How to Write One Song

How to Write One Song Plot Summary

Introduction

Every song begins with a simple act of defiance - the decision to create something where nothing existed before. Songwriting isn't just about musical talent or poetic prowess; it's about giving yourself permission to express what others might leave unsaid. Many people walk through life carrying melodies in their hearts and lyrics in their minds, yet never take that crucial step of bringing them into the world. What stops us from writing songs? Often, it's not a lack of ability but a paralyzing belief that our creations must be perfect or profound. The truth is that songwriting is accessible to anyone willing to silence their inner critic long enough to let imagination flow. Throughout these pages, we'll dismantle the barriers that separate you from your creative potential, providing practical approaches that transform songwriting from a mysterious talent possessed by the few into a liberating practice available to all.

Chapter 1: Giving Yourself Permission to Create

Songwriting begins with permission - specifically, the permission you give yourself to create without judgment. This fundamental shift in mindset transforms songwriting from something other people do into something you can do today. The greatest obstacle isn't technical knowledge or musical training but the belief that you're somehow not qualified to express yourself through song. Jeff Tweedy shares how he identified as a songwriter long before writing his first actual song. At around seven years old, he would confidently tell people, "Guess what? I'm a songwriter," despite not having written anything yet. This childhood delusion turned out to be remarkably effective self-actualization. He claimed the identity first, which eventually led him to write songs because he already saw himself as someone who could. His motivation was partly wanting to avoid being exposed as a fraud when someone inevitably asked to hear one of his songs. This story illustrates an important truth: you don't need to wait for permission or credentials to call yourself a songwriter. Tweedy emphasizes that "being" something isn't as real or meaningful as "doing" something. When you're focused on creating one song - not on becoming a famous songwriter or building a catalog of hits - you can bypass the paralysis that comes from comparing yourself to your heroes or worrying about your legitimacy. To start your songwriting journey, focus on verbs rather than nouns - what you want to do, not what you want to be. Many aspiring songwriters have dreamed of being Bob Dylan, but what they really want is to do what Dylan does - to make sounds that express something meaningful. And at that fundamental level, nothing is stopping you from doing exactly that. You might not play guitar or sing in the same way, but you can make your own sound and hear yourself. The path to songwriting begins with embracing the simple act of making noise, finding patterns you enjoy, and claiming those sounds as your own. No special qualifications required - just the willingness to start and the courage to hear yourself. Today, give yourself permission to create without worrying about the result. Make sounds, play with words, and allow yourself the freedom to experiment without judgment.

Chapter 2: Making Songwriting a Daily Practice

Establishing songwriting as a regular practice transforms it from an occasional burst of inspiration into a sustainable creative habit. When you commit to writing songs as part of your daily routine, you put yourself directly in the path of inspiration rather than waiting for it to strike randomly. Consistency is the secret weapon of nearly every prolific songwriter. Tweedy describes how he maintains a structured daily approach to songwriting that generates a steady stream of material. Each day, he focuses on three main activities: stockpiling words and lyrics through freewriting and poetic exercises; collecting musical ideas, melodies, and chord progressions; and finally, pairing these elements together. This methodical practice ensures he always has raw material to work with, even when inspiration feels distant. He notes that checking off even one of these activities daily maintains his creative momentum. What's particularly revealing about Tweedy's process is how he works with his natural rhythms rather than against them. He often writes late at night, right before sleep, when his critical mind begins to relax. He describes how this twilight state allows easier access to his subconscious, noting: "I truly think I do a lot of my best work while I'm asleep." He'll focus on a song before bed, and frequently wake with solutions to creative problems that had stumped him the previous evening. To establish your own songwriting practice, start small but remain consistent. Even five or ten minutes daily will accumulate significant material over time. Set a specific time - perhaps before work, during lunch, or right before bed - and protect it as sacred creative space. Keep tools of creation nearby: a notebook, phone recorder, or instrument within easy reach removes barriers to getting started. The key insight is that songwriting shouldn't feel like a struggle, even though it requires discipline. Tweedy challenges the romantic notion that great art must emerge from suffering, noting that "everyone suffers" to some degree, so the difference between those who create and those who don't isn't pain but persistence. "Working hard is a noble pursuit," he writes, distinguishing between difficult work and struggle. The bands you've heard of aren't necessarily the most talented - they're the ones who worked hardest at their craft. Remember that a daily songwriting practice isn't about producing finished masterpieces every day. It's about maintaining contact with your creative self and accumulating the raw materials from which songs eventually emerge. Through consistent practice, you train your subconscious to remain receptive to musical possibilities even when you're not actively writing.

Chapter 3: Collecting Words That Resonate

Words carry their own intrinsic music, rhythms, and emotional resonance. Before you worry about melody or chords, learning to collect and play with language gives you essential building blocks for songwriting. The goal is to break away from habitual speech patterns and discover fresh combinations that spark imagination. Tweedy shares how he deliberately works to shake up his language patterns through exercises like his "Word Ladder." In one example, he lists ten verbs associated with physicians (examine, thump, prescribe, etc.) alongside ten random nouns within his field of vision (cushion, guitar, wall, etc.). By connecting these unrelated words, he creates unexpected phrases like "the sunlight writes" or "the guitar is healing" that immediately evoke imagery and emotion. These combinations break language free from predictable pairings and generate the beginnings of lyrical ideas. In another revealing example, Tweedy describes how the Wilco song "I Am Trying to Break Your Heart" emerged from language exercises rather than a predetermined message. What makes this approach powerful is how it bypasses the common concern of "I don't know what to write about." Instead of starting with a theme, he lets meaningful patterns emerge through play. He explains: "I'm sure there will be some things that will surprise you, along with some nonsense." To collect your own resonant words, try several approaches. First, maintain a notebook or phone app where you immediately capture striking phrases, overheard conversations, or unusual word combinations. Second, experiment with exercises like Tweedy's "Word Ladder" or his technique of opening books randomly and letting words leap from the page to attach themselves to melodies you're humming. Third, record and transcribe your own conversations, mining your natural speech for authenticity. The key principle is avoiding self-judgment during this collection phase. Don't worry about creating perfect lyrics - focus instead on generating raw material you can refine later. Tweedy warns against overthinking or trying to sound poetic with fancy vocabulary: "Fancy multisyllabic words aren't going to make a lyric better." Simple, precise language used in unexpected ways typically creates more powerful lyrics than elaborate linguistic flourishes. For practical implementation, set aside regular time specifically for word collection. Try morning freewriting sessions before your critical mind fully awakens, or evening reflections when the day's experiences are fresh. Keep collection separate from evaluation - gather words freely now, decide what works later. This approach ensures you'll always have lyrical material available when musical inspiration strikes.

Chapter 4: Finding Music in Unexpected Places

Music surrounds us constantly, waiting to be recognized and captured. Beyond traditional instruments and formal training lies a world of sounds, rhythms, and melodies embedded in everyday life. Learning to hear and preserve these moments expands your musical vocabulary and provides fresh material for songwriting. Tweedy describes how he records not just guitar ideas but also environmental sounds that catch his attention: "I even record sounds I hear walking around outside that remind me of something musical. I just think, 'I want to hear that again,' and I don't know exactly why." Later, reviewing these recordings, he finds birdsongs from Australia alongside guitar snippets, both feeling equally valuable as creative catalysts. He views the conscious decision to record these sounds as a creative act in itself - an acknowledgment of beauty worth preserving. This approach challenges the notion that you need extensive musical training to write songs. Tweedy confesses he doesn't read music and lacks formal music theory background, yet has developed confident communication through his own musical language. To those who feel inadequate, he offers reassurance: "Have you ever heard a song and responded to it? OK, you know music!" He compares this to saying you can't talk without understanding grammar, or judge a painting without knowing color theory. To discover your own unexpected musical sources, begin by truly listening to your environment. Pay attention to rhythmic patterns in machinery, melodic qualities in speech, or harmonies in natural sounds. Record these using your phone's voice memo function to create a personal library of sonic inspiration. Additionally, experiment with unfamiliar instruments or music-making apps that place you in a beginner's mindset, where you're free from habitual patterns. For those with limited instrumental abilities, Tweedy suggests expanding the definition of "song" beyond traditional boundaries. A memorable moment, a signature greeting, even a physical gesture can contain musical qualities. The goal is to recognize that musicality exists in many forms beyond formal composition. The practical application involves creating simple recording habits and maintaining regular listening sessions. Set aside time to review your collected sounds, allowing unexpected connections to form between disparate elements. Remember that being a good listener is as important as being technically proficient - the best musicians are invariably those who hear possibilities others miss. As Tweedy notes, "I think the best musicians are the best listeners. I know there are a lot of musicians who can't play with a high level of physical aptitude or technique but who have made their worth known to the world through their ability to hear something nobody else has been able to."

Chapter 5: Pairing Words and Music Together

The magical moment in songwriting occurs when words and music unite to create something greater than either element alone. This pairing process, often shrouded in mystery, becomes more accessible when approached as a natural conversation between your collected words and musical ideas. Tweedy describes the emotion he experiences during this crucial pairing stage: "The moments that make my scalp tingle a bit are when I hear myself sing a lyric out loud for the first time. On occasion I make myself cry." This reaction doesn't come from pride in his cleverness, but from witnessing something unexpected being born - a truth he hadn't consciously intended to reveal. He shares how singing the seemingly simple lyric "She holds my hand between her knees / Like a dream I'm never sure what it means" unexpectedly surfaced buried memories of adolescent confusion during school dances. One practical method Tweedy uses for pairing words and music is what he calls "mumble tracks." When he has a melody but no lyrics, he sings nonsense syllables that fit the rhythm and vowel sounds of the eventual words. Recording these improvisations creates a template for the song's vocal phrasing. Later, he transcribes these mumblings, attempting to hear actual words in the sounds. Surprisingly, this process often reveals meaningful phrases: "I'm not smart enough to figure out how to account for that seemingly implausible feat, but I swear it has happened." To implement this pairing approach yourself, start by gathering your collected words and musical fragments. Play a melody or chord progression repeatedly while scanning your lyrical ideas, noting which phrases naturally align with the music's rhythm and emotional tone. Don't force connections - let the natural cadence of the words guide their placement within the musical structure. Record these experiments to evaluate them objectively later. Remember that songs often reveal their true nature during this pairing process rather than through preplanning. Tweedy compares his approach to Inuit carvers who don't impose a design on their material but instead reveal what's already hidden within: "The melody being the stone or ivory. I focus on just the sounds at first, carving toward words, and then words with meaning, until an image appears." The most important insight is that songs aren't mathematical equations with single correct solutions. The best pairings often surprise their creators. Trust the process, remain receptive to unexpected connections, and embrace the joy of discovery. As Tweedy explains, "When I'm in my most ideal state of creativity: I'm as excited about seeing what happens next as if I were watching myself do it."

Chapter 6: Breaking Through Creative Blocks

Creative blocks in songwriting aren't impenetrable walls but signals inviting a change in approach. Recognizing that these challenges are products of your own imagination gives you the power to dissolve them through practical strategies and mindset shifts. Tweedy challenges the very concept of "writer's block," reframing it as a judgment rather than an actual inability to create: "It's rare that you can't make anything. I don't believe a writer ever truly loses the ability to create. But all writers go through periods when they don't like what they're creating as much as they wish they did." This perspective transforms a seemingly immovable obstacle into a navigable challenge. In a revealing example, Tweedy describes being faced with a stubborn song that refused to take shape. Rather than abandoning it, he tried an unconventional approach - reversing the order of the chord progression while maintaining the original melody with minor adjustments. This simple reversal unlocked possibilities he hadn't previously considered. He also shares how rearranging a song's structure can profoundly transform its impact, citing lyrics from "An Empty Corner" that gained power simply by moving the final line to the opening position. When you encounter your own creative roadblocks, Tweedy offers several practical strategies. First, "start in the wrong place" by deliberately upending your usual approach - if you typically write on acoustic guitar, try electric; if you begin with verses, start with a chorus. Second, focus on your favorite fragment rather than the problematic sections: "Let's say you're stuck trying to finish a song. Do you have a favorite part? A favorite lyric? Start there." He notes that strong opening lines often provide enough momentum to carry through an entire song. Sometimes the wisest approach is to temporarily set aside a troublesome song. Tweedy explains how this creates space for your subconscious to work: "Put away whatever you're working on that you find frustrating. Don't think about it. Leave it alone." Returning later often reveals that the problems have untangled themselves, or that you can now see more clearly what the song actually wants to become rather than what you were forcing it to be. The most important insight is recognizing when your own judgment is creating the blockage. Our tendency to devalue what comes easily while romanticizing struggle can prevent us from accepting natural gifts. Tweedy admits he once felt embarrassed by the simple folk songs that flowed effortlessly from him, attempting to transform them into more complex compositions. Eventually he realized, "I was a lot more productive when I just went with it instead of trying to figure out how to turn a three-chord folk song into a prog-rock song." Remember that persistence matters. While avoiding unnecessary struggle, sometimes the only way through is forward: "Giving up becomes a habit. And the delayed gratification that comes from a song finished with some hardship is going to teach you more about writing songs than this entire book will ever be able to impart."

Chapter 7: Sharing Your Creation with the World

Sharing your song with others completes the creative cycle, transforming a private expression into a connection between souls. This final step requires vulnerability but offers rewards that transcend any anxiety about judgment or criticism. Tweedy makes one strong recommendation after you've written your song: "Play your song at least once for at least one person other than yourself." This doesn't necessitate a formal performance or professional recording - simply singing for someone you trust creates the essential bridge between private creation and shared experience. He explains that "the important part is that it's a consciousness outside of your own." The story of a sixty-something former heroin addict in an art therapy class powerfully illustrates why sharing matters. This woman, who had been virtually catatonic and hadn't spoken in group sessions, drew a simple self-portrait during therapy. When she held it up for others to see, she spoke for the first time, saying she couldn't remember when she'd last held a pencil. Tweedy describes the transformative moment: "She smiled! And cried. Everyone clapped and gathered around to hold her. It was such a stark, amazing, healing thing to see someone's eyes light up - become human again - when they realized they had the power to make something that wasn't there." While digital platforms offer unprecedented opportunities to share music globally, Tweedy focuses on the more intimate act of person-to-person sharing. He suggests that even playing for a pet could qualify - what matters is the experience of vulnerability and connection. This direct sharing reveals aspects of your song you might never notice alone, as you naturally adjust your delivery based on the listener's reactions. The act of sharing also helps you transcend perfectionism. When you sing for others, you might change words mid-performance or discover new emotional nuances in your creation. These moments of spontaneous adaptation demonstrate that songs aren't static artifacts but living expressions that evolve through performance. Tweedy observes: "Songs are pleas. It's all about reaching out and pulling in... or pushing out and looking in - in equal and unequal amounts." For practical implementation, start small. Choose a trusted friend, family member, or fellow songwriter for your first audience. Create a comfortable setting that minimizes performance anxiety, perhaps sharing over coffee or during a casual gathering. If singing directly for others feels too intimidating, consider recording your song and sending the audio file, though the live experience offers unique benefits. Remember that sharing isn't primarily about receiving validation or praise. It's about completing the creative circle, allowing your expression to exist in the space between people rather than solely within you. As Tweedy writes: "I would love for you to have the full weight of this one simple truth rest on your shoulders gently for long enough to understand what it is you've done."

Summary

Songwriting is an extraordinary act of defiance in a world that often discourages personal expression. Throughout these pages, we've explored how creation begins with permission - the permission you give yourself to make something imperfect, to experiment without judgment, and to value process over perfection. As Tweedy powerfully reminds us, "Each song and each act of creativity, indeed, is an act of defiance in a world that often feels determined to destroy itself." The journey of writing one song transforms how we experience creativity itself. Rather than waiting for inspiration or perfect circumstances, we've learned to establish daily practices that put us directly in inspiration's path. We've discovered how to collect resonant words, find music in unexpected places, pair these elements together, and break through creative blocks when they arise. Most importantly, we've recognized that sharing our creations completes the circle, turning private expression into connection. Your next step is simple but profound: set aside time today - even just fifteen minutes - to play with words, experiment with sounds, and begin your first song without expectations. Remember that "the songs we have yet to write will always be more important than the songs we've already sung, and certainly more important than the songs we never bring to life."

About Author

Loading...

Jeff Tweedy

Read more