Feedback (and Other Dirty Words)

Feedback (and Other Dirty Words) Plot Summary

Introduction

Have you ever received feedback that made you cringe, or worse, shut down completely? Perhaps you've witnessed colleagues avoiding feedback conversations like the plague, or maybe you're a leader who struggles to provide meaningful insights to your team members. The truth is, feedback has earned a bad reputation in our professional lives, often perceived as a weapon rather than a tool for growth and connection. Yet effective feedback lies at the heart of personal development, stronger relationships, and organizational success. When we reframe feedback as an opportunity rather than a threat, we open doors to authentic connection and continuous improvement. The pages ahead offer a roadmap to transform your relationship with feedback—teaching you to seek it confidently, receive it gracefully, and extend it thoughtfully. By embracing these principles, you'll not only enhance your own growth journey but create an environment where others can thrive through honest, supportive communication.

Chapter 1: Redefining Feedback as a Tool for Growth

Feedback, in its essence, is clear and specific information that's sought or extended with the sole intention of helping individuals or groups improve, grow, or advance. This definition stands in stark contrast to how most of us experience feedback—as criticism, judgment, or even punishment. The transformation begins when we recognize that feedback isn't inherently negative; rather, it's our collective experiences and misconceptions that have tainted its reputation. Consider the story of Steven and Mira from a technology company. When Mira, Steven's manager, says, "I've got some feedback for you, Steven. Would you step into my office?" Steven's heart immediately races, his palms begin to sweat, and his legs feel numb as he walks toward her office. A series of negative questions flash through his mind: "Why me? What did I do wrong? Am I getting fired?" This physiological response—what scientists call the "fight, flight, or freeze" reaction—is triggered by the mere mention of feedback, even though Steven and Mira have always had a cordial working relationship. What Steven doesn't realize is that Mira herself has been avoiding this conversation. She's nervous about delivering feedback from a recent project postmortem, concerned about how Steven might react. Both individuals enter the interaction gripped by fear, creating a lose-lose outcome that diminishes trust between them and reinforces their negative perceptions of feedback. This scenario illustrates why we need a movement to fix feedback. Studies show that despite its damaged brand, most of us still want more feedback—62 percent of employees desire more input from colleagues, and 83 percent appreciate feedback whether positive or negative. The paradox is that while we crave feedback, few of us actively seek or extend it. The journey to better feedback begins with understanding what it is and isn't. Feedback is a tool, not a weapon; communication, not accusation; observation offered with context, not judgment passed without context. It's an invitation to self-reflection, not a demand for self-blame. When we embrace this redefinition, we transform feedback from something we fear into something we value as essential to our growth and connection with others.

Chapter 2: Building Trust: The Foundation for Honest Exchange

Trust is the vital ingredient that makes feedback work. Without trust, even the most skillfully delivered feedback will likely be dismissed or rejected. When we receive insights from someone we don't trust or with whom we lack connection, that information often goes straight into our mental waste bin—even if it's positive. Similarly, when we share feedback with someone who doesn't trust us, we risk triggering their fight-flight-freeze response, shutting down any possibility for meaningful exchange. Laura, a senior consultant at a global firm, experienced this trust dynamic firsthand when working with a difficult client executive. For months, she had attempted to provide strategic advice only to be met with resistance and dismissal. Rather than continuing to push her recommendations, Laura shifted her approach to focus on building connection. She began scheduling informal coffee meetings to understand the executive's vision and concerns. She practiced active listening without judgment and demonstrated genuine interest in the executive's goals. After several weeks of these trust-building interactions, the executive began seeking Laura's input, creating an opening for the very feedback that had previously been rejected. This transformation occurred because Laura recognized that trust isn't handed out freely—it's built one interaction at a time, over time. Trust comes from a track record of engaging in feedback conversations that help rather than hurt. It creates a reinforcing loop that can be either positive or negative, depending on how we handle these exchanges. To build trust, we need to embrace several fundamental practices. First, we must be human—admitting mistakes, being authentic to our values, getting personal, and not taking ourselves too seriously. Second, we need to do what we say we'll do—keeping promises, not offering things we can't deliver, being consistent, and communicating honestly. Third, we should be kind—encouraging others, speaking with compassion, being available when needed, and valuing others' needs as much as our own. Finally, we must connect—spending focused time with others, seeking win-win outcomes, allowing for collaboration, and considering others' viewpoints without judgment. Dr. John Gottman's research on relationships offers a powerful insight applicable to feedback: stable and happy relationships maintain at least five positive interactions for every negative one—the 5:1 ratio. This means increasing positive connections through social events, recognition, collaborative work, or simply lending an ear to a colleague having a rough day. While this may seem challenging amid busy schedules, these moments of genuine interest and empathy are essential foundations for effective feedback.

Chapter 3: Becoming an Effective Feedback Seeker

Seeking feedback represents the most important role any of us can play in fixing feedback. When we become Seekers, we take control of our growth journey, demonstrating humility and valuing others' perspectives. Research shows that organizations that shift from giving feedback to asking for it drive performance improvement, growth mindset, effective decision-making, and stronger, more resilient teams. Take the example of Max, a mid-level manager at a manufacturing company who was passed over for promotion. Initially frustrated and confused, Max chose to become a proactive Seeker rather than ruminating on the rejection. He approached his supervisor with specific questions about development areas, then created what he called his personal "board of Extenders"—colleagues from different departments who could offer diverse perspectives on his leadership style. By focusing his ask on specific behaviors and skills he wanted to develop, Max made it easier for others to provide meaningful insights. Within six months, Max's feedback-seeking approach transformed his reputation in the organization. His willingness to hear difficult truths and act on them demonstrated a growth mindset that impressed senior leadership. More importantly, his example inspired others to adopt similar practices, gradually shifting the organization's feedback culture from one of avoidance to one of openness and continuous improvement. The benefits of being a Seeker are numerous: it generates trust, creates greater autonomy and control, increases the likelihood of acting on feedback, focuses on information that helps meet personal goals, and allows for choosing the right time and place for conversations. As a Seeker, you build connections with others and nurture trusted relationships that help you learn and grow. To become an effective Seeker, focus on these key practices: ask in advance, giving potential Extenders time to prepare thoughtful responses; give others permission to be frank and honest by clarifying what kind of feedback you're seeking and why; ask them to start noticing specific areas where you're working to improve; and make conscious choices about what to do with the feedback you receive. Remember to keep your requests focused and specific—rather than asking "How am I doing?" try "When I present to the IT team today, could you pay attention to how much eye contact I'm making?" Finally, diversify your feedback sources. The more perspectives you gather, the more accurate and valuable your insights will be. Your peers often know you best, seeing you at your best and worst every day. Include both supporters and critics in your "board of Extenders" to ensure you're getting a complete picture of your performance and potential.

Chapter 4: Receiving Feedback with Grace and Purpose

As a Receiver of feedback, your goal is to bring your best self to the situation—resisting knee-jerk reactions in favor of thoughtful responses. When someone offers you information they believe you need or want, whether solicited or unsolicited, you have the power to determine how you'll engage with that input and what you'll do with it afterward. Consider the story of a nonprofit executive who was passed over for promotion to managing director. When calling to congratulate Nalu, the successful candidate, she expressed her disappointment and confusion. Nalu responded with brutal honesty: "Actually, you should not have this job. Know why? You're arrogant. You have a reputation for hitting your numbers, you know the organization, you can paint a great vision and lay out a powerful strategy, but you're disconnected from your people and they don't enjoy working for you. I'm honored to have this job, and I honor and value the people who work for me. That's why I got the job and you didn't." Initially furious, the executive wisely gave herself the weekend to process this feedback. She acknowledged her emotions—feeling blindsided, hurt, and uncertain—while also affirming her strengths that Nalu had recognized. This self-awareness helped calm her threat response and open her mind to the feedback. By Sunday, she was ready to move forward, calling Nalu to apologize, congratulate him sincerely, and ask for specific insights on how she could improve her leadership approach. This executive demonstrated key receiving skills that we can all apply. First, she didn't rush to react, giving herself time to process before responding. Second, she shifted from "prove" mode (defending herself) to "improve" mode (focusing on growth). Third, she sought clarification by asking for specific examples and suggestions. Finally, she made a conscious choice about what to do with the feedback, ultimately using it to transform her leadership style. When receiving feedback that's difficult to hear, several techniques can help: breathe deeply and feel your feet on the ground to engage your "wise brain" rather than your reactive "primitive brain"; inquire for facts and examples if the feedback seems vague; ask to pause the conversation if you're feeling overwhelmed; seek additional perspectives if needed; and remember that it's okay to decline feedback that seems unhelpful or misguided. For positive feedback, practice saying "thank you" without deflecting or minimizing your contribution. Ask for specifics about what was helpful, share credit appropriately without diminishing your role, and reflect on how you can further develop the strengths being recognized. Remember that feedback should be short, but reflection can be long—sometimes a casual observation from a colleague can lead to profound insights when given proper consideration.

Chapter 5: Extending Feedback that Helps, Not Hurts

As an Extender of feedback, your mission is to engage with everyone around you—whether they work with you, for you, or above you. You need to be available when asked and willing to offer when the time is right. Your feedback should be authentic, specific, focused, and free of judgment—a responsibility that requires both skill and courage. Mai Ling's story illustrates how not to extend feedback. As a project manager handling a $2 million factory redesign, she missed a major milestone, causing her boss to receive an angry call from a client. Despite Mai Ling's otherwise strong performance, her boss immediately called and launched into criticism: "It was not fun getting my ass chewed by the client today, Mai Ling. You half-stepped the deadline and ruined our chances of winning the next bid. You've missed something like five deadlines in the past few months. What the hell is up?" This approach demonstrates several extending pitfalls: the boss allowed frustration to dictate the timing and tone, used judgmental language ("half-stepped"), made the feedback about himself rather than Mai Ling's development, and neglected to address previous missed deadlines, creating an inconsistent precedent. A more effective approach would involve checking bias (the boss might be suffering from the "halo effect" due to Mai Ling's certifications), increasing frequency of check-ins, clarifying intention, avoiding shame or blame, and helping Mai Ling envision future success. Effective Extenders recognize that feedback should be bite-sized and focused on one clear message. Research shows that our brains can only effectively process three to seven items at once, and this capacity diminishes further when we're stressed. By keeping feedback concise and specific, you help the Receiver absorb and process your insights. The "CONNECT" model provides a practical framework for extending feedback: Context (establish the right time and place), One thing (focus on a single clear message), Notice (share specific observations without judgment), No G.R.I.T. (avoid gossip, rumor, innuendo, or triangulation), Effect (explain the impact of the behavior), Conversation (invite dialogue), and Trust (build connection through the exchange). Remember that sharing positive feedback is equally important as improvement feedback. Research by Zenger and Folkman found that leaders who ranked in the top 10 percent for giving honest feedback had teams that ranked in the top quartile for engagement. Importantly, effective leaders demonstrate a preference for positive feedback, recognizing its power to develop people and reflect well on their leadership.

Chapter 6: Creating a Culture of Continuous Feedback

A culture of continuous feedback transforms not just individual interactions but entire organizations. When feedback flows freely between colleagues at all levels, innovation flourishes, engagement increases, and performance improves measurably. Research by the Institute for Corporate Performance found that companies with strong Performance Feedback Cultures had financial results double those of companies with weak feedback practices. Mary's situation demonstrates how cultural transformation begins with simple interactions. As a team member who had been late to Monday morning stand-ups three times in a row, Mary was called into her manager's office. The manager began by chastising her for tardiness and suggesting that her social drinking might be the cause. Mary broke down in tears, explaining that she had recently begun taking her stepson to therapy sessions across town on Monday mornings, making it impossible to arrive on time. This misunderstanding could have damaged their relationship permanently. Instead, the manager recognized an opportunity to create connection and improve team practices. Together, they explored solutions like shifting the stand-up time or setting up video calls for days when team members couldn't attend in person. This collaborative approach not only solved the immediate problem but demonstrated that feedback could be a tool for mutual understanding rather than judgment. Creating a feedback culture requires consistent practices that normalize open communication. Organizations succeeding in this area typically incorporate several key elements: they end meetings with reflection exercises (like "benefits and concerns" discussions); they devote time during team gatherings for expressing gratitude; they implement simple peer feedback processes like "Feedback Fridays"; and they involve employees directly in talent reviews, embracing the principle that "nothing about me without me." Leaders play a crucial role in cultivating feedback cultures by modeling desired behaviors. When leaders demonstrate humility by seeking feedback first, they signal that vulnerability is strength and continuous improvement is valued. Research shows that leaders who ranked in the top 10 percent for asking for feedback were also in the 86th percentile for overall leadership effectiveness, while those in the bottom 10 percent for asking ranked in just the 15th percentile for effectiveness. The transition to a continuous feedback culture isn't immediate or linear. It requires patience, consistency, and a willingness to address challenges openly. When resistance arises, as it inevitably will, successful organizations focus on the benefits—enhanced learning, stronger relationships, greater innovation, and improved results—rather than forcing compliance with new processes.

Chapter 7: Overcoming Fear Through Practice and Positivity

Fear stands as the greatest obstacle to effective feedback. Our brains are wired to perceive feedback as a threat, triggering the same fight-flight-freeze response that protected our ancestors from physical dangers. This reaction stems from our fundamental need for belonging—what we truly fear is isolation, ostracism, and abandonment, which threatened survival in our evolutionary past. The story of Sol, Mac, and their restaurant manager illustrates how triangulation—a common fear-based pattern—undermines honest feedback. As the restaurant closes, Sol tells the manager, "Mac doesn't appreciate how you wrote up the schedule last week. You gave Sam two tip-heavy shifts, and Mac got stuck with hosting duties. Mac even said you're the worst manager he's ever dealt with." This indirect communication pattern prevents real issues from being addressed while damaging trust between all parties. To overcome such fear-based patterns, we must first understand the science behind our reactions. When we feel threatened, our amygdala (the "primitive brain") triggers a cascade of stress hormones that prepare us for physical action rather than thoughtful conversation. Our hearing sharpens, pupils dilate, and blood flow diverts to our muscles—helpful for escaping predators but counterproductive for receiving constructive insights about our performance. Practical techniques can help manage this stress response. When you feel yourself getting caught in an emotional vortex, shift your attention to your body and senses for at least 10 seconds or three full breaths. Feel your feet flattened against the floor, notice the physical sensations in your body, or listen intently to the sounds around you. These simple practices engage your prefrontal cortex (the "wise brain"), making it impossible to remain in the primitive fear state. Another powerful approach is cultivating a growth mindset—the belief that abilities can be developed through dedication and hard work. Research by Dr. Carol Dweck found that individuals with a growth mindset embrace challenges, persist through setbacks, see effort as a path to mastery, learn from criticism, and find inspiration in others' success. When we shift from a fixed mindset ("I can't do this. I'm a failure") to a growth mindset ("I don't know how to do this yet"), we transform feedback from a threat to our identity into fuel for our development. The negativity bias—our tendency to give greater weight to negative experiences than positive ones—presents another challenge. Studies show we form negative opinions more rapidly, remember negative events longer, and process negative information more thoroughly than positive information. This explains why we might receive a stellar performance review but obsess over one minor criticism. The solution? For good to prevail over bad, it must win by numbers—hence the importance of the 5:1 ratio of positive to negative interactions. Practice makes perfect when it comes to overcoming feedback fear. Each time we engage in a challenging conversation with greater calm and self-awareness, we create neural pathways that allow for more positive responses in the future. Like any skill, receiving and extending feedback improves with repetition, gradually replacing old, suboptimal habits with healthier patterns of communication.

Summary

The journey to transform feedback from a source of fear to a catalyst for growth begins with a simple yet profound shift in perspective. When we redefine feedback as "clear and specific information that's sought or extended with the sole intention of helping individuals or groups improve, grow, or advance," we open the door to authentic connection and continuous development. As the authors remind us, "Light and easy, short and bite-size: that's the name of the extending game!" Your next step is refreshingly straightforward: choose one feedback practice to implement today. Perhaps you'll seek feedback from a trusted colleague on a specific skill you're developing, practice receiving without defensiveness the next time someone offers an observation, or extend appreciation to a team member with specific details about their contribution. By taking this first step, you join a movement that's transforming not just individual interactions but entire organizational cultures—creating environments where people feel safe being authentic, open about areas for growth, and consistently oriented toward a better future.

About Author

Loading...

M. Tamra Chandler

Read more