How Not To Be a Boy

How Not To Be a Boy Plot Summary

Introduction

In the small Lincolnshire village of Woodhall Spa during the 1970s and 80s, a young boy with curly blond hair and wide blue eyes was learning painful lessons about what it meant to be male in working-class Britain. Robert Webb, who would later become one of the country's most beloved comedians, grew up under the shadow of a father he once compared to Darth Vader – a man whose volatile temper and emotional unavailability embodied the most restrictive aspects of traditional masculinity. This environment, where boys were expected to be tough, to suppress emotion, and to conform to rigid gender expectations, created a profound disconnect between Webb's sensitive nature and the role he was expected to play. Webb's journey from that constrained childhood to becoming an outspoken critic of harmful masculine stereotypes offers a compelling exploration of how gender norms shape our lives and how we might break free from them. Through his evolution as a comedian, writer, husband, and father, Webb demonstrates both the damage inflicted by restrictive masculinity and the possibility of creating healthier alternatives. His story illuminates the often invisible ways that boys are conditioned from their earliest years, the psychological toll this conditioning exacts, and the transformative power of questioning what we've been taught about what it means to be a man.

Chapter 1: The Shadow of Darth: Childhood Under Restrictive Masculinity

Robert Webb's earliest memories reveal the complex dynamics of masculinity that would shape his life. Growing up in Woodhall Spa, a picturesque but provincial Lincolnshire village, Webb encountered rigid gender expectations from the beginning. His father Paul, a woodcutter with a reputation for drinking and fighting, embodied traditional masculinity at its most intimidating. Webb would later describe him as "Darth Vader" – a powerful but frightening presence whose approval seemed impossible to earn. One formative memory captures this relationship perfectly: at age two, Webb fell down the stairs, only to hear his father laughing at his distress. "Poor old boy, ha ha ha," his father chortled through his mustache, teaching the young boy that showing pain was something to be mocked rather than comforted. Behind this difficult father-son relationship lay a family tragedy that Webb would only fully understand years later. He was born just ten months after his eldest brother Martin died of meningitis at age six. This devastating loss haunted the family, particularly his father, whose grief manifested as anger and emotional unavailability. The village saw Paul Webb as charismatic and generous, unaware of the powder keg of repressed grief that exploded behind closed doors. This disconnect between public persona and private behavior taught Webb early lessons about the masks men wear and the emotions they hide. When Webb was five, his mother divorced his father and later married Derek Limb, a teetotal, mild-mannered man who represented the opposite of Paul Webb's volatility. This created a new dynamic where Webb experienced contrasting models of masculinity. Derek adored Webb, who with his "wide blue eyes and mass of curly, white-blond hair" was "Little Lord Fauntleroy in a tank top." This affection provided stability but created its own complications as Webb navigated between these different male archetypes, trying to understand what kind of man he was expected to become. School reinforced these confusing messages about masculinity. At Queen Elizabeth's Grammar School, Webb felt out of place among both the confident middle-class students and the sports-oriented boys who played football and engaged in games like "Ball Death" – a ritual involving kicking footballs at each other's testicles. His discomfort with traditional masculine activities was profound; he dreaded Games lessons and the communal showers that followed, where his skinny frame and sensitivity made him feel vulnerable and exposed. Academic success offered some refuge, but even there, certain subjects were coded as masculine or feminine, creating additional pressure to conform. Throughout his childhood, Webb developed coping mechanisms to navigate this challenging terrain. He created an elaborate fantasy world, complete with imaginary bodyguards he called "Guy-Buys" – a psychological defense against feelings of vulnerability. He learned to use humor as both shield and weapon, developing the quick wit that would later become his professional trademark. Most significantly, he began to observe and analyze the absurdities of gender expectations, laying the groundwork for the critical perspective that would eventually inform his comedy and writing. Even as he struggled to meet the impossible standards of boyhood, part of him recognized their arbitrary and often harmful nature. The lessons of Webb's childhood – that boys don't cry, that emotional vulnerability is weakness, that pain should be suppressed rather than expressed – became deeply internalized. These early experiences created patterns that would take decades to recognize and transform. Yet they also planted the seeds of resistance, a growing awareness that something was fundamentally wrong with a system that required boys to deny essential parts of their humanity in order to be considered "real men."

Chapter 2: Finding Voice: Comedy as Escape and Expression

Comedy became Robert Webb's salvation and identity. As a teenager who didn't fit neatly into the prescribed box of masculinity, he discovered that making people laugh offered both protection and purpose. The turning point came in his second year at school when Mrs. Slater, his English teacher, approached him with what seemed an impossible request: to take over the main part in a comic play after the original actor was hospitalized. Despite his terror of performing, Webb agreed. To his surprise, he discovered not only that he could make people laugh, but that he enjoyed it. Form 2S won the competition, and Webb experienced for the first time the intoxicating feeling of an audience's approval. This success awakened something profound in Webb. He began writing and performing in end-of-term revues and morning assemblies, developing his comic timing and discovering the power of making others laugh. Performance became his way of being seen on his own terms, rather than being judged by traditional masculine standards. While he couldn't compete with the "proper boys" in sports or fighting, he could outperform them on stage, turning his outsider status into a source of power rather than shame. His quick wit and theatrical performances earned him a reputation that transcended the usual social hierarchies, providing a form of validation that had previously seemed unattainable. Webb's comedic sensibility developed as a direct response to his environment. Growing up in a small village where conformity was prized, humor became his way of processing the absurdities of gender expectations. He observed how boys and men performed their masculinity – the posturing, the emotional suppression, the constant competition – and transformed these observations into material. His early performances revealed his talent for mimicry and his ability to highlight the ridiculous aspects of everyday life, particularly the arbitrary rules governing gender behavior. The discovery of alternative comedy in the 1980s provided Webb with models that expanded his understanding of what comedy could be. Watching shows like "Blackadder," "The Young Ones," and "A Bit of Fry and Laurie" introduced him to a world where intelligence, wordplay, and subversion were celebrated. These influences showed him that comedy could be both entertaining and meaningful – a way to challenge conventions rather than reinforce them. Most importantly, he discovered that many of his comedy heroes had met at Cambridge University, specifically in the Footlights comedy club, planting the seed for his own educational aspirations. Mrs. Slater proved instrumental in nurturing Webb's emerging voice. Unlike other teachers who emphasized conformity, she encouraged intellectual curiosity and treated her students as equals. When Webb tentatively asked if it was ridiculous for him to think of applying to Cambridge, her response – "No, not ridiculous... We've certainly sent dimmer people than you there" – gave him permission to dream beyond the limitations of his background. This validation from an authority figure who valued wit and intelligence over traditional masculine traits helped Webb see that there might be a place for him in the world after all. By his mid-teens, Webb had found his path. He began reading voraciously – Wilde, Austen, Shakespeare – developing the literary knowledge that would complement his performance instincts. His ambition crystallized around the discovery that many of his comedy heroes had met at Cambridge University in a group called the Footlights. Comedy had become not just an escape from the confines of traditional masculinity but a means of expressing a more authentic self – one that embraced sensitivity, intelligence, and creativity rather than suppressing these qualities in the name of being a "real man."

Chapter 3: Grief and Identity: Navigating Loss as a Young Man

When Webb was seventeen, his mother was diagnosed with cancer. The news came suddenly, and within weeks, it became clear that she would not recover. His father, visiting the bungalow where Webb lived with his mother, stepfather Derek, and young half-sister Anna-Beth, delivered the news with characteristic bluntness: "Y'mum's poorly, boy. It's terminal." The conversation quickly devolved into a discussion about hiring a cleaner, leaving Webb stunned and sobbing while the adults discussed practical matters. This moment encapsulated the disconnect between overwhelming emotion and the practical, stoic response expected of men facing tragedy. In the weeks that followed, Webb struggled to process what was happening. His mother, recognizing his distress, asked if there was anything he wanted to say to her. Instead of expressing his grief, Webb confessed his insecurity about being a virgin while his friends claimed sexual experience. Her response was characteristically gentle: "I won't say I'm surprised; I won't say I'm not surprised. But you'll catch up." When he promised to get three A grades and go to Cambridge, she replied, "I know you'll be happy wherever you end up, Rob. I'm proud of you already, so don't worry." This conversation, one of their last meaningful exchanges, revealed both Webb's difficulty expressing his true feelings and his mother's unconditional acceptance. After his mother died in April 1990, Webb experienced what he describes as "grief turned to anger." Unable to process his emotions directly, he channeled them into determination to succeed academically and escape Lincolnshire. The day after his mother's funeral, he attended a university fair in Nottingham, where he approached the Cambridge University representative. When she learned he had just come from his mother's funeral, she was shocked but encouraging: "You're sitting in the right chair, talking to the right person. It's not stupid in the slightest for you to think of us." This encounter reinforced Webb's growing belief that he needed to transform his loss into achievement. Living in the bungalow with his stepfather Derek and half-sister Anna-Beth became increasingly difficult. Derek, previously uninvolved in household management, now struggled to maintain order. Webb, focused on his exams and grief, found himself unable to help with Anna-Beth's care. After shouting at her one day and seeing her run to what had been their mother's side of the bed to cry, Webb realized he couldn't stay. In a pivotal decision, he approached his father and asked to move in with him. Despite their difficult history, Webb saw this as an escape from the constant reminders of his mother's absence. The cultural pressure to remain stoic in the face of profound loss created an impossible situation for Webb – one where expressing his true feelings conflicted with everything he had been taught about masculinity. He began to see himself as "the good news... the silver lining" to his mother's death – a narrative that was "almost completely insane" but provided emotional protection. This self-image as someone destined to conquer the world on his mother's behalf would drive him forward but also create problems later, as he placed impossible expectations on himself and struggled to acknowledge his ongoing grief. Friends became crucial lifelines during this period of loss. Webb's friendship with Will, in particular, provided emotional support that transcended typical male bonding. Their relationship, which occasionally blurred the lines between friendship and something more intimate, gave Webb permission to express vulnerability in ways that his upbringing had discouraged. These connections, along with his determination to succeed academically, helped Webb navigate the immediate aftermath of his loss, though the deeper work of processing his grief would continue for decades.

Chapter 4: Creative Partnership: The Mitchell and Webb Dynamic

At Cambridge University, Robert Webb found himself in an environment that both challenged and nurtured his developing identity. As a working-class boy from Lincolnshire with a regional accent and secondhand clothes, he initially felt like an impostor among the confident, predominantly middle-class students. The Cambridge Footlights comedy club became the center of Webb's university experience, though not without struggle. His first year brought repeated rejection as he auditioned unsuccessfully for the major Footlights shows. Rather than abandoning his ambitions, Webb persisted, honing his skills through smaller performances until he finally broke through in his second year. It was at Cambridge that Webb met David Mitchell, forming what would become one of British comedy's most successful partnerships. Their connection was immediate and profound, based on shared sensibilities and complementary talents. Webb recognized in Mitchell a brilliant comic mind that matched his own ambitions. Where Webb brought physical comedy and emotional expressiveness, Mitchell contributed verbal dexterity and logical precision. This balance created a dynamic that worked both on stage and off, as they developed a friendship that provided mutual support through the challenges of establishing their careers. The Mitchell and Webb partnership flourished through their complementary approaches to comedy and life. Mitchell's methodical, intellectually rigorous style balanced Webb's more intuitive, emotionally driven approach. In performance, this created a perfect tension – Mitchell often playing the straight man to Webb's more outlandish characters. Their collaboration began with university shows and continued beyond graduation, laying the foundation for future successes including "Peep Show," "That Mitchell and Webb Look," and numerous other projects. This partnership provided Webb with both creative fulfillment and emotional stability during the often challenging transition to professional life. After graduating from Cambridge in 1995, Webb and Mitchell faced the harsh realities of the entertainment industry – inconsistent work, financial precarity, and the constant need to prove themselves in a highly competitive field. The early years of their career were marked by a series of odd jobs that supported their comedy ambitions: working as theater ushers, driving delivery trucks, and taking various temporary positions while continuing to develop material together. Their persistence through these lean years demonstrated a commitment that transcended the initial glamour of performance. The creation of "Peep Show" in 2003 marked a turning point in their careers. Cast as the irresponsible, impulsive Jeremy Usborne opposite Mitchell's uptight Mark Corrigan, Webb found a role that showcased his comedic talents while also reflecting aspects of his own personality. The show's innovative point-of-view filming style and unflinching portrayal of male friendship resonated with audiences and critics alike. Though initially modest in viewership, "Peep Show" gradually built a devoted following, eventually running for nine seasons and establishing itself as one of British comedy's most acclaimed productions. Throughout their partnership, Webb and Mitchell maintained distinct identities while supporting each other's growth. They expanded into various creative outlets, developing their sketch show "That Mitchell and Webb Look" and pursuing individual projects that allowed them to explore different aspects of their talents. Their professional relationship demonstrated an alternative model of male friendship – one based on mutual respect, creative collaboration, and emotional honesty rather than competition or posturing. This dynamic not only contributed to their professional success but also provided Webb with a relationship that challenged traditional masculine norms in its depth and vulnerability.

Chapter 5: Confronting Patterns: Alcohol, Family, and Self-Destruction

By his mid-thirties, Robert Webb had achieved considerable professional success, but his personal life revealed troubling patterns. Following the birth of his daughters with wife Abigail Burdess, Webb found himself repeating destructive behaviors he had witnessed in his father. Despite his conscious rejection of traditional masculinity, he fell into similar traps – emotional distance, excessive drinking, and an inability to fully engage with family responsibilities. This contradiction between his stated values and actual behavior created profound cognitive dissonance, fueling further self-medication through alcohol. Webb's relationship with alcohol evolved from social drinking to problematic dependence. While never reaching the point of physical addiction, his drinking became a primary coping mechanism for stress, anxiety, and the emotional demands of family life. He maintained professional functionality, never drinking before performances or during filming, but his home life suffered as evening drinking sessions extended later and grew heavier. The pattern became particularly concerning as he recognized how it mirrored his father's behavior – the very model he had sworn to reject. The impact on Webb's marriage and family was significant. His wife Abigail found herself shouldering a disproportionate share of parenting and household responsibilities despite their agreement to create an equal partnership. Webb's emotional and often physical absence during his daughters' early years created strain in his marriage and prevented him from fully experiencing the joys and challenges of fatherhood. When his wife told him, "You let me down" during a period when he was drinking heavily after their first daughter's birth, Webb had to face how he was repeating some of his father's mistakes. Recognition of these patterns came gradually rather than in a dramatic moment of clarity. Webb began to see how his behavior contradicted his self-image as a progressive, feminist man. The discrepancy between his public advocacy for gender equality and his private replication of traditional male patterns became increasingly difficult to ignore. This realization was painful but essential, forcing Webb to confront the gap between his intellectual understanding of harmful masculinity and his lived experience of perpetuating it. Webb's journey toward recovery involved multiple dimensions. He significantly reduced his alcohol consumption, recognizing how it undermined his capacity for emotional presence. He recommitted to therapy, addressing not only his current behaviors but their roots in childhood experiences. Perhaps most importantly, he began the difficult work of redefining his role as husband and father, taking more active responsibility for domestic labor and emotional care within his family. This process required both practical changes in daily habits and deeper psychological work to identify and transform ingrained patterns. The confrontation with his self-destructive tendencies represented a crucial turning point in Webb's relationship with masculinity. By recognizing how traditional masculine norms had shaped his behavior despite his conscious rejection of them, he gained deeper insight into their pervasive influence. This understanding informed not only his personal growth but also his public commentary on gender issues. Webb's willingness to acknowledge his own contradictions and struggles gave authenticity to his advocacy, demonstrating that challenging harmful masculinity requires ongoing self-reflection rather than simple declarations of enlightenment.

Chapter 6: Redefining Manhood: Fatherhood, Marriage, and Advocacy

Becoming a father to two daughters transformed Robert Webb's understanding of gender in profound ways. Watching Esme and Dory navigate a world still shaped by rigid gender expectations heightened his awareness of how early these influences begin. He observed with dismay how toys, clothes, media, and casual comments from adults all reinforced limiting stereotypes about what girls could be and do. This firsthand witness to gender conditioning in action strengthened Webb's resolve to create a different environment for his daughters – one where their humanity took precedence over their gender. Webb's approach to fatherhood evolved significantly as he worked to break generational patterns. Initially, he struggled to fulfill his commitment to equal parenting, falling back on traditional gender divisions despite his stated intentions. The gap between his feminist principles and his actual behavior created both guilt and motivation for change. Gradually, he developed a more engaged parenting style, taking active responsibility for childcare tasks traditionally assigned to mothers. This evolution required not only practical adjustments but also emotional growth – learning to be present, patient, and attuned to his children's needs. Marriage provided another arena for Webb to redefine masculinity. His relationship with Abigail Burdess, a fellow comedy writer, began with shared creative and intellectual interests. However, maintaining an equal partnership proved more challenging than Webb initially anticipated. The default patterns of heterosexual relationships – with women assuming greater responsibility for emotional and domestic labor – reasserted themselves despite both partners' commitment to equality. Recognizing and addressing these imbalances became an ongoing project, requiring honest communication and willingness to change entrenched habits. Webb's public voice on gender issues emerged alongside his personal evolution. In 2017, he published a memoir examining how traditional masculinity had shaped his life and relationships. The book combined personal narrative with cultural critique, using Webb's experiences to illuminate broader patterns of gender conditioning. This public examination of his own struggles with masculine norms resonated with readers seeking alternatives to traditional gender scripts. Webb's willingness to acknowledge his own contradictions and ongoing growth gave his perspective authenticity and nuance. The process of redefining masculinity extended beyond Webb's immediate family to his creative work and public persona. His comedy increasingly incorporated critiques of gender stereotypes, using humor to expose their absurdity. In interviews and social media, he advocated for more expansive understandings of gender that would benefit both women and men. Webb questioned what the word "masculinity" actually means beyond "conjuring a bunch of stereotypes about driving gloves and body odour." Through his writing and public speaking, he argued that "masculinity is something to recover from" – not because being male is problematic, but because traditional masculine expectations burden men with "a load of extra baggage that is worth noticing." Webb's journey toward a redefined masculinity remains ongoing rather than complete. He continues to navigate the tension between ingrained patterns and conscious choices, between cultural conditioning and personal agency. What distinguishes his approach is the recognition that challenging harmful masculinity requires continuous self-reflection rather than a one-time declaration of enlightenment. By embracing this process as lifelong rather than finite, Webb offers a model of masculinity characterized by growth, accountability, and the courage to change – qualities that benefit not only men themselves but everyone in their lives.

Summary

Robert Webb's journey represents a profound challenge to restrictive notions of masculinity. From his early struggles as a sensitive boy in working-class Lincolnshire to his evolution as a comedian, husband, and father, Webb has consistently questioned the arbitrary rules that limit male expression and experience. His story illuminates how gender conditioning shapes boys from their earliest years, creating patterns that can take a lifetime to recognize and transform. Through both painful lessons and hard-won insights, Webb demonstrates that breaking free from these constraints is not only possible but essential for authentic living. The core message of Webb's life story is that true strength lies in vulnerability rather than its suppression. By confronting his own contradictions – between his feminist principles and his behavior, between his critique of traditional masculinity and his unconscious replication of it – Webb offers a model of masculinity defined by growth rather than rigidity. His journey reminds us that challenging gender stereotypes benefits everyone, not just women. When men free themselves from the narrow confines of traditional masculinity, they gain access to the full range of human experience – emotional depth, meaningful connection, and the ability to care for themselves and others. In a world still struggling with toxic expressions of manhood, Webb's ongoing evolution provides both inspiration and practical guidance for anyone seeking to break free from limiting stereotypes and embrace their complete humanity.

About Author

Loading...

Robert Webb

Read more