Astroball

Astroball Plot Summary

Introduction

In the summer of 2014, the Houston Astros were the laughingstock of baseball. They had lost over 100 games for three consecutive seasons, their television ratings had hit absolute zero for some games, and they were operating with a payroll so small it seemed they weren't even trying to win. Yet, amid this wreckage stood a bold prediction on the cover of Sports Illustrated: "Your 2017 World Series Champs." The declaration seemed absurd at the time, prompting widespread mockery. Behind this audacious prediction was one of the most fascinating experiments in modern sports management. The Astros had embarked on a radical rebuilding strategy, guided by an analytical approach that blended cutting-edge data science with traditional baseball scouting. This unprecedented "process" represented a revolutionary approach to talent evaluation, player development, and organizational culture. The journey from baseball's basement to its pinnacle offers profound insights about balancing human intuition with statistical analysis, the importance of creating an environment where talent can flourish, and how organizations can execute long-term visions despite intense public pressure for immediate results. For anyone interested in leadership, organizational transformation, or the science of decision-making, this remarkable turnaround provides valuable lessons that extend far beyond the baseball diamond.

Chapter 1: The Strategic Demolition: Rebuilding from the Ground Up (2011-2013)

When Jim Crane purchased the Houston Astros in November 2011 for $680 million, he inherited a franchise in disarray. The team had been gradually declining since their 2005 World Series appearance, and by 2011, they posted a dismal 56-106 record. Their farm system was ranked the worst in baseball, their major league roster was filled with aging, overpaid players, and the organization was losing tens of millions of dollars annually. Rather than making cosmetic changes to create the illusion of competitiveness, Crane hired Jeff Luhnow as general manager, a Stanford-educated former McKinsey consultant who had revolutionized the St. Louis Cardinals' drafting system. Luhnow arrived with a radical 23-page proposal outlining a complete organizational teardown and rebuilding process. The plan was controversial but clear: strip the organization to its foundation and rebuild methodically, with an unwavering focus on long-term success rather than short-term respectability. What followed was arguably the most extreme rebuilding strategy in modern sports history. Luhnow traded virtually every established player with value, including Carlos Lee, Wandy Rodriguez, and Brett Myers, acquiring prospects in return. The Astros' payroll plummeted to an astonishing $26 million by 2013—less than half of the next lowest team and roughly one-tenth of what the Yankees were spending. This approach generated intense criticism from baseball traditionalists, players' agents, and even the players' union, who accused the Astros of making a mockery of competitive integrity. The results on the field were predictably catastrophic. The Astros lost 107 games in 2012 and an American League-worst 111 games in 2013, culminating in a humiliating 15-game losing streak to end the season. The nadir came when Astros infielder Jonathan Villar slid face-first into the posterior of Reds second baseman Brandon Phillips while attempting to steal a base—a play dubbed the "Butt Slide" that became emblematic of the team's futility. By 2013, the Astros had become a national punchline, even appearing as the answer to a question on Jeopardy! Yet beneath this public embarrassment, Luhnow and his team—including former NASA rocket scientist Sig Mejdal, whom Luhnow named "Director of Decision Sciences"—were methodically implementing their plan. They invested heavily in analytics, built what they called "Ground Control," a proprietary database that integrated scouting reports with performance metrics, and focused intensely on the amateur draft. Their demolition strategy served a clear purpose: to accumulate as many high draft picks as possible, which they would use to select elite young talent who would form the core of a future championship team. The pain of these years was severe, but the organization remained committed to what they called "the process"—a term that became so central to their identity that they eventually printed it on t-shirts sold at their stadium. As Luhnow often reminded critics: "At the end of the day, when you're in 2017, you don't really care that much about whether we lost 98 or 107 in 2012. You care about how close we are to winning a championship in 2017."

Chapter 2: The Nerd Cave: How Analytics Reshaped Baseball Decision-Making

The intellectual center of the Astros' rebuilding effort was an unassuming office they nicknamed "the Nerd Cave." Here, Sig Mejdal and his team of analysts—many with backgrounds in fields like aerospace engineering, physics, and economics—pioneered approaches to baseball decision-making that would fundamentally reshape the industry. Mejdal's journey to baseball was unusual. After earning degrees in mechanical engineering and cognitive psychology, he worked for Lockheed Martin and then NASA, where he studied human fatigue and performance. A lifelong baseball fan who had once dealt blackjack in Lake Tahoe, Mejdal became fascinated with how statistical analysis could improve decision-making in baseball. When the Astros hired him, Luhnow created a position never before seen in baseball: Director of Decision Sciences. The "Nerd Cave" team built systems far more sophisticated than the early sabermetrics popularized in Moneyball. While traditional analytics focused on discovering undervalued skills like on-base percentage, the Astros' system combined data from multiple sources: traditional scouting reports, advanced performance metrics, medical information, psychological assessments, and even biomechanical measurements. Their database, Ground Control, processed this information through complex algorithms to project player performance and development patterns. One innovation was their approach to integrating scouting and analytics. Rather than seeing these as competing methodologies, the Astros viewed them as complementary. They systematically evaluated their scouts' judgments against actual outcomes to determine which observations had predictive value. "If a human being can sense it, a human being can quantify it," Mejdal explained. "If he can quantify it, he can learn about it." This approach helped identify overlooked talents like pitcher Collin McHugh, whom they claimed off waivers in 2013 after discovering through PITCHf/x data that his curveball had an elite spin rate despite his poor overall statistics. The Astros also pioneered defensive shifts based on probabilistic models of where hitters were likely to hit the ball against specific pitches. This approach initially faced resistance from players who had been taught traditional defensive positioning their entire careers. Dallas Keuchel, who would eventually embrace the shifts and win a Cy Young Award, admitted: "The first time a ball goes to the regular shortstop position but there's nobody there, that's the only thing you can remember through the course of the game." Perhaps most revolutionary was how the Astros' analytics department evaluated amateur talent. For the draft, they developed a system that assigned each prospect a single numerical value representing their projected future contribution. This allowed them to make controversial but data-driven selections like Carlos Correa with the first overall pick in 2012, when most observers expected them to select Byron Buxton or Mark Appel. They also employed "portfolio theory" from finance, diversifying their draft selections to manage risk across multiple prospects. Critics accused the Astros of dehumanizing players by reducing them to numbers. Mejdal pushed back: "We realize these are human beings, not widgets. As far as assigning a number to a person—well, I assume you get a salary? Do you feel dehumanized because your boss has put a number on you?" The team's approach wasn't about eliminating human judgment but about making it more rigorous and integrating it with objective data—a methodology that would eventually transform baseball operations across the sport.

Chapter 3: Growth Mindset: Developing Players Beyond Traditional Methods

By 2014, the Astros' analytics team had constructed sophisticated models for identifying talent, but they recognized that merely drafting or acquiring the right players wasn't enough. The organization needed to develop these players by helping them improve beyond their projected ceilings. This is where the concept of the "growth mindset" became central to their philosophy. The term "growth mindset," popularized by psychologist Carol Dweck, describes the belief that abilities can be developed through dedication and hard work. The Astros sought players who exhibited this trait—those who were unsatisfied with their current skills and constantly sought improvement. This quality became as valuable in their player evaluations as physical tools or performance statistics. George Springer exemplified this approach. When drafted in 2011, Springer was an undisciplined free-swinger who struck out at alarming rates. In his first minor league season, he struck out once every 3.7 plate appearances—a rate that historically indicated little chance of major league success. Traditional development might have accepted these flaws as unchangeable, but the Astros provided Springer with specific data about his swing patterns and plate discipline issues, then worked with him to make adjustments. "I slowly figured out what kind of hitter I wanted to be, what kind of hitter I am, instead of getting in the box and blindly swinging," Springer later explained. Through his willingness to adapt and the organization's targeted development approach, Springer transformed from a high-risk prospect to an All-Star who balanced power with improved plate discipline. José Altuve's evolution was equally remarkable. Standing only five-foot-six, Altuve was initially signed for just $15,000 out of Venezuela after most teams dismissed him because of his size. Though he reached the majors quickly, the Astros' analytics team identified how he could improve: by focusing his swings on pitches he could drive rather than making contact with everything. Under their guidance, Altuve transformed from a slap-hitting singles hitter into an MVP-caliber player who could hit for both average and power while maintaining exceptional plate discipline. Dallas Keuchel represented perhaps their greatest development success. A soft-tossing left-hander who never threw harder than 90 mph, Keuchel struggled in his first major league season with a 5.27 ERA. Rather than giving up on him, the Astros provided him with detailed data about pitch selection and location tendencies of opposing hitters. Keuchel embraced this information and began studying opposing lineups meticulously. "I spent hours each day poring over video and scouting reports," Keuchel said. He learned to pitch "backward"—using off-speed pitches early in counts when conventional wisdom suggested fastballs—and to locate his pitches precisely where hitters were weakest. By 2015, despite never gaining velocity, Keuchel won the American League Cy Young Award. The organization created a culture where information flowed freely between the analytics department and the field. They installed advanced technology at every level of their minor league system, providing players with immediate feedback on their performance. Perhaps most importantly, they hired coaches and development staff who embraced both traditional baseball knowledge and cutting-edge analytics, creating an environment where players could integrate both approaches. This development philosophy extended beyond individual performance to team tactics. The Astros pioneered strategies like extreme defensive shifts, encouraged pitchers to throw their best pitches more frequently regardless of convention, and optimized batting orders based on matchup data. By 2015, two years ahead of schedule, these methods produced their first winning season since 2008, as players throughout the organization embraced the growth mindset that would ultimately lead to championship contention.

Chapter 4: Chemistry in the Clubhouse: The Human Element of Success

As the Astros emerged from their rebuilding phase in 2015, their front office recognized that pure analytics had limitations. While their data-driven approach had assembled impressive young talent, something intangible was missing—the cohesive clubhouse culture necessary for championship teams. This became painfully evident when they lost a hard-fought division series to the Kansas City Royals, a team known for their exceptional team chemistry. Jeff Luhnow and his team began to appreciate what baseball traditionalists had long valued: the importance of veteran leadership, clubhouse dynamics, and team cohesion. "Just because you can't quantify it doesn't mean it doesn't exist," Luhnow acknowledged. This realization led to one of his most significant decisions—signing 40-year-old Carlos Beltrán to a one-year, $16 million contract before the 2017 season. Beltrán's impact went far beyond his on-field production. He transformed the clubhouse culture in ways that analytics couldn't measure but that players felt immediately. He instituted team rituals like post-victory ceremonies where championship belts were awarded to the game's best hitter and pitcher. These ceremonies, complete with music and a fog machine, created moments of shared celebration that strengthened team bonds. More significantly, Beltrán served as a mentor to younger players, particularly fellow Puerto Ricans Carlos Correa and José Altuve. He would spend hours in the video room studying opposing pitchers, then share his findings with teammates. "The biggest thing I've learned from him is to look at the bigger picture," Correa explained. "It's not only about playing defense and catching the ball and throwing the ball and hitting it. It's way more than that. He showed me how to prepare the right way every single day." Beltrán also helped bridge cultural divides in a clubhouse with players from diverse backgrounds. He encouraged English-speaking players to learn Spanish and vice versa, creating an environment where information and camaraderie flowed freely across linguistic barriers. When Cuban first baseman Yuli Gurriel joined the team with limited English skills, young third baseman Alex Bregman took it upon himself to communicate with him in rudimentary Spanish, building a friendship that transcended language. The chemistry extended to the field, where players developed an unselfish approach to the game. "We wear this patch on our jersey the rest of the year to represent you," manager A.J. Hinch told Houston fans after Hurricane Harvey devastated the city in August 2017. This "Houston Strong" ethos unified the team around a purpose greater than themselves. Research has shown that team chemistry can account for significant variations in performance. A study presented at the 2017 MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference found that chemistry could explain up to 44 percent of a team's variance from expected performance. The Astros embraced this reality, recognizing that while data could identify talent, human connections determined how effectively that talent worked together. By the 2017 playoffs, this chemistry proved crucial. When the team fell behind three games to two against the Yankees in the American League Championship Series, Beltrán called a team meeting. "Guys, this is simple," he told them calmly. "We're going home. We're going to play in front of our crowd. We took the first two games of the series there. We can do it again." The team responded by winning the final two games at home, demonstrating a resilience that pure talent alone couldn't provide. The Astros had evolved from an organization that once focused almost exclusively on data to one that balanced analytics with human factors. They discovered that the most effective approach wasn't choosing between traditional baseball wisdom and modern analytics, but creating an environment where both could flourish together.

Chapter 5: The Verlander Decision: When Gut Feelings Override Analytics

As August 2017 drew to a close, the Astros faced a critical moment. Despite leading their division by a comfortable margin, the team had stumbled through a disastrous month, going 11-17 and looking vulnerable. Their starting rotation had faltered, with an ERA approaching 5.00 for the month, and injuries had decimated their lineup. The deadline for acquiring playoff-eligible players was approaching on August 31, and pressure mounted for general manager Jeff Luhnow to make a bold move. The Detroit Tigers had made Justin Verlander available. The 34-year-old former Cy Young winner and MVP had rebounded from early-season struggles and was once again pitching like an ace. With two years and $56 million remaining on his contract, Verlander represented exactly the type of expensive veteran acquisition that the analytically-minded Astros had typically avoided. Sig Mejdal's algorithms suggested that trading multiple top prospects for an aging pitcher with a large contract was precisely the type of emotionally-driven decision that data-oriented teams should resist. Luhnow found himself torn between competing imperatives. On one hand, the data suggested patience—the Astros still had the American League's best record despite their slump, and their injured players would return for the playoffs. On the other hand, the team needed a psychological boost, and Houston itself was reeling from the devastation of Hurricane Harvey. Owner Jim Crane told Luhnow that providing hope for a battered city should factor into his decision. As the deadline approached on August 31, Luhnow was caught in a peculiar situation. He was at his in-laws' house in Los Angeles, negotiating one of the most consequential trades in franchise history from their dining room table while family members prepared for a dinner party around him. With just minutes remaining before the midnight eastern time deadline, he reached an agreement with the Tigers: Franklin Pérez, Daz Cameron, and Jake Rogers—three highly-regarded prospects—for Verlander, with Detroit paying $16 million of the remaining salary. There was one final hurdle: Verlander's full no-trade clause gave him the power to veto any deal. The pitcher had less than 30 minutes to decide whether to leave Detroit, his home for 13 seasons, for Houston. With Astros ace Dallas Keuchel lobbying him by phone and his fiancée Kate Upton offering counsel, Verlander made his decision with just seconds to spare. "The deal's been approved," the commissioner's office told Luhnow. "But, Jeff? Don't ever put me through that again. We received final verification from Verlander at 11:59 and 58 seconds." The acquisition represented a fundamental departure from the Astros' process-oriented approach. By sacrificing 18 controllable future years of talented prospects for two expensive years of a veteran pitcher, Luhnow had made a decision that his own analytical models likely wouldn't have recommended. Yet he recognized that the moment called for something the algorithms couldn't capture—the intangible impact of adding an experienced ace with championship pedigree to a young team at a pivotal moment. Verlander's impact was immediate and profound. He won all five of his regular season starts for Houston, with a microscopic 1.06 ERA. Beyond his performance, his presence brought a swagger and confidence that had been missing during the team's August struggles. "He is the most prepared pitcher I've ever been around," marveled veteran Carlos Beltrán. The Astros finished the season on a 21-8 tear, entering the playoffs with renewed momentum. The Verlander trade illustrated an important evolution in the Astros' philosophy. Their analytical foundation remained intact, but they had developed the wisdom to know when human judgment should override statistical models. As Luhnow explained, "It's not about rejecting analytics, but understanding their limitations in specific contexts." In baseball, as in life, the most important decisions often require balancing quantitative analysis with qualitative factors that resist easy measurement—what traditionalists would simply call a gut feeling.

Chapter 6: Hurricane Harvey and Houston Strong: Baseball Beyond Statistics

On August 26, 2017, as the Astros played a series in Anaheim against the Angels, Hurricane Harvey made landfall in Texas. What followed was one of the most devastating natural disasters in American history. The storm dumped more than 50 inches of rain on Houston, flooding over 300,000 homes and causing approximately $150 billion in damage. The city that had been rebuilt multiple times throughout its history—from swampland to oil boomtown to space-age metropolis—faced perhaps its greatest challenge yet. The Astros were stranded on the road, unable to return home as airports closed and highways disappeared under floodwaters. Their three-game series against the Texas Rangers was hastily relocated to Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Florida, where they played in a nearly empty stadium, losing two of three games while their thoughts remained with their families and community back in Houston. "We haven't been playing our best in this series, and now we get on a plane and get home," said manager A.J. Hinch. "It's the best news of the day." When the team finally returned to Houston on August 31—the same day Jeff Luhnow acquired Justin Verlander—they witnessed firsthand the devastation that had befallen their city. The next day, an off day on their schedule, players fanned out across Houston to participate in relief efforts. Dallas Keuchel served meals to police officers, Lance McCullers volunteered at an animal shelter, and José Altuve led a contingent of 16 players to the George R. Brown Convention Center, which housed more than 9,000 evacuees. "I feel like I owe Houston something, after all they have done for me," said Altuve, who had risen from an undersized prospect signed for just $15,000 to become the face of the franchise. For a Venezuelan immigrant who had found a home in Houston, the opportunity to give back to his adopted city in its time of need carried profound meaning. When the Astros resumed play at Minute Maid Park on September 2, they wore patches over their hearts that read "H STRONG"—shorthand for the "Houston Strong" rallying cry that had emerged throughout the city. Before the first game of a doubleheader against the Mets, Hinch addressed a crowd of more than 30,000 fans, many of whom had temporarily escaped flooded homes to attend. "We wear this patch on our jersey the rest of the year to represent you," he told them. "Stay strong, be strong, and we appreciate every one of you." The team swept the doubleheader, and something changed in their collective demeanor. The devastating hurricane had given them a purpose that transcended baseball. They weren't just playing for themselves or even for a championship—they were playing for a city in desperate need of hope and joy. "Houston Strong" became more than a slogan; it became their identity. This newfound sense of purpose coincided with Verlander's arrival and Carlos Correa's return from injury. The Astros finished the regular season on a 21-8 tear, and when they faced the Rangers in the season's final month, they outscored their in-state rivals 37-7 in a three-game sweep, with each victory coming by at least nine runs. The message was clear: this team was no longer just analytically sound; they were emotionally fortified as well. Hurricane Harvey transformed the relationship between the team and its city. Despite their analytics-driven approach to baseball operations, the Astros recognized that sports can serve a function that defies statistical measurement—providing communal healing in times of crisis. As they entered the playoffs, they carried with them not just the expectations of a fanbase, but the hopes of a wounded metropolis looking for something to celebrate.

Chapter 7: World Series Victory: The Process Finally Bears Fruit (2017)

The 2017 postseason began with the Astros dispatching the Boston Red Sox in four games in the American League Division Series. José Altuve announced his playoff arrival by slugging three home runs in Game 1 alone, while Justin Verlander continued his dominance with a complete-game victory in Game 4. The team seemed to be peaking at the perfect moment, blending their analytical approach with newfound emotional resilience. The American League Championship Series against the New York Yankees proved more challenging. After winning the first two games at home behind stellar pitching from Dallas Keuchel and Justin Verlander, the Astros lost three straight in New York, managing just five runs total in those games. Their season on the brink, Carlos Beltrán called a team meeting after Game 5. "Guys, this is simple," he told them. "The first two games, we took care of business at home. When we came here, I know nobody, not even myself, was expecting to lose three games in a row. But in order for the Yankees to survive the series, this was what they needed to do. Now we go home." The Astros responded by winning the final two games at Minute Maid Park, with Verlander throwing seven shutout innings in Game 6 and Charlie McCullers closing out Game 7 by throwing 24 consecutive curveballs to the Yankees' fastball-hunting lineup. Their comeback demonstrated how far they had evolved from the analytically sound but emotionally fragile team of previous seasons. The World Series against the Los Angeles Dodgers pitted baseball's two best teams against each other. The Dodgers had won 104 games during the regular season and boasted a $265 million payroll—nearly double the Astros' $150 million. Their roster featured Clayton Kershaw, widely considered the best pitcher of his generation, and their front office matched Houston's analytical sophistication. After splitting the first two games in Los Angeles—including an epic 11-inning Game 2 victory highlighted by George Springer's dramatic comeback from a four-strikeout performance in Game 1—the series shifted to Houston. In Game 3, Beltrán quietly informed his teammates that Dodgers starter Yu Darvish was tipping his pitches: when he planned to throw his slider, he didn't adjust his grip, but when throwing his fastball, he would regrip the ball. Armed with this insight, the Astros knocked Darvish out in the second inning on their way to a 5-3 win. The teams split Games 4 and 5, with the latter producing one of the most extraordinary contests in World Series history—a 13-12, 10-inning Astros victory in which the teams combined for seven home runs. After the Dodgers forced Game 7 with a 3-1 win in Los Angeles, Houston faced Darvish again. Springer, continuing his remarkable series, launched a two-run homer in the second inning that gave the Astros a commanding 5-0 lead they would never relinquish. When Charlie Morton induced a ground ball to José Altuve for the final out, the vision laid out in Sports Illustrated's seemingly preposterous 2014 cover prediction had come true: the Houston Astros were World Series champions. In the celebration that followed, Carlos Correa dropped to one knee and proposed to his girlfriend on national television, while his father embraced him in tears, whispering, "We did it." The championship represented the culmination of the process that began with the controversial teardown in 2011. The core of the team—Springer, Altuve, Correa, Bregman, Keuchel, and McCullers—had all been acquired and developed during the rebuilding years. Crucial veterans like Verlander and Beltrán had been added at precisely the right moments to complement that homegrown foundation. Most importantly, the Astros had evolved beyond their initial reliance on pure analytics to embrace the human elements of baseball—leadership, chemistry, emotion, and purpose. Their victory offered a blueprint for modern sports management: use data to make better decisions, but never forget that those decisions ultimately affect and are implemented by human beings with thoughts, feelings, and their own capacity for growth. As owner Jim Crane reflected amid the celebration at Dodger Stadium: "Even when the heat was on, I told Jeff Luhnow, 'I'll stick to the plan. The plan, the plan, work the plan.' And that's what he did." Six years after embarking on baseball's most radical rebuilding strategy, the Houston Astros had proven that sometimes, the process works exactly as designed.

Summary

The Houston Astros' transformation from baseball's worst team to World Series champions represents one of the most remarkable organizational turnarounds in modern sports history. At its core, this story reveals the tension between analytical decision-making and human factors that drives not just baseball, but any complex endeavor. The Astros initially leaned heavily on their data-driven approach, stripping the organization to its foundation and enduring years of failure to rebuild methodically. Yet their ultimate success came only when they evolved to balance their analytical rigor with an appreciation for intangibles like leadership, team chemistry, and personal growth. The team discovered that their greatest competitive advantage came not from choosing between traditional baseball wisdom and modern analytics, but from synthesizing both into something more powerful than either could be alone. This journey offers valuable lessons that extend beyond baseball. First, meaningful transformation often requires the courage to withstand criticism and short-term pain in service of a long-term vision. Second, even the most sophisticated data analysis cannot account for all variables in human systems; the wisest decision-makers know when to trust their gut feelings despite what the numbers suggest. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the Astros demonstrated that organizations achieve their greatest potential when they create environments where people can continually grow and improve beyond their projected limitations. In an increasingly data-driven world, their story reminds us that while analytics can guide our decisions, it is ultimately human beings—with their resilience, adaptability, and capacity for growth—who determine whether those decisions bear fruit.

About Author

Loading...

Ben Reiter

Ben Reiter is a senior writer for Sports Illustrated, which he joined in 2004. He has written 25 cover stories for the magazine and has also contributed to Time and The Village Voice, among other publications. His SI feature 'The Seeker: The Complicated Life and Death of Hideki Irabu' won the 2017 Deadline Award for Magazine Profile. He frequently appears on radio and television stations across the United States and around the world, and is a regular commentator on the MLB Network. Reiter is a graduate of Yale and Cambridge. He lives in New York City with his family. Astroball is his first book.

Read more