A Thousand Brains
A New Theory of Intelligence
Categories
Nonfiction, Psychology, Philosophy, Science, Technology, Artificial Intelligence, Audiobook, Biology, Neuroscience, Brain
Content Type
Book
Binding
Hardcover
Year
2021
Publisher
Basic Books
Language
English
ISBN13
9781541675810
File Download
PDF | EPUB
A Thousand Brains Plot Summary
Introduction
How does the brain create intelligence? This fundamental question has puzzled scientists and philosophers for centuries. Traditional views of the brain as a hierarchical processing system fail to explain how humans develop such flexible, adaptable intelligence. The Thousand Brains Theory offers a revolutionary framework that challenges our understanding of how the brain works and what intelligence truly is. At its core, this theory proposes that intelligence emerges not from a single model of the world, but from thousands of models working in parallel across the neocortex. Each cortical column—tiny processing units arranged throughout the brain—creates its own complete model of objects and concepts using maplike reference frames. These thousands of models vote to form our unified perception and understanding of reality. This paradigm shift has profound implications not only for neuroscience but also for artificial intelligence, our understanding of consciousness, and ultimately the future of humanity itself.
Chapter 1: The Fundamental Framework of Cortical Columns
The neocortex, which comprises about 70 percent of the human brain, is the seat of human intelligence. While it appears uniform on the surface, it's organized into approximately 150,000 cortical columns—cylindrical structures about 1mm wide that extend through the 2.5mm thickness of the neocortex. Vernon Mountcastle first proposed in 1978 that these columns perform essentially the same operations regardless of whether they process vision, touch, language, or abstract thought. This revolutionary idea suggested that intelligence stems from a universal algorithm implemented by these columns. Each cortical column contains roughly 100,000 neurons arranged in layers. The layers connect vertically, with most neural connections flowing up and down within the column rather than horizontally to other columns. This organizational structure is remarkably similar throughout the neocortex—the visual cortex, auditory cortex, and language areas all share the same basic neural architecture. This similarity exists despite these regions processing completely different types of information, supporting Mountcastle's proposal of a universal algorithm. What exactly does a cortical column do? Rather than just detecting simple features as previously thought, each column learns complete models of objects and concepts. A column in the visual cortex doesn't just recognize lines or edges; it builds a model of entire objects through movement and sensory input. Similarly, columns in language areas don't just process word sounds; they create models of language structure and meaning. Each column is essentially a complete sensory-motor system, capable of learning, predicting, and generating behavior. Consider how you recognize everyday objects. When you touch a coffee cup with your finger, the column receiving input from that finger doesn't just detect the texture or temperature—it predicts what you would feel if you moved your finger to another part of the cup. As you move your finger around the cup, the column builds a complete model of the cup's shape and properties. This is why you can recognize a cup even when touching only a small part of it. The same principle applies to vision, hearing, and even abstract concepts like democracy or mathematics. This understanding fundamentally changes how we conceptualize intelligence, moving from simple feature detection to a system of thousands of complete modeling systems working in parallel.
Chapter 2: Reference Frames: The Brain's Universal Algorithm
Reference frames form the structural backbone of how the brain organizes and accesses knowledge. Similar to how a map uses coordinates to identify locations, the brain employs reference frames to represent the structure of objects, concepts, and relationships. A reference frame essentially creates an invisible coordinate system that attaches to whatever the brain is modeling. When you grasp a coffee cup, your brain establishes a reference frame centered on the cup itself, allowing you to know where your fingers are relative to different parts of the cup—the handle, rim, or base—regardless of where the cup is located in the room. These reference frames exist throughout the neocortex and serve multiple critical functions. First, they allow the brain to learn the structural relationships between features—how parts of an object are arranged relative to each other. Second, they enable prediction based on location—if your finger is at one point on the cup, your brain can predict what you would feel if you moved your finger to another location. Third, reference frames support planning and execution of movements by calculating the necessary motions to get from one location to another. Finally, they provide a mechanism for thinking itself—as your brain activates successive locations in a reference frame, different pieces of knowledge come to mind. The brain uses specialized neurons to implement these reference frames. Evidence suggests that cortical columns contain neurons similar to the "grid cells" and "place cells" first discovered in the hippocampus and entorhinal cortex—brain regions critical for navigation. In these older brain regions, grid cells create maplike representations of physical environments, while place cells fire when an animal is in specific locations. The Thousand Brains Theory proposes that similar cells exist throughout the neocortex, but instead of mapping physical spaces, they map objects, concepts, and even abstract ideas. Imagine learning to use a new smartphone. As you interact with it, your brain creates a reference frame attached to the phone. This frame maps the locations of buttons, screen elements, and functions. When you want to open an app, your brain activates the corresponding location in this reference frame, which then guides your finger to the correct spot. This same mechanism applies to abstract domains—when learning mathematics, your brain creates reference frames for number relationships or geometric principles. This explains why spatial metaphors are so common in describing abstract concepts: we literally think by moving through reference frames in our minds, whether we're contemplating physical objects or philosophical ideas.
Chapter 3: How the Brain Builds Models of the World
The brain constructs its model of reality through constant interaction with the environment. Unlike traditional views suggesting the brain passively processes sensory inputs, the Thousand Brains Theory reveals that learning is fundamentally active and based on movement. As you move through the world—turning your head, shifting your eyes, or touching objects—your brain observes how sensory inputs change with each movement. These changes allow the brain to build a predictive model that captures the structure of reality. Each cortical column learns by associating sensory inputs with locations in reference frames. When you touch a coffee cup, the column receiving input from your finger doesn't just register the sensation—it learns what that sensation means in the context of where your finger is located on the cup. As you move your finger around, the column builds a complete model by associating different sensations with different locations. Similarly, when you look at a face, columns in your visual cortex associate visual features with locations in a face-centered reference frame. This process happens across all sensory modalities and for all types of knowledge. A key component of this learning process is prediction. The brain constantly predicts what sensory inputs it will receive based on its current model and planned movements. These predictions occur at the cellular level through a mechanism involving dendrite spikes—electrical signals that travel along the branching extensions of neurons. When a neuron recognizes a pattern, it generates a dendrite spike that primes it to respond more quickly to an expected input. If the prediction is wrong, the brain updates its model. This continuous cycle of prediction, observation, and model updating is how we learn about the world. Consider learning to ride a bicycle. Initially, your brain lacks an accurate model of how a bicycle responds to your movements. As you practice, your predictions often fail, resulting in wobbles or falls. But with each attempt, your brain updates its model, gradually improving predictions about how the bicycle will respond to your actions. Eventually, your model becomes so accurate that riding feels natural and requires little conscious effort. This same principle applies to all learning, from basic physical skills to abstract concepts like mathematics or language. The brain builds sophisticated models through thousands of predictions and corrections, creating a rich understanding of the world that guides perception, action, and thought.
Chapter 4: The Thousand Brains Voting Mechanism
At the heart of the Thousand Brains Theory lies a profound insight: our unified perception of reality emerges from thousands of separate models voting to reach consensus. Each cortical column creates its own model of whatever it senses, but these models are complementary rather than identical. When you hold a coffee cup, dozens to hundreds of columns receive input from different parts of your hand. Each column builds its own model of the cup, but from a slightly different perspective. Some columns might have more information about the handle, others about the rim or base. How does the brain integrate these diverse models into a single coherent perception? The answer is voting. Columns communicate with each other through long-range connections that extend throughout the neocortex. These connections allow columns to share what object they believe they're sensing. When you grasp a cup, some columns might be uncertain about what they're touching—the curved surface could belong to many different objects. But collectively, the pattern of inputs across all columns will uniquely identify a coffee cup. Through a process of consensus-building, columns that agree on the cup identity reinforce each other, while alternative interpretations are suppressed. This voting mechanism explains why recognizing objects with your whole hand is easier than with just one finger—more columns provide more votes. Remarkably, this voting process works across different sensory modalities. When you see, touch, and hear a car door closing, columns processing visual, tactile, and auditory inputs all vote for "car door." This explains how our brain solves the binding problem—how diverse sensory inputs combine into unified perceptions. The voting process doesn't require converting inputs into a common format; it only requires agreement on what object is being sensed. This allows columns specializing in different senses to work together despite processing fundamentally different types of information. This voting mechanism has profound implications for how we understand consciousness and perception. When you look at an ambiguous image like the famous duck-rabbit illusion, your perception flips between interpretations because the voting mechanism can only reach one consensus at a time. Similarly, when you shift attention from one object to another in a complex scene, you're essentially changing which set of columns is dominating the vote. The stability of our perceptions—the fact that the world doesn't appear to jump around despite our constantly moving eyes—results from this voting process maintaining consistent object representations even as our sensory inputs rapidly change. Your perception of reality is quite literally a democracy of thousands of models reaching consensus about what exists in the world around you.
Chapter 5: From Biological to Machine Intelligence
The Thousand Brains Theory revolutionizes our approach to artificial intelligence by revealing that today's AI systems fundamentally differ from human intelligence. Current AI technologies, including deep learning neural networks, don't operate on the principles that make biological intelligence so flexible and powerful. While these systems can outperform humans on specific tasks like playing chess or recognizing images, they lack the ability to learn continuous models of the world through movement and reference frames. To create truly intelligent machines—artificial general intelligence (AGI)—we must implement four critical attributes derived from how the brain works. First, machines must learn continuously, updating their models with each new experience rather than requiring complete retraining. Second, they must learn through movement, building models by observing how inputs change as sensors move relative to the world. Third, they need many models working in parallel, like the thousands of cortical columns in the neocortex. Finally, they must organize knowledge using reference frames, providing the structural backbone for representing objects, concepts, and relationships. These principles explain why current AI systems, despite impressive capabilities, cannot be considered truly intelligent. A chess-playing computer has a reference frame (the chessboard), but this frame is limited to a specific domain and cannot represent the rich structure of the physical world. Image recognition systems can label pictures but don't understand the three-dimensional structure of objects or how they change when manipulated. Self-driving cars have reference frames for navigation but lack the flexible modeling capabilities of the human brain. The path to machine intelligence doesn't require replicating human emotions or motivations. The old brain—the parts that generate emotions, desires, and instincts—evolved to serve gene replication. For intelligent machines, we can choose which motivations to implement, if any. A machine with the equivalent of a neocortex but without an old brain would be conscious and intelligent but would not harbor human-like fears, desires, or survival instincts. This explains why the fears of superintelligent machines rebelling against humanity are largely unfounded. Intelligence itself is benign; it's the motivations paired with intelligence that determine behavior. By understanding the principles of biological intelligence, we can create machines that augment human capabilities without introducing new existential risks.
Chapter 6: False Beliefs and the Old-New Brain Conflict
Our brains create a simulation of reality rather than directly perceiving it. What we experience as "seeing," "hearing," or "touching" isn't the world itself but our brain's model of it. This fundamental insight from the Thousand Brains Theory helps explain one of humanity's greatest vulnerabilities: our susceptibility to false beliefs. Since we experience our brain's model rather than reality directly, our perceptions and beliefs can be wrong even when they feel unquestionably true. The conflict between the old brain and the new brain (neocortex) plays a crucial role in false beliefs. The old brain comprises ancient structures that evolved over hundreds of millions of years to ensure survival and reproduction. It generates emotions, basic drives, and instinctive behaviors. The neocortex, by contrast, learns a model of the world that can predict outcomes and plan accordingly. These two systems frequently clash. The old brain might demand immediate pleasure or tribal loyalty, while the neocortex recognizes the long-term consequences of such impulses. This explains why we often act against our own rational judgment—eating unhealthy foods, ignoring climate change, or perpetuating harmful social divisions. False beliefs become particularly dangerous when they're viral—designed to spread from person to person. Viral beliefs often include mechanisms that promote their own propagation while preventing contradictory evidence from being considered. They typically contain instructions like "spread this belief to others," "distrust anyone who challenges this belief," and "ignore evidence that contradicts this belief." These viral beliefs exploit our brain's architecture, particularly how the neocortex learns from language rather than direct experience. Since we can't personally verify everything we learn through language, we become vulnerable to accepting false information. Consider climate change denial. The climate changes too slowly for most people to directly perceive, so we must rely on others' reports and scientific data. Those with a vested interest in maintaining the status quo can spread viral beliefs that instruct people to dismiss scientific evidence and view climate scientists as untrustworthy. Similarly, many religious and political beliefs include viral mechanisms that ensure their propagation across generations despite contradictory evidence. These false beliefs can lead humanity to make disastrous decisions about our collective future, prioritizing short-term gratification or tribal identities over long-term survival. Understanding how our brains form and maintain beliefs is the first step toward developing greater resistance to these dangerous thought patterns and addressing the existential risks they create.
Chapter 7: Knowledge Preservation Beyond Biological Limits
Humanity faces an existential paradox: our intelligence has enabled unprecedented understanding of the universe, yet this same intelligence has created technologies that threaten our survival. Climate change, nuclear weapons, and emerging biotechnologies could make Earth uninhabitable, potentially ending not just our species but the only known instance of intelligence in the universe. Given this reality, we must consider how to preserve our most valuable achievement—knowledge—beyond the limitations of our biological existence. Several approaches could help extend the reach of human knowledge beyond our biological constraints. Becoming a multi-planet species by establishing colonies on Mars represents one strategy, though the harsh Martian environment would require intelligent, autonomous robots to prepare habitable settlements. Even successful colonization wouldn't solve the fundamental problems caused by our old-brain behaviors and susceptibility to false beliefs. Another approach involves modifying human genes to overcome biological limitations that prevent interstellar travel or to reduce destructive behaviors driven by our evolutionary heritage. While controversial, such modifications might be necessary if we prioritize the preservation of intelligence over the specific biological form it currently takes. Perhaps the most promising strategy is creating non-biological intelligence that can carry human knowledge beyond our solar system. Intelligent machines could travel between stars, survive for millions of years, and continue the quest for understanding that humans began. Unlike humans, these machines wouldn't be driven by old-brain impulses or susceptible to viral false beliefs. They could preserve human knowledge while continuing to make new discoveries, creating a legacy that outlasts our species. This approach represents a profound choice: prioritizing the propagation of knowledge over the propagation of genes. These options force us to confront a fundamental question: What about humanity do we most value? Is it our specific biological form, our genetic lineage, or the knowledge and understanding we've accumulated? The Thousand Brains Theory suggests that what makes us special isn't our bodies or genes but our intelligence—our ability to build models of reality and understand the universe. If we accept this perspective, then ensuring the continuation of intelligence and knowledge—whether in human form or not—becomes our most meaningful purpose. By embracing this role as knowledge-bearers rather than mere gene-propagators, we can find purpose that transcends our biological limitations and leave a legacy that truly matters in the cosmic scale.
Summary
The Thousand Brains Theory fundamentally reimagines intelligence as emerging from thousands of parallel models working together rather than a hierarchical processing system. Each cortical column in the neocortex builds complete models of objects and concepts using reference frames, with these models voting to create our unified perception of reality. This framework explains not only how we perceive and understand the world, but also why we're susceptible to false beliefs and how the conflict between our old and new brains shapes human behavior. This theory has profound implications that extend far beyond neuroscience. It provides a blueprint for creating truly intelligent machines that learn continuously through movement using reference frames. It explains why machine intelligence poses less existential risk than our own biological limitations and false beliefs. Most importantly, it offers a new perspective on humanity's purpose—suggesting that our greatest value lies not in our genes but in our accumulated knowledge and understanding of the universe. As we face increasing existential threats, this theory invites us to consider how intelligence might continue beyond our biological constraints, ensuring that the universe continues to know itself through the models we've built of reality.
Best Quote
“It is human nature - aka old brain - to suspect everyone wants to steal your idea, where the reality is that you are lucky if anyone cares about your idea at all.” ― Jeff Hawkins, A Thousand Brains: A New Theory of Intelligence
Review Summary
Strengths: The review highlights the book's fascinating theory on artificial intelligence, particularly the connection between neuroscience and machine learning. It praises the author, Jeff Hawkins, for his extensive experience and provides a clear introduction to his thinking. The book's detailed exploration of the brain's evolution and the neocortex's role in perception and self-location is also noted as a strength. Weaknesses: Not explicitly mentioned. Overall Sentiment: Enthusiastic Key Takeaway: The book offers an insightful theory on artificial intelligence, emphasizing the neocortex's evolution and its role in developing predictive models, making it a valuable resource for understanding the intersection of neuroscience and AI.
About Author
Richard Dawkins
Read moreRelated Books by Richard Dawkins
Trending Books
Download PDF & EPUB
To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
A Thousand Brains
by Richard Dawkins
Table of Contents
A Thousand Brains
By Richard Dawkins
