Fooling Houdini

Fooling Houdini Plot Summary

Introduction

The sound of applause filled the auditorium as the magician stepped onto the stage. His hands moved with grace and precision, cards dancing between his fingers like living creatures with minds of their own. The audience gasped as a selected card vanished, only to reappear moments later inside a sealed envelope. What appeared supernatural was actually a beautiful blend of psychology, mathematics, and thousands of hours of practice – a symphony of deception that left viewers both delighted and baffled. Magic has always inhabited that curious space between art and science, illusion and reality. It's a world where skilled practitioners manipulate our perceptions so effectively that we willingly surrender to the impossible. But what happens when someone attempts to cross from casual hobbyist to professional magician? What secrets lie behind the curtain of this ancient art form? This journey into the underground community of magic reveals not just how tricks are performed, but how our minds work, how we perceive reality, and ultimately, how easily we can be fooled. Through one person's quest to master this craft, we discover that magic is far more than mere entertainment – it's a window into human psychology, a laboratory for studying perception, and a path to understanding the hidden powers of the mind.

Chapter 1: The Magic Olympics: A Humbling Beginning

Stockholm, Sweden. The lobby of a grand hotel buzzed with activity as magicians from around the world gathered for the 2006 World Championships of Magic – the Magic Olympics. A stunning young Belgian woman attracted a small crowd as she transformed cards in her hands – aces became kings, kings became queens, queens became jacks, and jacks became tens. With each graceful motion, the audience's excitement grew. Nearby, others performed their own miracles: shell games, extreme card manipulations, mentalism acts. The author stood in awe, clutching a worn deck of blue Bicycle cards, drinking in the scene. For the author, getting into the Magic Olympics had been something of a miracle itself. To be eligible, one must belong to one of the eighty-seven magic societies sanctioned by the Fédération Internationale des Sociétés Magiques (FISM) and obtain written authorization from the society's president. Despite never having competed in any tournament before, the author had secured approval from Richard M. Dooley, president of the Society of American Magicians. The competition itself proved to be a crushing experience. Standing before an audience of nearly a thousand people, including television crews and reporters from around the world, the author froze. His hands trembled with nervousness, causing him to drop a coin. His carefully practiced card manipulations unraveled as stage fright took over. When he accidentally moved his hands below the table – violating a fundamental rule of close-up magic – the Spanish judge waved for him to stop. "That will be all," he said flatly. "It's over." The author hadn't just lost; he'd been red-lighted in the middle of his act – a rare and humiliating form of elimination. Weeks later, on the flight home, the author reflected on his experience. Before the Magic Olympics, he had thought himself a fairly competent magician. Now he realized he'd only been fooling himself. His tricks were derivative and impractical. As one online commentator succinctly put it, they were "crap." Unlike master magician Lennart Green, who had once been wrongly disqualified at a previous Olympics only to return and win gold with the same routine, the author had been eliminated because he was genuinely bad. He had no business trying to pass himself off as a world-class magician. The experience left him wounded and humiliated, shattering not only his dignity but also his will to perform. Though painful to admit, he knew his love affair with magic was over. Like any long-term relationship that abruptly ends, this breakup was fraught with heartache. Magic and he were parting company, and the breakup had not been mutual. He'd been cruelly, callously, and unceremoniously dumped. Yet sometimes our greatest failures become the catalysts for extraordinary transformations. This humbling defeat would mark not the end of a journey, but rather its true beginning – the first step toward understanding that mastering magic requires far more than learning a few tricks. It demands discipline, psychological insight, and a willingness to journey into the mysterious realms where science, art, and deception converge.

Chapter 2: Mystery School: Learning from Masters

Two months after the Stockholm disaster, the author's personal life took another hit when his girlfriend announced she was moving to Venezuela. By October, she was gone, and he was alone with his misery. The following spring brought good news in the form of acceptance to a PhD program in physics at Columbia University – a field he'd long been interested in but hadn't initially pursued. While physics offered intellectual stimulation, studying the cosmos couldn't fill the void left by his magical aspirations. Gradually, the magic virus that had infected him since childhood began stirring again. Eventually, he worked up the nerve to attend a gathering of the Society of American Magicians (SAM). To his surprise, nobody mentioned his Olympic failure. If anything, the chutzpah he'd shown in competing seemed to have earned him some respect. This encouraged him to return to Tannen's, New York's oldest magic store, where he observed teenagers performing card manipulations with remarkable speed and skill. The author's renewed interest in magic led him to Las Vegas for a three-day master class at McBride's Magic and Mystery School. The school's founder, Jeff McBride, was one of the world's top professional magicians, known for his exotic outfits and love of masks. McBride's home – dubbed the McBride House of Mystery – was adorned with scrolls, New Age artifacts, and masks from around the world. The workshop began with participants gathering around a flame and taking a vow of secrecy. During the class, the author performed one of the tricks he'd attempted at the Magic Olympics. After he finished, McBride put his hand on the author's shoulder and delivered a gentle critique: "It's a great effect, but a bad method." The sight lines were flawed, the handling convoluted. The trick was beyond repair. Moreover, McBride's feedback revealed the author's deeper issues as a performer: he lacked stage presence and a coherent persona, ad-libbed his patter, had remedial card-handling skills, and exposed his moves through poor technique. McBride explained that magicians progress through four developmental stages: Trickster, Sorcerer, Oracle, and Sage. The Trickster is the impish beginner who uses magic to overcome shyness and build self-esteem. The Sorcerer is disciplined and technically skilled. The Oracle explores the psychology of magic. Finally, the Sage passes wisdom to the next generation. The author realized he was still a Trickster, having made no meaningful growth since he started doing magic years ago. The journey from magical novice to master isn't merely about accumulating techniques – it's about finding mentors who can guide your development. "In order to go from Trickster to Sorcerer you need a master," McBride explained. "The question you need to ask yourself is 'Who's your Yoda?'" Convinced that finding a sensei was his ticket to advancement, the author set out to find a mentor in New York City. When he canvassed local magicians for recommendations, the answer always came back the same: "Just hang around Wes." This wisdom points to a universal truth about mastery in any domain: technical knowledge alone isn't enough. True growth requires guidance from those who have walked the path before us. The author's quest for magical mastery was becoming a metaphor for the deeper human need to connect with wisdom traditions through personal relationships with genuine masters who can illuminate the way forward.

Chapter 3: The Psychology of Deception

Wesley James was a grizzled sleight-of-hand master who virtually lived at a grimy pizza parlor near Herald Square in Manhattan. With what remained of his silver hair clinging to his temples and falling down his back in a yard-long Manchu queue, Wes looked older than his nearly seventy years. But his hands moved with the elegance of a concert pianist's, preserved, it seemed, at the expense of the rest of his body. When the author first approached Wes at Rustico II pizzeria, he was showing Jack Diamond an obscure "hand mucking" technique – a diabolical way to switch cards during poker. Attempting to impress Wes, the author executed a spread pass, a move for transposing two halves of a deck. "You're flashing," Wes immediately pointed out, indicating that the author's thumb position was a dead giveaway. Still trying to make an impression, the author produced his newly purchased copy of S. W. Erdnase's "The Expert at the Card Table," the card cheater's bible. Unimpressed, Wes simply stated: "There are fifteen mistakes in Erdnase. Eight that are universally acknowledged, four more that only a few people know of, and three that only I know about." The ice began to thaw when the author pulled out his physics textbook. Science became their common ground, leading to discussions about quantum mechanics, card counting, the mathematics of shuffling, and deck memorization. Pivoting from physics, the author mentioned that his Ambitious Card routine drew on quantum physics concepts. Wes seemed to like the idea but criticized the author's technique, reshaping his hand position and coaching him through proper execution. After hours of practice, something clicked – like a dead bolt latching into place. "Yes," Wes said with the first hint of excitement. "That's it! You've got it!" Under Wes's guidance, the author learned the classic gambling sleights: false cuts, rigged shuffles, crooked deals, glimpsing cards, and various card switches. These techniques, refined over decades, power high-stakes hustles worldwide. "What we're doing here is very ancient and very tribal," Jeff McBride had said during a magic gathering. Indeed, the connection between magic and gambling runs deep, with many great masters honing their skills in the underground gambling world. Magic, after all, is cheating for amusement. After learning these techniques, the author experienced their power firsthand during a poker game with friends. He secretly executed second deals and false shuffles throughout the night – not to cheat but to see if the moves would "fly" undetected. No one noticed. Though he didn't benefit from these moves financially, the experience gave him an incredible rush. "There's something deeply liberating about letting go of the reins that couple cause and effect," he reflected. The psychology behind these deceptions reveals something fundamental about human nature. Whether in magic, gambling, or everyday life, our perception is filtered through expectations, and our attention is more limited than we realize. The best deceivers don't rely on speed but on misdirection – controlling where we focus. By understanding these psychological principles, magicians can make the impossible seem real, gamblers can extract money from marks, and ordinary people can gain insight into how easily we can all be manipulated. Perhaps this explains why many scientists are drawn to magic and many magicians to science – both fields appeal to those who, as Victorian magician John Nevil Maskelyne noted, "take an interest in mysteries."

Chapter 4: Mathematics Behind the Magic

The author's investigation of magic's mathematical foundations led him to the Conjuring Arts Research Center, one of the world's largest magic libraries, hidden in a nondescript building on West Thirtieth Street in New York. Inside this windowless sanctuary decorated with heavy oak furniture, skulls, and display cases of magical artifacts, he sought obscure publications that might contain forgotten secrets. His quest began after attending a lecture by David Bayer, a Columbia University mathematics professor who had served as Russell Crowe's hand double in the film "A Beautiful Mind." During the lecture, Bayer demonstrated a remarkable card trick: after allowing the author to shuffle a deck three times, Bayer could still identify a randomly selected card. The secret lay in the mathematics of shuffling – particularly in the surprising fact that shuffling cards doesn't randomize them as effectively as most people think. In 1992, Bayer and renowned mathematician Persi Diaconis published groundbreaking research on card shuffling. Their paper, "Trailing the Dovetail Shuffle to Its Lair," revealed that it takes an average of seven riffle shuffles to thoroughly mix a deck of cards – far more than the three or four shuffles standard in casinos at that time. Before their work, nobody knew exactly how many shuffles were required, and casinos were vulnerable to skilled players who could exploit the persistent lack of randomness. The mathematics behind this discovery is fascinating. When you riffle shuffle once, you split the deck into two halves and interleave them. This creates at most two "rising sequences" – consecutive runs of cards in ascending order. Each additional shuffle at most doubles the number of rising sequences. After three shuffles, there are at most eight rising sequences, making it possible for a knowledgeable observer to track displaced cards. Even more striking was the discovery that randomization isn't a gradual process but occurs suddenly through what mathematicians call a "phase transition." There's little appreciable difference between one shuffle and five, but around the seventh shuffle, the cards rapidly become mixed. The randomness suddenly congeals, like water freezing at exactly zero degrees Celsius. Inspired by this research, the author developed an original card trick using a mathematical principle called a De Bruijn sequence – a special arrangement where every possible subsequence of a given length appears exactly once. By memorizing a deck arranged according to this pattern, he could perform a miracle: a deck would be tossed into the audience, six people would select cards, and by merely asking which people had black cards versus red cards, he could name all six selections with absolute certainty. To memorize the complex sequence, the author learned the "method of loci" from memory champion Joshua Foer. This ancient technique involves creating a "memory palace" – an imaginary space where information is stored as vivid images along a familiar path. Using his childhood home as his palace, the author placed distinctive images representing each card at different locations throughout the house. This allowed him to recall the entire deck's order and track which cards corresponded to which color patterns. Mathematics and magic share a rich historical connection. The earliest recorded magic tricks appear in a fifteenth-century book written by a Tuscan mathematician who was friends with Leonardo da Vinci. For centuries, magic and science were viewed as parallel paths to wisdom. Newton wrote extensively about the occult while developing the laws of physics. Leibniz, co-inventor of calculus, began as an alchemist. The father of modern magic, Jean-Eugène Robert-Houdin, was an accomplished scientist who conducted early experiments in electromagnetism. This beautiful intersection of mathematics and magic reveals that behind the most astonishing illusions often lie elegant principles that, when understood, make the universe itself seem more magical. As Arthur C. Clarke famously observed, "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic" – a saying that applies equally to the extraordinary capabilities of the mathematically trained human mind.

Chapter 5: The Ethics of Illusion

One winter evening, during a gathering at a friend's apartment, the author performed a routine where he appeared to read a woman's mind. Using techniques of "cold reading" – employing Barnum statements, fishing for clues, and psychological insights – he convinced her that he knew intimate details about a person she had written on a slip of paper. "George is still with you," he told her as tears filled her eyes. "And he misses you too." The secret to this illusion was simple: he'd secretly glimpsed the name using a technique called a center tear while pretending to destroy the paper. This experience opened a moral quandary that lies at the heart of mentalism – the branch of magic that includes mind reading, fortune telling, and communing with the dead. Unlike conventional magic tricks, mentalism often leaves audiences believing the performer possesses genuine supernatural powers. While card tricks elicit wonder, mentalism can evoke tears, accusations of spying, or even declarations of love. "That's not magic," one woman had told the author after seeing a card trick. "Show me some real magic." To learn more about this powerful form of deception, the author attended MINDvention, the world's largest mentalism convention, in Las Vegas. There, the ethical debates were passionate. "As soon as you give a disclaimer, you devalue what you're doing," argued one performer who claimed to communicate with the dead. Others cautioned restraint: "The stuff that we dabble in is incredibly powerful. A lot of people are desperate to believe." The divide between ethical and unethical practices in mentalism often comes down to honesty about one's methods. Professional magicians who use mentalism techniques as entertainment might be considered "honest liars" – they deceive through their tricks but don't claim supernatural powers. In contrast, those who exploit these same techniques to promote false beliefs or profit from people's grief might be called "dishonest liars" – a category that includes some TV psychics, faith healers, and cult leaders. This ethical dilemma isn't new. Before becoming a famous escape artist, Houdini traveled as a spirit medium, offering to connect people with dead relatives. He would scout local cemeteries beforehand for information on the deceased. Years later, he looked back with shame on this period and dedicated himself to exposing fraudulent mediums with religious fervor. The line between entertainment and exploitation has always been thin in the world of illusion. The author himself confronted these issues when he published an article in Harper's magazine that exposed some magical methods. The response from the magic community was swift and severe. He received a certified letter from the Society of American Magicians demanding his resignation for violating their code of ethics. "I had signed an oath," he acknowledged. Local magicians refused to speak to him. One confronted him on the street: "You're just a loose cannon, and it's really dangerous." Despite this backlash, the author came to believe that exposure doesn't threaten magic as much as many practitioners fear. Throughout history, magicians have routinely exposed one another's methods, driving innovation. Penn and Teller often reveal secrets in their shows, only to fool audiences with the same effects done differently. Magic, it seems, is about more than just knowing the secret – it's about the experience of wonder that transcends explanation. The ethical questions surrounding magic mirror larger societal tensions between secrecy and transparency, tradition and innovation, protection and freedom. They remind us that deception, while powerful, carries responsibility – and that the greatest magic may lie not in hiding truth but in revealing how beautifully complex our perception of reality can be.

Chapter 6: Finding My Voice as a Performer

As the author's obsession with magic intensified, it began bleeding into every aspect of his life. His physics studies at Columbia suffered as he devoted more time to practicing sleights and attending magic gatherings. "I just hope I live long enough to see you get your PhD," his father lamented. Even his relationships were affected. "It's annoying and I asked you to stop and you wouldn't," screamed a girlfriend after he persisted in practicing card moves during their date. Friends would only agree to go out with him if he promised not to do card tricks the entire time. The transformation was both internal and external. He started dressing differently – earrings, a leather cuff, a ring on his right forefinger (that doubled as a prop). He developed an impressive repertoire of effects: he could visibly penetrate a balloon with a cell phone, pass a quarter through a bottle, make a dollar appear inside a lemon, shoot fireballs from his hands, and execute the spin change he'd seen the Belgian girl perform at the Magic Olympics. Despite these technical advances, something was still missing – an authentic voice as a performer. A breakthrough came when he met Kate, an actress who eventually became both his girlfriend and acting coach. She showed him how to block out an act, find his light, and project onstage. When he considered expensive courses in elaborate sleight-of-hand techniques, Kate provided crucial insight: "That's not you. You're a goofy physics geek. Your magic should reflect that." This simple observation pointed toward a fundamental truth about performance: authenticity matters more than technical flash. The author began connecting his magic to his background in physics and mathematics. Through research at the Columbia library and consultation with mathematician David Bayer, he developed an original routine based on the mathematics of card shuffling and a principle called a De Bruijn sequence. The effect was astounding: after a deck was tossed into the audience and six people selected cards, he could name all six selections by merely asking who had black cards versus red cards. For his finale, he created an even more powerful effect using the perfect "faro shuffle" – a technique where cards are divided exactly in half and perfectly interwoven. After eight perfect faro shuffles, a deck returns to its original order. By exploiting this mathematical property, he created an illusion where blue markings on the edges of cards would rearrange themselves to spell out both a freely selected card and a secretly written name. The effect combined technical skill, mathematical principles, and theatrical presentation into something uniquely his own. The author's journey culminated in a performance at the IBM Gold Cups, the most prestigious annual close-up competition in the world. Although he didn't win, he succeeded in facing his fears and proving he could compete at a high level. More importantly, when former Magic Olympics judge Obie O'Brien – the very man who had red-lighted him years earlier – walked into the room during his performance, the author maintained his composure and delivered his best performance yet. Afterward, O'Brien even smiled at him – a small gesture that represented enormous personal growth. Through this journey from humiliated novice to competent performer, the author discovered that finding one's voice in magic – or in any creative pursuit – isn't about mimicking others or mastering every technique. It's about identifying your unique strengths and building upon them authentically. As clown instructor Christopher Bayes had told him: "Try to proceed with a kind of playful integrity... We see this little gift that you brought for us, which is the gift of your truth. Not an idea of your truth, but the gift of your real truth. And you can play forever with that, because it's infinite."

Summary

The journey through the secretive world of magic reveals far more than just how tricks are performed – it illuminates fundamental truths about human perception, learning, and authenticity. From the humbling experience of public failure to the gradual mastery of complex skills under expert guidance, we witness how dedication to any craft can transform not just our abilities but our very identity. The magician's path mirrors our own struggles to find authenticity in a world filled with illusion and deception. Perhaps the most powerful lesson is that true mastery in any domain requires a balance of technical skill, psychological understanding, and personal authenticity. Just as the author discovered that his unique background in physics gave him a distinctive magical voice, we too must recognize that our greatest strengths often lie in embracing what makes us different rather than trying to conform to others' expectations. Whether in magic, career, relationships, or personal growth, finding your authentic expression is the ultimate transformation. As physicist Richard Feynman discovered when he turned a mundane observation about a wobbling plate into Nobel Prize-winning work, our most meaningful breakthroughs often come when we approach life with playful curiosity rather than rigid seriousness. In the end, magic – like life itself – is less about fooling others than about the journey of discovering your own unique powers of creation and connection.

About Author

Loading...

Alex Stone

There is more than one author with this nameWhen Alex Stone was five years old, his father bought him a magic kit—a gift that would spark a lifelong love. Years later, while living in New York City, he discovered a vibrant underground magic scene exploding with creativity and innovation and populated by a fascinating cast of characters: from his gruff mentor, who holds court in the back of a rundown pizza shop, to one of the world’s greatest card cheats, who also happens to be blind. Captivated, he plunged headlong into this mysterious world, eventually competing at the Magic Olympics and training with great magicians around the globe to perfect his craft.From the back rooms of New York City’s century-old magic societies to cutting-edge psychology labs; three-card monte on Canal Street to glossy Las Vegas casinos; Fooling Houdini recounts Alex Stone’s quest to join the ranks of master magicians. As he navigates this quirky and occasionally hilarious subculture, Stone pulls back the curtain on a community shrouded in secrecy, fueled by obsession and brilliance, and organized around a single overriding need: to prove one’s worth by deceiving others. But his journey is more than a tale of tricks, gigs, and geeks. In trying to understand how expert magicians manipulate our minds to create their astonishing illusions, Stone uncovers a wealth of insight into human nature and the nature of perception. Every turn leads to questions about how the mind perceives the world and processes everyday experiences. By investigating some of the lesser-known corners of psychology, neuroscience, physics, history, and even crime, all through the lens of trickery and illusion, Fooling Houdini arrives at a host of startling revelations about how the mind works—and why, sometimes, it doesn’t.Alex Stone has written for Harper’s, Discover, Science, and the Wall Street Journal. He graduated from Harvard University with a degree in English and has a masters degree in physics from Columbia University. He grew up in Wisconsin, Texas, and Spain. He currently lives in New York City.

Read more