jessica Livingston, co-founder of Y Combinator, notes that startups often lose their edge when they raise too much money too quickly: "I've seen many startups shift from being resourceful to wasteful after raising money. They stop questioning expenses and start assuming that throwing money at problems will solve them." The most resilient founders maintain a resourceful mindset even when resources become abundant. They recognize that creativity thrives under constraints and that the discipline formed during lean times becomes a competitive advantage that lasts throughout the journey.

Chapter 3: Pinterest's Visual Conviction Against Industry Consensus

When Pinterest co-founder Ben Silberman was developing his platform in 2010, he faced a critical decision about the site's design. The conventional wisdom at the time, backed by data from similar websites, suggested that social platforms should prioritize user profiles and social connections. But Silberman had a different vision: he wanted Pinterest to focus entirely on the visual discovery experience, with large images taking center stage. His team was divided. Some argued that following established patterns would make the platform more familiar to new users. Others worried that without prominent social features, growth would stall. Investors questioned whether the design was too unconventional. The pressure to conform to existing models was intense. Despite the pushback, Silberman held firm to his conviction. "I just felt in my gut that people wanted a place to discover ideas through images, not another profile-centric social network," he later explained. He wasn't opposed to gathering input, but he recognized that true innovation rarely emerges from consensus. Pinterest launched with its distinctive visual-first design, and the results spoke for themselves. Users were drawn to the immersive discovery experience, and the platform grew rapidly. Today, with hundreds of millions of monthly active users, Pinterest's visual approach has been widely imitated across the internet. "Conviction > Consensus" is how Belsky frames this principle. He explains: "When working in a group, innovators must be willing to be the fool. The best decisions tend to be the hardest and least popular. When you feel like you're on your own, you'll question yourself." This doesn't mean ignoring feedback or acting unilaterally. Rather, it means developing the judgment to know when to seek input and when to trust your vision. As venture capitalist Mark Suster puts it: "No answers are obvious or everybody would be doing these things. I am amazed at how some entrepreneurial teams dither. I watch founders who want to get 'air cover' for hard decisions by getting too much input from their teams or boards." The messy middle of any journey is filled with difficult decisions that can't be resolved through polling. Having the courage to follow your convictions, especially when they run counter to conventional wisdom, is often what separates transformative ventures from mediocre ones.

Chapter 4: Killing Your Darlings: Behance's Painful Path to Focus

In 2011, Behance founder Scott Belsky faced a painful decision. His company had developed multiple product lines: the Behance creative network, a project management tool called Action Method, a line of paper products, and a conference and content platform called 99U. All were connected to the company's mission of "organizing and empowering the creative world," but the team's energy was severely divided. "We were splitting our energy across too many things," Belsky recalls. "We had no problem killing things that didn't work—and there were many—but we struggled to kill things that worked just well enough." The team was passionate about each initiative, and each had its own devoted customers and promising metrics. But this divided focus was taking a toll. Product updates were slower than competitors. The team was stretched thin. Fundraising became complicated because investors couldn't easily categorize the business. Belsky realized they were in what he now calls "the lost years" of Behance—inching forward too slowly by preserving too many potential paths to success. After much deliberation, Belsky made the difficult call to kill Action Method despite its loyal fan base. They outsourced the paper product line to a third party and stopped investing resources in it. For 99U, they found a way to compartmentalize the effort and validated that the brand and marketing benefits exceeded the costs. "Cutting off a tree's newest branch is painful, even if you know that doing so will strengthen the tree's core," Belsky explains. "The flaw with pursuing and preserving many options is that doing so stunts your progress in any particular direction. When your energy is split, so is your speed and focus." This principle of "killing your darlings"—a term borrowed from the literary world—applies across creative fields. Stephen King advises writers: "Kill your darlings, kill your darlings, even when it breaks your egocentric little scribbler's heart, kill your darlings." The same discipline is required for entrepreneurs who can't bear the thought of killing something they conceived, especially if it has some value. The sweetgreen restaurant chain faced a similar challenge when they spent significant time developing a juice line they were passionate about, only to eventually call it quits to focus on their core products. Dan Teran, founder of Managed by Q, cut a quarter of the services they offered customers despite seeing growth in those categories, choosing to focus where they could be "best in the world." Focused creativity is more important than more creativity. When you find yourself sustaining multiple initiatives that divide your energy, ask yourself: What would happen if you went all-in on just one? The path to escape velocity often requires the courage to kill your darlings.

Chapter 5: The Critical First Mile: Why Users Abandon Great Products

When Adobe acquired Behance in 2012, Belsky was shocked to learn how many people downloaded Photoshop each year, opened it once, and never opened it again. The problem wasn't the software's capability—Photoshop was the industry standard—but rather the intimidating first experience. A new Photoshop document was a blank page, and most people had no idea what to do next. "The first mile of a user's experience is almost always an afterthought," Belsky observes. "We spend so much time focusing on making what's behind a locked door brilliant, we sometimes forget to give the user the key." This insight led Belsky to develop what he calls the "first mile" principle: the critical first 30 seconds of a customer's experience with your product determines whether they'll continue using it. During this brief window, users need to understand three things: why they're there, what they can accomplish, and what to do next. For Behance, this meant rethinking their sign-up process. The team had created an elaborate onboarding that asked new members to select their top three creative fields from a long list of options. While this information was valuable for connecting users to relevant communities, they discovered they were losing more than 10 percent of new members at this step. "We decided to remove it and resolved to capture this information later on, sometime after the first mile once new Behance users were actively using the product," Belsky explains. By reducing and iterating the first mile experience, sign-ups increased by approximately 14 percent—a greater impact than any new feature that year. Belsky also discovered that during those first 30 seconds, people are fundamentally lazy, vain, and selfish. They don't want to invest time to understand your product, they care how they appear to others, and they want immediate personal benefit. The most effective first mile experiences account for these human tendencies rather than fighting against them. The best approach follows a simple hierarchy: Do > Show > Explain. Rather than explaining how to use your product, the most effective onboarding experiences do things proactively for users. Photography apps like Instagram apply smart filters all at once rather than forcing customers to learn individual editing tools. Paperless Post provides templates to choose from rather than explaining how to create a digital card from scratch. "You can't expect new customers to endure explanation," Belsky notes. "You can't even expect customers to patiently watch as you show them how to use your product. Your best chance at engaging them is to do it for them—at least at first."

Chapter 6: Building a High-Signal Network in a Noisy World

As Behance grew from a small startup to a platform with millions of users, Belsky noticed a pattern in his own productivity. The more successful the company became, the more noise he encountered—endless emails, meeting requests, and opportunities that demanded his attention but provided little value. "The more accomplished you become, the more noise you are exposed to," Belsky observes. "'Noise' has become a commonly used reference for the incessant banter, marketing messages, and regurgitation of stuff you already know. 'Signal' is the stuff you hear and learn from others that impacts you: the right question, feedback, or introduction that changes your plans." Belsky realized that his ability to make good decisions depended on improving his signal-to-noise ratio—amplifying valuable information while filtering out distractions. This required a fundamental shift in how he built his professional network. In the early days of Behance, Belsky optimized for surface area. He attended industry conferences, scheduled lunches with anyone he could reach, and cast a wide net. "By expanding the surface area of what you learn and who you meet, you increase your chances of finding more signal," he explains. While most conversations didn't amount to anything material, each interaction deepened his understanding of the industry. As Behance matured, Belsky shifted from seeking surface area to going deep with a smaller group of people he respected. He identified individuals who consistently provided high-quality insights—people who understood their field, had strong opinions, and followed through on commitments. These relationships became his most reliable sources of signal. "High-signal people don't want to discuss what's popular; they want to discuss what's not, or why what's popular is wrong," Belsky notes. When meeting such individuals, he focused on asking questions and listening rather than showcasing himself. By understanding their interests and expertise, he built reciprocal relationships that amplified signal. This approach extends beyond personal connections to information sources. Belsky became more discriminating about which newsletters, blogs, and events deserved his attention. He evaluated each based on its signal-to-noise ratio, cutting those that consumed time without providing actionable insights. "The sixth-sense-like intuition that leaders get at the peak of their career is the result of developing a network and filter that fosters a high signal-to-noise ratio," Belsky concludes. By going deeper with those you consider most competent, you amplify the power of signal in your life and make better decisions as a result.

Chapter 7: Chef Sakurada: The Art of Ending on Your Own Terms

In the back alleys of Kyoto, Japan, Chef Isuzu Sakurada had spent decades perfecting his craft at his small restaurant, Sakurada. With just four tables and ten seats, the intimate venue became renowned for its exquisite dashi (soup stock) and traditional Japanese cuisine. Young chefs from across Japan would travel to Kyoto to learn from Sakurada, whose dedication to his art was absolute. After years of quiet excellence, Sakurada received the culinary world's highest honor: two Michelin stars, placing his restaurant among the most celebrated in the world. For most chefs, this recognition would mark the beginning of expansion, higher prices, and a global brand. But Sakurada had a different vision for his legacy. Shortly after receiving his Michelin stars, to the shock of his staff, community, and the culinary world, Sakurada announced he would close his restaurant in one hundred days. Foodies from around the world made pilgrimages to dine at Sakurada before time ran out. Loyal patrons came for their last meals and left in tears. The announcement attracted so much fascination that a documentary was filmed chronicling the process of shutting down his restaurant. When Belsky had the opportunity to meet Sakurada's son-in-law, he learned that the chef's decision wasn't driven by health concerns or financial troubles. Rather, Sakurada had garnered tremendous respect from his local community and global acclaim from Michelin, which had "made him feel so full." He had achieved everything he set out to accomplish and now wanted to spend more time with his family and in nature. In a miraculous coincidence, Belsky later encountered Chef Sakurada playing with his granddaughter in a small square. "I was struck by the man's sense of peace and happiness," Belsky recalls. "His smile and mannerisms carried no weight to them—the man seemed so incredibly content with his world." Sakurada's story illustrates what Belsky calls "ending on your own terms"—recognizing when you've achieved what matters most and having the courage to move on. It's not just about leaving at your peak; it's about moving on when you feel fully satisfied and can therefore allow yourself to pursue something different. This principle applies beyond creative careers. Belsky's father, an orthopedic surgeon who had achieved success as a team doctor for major sports teams, decided in his sixties that a day in the operating room was less enticing than a day with his grandchildren. Rather than wait until his work started to suffer, he proactively approached his partners and created a transition plan. "A great finish is on your own terms, and it starts with that fully satisfied feeling that you want to hold on to," Belsky concludes. "Your legacy will never retire, but it is set on the note you leave it with." One of his favorite ancient sayings captures this wisdom: "Wealth is ultimately feeling like you got your full portion."

Summary

The journey through any bold venture follows a predictable pattern: the exciting beginning, the long and volatile middle, and the eventual end. Success hinges not on avoiding the messy middle, but on developing specific skills to navigate it effectively. First, cultivate endurance by embracing the long game and finding meaning in the process itself rather than seeking constant validation. Second, optimize relentlessly - prune projects that divide your focus, create powerful first impressions for new users, and build networks that amplify signal over noise. Take immediate action by identifying what you can kill today - which projects, features, or commitments are dividing your energy without providing proportional returns? Then examine your first mile experience through fresh eyes: if someone encountered your product, service, or idea for the first time, would they immediately understand why they're there, what they can accomplish, and what to do next? Finally, audit your information diet and relationships - are you surrounding yourself with high-signal people who challenge your thinking, or merely accumulating noise? Remember that the messy middle is where greatness is forged, but only for those with the wisdom to endure and optimize their way through it.

About Author

Loading...

Scott Belsky

Read more

Related Books by Scott Belsky

Loading...

Making Ideas Happen

Scott Belsky

Overcoming the Obstacles Between Vision and Reality

★★★★☆4.1