Faith, Hope and Carnage

Faith, Hope and Carnage Plot Summary

Introduction

It was a crisp autumn morning when I first encountered Nick Cave's profound voice echoing through a small, dimly lit venue. The haunting melodies wrapped around the audience like a sacred shroud, creating an almost transcendental experience. As I looked around, I noticed tears streaming down the faces of strangers, each finding their own meaning in the shared moment of vulnerability. This is the unique power of Cave's artistry - the ability to transform personal tragedy into universal catharsis, to create communion through the acknowledgment of pain. In this remarkable journey, we follow Nick Cave's evolution through one of life's most devastating experiences - the loss of his son Arthur - and witness how this unfathomable grief transformed not only his creative process but his entire relationship with the world. Through intimate conversations with journalist Seán O'Hagan, Cave opens himself with unprecedented vulnerability, exploring faith in an uncertain world, the healing power of art, and how creative expression can serve as both sanctuary and salvation. The raw honesty with which Cave discusses spirituality, collaboration, and the redeeming power of human connection offers profound insights for anyone seeking meaning amid life's inevitable sorrows.

Chapter 1: The Beautiful Discomfort of Creative Evolution

Nick Cave sits in a studio with his longtime collaborator Warren Ellis, surrounded by synthesizers and loop machines. Gone are the structured narratives and linear songwriting that defined his earlier work. Instead, they're immersed in pure improvisation, following musical threads without knowing where they might lead. "We were just falling into this sound," Cave explains, "following our hearts and our understanding of each other as collaborators, towards this newness." This approach represents a radical departure from Cave's previous songwriting methods. For decades, he would arrive at the studio with meticulously crafted lyrics and melodies, presenting fully-formed songs to his band, The Bad Seeds. Now, he and Ellis spend days playing non-stop, then sifting through hours of material to find moments of accidental brilliance - perhaps just a minute of music or a single evocative line. These fragments become the foundation for songs that feel more abstract, more emotionally direct, and somehow more authentic to Cave's current experience. The shift wasn't without resistance. Cave acknowledges that some long-time fans wish he'd return to writing what they consider "proper" songs - structured narratives with clear beginnings, middles, and ends. "There are definitely a number of disgruntled older fans who wish I'd go back to writing so-called 'proper' songs," Cave admits. "But I can't see that happening any time soon." He recognizes the deep nostalgia some fans feel for his earlier work, how they associate those songs with their own pasts and "better days." Yet Cave refuses to let these expectations dictate his artistic direction. "You can't allow the nostalgic or sentimental impulses of certain long-time fans to hold back the natural forward motion of the band," he insists. Instead, he embraces what he calls "the lovely discomfort and danger that comes from attempting something new." This willingness to evolve, to challenge both himself and his audience, has resulted in some of the most critically acclaimed work of his long career. This transformation in Cave's creative process reflects a deeper philosophical shift in how he views both art and life. His embrace of uncertainty and improvisation mirrors his personal journey through grief - learning to navigate a world where traditional narratives have been shattered, where meaning must be discovered rather than imposed. The discomfort he feels stepping into unknown creative territory has become not something to avoid, but something to welcome as the birthplace of authentic expression and genuine connection.

Chapter 2: Grief as Transformation: Finding Meaning After Catastrophe

When Nick Cave's 15-year-old son Arthur died in 2015 after falling from a cliff near their home in Brighton, England, the world as Cave knew it shattered completely. "Arthur died and everything changed," Cave says simply. "That sense of disruption, of a disrupted life, infused everything." The linear narrative of his life no longer made sense. The orderly progression of events that most of us take for granted had been violently interrupted, leaving behind a fragmented reality that defied conventional understanding. In the aftermath, Cave found himself existing in what he calls an "impossible realm" - a liminal space between rational thought and something more mysterious. He describes how, after Arthur's death, "the world seemed to vibrate with a peculiar, spiritual energy." Surprisingly, he found himself becoming more susceptible to what he terms "magical thinking" - a willingness to dispense with pure rationality that he found unexpectedly comforting. "That may well be a strategy for survival," he acknowledges, "but it is something that persists to this day." This openness to mystery extended to Cave's music. He speaks of feeling Arthur's presence in the songs on his album "Ghosteen," describing it as "an invented place where the spirit of Arthur can find some kind of haven or rest." Rather than seeing this as merely metaphorical, Cave insists, "I feel him roaming around the songs." This belief, while perhaps challenging for some to accept, provided Cave with a vital connection to his son and a path forward through overwhelming grief. What's particularly striking about Cave's experience is how this catastrophic loss ultimately became transformative. "I became a person after my son died," he explains. "Not part of a person, a more complete person." He describes developing a deeper empathy for others and a heightened sense of life's precariousness. "I feel a kind of deep inclusion in the human predicament," he says, "and an understanding of our vulnerability and the sense that, as individuals, we are, each of us, imperilled." This transformation wasn't about "getting over" grief or finding closure. Rather, it was about allowing grief to expand his capacity for compassion and his appreciation for life's fragility. Cave came to see grief not as something to overcome but as something that forever changes us - ideally making us more open, more connected, and more alive to both joy and sorrow. "We become different," he affirms. "We become better." His journey suggests that our deepest wounds, when fully experienced rather than denied, can become doorways to profound spiritual and emotional growth.

Chapter 3: The Sacred Dimension of Music and Performance

In a packed concert hall, Nick Cave stands on stage, the audience completely silent, rapt in collective reverence. "It was like we were journeying into the unknown," Cave recalls of performing songs from his album "Carnage" after the pandemic. "The music itself was so radically reduced, so intimate that there was nothing to hide behind. Not even the habitual self." This stripped-down performance created what Cave calls a "radical intimacy" - a vulnerable communion between artist and audience that transcended entertainment. For Cave, this experience represents the profound spiritual power of live music. He describes concerts as one of the last remaining places where people can feel genuine awe in real time. "We come together around a shared objective," he explains, "something that unites and raises the collective soul. There is also a loss of self, a sense of being swept up by something larger." In a secular age, this communal transcendence has become increasingly rare and precious. Cave recounts transformative musical experiences he's witnessed, including Nina Simone's performance at London's Festival Hall. The audience "beamed the healing power of her own music straight back at her so that her transformation occurred before our eyes," he remembers. "We returned the music she sent to us, back to her, bright with our love." This circular exchange of energy between performer and audience creates what Cave calls a "sacred space" - a realm where ordinary boundaries dissolve and something deeper emerges. This spiritual dimension isn't limited to explicitly religious music. Cave believes all music has the potential to "penetrate all the fucked-up ways we have learned to cope with this world" and reach "the thing that lies below and is essential to us all, that is pure, that is good." For him, music serves as evidence that "something else is going on, something unexplained," allowing us to "experience genuine moments of transcendence." The healing potential of this experience extends in both directions. Cave speaks movingly of the Skeleton Tree tour, which he undertook shortly after his son's death. Despite his initial trepidation about performing in such a vulnerable state, he found that "walking on stage into the force field of the audience's concern and awareness and love was so restorative to the soul." The audience's compassion created a safe space for his grief, while his willingness to share that grief provided them with permission to acknowledge their own pain. In a world increasingly fragmented by technology and individualism, Cave's perspective reminds us of music's ancient power to create meaningful human connection. It suggests that concerts aren't merely entertainment but potential sites of collective healing - sacred gatherings where we might temporarily transcend our isolation and glimpse something essential about our shared humanity.

Chapter 4: Vulnerability as Creative Power

On a quiet morning in 2020, Nick Cave sits at his piano, attempting to write new songs for an upcoming album. Instead of confidence, he feels overwhelmed by doubt and anxiety. "You start from a point of deprivation, of nothingness, of complete lack," he explains. "And that's when you're confronted with yourself minus your ideas, the very things that normally insulate you from all the ingrained negative bullshit about yourself and your capabilities that lives inside you like a curse." This vulnerability isn't new to Cave, despite his decades of songwriting success. "You'd think that after writing around two hundred and fifty songs or whatever it is, things would get better, but I haven't found that to be the case," he admits. Each time he begins the creative process, he starts with "a new, blank notebook, an idea-free mind and a considerable amount of anxiety." The terror of facing the blank page never diminishes. Yet paradoxically, Cave has discovered that this very vulnerability becomes the source of his creative power. Rather than trying to overcome or bypass his anxiety, he has learned to trust it as part of the process. "I've grown increasingly impatient with my own scepticism," he reflects. "It feels obtuse and counter-productive, something that's simply standing in the way of a better-lived life." This embrace of vulnerability extends beyond his creative work into his approach to life itself. Following his son's death, Cave made the counterintuitive decision to engage more openly with his audience through "The Red Hand Files," where he answers personal questions from fans with remarkable candor. When asked why he would put himself in such a vulnerable position, Cave replies, "I feel very attached to the work I'm doing, so I'm not considering doing something else. There is a real feeling of joy around the things I'm involved in." Cave has come to see vulnerability not as weakness but as strength. "To be truly vulnerable is to exist adjacent to collapse or obliteration," he explains. "In that place we can feel extraordinarily alive and receptive to all sorts of things, creatively and spiritually. It can be perversely a point of advantage, not disadvantage as one might think." The more time he spends in this vulnerable space, "the less worried you become of how you will be perceived or judged, and that is ultimately where the freedom is." This paradoxical wisdom - finding strength through acknowledged weakness, freedom through surrender - offers a profound counterpoint to cultural ideals of invulnerability and control. Cave's journey suggests that our creative and spiritual growth depends not on conquering our fears and doubts, but on learning to create alongside them, allowing our vulnerability to connect us more deeply to ourselves, to others, and to the mystery at the heart of existence.

Chapter 5: The Utility of Belief in an Uncertain World

In the midst of overwhelming grief following his son's death, Nick Cave found himself drawn to spiritual and religious ideas in ways that surprised him. "When it happened, it just seemed like I had entered a place of acute disorder – a chaos that was also a kind of incapacitation," Cave recalls. Yet within this chaos, he discovered what he calls "the utility of belief" - the practical value of faith regardless of its objective truth. Cave shares an analogy from his experience with Narcotics Anonymous when he was getting clean from heroin addiction. The program asks participants to surrender to a higher power, which many initially resist as irrational. "I mean, why should you surrender your life to something that you think doesn't exist?" Cave points out. Yet those desperate enough to follow the instructions often experience profound healing. "They get better, they get clean, their lives greatly improve," he observes. "The believing itself has a certain utility – a spiritual and healing benefit, regardless of the actual existence of God." This pragmatic approach to faith extends beyond traditional religion. Cave describes how, after Arthur's death, he and his wife Susie experienced what he calls "points of light" - small, meaningful gestures from strangers that restored their faith in human goodness. "We began to see, in a profound way, that people were kind. People cared," Cave recalls. "I came to the conclusion that the world wasn't bad, at all – in fact, what we think of as bad, or as sin, is actually suffering." Cave doesn't demand certainty in his beliefs, embracing instead what he calls "poetic truth" or the idea that something can be "true enough." He explains, "To me that's such a beautiful, humane expression." This perspective allows him to remain open to spiritual possibilities without requiring definitive proof. "I believe this gives my life, and especially my work, meaning and potential and soul, too, beyond what the rational world has to offer," he reflects. This approach to faith isn't about escapism or denial but about finding resources to face life's hardest realities. When Cave describes the grief process, he acknowledges, "There were points of light. These points of light were essentially thoughtful gestures from the people we encountered." This recognition that goodness persists even amid tragedy became a lifeline. "I think Susie and I instinctively understood that we needed to move towards this loving force, or perish," he says. Cave's journey suggests that the value of belief lies not in its verifiability but in its capacity to help us navigate life's darkest passages. By remaining open to mystery, to possibility, to what lies beyond rational understanding, we access vital sources of resilience and meaning that can sustain us when certainty fails. In an uncertain world, sometimes it's the uncertainties we embrace, rather than the facts we verify, that most powerfully shape our capacity to endure and eventually thrive.

Chapter 6: Absolution Through Art: Making Amends Through Creation

In his studio in Camberwell, Nick Cave meticulously crafts a series of ceramic figurines depicting the life of the Devil - from birth to death and ultimate forgiveness. This unlikely artistic pursuit became a consuming passion during the pandemic, with Cave working four days a week for over a year on the project. What began as a simple creative experiment evolved into something far more profound - a physical manifestation of Cave's deepest spiritual yearnings. "To me, they are soul objects," Cave explains of the figurines. "They were something I needed to make, because I needed to see them, to bear witness to them, so they could relate back to me the larger and unambiguous meaning of my predicament." Unlike songs, which Cave describes as "impressionistic and abstract," these tangible objects presented something concrete and undeniable about his inner state. The figurines tell the story of a broken life "that collects meaning through misfortune and transgression," culminating in a final sculpture entitled "Devil Forgiven." The theme of forgiveness runs through this project like a current. When asked what the figurines are essentially asking, Cave responds: "Can we be forgiven? I think that question is fundamental to all our lives. In fact, it may be the question that our lives pivot around or, indeed, the whole world revolves around." This need for absolution extends beyond the figurines to all of Cave's recent work - his music, his writings, his public conversations. With striking candor, Cave admits, "When I look at the work and the way I live my life in general now, it becomes increasingly clear that it is an attempt to... Look, this is hard to say." After a pause, he continues, "I feel that, as his father, he was my responsibility and I looked away at the wrong time, that I wasn't sufficiently vigilant." The work Cave creates - "the records, The Red Hand Files, the sculptures" - contains "not a song or a word or a stitch of thread that is not asking for forgiveness, that is not saying we are just so sorry." This understanding of art as a form of atonement gives Cave's creative work a profound spiritual dimension. "Art does have the ability to save us, in so many different ways," he reflects. "It can act as a point of salvation, because it has the potential to put beauty back into the world. And that in itself is a way of making amends, of reconciling us with the world." Through creation, Cave seeks to "redress the balance of things, of our wrongs, of our sins." Cave's journey suggests that art can serve as more than self-expression or entertainment - it can become a vehicle for spiritual redemption, a way of transforming our deepest wounds into gifts for others. By creating beauty from pain, by sharing vulnerability instead of hiding it, we participate in a kind of sacred exchange that benefits both creator and audience. In this view, the artist's role takes on an almost priestly function, offering both personal and collective healing through the transformative power of creative work.

Chapter 7: The Impossible Realm: Between Rational and Divine

One afternoon, while deep in conversation, Nick Cave attempts to articulate an elusive spiritual concept: "There is another place that can be summoned through practice that is not the imagination, but more a secondary positioning of your mind with regard to spiritual matters." He references religious writer Cynthia Bourgeault's concept of "the imaginal realm" - a liminal state of awareness that exists "before dreaming, before imagining, that is connected to the spirit itself." Cave describes this state as an "impossible realm where glimpses of the preternatural essence of things find their voice." In this space between the rational and the mysterious, Cave feels a connection to his deceased son Arthur. "Arthur lives there," he says simply. "Inside that space, it feels a relief to trust in certain glimpses of something else, something other, something beyond." This impossible realm became particularly vivid for Cave while recording his album "Ghosteen." He describes the studio sessions as having "an extremely, I don't know, concentrated" atmosphere that was "unsettling and strange." Cave recalls, "I do think the great beauty of Ghosteen ultimately lies in the tenuous grip both Warren and I had, not only on the songs themselves, but on our own sanity." The result was music that felt "weird, beautiful, holy" - infused with what Cave calls "spirits in the air." Cave acknowledges that discussing such experiences risks sounding irrational or delusional. "When we talk about these things, they are easy to demolish, they are easy to scare away," he admits. "The argument is lost the moment it is put into words and enters the rational world." Yet he insists on defending these ineffable experiences, declaring, "God cannot be defended, hence we must." For Cave, remaining open to mystery isn't a rejection of rationality but an acknowledgment of its limitations. "I think the rational aspect of our selves is a beautiful and necessary thing," he clarifies, "but often its inflexible nature can render these small gestures of hope merely fanciful. It closes down the deeply healing aspect of divine possibility." By remaining attentive to experiences that transcend rational explanation, Cave finds access to vital sources of meaning and comfort. This willingness to dwell in the space between knowing and not-knowing characterizes Cave's approach to both art and spirituality. He embraces what poet John Keats called "negative capability" - the capacity to remain in "uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason." For Cave, this openness to mystery isn't escapism but a kind of courage - the willingness to face the unknown without demanding certainty. His journey suggests that some of life's most profound truths may lie not in what we can prove, but in what we can only glimpse through faith, intuition, and the transformative power of art.

Summary

Throughout this remarkable journey with Nick Cave, we witness how catastrophic loss can paradoxically become a gateway to profound transformation. "The loss of my son defines me," Cave acknowledges with stark honesty, yet through this devastating experience, he discovers what he calls "a strange reckless power" - the freedom that comes when the worst has already happened. This power manifests not as hardness or detachment but as heightened sensitivity and connection. "I feel a kind of empathy with people that I never felt before," he reveals. "It feels urgent and new and fundamental." Cave's evolution offers powerful wisdom for navigating our own inevitable losses. He shows us that grief need not be merely endured but can become a teacher, expanding our capacity for compassion and deepening our appreciation for life's fragility. "We are marked by it," Cave says of grief, yet this marking need not define us as victims but as more fully realized human beings. Most profoundly, Cave demonstrates how creative expression can transmute suffering into meaning, not by erasing pain but by transforming it into something that connects us more deeply to ourselves and others. His journey reminds us that our wounds, when acknowledged rather than hidden, can become sources of authentic power and unexpected beauty - not despite our brokenness but because of it.

About Author

Loading...

Nick Cave

Nicholas Edward Cave is an Australian musician, songwriter, author, screenwriter, and occasional actor. He is best known for his work in the rock band Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, and his fascination with American music and its roots. He has a reputation, which he disowns, for singing dark, brooding songs which some listeners regard as depressing. His music is characterised by intensity, high energy and a wide variety of influences. He currently lives in Brighton & Hove in England. Cave released his first book King Ink, in 1988. It is a collection of lyrics and plays, including collaborations with American enfant terrible Lydia Lunch.While he was based in West Berlin, Cave started working on what was to become his debut novel, And the Ass Saw the Angel (1989). Significant crossover is evident between the themes in the book and the lyrics Cave wrote in the late stages of the Birthday Party and the early stage of his solo career. "Swampland", from Mutiny, in particular, uses the same linguistic stylings ('mah' for 'my', for instance) and some of the same themes (the narrator being haunted by the memory of a girl called Lucy, being hunted like an animal, approaching death and execution). A collectors' limited edition of the book appeared in 2007.Cave wrote the foreword to a Canongate publication of the Gospel according to Mark, published in the UK in 1998. The American publication of the same book contains a foreword by a different author.

Read more