Better Than Before

Better Than Before Plot Summary

Introduction

Why do some habits stick while others fade away? Why can we follow certain routines effortlessly while struggling to maintain others that seem equally important? These questions lie at the heart of the human experience with habit formation - a process that shapes our lives more profoundly than we often realize. The framework presented here reveals that habits are not merely about willpower or motivation, but about understanding the architecture of behavior change and designing systems that work with our unique tendencies rather than against them. At its core, this exploration of habits offers a revolutionary insight: there is no one-size-fits-all approach to habit formation. Instead, successful habit change demands self-knowledge and strategic thinking. By examining the pillars of habit formation, the optimal timing for beginning new behaviors, and techniques for managing desire and resistance, we gain a comprehensive understanding of how to transform our daily routines. The framework illuminates not just the mechanics of habit change but the deeply personal nature of the process, showing how our individual tendencies, distinctions, and relationships with others all influence our ability to master the habits that shape our everyday lives.

Chapter 1: The Four Tendencies Framework: Understanding How We Respond to Expectations

The Four Tendencies framework represents a groundbreaking approach to understanding how people respond to expectations - both outer expectations (from bosses, family members, society) and inner expectations (our own resolutions and desires). This fundamental distinction divides people into four categories that powerfully influence how they approach habits and change. Upholders readily meet both outer and inner expectations. They wake up thinking, "What's on my schedule and to-do list today?" and follow through without much struggle. They don't need external accountability because they're naturally motivated to meet commitments to themselves and others. However, they may appear rigid and can feel anxious when expectations are unclear. Upholders find habit formation relatively straightforward since they naturally honor their own intentions. Questioners question all expectations and will only follow rules that make sense to them. They need reasons and justifications. A Questioner won't take vitamins simply because a doctor prescribed them; they need to understand why vitamins are necessary. They essentially turn all expectations into inner expectations. Once convinced of a habit's value, they follow through consistently, but they may suffer from "analysis paralysis" while seeking perfect information before acting. Obligers readily meet outer expectations but struggle with inner expectations. They excel at meeting deadlines for work but might fail to follow through on personal goals like exercise. For Obligers, external accountability is crucial - they need someone expecting something from them. A running buddy, a coach, or even an app that sends reminders can make the difference between success and failure. Without such accountability, Obligers often experience a sense of burnout and may eventually rebel. Rebels resist all expectations, both outer and inner. They value authenticity and self-determination above all. They act from a sense of choice and identity, doing things because they want to in the moment, not because someone (including their past self) decided they should. Rebels often respond well to challenges, information, and the freedom to make their own choices, but conventional habit-formation advice frequently fails them. Consider how these tendencies play out in real life: An Upholder might set a New Year's resolution to exercise daily and simply stick to it. A Questioner will research exercise benefits extensively before committing. An Obliger might join a running group because they know they'll show up for others even when they wouldn't for themselves. A Rebel might reject a formal exercise program but embrace physical activity when framed as an expression of personal freedom or identity. Understanding your own tendency doesn't change it, but it provides essential insight into which habit strategies will work for you. An Obliger trying to use willpower alone will likely fail, while setting up external accountability will lead to success. Similarly, attempting to pressure a Rebel often backfires, while appealing to their sense of identity might work beautifully. The Four Tendencies framework explains why universal advice about habit formation so often fails - different people need fundamentally different approaches.

Chapter 2: Self-Knowledge: Discovering Your Personal Habit Distinctions

Beyond the Four Tendencies, deeper self-knowledge about personal distinctions dramatically affects habit formation success. These distinctions aren't about better or worse approaches but about understanding your natural inclinations and working with them rather than against them. Recognizing these aspects of yourself allows you to craft habit strategies that feel natural rather than forced. One crucial distinction is whether you're a Lark or an Owl - your natural chronotype. Larks wake early and have their most productive hours in the morning, while Owls come alive later and may do their best work at night. This distinction is largely genetic, not a matter of discipline. A Lark trying to establish an evening exercise routine is fighting an uphill battle, just as an Owl forcing morning meditation is setting themselves up for failure. The key is aligning habits with your natural energy patterns rather than struggling against them. Another significant distinction lies in how you approach projects - are you a Marathoner, Sprinter, or Procrastinator? Marathoners prefer steady, consistent progress on tasks, often working ahead of deadlines. Sprinters thrive under pressure and deliberately wait until deadlines approach to harness that energy. Procrastinators delay but unlike Sprinters, they suffer anxiety about their delay. Understanding this distinction helps you structure habit formation appropriately - a Marathoner might benefit from daily small steps, while a Sprinter might prefer intensive habit "sprints." How you respond to deprivation reveals whether you're an Abstainer or a Moderator. Abstainers find it easier to give something up entirely than to indulge moderately - having one bite of chocolate leads to eating the whole bar. Moderators, conversely, feel deprived by total restriction and do better with occasional indulgences. An Abstainer might successfully quit sugar completely while a Moderator would be more successful allowing occasional treats. Trying to follow the wrong approach can lead to frustration and failure. Consider how these distinctions manifest in real life. An Abstainer who loves chocolate might keep it out of the house entirely, knowing that "just one square" is impossible. A Moderator might keep a high-quality chocolate bar and enjoy one square daily. A Lark might schedule important habit work for 6 AM when they're naturally energetic, while an Owl might set aside time after dinner. A Marathoner might work on a manuscript for 30 minutes daily for months, while a Sprinter might schedule intensive weekend writing retreats. These distinctions extend to many other areas - whether you prefer simplicity or abundance, familiarity or novelty, starting or finishing, taking small steps or big steps. They explain why habit advice that works perfectly for one person fails completely for another. Understanding your own nature isn't self-indulgent; it's the foundation of successful habit formation. The more your habit strategies align with your natural tendencies, the less friction you'll experience and the more likely your habits are to stick.

Chapter 3: The Pillars of Habits: Monitoring, Foundation, Scheduling, Accountability

Four fundamental strategies form the pillars that support all successful habits. These essential approaches provide the structure needed to transform occasional behaviors into automatic routines, regardless of which specific habits you're trying to build. Understanding and implementing these pillars dramatically increases the likelihood that new habits will stick. Monitoring - the act of tracking your behavior - carries surprising power in habit formation. The simple act of measuring something tends to improve it, even before making conscious changes. This phenomenon explains why keeping a food journal often leads to weight loss or why tracking spending typically reduces expenses. Monitoring brings awareness to unconscious behaviors and creates a feedback loop that motivates improvement. Consider how a roadside speed display showing drivers how fast they're going naturally encourages slowing down, or how step counters motivate increased walking. Importantly, monitoring must focus on specific, concrete behaviors - "be more mindful" is too vague to track, while "meditate for five minutes daily" provides clear data. The Foundation pillar recognizes that certain basic habits create the conditions for all other habits to flourish. These foundation habits include adequate sleep, regular physical activity, nutritious eating, and managing clutter. When these fundamentals are neglected, even the most motivated person struggles to maintain other good habits. For instance, chronic sleep deprivation depletes willpower and decision-making ability, making it nearly impossible to resist temptation or follow through on intentions. Similarly, regular movement boosts mood and energy, creating the physical and mental conditions needed for other positive behaviors. Foundation habits should be prioritized because they disproportionately influence overall well-being and habit success. Scheduling transforms vague intentions into concrete plans by specifying exactly when and where a habit will occur. Research consistently shows that habits stick better when tied to specific times and triggers rather than left to whenever we "feel like it" or "find time." For example, deciding to "exercise when I can" rarely works, while "exercise Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at 7 AM" creates clarity that increases follow-through. Scheduling eliminates the daily decision of whether to perform a habit, conserving the mental energy required for habit maintenance. Additionally, scheduling helps ensure that important-but-not-urgent activities receive the time they deserve. Accountability, the final pillar, harnesses our desire to meet others' expectations. Knowing someone else is watching or waiting dramatically increases follow-through. This explains why people are more likely to show up for a fitness class than to exercise alone, or why writers with deadlines produce more than those without external pressure. Accountability takes many forms - from workout buddies to public commitments to automated reminders. For many people, especially those with an Obliger tendency, external accountability is the single most powerful factor in habit formation. Even simple accountability measures like joining an online challenge or telling a friend about your intentions can significantly boost success rates. These four pillars can be seen operating in successful real-world habit formation. Consider someone successfully establishing a meditation practice by monitoring their daily sessions, ensuring adequate sleep so they're not too tired to meditate, scheduling meditation immediately after morning coffee, and joining a meditation group that expects attendance. By systematically addressing each pillar, they create multiple layers of support for their new habit.

Chapter 4: The Best Time to Begin: First Steps, Clean Slate, Lightning Bolt

The timing of habit formation significantly impacts success, with three distinct strategies helping to identify optimal moments for beginning new habits. Understanding these timing elements allows for strategic habit initiation when momentum and opportunity are greatest, rather than struggling against unnecessary resistance. The First Steps strategy acknowledges that beginning is often the hardest part of habit formation. Taking even a tiny initial step creates momentum that makes subsequent steps easier. This approach emphasizes that perfectionism and elaborate preparation often become forms of procrastination - it's better to start imperfectly than never start at all. For example, writing a single sentence breaks the psychological barrier to writing, making it easier to continue. The strategy works by overcoming activation energy - the initial resistance to starting - which is typically greater than the energy required to continue. Consider someone wanting to exercise who finds getting dressed and traveling to the gym more daunting than the workout itself. By focusing on just putting on workout clothes as the "first step," they overcome the greatest barrier. The Clean Slate strategy leverages natural transition points in life when old habits are disrupted, creating ideal opportunities for establishing new patterns. Major life changes - moving to a new home, starting a new job, recovering from illness, or even returning from vacation - temporarily suspend existing routines, making it easier to insert new behaviors before old patterns reassert themselves. During these transitions, the mental scripts that typically trigger automatic behaviors are temporarily suspended. A person who moves to a new home might easily establish a habit of hanging up coats immediately that would have been difficult in their old environment where leaving coats on chairs was deeply ingrained. Similarly, January 1st provides a psychological clean slate that explains why New Year's resolutions, despite their mixed reputation, remain popular. The Lightning Bolt strategy recognizes that sometimes habits change dramatically and instantly following a powerful insight or emotional experience. Unlike gradual habit formation, Lightning Bolt changes require no effort or willpower - they happen when a realization hits with such force that behavior transforms immediately. A smoker who suddenly quits after decades, or someone who radically changes their diet after reading compelling health information, exemplifies this phenomenon. While Lightning Bolts can't be scheduled or forced, they can be prepared for by exposing oneself to potentially transformative ideas and experiences. A person might read widely about nutrition, for instance, creating conditions where a Lightning Bolt insight could occur. These timing strategies appear in countless successful habit transformations. Consider the story of someone who finally began writing their novel after years of procrastination. They started with just five minutes of writing daily (First Steps), began immediately after changing jobs when their schedule was already disrupted (Clean Slate), and maintained motivation after reading an article about mortality that triggered the realization that "someday" might never come (Lightning Bolt). By recognizing and utilizing these timing elements, they succeeded where previous attempts had failed. Understanding these timing strategies helps explain why identical habit approaches yield different results at different times. The same exercise program that feels impossible to maintain during a busy work period might become effortless when started during vacation, or after a health scare provides Lightning Bolt motivation. Rather than forcing habits against timing headwinds, we can strategically launch them when conditions are most favorable.

Chapter 5: Strategy of Convenience vs. Inconvenience: Environmental Design for Habits

The physical environment profoundly shapes our behavior, often more powerfully than willpower or motivation. By strategically adjusting the convenience or inconvenience of activities, we can design environments that naturally lead to better habits without requiring constant discipline or decision-making. This approach acknowledges that human behavior follows the path of least resistance. The Strategy of Convenience makes desired behaviors easier to perform, reducing friction that might otherwise prevent good habits. This principle explains why placing a bowl of fruit on the counter increases fruit consumption, or why keeping exercise clothes packed and ready encourages workout consistency. Convenience affects virtually every habit domain - people are more likely to save money when enrollment is automatic, more likely to take medication when it's pre-sorted into daily containers, and more likely to maintain relationships when interaction requires minimal effort. Even small convenience adjustments yield significant results. Studies show that moving healthy cafeteria options to eye level increases their selection, and placing recycling bins in prominent locations boosts recycling rates. The power of convenience explains why digital products with "one-click" options are so successful - each removed step dramatically increases follow-through. Conversely, the Strategy of Inconvenience deliberately introduces friction to discourage unwanted behaviors. This works because humans naturally avoid unnecessary effort. Making unhealthy foods harder to reach, removing saved credit card information from shopping sites, or placing the television remote in a drawer rather than on the coffee table creates small barriers that reduce impulsive actions. Some people successfully curb social media use by deleting apps from their phones (requiring reinstallation to check accounts), or discourage snacking by storing treats in hard-to-open containers in inconvenient locations. The strategy works even with minimal inconvenience - studies show that simply placing candy in opaque rather than transparent containers significantly reduces consumption. These strategies work together to create habit-friendly environments. Consider how a person might redesign their home to support better sleep habits. They make sleep more convenient by placing pajamas on the bed, setting out a glass of water on the nightstand, and programming lights to dim automatically at bedtime. Simultaneously, they make sleep disruption inconvenient by storing digital devices in another room, placing the television behind cabinet doors rather than prominently displayed, and positioning bookshelves away from the bed to discourage late-night reading. Together, these environmental adjustments naturally guide behavior toward better sleep without requiring constant willpower. The power of environmental design explains why habit change often fails when people focus exclusively on motivation while ignoring their surroundings. A highly motivated person attempting to eat healthfully in a kitchen stocked with visible, easily accessible junk food faces unnecessary difficulty. Similarly, expecting to read more while keeping a television prominently displayed and books hidden away creates environmental resistance. Rather than fighting against our tendency to follow the path of least resistance, these strategies harness this tendency by carefully designing which paths become easiest. In real-world applications, we see these principles in action everywhere from Google's office designs (with healthy snacks placed at eye level and desserts hidden in opaque containers) to addiction treatment programs that recommend removing alcohol from the home rather than relying solely on willpower. By thoughtfully engineering our environments, we can make good habits feel effortless and bad habits require deliberate effort - precisely the opposite of our natural starting point.

Chapter 6: Managing Temptation: Abstaining, Safeguards, and Loophole-Spotting

Even with the best intentions, temptation inevitably challenges our habit goals. Rather than relying solely on willpower in these moments, strategic approaches to managing temptation can dramatically increase long-term success. These strategies acknowledge human vulnerability while creating systems to protect good habits during moments of weakness. The Strategy of Abstaining recognizes that for many people, complete avoidance of temptation works better than moderation. Abstainers find it easier to have none of something (chocolate, alcohol, social media) than to have just a little. This approach eliminates the mental negotiation that often leads to overindulgence - there's no daily decision about "how much is appropriate" because the rule is simple: none. This strategy proves particularly effective for habit goals involving potentially addictive substances or behaviors. As 18th-century writer Samuel Johnson observed about alcohol: "I can't drink a little, therefore I never touch it. Abstinence is as easy to me as temperance would be difficult." While this approach isn't universal - many people do better with moderation - understanding whether you're naturally an Abstainer or Moderator provides crucial insight into which temptation management strategy will serve you best. Safeguards prepare for moments of weakness by anticipating and planning for temptation rather than being blindsided by it. This includes identifying trigger situations and creating specific if-then plans for handling them. For example, "If I'm offered dessert at a restaurant, then I'll order tea instead" or "If I feel the urge to skip my workout, then I'll just put on my exercise clothes and do five minutes." Safeguards acknowledge that willpower fluctuates and creates pre-committed responses that require less in-the-moment decision-making. Research consistently shows that people who use if-then planning navigate temptation more successfully than those relying on general intentions. Effective safeguards might include avoiding certain routes home to prevent impulse shopping, scheduling challenging tasks during peak energy hours, or removing tempting apps from phones during work periods. Loophole-Spotting targets the ingenious ways we justify breaking our own rules. Common loopholes include "just this once" thinking, moral licensing ("I've been so good, I deserve this exception"), false choice framing ("I can't exercise because I need to work"), and tomorrow logic ("I'll be perfect starting tomorrow"). By becoming aware of these mental justifications, we can recognize and reject them in the moment. For instance, catching yourself thinking "I deserve this cookie because I had a stressful day" allows you to counter with "Stress eating won't actually solve my stress problem." This strategy works by bringing subconscious rationalizations into conscious awareness where they can be evaluated more objectively. These approaches appear in successful real-world habit maintenance. Consider someone maintaining a consistent writing practice despite numerous challenges. They might abstain completely from checking email until their daily writing is complete, safeguard their writing time by creating an if-then plan for handling interruptions, and recognize when they're using the loophole of "I'll write twice as much tomorrow" to justify skipping today's session. By systematically addressing temptation rather than hoping for perfect willpower, they maintain their habit through inevitable challenges. The most effective temptation management often combines strategies - perhaps abstaining from certain triggers while moderating others, implementing safeguards for predictable challenges, and developing awareness of personal loophole patterns. This comprehensive approach acknowledges that temptation is inevitable but surrender to it is not.

Chapter 7: Finding Motivation: Rewards, Treats, Pairing, and Clarity

Maintaining long-term motivation for habits requires sophisticated strategies that work with human psychology rather than against it. While conventional wisdom often focuses on simple reward systems, truly effective motivation embraces more nuanced approaches that create sustainable engagement without undermining intrinsic motivation. The strategy of rewards requires careful implementation, as traditional reward systems often backfire for habit formation. Research shows that external rewards can actually decrease intrinsic motivation - the enjoyment of an activity for its own sake. When children are rewarded for drawing, for instance, they subsequently show less interest in drawing during free time than children who weren't rewarded. This explains why "If I exercise, I'll reward myself with cake" approaches often fail long-term. Instead, effective rewards come from within the habit itself - the natural satisfaction of mastery, the physical benefits of exercise, or the creativity unleashed through consistent practice. Rather than seeking rewards outside the habit, focus on noticing and appreciating the inherent rewards that come from the habit itself. A writer might focus on the pleasure of creative expression rather than establishing external treats for writing sessions. Treats differ from rewards in that they're given without requiring anything in return - they're unconditional pleasures that replenish our energy and willpower. Regular treats prevent the feeling of deprivation that often leads to habit abandonment. However, the most effective treats align with rather than undermine long-term goals. A social media break might feel like a treat but could deplete mental energy, while a brief walk outside might genuinely refresh. Effective treats might include listening to favorite music, spending time in nature, enjoying a cup of tea in silence, or engaging in a brief creative activity. By regularly incorporating true treats, we maintain the emotional resources needed for habit consistency. Someone maintaining a challenging work schedule might incorporate ten-minute "sanctuary breaks" throughout the day, preventing burnout and sustaining motivation. Pairing combines a desired activity with a necessary one, creating a temptation bundling effect that increases motivation. This strategy allows the pleasure of one activity to fuel engagement with another. For example, only watching favorite TV shows while exercising, only enjoying audiobooks during commutes, or only drinking favorite coffee while working on difficult projects. Pairing works by transforming habits from obligations into opportunities - "I get to listen to my podcast" rather than "I have to walk." This strategy appears in countless successful habit systems, from people who only allow themselves to check social media while on exercise bikes to those who reserve favorite music for household chores. Clarity provides the foundation for all motivation by connecting habits to deeply held values and identity. Without clarity about why a habit matters personally, motivation inevitably falters. This involves honestly examining questions like: Why does this habit matter to me specifically? Does it align with my true values or someone else's expectations? What identity do I want to embody? Sometimes lack of motivation signals that a habit doesn't actually align with personal values or priorities. A person struggling to maintain a running habit might discover through reflection that they genuinely prefer yoga, or someone forcing themselves to network might realize they value deeper connections with fewer people. Clarity ensures that habits serve authentic goals rather than external pressures or assumed "shoulds." These motivation strategies combine powerfully in successful habit systems. Consider someone maintaining a consistent meditation practice by focusing on how meditation itself provides the reward of increased calm (internal rewards), enjoying a special tea before sessions (treats), only meditating in a beautiful space with a view (pairing), and maintaining clear connection to how meditation supports their value of mindful parenting (clarity). This comprehensive approach creates sustainable motivation that doesn't rely on willpower alone.

Summary

The core insight that emerges from this exploration of habits is both liberating and empowering: there is no universal formula for habit mastery, but rather a sophisticated framework that must be personalized to our unique tendencies, preferences, and circumstances. The most transformative habits aren't those that require heroic willpower or dramatic lifestyle changes, but those that work harmoniously with our existing nature while strategically removing friction and resistance. This understanding of habits reaches far beyond simple productivity tips or life hacks - it touches the very essence of how we shape our daily experiences and ultimately our lives. By recognizing that habits form the invisible architecture of everyday life, accounting for nearly half of our daily behaviors, we gain tremendous power to direct our time and energy toward what truly matters. When we align our habits with our values, make them convenient, manage temptation effectively, and design environments that support rather than undermine our intentions, we create the conditions for what might be called "everyday life in utopia" - a life where our actions naturally flow toward our deeper aspirations rather than against them. The ultimate goal isn't perfect habits but better ones - habits that bring us closer to the people we wish to become, one small, consistent action at a time.

About Author

Loading...

Gretchen Rubin

Out now: "Secrets of Adulthood"The #1 New York Times bestselling author of The Happiness Project and Better Than Before distills her key insights into simple truths for living with greater satisfaction, clarity, and happiness. Order your copy of "Secrets of Adulthood" today. Author BioGretchen Rubin is one of today’s most influential and thought-provoking observers of happiness and human nature. She’s the author of many New York Times bestselling books, such as The Happiness Project, Better Than Before, and The Four Tendencies, Life in Five Senses, and Secrets of Adulthood, which have sold millions of copies in more than thirty languages. Her next book Secrets of Adulthood comes out April 2025.She’s the host of the popular, award-winning podcast Happier with Gretchen Rubin, where she and her co-host (and sister) Elizabeth Craft explore strategies and insights about how to make life happier. As the founder of The Happiness Project, she has helped create imaginative products for people to use in their own happiness projects.She has been interviewed by Oprah, eaten dinner with Nobel Prize-winner Daniel Kahneman, walked arm-in-arm with the Dalai Lama, had her work reported on in a medical journal, been written up in the New Yorker, and been an answer on Jeopardy!Gretchen Rubin started her career in law, and she realized she wanted to be a writer while she was clerking for Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor. Raised in Kansas City, she lives in New York City with her family.

Read more

Related Books by Gretchen Rubin

Loading...

The Happiness Project

Gretchen Rubin

Or, Why I Spent a Year Trying to Sing in the Morning, Clean My Closets, Fight Right, Read Aristotle, and Generally Have More Fun

★★★½☆3.6

Loading...

The Four Tendencies

Gretchen Rubin

The Indispensable Personality Profiles That Reveal How to Make Your Life Better (and Other People’s Lives Better, Too)

★★★½☆3.8

Loading...

Outer Order, Inner Calm

Gretchen Rubin

Declutter and Organize to Make More Room for Happiness

★★★½☆3.5