At The Existentialist Café

At The Existentialist Café Plot Summary

Introduction

In a small cabin nestled in the Black Forest of Germany, a bespectacled philosopher paced back and forth, wrestling with what he considered the most fundamental question forgotten by Western thought: "What is the meaning of Being?" This question would define Martin Heidegger's intellectual journey and establish him as one of the most influential—and controversial—philosophers of the 20th century. Born to humble beginnings in rural Germany, Heidegger would rise to philosophical prominence with his revolutionary work "Being and Time," challenging centuries of metaphysical tradition and transforming how we understand human existence in the world. Heidegger's legacy presents a profound paradox: a thinker who sought to reawaken humanity to authentic existence while himself becoming entangled in one of history's darkest political movements. Through his phenomenological analysis of everyday life, his critique of modern technology, and his exploration of poetic dwelling, Heidegger developed concepts that continue to resonate across disciplines—from psychology and architecture to environmental thought and artificial intelligence. His intellectual journey reveals both the extraordinary power of philosophical thinking and its potential ethical pitfalls, offering lessons about the relationship between abstract thought and concrete human responsibility that remain urgently relevant today.

Chapter 1: Early Years and Philosophical Awakening

Martin Heidegger was born on September 26, 1889, in the small town of Messkirch, Germany, to a modest Catholic family. His father worked as a sexton at the local church, a position that immersed young Martin in religious rituals and ceremonies from an early age. This early exposure to Catholic traditions would profoundly influence his philosophical thinking, even after he later distanced himself from formal religion. The rural setting of his childhood, nestled in the Black Forest region, also left an indelible mark on his worldview. Throughout his life, Heidegger maintained a deep connection to the countryside, the changing seasons, and the simple rhythms of rural life—themes that would later permeate his philosophical writings. Heidegger's intellectual journey began when he received a scholarship to attend a Jesuit seminary. Initially destined for the priesthood, his path took a dramatic turn when he encountered philosophical texts that awakened something profound within him. At the age of seventeen, he was given a book by Franz Brentano on Aristotle's conception of being, which sparked his lifelong philosophical quest. This pivotal moment redirected his trajectory from theology toward philosophy. After brief studies in theology at the University of Freiburg, he switched to mathematics and then philosophy, where he eventually became a student of Edmund Husserl, the founder of phenomenology. Under Husserl's mentorship, Heidegger began developing his unique approach to philosophical inquiry—one that would eventually challenge and transform the entire landscape of Western thought.

Chapter 2: The Phenomenological Path with Husserl

Edmund Husserl, already established as the founder of phenomenology, became Heidegger's mentor at the University of Freiburg in 1916. Their relationship was complex and formative, with Husserl initially seeing the brilliant young philosopher as his intellectual heir. Husserl's phenomenological method—the careful description of things as they appear to consciousness, without theoretical presuppositions—provided Heidegger with a foundation, but one he would radically transform. While Husserl focused on consciousness and its intentional structures, Heidegger became increasingly interested in the more fundamental question of Being itself. The apprenticeship with Husserl proved crucial for Heidegger's development, though he would later characterize it as a necessary path he had to overcome. During this period, Heidegger served as Husserl's assistant, gaining intimate knowledge of phenomenological methods while simultaneously developing his own distinctive approach. He began teaching courses that reinterpreted ancient Greek philosophy through a phenomenological lens, earning a reputation as a mesmerizing lecturer. Students described his teaching style as electrifying—he would pace the room, pause dramatically, and speak with an intensity that made philosophical problems feel urgent and alive. By the mid-1920s, the intellectual distance between Husserl and Heidegger was growing. Husserl remained committed to philosophy as a rigorous science, while Heidegger increasingly turned toward more existential concerns and a radical questioning of the Western philosophical tradition. This divergence became apparent in Heidegger's lectures, where he began developing the ideas that would culminate in his masterwork. Despite their philosophical differences, Husserl continued to support Heidegger's career, helping him secure a position at Marburg University in 1923 and later recommending him as his own successor at Freiburg. The relationship between the two philosophers would eventually sour, particularly after Heidegger's rise to prominence and his controversial political choices in the 1930s. When Husserl, who was Jewish, faced discrimination under Nazi policies, Heidegger's failure to defend his mentor created a painful rift. The story of their relationship reveals not just an intellectual divergence but also raises profound questions about the moral responsibilities of thinkers. Nevertheless, the phenomenological foundation Husserl provided remained essential to Heidegger's philosophical journey, even as he transformed it into something his teacher could scarcely recognize.

Chapter 3: Being and Time: Dasein's Emergence

In 1927, Heidegger published "Being and Time," a work that would revolutionize philosophy and establish him as one of the most significant thinkers of the 20th century. The book emerged from years of intense thinking about the fundamental question that Heidegger believed Western philosophy had forgotten: the question of Being itself. Rather than asking about specific beings or entities, Heidegger sought to understand what it means for anything to be at all. This seemingly abstract inquiry was, for him, the most concrete and urgent task of thought. Central to "Being and Time" is the concept of Dasein, Heidegger's term for human existence. Unlike traditional philosophical approaches that viewed humans as subjects observing objects, Heidegger portrayed Dasein as always already thrown into a world of meaning, relationships, and practical concerns. We do not primarily encounter things as neutral objects for theoretical contemplation but as equipment ready-to-hand for our projects. A hammer, for example, is not first understood as an object with certain properties, but as something for hammering. Only when tools break down do we notice them as present-at-hand objects. Heidegger's analysis of everyday existence revealed structures that had been overlooked by previous philosophy. He described how Dasein typically lives in a state of "fallenness," absorbed in conventional ways of understanding and behaving that he called the "they-self." In this mode, we avoid confronting our own mortality and the responsibility of authentic existence. Authenticity, for Heidegger, emerges through experiences of anxiety that disclose the groundlessness of existence and call us to face our finitude. By acknowledging death as our "ownmost possibility," we can break free from conventional patterns and take responsibility for our existence. The temporal structure of Dasein forms another crucial dimension of the work. Heidegger argued that human existence is fundamentally temporal—not simply in the sense of occurring within time, but as constituted by temporality itself. Our being is always stretched between past, present, and future. We project ourselves forward into possibilities based on what we have been, while making present our concerns in the world. This dynamic temporality means that Dasein is never complete or fully present but always "ahead of itself" in its projects and possibilities. Though notoriously difficult and left incomplete (Heidegger published only the first two divisions of a planned six-part work), "Being and Time" transformed philosophical discourse across multiple traditions. Its influence extended far beyond academic philosophy to fields including psychology, literary theory, theology, and architecture. The work's radical rethinking of human existence, language, and temporality opened new pathways for thought that continue to be explored today. Despite its difficulty and the controversies surrounding its author, "Being and Time" remains a watershed moment in philosophical history—the point at which the question of Being was reawakened after centuries of slumber.

Chapter 4: The Nazi Period and Turning Point

In April 1933, shortly after Hitler's rise to power, Heidegger was elected rector of Freiburg University and joined the Nazi Party—decisions that would cast a long shadow over his legacy. His infamous rectoral address proclaimed the need for a spiritual renewal of the German university and seemed to align academic values with Nazi ideology. During his brief tenure as rector, which lasted only until April 1934, he implemented Nazi policies at the university, including the dismissal of Jewish faculty members—among them his former mentor, Edmund Husserl. This period represents the most troubling chapter in Heidegger's life, raising profound questions about the relationship between his philosophy and his politics. Heidegger's motivations for supporting National Socialism remain contested. Some scholars suggest he initially saw in Nazism the possibility for a spiritual revolution that would counter the technological nihilism of the modern age. Others point to his provincial conservatism, anti-modernism, and latent antisemitism. Whatever his intentions, Heidegger soon became disillusioned with the crude biological racism and technological mobilization of the Nazi regime. After resigning as rector, he retreated into a more private existence, continuing to teach but increasingly focusing on the critique of Western metaphysics and technology. The post-rectorate period marked what Heidegger himself later described as a "turning" (Kehre) in his thought. While "Being and Time" had approached the question of Being through an analysis of human existence, his later work shifted toward a more historical and poetic meditation on Being itself. He turned to pre-Socratic Greek thinkers, poetry (especially Hölderlin), and art as sources for a more primordial understanding of Being. This turning was not a rejection of his earlier work but a deepening and broadening of its concerns, now expressed in a more meditative and often obscure language. After the war, Heidegger faced denazification proceedings and was temporarily banned from teaching. He never offered a clear public apology or explanation for his Nazi involvement, maintaining a troubling silence on the Holocaust. In a 1966 interview with Der Spiegel (published posthumously), he referred to his rectorship as a "great mistake" but offered little in the way of moral reckoning. This ambiguous relationship to his Nazi past has made Heidegger one of the most controversial figures in philosophical history. His case raises difficult questions about whether and how we can separate a thinker's ideas from their political and moral failings—questions that continue to provoke debate among scholars and readers of philosophy.

Chapter 5: Later Thought: Technology and Dwelling

Following World War II and his denazification period, Heidegger's thought took a distinctive turn toward critiquing modern technology and exploring more poetic approaches to human dwelling on earth. In his influential 1954 essay "The Question Concerning Technology," he argued that the essence of modern technology is not itself technological but rather a particular way of revealing the world. This mode of revealing, which he called "enframing" (Gestell), reduces everything—including nature and eventually humans themselves—to a "standing reserve" awaiting optimization and exploitation. For Heidegger, the danger of technology lies not in specific machines but in this underlying attitude that transforms rivers into hydroelectric power sources, forests into timber resources, and humans into human resources. Heidegger sought alternatives to this technological worldview in what he called "meditative thinking" as opposed to "calculative thinking." He increasingly turned to poetry, particularly that of Friedrich Hölderlin, to articulate a different relationship to Being. In essays like "Building Dwelling Thinking" and "Poetically Man Dwells," he explored how humans might inhabit the earth not as masters and exploiters but as mortals who dwell poetically among things, other beings, and the fourfold of earth, sky, mortals, and divinities. This later Heidegger emphasized the importance of "letting be" (Gelassenheit)—allowing things to reveal themselves on their own terms rather than forcing them into our conceptual frameworks. Language took center stage in Heidegger's later philosophy. Rather than viewing language as a tool humans use to express pre-existing thoughts, he described it as "the house of Being" in which humans dwell. Authentic language, especially poetic language, does not merely represent reality but lets Being itself come to presence. In his often cryptic later writings, Heidegger experimented with language, etymology, and unconventional syntax to break through calcified patterns of thinking and speaking. These texts can be frustrating for readers seeking clear arguments but reward those willing to engage with them as performances of a different kind of thinking. Throughout his later period, Heidegger maintained a critical stance toward modernity while seeking resources for a different future in pre-Socratic Greek thought, Asian philosophy (particularly Taoism), and the rural traditions of his Black Forest homeland. He spent much time at his mountain cabin in Todtnauberg, where he wrote many of his later works in relative isolation. This retreat from urban academic life embodied his philosophical emphasis on rootedness and place. Critics have seen in this tendency a problematic romanticism and anti-modernism, while admirers find in it a necessary counterweight to technological globalization. Regardless of one's assessment, Heidegger's later thought on technology, language, and dwelling has proven remarkably prescient in an age of environmental crisis, digital transformation, and cultural displacement.

Chapter 6: Global Influence and Legacy

Heidegger's influence extends far beyond philosophy proper, permeating fields as diverse as psychology, literary theory, architecture, environmental thought, and religious studies. In France, thinkers like Jean-Paul Sartre, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, and Jacques Derrida transformed Heideggerian concepts into existentialism, phenomenology of perception, and deconstruction, respectively. Though Sartre's interpretation of Heidegger in "Being and Nothingness" diverged significantly from Heidegger's intentions, it helped popularize existentialist themes derived from his work. Later, the deconstructionist movement led by Derrida engaged deeply with Heidegger's critique of Western metaphysics and his explorations of language. In psychology and psychiatry, Heidegger's analysis of human existence inspired existential approaches to therapy. Psychiatrists like Ludwig Binswanger and Medard Boss developed "Daseinsanalysis," which approached psychological disturbances not as medical disorders but as modifications of human existence. This perspective influenced figures like R.D. Laing and contributed to humanistic psychology's emphasis on authenticity and meaning. Similarly, in theology, thinkers like Rudolf Bultmann and Paul Tillich incorporated Heideggerian concepts into their reinterpretations of religious traditions. East Asian reception of Heidegger represents another significant dimension of his global impact. Japanese philosophers of the Kyoto School, including Kitaro Nishida and Keiji Nishitani, found resonances between Heidegger's critique of Western metaphysics and Buddhist conceptions of emptiness. This cross-cultural dialogue continues today, with scholars exploring connections between Heideggerian thought and various Eastern philosophical traditions. Heidegger himself expressed interest in East Asian thinking, particularly Taoism, seeing in it possibilities for overcoming Western metaphysical frameworks. Heidegger's legacy remains profoundly contested, with his Nazi affiliation casting a long shadow over his philosophical contributions. The publication of his "Black Notebooks" in recent years has intensified debates about antisemitism in his thinking. Some scholars argue that his political failings are inseparable from his philosophy, while others maintain that his thought contains resources for critique that transcend his personal failings. What remains undeniable is the transformative impact of his work on multiple intellectual traditions. Whether embraced, modified, or rejected, Heidegger's fundamental questions about Being, technology, language, and human existence continue to provoke thought across disciplinary and cultural boundaries. His philosophical journey, with all its brilliance and darkness, remains one of the most significant of the twentieth century—a testament to both the power of thinking and its potential ethical pitfalls.

Summary

Martin Heidegger's philosophical legacy embodies a profound paradox: a thinker who sought to reawaken humanity to the question of Being while failing to confront the moral catastrophe of his time. His work fundamentally transformed how we understand human existence, language, and our relationship to technology and the natural world. From his radical reinterpretation of phenomenology in "Being and Time" to his later meditations on dwelling poetically on earth, Heidegger challenged the foundations of Western thought and opened new pathways for thinking. His concepts of Dasein, authenticity, care, and the critique of technological enframing continue to resonate in an age grappling with environmental crisis, digital transformation, and questions of meaning. The enduring value of Heidegger's thought lies in its power to disrupt our habitual ways of seeing the world and ourselves. He teaches us to question the technological frameworks that increasingly dominate our lives and to seek more thoughtful ways of dwelling on earth. At the same time, his case reminds us that philosophical brilliance offers no immunity to moral and political failure. Perhaps the most important lesson from Heidegger's journey is the need to combine rigorous questioning with ethical responsibility—to pursue the question of Being while remaining attentive to the concrete suffering of beings. For those willing to engage critically with his complex legacy, Heidegger remains an essential thinker whose questions cannot be easily dismissed, even as his answers and his life continue to provoke necessary debate.

About Author

Loading...

Sarah Bakewell

Sarah Bakewell was a bookseller and a curator of early printed books at the Wellcome Library before publishing her highly acclaimed biographies The Smart, The English Dane, and the best-selling How to Live: A Life of Montaigne, which won the National Book Critics Circle Award for Biography. In addition to writing, she now teaches in the Masters of Studies in Creative Writing at Kellogg College, University of Oxford. She lives in London.

Read more

Related Books by Sarah Bakewell

Loading...

How to Live

Sarah Bakewell

Or A Life of Montaigne in One Question and Twenty Attempts at an Answer

★★★★½4.5

Loading...

Humanly Possible

Sarah Bakewell

Seven Hundred Years of Humanist Freethinking, Inquiry, and Hope

★★★★☆4.0