Humble Inquiry

Humble Inquiry Plot Summary

Introduction

In a world dominated by the compulsion to tell rather than ask, we often miss opportunities for deeper connection and understanding. Think about the last time someone offered unsolicited advice when what you really needed was someone to listen. Or perhaps you've been in a leadership position where you felt pressured to have all the answers, rather than asking thoughtful questions that could unlock collective wisdom. The gentle art of asking instead of telling represents a fundamental shift in how we communicate and build relationships. When we approach conversations with genuine curiosity and humility, we create space for authentic connection. By mastering the skill of humble inquiry—asking questions to which we don't already know the answers—we can transform our personal relationships, our leadership effectiveness, and our ability to navigate complex situations. This approach isn't about appearing weak; rather, it demonstrates the strength to acknowledge interdependence and the wisdom to recognize that the most valuable insights often come from conversations where we've learned to truly listen to each other.

Chapter 1: Embrace Curiosity: The Foundation of Humble Inquiry

Humble Inquiry is the fine art of drawing someone out through questions to which you genuinely don't know the answer. It's about building relationships based on curiosity and interest in the other person. This approach goes beyond mere questioning technique—it's an entire attitude that includes listening deeply, responding appropriately, and revealing more of yourself in the relationship-building process. Edgar Schein, a renowned social psychologist, shares a revealing personal story that sparked his interest in this topic. While examining some unusual mushrooms that had grown after a heavy rain, an elderly woman walking her dog approached him and declared, "Some of those are poisonous, you know." When Schein replied that he knew this, she doubled down with "Some of them can kill you, you know." The interaction left him wondering why she hadn't simply asked what he was doing or what he was looking at. Her need to lecture not only offended him but also prevented any meaningful connection from forming between them. This seemingly trivial encounter highlights one of our most pervasive communication problems. We value telling each other things, showing off our knowledge, and winning arguments more than we value genuine inquiry. When we tell instead of ask, we temporarily put the other person down by implying they don't know something they should. We betray arrogance by assuming our knowledge is correct and that we have the right to structure other people's experiences for them. The practice of Humble Inquiry operates from a different foundation—what Schein calls "Here-and-now Humility." This isn't about being humble as a personality trait, but rather recognizing moments when we are dependent on others for information or help. When we acknowledge this interdependence, we naturally become more curious about what others know, creating psychological safety for them to share their knowledge. To develop the skill of Humble Inquiry, start by noticing when you feel the impulse to tell rather than ask. In those moments, pause and consider what you might learn by asking an open-ended question instead. Practice phrases like "Tell me more about that..." or "What led you to that conclusion?" These invitations create space for others to share what they know without feeling judged or directed. The beauty of embracing curiosity is that it transforms relationships while simultaneously helping us make better sense of complex situations that we cannot understand alone. When we approach conversations with genuine interest rather than predetermined answers, we open ourselves to insights that would otherwise remain hidden.

Chapter 2: Create Safety: Building Trust Through Questions

Creating psychological safety—an environment where people feel comfortable speaking up, sharing ideas, and even making mistakes—is essential for meaningful communication. The right kind of questions can establish this safety, while the wrong approach can shut down dialogue completely. Humble Inquiry helps create the conditions where truth can emerge without fear. A powerful example of this comes from a story about a large urban energy utility where safety was paramount. When a worker was immediately terminated for lifting his protective face shield (violating a firm safety rule), his manager conducted a mandatory review. Rather than merely enforcing the rule, the manager asked open-ended questions: "What were you thinking? Can you tell me the whole story of what happened that day?" The worker explained that his shield had completely fogged up in the hot, humid conditions, making it impossible to see the equipment he needed to fix. When the manager inquired if there were anti-fogging shields available for such weather, the worker revealed there weren't. This conversation led to a complete reversal of the situation. Not only was the employee reinstated due to the extenuating circumstances, but he was also asked to join a task force to find better safety equipment. The manager's questions—though initially sounding accusatory—were asked with a sincere desire to understand the full context, communicating mutual fact-finding rather than punishment. The psychological safety created through these questions allowed the truth to emerge—that the company's equipment was inadequate for certain weather conditions. Had the manager simply enforced the rule without inquiry, this valuable information would have remained hidden, and the underlying safety issue would have persisted. To create safety through your questions, adopt an attitude that makes it clear you're genuinely interested in learning rather than judging or testing. Pay attention to your tone, timing, and body language—all of which can either support or contradict your verbal questions. Make sure to acknowledge and appreciate the information shared, even when it's not what you expected to hear. Remember that building trust requires consistency. A single conversation conducted with Humble Inquiry can open the door, but maintaining that open door requires regularly demonstrating that you value others' insights and perspective. The more you practice asking questions that create safety, the more naturally this approach will become part of your communication style.

Chapter 3: Listen Deeply: Beyond Hearing Words

Listening deeply is perhaps the most underrated yet critical component of effective Humble Inquiry. It's not merely about hearing words, but fully receiving what another person is communicating—verbally and non-verbally—and demonstrating that you've understood. This level of listening transforms relationships and unlocks insights that superficial conversation misses. Ken Olsen, the founder of Digital Equipment Corporation, demonstrated masterful deep listening when interviewing Edgar Schein for a consultant position. When Schein arrived at Olsen's office, he noticed several canoe paddles and photographs of woods and streams on the walls. Schein asked about them, and Olsen responded with an enthusiastic detailed account of his summer escapes to the Canadian wilderness. After this exchange and just a few professional questions, Olsen immediately invited Schein to attend the weekly meeting of the operations committee—the governing group of the company—saying simply, "Just observe us and see if you can help." Reflecting on this interaction, Schein realized that the "chemistry" between them had been built naturally and quickly because he had shown genuine curiosity about something Olsen was passionate about. His attentive listening to Olsen's response about the canoe paddles had drawn them together personally in a way that bridged professional distance. This interaction demonstrated how deep listening can rapidly build trust and connection. Deep listening requires a willingness to be fully present and attentive to both what is said and what remains unsaid. It means temporarily setting aside your own agenda, suspending judgment, and resisting the urge to formulate your response while the other person is still speaking. When you listen in this way, you often discover important context that would have otherwise remained hidden. To practice deep listening, focus first on becoming aware of your listening habits. Notice when your mind wanders or when you interrupt. Make a conscious effort to maintain eye contact, provide encouraging verbal and non-verbal cues, and ask clarifying questions that demonstrate your engagement. Most importantly, learn to be comfortable with silence—those moments after someone speaks often contain the most revealing insights if you give them space to emerge. The payoff of deep listening extends beyond the immediate conversation. When people feel truly heard, they're more likely to speak honestly, share creative ideas, and commit to collective solutions. As Schein discovered with Ken Olsen, a single conversation characterized by deep listening can establish a foundation of trust that supports a productive relationship for years to come.

Chapter 4: Navigate Difficult Conversations With Questions

Difficult conversations—those laden with potential conflict, disagreement, or emotional tension—are often where the art of asking instead of telling proves most valuable. The right questions can transform potentially adversarial exchanges into collaborative problem-solving sessions, allowing all parties to maintain dignity while working toward resolution. A compelling example of this approach comes from a consulting engagement with a large Australian petrochemical conglomerate. During lunch with the senior management team, the CEO brought up the issue of filling a vacant VP of Administration position. Stuart seemed like a good candidate for promotion, but the other two VPs expressed vague discomfort without being able to specify why they felt uncomfortable. The conversation stalled in ambiguity. After observing this exchange, consultant Edgar Schein asked what seemed like a naive question: "What does the VP of Administration do?" Despite receiving some impatient smiles, the executives explained the role covered finance, accounting, personnel, long-range planning, and public relations. This question prompted a breakthrough—one VP suddenly identified that Stuart's weakness in public relations was causing their hesitation. The team quickly realized they could separate PR into a new role focused on environmental regulations, while promoting Stuart to handle the internal administrative functions he was perfect for. This intervention illustrates the power of what Schein calls "accessing my ignorance" in difficult conversations. By asking a basic question that no one else was willing to ask, he helped unlock a solution that had been obscured by the executives' inability to articulate their concerns clearly. The question allowed them to reframe the problem in a way that honored Stuart's strengths while addressing legitimate organizational needs. When navigating difficult conversations, start by slowing down and becoming aware of your emotional reactions. Notice if you're feeling defensive, angry, or anxious, as these emotions often trigger telling rather than asking. Instead of reacting, try framing a question that helps clarify the situation: "Can you help me understand your perspective?" or "What do you see as the core issue here?" Follow up with questions that explore possibilities: "What options haven't we considered yet?" or "How might we approach this differently?" These types of questions shift the focus from positions to interests and from blame to joint problem-solving. They create space for new insights to emerge. Remember that the effectiveness of your questions depends not just on their content but on how you ask them. Questions asked with genuine curiosity and respect will yield different responses than those perceived as challenges or accusations. Your tone, timing, and body language all contribute to how your questions are received in difficult conversations.

Chapter 5: Practice Mindful Inquiry in Leadership

Leadership traditionally emphasizes having answers and providing direction. However, in today's complex and rapidly changing environment, the most effective leaders are often those who excel at asking thoughtful questions that engage collective intelligence. Mindful inquiry—asking questions with full awareness of purpose, context, and impact—is a powerful leadership tool that builds engagement while uncovering crucial insights. A revealing story about leadership through inquiry comes from DEC CEO Ken Olsen's management style. He would wander around the company, stop at an engineer's desk and ask, "What are you working on?" Unlike many executives who might use such questions as a form of surveillance, Olsen conveyed genuine interest. These conversations could develop into lengthy technical discussions that were satisfying for both Olsen and the engineer. Even as the company grew to over 100,000 employees worldwide, Olsen was well-loved because so many had experienced him as a "humble inquirer" in this manner. What made Olsen's approach particularly effective was his ability to demonstrate that he wasn't checking up on people but was genuinely interested in their work. This approach humanized relationships across hierarchical boundaries. Despite occasionally being "brutal and tyrannical" when disappointed by senior managers who failed to treat their own employees with similar respect, Olsen's fundamental approach valued learning through inquiry. To practice mindful inquiry in your leadership, start by reflecting on your current questioning habits. Are you asking questions to which you already know the answers? Are you using questions as indirect ways of giving orders? Or are you genuinely curious about what others might contribute? Effective mindful inquiry begins with honest self-assessment. Develop the discipline of asking questions that open possibilities rather than narrowing options. Instead of "Have you considered doing X?" try "What approaches have you considered so far?" Before offering solutions, ask "What do you see as the main challenges here?" or "What would success look like to you?" These questions demonstrate respect for others' expertise while encouraging deeper thinking. Create regular opportunities for inquiry in your leadership routine. This might include beginning meetings with open questions, scheduling "listening tours" to understand different perspectives in your organization, or implementing after-action reviews that focus on learning rather than blame. The consistent practice of mindful inquiry signals to your team that their insights are valued and creates a culture where ideas can flow freely. The paradox of leadership through inquiry is that by asking rather than telling, you often strengthen rather than diminish your leadership influence. When people feel their perspectives matter, they become more engaged, creative, and committed to shared goals.

Chapter 6: Transform Relationships Through Humble Questions

Relationships—whether personal or professional—thrive on mutual understanding and trust. Humble questions provide a powerful way to deepen connections by signaling genuine interest in the other person's experience, creating space for authentic sharing, and establishing patterns of openness that can transform relationships over time. A powerful example of relationship transformation through questions occurred when Edgar Schein was asked to chair a task force for a regional environmental organization's capital campaign. The CEO was anxious to begin the first meeting by telling the board members about mistakes made in a previous campaign. Schein suggested an alternative approach focused on relationship-building. After an informal dinner, he took the floor and proposed: "While we have our dessert and coffee, why don't we go around the room, speaking from the heart about why we belong here and why each of us is committed to this organization." What followed was transformative. In just thirty minutes, board members who had previously known each other only casually saw each other as "whole people" with shared passion for the organization's mission. The exercise revealed their collective energy and commitment to the difficult capital campaign ahead. The approach was so effective that it was later extended to staff meetings, where employees expressed surprise at hearing the board's heartfelt commitment—many said it was the first time they had experienced such authentic communication from their board. This story illustrates how humble questions that invite personal reflection and sharing can rapidly transform group dynamics. By creating space for people to reveal their motivations and values, Schein helped build the trust and cohesion necessary for the challenging work ahead. To transform your own relationships through humble questions, start by identifying relationships that would benefit from deeper connection. Consider which conversations tend to remain superficial or transactional when they could be more meaningful. Then, look for opportunities to ask questions that invite the other person to share their perspective, experience, or values. Effective relationship-building questions often include: "What matters most to you about this project?", "How did you come to be interested in this field?", or "What's been your experience with this situation?" Follow up with questions that show you're truly listening: "Can you tell me more about that?" or "How did that affect you?" These questions demonstrate that you value the other person's unique perspective. Remember that relationship transformation is a reciprocal process. As you ask humble questions, be willing to share your own thoughts and experiences when invited. Authentic relationships develop through mutual disclosure, not one-sided interrogation. The goal is creating a safe space where both people feel seen, heard, and valued.

Summary

The art of asking instead of telling represents a profound shift in how we approach our conversations, relationships, and leadership challenges. Throughout this exploration, we've discovered that humble inquiry—asking questions to which we don't already know the answer—creates the foundation for genuine connection and collaborative problem-solving. As Edgar Schein powerfully states, "Humble Inquiry is the fine art of drawing someone out, of asking questions to which you do not already know the answer, of building a relationship based on curiosity and interest in the other person." The practice of humble inquiry doesn't require special techniques or elaborate strategies—it simply asks us to approach others with genuine curiosity and the willingness to temporarily suspend our own agenda. Begin today by choosing one conversation where you'll consciously practice asking instead of telling. Notice how this shift affects the quality of the interaction and what new insights emerge when you create space for others to share their knowledge and perspective. Through this simple yet profound practice, you can transform your relationships, enhance your effectiveness, and contribute to building a world where people truly listen to each other.

About Author

Loading...

Edgar H. Schein

Read more

Related Books by Edgar H. Schein

Loading...

Helping

Edgar H. Schein

How to Offer, Give, and Receive Help

★★★½☆3.9