Good Boundaries and Goodbyes

Good Boundaries and Goodbyes Plot Summary

Introduction

I was sitting at a coffee shop when I noticed her – a woman about my age, clutching her phone with white knuckles, tears streaming down her face. She kept looking at the screen, then setting it down, only to pick it up again moments later. I recognized that look – the painful dance of wanting to respond to someone who keeps pulling you back into a relationship that's slowly draining your spirit. Later, as I was leaving, I passed by her table and our eyes met briefly. She gave me a small smile that didn't reach her eyes, quickly wiping away her tears as if to say, "I'm fine." But she wasn't fine. And I knew, because I'd been there too. Relationships are complex territories where our deepest joys and most profound wounds intersect. We're taught how to form connections but rarely shown how to maintain healthy ones or when to step away from harmful ones. The art of establishing boundaries – those invisible lines that protect our well-being while still allowing genuine connection – is something many of us struggle with daily. Throughout these pages, we'll explore the delicate balance between loving others deeply and protecting ourselves wisely. We'll examine why setting boundaries isn't selfish but necessary, how to communicate them effectively, and yes, even when a goodbye might be the most loving choice we can make – both for ourselves and sometimes for the other person too. This journey isn't about building walls, but about creating doorways that allow the right people to enter our lives in the right ways.

Chapter 1: The Foundation: Understanding Boundaries as God's Design

The tiny kitchen felt suffocating as Sarah stood there, phone pressed to her ear, listening to her sister's familiar litany of demands. "I need you to watch the kids this weekend. Tom and I haven't had a date night in months, and you don't have plans anyway." Sarah felt that familiar knot forming in her stomach – the one that appeared whenever her sister made these last-minute requests. She'd canceled her own plans countless times before, always prioritizing her sister's needs above her own. But something felt different today as she looked at the half-finished painting on her easel – the one she'd promised herself she'd complete this weekend. "Actually, I do have plans," Sarah heard herself say, her voice steadier than she expected. "I can't watch the kids this weekend, but I could help you find a sitter." The silence on the other end was deafening. Then came the guilt trip, the accusations of selfishness, the reminder of all the times her sister had "been there" for her. Sarah closed her eyes, breathing through the discomfort. This was new territory – standing her ground, honoring her own time and commitments. When she finally hung up, she felt both lighter and heavier – free but guilty, relieved but anxious. This scenario plays out in countless ways across relationships. Whether with family members who overstep, friends who drain our energy, partners who dismiss our feelings, or colleagues who exploit our willingness to help – the absence of healthy boundaries leaves us vulnerable to manipulation and resentment. The misconception many hold is that boundaries are walls built from selfishness. In reality, they're more like property lines that define where one person ends and another begins. Boundaries aren't just a modern psychological concept – they're woven into the fabric of creation itself. From the very beginning, God established boundaries: separating light from darkness, waters above from waters below, setting limits in the Garden of Eden. These weren't arbitrary restrictions but loving parameters designed to protect and nurture life. Even God Himself respects the boundaries He created, honoring our free will despite knowing we might use it unwisely. When we establish healthy boundaries, we aren't rejecting relationships but redefining them in ways that honor both parties. We create space for genuine love to flourish – love that isn't based on obligation, manipulation, or fear. This foundation helps us understand that saying "no" to certain behaviors or requests isn't unloving; often, it's the most loving thing we can do. By honoring our own limits and respecting others', we mirror the divine wisdom that recognized boundaries as essential to healthy existence from the very beginning.

Chapter 2: Recognizing When Access Exceeds Responsibility

Michael sat in his counselor's office, exhausted beyond words. For three years, he'd been supporting his friend through a difficult divorce, offering emotional support, financial help, and countless hours of listening. "But nothing changes," he explained, running his hands through his hair. "Every time I think he's turning a corner, he makes another destructive choice. Last night he called at 2 AM, drunk again, asking me to drive across town to pick him up from a bar." The counselor nodded thoughtfully before asking a question that stopped Michael in his tracks: "Has your friend ever shown the same level of responsibility for your wellbeing as the access he expects to have to your life?" This question illuminates a crucial imbalance in many relationships – when one person demands high levels of access (to our time, emotions, resources) without demonstrating corresponding responsibility. Michael's friend expected 24/7 availability but showed little accountability for how his choices affected Michael or commitment to making positive changes despite Michael's sacrifices. This imbalance creates a relationship vacuum that can deplete even the most compassionate person. Consider the difference between healthy and unhealthy access. In a balanced relationship, the level of access matches the level of responsibility. Close friends earn intimate knowledge of our lives through demonstrated trustworthiness. Family members respect our boundaries even as they share our lives. Romantic partners grow in mutual vulnerability as they prove themselves reliable caretakers of each other's hearts. But when someone demands unlimited access while demonstrating limited responsibility – through broken promises, disregard for our needs, or exploitation of our generosity – the relationship becomes fundamentally unbalanced. This principle appears throughout scripture as well. Even God, who offers unlimited love, adjusts access based on responsibility. In ancient Israel, not everyone could enter the Holy of Holies – only those who had demonstrated specific levels of responsibility and preparation. This wasn't about favoritism but about recognizing that closeness requires corresponding care and accountability. The solution isn't necessarily cutting people off, but adjusting access to match responsibility. For Michael, this meant no longer taking 2 AM calls but being available for lunch meetings with his friend. It meant offering to go together to recovery meetings instead of providing financial bailouts. When we align access with responsibility, we create relationships where mutual respect can thrive, and we protect ourselves from becoming drained by one-way dynamics that leave us empty and resentful.

Chapter 3: The Painful Truth: Dysfunction and Its Impact

"I don't understand what's happening to me," Emma confessed, her voice barely audible. "I used to be confident, creative, full of energy. Now I second-guess every decision. I can't sleep. I've even developed stomach problems." Her therapist nodded knowingly. For months, Emma had described her relationship with a colleague who alternated between excessive praise and cutting criticism, between seeking her help and undermining her work. "Last week, I found myself apologizing to him for a mistake he made. When I got home, I couldn't stop crying, and I didn't even know why." Emma was experiencing the physical and emotional toll of a dysfunctional relationship. Like many people, she hadn't recognized the pattern forming – how her boundaries were being systematically violated until her sense of reality itself had become distorted. The colleague's unpredictable behavior, gaslighting techniques, and emotional manipulation had created an environment where Emma's nervous system remained in constant high alert, resulting in anxiety, self-doubt, and even physical symptoms. Dysfunction in relationships rarely appears suddenly. It creeps in gradually, often disguised as normal interaction. A boundary is pushed slightly, then a little more. Explanations are offered that don't quite align with reality. Responsibilities shift imperceptibly until one person is carrying an unfair burden. The occasional disrespect becomes a pattern. And because humans are remarkably adaptable, we adjust to these incremental changes, normalizing what should alarm us. This normalization of dysfunction explains why many people remain in harmful relationships far longer than outsiders understand. The proverbial frog in gradually heating water doesn't jump out because the danger increases so subtly. Similarly, our psychological adaptations – rationalizing another's behavior, blaming ourselves, lowering our expectations – help us cope with uncomfortable realities but prevent us from recognizing the true harm being done. The impact of relational dysfunction extends far beyond emotional discomfort. Research shows that chronic boundary violations and relational stress affect our physical health, cognitive function, and even our immune systems. The constant cortisol release from ongoing relational tension impacts everything from our sleep quality to our heart health. Our brains, designed to seek coherence between what we're told and what we experience, become exhausted when constantly reconciling contradictions in dysfunctional relationships. Recognizing this connection between relational health and personal wellbeing marks a crucial turning point. It helps us understand that setting boundaries isn't merely a psychological preference but a necessary act of self-care with profound implications for our holistic health. When Emma finally understood that her physical symptoms were directly connected to the relational dysfunction she was experiencing, she found the motivation to establish firm boundaries that her rational mind alone couldn't justify. Sometimes, our bodies recognize what our minds are still trying to deny.

Chapter 4: Setting Boundaries Without Guilt or Fear

"What exactly do you say to her?" I asked Lisa, genuinely curious. For years, I'd watched her navigate a relationship with a particularly difficult family member – someone who regularly invaded her privacy, criticized her choices, and demanded time and attention regardless of Lisa's own needs. Unlike many others in similar situations, Lisa maintained both her kindness and her boundaries with remarkable grace. "I keep it simple," she replied, sipping her coffee. "When she starts criticizing my parenting, I say, 'I know we have different approaches, but I'm comfortable with my decisions.' Then I change the subject. If she persists, I say, 'I've shared my thoughts on this, and I'd prefer we talk about something else now.' If even that doesn't work, I excuse myself from the conversation." Lisa smiled. "The first few times were terrifying. I was shaking. But it gets easier with practice." Lisa exemplifies what many find so challenging – setting boundaries without either aggressive confrontation or apologetic surrender. Her approach highlights several key principles. First, she focuses on managing her own responses rather than controlling the other person. Second, she communicates clearly without accusation. Third, she implements consequences (like leaving the conversation) when boundaries aren't respected. Most importantly, she does all this without the excessive guilt that paralyzes many boundary-setters. This guilt often stems from misconceptions about what boundaries really are. Many believe boundaries are about rejection or punishment when they're actually about clarifying what behaviors we will and won't participate in. Others fear that boundaries contradict biblical values of sacrificial love and forgiveness. Yet even Jesus, who exemplified perfect love, established clear boundaries – withdrawing to pray despite others' demands, specifying which behaviors he would and wouldn't tolerate, and sometimes even walking away when people refused to respect his boundaries. Fear presents another obstacle to healthy boundary-setting. We fear others' disapproval, rejection, or anger. We fear being seen as selfish or unkind. We fear the relationship might end if we assert our needs. These fears aren't entirely unfounded – people accustomed to unlimited access often react poorly when boundaries appear. Yet the alternative – continuing in boundaryless relationships – ultimately leads to resentment, burnout, and relationships that lack authenticity. The path forward involves recognizing that effective boundaries actually preserve relationships rather than damaging them. They prevent the slow accumulation of resentment that eventually destroys connection. They create clarity that reduces conflict. They allow us to give freely from a place of genuine choice rather than obligation or fear. When we understand boundaries this way, we can begin setting them with confidence rather than guilt – not as walls built from selfishness, but as bridges designed for sustainable relationship. This journey requires courage, practice, and often support from others who understand healthy boundaries. But as we persist, like Lisa, we discover that what once felt terrifying gradually becomes natural – a way of honoring both ourselves and others by being truthful about what we can and cannot give. In this truth lies the foundation for relationships that can endure and flourish rather than drain and destroy.

Chapter 5: Accepting Reality: When Goodbyes Become Necessary

The afternoon sun streamed through the windows as Rachel sat across from her counselor, turning her wedding ring around her finger. "I've tried everything," she whispered. "Individual counseling, marriage counseling, setting boundaries, implementing consequences when those boundaries were crossed. I've prayed. I've forgiven. I've tried again." Her voice cracked. "But the affairs continue. The lies continue. Last month I found evidence he's been hiding money from our joint accounts. When I confronted him, he denied everything, even with the proof right in front of us." She looked up, tears streaming down her face. "How do I know when it's time to say goodbye?" This question haunts many who find themselves in relationships where patterns of betrayal, abuse, addiction, or profound dysfunction persist despite repeated attempts at reconciliation. Society often praises those who stay at all costs, celebrating endurance without examining its price. Religious communities sometimes compound this pressure, suggesting that forgiveness must always mean reconciliation or that suffering in a relationship somehow demonstrates spiritual virtue. Yet there comes a point in some relationships where acceptance of reality must override wishful thinking. This reality might include recognizing that one person cannot create change in an unwilling other. It might mean acknowledging that patterns aren't occasional mistakes but entrenched behaviors unlikely to change. It might involve facing the truth that continued exposure to certain behaviors is causing severe damage to your mental, emotional, spiritual, or physical health – or to your children's wellbeing. Accepting such realities doesn't mean giving up easily or abandoning commitments lightly. It means acknowledging what is actually happening rather than what we wish were happening. It means recognizing the difference between difficult relationships (which require work and patience) and destructive relationships (which cause ongoing harm despite sincere efforts at change). This distinction is crucial – many endure truly destructive situations because they've been taught that all relationship challenges simply require more effort, more forgiveness, more sacrifice. The decision to say goodbye – whether through divorce, estrangement, or significant distancing – is never simple. It involves grief, practical challenges, and often judgment from others who don't understand the full situation. For Rachel, it meant confronting her deepest fears about failure, loneliness, and financial uncertainty. It meant processing what her faith truly taught about marriage versus what cultural Christianity had superimposed onto scripture. It required distinguishing between abandoning someone and accepting that she couldn't force them to choose integrity and fidelity. This acceptance of reality – however painful – ultimately opens the door to healing. It allows us to stop pouring energy into changing what cannot be changed and redirect it toward building a healthier future. It frees us from the endless cycle of hope and disappointment that keeps us trapped in harmful situations. Sometimes, the most loving action – both for ourselves and paradoxically for the other person – is to accept that a relationship in its current form cannot continue, and to say goodbye with as much grace and clarity as possible.

Chapter 6: Processing Grief and Moving Forward

The box sat unopened in Daniel's closet for nearly a year after he finally established complete separation from his emotionally abusive father. Inside were childhood photos, letters, and mementos – physical reminders of a relationship that had caused both joy and profound pain. "I couldn't look at them," he explained, "but I couldn't throw them away either. It felt like I was stuck in emotional limbo." This limbo is familiar to many who've needed to end or significantly alter important relationships. Even when the decision is clearly necessary, the grief that follows can be overwhelming and complex. Unlike the grief following a death, which typically receives social support and recognition, the grief of necessary goodbyes often goes unacknowledged. Friends might say, "At least they're still alive" or "Maybe someday you'll reconcile," not understanding that these comments minimize the very real loss being experienced. Some religious communities add another layer of complexity, suggesting that complete healing should happen quickly through forgiveness, or that ongoing sadness somehow indicates spiritual failure. The reality is that processing grief after a significant relationship change requires time, space, and often professional support. Daniel described working with a therapist who helped him understand that his grief wasn't just about losing the relationship as it was, but also mourning the relationship he'd always hoped for but never had. "I wasn't just grieving my father – I was grieving the father I'd needed and wanted him to be," he explained. This distinction helped him validate his feelings rather than dismissing them as excessive or unwarranted. Healing also involves navigating complex emotions that might seem contradictory. Many experience relief alongside sadness, guilt alongside certainty, anger alongside compassion. These seemingly opposing feelings don't indicate confusion or mistake; they reflect the multifaceted nature of human relationships and the complicated process of disentangling from them. Acknowledging all these emotions without judgment becomes a crucial step in moving forward. For Daniel, a turning point came when he finally opened that box with his therapist present. Together, they sorted the contents – keeping some items, disposing of others, and creating a small memory book that acknowledged both the good moments and the painful reality. This tangible act became symbolic of a larger truth: we can honor what was valuable in a relationship while still accepting its end or fundamental change. We can carry forward lessons and even good memories without returning to situations that proved harmful. Moving forward doesn't mean forgetting or pretending the relationship never mattered. Instead, it means integrating the experience into our life story in a way that promotes healing rather than ongoing harm. It means establishing new patterns, creating new connections, and gradually building a life where the absence of that relationship isn't the defining feature. It often involves forgiveness – not as a quick fix or a requirement for reconciliation, but as a process that frees us from the binding power of resentment and allows our own healing to progress regardless of the other person's choices. When Daniel finally placed the memory book on his shelf, positioning it neither hidden away nor prominently displayed, he described feeling a sense of peace he hadn't expected. "It has its place in my story," he said, "but it no longer defines my future." This perspective represents the ultimate goal of processing relational grief – not erasing the past, but preventing it from controlling what comes next.

Summary

Throughout these pages, we've walked the challenging terrain of human connection, exploring how boundaries serve not as barriers to intimacy but as essential guardians of it. We've witnessed characters like Sarah learning to honor her own needs without abandoning her love for her sister, Michael discovering how to align access with responsibility, Emma recognizing the physical impact of relational dysfunction, Lisa setting boundaries with graceful firmness, Rachel accepting painful realities, and Daniel processing grief while creating space for new beginnings. Their stories reflect our own struggles and possibilities in navigating the complex landscape of human relationships. The wisdom threaded through these narratives offers transformative guidance for our own relational journeys. First, boundaries aren't selfish—they're necessary parameters that protect our capacity to love sustainably rather than burn out from unhealthy patterns. Second, we can love people deeply without taking responsibility for their choices or allowing their dysfunction to determine our wellbeing. Third, accepting reality—even painful reality—ultimately frees us to move forward rather than remaining trapped in cycles of hope and disappointment with those unwilling or unable to change. Perhaps most importantly, we've seen that establishing healthy boundaries and sometimes even saying necessary goodbyes doesn't diminish our capacity for love and connection; rather, it preserves and enhances it, allowing us to build relationships characterized by mutual respect, appropriate responsibility, and genuine care rather than exploitation, enmeshment, or harm. As we apply these principles in our own lives, we discover the freedom to love others authentically while honoring the boundaries that allow both them and us to thrive.

About Author

Loading...

Lysa TerKeurst

Lysa TerKeurst is president of Proverbs 31 Ministries and the New York Times best-selling author of Univited, The Best Yes, Unglued, Made to Crave, and 18 other books. Her newest book, It’s Not Supposed to be This Way, is scheduled for release in November of 2018. Lysa was recently awarded the Champions of Faith Author Award and has been published in multiple publications such as CNN and Fox News online. Additionally, she has appeared on the Today Show as one of the leading voices in the Christian community. Each year, Lysa is a featured keynote presenter at more than 40 events across North America, including the Women of Joy Conferences and the Catalyst Leadership Conference. She has a passion for equipping women to share their stories for God's glory through Proverbs 31 Ministries' annual She Speaks Conference and writer training program, COMPEL: Words That Move People. Connect with Lysa on social media @lysaterkeurst or at http://lysaterkeurst.com/.

Read more

Related Books by Lysa TerKeurst

Loading...

Forgiving What You Can't Forget

Lysa TerKeurst

Discover How to Move On, Make Peace with Painful Memories, and Create a Life That’s Beautiful Again

★★★★☆4.1