Raising Cain

Raising Cain Plot Summary

Introduction

Luke sits in the oversized leather chair of the school psychologist's office, his baseball cap clutched nervously in his hands. At thirteen, he's been sent here because of falling grades and a recent outburst where he kicked a hole in his bedroom wall. "I'm fine," he says defiantly, eyes flashing with anger. When asked about his family, his answers are curt: his sister is an idiot, his brother a jerk, his father is never around, and his mother treats him like a child. But when gently asked if he feels sad, Luke's eyes well up with tears as he looks down. "I don't know. Maybe, I guess." This moment of vulnerability reveals the emotional reality many boys face daily. Beneath their masks of anger, defiance, or indifference lies a complex emotional landscape they've been taught to hide. Our culture sends boys powerful messages about masculinity that discourage emotional expression beyond anger. The consequences are profound: boys who cannot name or process their feelings become men who struggle with relationships, mental health, and finding meaning in their lives. By understanding the hidden emotional world of boys, we can help them develop the emotional literacy they need to thrive, creating pathways for authentic connection and resilience that will serve them throughout their lives.

Chapter 1: The Mask of Masculinity: How Boys Learn to Hide

Danny was a fifteen-year-old soccer player whose game had mysteriously fallen apart. Once a star goalie, he now struggled on the field, and his grades were slipping too. His parents encouraged him to see a therapist, hoping to turn things around. When he arrived for his session, Danny appeared confident on the surface, but his eyes told a different story - they were tired, sad, weighed down by something unseen. As the conversation unfolded, it became clear that Danny wasn't clinically depressed; he had too much natural energy for that diagnosis. Yet he was deeply discouraged by the events of the past year, analyzing his soccer performance as if watching another player from the sidelines. "I know I'm a better goalie than the way I'm playing," he explained. "It's like I'm distracted when I'm out there, and then when I don't play as well as I should, I get really mad, and then I play even worse." The source of Danny's troubles wasn't immediately obvious. His parents were supportive, his home life stable. His father had even told him that setbacks were normal and a test of character - one that Danny was "good enough to beat." But this encouragement hadn't helped. In fact, Danny felt worse for failing parents who were so clearly in his corner. Through careful conversation, the therapist helped Danny revisit the past year to search for the source of his distraction. Two seemingly minor events emerged. First, Danny had injured himself foolishly while showing off, causing him to miss three critical games his team ultimately lost. Second, and perhaps more significantly, he had tried out for the varsity hockey team but, intimidated by the older players' size and skill, had withdrawn despite performing adequately in tryouts. He told his coach he'd decided not to play, but in his heart, he felt like a coward and a quitter. For nearly a year, Danny had kept these feelings of shame and self-contempt bottled up inside. The emotional burden trapped him, affecting his concentration both on the field and in the classroom. What Danny needed most was a safe space to air these feelings of perceived cowardice and his constant self-reproach. After just four conversations with his therapist, the psychological burden that had trapped him for a year began to lift. His concentration on the field and in the classroom started to improve as he learned to process his emotions rather than suppress them. Danny's story illustrates a common pattern among boys: stoicism in the face of emotional pain. Rather than talk about their feelings, many boys adopt a stance of emotional isolation, refusing to share what troubles them. This stoicism knots together with pride, reinforcing itself. Not only is it difficult for these boys to express themselves, but they take a certain pride in keeping their mouths shut. In psychological distress, they're like the captain of the Titanic, standing on the bridge gallantly going down with their ship. They want to appear strong and brave, even when they're drowning inside. The difference is, of course, that most boys aren't on a sinking ship. They're just struggling with being young, with having high expectations of themselves, with wanting to please their parents, and with not knowing themselves very well.

Chapter 2: School Battlegrounds: Academic Pressure and Gender Expectations

It is midmorning circle time in Ms. Alvarez's kindergarten class, and fifteen children—six boys and nine girls—sit on a carpet waiting for her to begin reading. On one side of the circle, the girls sit shoulder to shoulder, some with legs crossed, some with hands clasped in their laps, some waiting quietly, expectantly, others chatting happily. Beside them sits Daniel, equally self-possessed, relaxed, and waiting. Daniel is the best reader in the class; for him story time is the happiest time of his day. A few feet away sit four boys who are a study in contrast. Justin leans sideways onto Will's chest; Will collapses onto Bashir's shoulder; while Bashir presses against Ryan, who is doing all he can not to tip over. This falling tableau doesn't turn into a total collapse; it seems frozen in space. The boys are quiet, waiting for Ms. Alvarez to begin reading. They are doing their best to follow the classroom rules, and she knows it. Yet she cannot start reading until Christopher comes to join the circle. Christopher had been playing with Tangrams when Ms. Alvarez rang the bell. On the way to returning his Tangrams, he ran his finger through the chalk swirls on the blackboard, bumped into Justin, and stopped to pick up plastic fruits in the play kitchen. Now he is standing at the supply shelves, idly sifting through colored markers. "Christopher, are you going to join us?" asks Ms. Alvarez. Her question catches his attention. He looks over but doesn't move. "Christopher, we're waiting," she says firmly. Christopher hesitates, then drops the markers and starts across the room. Meanwhile, the domino boys have begun to collapse. Justin has fallen into Will, and Will is trying to push him out of his lap. Though the process of getting the boys to sit quietly has taken only two to three minutes, it's hard not to be annoyed at Justin and Christopher. They waste a disproportionate amount of class time every day. The gender split is obvious; the girls bring energy and exuberance to the circle, too, but it is contained; they readily follow instructions. The boys have a much harder time sitting still. Grade school is largely a feminine environment, populated predominantly by women teachers and authority figures, that seems rigged against boys, against the higher activity level and lower level of impulse control that is normal for boys. As one disappointed first-grade boy remarked unhappily at the end of his first day of school: "You can't do anything!" The trouble wasn't really that he couldn't do anything, of course, but that everything he loved to do—run, throw, wrestle, climb—was outlawed in the classroom. From kindergarten through sixth grade, a boy spends more than a thousand hours a year in school, and his experiences there are profoundly shaping. The average boy faces a special struggle to meet the developmental and academic expectations of an elementary school curriculum that emphasizes reading, writing, and verbal ability—cognitive skills that normally develop more slowly in boys than in girls. Some boys are ahead of the others on that developmental curve, and some girls lag behind, but when we compare the average boy with the average girl, the average boy is developmentally disadvantaged in the early school environment. This developmental disadvantage creates a perfect storm for many boys. They enter a system that demands skills they haven't yet mastered, then labels them as problems when they struggle. The boy who can't sit still becomes "disruptive." The one who has trouble focusing becomes "inattentive." The one who processes information differently becomes "learning disabled." These labels follow boys through their educational careers, shaping not just how others see them but how they come to see themselves. A boy who repeatedly hears that he's a problem internalizes that message, often responding with either resignation or rebellion. The classroom becomes a battleground where boys must constantly negotiate between their natural developmental needs and institutional expectations. This negotiation exacts an emotional toll that often goes unrecognized. Behind the fidgeting, the class clowning, or the apparent disinterest may be a boy desperately trying to adapt to an environment that feels fundamentally at odds with who he is. Understanding this struggle is essential for creating educational spaces where boys can thrive emotionally as well as academically, where their developmental differences are accommodated rather than pathologized.

Chapter 3: Father Wounds: The Search for Male Connection

When twelve-year-old Jody first came to therapy, he carried himself as if bearing an invisible weight. Four years had passed since his father died of cancer, but the grief remained fresh and overwhelming. Jody had loved his father passionately, and his father had loved him. They had closely identified with each other, sharing interests and a special bond. After his father's death, Jody fell into a deep depression that initially went unnoticed amid his mother's and sister's more outward expressions of grief. In therapy, it became clear that Jody had a tremendous emotional hunger for a father figure, but he actively resisted developing closer relationships with any of the older men in his life - his teachers, his uncles, family friends, even his therapist. This resistance wasn't simply stubbornness. For Jody, becoming attached to another father figure felt like a betrayal of his great love for his dad. He was being loyal to his father by withdrawing from such contacts. He was carrying a torch for his dad. The sadness in his eyes was palpable, creating an almost physical presence that made others uncomfortable. Even his therapist, trained to sit with emotional pain, sometimes felt an urge to escape the intensity of Jody's grief. "If the intensity of these boys' pain can make me want to turn and run," the therapist reflected, "imagine what other people in Jody's life felt." Jody was suffering from what Freud described as "strangulated grief" - grief that has not found full expression and progressed through all its stages. This occurs in both men and women, but culturally men - and boys as well - are at greater risk for an incomplete grieving process. Why? Because grieving doesn't look strong or masculine. It looks weak, vulnerable, and dependent. Grieving involves surrendering to love and sadness, emotions that many men cannot bear to feel because they seem at odds with masculine identity. Trapped by the "Big Impossible" that denies a boy the freedom of emotional expression to grieve and be comforted, boys like Jody become isolated with their sorrow. The father-son relationship shapes a boy's emotional development in profound ways, whether through presence or absence. When fathers model emotional courage - the willingness to acknowledge vulnerability, express feelings openly, and connect authentically with others - they give their sons permission to do the same. Conversely, when fathers remain emotionally distant or demonstrate that "real men" don't show weakness, they teach their sons to suppress their emotional lives, often with devastating consequences. Many men recall moments when their fathers shut down emotional expression with phrases like "big boys don't cry" or "man up," creating wounds that persist into adulthood. What boys need from their fathers isn't perfection but authenticity. They need to see their fathers struggle, make mistakes, apologize, express joy, and sometimes even cry. These moments of genuine emotional expression become landmarks in a boy's memory, points of reference that tell him it's safe to be fully human. When a father shares his own fears or uncertainties, he doesn't diminish himself in his son's eyes - rather, he demonstrates a deeper kind of strength that comes from self-awareness and emotional honesty. This modeling creates a foundation for emotional resilience that serves boys throughout their lives.

Chapter 4: Mother-Son Bonds: Navigating Adolescent Changes

Sam and his mother had always been especially close. When Sam's older brother was off playing Little League games with his dad, she would take Sam, still a toddler, along to her sculptor's studio and give him his own pile of clay to work with. At night, when father and older son were poring over Civil War history books, Sam and his mother would snuggle together on the sofa, as she read him the poetry that she had loved as a child. But when Sam turned twelve, he began to pull away from his mother. Almost overnight, he began to complain that poetry was for "babies" and working in clay was "boring." He started to dodge her hugs and after dinner on most nights beat a quick retreat to the privacy of his room. His mother tried not to feel hurt, reminding herself that at this age Sam needed some room to grow, but his emotional withdrawal was difficult for her to accept. So every time he pulled away, she stepped in to close the gap. In a reprise of their cherished bedtime routine when he was younger, she began knocking on his door at night, wanting to come in and talk. As she sat on the edge of his bed, trying to make conversation, he made no effort to conceal his impatience. When she tried to explain that she simply missed their conversations, he only said, "Mom, I have to get back to my studying. Would you please just leave?" A mother can experience her son's first moves toward independence as rejection, but that isn't what they are. Sam's mother's intense effort to hold on to him only made him want more to pull away, and ultimately it damaged their relationship. Thirty years later Sam still recalls the friction of that time. It is common to regard a mother's connection to her son as finite, an inevitable casualty of a boy's growth into manhood. Certainly, there comes a point in his young life when a boy must shift his central attachment from his mother to his father and begin to identify himself as a man-in-the-making. However, there is no point—not at age four, or nine, or thirteen, when a boy must "give up" his mother, or when a mother must "give up" her son. The fundamental pattern of the relationship between a boy and his mother is one of exploration and return. He is the explorer; she is his "home base." Emotionally, as well as physically, throughout his childhood, as a boy explores, he carries the safety and familiarity of his mother with him. As he grows, a boy must be able to leave his mother without losing her completely and return to her without losing himself. A mother's loving task is parallel: she must try to understand and respond to what her son needs at different stages of his life. When a relationship has this balance, we describe it as synchronous. This synchronicity becomes especially challenging during adolescence, when a boy's developmental need to establish his masculine identity can clash with his emotional need for maternal connection. Many mothers misinterpret their sons' adolescent withdrawal as a permanent rejection rather than a necessary, if sometimes awkward, step toward maturity. They respond either by clinging more tightly, as Sam's mother did, or by prematurely disconnecting from their sons emotionally. Neither response serves a boy's development. What boys need instead is for their mothers to remain emotionally available while respecting their growing need for autonomy. The most emotionally healthy mother-son relationships evolve rather than dissolve during adolescence. The physical affection of childhood may give way to different expressions of care, but the emotional bond remains intact. A mother who can navigate this transition skillfully - offering her son both roots and wings - provides him with a model for balanced relationships that will serve him throughout his life. She teaches him that emotional connection and independence aren't mutually exclusive, that vulnerability and strength can coexist, and that authentic masculinity includes the capacity for deep attachment.

Chapter 5: The Fortress of Solitude: Emotional Isolation and Its Costs

Martin, a bespectacled video production technician, recalled life as the son of a corporate executive—a man of high intellect and short temper—and a mother he experienced as dutiful but emotionally distant. School was more of a struggle for Martin than his father could accept, and his criticism was relentless. Martin could not recall ever having had a conversation with his father that had started and ended on a pleased note. Junior high school began one of the worst periods of his life. Martin's grades were just average, even though he worked pretty hard. He wasn't at all athletic and was made to feel self-conscious when he was forced to do sports in gym class. At home his mother was too busy with three-year-old twin sisters to offer much support, and he preferred to avoid his father and the predictable criticism altogether. He considered a couple of boys in his class "school friends": they sat together at lunch, but they never socialized outside of school. It seemed to Martin that nothing in his life was working right; his grades, his social life, and his father's criticism were continual reminders of his status as "a loser." "I'd come home every day and go upstairs to my room to 'study,' but it wouldn't last long. I couldn't track on the material. So I'd sit there and hate myself—really hate myself—and think about how many ways I was a loser. I'd think about how my father would blow up when he heard about the latest bad test grade." When his feelings of self-loathing became intolerable, Martin's response was to retreat—literally—to a corner of the attic, where he used his pocketknife to carve into the rafter a countdown of the days left in the school year. He would sit for hours by the tiny attic window, staring down at the people and the world below him that he felt were passing him by. Then he discovered a box with his father's old collection of Playboy magazines, and sexual fantasy gave him some relief from his painful feelings. Emotional isolation has become virtually a reflex by the time a boy reaches adolescence. He has learned to deny his emotional neediness and routinely disguise his feelings. Intimidated by the constant threat of humiliation presented by the culture of cruelty and the ensuing erosion of trust, boys strike a psychological bargain—a bad one—namely, that they'd rather hide out than take any more hits. The more pressure a boy feels, the more deeply he withdraws. A boy distanced from genuine emotional interaction misses the opportunity for meaningful emotional growth. For all of us, psychological and personal growth come when we can face what it is that bothers us, gain an understanding of it, and figure out what to do about it. An emotionally isolated boy, when troubled, is more likely to look for a scapegoat, blaming other people or circumstances for his problems. What neither a boy nor his parents realize is that this effort to cut himself off from his family, his emotions, and any reflection on his state of mind is exhausting. When boys succeed at it, they only add to their own misery. The fortress of solitude that many boys construct around themselves may feel like protection, but it ultimately becomes a prison, cutting them off from the very connections that could help them navigate their difficulties. This isolation carries long-term costs that extend far beyond adolescence. Boys who don't learn to recognize and express their emotions grow into men who struggle with intimacy, who lack emotional resilience, and who often resort to unhealthy coping mechanisms like substance abuse or workaholism. The path out of isolation begins with creating safe spaces where boys can gradually lower their defenses without fear of ridicule or rejection, where they can practice the emotional literacy that will serve them throughout their lives.

Chapter 6: Depression's Different Face: When Boys' Pain Goes Unrecognized

Loren was about as engaging as a hornet's nest—an unpleasant, irritable fourteen-year-old. He worked well in class but was a snarly student, critical of teachers as "stupid" and of fellow students as "morons." His teachers had pretty much written him off as "a case"—meaning he was a boy "with issues"—and they wondered at faculty meetings whether the school should even try to keep him. His attitude wasn't any better at home. He smashed things when he got angry, which was often. His parents blamed each other for their son's difficulties, creating tension at home. With him they alternated between appeasement and support to encourage him, and anger and punishment when he screwed up. Loren was depressed, and as it does in many boys, his depression presented, not as a sad, down mood, but as irritability. He didn't like himself very much, didn't really believe that anyone else did either, and didn't have much hope that things would change. Once he was properly diagnosed, he was treated with antidepressants and individual and family therapy over the summer. By the start of the next school year, Loren was recovered. Loren's was not a hopeless case; this was no miracle cure. He was a boy whose illness had been made worse when the people around him became so caught up in reacting to the symptoms that they couldn't see what was behind them. Symptoms of depression in boys may be hard to read or be missed because the boys often don't look sad or "depressed." They look edgy or angry, hostile or defiant. A boy's depression is often ignored because he is meeting cultural expectations of masculinity. Stoicism, emotional reserve, or even a withdrawal into his fortress of solitude are accepted and sometimes admired male behaviors. Depressive behavior in boys often only comes to our attention when it finally costs them performance points in school or on the playing field, or when it gets them into trouble with the law. Consider Keith, who toward the end of his freshman year in high school, circulated a note to his friends saying that he was going to throw himself off a bridge at the end of the school day. The note also contained some extraordinarily vitriolic attacks on his parents and a lot of swearwords. Two friends who were very concerned brought the note to the school counselor. Keith was furious that the note had been brought to attention and insisted that it was meant to be a joke. Though he was articulate and at moments persuasive, the counselor took the note absolutely seriously and called his parents. When finally reached, Keith's mother, a busy corporate attorney, was irritated. She assured the counselor that it was just her son's dark sense of humor, nothing more. She didn't want the school to overreact in a way that would bring him to the attention of the authorities. Stunned by her reaction, the counselor insisted that any suicide threat has to be taken seriously and wouldn't let Keith leave school until his parents came in for a meeting. The parents said "yes, yes" to recommendations for therapy and took Keith home, but they never followed up. They moved him to another school the following year. There, Keith made a very serious suicide attempt. He was hospitalized and finally, in therapy long overdue, revealed that he had been abused between the ages of eight and ten by an uncle. Depression and suicidality in boys often hide behind masks that make them difficult to recognize. The angry boy, the defiant boy, the class clown, the risk-taker - all may be expressing emotional pain in the only ways they know how. Our cultural expectations for masculine behavior can blind us to the suffering beneath these behaviors, leading us to respond with discipline rather than support. This misreading of boys' emotional signals can have tragic consequences, as it nearly did for Keith. The path to better supporting boys' mental health begins with recognizing that depression in boys often looks different than it does in girls. While girls may become tearful or withdrawn, boys more commonly become irritable, aggressive, or engage in high-risk behaviors. By expanding our understanding of how emotional pain manifests in boys, we can respond more effectively to their needs, creating spaces where they can receive the support they need before reaching a crisis point.

Chapter 7: Breaking Through: Pathways to Emotional Literacy

Foster, a short, chubby thirteen-year-old, was the oldest child of four, and he had recently withdrawn from the affectionate, teasing relationship he had always enjoyed with his younger brothers and sisters. He spent less time with his mom than he used to. "We used to be a lot closer," she said. "I wish I knew what was going on with him, and I wonder if he's okay." Foster's mother had a chronic kidney disorder that was being successfully managed, but despite her good checkups, her children's anxiety about her health continued on a low simmer. Foster's father was an entrepreneur whose business was failing, and the stress level at home was on the rise. Now, sitting in the therapist's office tapping his pencil nervously against his knee, it is clear that Foster is, in effect, battening down the hatches to keep himself, and his life, to himself. He needs to relax if therapy is to make any progress. With his parents' prior approval, the therapist embarks on a brief field trip to the neighborhood's favorite corner store, where Foster can choose two items for a snack, something the therapist often does with boys, in order to get them to let their guard down and to give them something nonthreatening to talk about. After several weeks of talking junk food with Foster, they turn to the "work" of therapy, which involves questions about his family. They talk about the lay of the land at home, who's who, and then they turn to his feelings. The therapist pulls out a piece of paper and a pencil, writes "Dear Mom," and asks Foster what he would tell his mother if he could share what was on his mind. Initially he balks, protesting that he wouldn't know what to say. But then he begins to speak. First, he apologizes for screaming and swearing at her. He says he is sorry. The therapist writes it down. And that he would try to be more respectful. He also hopes she would be more respectful of him. The therapist continues to write his thoughts down, dictation style. Boys often appreciate such directions. Foster did, for sure. That day, and over time, it becomes clear that Foster is quite worried about circumstances at home. He is concerned about his moodiness and feels saddened by his parents' troubles. In the therapy setting, Foster comes to recognize that although there isn't much he can do about the serious challenges facing his family—and they are unnerving for a boy—if he can learn to confront his fears and talk about them, their grip on his life is lessened. After about four months of therapy, Foster is no longer in hiding. The change is visible: the hangdog demeanor is gone, replaced by a more buoyant expression and enthusiasm. He looks forward to the sessions, with the store ritual and "Twinkie" conversations. In contrast to his first visits, the therapist no longer has to "do all the work" of their conversations about feelings. The therapy setting has done what it was designed to do: provide a safe environment for talking about difficult things. Foster begins to hang out with a friend who likes skateboarding, and they begin skateboarding together. Foster becomes surprisingly proficient, despite his lack of coordination. Over the next year, they continue to work through Foster's feelings about his parents' marriage as well as his worries for his father and for his mother's health. Meanwhile, he spends more and more time with his friend. They build a skateboard ramp, and their skillful risky tricks attract an admiring audience of other boys. Soon Foster has a group of boys around him. Boys need an emotional vocabulary that expands their ability to express themselves in ways other than anger or aggression. They need to experience empathy at home and at school and be encouraged to use it if they are to develop conscience. Boys, no less than girls, need to feel emotional connections. Throughout their lives, but especially during adolescence, they need close, supportive relationships that can protect them from becoming victims of their turbulent, disowned emotions. Most important, a boy needs male modeling of a rich emotional life. He needs to learn emotional literacy as much from his father and other men as from his mother and other women, because he must create a life and language for himself that speak with male identity. A boy must see and believe that emotions belong in the life of a man.

Summary

The emotional lives of boys are complex landscapes often hidden beneath cultural expectations of stoicism and strength. From Luke's reluctant tears in the school psychologist's office to Foster's transformation through therapy, we've witnessed how boys struggle to navigate their feelings in a world that offers them few tools for emotional expression. The stories of Danny, Jody, Sam, Martin, Loren, Keith, and Foster reveal a common thread: boys desperately need safe spaces to express their authentic emotions without fear of judgment or rejection. When denied these spaces, they retreat into fortresses of solitude that protect them from immediate pain but ultimately cut them off from the connections that foster resilience and growth. The path to emotional literacy for boys isn't about forcing them to express themselves like girls, but about expanding their emotional vocabulary in ways that honor their masculine identity while freeing them from its most restrictive aspects. This journey requires adults who can model emotional courage, who can recognize the pain behind anger and withdrawal, who can create environments where vulnerability is seen as strength rather than weakness. When we provide boys with these supports, the transformation can be remarkable. Like Foster, who moved from isolation to connection through skateboarding and friendship, boys can learn that their emotions aren't enemies to be conquered but guides to be consulted on their journey toward authentic manhood. By helping boys develop emotional literacy, we don't just improve their lives today; we create the foundation for healthier relationships, greater resilience, and more fulfilling lives for the men they will become.

About Author

Loading...

Dan Kindlon

Dan Kindlon, Ph.D., a member of the Harvard University faculty for over fifteen years, teaches child psychology and conducts research in child development. A leading clinical and research psychologist specializing in behavioral problems in children and adolescents, Dr. Kindlon has focused on the diagnosis and treatment of emotional issues, learning disabilities and attention deficit disorders in over 20 years of clinical practice. He is the author of many articles in scientific journals and several books, including Alpha Girls, Raising Cain, Too Much of a Good Thing, and Tough Times, Strong Children. Dr. Kindlon lectures widely to groups of parents, educators, and mental health professionals, and has made many national media appearances, including on The Today Show, 20/20, CNN, and National Public Radio. He lives outside Boston with his wife and two children.

Read more