Fifth Sun

Fifth Sun Plot Summary

Introduction

In the heart of what is now Mexico City, a young Aztec woman once stood before her captors, refusing to bow even as flames licked at her feet. "I am the daughter of the lord of Chalco," she declared defiantly, "and through me, my lineage will continue!" This moment of extraordinary courage reveals much about the Aztec world—its complex political hierarchies, the centrality of lineage, and the fierce determination that characterized its people. The Aztecs were not simply the blood-soaked empire of popular imagination, but a sophisticated civilization with intricate social structures, profound artistic achievements, and a complex relationship with power. Through the lens of the Aztec experience, we witness one of history's most dramatic cultural collisions and transformations. From their emergence as a marginalized group to their rise as the dominant power in Mesoamerica, and finally to their adaptation under Spanish colonial rule, their story illuminates universal questions about how societies build power, how empires fall, and how conquered peoples preserve their identity even in the face of overwhelming change. This historical journey offers invaluable insights for anyone interested in understanding how civilizations rise, fall, and transform—and how human societies navigate the aftermath of conquest.

Chapter 1: Origins: Mexica Migration and Settlement (1200-1350)

The story of the Aztecs begins not with empire but with migration. In the early 1300s, the people who would later be known as the Aztecs—but who called themselves Mexica—arrived in the Valley of Mexico as outsiders, a semi-nomadic group seeking a place to settle. According to their own histories, they had journeyed from a place called Aztlan, guided by their patron deity Huitzilopochtli. The valley they entered was already home to established city-states, and the newcomers were initially forced to occupy marginal territories. In 1325, the Mexica founded Tenochtitlan on a small, swampy island in Lake Texcoco. This seemingly unpromising location would eventually become the heart of their empire. Their first ruler, Acamapichtli, who began his reign around 1375, established crucial political alliances through strategic marriages with women from prestigious lineages of neighboring cities. These connections gave the fledgling settlement legitimacy and protection. Under his leadership and that of his successors, the Mexica began transforming their island home, building chinampas (floating gardens) that provided agricultural abundance despite their limited territory. By the early 1400s, the Mexica had become vassals to the powerful city-state of Azcapotzalco, ruled by a formidable leader named Tezozomoc. This subordinate position required them to pay tribute and provide military service, but it also allowed them to learn the political and military systems of the region from the inside. When Tezozomoc died in 1426, his son Maxtla seized power, creating political instability throughout the valley. The Mexica ruler Chimalpopoca was killed in the ensuing power struggle, setting the stage for a dramatic shift in regional politics. The ascension of Itzcoatl as the new Mexica ruler in 1428 marked a crucial turning point. Forming an alliance with the exiled prince Nezahualcoyotl of Texcoco and the smaller city-state of Tlacopan, Itzcoatl led a successful rebellion against Azcapotzalco. After their victory, Itzcoatl took a remarkable step that would shape Aztec history forever: he ordered the burning of existing historical records and commissioned new ones that emphasized the Mexica's divine destiny to rule. This deliberate reshaping of historical memory helped transform the Mexica from marginal newcomers to rightful rulers in just one generation. The foundation of the Triple Alliance between Tenochtitlan, Texcoco, and Tlacopan in 1428 created the political structure that would eventually control much of Mesoamerica. Though often portrayed as equal partners, Tenochtitlan quickly became the dominant force. The Mexica had completed their remarkable journey from outsiders to rulers, establishing patterns of conquest, tribute collection, and political control that would define their expanding empire in the decades to come.

Chapter 2: Imperial Foundations: The Triple Alliance (1350-1450)

Following the defeat of Azcapotzalco in 1428, the Triple Alliance embarked on a period of rapid expansion that transformed the political landscape of central Mexico. Under the leadership of Itzcoatl (1428-1440) and his successor Moctezuma I (1440-1469), the Mexica-dominated alliance systematically conquered neighboring territories, creating an empire that stretched from the Gulf of Mexico to the Pacific coast. This was not merely territorial acquisition but the implementation of a sophisticated imperial system designed to extract wealth while maintaining political stability. The empire operated through a carefully calibrated balance of force and accommodation. Conquered territories were generally allowed to maintain their local rulers and customs, provided they acknowledged Aztec supremacy and delivered regular tribute payments. These payments included not only basic commodities like maize, beans, and cotton, but also luxury goods such as jade, gold, quetzal feathers, and cacao. The tribute system created vast wealth that flowed into Tenochtitlan, transforming it from a modest island settlement into a magnificent metropolis of stone temples, palaces, and bustling markets. Military expansion was accompanied by significant internal development. Moctezuma I initiated major infrastructure projects, including the construction of a massive dike to control flooding in Lake Texcoco and the expansion of the Great Temple complex at the heart of Tenochtitlan. These projects served practical purposes while simultaneously demonstrating Aztec power and reinforcing their cosmological worldview. The Great Temple, with its dual shrines to Huitzilopochtli (god of war) and Tlaloc (god of rain), physically embodied the twin foundations of Aztec imperial ideology: military conquest and agricultural abundance. The empire's growth was supported by an increasingly stratified social structure. The nobility (pipiltin) consolidated their control over land and resources, while commoners (macehualtin) provided labor and military service. A distinctive merchant class (pochteca) conducted long-distance trade and often served as imperial agents in distant territories. Religious specialists maintained the complex calendar of ceremonies that legitimized Aztec rule as divinely ordained. This social organization created pathways for limited social mobility while maintaining the overall hierarchical structure. By the 1460s, the empire faced new challenges as it pushed against the boundaries of powerful independent states like Tlaxcala and encountered resistance from more distant regions. The costs of maintaining imperial control grew, requiring ever more elaborate systems of administration and coercion. The empire responded by intensifying both its military campaigns and its ideological justifications for rule, including the practice of ritual sacrifice that has so captured the modern imagination. These practices, however, were embedded in a complex cosmological understanding that saw human sacrifice as necessary for maintaining cosmic balance and ensuring the sun's continued movement across the sky. The imperial system established during this period would continue to evolve, but its fundamental patterns—conquest, tribute collection, strategic alliance-building, and religious legitimation—remained the foundation of Aztec power until the Spanish arrival. The rapid transformation from a marginalized group to imperial power demonstrates both the remarkable adaptability of the Mexica and the effectiveness of their political, military, and ideological innovations.

Chapter 3: Tenochtitlan's Golden Age: Cultural Zenith (1450-1519)

The reign of Axayacatl marked a period of cultural flourishing even as the empire faced new military challenges. Ascending to the throne in 1468 at a young age, Axayacatl inherited an empire at its territorial peak. Under his rule, Tenochtitlan reached new heights of architectural splendor and artistic achievement, with the city's population swelling to perhaps 200,000 people, making it one of the largest urban centers in the world at that time. The island metropolis, connected to the mainland by three great causeways, dazzled visitors with its orderly grid of canals, towering temples, and bustling marketplaces. Axayacatl continued the empire's military expansion, but with mixed results. His conquest of neighboring Tlatelolco in 1473 eliminated the last independent enclave within the island and brought its magnificent marketplace under direct Mexica control. However, his ambitious campaign against the Purépecha (Tarascans) to the west ended in a devastating defeat—the first major military setback for the expanding empire. This failure revealed the limits of Aztec military power and created a western frontier that would remain contested until the Spanish arrival. Despite these military challenges, Axayacatl's reign witnessed remarkable cultural achievements. The famous Calendar Stone (often mistakenly called the "Aztec Calendar"), a massive basalt monolith depicting the cosmos and history of the world according to Aztec cosmology, was commissioned during this period. Poetry and song flourished, with rulers and nobles competing to compose the most moving verses. One surviving poem attributed to Axayacatl himself reveals the philosophical depth of Aztec thought: "We only come to sleep, we only come to dream. It is not true, it is not true that we come to live on earth." Daily life in Tenochtitlan during this cultural apex reflected the empire's complex social organization. Children received education appropriate to their social station—noble children attended specialized schools (calmecac) that prepared them for leadership roles, while commoner children learned practical skills at the telpochcalli (youth houses). Women managed households, traded in markets, worked as midwives and healers, and participated in religious ceremonies, though they were largely excluded from formal political power. The city's specialized craftspeople produced extraordinary works of art, from intricate featherwork to sophisticated goldsmithing. Religion permeated every aspect of Aztec life during this period. The ritual calendar dictated a continuous cycle of ceremonies honoring different deities, from Huitzilopochtli (the Mexica patron god of war) to Tlaloc (god of rain) to Quetzalcoatl (the feathered serpent associated with knowledge and priesthood). These ceremonies ranged from simple offerings of food and flowers to elaborate processions and, yes, human sacrifice—though modern scholarship has increasingly questioned the exaggerated numbers reported by Spanish sources. These religious practices were not merely expressions of bloodthirstiness, as later European accounts would claim, but reflected a sophisticated cosmology in which human action was necessary to maintain the balance of the universe. By the time of Axayacatl's death in 1486, the Aztec Empire had reached a crucial juncture. Its cultural achievements were unparalleled, but the military setbacks and growing resistance from subject peoples suggested that the imperial system was under strain. His successors would face the challenge of maintaining an increasingly complex political structure in the face of mounting internal and external pressures—a challenge that would ultimately be interrupted by the arrival of strangers from across the sea.

Chapter 4: Conquest and Collision: Spanish Invasion (1519-1521)

When Spanish ships appeared on the horizon in 1519, the Aztec Empire was ruled by Moctezuma II, a leader known for his religious devotion and political caution. Reports of strange bearded men in floating mountains had reached him years earlier, but nothing had prepared him for the reality of Hernán Cortés and his expedition of about 500 Spaniards. Moctezuma faced an unprecedented diplomatic challenge: how to respond to visitors who fit into no existing category of his political world. Contrary to popular myths about Aztecs mistaking Spaniards for gods, Moctezuma's initial strategy was pragmatic. He sent emissaries with lavish gifts to assess the strangers while simultaneously preparing defensive positions. When these diplomatic overtures failed to turn the Spaniards away, Moctezuma reluctantly invited them to Tenochtitlan, hoping to better understand their intentions and capabilities. The Spanish arrival in November 1519 brought two radically different worlds face to face. The Spaniards were awestruck by the magnificent island city, which Bernal Díaz del Castillo compared to "an enchanted vision from the tale of Amadís." The situation deteriorated rapidly. Within weeks, Cortés took the audacious step of taking Moctezuma hostage, using him as a puppet ruler. This precarious arrangement collapsed in May 1520 when, during Cortés's temporary absence, his lieutenant Pedro de Alvarado ordered a massacre of Aztec nobles during a religious festival. The enraged population rose up, forcing the Spaniards to flee during what became known as the Noche Triste (Sad Night). The Spaniards suffered heavy casualties as they fought their way out of the city, but enough survived to regroup with their indigenous allies. The most powerful of these allies were the Tlaxcalans, longtime enemies of the Aztecs who saw in the Spanish arrival an opportunity to overthrow their hated rivals. Other subject peoples and disaffected groups within the empire also joined the Spanish cause, providing crucial manpower, supplies, and local knowledge. Without these indigenous allies, who ultimately numbered in the tens of thousands, the Spanish conquest would have been impossible. This reality complicates the simple narrative of European technological superiority often used to explain the empire's fall. The final siege of Tenochtitlan began in May 1521, with Cortés commanding a combined force of Spaniards and indigenous allies. The new Aztec emperor, Cuauhtémoc, organized a fierce defense, but the city faced overwhelming odds. The Spaniards cut off the causeways and aqueducts, while their indigenous allies prevented food from reaching the increasingly desperate population. Spanish brigantines controlled the lake, preventing canoe traffic. Most devastatingly, smallpox—introduced by the Europeans—had swept through the city months earlier, killing many defenders and undermining morale. Despite these disadvantages, the Aztecs fought street by street, forcing the invaders to destroy much of the city they hoped to capture. After 75 days of brutal fighting, with food and water exhausted and much of the city in ruins, Cuauhtémoc finally surrendered on August 13, 1521. The magnificent capital of the Aztec Empire had fallen, and with it, indigenous political sovereignty in central Mexico. The Spanish victory, however, was not simply the triumph of European arms over indigenous resistance, but the result of a complex political realignment that exploited existing tensions within the Mesoamerican world.

Chapter 5: Colonial Adaptation: Indigenous Survival Strategies (1521-1600)

The immediate aftermath of conquest brought devastation to the indigenous population of central Mexico. Beyond the direct casualties of war, European diseases swept through communities with no prior exposure or immunity. Smallpox, measles, and typhus killed millions in successive waves of epidemics, with the population declining by as much as 90 percent over the century following contact. This demographic catastrophe fundamentally altered the social and economic landscape, creating labor shortages and abandoned lands that Spanish colonizers would exploit. Spanish colonial rule was established through the encomienda system, which granted Spanish conquistadors the right to demand labor and tribute from indigenous communities. While technically different from slavery, this system imposed heavy burdens on native populations already devastated by disease and displacement. The first generation of encomenderos often ruled with brutal efficiency, extracting maximum wealth with little concern for indigenous welfare. In Tenochtitlan, renamed Mexico City, the Spaniards built their new capital directly atop the Aztec ceremonial center, using stones from demolished temples to construct churches and government buildings. Despite these traumas, indigenous communities demonstrated remarkable resilience and adaptability. The altepetl (city-state) remained the basic unit of indigenous social organization, with traditional noble families often maintaining leadership positions as gobernadores within the Spanish colonial system. These indigenous elites became crucial intermediaries, negotiating between Spanish demands and community needs. They learned Spanish legal procedures and used the colonial courts to defend community lands and rights, sometimes successfully challenging Spanish abuses. Religious transformation was central to the colonial experience. Franciscan, Dominican, and Augustinian friars established missions throughout central Mexico, baptizing millions and building hundreds of churches. Yet this was not simply a matter of European imposition. Indigenous people actively engaged with Christianity, interpreting it through their own cultural frameworks and incorporating elements that resonated with pre-existing beliefs. The famous apparition of the Virgin of Guadalupe to Juan Diego in 1531 (whether historical or legendary) symbolized this religious synthesis, with the dark-skinned Virgin appearing on a hill previously associated with the goddess Tonantzin. Economic life was transformed through the introduction of European crops, animals, and technologies. Wheat, cattle, horses, and metal tools changed agricultural practices, while new industries like silk production and sugar refining created alternative livelihoods. Indigenous craftspeople adapted their skills to new markets, producing hybrid art forms that combined European and Mesoamerican aesthetics. In urban areas, native artisans organized into guilds, producing paintings, sculptures, and textiles that served both Spanish and indigenous patrons. By the end of the sixteenth century, a new colonial society had emerged from the ruins of the Aztec Empire. This society was hierarchical, with Spaniards at the top and indigenous commoners at the bottom, but it also contained complex gradations based on ancestry, wealth, and occupation. The "Republic of Indians" existed alongside the "Republic of Spaniards" in a system of legal separation that nonetheless experienced constant cultural exchange. Indigenous communities maintained distinct identities while adapting to colonial realities, preserving elements of their heritage even as they incorporated European influences. This pattern of cultural persistence amid transformation would continue to characterize indigenous experience throughout the colonial period.

Chapter 6: Cultural Persistence: Nahua Identity Through Annals (1600-1700)

The seventeenth century witnessed a remarkable phenomenon across central Mexico: the flourishing of indigenous historical writing. Despite continued population decline, economic hardship, and increasing pressure to assimilate into Spanish colonial society, Nahua communities invested significant resources in creating and maintaining historical records known as annals (xiuhpohualli). These year-by-year accounts documented local events, weather patterns, political leadership changes, and religious celebrations, creating an unbroken narrative thread connecting present communities to their pre-conquest past. Don Domingo de San Antón Muñón Chimalpahin Quauhtlehuanitzin exemplifies this tradition of indigenous scholarship. Born into a noble family from Chalco around 1579, Chimalpahin moved to Mexico City as a young man and became caretaker of the church of San Antonio Abad. In his spare time, he produced an extraordinary body of historical writing, including eight "relations" covering the history of central Mexican peoples from mythical origins to his own time. Chimalpahin's work demonstrates sophisticated engagement with both Nahua and European historical traditions. He consulted pre-conquest pictorial manuscripts, interviewed elders about oral traditions, studied Spanish chronicles, and incorporated biblical chronology into his understanding of the past. His writings reveal a scholar deeply committed to preserving indigenous historical memory while making sense of the profound transformations of his era. Across the central Mexican landscape, similar historical projects were underway in communities large and small. In Tlaxcala, Don Juan Buenaventura Zapata y Mendoza compiled extensive annals recording both local events and broader colonial developments. In the Puebla-Tlaxcala region, anonymous scribes maintained community records that blended pre-conquest historical genres with European influences. These texts served multiple purposes: they legitimized the authority of indigenous governing councils, documented land rights, preserved ritual knowledge, and maintained connections to ancestral traditions in a rapidly changing world. The content of these annals reveals the complex reality of indigenous life in seventeenth-century New Spain. They record natural disasters, epidemics, and economic hardships alongside moments of community celebration and achievement. They document tensions between indigenous communities and Spanish authorities, particularly around labor demands and tribute collection. They also reveal internal community conflicts, as traditional nobility struggled to maintain authority in the face of demographic collapse and colonial pressures. Yet throughout these challenges, the annals demonstrate a persistent sense of community identity rooted in shared history and territory. Religious life as portrayed in these texts reflects the emergence of a distinctly indigenous Catholicism. The annals meticulously record the construction and renovation of churches, the celebration of Catholic feast days, and the activities of religious confraternities. Yet they often describe these Christian practices using conceptual frameworks derived from pre-conquest religious traditions. Saints' days were celebrated with elements reminiscent of pre-conquest festivals, including elaborate dances, communal meals, and processions that reinforced community bonds. Church construction became a focus of community pride and identity, much as temple-building had been in the pre-conquest era. By maintaining these historical records, Nahua communities accomplished something remarkable: they created a continuous narrative of their existence that spanned the conquest divide. Rather than accepting Spanish characterizations of pre-conquest society as purely "pagan" and "barbaric," they insisted on their own understanding of the past and its connection to the present. This historical consciousness provided a foundation for indigenous identity that could incorporate Catholic beliefs and Spanish political structures while maintaining distinctive cultural patterns and community autonomy. The annals tradition would continue into the eighteenth century, providing an invaluable window into how indigenous peoples understood their place in colonial society and their connection to ancestral traditions.

Chapter 7: Modern Legacy: Aztec Heritage in Mexican Identity

The legacy of Aztec civilization extends far beyond the colonial period, profoundly shaping Mexican national identity from independence to the present day. When Mexico achieved independence from Spain in 1821, the new nation sought symbols that could unite its diverse population and distinguish it from its colonial past. The Aztec eagle and serpent emblem was adopted for the national flag, and Aztec imagery appeared on coins, monuments, and official documents. This appropriation of indigenous symbolism, however, often occurred alongside policies that marginalized living indigenous communities, creating a paradox that continues to this day: the glorification of the pre-Hispanic past alongside the struggle for rights and recognition by contemporary indigenous peoples. The Mexican Revolution (1910-1920) marked a turning point in how the nation engaged with its indigenous heritage. Revolutionary leaders like Emiliano Zapata, himself of Nahua descent, mobilized indigenous communities with promises of land reform and cultural autonomy. In the revolution's aftermath, the cultural movement known as indigenismo celebrated Mexico's indigenous roots through art, literature, and education. Muralists like Diego Rivera created monumental works depicting Aztec history and mythology, while archaeologists excavated and restored sites like the Templo Mayor in the heart of Mexico City. Public education emphasized the achievements of pre-Hispanic civilizations, creating a narrative of national identity that positioned modern Mexico as the inheritor of both indigenous and European traditions. This national embrace of Aztec heritage has been complicated by growing indigenous activism since the late 20th century. The Zapatista uprising in Chiapas in 1994 (named after revolutionary leader Emiliano Zapata) highlighted the continued marginalization of indigenous communities despite official celebration of indigenous heritage. Indigenous scholars and activists have increasingly challenged non-indigenous interpretations of their history and culture, insisting on their right to control their own historical narrative. This has led to significant reevaluation of sources and perspectives in academic studies of Aztec civilization, with greater attention to indigenous-authored texts and indigenous viewpoints. Contemporary Nahua communities, numbering over 1.5 million speakers, have experienced a cultural renaissance in recent decades. Nahuatl language revitalization programs have been established in various regions, and Nahua writers, artists, and scholars have created works that engage with their cultural heritage on their own terms. Some have created Nahuatl-language literature, theater, and poetry, while others have focused on recovering traditional ecological knowledge, agricultural practices, and healing traditions. These efforts represent not simply preservation of the past but creative engagement with cultural heritage in response to contemporary challenges. The archaeological legacy of the Aztecs continues to yield new discoveries that reshape our understanding of this civilization. The ongoing excavation of the Templo Mayor, accidentally discovered by electrical workers in 1978, has revealed extraordinary artifacts and insights into Aztec religious practices and imperial ideology. Each new finding generates public excitement and scholarly debate, demonstrating the continued relevance of Aztec studies to understanding Mexico's past and present. Today, the Aztec legacy exists in countless aspects of Mexican life: in place names and language, in cuisine and agricultural practices, in art and architecture, and in deeply held cultural values regarding community, family, and relationship to the natural world. This living heritage represents neither a museum piece frozen in time nor a romanticized myth, but rather a dynamic cultural tradition that continues to evolve through the creative engagement of those who claim it as their inheritance. As one Nahuatl poet suggested, perhaps we have now entered the era of the Sixth Sun—a new age of indigenous cultural revitalization and self-determination built upon the foundations of the past.

Summary

The arc of Aztec history reveals a civilization defined by remarkable adaptability and resilience. From their humble beginnings as marginalized newcomers to the Valley of Mexico, through their meteoric rise to imperial dominance, and finally in their complex adaptations to Spanish colonization, the Aztecs and their descendants demonstrated an extraordinary capacity to navigate changing circumstances while maintaining core elements of their identity. The central tension throughout this history was between centralized power and local autonomy—a tension visible in the empire's relationship with conquered peoples and later in indigenous communities' negotiations with Spanish colonial authorities. This dynamic process of adaptation without complete assimilation challenges simplistic narratives of conquest and cultural extinction. The Aztec experience offers profound insights for our understanding of how societies respond to catastrophic change. Rather than seeing the Spanish conquest as an absolute endpoint, we can recognize the ways indigenous communities preserved cultural memory and agency even under colonial domination. This perspective encourages us to look beyond dramatic moments of historical rupture to examine the continuous processes of negotiation, resistance, and creative adaptation that characterize human societies under pressure. It reminds us that cultural survival often depends not on rigid preservation of tradition but on strategic flexibility and the ability to incorporate new elements while maintaining core values and social structures. In our own era of rapid global change and cultural contact, the Aztec legacy suggests that resilience comes not from isolation but from engagement that maintains a strong sense of identity amid transformation.

About Author

Loading...

Camilla Townsend

Camilla Townsend (Ph.D., Rutgers University) is professor of history at Rutgers University (New Brunswick, NJ). Her special interest is in the relations between indigenous peoples and Europeans throughout the Americas.

Read more