Fantasyland

Fantasyland Plot Summary

Introduction

When the Puritans arrived on American shores in the early 1600s, they brought with them not just their physical possessions but a revolutionary approach to truth itself. These religious dissenters believed they were building God's kingdom on earth—a "city upon a hill" that would serve as a model for all humanity. This extraordinary blend of religious zeal and utopian vision established a pattern that would define American culture for centuries to come: a willingness to believe in the fantastic, to prioritize personal conviction over established authority, and to reinvent reality according to one's desires. From the Salem witch trials to QAnon, from P.T. Barnum's elaborate hoaxes to social media echo chambers, America has consistently blurred the boundaries between fact and fiction, reality and fantasy. This journey through America's relationship with truth reveals how the same qualities that drove American innovation and creativity—individualism, religious freedom, entrepreneurial spirit—also created fertile ground for delusion and unreality. Understanding this history is essential for anyone seeking to comprehend contemporary American politics, religion, media, and technology. The patterns established centuries ago continue to shape how Americans perceive reality today, with profound implications for democracy, science, and social cohesion.

Chapter 1: Religious Foundations: Faith and Fantasy in Colonial America (1600s-1700s)

America's unique relationship with fantasy began with its earliest European settlers. The Puritans who established Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1630 weren't merely seeking religious freedom—they believed they were fulfilling biblical prophecy by creating a perfect Christian society in the wilderness. Their leader John Winthrop's famous sermon declaring their settlement "a city upon a hill" wasn't just inspirational rhetoric; it reflected their genuine belief that God had chosen them for a divine mission. This conviction that America had a special destiny would become a recurring theme in national identity. The colonial period witnessed an extraordinary proliferation of religious expression. While European Protestantism was generally becoming more moderate, American religious practice often grew more extreme and experiential. The Great Awakening of the 1730s-40s saw preachers like George Whitefield drawing crowds of thousands with emotional sermons that emphasized direct personal experience of God. Participants reported falling into trances, speaking in tongues, and receiving divine revelations. This democratization of religious authority—the idea that ordinary people could interpret God's will without institutional mediation—established a distinctly American approach to truth. Colonial America also developed a striking tendency toward conspiracy thinking. The Salem witch trials of 1692-93 represented its most dramatic manifestation, resulting in the execution of twenty people based largely on "spectral evidence"—testimony about dreams and visions that couldn't be empirically verified. But fear of hidden conspiracies extended beyond witchcraft. Many colonists believed in elaborate Catholic plots to undermine Protestant societies or saw Native American resistance as evidence of satanic influence rather than a rational response to colonization. What made America's relationship with fantasy distinctive wasn't just the content of these beliefs but the social conditions that allowed them to flourish. Religious freedom, enshrined in various colonial charters and later in the First Amendment, created an unprecedented marketplace of ideas where competing visions of reality could develop without institutional constraint. As one observer noted in 1782, America had become "an asylum for mankind" where people could "not only believe what they please, but they may publicly profess it." By the time of the American Revolution, the colonies had developed a paradoxical approach to reality. The Founding Fathers, many influenced by Enlightenment rationalism, attempted to establish a government based on reason and empirical observation. Yet they built this rational structure atop a cultural foundation that had already embraced the primacy of individual belief over established fact. Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin might have been skeptical of religious miracles, but most Americans remained deeply committed to supernatural worldviews. This tension between reason and fantasy would define American culture going forward. The revolutionary period established both a commitment to Enlightenment principles and a deep-seated belief in America's exceptional destiny—a combination that would allow Americans to be simultaneously practical in building a nation and fantastical in how they understood that nation's purpose and meaning. The seeds planted in colonial soil would grow into a distinctively American approach to reality that continues to shape national life today.

Chapter 2: The Barnum Effect: Entertainment and Deception (1800s)

The nineteenth century witnessed America's transformation from a religious experiment into the world's first full-fledged entertainment society. No figure embodied this shift more perfectly than P.T. Barnum, who understood something profound about the American character: people wanted to be amazed, even if that meant being deceived. When Barnum opened his American Museum in 1841, he created a new kind of reality—one where fact and fiction blended seamlessly. Visitors could see genuine scientific exhibits alongside elaborate hoaxes like the "Feejee Mermaid" (actually a monkey torso sewn to a fish tail) or the elderly Black woman he promoted as George Washington's 161-year-old former nurse. Barnum's genius wasn't just in creating hoaxes but in making the audience complicit in them. "I don't believe in duping the public," he famously said, "but I believe in first attracting and then pleasing them." Americans didn't mind being fooled because the experience was worth the price of admission. This willingness to suspend disbelief for entertainment's sake became a defining national trait. When newspapers debated whether Barnum's exhibits were genuine, it only increased public interest. The line between skepticism and credulity blurred as Americans developed what Barnum called "humbug detectors"—they prided themselves on not being fooled, even as they eagerly embraced new forms of deception. The Gold Rush of 1849 demonstrated how quickly Americans could be swept up in collective fantasy. When news of gold discoveries in California spread, approximately 300,000 people abandoned their previous lives based on rumors of instant wealth. Most "forty-niners" found no gold, but the experience reinforced a distinctly American belief: that overnight transformation from ordinary citizen to extraordinary success was not just possible but expected. This fantasy of sudden wealth without systematic effort would become a recurring theme in American culture, from lottery tickets to get-rich-quick schemes. The nineteenth century also saw the rise of spiritualism, a movement claiming the living could communicate with the dead. What began with the Fox sisters of upstate New York in 1848 (who later admitted they had faked the mysterious "rappings" by cracking their toe joints) grew into a national phenomenon. Séances became popular entertainment, with mediums performing elaborate shows of supernatural contact. Even respected figures like Supreme Court Justice Henry David Miller and Mary Todd Lincoln participated. The movement blended religious yearning with theatrical spectacle, creating a new form of American experience where the supernatural became accessible through commercial transactions. Meanwhile, the American frontier generated its own mythologies. Buffalo Bill Cody transformed his experiences as a scout into the Wild West Show, a theatrical spectacle that blurred the line between historical events and pure entertainment. Audiences didn't distinguish between the real Buffalo Bill and his performed persona—they were consuming a packaged version of the frontier experience that was more exciting than the complex reality. This commodification of history would become a recurring pattern in American culture, with entertainment value often trumping factual accuracy. By century's end, America had developed what Mark Twain called a "hunger for the marvelous." From patent medicines that promised miraculous cures to newspapers that freely mixed fact and fiction, Americans had created a culture where entertainment value often mattered more than truth. This wasn't simply gullibility—it reflected a distinctly American approach to reality that valued imagination, possibility, and good storytelling. The foundations laid during this period would prove crucial for the next stage of America's journey into fantasyland.

Chapter 3: Spiritual Entrepreneurs: Alternative Realities Take Root (1830-1950)

Between 1830 and 1950, America became an unparalleled incubator for new religious and spiritual movements, each offering its own alternative to conventional reality. This period saw the emergence of what might be called "spiritual entrepreneurship"—a distinctly American approach to religion that combined charismatic leadership, innovative theology, and business acumen. Joseph Smith's founding of Mormonism in the 1830s established a template: a charismatic prophet receives divine revelations, attracts followers, and builds an organization that blends spiritual and material concerns. Despite persecution that led to Smith's murder in 1844, the Mormon church thrived under Brigham Young's leadership, eventually establishing Utah as a theocratic territory. Christian Science, founded by Mary Baker Eddy in 1879, represented another innovative American approach to reality. Eddy's teaching that illness was an illusion that could be overcome through proper understanding of God challenged conventional medicine and offered a spiritual alternative to scientific materialism. Her book "Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures" became a bestseller, and she built an influential organization that included a major newspaper, The Christian Science Monitor. Like other successful spiritual entrepreneurs, Eddy combined religious innovation with savvy institution-building. The early 20th century witnessed the birth of Pentecostalism, beginning with the Azusa Street Revival in Los Angeles in 1906. Led by William J. Seymour, an African American preacher, the revival featured speaking in tongues, faith healing, and ecstatic worship. Participants believed they were experiencing a new Pentecost, with the Holy Spirit manifesting just as in biblical times. Unlike more established denominations, Pentecostalism emphasized direct spiritual experience over theological education, allowing anyone who felt the Spirit to preach or heal. This democratization of religious authority proved enormously appealing, and Pentecostalism spread rapidly across America and globally. New Thought movements also flourished during this period, teaching that positive thinking could literally transform reality. Phineas Quimby, Ernest Holmes, and others developed systems claiming that proper mental attitudes could cure disease and attract prosperity. Norman Vincent Peale's "The Power of Positive Thinking" (1952) brought these ideas to mainstream America, selling millions of copies and influencing business culture. These movements reflected a distinctly American optimism and pragmatism—if a belief system "worked" by producing desired results, its metaphysical claims were secondary. What made this proliferation of alternative realities possible was America's unique combination of religious freedom, entrepreneurial culture, and frontier mentality. Unlike Europe with its established churches and traditional hierarchies, America offered space for spiritual innovation without institutional constraints. The separation of church and state meant that no single religious authority could suppress new movements. Meanwhile, the constant westward expansion provided both physical space for experimental communities and a psychological openness to new beginnings. By mid-century, these alternative spiritual movements had profoundly influenced mainstream American culture. Their emphasis on mind over matter, positive thinking, and personal transformation shaped everything from business seminars to self-help literature. Their techniques for altering consciousness—from meditation to visualization—would later influence the counterculture of the 1960s. Most importantly, they normalized the idea that reality was malleable—that through faith, positive thinking, or spiritual techniques, individuals could reshape their world according to their desires. This belief in the power of mind over matter, initially confined to spiritual contexts, would eventually expand into other domains of American life.

Chapter 4: The Great Unmooring: Counterculture Transforms Reality (1960s-1980s)

The 1960s marked a pivotal moment in America's relationship with reality—a "great unmooring" when the boundaries between fact and fantasy began to dissolve across society. The decade began with relative consensus about what constituted reality, but by its end, that consensus had fractured. The counterculture, with its rejection of "the Establishment" and embrace of alternative consciousness, played a crucial role in this shift. Timothy Leary, the Harvard psychologist turned LSD evangelist, urged Americans to "turn on, tune in, drop out"—to reject conventional reality in favor of psychedelic experience. His message resonated far beyond those who actually took drugs, helping normalize the idea that reality was subjective and malleable. The human potential movement, centered at places like California's Esalen Institute, further blurred boundaries. Founded in 1962, Esalen became a laboratory for exploring consciousness through everything from Gestalt therapy to Eastern spirituality. Its workshops taught that personal transformation could occur through techniques ranging from encounter groups to meditation. What began as fringe experimentation gradually influenced mainstream psychology, education, and business. By the 1970s, previously esoteric practices like yoga and meditation had entered the American mainstream, bringing with them worldviews that challenged scientific materialism. Religious experimentation flourished during this period. Young Americans flocked to Eastern spiritual traditions, with the Beatles' interest in Transcendental Meditation exemplifying this trend. New religious movements like Scientology, founded by science fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard, gained prominence despite (or perhaps because of) their fantastic claims about human origins and potential. The Jesus People movement combined evangelical Christianity with counterculture aesthetics, while Pentecostalism continued its explosive growth. What united these diverse movements was their emphasis on direct experience over institutional authority—the idea that truth was something felt rather than learned. Television transformed American consciousness during this period, creating a shared national experience while simultaneously undermining traditional sources of authority. The Vietnam War became the first conflict broadcast nightly into American homes, creating a disconnect between official narratives and visible reality. The moon landing in 1969 demonstrated both technological triumph and the power of media to shape perception—conspiracy theories about it being faked emerged almost immediately. As media theorist Marshall McLuhan observed, the medium itself was becoming the message, changing how Americans processed information and understood reality. The political upheavals of the era further eroded trust in institutions. The assassinations of the Kennedy brothers and Martin Luther King Jr., the revelations of the Pentagon Papers, and finally the Watergate scandal convinced many Americans that official narratives couldn't be trusted. Conspiracy thinking, once confined to the fringes, moved toward the mainstream. The CIA's actual covert operations, once exposed, made even far-fetched conspiracy theories seem plausible. By the late 1970s, films like "Three Days of the Condor" and "The Parallax View" reflected a new national paranoia. By the 1980s, what had begun as countercultural rejection of consensus reality had paradoxically become mainstream. Ronald Reagan, a former actor, embodied this new relationship with truth—his ability to project sincerity mattered more than factual accuracy. When caught in contradictions, he would respond with anecdotes and stories that felt true, even when demonstrably false. This approach proved remarkably effective, suggesting that Americans had come to value emotional resonance over factual precision. The great unmooring was complete: America had entered a new phase where reality itself had become negotiable, setting the stage for even more dramatic developments in the decades to come.

Chapter 5: The Fantasy-Industrial Complex: Media and Politics Merge (1980s-2000s)

The period from the 1980s through the early 2000s witnessed the consolidation of what might be called America's "fantasy-industrial complex"—an interconnected system of media, politics, technology, and commerce that increasingly blurred the line between reality and fiction. Cable television transformed the media landscape, fragmenting the national audience and creating specialized channels catering to specific interests and worldviews. CNN launched in 1980, offering 24-hour news coverage that prioritized immediacy and drama over context and analysis. By the 1990s, Fox News had emerged as an explicitly partisan alternative, further fracturing the shared understanding of current events that broadcast networks had previously provided. The entertainment industry increasingly merged with other domains of American life. Politics became more theatrical, with Ronald Reagan—a former actor—pioneering a presidency that emphasized symbolic gestures and emotional resonance over policy details. His successor George H.W. Bush hired Hollywood producers to stage dramatic photo opportunities, while Bill Clinton appeared on MTV and played saxophone on late-night television. The line between politician and celebrity blurred further when professional wrestler Jesse Ventura was elected governor of Minnesota in 1998, presaging even more dramatic developments in the new millennium. Reality television emerged as a dominant cultural form during this period, beginning with shows like "COPS" (1989) and reaching new heights with "Survivor" (2000) and "American Idol" (2002). These programs presented highly manipulated situations as authentic experiences, training viewers to accept staged scenarios as reality. The participants became famous not for any particular talent or achievement but simply for being themselves—or rather, performing versions of themselves crafted for maximum entertainment value. This new celebrity paradigm suggested that fame itself was the ultimate achievement, regardless of how it was attained. Religious broadcasting expanded dramatically during these decades, with televangelists like Pat Robertson, Jerry Falwell, and Jimmy Swaggart reaching millions of viewers. The Christian Broadcasting Network, founded by Robertson in 1961, grew into a media empire that blended religious programming with news and entertainment. Trinity Broadcasting Network, launched in 1973, became the world's largest religious television network by the 1990s. These networks presented a worldview where supernatural intervention in daily life was expected and where political developments were interpreted through apocalyptic prophecy. The rise of talk radio, particularly after the repeal of the Fairness Doctrine in 1987, created another powerful medium for alternative realities. Rush Limbaugh pioneered a form of political entertainment that blended news, opinion, and performance in ways that made fact-checking nearly impossible. By the mid-1990s, his show reached over 20 million listeners weekly. Similar programs proliferated across the dial, creating information ecosystems where listeners could immerse themselves in worldviews that reinforced their existing beliefs while demonizing alternatives. By the early 2000s, the fantasy-industrial complex had fundamentally altered American society. Reality had become a commodity to be packaged and sold, with entertainment value often trumping factual accuracy. The traditional gatekeepers of information—established media, academic institutions, government agencies—found their authority increasingly challenged by alternative sources claiming to reveal hidden truths. Americans had not abandoned the concept of truth entirely, but many had come to believe that truth was something felt rather than verified, something that resonated emotionally rather than standing up to empirical scrutiny. This transformation set the stage for even more dramatic developments in the internet age.

Chapter 6: Digital Delusions: How Technology Fractured Shared Reality (2000-Present)

The dawn of the 21st century accelerated America's journey into fantasyland, as digital technology transformed how information is created, distributed, and consumed. Social media platforms, beginning with MySpace (2003) and followed by Facebook (2004), Twitter (2006), and later Instagram and TikTok, revolutionized communication by allowing anyone to broadcast to potential audiences of millions. This democratization of media brought benefits but also eliminated traditional gatekeeping functions that had once filtered out misinformation. The result was an information environment where conspiracy theories, pseudoscience, and outright fabrications could spread as rapidly as verified facts. Echo chambers became the defining feature of online discourse. Algorithms designed to maximize engagement naturally fed users content that confirmed their existing beliefs, creating feedback loops that reinforced and radicalized viewpoints. Studies showed that Americans increasingly lived in separate information universes, with conservatives and liberals not merely interpreting the same facts differently but operating from entirely different sets of "facts." This phenomenon extended beyond politics to encompass science, medicine, history, and virtually every domain of knowledge. Climate change, vaccines, evolution—topics with strong scientific consensus became battlegrounds where personal belief trumped expert opinion. Conspiracy thinking flourished in this environment. The 9/11 "truther" movement gained significant traction despite overwhelming evidence against its claims. The "birther" conspiracy, which falsely alleged that President Barack Obama was not born in the United States, moved from fringe websites to mainstream discussion, promoted by prominent figures including future president Donald Trump. QAnon, which emerged in 2017 with anonymous posts on message boards claiming that a secret government insider was revealing a hidden war against a cabal of Satan-worshipping pedophiles, grew from internet curiosity to genuine political force, with adherents winning congressional seats. The concept of "alternative facts," inadvertently coined by presidential counselor Kellyanne Conway in 2017, captured this new relationship with reality. Facts were no longer understood as objective truths but as partisan positions one could choose to accept or reject. This approach extended to science, with significant portions of Americans rejecting expert consensus on issues from climate change to vaccine safety. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted this divide, as mask-wearing, social distancing, and eventually vaccination became political identity markers rather than public health measures evaluated on their merits. Traditional media struggled to adapt to this new landscape. The economic model of journalism collapsed as advertising revenue shifted to digital platforms, leading to massive staff reductions and the closure of many local newspapers. Cable news networks increasingly embraced partisan positioning to maintain viewership, with programming that blurred the line between reporting and opinion. The 24-hour news cycle incentivized speed over accuracy and controversy over context. Meanwhile, entirely fabricated "news" websites proliferated, some operated by political operatives, others by entrepreneurs simply seeking profit through clickbait. The culmination of these trends arrived with the 2016 and 2020 presidential elections. Donald Trump's political rise embodied America's new relationship with truth—he made thousands of demonstrably false statements yet maintained the fervent support of his base, who often took him "seriously but not literally" or simply rejected fact-checking as partisan attack. The aftermath of the 2020 election, when millions of Americans believed claims of widespread fraud despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, demonstrated how completely separate reality systems had become entrenched. By the 2020s, America had reached a crisis point in its relationship with reality, raising profound questions about whether democracy itself could function when citizens no longer shared a basic understanding of the world.

Summary

America's journey into fantasyland reveals a profound tension that has shaped the national character from the beginning. The same qualities that made America exceptional—religious freedom, individualism, entrepreneurial spirit, technological innovation—also created fertile ground for fantasy to flourish. The Puritans' religious zeal, Barnum's entertaining deceptions, the spiritual entrepreneurs' alternative realities, the counterculture's rejection of establishment truth, the fantasy-industrial complex's commercialization of unreality, and the internet's fragmentation of shared facts all represent points along a continuous historical trajectory. Throughout this evolution, Americans have maintained a paradoxical relationship with reality: pragmatic and industrious in building the world's most powerful nation while simultaneously embracing increasingly fantastical beliefs about how that world operates. This history offers crucial insights for navigating our current predicament. First, we must recognize that the problem isn't simply one of education or information—it's deeply rooted in American identity and culture. Addressing it requires not just fact-checking but creating compelling narratives that satisfy the same psychological needs currently met by fantasy. Second, rebuilding institutional trust is essential—when people lose faith in traditional sources of authority, they become vulnerable to alternative realities. Finally, we must find ways to preserve the creative benefits of American individualism while restoring a shared commitment to empirical reality. The challenge isn't to eliminate fantasy entirely—imagination and speculation drive innovation—but to reestablish boundaries between the realms of entertainment, belief, and factual discourse. America's exceptional capacity for reinvention suggests this rebalancing remains possible, though the path forward will require confronting uncomfortable truths about our national character.

About Author

Loading...

Kurt Andersen

Kurt Andersen is the author of the novels Turn of the Century, Heyday, and True Believers, and and, with Alec Baldwin of You Can't Spell America Without Me. His non-fiction books include Fantasyland, Reset and The Real Thing.He is also host of the Peabody Award-winning weekly public radio program Studio 360,.Previously, Kurt was a co-founder and editor-in-chief of the satirical magazine Spy, editor-in-chief of New York magazine, a columnist for New York, staff writer at The New Yorker, and design and architecture critic for Time.

Read more

Related Books by Kurt Andersen

Loading...

Evil Geniuses

Kurt Andersen

The Unmaking of America: A Recent History

★★★★☆4.2