Chief Joy Officer

Chief Joy Officer Plot Summary

Introduction

The morning sun streamed through the windows as Sarah stared at her resignation letter. After eight years at a prestigious firm, she was walking away from a corner office and substantial salary. Something felt broken in how work happened there—the constant fear, the politics, the hollow achievements. As she packed her belongings, Sarah wondered if there was another way to lead, one where success and joy could coexist. This question lies at the heart of modern leadership. In a world dominated by fear-based management, strict hierarchies, and cultures that prioritize results over humans, we've forgotten that organizations are collections of people with hopes, dreams, and a fundamental desire to matter. The path forward requires a radical shift—from leadership that demands compliance to leadership that fosters community, from systems designed for control to those built for human flourishing. By embracing authenticity, humility, and a servant mindset, leaders can transform workplaces into spaces where both results and relationships thrive. This approach isn't merely idealistic; it's increasingly becoming the competitive advantage that separates organizations that adapt and evolve from those that stagnate and fail.

Chapter 1: The Birth of a Joy-Centered Leadership Philosophy

Richard Sheridan stared out the window of his office, contemplating the contradiction of his success. As Vice President of R&D at a software company, he had everything the world measures as achievement—the title, the salary, the authority. Yet he found himself playing solitaire with his monitor turned away from the door, taking back roads to work to delay his arrival, and sneaking out as close to 5 p.m. as possible without being noticed. The symptoms were unmistakable: he was burning out. One afternoon in October 1997, his CEO called him into his office and offered him a promotion to VP of R&D. To everyone's surprise, including his own, Sheridan declined. The prospect of more responsibility in a broken system felt like a prison sentence. But overnight, something shifted in his thinking. What if this was his chance to lead differently? What if he could build "the best damn software team Ann Arbor had ever seen"? With this newfound purpose, Sheridan accepted the position with one condition: his CEO would support him in reimagining how the team worked. Soon after, he discovered a video of IDEO's collaborative approach to innovation and began exploring iterative software development methodologies. He gathered his team and proposed a radical experiment—they would abandon their isolated cubicles and offices for an open workspace where they could collaborate freely. The condition for joining? They had to embrace this new way of working together. Six months into this experiment, Sheridan experienced a revelatory moment. One of his programmers approached him casually mentioning, "Hey Rich, we had an emergency today. But everything's okay, it's all taken care of." Previously, any crisis would have required Sheridan's immediate involvement, with frantic calls and urgent meetings. Now, his team was solving problems without him. The shift was profound—from a boss-centered organization to one where leadership emerged naturally from all levels. This transformation wasn't just philosophical—it delivered results. The company became Michigan's top-performing public company, eventually leading to an acquisition. Although the dot-com crash would later erase these gains, Sheridan had discovered something more valuable than stock options: a leadership approach centered on joy rather than fear, collaboration rather than control, systems rather than heroes. This philosophy would become the foundation for his next venture and a lifetime dedicated to reimagining what work could be.

Chapter 2: Authenticity and Vulnerability as Leadership Strengths

At a lunch and learn session hosted by Ele's Place, a nonprofit serving grieving children, Sheridan and his team encountered a powerful visual metaphor. The organization's representatives brought white plastic masks that grieving teenagers had decorated as part of their healing process. On the outside of each mask were words like "I'm okay," "I'm fine," "I've moved on"—the emotions they wanted the world to see. But on the inside, hidden from view, were their true feelings: "When will the pain go away?" "Lonely," "Scared," "Hurting," "Angry," and "Lost." As the facilitators explained, these teens found healing when they shared the inside of their masks with each other, discovering they weren't alone in their private suffering. For Sheridan, this exercise illuminated something profound about leadership. Leaders wear masks too—projecting confidence, competence, and control while hiding uncertainty, worry, and vulnerability. The question emerged: is this necessary, or is it preventing authentic connection? At Menlo Innovations, the software company Sheridan founded after his previous employer collapsed, a team member was diagnosed with a dangerous tumor requiring surgery. Initially asking for privacy, he later decided to share his news with the entire team during their daily standup meeting, expressing his fear about the upcoming procedure. Without hesitation, a colleague named Eric walked up and embraced him in a supportive hug. The culture had created a space where vulnerability wasn't just accepted—it was met with compassion. This authenticity extends beyond crisis moments. Menlo allows new parents to bring infants to work—not as daycare but to be with their parent. When visitors express concern about productivity loss, Sheridan responds, "Compared to what?" The worry, anxiety, and scheduling chaos of separation creates its own productivity drain, while the occasional baby giggles, smiles, and even first steps bring unexpected joy to the workplace. The company's paired work environment—where two people collaborate on a single task—creates further opportunities for authentic connection. This practice makes it difficult to maintain facades over time. With pairs rotating weekly, everyone eventually works alongside everyone else, learning about their colleagues' styles, strengths, weaknesses, and sometimes personal challenges. The environment discourages headphones and encourages "High-Speed Voice Technology"—simply talking to each other—fostering real-time human connection. Authenticity doesn't mean abandoning aspiration or professional growth. "Fake it till you make it" still has its place. The difference lies in what questions drive us. Rather than "What kind of leader does my boss want me to be?" or "How can I get the same prize as that successful executive?", the authentic leader asks, "What kind of leader do I want to be?" This ongoing self-reflection represents the truest form of bringing your whole self to work—vulnerabilities, aspirations, and all.

Chapter 3: Systems Over Heroes: Creating Sustainable Excellence

In the summer of 1968, a ten-year-old boy's family placed an order for a new bookshelf. When his parents went out for dinner one evening, he decided to surprise them by assembling it himself. Following the multi-page instruction manual, he carefully attached all thirty wooden pieces with nearly one hundred nuts, bolts, and screws. After completing the assembly, he realized a new challenge—the bookshelf was in the garage, but his mother wanted it in the living room. Undeterred, he inched the massive furniture piece through the house, set up his mother's knickknacks and his father's books, and even had his mother's favorite record playing when they walked in. His father was speechless. His mother cried with joy. Years later, Richard Sheridan realized this childhood memory contained a profound truth about sustainable excellence. The joy he experienced came not from personal recognition but from serving others through thoughtful, systematic work. This revelation challenged the hero-worship culture endemic to software development and most business environments. When things go wrong in an organization—missed deadlines, budget overruns, quality problems—leaders typically respond in one of three ways: they see it as random bad luck, blame inadequate people, or recognize a systemic issue. Systems thinkers instinctively focus on the third explanation, understanding that improving systems is the most reliable path to improvement. At Menlo Innovations, this systems thinking manifests in many ways. Their time-tracking system captures work down to the quarter hour, allowing better future predictions and preventing the crazy overtime that leads to bugs and burnout. Their visual management system uses colorful dots on cards to show project status at a glance, making progress transparent to everyone. When problems arise, they have verbal cues like "Rich is uncomfortable!" to diffuse tension, or "It's James's fault—now let's solve the problem" to quickly move past blame to solutions. One particularly powerful system is their quarterly meeting where team members submit questions in advance for leadership to address. During a difficult financial period, questions were direct and challenging: "Are you concerned about developers leaving?" "How do we stay competitive when we pay less than competitors?" "Would you consider working with a business consultant?" Rather than deflecting or becoming defensive, leadership embraced this forum for speaking truth to power, recognizing that the team's willingness to express fears openly represented organizational strength, not weakness. The most telling distinction between hero-based and systems-based organizations emerges during failure. Hero-centered cultures blame individuals when things go wrong. Systems-centered cultures ask how their current processes fostered the problems. As one visitor to Menlo observed, "Leaders who create joyful environments are invariably systems thinkers." They constantly look for ways to make work more humane, more predictable, and more likely to produce quality results that foster pride in the team. In the end, sustainable excellence comes not from superhuman effort but from thoughtfully designed systems that bring out the best in ordinary humans—allowing joy to emerge naturally from work well done.

Chapter 4: Building Intentional Culture Through Daily Practices

"Who do people report to here?" The question came from Cam, an attendee at a Menlo Innovations seminar. After teaching versions of this workshop for seven years, Sheridan had never encountered this query. He asked Cam to wait, gathered five team members, and had them line up in front of the class. When Cam repeated his question, the team members looked thoughtful, then offered varying responses: "Well, I guess the process," said one. "In some cases, the project manager," offered another. Then, almost in unison, they crossed their arms with fingers pointing left and right to each other, saying "We report to each other." Unconvinced, Cam pressed further: "Let's say you want to hire someone, who makes that decision?" "We do," they explained, describing their collaborative interview process. "Who does your performance reviews?" "We do," they replied, detailing their Feedback Lunch system. "Who makes firing decisions?" "Well, we do, with loads of interactions with Rich and James." Cam's exasperation was understandable—how could an organization function without traditional hierarchy? What made this non-hierarchical approach work was an intentional culture built through consistent daily practices. Every new person at Menlo experiences the Extreme Interviewing process where candidates work in pairs on exercises while being observed for collaborative skills. Interviewers don't evaluate technical prowess as much as "kindergarten skills" like sharing, helping others, and making their partner look good. Successful candidates proceed to a one-day paid trial, then a three-week engagement before becoming full team members. The company's paired work environment—where two people share a computer and rotate partners weekly—creates natural accountability and knowledge transfer. Their daily standup meeting brings everyone together briefly to discuss progress and challenges. Show and Tell sessions occur regularly where customers, not engineers, demonstrate the software to ensure it meets their needs. Status is tracked visually with colored dots on cards posted on walls, making progress transparent to everyone. Even physical space reinforces cultural values. When visitors ask what simple change could transform their organization, Sheridan often suggests, "Move out of your office and turn it into a conference room." When the leader of GE Global Services followed this advice—giving up his office, tearing down walls, and adopting High-Speed Voice Technology (actually talking to people instead of emailing)—he transformed his employee services unit and inspired changes throughout GE. What makes these practices powerful isn't just their individual impact but their consistency and interconnection. When a tour group was forming one day, team members jumped from their chairs to update status indicators on their boards—they didn't want visitors to see discrepancies between what Sheridan described and actual practice. The ongoing storytelling about these practices reinforces their importance and holds everyone, including leadership, accountable. Culture isn't just about grand statements or inspirational posters. It lives in the small, repeated interactions that happen every day—the way feedback is given, the way meetings are conducted, the way problems are solved. By designing these daily practices intentionally, organizations create environments where human creativity, collaboration, and joy naturally emerge.

Chapter 5: The Power of Storytelling in Organizational Growth

In the summer of 1968, a ten-year-old boy and his father embarked on a weeklong canoe trip down Michigan's Manistee River. One afternoon, their canoe struck a rock, puncturing the canvas bottom. Pulling ashore on a secluded stretch of riverbank, they made camp as the father contemplated their predicament. After dinner, he asked his son to collect pine tar chips and birch bark from the surrounding forest. Heating the pine tar over their campfire, the father poured it around the hole in the canoe and instructed the boy to press the birch bark into the molten tar. "This is how the Native Americans repaired their canoes," he explained. For the young boy, this moment was pure magic—using ancient wilderness skills to overcome a crisis far from civilization. Years later, Richard Sheridan recognized how this childhood experience had taught him the intoxicating power of storytelling. As a leader, he discovered that stories connect us from heart to mind, from concept to reality, in ways that policies and memos never could. They preserve institutional knowledge, transmit values, and inspire action by making abstract principles concrete and memorable. At Menlo Innovations, storytelling permeates daily work. Tour guides share the company's origin story, explaining how traditional management approaches led to burnout and disillusionment before a new model emerged. They tell of the Organ Transplant Information System emergency in 2004, when a kidney became available but the patient record couldn't be retrieved—illustrating why software quality matters literally as a life-or-death issue. They recount the prospective client who offered $60,000 for a project Menlo estimated at $200,000; when Menlo declined and another company accepted, that company ended up spending over $200,000 and nearly went out of business. These stories aren't just for external audiences. Team members tell stories to each other, especially helping newer staff understand the company's history and values. Sheridan noticed that when leading tours, team members would pause their work to listen as he told familiar stories. Though they'd heard them countless times, these narratives reinforced their shared mission and values. The team playfully began calling him "Chief Storyteller," a title he eventually added to his business card. As tour frequencies increased, the company needed more storytellers. They began pairing Sheridan with other team members for tours, allowing him to step back while others developed their narrative skills. In this process, he heard his own stories retold through different perspectives and discovered new stories he'd never heard before. When one team member pointed out that a story Sheridan frequently told wasn't exactly accurate, she added, "Oh no, I love the way you tell the story, and the changes wouldn't affect the point you're making." This revealed another truth about organizational storytelling: exact facts matter less than the emotional truth and lessons conveyed. The most powerful outcome is when customers begin telling Menlo stories themselves. After running several memorable experiments with an automotive executive named Don, the next time Sheridan visited Don's offices in Tennessee, Don spent several minutes telling his colleagues about his remarkable experience at Menlo. These human connections created through shared narrative aren't easily broken—they forge bonds that transcend transactional business relationships. By developing a culture of storytelling, organizations create a self-reinforcing cycle where values, purpose, and practices become embedded in the hearts and minds of everyone involved. The stories we tell each other become the stories we live by.

Chapter 6: From Fear to Trust: Transforming Workplace Relationships

Richard Sheridan stood in the parking lot of his office building, staring at his phone and the devastating news it contained. After their most successful year ever, business had suddenly dried up. Current projects were ending and new ones weren't materializing. Market uncertainty from events like Brexit and the contentious 2016 U.S. presidential election had clients hoarding cash and delaying decisions. As Sheridan made his way inside, Lisa, one of their senior leaders, approached him with a simple but profound question: "Rich, where does your optimism come from?" It wasn't just about that moment. Lisa had observed Sheridan's persistent optimism through both good times and challenging ones. While others might see optimism as naive in the face of business realities, Sheridan understood it as a fundamental leadership choice—not blind positivity but a deliberate stance that shapes how a team responds to difficulty. Fear represents the greatest enemy of joyful workplaces. Traditional leadership often leverages fear—fear of missing deadlines, fear of being outperformed, fear of making mistakes. This approach creates a permission-seeking culture where employees avoid risks and innovation stagnates. Every policy manual addressing dress codes, working hours, or internet usage implicitly communicates distrust. Every closed-door executive meeting reinforces hierarchy and exclusion. At Menlo Innovations, the journey from fear to trust begins with their hiring process. Candidates participate in "Extreme Interviewing" where they're paired with other applicants and instructed to "make your partner look good" even though they're competing for the same position. This immediately signals that collaboration matters more than individual achievement. New hires work in pairs for their first three weeks, experiencing both support and transparency from day one. Their physical environment reinforces trust through radical openness. No private offices exist, not even for the founders. Work happens in a large open space where conversations are audible and visible to everyone. Project status is tracked on public boards with colored dots showing progress. When problems arise, they're discussed openly rather than hidden away. Even traditional management practices get reimagined. Annual performance reviews are replaced with "Feedback Lunches" where peers provide constructive input. Compensation is transparent, with eighteen pay grades known to everyone. Profit-sharing bonuses are distributed equally to all team members regardless of seniority or role. When difficult situations arise—like attendance issues stemming from personal problems—the team responds with support rather than punishment, such as offering rides to work. Perhaps most powerfully, the company maintains a "forgiveness over permission" culture. When MassMutual, a 169-year-old insurance company, wanted to foster innovation after hearing Sheridan speak, they didn't create committees or policy documents. Instead, they gave team members helium balloons to mark desks where experiments were happening, encouraging others to ask, "What experiment are you running?" Within six months, these simple balloons had transformed how the claims division approached improvement. The shift from fear to trust doesn't happen overnight. It requires consistent reinforcement through systems that reward collaboration over competition, transparency over secrecy, and learning over blame. As Sheridan observed through market ups and downs, organizations built on trust develop resilience that fear-based cultures cannot match. Even in difficult times, people will rally around a common purpose when they trust both their leaders and each other.

Chapter 7: Leading Beyond Hierarchy and Traditional Management

During a seminar for Nationwide Financial, Cam asked a question that caught Richard Sheridan completely off guard: "Who do people report to at Menlo?" After gathering several team members to answer, Sheridan watched as they explained their unusual system. Hiring decisions? Made by the team. Performance reviews? Conducted through peer feedback lunches. Firing decisions? A collaborative process. Even promotions happened through peer evaluation rather than boss approval. This non-hierarchical approach hadn't been Sheridan's original intention when founding Menlo Innovations. He and his partners hadn't set out to create a "bossless" workplace—they were simply focused on survival and producing joy for their customers. Yet over time, they discovered that traditional hierarchy often impeded the very outcomes they sought: speed, adaptability, and human engagement. Ron Sail, a leader at GE Global Services, visited Menlo and returned to Schenectady, New York, with radical ideas. He promptly gave up his office, tore down walls, and moved into open space with his team. He adopted practices like daily standups and visual management. The transformation was so successful that other GE divisions wanted to replicate it. Ron's willingness to abandon traditional status symbols of leadership opened new possibilities for his entire organization. The shift beyond hierarchy requires rethinking fundamental assumptions about management. At Menlo, this manifests in several key practices. Their "It's OK to say I don't know" poster encourages intellectual humility at all levels. Their "Rich is uncomfortable!" callout allows anyone to flag inappropriate behavior without formal reporting procedures. Their quarterly meetings create space for team members to ask challenging questions directly to leadership—questions like "How do we stay competitive when we pay less than competitors?" or "Would you consider working with a business consultant?" This approach doesn't mean abandoning all structure. Menlo maintains clear systems for work authorization, client engagement, and financial management. However, these systems are designed to enable distributed decision-making rather than concentrate power. Their Open Book Management practices make financial information transparent to everyone, allowing team members to understand business realities and contribute solutions during difficult periods. Perhaps most striking is how Menlo handles employees who leave and later wish to return. Unlike traditional companies that maintain "blackball" lists of former employees deemed disloyal, Menlo welcomes back those who've gained outside perspective. Ian, who left Menlo three times and returned each time as "a better Ian," exemplifies this philosophy. During one return, he told Sheridan, "Rich, do you know how hard it is to build Menlo?" His experience trying to recreate their culture elsewhere had given him deeper appreciation for what they'd built together. The benefits of leading beyond hierarchy become most evident during crises. When business slowed dramatically in 2016, the team didn't wait for top-down solutions. They created a visual sales management system to track leads, established biweekly reviews of sales activity, and adjusted their marketing approach. Because responsibility was distributed rather than concentrated, recovery came more quickly and with greater buy-in than a traditional restructuring would have produced. As the world moves increasingly toward what Sheridan calls a "mind-set-based economy," organizations that can adapt quickly will thrive while rigid hierarchies struggle. Leading beyond traditional management isn't about abandoning all structure—it's about creating systems that harness the full intelligence, creativity, and commitment of everyone involved.

Summary

At its heart, the journey to joy-centered leadership begins with a fundamental shift in perspective. Rather than seeing leadership as a position of authority that must be defended, it becomes a practice of service that must be shared. Throughout the stories in this book—from the broken software team transformed through open collaboration, to the ten-year-old assembling a bookshelf for his mother's delight, to the insurance company revolutionized by simple helium balloons—we see how leaders who choose joy over fear create ripples that transform entire organizations. The path forward requires embracing seemingly contradictory strengths: authenticity alongside aspiration, humility alongside vision, optimism alongside clear-eyed reality. It demands systems that reinforce human connection rather than bureaucratic control, and storytelling that brings values to life through shared experience. Most importantly, it requires the courage to dismantle the walls—both physical and psychological—that separate leaders from those they serve. When we realize that leadership isn't about having all the answers but creating spaces where better questions can emerge, we unlock potential that conventional management could never access. The greatest joy in leadership comes not from personal achievement but from witnessing others discover their capacity to lead, solving problems we never could have tackled alone, and building organizations that truly enhance the lives they touch.

About Author

Loading...

Richard Sheridan

Read more

Related Books by Richard Sheridan

Loading...

Joy Inc.

Richard Sheridan

How We Built a Workplace People Love

★★★★☆4.1