A Handbook for New Stoics

A Handbook for New Stoics Plot Summary

Introduction

Life often feels like a storm we can't control. Unexpected challenges arise, people disappoint us, and circumstances shift without warning. In these moments, we might find ourselves reacting with frustration, anxiety, or despair—emotions that only compound our suffering. But what if there was a time-tested approach to navigating life's uncertainties with greater equanimity and purpose? For over two thousand years, Stoic philosophy has offered practical wisdom for thriving in an unpredictable world. Far from encouraging emotional suppression, Stoicism provides a framework for distinguishing between what we can and cannot control, transforming our relationship with adversity, and cultivating virtues that lead to genuine flourishing. Through weekly practices that build upon one another, you'll develop the mental habits and perspectives that allow you to respond to life's challenges with wisdom rather than reactivity, finding tranquility and meaning regardless of external circumstances.

Chapter 1: Master the Discipline of Desire and Find Inner Peace

The foundation of Stoic practice begins with understanding the discipline of desire—learning to want what is within your control and to accept with equanimity what isn't. This discipline teaches us to recognize that our happiness depends not on external circumstances, but on our judgments about them. By redirecting our desires toward what we can influence—our own character, intentions, and responses—we free ourselves from the emotional turbulence that comes from attaching our well-being to things beyond our control. Consider Mike, who attended his twenty-five-year college reunion expecting a pleasant reconnection with old friends. Instead, it became an exercise in inadequacy. His classmates Aziz and Saliah were still happily married since sophomore year, while Mike's marriage had lasted less than five years. His former roommate Steve maintained his athletic physique while Mike had developed a potbelly and thinning hair. Steve had also reached the C-suite, while Mike remained in middle management at a company whose products he didn't believe in. Looking in the bathroom mirror after the cocktail hour, Mike couldn't help but feel like a failure. "No wonder I'm unhappy," he thought. "Everything is awful." Mike's suffering stemmed not from his circumstances themselves, but from his judgments about them. He had placed the measure of his worth in externals—his marital status, physical appearance, and career advancement—all things not entirely within his control. The Stoic approach would invite Mike to shift his focus from these externals to what truly matters: his character, his values, and how he responds to life's challenges. This shift begins with the dichotomy of control—distinguishing between what is and isn't within our power. As Epictetus teaches, "Some things are within our power, while others are not. Within our power are opinion, motivation, desire, aversion, and, in a word, whatever is of our own doing; not within our power are our body, our property, reputation, office, and, in a word, whatever is not of our own doing." By focusing our desires on what we can control, we ensure we'll always get what we want. Practicing this discipline involves several key steps. First, regularly examine your thoughts and emotions to identify when you're attaching your happiness to externals. Second, practice taking an outside view of your troubles, as if advising a friend rather than being caught in your own drama. Third, strengthen yourself through minor physical discomforts to build resilience. Finally, remind yourself of the impermanence of all things, appreciating what you have while recognizing nothing lasts forever. Through these practices, you'll gradually find yourself less disturbed by external events and more centered in your own virtue and character—the only true goods that can never be taken from you.

Chapter 2: Take Purposeful Action Through Stoic Principles

The second pillar of Stoic practice focuses on how we act in the world. The discipline of action teaches us to move through life with intention and purpose, guided by virtue rather than impulse or social pressure. This isn't about controlling outcomes—which remain beyond our complete control—but about ensuring our actions themselves embody wisdom, justice, courage, and temperance regardless of results. Ameerah experienced this challenge firsthand at her gym. As she approached the squat rack, she found someone using it for bicep curls—an exercise that doesn't require this specialized equipment. She felt her anger rising as she considered the poor gym etiquette of the person occupying the equipment she needed. While her frustration was understandable, the Stoics would caution that anger isn't useful in this situation and would only disturb her own peace of mind. Epictetus offers guidance for such moments: "When you are about to undertake some action, remind yourself what kind of action it is. If you're going to bathe, picture what happens in a bathhouse—the people who splash water, those who push, those who speak rudely, those who steal. And then you will undertake your action more securely if from the start you say: 'I want to bathe and to keep my choices in accordance with nature.' And likewise for every action. For if anything should happen that interferes with your bathing, you'll have ready: 'Well, this was not my only aim, but also to keep my choices in accordance with nature; and I cannot do that if I'm annoyed at what's happening.'" Rather than allowing her anger to consume her, Ameerah could approach the situation differently. She might remind herself that her primary goal isn't just to complete her workout but to maintain her inner tranquility while doing so. With this perspective, she could calmly ask the person if they would mind doing bicep curls elsewhere since she needs the squat rack for its intended purpose. If they refuse, she can adapt her workout plan without losing her composure. To practice this discipline, start by setting an intention each morning to keep your peace of mind alongside your external goals. When entering potentially frustrating situations, mentally rehearse maintaining your composure regardless of what happens. Choose your company wisely, as we tend to absorb the qualities of those around us. Speak thoughtfully rather than impulsively, and practice rolling with insults rather than being wounded by them. Remember that purposeful action isn't just about personal tranquility—it extends to our responsibilities toward others. The Stoics believed humans are naturally social creatures meant to work together for mutual benefit. By acting with justice and kindness, even toward difficult people, we fulfill our nature as rational, social beings and contribute to the common good.

Chapter 3: Train Your Mind with Daily Stoic Practices

The discipline of assent—the third and most advanced Stoic practice—focuses on training your mind to evaluate impressions correctly before giving them your agreement or "assent." This discipline helps you recognize that events themselves don't disturb you; rather, it's your judgments about those events that create emotional disturbance. By learning to withhold automatic assent to misleading impressions, you gain freedom from unnecessary suffering. Vasily discovered this principle while working with his anger through the discipline of action. While trying to act contrary to his anger, he noticed that he started catching his value judgments before they led to the emotion itself. He realized that his anger wasn't caused directly by external events but by his opinions about those events—opinions that he could examine and potentially revise. Epictetus describes this process: "Make it your study then to confront every harsh impression with the words, 'You are but an impression, and not at all what you seem to be.' Then test it by those rules that you possess; and first by this—the chief test of all—'Is it concerned with what is in our power or with what is not in our power?' And if it is concerned with what is not in our power, be ready with the answer that it is nothing to you." When Vasily felt anger arising at a colleague who missed a deadline, he could pause and examine his impression: "This person is incompetent and disrespectful." He might then ask himself: "Is my colleague's behavior within my control?" Recognizing it isn't, he could then question his judgment: "Is it necessarily true that they're incompetent or disrespectful? Might there be circumstances I'm unaware of?" This examination creates space between the initial impression and his response, allowing him to choose a more reasoned reaction. To practice this discipline, start by catching your initial impressions—especially those that trigger strong emotions. When you notice a harsh impression arising, pause and say to yourself, "This is just an impression, not necessarily reality." Then examine whether the object of your impression is within your control. If not, remind yourself that it cannot harm your character or true well-being unless you allow it to. Advanced practitioners can further refine this process by decomposing their impressions, breaking down complex emotional reactions into their component parts and examining each one. They also develop ready-at-hand maxims—brief Stoic principles they can recall in challenging moments to maintain perspective and respond virtuously. With consistent practice, this discipline becomes second nature, allowing you to maintain tranquility even in the most difficult circumstances. As Marcus Aurelius wrote, "You have power over your mind—not outside events. Realize this, and you will find strength."

Chapter 4: Build Resilience Through Adversity Training

Stoicism is often misunderstood as mere endurance of hardship, but it actually offers sophisticated techniques for transforming our relationship with adversity. Rather than simply gritting our teeth through difficulties, Stoic practice helps us use challenges as opportunities for growth, developing psychological resilience that serves us in all circumstances. Giovanni exemplified this approach after experiencing a difficult divorce. While many of his friends who went through similar experiences harbored bitterness and resentment, Giovanni approached his situation differently. Instead of focusing solely on his pain, he reflected on what role he played in the divorce, what he learned about himself through the process, and how he could use this experience to become a better person. Seneca captures this perspective beautifully: "We see athletes, who study only their bodily strength, engage with the strongest of men, and insist that those who train them for the arena should put out their whole strength when practicing with them. They endure blows and maltreatment, and if they cannot find any single person who is their match, they engage with several at once... You should know that good men ought to act in like manner, so as not to fear troubles and difficulties, nor to lament their hard fate, to take in good part whatever befalls them, and force it to become a blessing to them. It does not matter what you bear, but how you bear it." This approach invites us to reframe difficulties as training grounds for virtue. Just as athletes seek out challenging opponents to improve their skills, we can view life's obstacles as opportunities to strengthen our character. When Giovanni faced the pain of his divorce, he didn't simply endure it passively—he actively engaged with it, asking what virtues he could practice in response and how he might grow from the experience. To build this kind of resilience, begin with premeditation of adversity (premeditatio malorum)—a practice of visualizing potential challenges before they occur. Each morning, take a few moments to consider what difficulties you might face during the day and how you would respond virtuously. This mental rehearsal prepares you to face real challenges with greater equanimity. Another powerful practice is voluntary discomfort—intentionally exposing yourself to minor hardships like cold showers, fasting, or sleeping on a hard surface. These self-imposed discomforts help you realize that many things you fear or avoid aren't as terrible as your imagination suggests, building confidence in your ability to handle whatever comes your way. Remember that the goal isn't to become indifferent to pain or loss, but to respond to these experiences with wisdom and virtue rather than being overwhelmed by them. As Epictetus reminds us, "It's not what happens to you, but how you respond to it that matters."

Chapter 5: Cultivate Wisdom Through Self-Examination

At the heart of Stoic practice lies the commitment to honest self-examination. Without regular reflection on our thoughts, actions, and character, we cannot make meaningful progress toward wisdom. The Stoics developed various techniques for self-scrutiny that remain remarkably effective today. Niamh discovered the value of this practice after losing her temper at her husband for not washing the dishes. Though she'd had a long day, and her husband did indeed neglect his share of household duties frequently, she regretted the harsh words she used that clearly hurt him. As she lay in bed that night, she found herself rehashing the argument and berating herself for her loss of control. Seneca describes a more productive approach to such reflection: "The spirit ought to be brought up for examination daily. It was the custom of Sextius when the day was over, and he had betaken himself to rest, to inquire of his spirit: 'What bad habit of yours have you cured today? What vice have you checked? In what respect are you better?' Anger will cease, and become more gentle, if it knows that every day it will have to appear before the judgment seat. How sweet is the sleep that follows this self-examination!" Rather than ruminating unproductively on her mistake, Niamh could adopt this evening review practice. She might ask herself: "Where did I go wrong today? What triggered my anger? What virtue could I have practiced instead? What will I do differently next time?" This structured reflection transforms regret into learning, helping her respond more virtuously in similar situations in the future. The Stoic approach to self-examination balances honest assessment with self-compassion. The goal isn't harsh self-criticism but growth in wisdom and virtue. As Seneca continues: "I make use of this privilege, and daily plead my cause before myself: when the lamp is taken out of my sight... I pass the whole day in review before myself, and repeat all that I have said and done. I conceal nothing from myself, and omit nothing, for why should I be afraid of any of my shortcomings, when it is in my power to say, 'I pardon you this time; see that you never do that anymore?'" To practice effective self-examination, set aside time each evening for reflection. Review your day's actions, identifying moments when you lived according to your values and when you fell short. Consider what triggered unhelpful responses and how you might handle similar situations in the future. Keep a journal to track patterns and progress over time. Another powerful technique is to imagine how a wise person—whether a historical Stoic like Epictetus or someone you personally admire—would handle situations you find challenging. This "sage on your shoulder" approach helps you see beyond your immediate reactions to more virtuous possibilities. Through consistent self-examination, you'll develop greater self-awareness and the ability to align your actions with your highest values, gradually becoming the person you aspire to be.

Chapter 6: Live Virtuously in an Uncertain World

The ultimate aim of Stoic practice is to live virtuously regardless of external circumstances. While we cannot control what happens to us, we can control how we respond—choosing wisdom over ignorance, justice over selfishness, courage over cowardice, and temperance over excess. These cardinal virtues form the foundation of a life well-lived, according to the Stoics. Alice had been practicing Stoicism for some time, applying its principles to manage her stress about work performance. Through the discipline of desire, she learned to focus less on outcomes like promotions or praise and more on performing her duties with excellence and integrity. The discipline of action taught her to fulfill her role at work in a more mindful manner, treating colleagues with fairness and kindness even when under pressure. Yet Alice recognized she wasn't a sage—the Stoic ideal of the perfectly wise person. She continued working on the discipline of assent, catching and examining her automatic judgments about situations. This ongoing practice helped her maintain perspective when facing challenges, remembering that her true worth came not from external success but from her character and intentions. Epictetus captures this comprehensive approach to Stoic living: "It is by this principle above all that you must guide yourself in training. Go out as soon as it is dawn and whomsoever you may see and hear, question yourself and answer as to an interrogator. What did you see? A beautiful woman or boy. Apply the rule: Is this within the will's control or beyond it? Beyond. Away with it then! I say, if we did this and trained ourselves on this principle every day from dawn to night, we should indeed achieve something." To live virtuously in an uncertain world, integrate all three Stoic disciplines into your daily life. Start each morning by setting your intentions for the day, reminding yourself of your values and what truly matters. Throughout the day, pause before responding to challenging situations, asking yourself what virtue is called for in that moment. End each day with reflection, reviewing your actions and identifying opportunities for growth. Remember that Stoicism isn't about achieving perfection but about making progress. As Seneca acknowledges: "I am not yet a wise man, nor shall I ever be. And so do not require me to be equal to the best, but better than the wicked. It is enough for me if every day I reduce the number of my vices, and blame my mistakes." The path of virtue isn't always easy, but it offers something far more valuable than ease: a life of meaning, integrity, and genuine tranquility that cannot be shaken by external events. By aligning your choices with wisdom rather than impulse, you become the author of your own flourishing.

Summary

The ancient Stoics offer us timeless wisdom for navigating life's complexities with grace and purpose. By mastering the three disciplines—desire, action, and assent—we learn to focus on what we can control, act with intention and virtue, and examine our judgments before giving them power over us. As Epictetus reminds us, "Make the best use of what is in your power, and take the rest as it happens. Some things are up to us and some things are not up to us." Your journey through Stoic practice doesn't require dramatic life changes or extraordinary circumstances. It begins with simple daily habits: distinguishing between what you can and cannot control, examining your impressions before assenting to them, practicing virtuous action in ordinary situations, and reflecting honestly on your progress. Choose one Stoic exercise that resonated with you—perhaps the evening self-examination or the dichotomy of control—and commit to practicing it consistently for the next week. Through this gradual, intentional process, you'll develop the mental habits and perspectives that lead to genuine tranquility and flourishing, regardless of what life brings your way.

About Author

Loading...

Massimo Pigliucci

Massimo Pigliucci is an author, blogger, podcaster, as well as the K.D. Irani Professor of Philosophy at the City College of New York. His academic work is in evolutionary biology, philosophy of science, the nature of pseudoscience, and practical philosophy. His books include How to Be a Stoic: Using Ancient Philosophy to Live a Modern Life (Basic Books) and Nonsense on Stilts: How to Tell Science from Bunk (University of Chicago Press). His new book is Beyond Stoicism: A Guide to the Good Life with Stoics, Skeptics, Epicureans, and Other Ancient Philosophers (The Experiment). More by Massimo at https://massimopigliucci.org.

Read more

Related Books by Massimo Pigliucci

Loading...

How to Be a Stoic

Massimo Pigliucci

Ancient Wisdom For Modern Living

★★★★½4.5

Loading...

How to Live a Good Life

Massimo Pigliucci

A Guide to Choosing Your Personal Philosophy

★★★★☆4.3