High Road Leadership

High Road Leadership Plot Summary

Introduction

In today's increasingly polarized world, we face a leadership crisis that threatens to tear apart the social fabric binding us together. When disagreement reigns and people entrench themselves in opposing sides, the chasm between "us" and "them" grows wider each day. This division manifests across all sectors of society, from politics and business to communities and even families. While disagreement has always existed in human interactions, the troubling trend now is that we no longer see others as merely disagreeing - we see them as fundamentally disagreeable human beings with wrong motives. What distinguishes effective leaders in such a divided landscape is their ability to resist this divisive current and instead build bridges across differences. Through careful analysis of leadership behaviors and motivations, we discover that the most impactful leaders consistently choose what can be called the "high road" - a path characterized by valuing all people, acknowledging one's humanness, doing the right things for the right reasons, and giving more than taking. This approach stands in stark contrast to middle-road leaders who merely seek fairness and low-road leaders who prioritize self-interest at others' expense. By examining the practices of high-road leadership and providing practical strategies to develop these capacities, we gain insight into how we might heal divisions and create environments where collaboration and mutual respect flourish despite differences.

Chapter 1: The Crisis of Division: Why We Need High-Road Leadership

Our world has devolved into a landscape where disagreement reigns and division has become the default mode of interaction. People instinctively pick sides and turn against those perceived to be on the other side. This chasm between "us" and "them" infiltrates every aspect of modern discourse - those on "our side" think, act, look, vote, eat, live, speak, and work like us. Everyone else belongs to the opposing camp. Even when one side "wins" in these confrontations, it's rarely a genuine victory because it benefits only a segment of society rather than the whole. The deterioration of leadership quality lies at the heart of this crisis. What makes the difference between good and bad leaders comes down to two critical factors: skills and values. Leadership rises when leaders possess both good leadership skills and good values. It falls when either component is lacking. Leaders with poor skills but good values might be well-intentioned but ultimately cannot help their people effectively. More dangerously, leaders with good skills but poor values manipulate people for personal gain, creating win-lose situations that damage social cohesion. Politics, especially in the United States, sets a troubling standard for how people treat each other. While in the past, political opponents would fight hard during campaigns but work together afterward, today's politics resembles war more than sport. The attitude after elections increasingly becomes, "I fought, I won, you don't deserve a voice." This explains why polls show that approximately two-thirds of Americans have little confidence in elected officials or the federal government. Unfortunately, this combative approach has bled into nearly every aspect of life, making cooperation increasingly difficult. The fundamental shift in human interaction centers on how we view disagreement. There's a significant difference between believing someone's ideas are wrong versus believing their motives are wrong. When we merely think others' opinions are incorrect, we remain willing to engage in discussion and seek common ground. However, when we believe their motivations are corrupt, we draw lines, build walls, and refuse positive engagement because we assume malicious intent. This ends relationships and halts progress. Most people today possess strong confirmation bias - seeking information that affirms existing beliefs while ignoring contradictory evidence. Good leaders must rise above this tendency by developing a collaboration bias that brings people together to increase mutual understanding and broaden perspectives. Leaders must recognize that neither they nor their "side" possesses all the answers. This approach proves challenging in all settings but particularly in government, where citizens hold vastly different visions for society's direction. The pathway forward requires leaders who can transcend divisiveness by building bridges rather than walls. By focusing on valuing all people, acknowledging human imperfection, practicing accountability, and embracing authenticity, high-road leaders create environments where differences can be discussed productively rather than destructively. This approach represents our best hope for healing the divides that threaten to tear apart our communities, organizations, and nations.

Chapter 2: The Three Paths: Low, Middle, and High-Road Leadership Examined

When interacting with others, people choose one of three paths: the low road, the middle road, or the high road. These paths fundamentally shape how leaders relate to followers and determine their effectiveness in bringing people together in a divided world. The middle road, where most people travel, values fairness above all else. Middle-road leaders operate on an equitable exchange principle - "I have received this much, so I should give that much." They willingly compromise but prefer to get their share first before reciprocating. This approach works when all parties act in good faith, but it has significant limitations. Middle-road thinking creates a scorekeeper mentality where people constantly calculate what they give versus what they receive. When middle-road leaders feel wronged, they often seek proportional revenge, following the "eye for an eye" principle. While democratic governments typically function through middle-road compromises, this approach falters because participants want others to make the first move toward fairness, change, or reconciliation. The result is often a stalemate where progress stalls while each side waits for the other to take the initial step. The low road revolves around self-interest at the expense of others. Low-road leaders believe taking is the only way to get what they want, fearing they'll be left out or behind if they don't seize advantages. Many who travel this path see themselves as victims entitled to take from others to rectify perceived injustice. Ironically, by consistently exploiting others for personal gain, they actually create greater injustice. Low-road leaders actively leverage division, often working to widen the chasm between groups rather than bridge it. They keep people divided because they believe it helps maintain their position and power. Despite constantly taking from others, low-road individuals remain perpetually unsatisfied - the more they take, the more they want, creating an endless cycle of need. The high road stands in stark contrast to both alternatives as an others-first approach. High-road leaders intentionally give first without concern about receiving anything in return. They value every person regardless of which road that person travels. Rather than worrying about fairness in each interaction, high-road leaders recognize life isn't fair and work to keep the balance in others' favor. This approach doesn't stem from moral superiority but from a fundamentally different mindset - focusing on others' well-being rather than self-promotion. High-road leaders actively look for good in people to bring out their best. When they fall into low-road behaviors, as everyone occasionally does, they don't make excuses but correct themselves and return to the high road. The contrasts between these three leadership approaches become evident when comparing their core attributes side-by-side. High-road leaders value others, bring people together, close gaps between people, give more than they receive, and give first without conditions. Middle-road leaders seek value from others, move back and forth between cooperation and self-protection, maintain the status quo of divisions, give equal to what they've received, and keep meticulous score. Low-road leaders actively devalue others, divide people, widen gaps, take more than they give, give nothing, and prioritize themselves at others' expense. Treating others better than they treat you, consistently and without judgment, represents the best path for bringing people together in a divided world. While everyone occasionally makes low-road decisions, acknowledging mistakes, apologizing, and making amends puts you back on the high-road path. This approach allows leaders to travel light, unburdened by grudges, resentment, or guilt. The high road proves most effective because it brings people together, brings out their best, creates winners without creating losers, distinguishes you from the crowd, and provides a path to significance beyond mere success.

Chapter 3: Core Values of High-Road Leaders: Valuing People and Authenticity

Valuing all people forms the foundation of high-road leadership. This doesn't mean simply giving compliments or making people feel important; it means recognizing every person's inherent worth as a human being, communicating that recognition, and helping them feel and believe their own worth. High-road leaders don't pick and choose who deserves value - they understand that devaluing anyone based on others' opinions or personal preference takes them off the high road. People instinctively sense whether we genuinely value them. In today's culture, we've crossed a dangerous line when we moved from simply disagreeing with others to devaluing them because we disagree. This shift toward low-road leadership fuels the anger permeating society. When others respond in kind, the cycle intensifies. While making negative points may seem easier than making positive differences, anger never produces winning outcomes for anyone involved. High-road leaders believe in people's potential as strongly as they value their worth. When you believe others can achieve, improve, and contribute meaningfully to the world, you naturally invest in them. This belief manifests through expressing confidence in others, equipping them with necessary skills and knowledge, and challenging them to reach higher. Believing in people's unlimited capacity for growth motivates high-road leaders to help others maximize their potential rather than settling for mediocrity. Extending unconditional love represents another core value of high-road leaders. While valuing people stems from embracing their worth and believing in them acknowledges their potential, unconditional love accepts them without strings attached. This love doesn't depend on what people say or do; it continues regardless of their actions or responses. This mindset faces continual testing and requires ongoing recommitment, but it creates an unparalleled leadership atmosphere. Authenticity stands as another essential value for high-road leaders. They embrace authenticity by refusing to hide behind façades or pretend to be something they're not. They openly acknowledge both strengths and weaknesses, understanding that followers already recognize their flaws. The purpose of admitting weaknesses isn't to reveal new information but to demonstrate self-awareness - letting people know you recognize what they already see. High-road leaders embrace and live good values consistently. They understand the danger of espousing one set of values while secretly living by another. This authenticity manifests through several practices: living between success and failure rather than defining themselves by either extreme; valuing character over reputation; focusing on choices rather than innate gifts; valuing their unique contribution without overinflation or self-deprecation; and honestly acknowledging mistakes when they occur. Developing these core values requires deliberate effort for most people. It begins with developing humble appreciation for yourself - seeing your worth while not thinking too highly of yourself. Next comes choosing to focus on others rather than remaining self-centered. Taking action to demonstrate you value others through acknowledgment, seeking common ground, and treating them with dignity accelerates the process. As you consistently practice these behaviors, your heart for people naturally grows, and you begin experiencing the positive returns of valuing others: stronger relationships, emotional fulfillment, and enhanced leadership influence. When leaders consistently live these core values, they transform workplaces, communities, and relationships. By valuing all people, believing in their potential, loving them unconditionally, and embracing authentic leadership, high-road leaders create environments where people thrive despite differences. This approach provides the foundation for bringing people together in a world determined to divide them.

Chapter 4: The Leader's Inner Work: Emotional Capacity and Accountability

Leading people effectively on the high road requires significant internal development, particularly in emotional capacity and accountability. Emotional capacity refers to a leader's ability to respond positively to adversity, failure, criticism, and pressure. High-road leaders stand strong during internal conflicts, adverse situations, and difficult interactions. They manage their emotions effectively to lead others well, especially in today's challenging environment where many people struggle emotionally. Developing emotional capacity begins with refusing to see yourself as a victim. The victim mentality disempowers leaders by attributing responsibility for circumstances to external forces rather than personal choices. Leaders who view themselves as victims believe bad things continuously happen to them through no fault of their own, see no point in trying to create change, and expect salvation only through others' actions. This mindset proves emotionally draining and relationally destructive. The antidote involves taking responsibility for your life, focusing on opportunities rather than problems, making action your priority, and expressing gratitude despite difficulties. Controlling emotions and processing them quickly represents another crucial aspect of emotional capacity. Leaders must avoid letting strong emotions overwhelm their judgment during high-pressure situations. This doesn't mean suppressing feelings but rather developing emotional homes - positive emotional states that counteract negative ones. For example, when experiencing sadness, intentionally tapping into gratitude provides a healthier alternative. Processing emotions through daily reflection accelerates emotional recovery and promotes learning from experiences. High-road leaders also keep short accounts in relationships, refusing to carry emotional baggage or hold grudges. They resolve conflicts quickly, apologize when wrong, forgive others who harm them, and move forward. This approach prevents wasted energy on negative emotions that primarily harm the person holding them. Leaders focused on the future recognize that dwelling on past wrongs only slows progress toward important goals and diminishes leadership effectiveness. Accountability forms the second essential element of a leader's inner work. This means accepting responsibility for expected outcomes - both positive and negative - without blaming others or external circumstances. Accountability isn't passive but active and intentional. Leaders demonstrate accountability by consistently taking ownership of their actions and decisions, even when results fall short of expectations. Personal responsibility represents the foundation of accountability. Leaders must first hold themselves accountable before attempting to hold others accountable. Team responsibility extends this principle to group settings, ensuring teammates can depend on each other when it matters most. Leadership responsibility encompasses taking ownership for the team's overall performance, redistributing workloads when necessary, and creating conditions for team members to succeed. Accountability builds credibility with followers over time. When leaders consistently take responsibility for their actions, admit mistakes, and work to rectify errors, they earn trust. This credibility must be continually reinforced through daily actions rather than resting on past achievements. Accountability also promotes consistency, enabling leaders to maintain focus on long-term goals despite setbacks or distractions. Additionally, leaders who hold themselves accountable experience increased self-respect, which fuels positive cycles of good choices and growing confidence. Everyone, regardless of position, needs accountability relationships. Without external accountability, leaders tend to drift off course and find themselves on the low road. Even the most self-disciplined leaders benefit from others who provide perspective on blind spots, offer wisdom from different viewpoints, and deliver valuable feedback. These accountability relationships help close the gap between intentions and results, increasing the likelihood of positive change and follow-through on commitments. The inner work of developing emotional capacity and embracing accountability prepares leaders for the challenges of high-road leadership. By refusing victim thinking, processing emotions effectively, resolving conflicts quickly, and taking responsibility for outcomes, leaders build the internal foundation necessary to bring people together in a divided world. This inner work doesn't happen automatically - it requires intentional effort and consistent practice, but the results transform both the leader and those they influence.

Chapter 5: Living the High Road: Serving Others and Building Trust

High-road leadership fundamentally revolves around serving others rather than seeking personal advancement. This service mindset begins with placing people above your own agenda - a challenging but essential practice. Leaders always have agendas - goals they want to accomplish, causes they champion, or problems they aim to solve. While these objectives can drive positive change, they become problematic when leaders prioritize them above people's welfare. Developing empathy forms the foundation for placing others first. Leaders must listen attentively to understand perspectives different from their own, imagining themselves walking in others' shoes. This requires venturing beyond comfortable circles and familiar viewpoints to embrace different thinking. Making time for people daily demonstrates this commitment through practices like "walking slowly through the crowd" - taking time to connect with individuals rather than rushing past them. Creating win-win outcomes represents another crucial aspect of prioritizing people, as win-lose scenarios typically produce short-term gains but long-term losses through damaged relationships and diminished trust. Leading effectively while placing people first requires mastering what can be called the "leadership dance" - adapting your approach to fit changing situations and people. Sometimes this means leading from the front by setting examples that inspire others to follow. Other times, it involves walking beside people, asking questions and listening carefully to understand their needs and perspectives. On occasion, leaders must position themselves below others by serving them directly - removing obstacles, providing resources, and lifting burdens that prevent their best performance. Supporting from behind also proves valuable by pulling people forward through encouragement, pushing them through appropriate challenges, or patiently waiting when they're not yet ready to move. Finally, leading from above involves advancing the big picture by communicating vision and aligning resources to help everyone succeed. Giving more than you take represents another hallmark of high-road leadership. This generosity flows from three types of thinking: open-hearted generosity (desiring to add value to others), open-minded generosity (thinking the best of others), and open-handed generosity (giving freely and often). High-road leaders approach every interaction asking what they can contribute rather than what they might receive. They share their talents, time, opportunities, financial resources, connections, and experiences generously without expectation of return. Developing emotional capacity enables leaders to withstand the pressures inherent in leadership. By refusing victim thinking, controlling emotions, keeping short accounts in relationships, putting others' opinions in perspective, distinguishing between problems and facts of life, becoming comfortable with discomfort, growing capacity beyond responsibilities, and prioritizing self-care, leaders build the resilience necessary for high-road leadership. This emotional resilience allows them to bear difficulties for the sake of their people and organization while rebounding quickly from setbacks. Embracing authenticity creates trust with followers by eliminating the gap between public and private personas. Authentic leaders embrace and live good values consistently, acknowledge they live between success and failure rather than embodying either extreme, value character over reputation, focus on choices rather than innate gifts, appreciate their unique contribution without exaggeration, and honestly admit mistakes. This authenticity allows people to connect with the real person behind the leadership role, fostering deeper relationships and greater influence. Taking accountability for actions builds trust and creates credibility with followers. Accountable leaders accept responsibility for outcomes without blaming others or circumstances. They understand that accountability and responsibility work together - accountability means owning outcomes while responsibility means accepting obligations. By taking personal responsibility, honoring team commitments, and embracing leadership obligations, high-road leaders earn trust and inspire others to follow suit. This accountability proves contagious, encouraging team members to step up and take ownership themselves. Through these practices - placing people first, giving generously, developing emotional capacity, embracing authenticity, and taking accountability - high-road leaders build environments where trust flourishes despite differences. They demonstrate that effective leadership isn't about position or power but about service that transforms both individuals and organizations. By consistently choosing the high road in their interactions, these leaders bring people together in a world determined to divide them.

Chapter 6: From Theory to Practice: Implementing High-Road Leadership

Implementing high-road leadership requires moving beyond theoretical understanding to practical application. This transition begins with living by the bigger picture - developing the distinctive ability to see more than others and before others. This broader perspective allows leaders to recognize opportunities, anticipate challenges, and guide people effectively through changing circumstances. Unlike those focused solely on immediate concerns, high-road leaders understand situations within their larger context, which enables them to make better decisions and create meaningful change. Developing this bigger-picture perspective requires growth in three key areas. First comes maturity - characterized by humility, perspective, and patience. Mature leaders understand the world doesn't revolve around them, can distinguish between important and trivial matters, and demonstrate patience in pursuing long-term goals over immediate gratification. Second, understanding the greater context enhances decision-making by considering informational, historical, situational, motivational, collaborative, experiential, and tactical frameworks. Finally, becoming intentional about seeking and living the bigger picture transforms how leaders approach every situation, allowing them to frame their "masterpiece" (core contribution), uplevel added value to appreciated value, become distinctive rather than merely different, and create environments that bring out the best in people. Avoiding scorekeeper mentality represents another crucial aspect of implementing high-road leadership. Keeping score with others inevitably leads to middle or low-road leadership by placing guilt on others, creating feelings of unfairness, becoming an act of control, removing gratitude, increasing emotional baggage, and breeding entitlement. Instead, high-road leaders keep track without keeping score - focusing on their own behavior rather than manipulating others. They forgive freely because they recognize everyone needs forgiveness, and they practice the Platinum Rule by treating others better than they themselves are treated. Desiring the best for others forms the culminating practice of high-road leadership. This requires changing thinking patterns from self-focused to others-focused, expressing that desire through affirming words and actions, and following through with practical steps that help others experience their best. High-road leaders consistently communicate value to others through affirmation, express belief in their potential through encouragement, empower them by communicating genuine need for their contributions, expand their horizons by wanting more for them than from them, and serve them by actively helping when needed. They also enlarge others by doing things for them they cannot do for themselves - providing access to relationships, experiences, or opportunities otherwise unavailable. These high-road practices create profound impacts on both leaders and followers. Leaders who implement these principles experience greater fulfillment as they witness others' growth and success. Followers develop increased confidence, engagement, and commitment as they feel valued, believed in, and supported. Organizations benefit through improved collaboration, innovation, and resilience as people work together across differences rather than against each other from entrenched positions. Implementing high-road leadership doesn't require perfection - all leaders occasionally make low-road decisions or engage in middle-road thinking. What distinguishes high-road leaders is their commitment to quickly acknowledge mistakes, make necessary corrections, and return to high-road practices. This consistent pattern of choosing the higher path, even after missteps, gradually transforms leadership effectiveness and organizational culture. The journey to high-road leadership ultimately depends on intentionality - consciously choosing to value others, acknowledge humanness, do right things for right reasons, give generously, develop emotional capacity, place people first, embrace authenticity, take accountability, live by the bigger picture, avoid scorekeeping, and desire others' best. These choices, made consistently over time, enable leaders to bridge divides that seem uncrossable, create collaboration where conflict once reigned, and bring people together in a world determined to divide them.

Summary

The fundamental insight illuminated throughout this exploration of high-road leadership is that genuine leadership power comes not from division but from connection. In a world increasingly fragmented by tribalism and polarization, high-road leaders distinguish themselves by their consistent choice to bring people together rather than exploit differences. This approach operates from a radically different mindset than conventional leadership - valuing all people regardless of agreement, acknowledging personal humanness instead of projecting perfection, prioritizing people above personal agendas, and giving generously without keeping score. The resulting leadership creates environments where trust flourishes, collaboration replaces combat, and mutual respect supersedes mutual suspicion. The practical wisdom offered through this examination of high-road leadership applies across all domains of human interaction - from political and business leadership to community engagement and family relationships. While middle-road leaders seek fairness through transactional exchanges and low-road leaders exploit others for personal gain, high-road leaders consistently elevate those around them by serving their needs and amplifying their strengths. This path demands greater emotional capacity, authentic self-presentation, and unwavering accountability - internal qualities that manifest externally through transformed relationships and organizations. For those willing to embrace the challenge of high-road leadership, the rewards extend far beyond personal success to meaningful significance that changes lives, heals divisions, and creates communities where people thrive despite differences. In this approach lies our best hope for navigating the complex challenges facing our divided world.

About Author

Loading...

John C. Maxwell

Read more

Related Books by John C. Maxwell

Loading...

How Successful People Think

John C. Maxwell

Change Your Thinking, Change Your Life

★★★★☆4.3

Loading...

The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership

John C. Maxwell

Follow Them and People Will Follow You

★★★★☆4.4

Loading...

The 16 Undeniable Laws of Communication

John C. Maxwell

Apply Them and Make the Most of Your Message

★★★★☆4.4

Loading...

The 15 Invaluable Laws of Growth

John C. Maxwell

Live Them and Reach Your Potential

★★★★½4.6

Loading...

Be the Unicorn

John C. Maxwell

12 Data-Driven Habits That Separate the Best Leaders from the Rest

★★★½☆3.7

Loading...

5 Levels of Leadership

John C. Maxwell

Proven Steps to Maximize your Potential

★★★★☆4.3

Loading...

Leadershift

John C. Maxwell

The 11 Essential Changes Every Leader Must Embrace

★★★★☆4.3

Loading...

Leadership 101

John C. Maxwell

What Every Leader Needs to Know

★★★★☆4.1

Loading...

Failing Forward

John C. Maxwell

Turning Mistakes Into Stepping Stones For Success

★★★★☆4.2

Loading...

Developing the Leader Within You

John C. Maxwell

Discover the Biblical Foundations for Leadership

★★★★☆4.2