Languishing

Languishing Plot Summary

Introduction

Have you ever felt stuck in a strange emotional limbo - not depressed enough to seek help, but far from thriving? This middle state, known as languishing, affects millions of people who appear functional on the surface while experiencing an inner emptiness. The pandemic brought this condition into sharp focus, but it has been silently spreading through our society for decades, leaving people feeling disconnected despite our hyperconnected world. The science of mental wellness has undergone a revolution in recent years, moving beyond the traditional focus on treating illness to understanding what makes humans truly flourish. This book explores the groundbreaking dual-continua model that shows mental health is more than just the absence of mental illness - it's a separate dimension that requires its own cultivation. You'll discover why happiness alone isn't enough for psychological well-being, how specific "vitamins" like connection and purpose nourish our mental health, and practical strategies to move from languishing to flourishing even during challenging times.

Chapter 1: Understanding Languishing: The Middle Ground of Mental Health

Languishing represents a state of emotional emptiness and stagnation - a feeling of running on empty. It's not depression, as you're not hopelessly sad or unable to get out of bed, but rather a sense of restless emptiness that pervades your days. You might feel emotionally flattened, disconnected from your community, and experience a persistent unease that something is missing from your life. Tasks that once gave you meaning now seem pointless, and small setbacks leave you feeling defeated. This condition often sets in slowly and imperceptibly until suddenly you're engulfed in it. When someone asks "How are you?", it feels like an unwelcome pop quiz because you don't quite know the answer yourself. Languishing makes you more vulnerable to a wide variety of risks, including developing post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, and even premature death. It's particularly prevalent during three phases of life: adolescence (ages 12-19), young adulthood (ages 25-34), and after age 75. Languishing affects people across all demographics. Teenagers might act out through risky behaviors as they struggle with identity and belonging. College students report feeling disconnected despite being surrounded by peers. Young professionals juggle career pressures and family responsibilities while questioning their life choices. Even those with objectively enviable lives - loving families, good jobs, nice homes - can experience this sense of emptiness and disconnection. The pandemic magnified our mental and emotional distress, but we've been traveling down this path for quite some time. Modern life often leaves us hungry for richer, more meaningful connections. We crave belonging, warm relationships, and acceptance. The irony is that many of us feel too drained to pursue the very connections that would help us flourish. Languishing is not just a personal struggle but a public health problem. It impairs our ability to function in countless ways - from reduced work productivity to ethical lapses in professional settings. It makes us more vulnerable to mental illness and creates a vicious cycle where disconnection leads to more disconnection. Understanding languishing is the first step toward breaking this cycle.

Chapter 2: The Dual-Continua Model: Redefining Mental Wellness

The dual-continua model of mental health represents a revolutionary way to understand our psychological wellbeing. Unlike traditional approaches that view mental health as simply the absence of mental illness, this model proposes that mental health and mental illness exist on two separate but related dimensions. You can have high mental health with mental illness, low mental health without mental illness, or any combination in between. This insight comes from research showing that depression and wellbeing have a surprisingly modest correlation. Reducing symptoms of depression doesn't automatically increase levels of wellbeing. The brain structures that activate when we feel sad aren't simply the inverse of those that light up when we feel happy. There's some overlap, but happiness isn't merely the opposite of sadness when it comes to how our brain is wired. The dual-continua model exists throughout our biology. Our immune system contains both harmful agents (representing the negative axis) and protective elements (the positive axis). Our cholesterol system has both "bad" and "good" cholesterol, with optimal heart health requiring both low levels of bad cholesterol and high levels of good cholesterol. Similarly, telomeres (the protective caps on our chromosomes) can be damaged by stress but protected by telomerase, a substance that increases with positive social connections. This model has profound implications for treatment approaches. Even if we had a cure for mental illness—which we don't—people might then be free of mental illness but not necessarily flourishing. Some psychiatric medications can cause emotional blunting, turning down the volume on sadness but also on positive emotions, potentially leaving patients languishing. This explains why treating mental illness alone isn't enough to create flourishing. The dual-continua model is even encoded in our DNA. Studies of twins show that flourishing and languishing are just as heritable as depression or anxiety, with about 60% of both conditions attributable to genetics. However, having a high genetic liability to mental illness doesn't preordain an individual to low levels of wellbeing. The genes that predict mental illness overlap with those that predict mental health by just under half, meaning there's substantial genetic independence between the two dimensions.

Chapter 3: Beyond Happiness: Why Functioning Well Matters

We humans often get fooled by feelings, chasing happiness directly only to find it eludes us. Happiness is an emotion—like anger, fear, disgust, surprise, and sadness—and emotions, by definition, are fleeting. They're like wind socks at an airport, indicating which direction the wind is blowing at any given moment so we can direct our activities accordingly. They're not built to last. Happiness serves an evolutionary purpose: when we get something we want or need, we experience a dopamine rush that signals pleasure and reward. This helps our brain remember the details of the experience that brought that reward. For our ancestors, pleasure came from basic needs like food and belonging to a tribe. Our brain makes us feel happy when we get what we want because it knows we'll need more of it to sustain ourselves. The problem begins when we place pleasure and happiness on a pedestal. Western cultures, particularly American society, have become obsessed with feeling good. We've transformed the world from a place of scarcity to one of overwhelming abundance, with countless opportunities for quick dopamine hits. We're like greyhounds pursuing a mechanical rabbit around a never-ending track—never completing our quest and never in control of the outcome. Eastern cultures, by contrast, have reservations about the single-minded pursuit of bliss, encouraging us instead to prepare the mind for the inevitable pain life brings. They advocate for psychological flexibility—the ability to accept negative experiences and choose how to respond based on our values. This approach helps us stop perceiving difficult emotions as threats or personal failures, but rather as temporary sources of discomfort that we can treat with tenderness. Flourishing encompasses three kinds of well-being: emotional, psychological, and social. The emotional component involves feeling happy, satisfied, or interested in life. The psychological component includes having purpose, personal growth, self-acceptance, autonomy, environmental mastery, and positive relationships. The social component involves social contribution, integration, acceptance, actualization, and coherence. Research shows that people who only feel good (emotional well-being) without functioning well (psychological and social well-being) have much higher rates of mental illness than those who are flourishing. When we prioritize functioning well over merely feeling good, we create a virtuous cycle that leads to genuine flourishing. The happiness we seek will come as a by-product of working on ourselves to become better people.

Chapter 4: The Five Vitamins Essential for Psychological Flourishing

Just as our bodies need specific nutrients to function optimally, our minds require certain psychological "vitamins" to flourish. These five essential elements—Learning, Connecting, Transcending, Helping, and Playing—work together to create the conditions for mental wellness, much like physical vitamins support bodily health. Learning involves acquiring new knowledge or skills of your own choosing, for your own reasons. When we learn something new that matters to us personally, it enhances our self-image and contributes to psychological well-being. This isn't about formal education or acquiring credentials; it's about following genuine curiosity and expanding your sense of self. A Brooklyn resident who discovers gardening during a pandemic isn't just learning about plants—he's becoming a different person with new capabilities and perspectives. For learning to boost well-being, it must be autonomous and meaningful, not forced or externally motivated. Connecting refers to building and maintaining warm, trusting relationships characterized by reciprocity and equality. These connections need to go beyond shared interests or casual interactions to provide genuine emotional sustenance. True connection happens when both parties give and receive freely without scorekeeping, when there's mutual empathy and understanding, and when both feel they matter to each other. Research consistently shows that the quality of our relationships predicts our mental health more strongly than almost any other factor, including income, education, or physical health. Transcending involves practicing acceptance and directing kind attention toward ourselves and others. Whether through meditation, spiritual practices, or simply appreciating beauty and wonder, transcendence helps us become comfortable with being part of something bigger than ourselves. It teaches us to accept what we cannot change, quiet our minds, and respond to life's inevitable challenges based on our values rather than react out of fear or anger. This vitamin helps us develop mental flexibility—the ability to stay present with difficult experiences while making conscious choices aligned with what matters most to us. Helping means finding your purpose by identifying where your deep gladness meets the world's deep need. Purpose isn't about grand ambitions or changing the world; it can be found in providing essential care to loved ones or filling an unmet need in your community. When we dedicate some portion of our lives to personally and socially important activities, we discover a sense of "mattering" that gives life direction and meaning. Purpose creates a virtuous cycle where contributing to others' well-being enhances our own. Playing involves stepping out of time through activities done for their own sake, not for achievement or productivity. Whether it's learning a new hobby, exploring an unfamiliar place, or simply engaging in something that brings joy, play quiets our preoccupation with outcomes and deadlines. Unlike work or other goal-directed activities, play creates a psychological space where we can experiment, take risks, and express ourselves freely. This vitamin is often the first to be sacrificed in our busy lives, yet it's essential for creativity, problem-solving, and emotional regulation. These vitamins work synergistically—each enhances the effects of the others. Rather than trying to incorporate all five perfectly every day, aim for a balanced "diet" over time, stealing even small moments for these nourishing activities. The clarity of your intentions matters more than the quantity of time spent; approach these vitamins with humility and authenticity rather than as another set of achievements to showcase.

Chapter 5: Connection: Building Warm and Trusting Relationships

Meaningful connections form the bedrock of flourishing, yet many of us struggle to develop them in our increasingly interconnected but paradoxically isolated world. We often mistake having friends for cultivating friendships. The difference is profound: friends provide casual interaction, while friendships offer deep emotional sustenance. True friendships hinge on reciprocity, with both sides giving and receiving freely without scorekeeping. They require a mutual sense of equality, empathy, understanding, collaboration, and compromise. Consider what emotionally close and satisfying friendships look like in practice. When you share that you've had a difficult day, a casual friend might respond with their own story, while a true friend asks thoughtful questions and offers meaningful support. When facing a crisis like a parent's hospitalization, a casual friend expresses concern, while a true friend offers concrete help—driving you to the hospital or bringing food for your family. Both types of connections have value, but flourishing requires the deeper variety. Our need for connection is so fundamental that people will go to extraordinary lengths to find it. Even gangs provide a sense of belonging, protection, and purpose that their members might not find elsewhere. Throughout human evolution, our survival depended on being useful, valued members of a group. This tribal nature remains part of our social DNA, teaching us the necessity of connection that comes from membership in something—whether church choirs, sports teams, or close friend groups. Many of us struggle with feeling we don't belong or aren't equal to those around us. Childhood messages that we're outsiders can warp our self-narrative, making it nearly impossible to trust that people will accept us if we let our guards down. As Brené Brown wrote, "I don't think there's anything lonelier than being with people and feeling alone." Breaking through these barriers requires deep inner work to challenge false beliefs about our worthiness and build a self-narrative around our fundamental equality. The concept of "mattering" represents a vital ingredient in flourishing. Do people depend on you? Do they listen to what you say? Would you be missed if you were suddenly gone? Research shows that feelings of not mattering are strongly linked to loneliness, low self-esteem, and decreased sense of competence. This creates a vicious cycle: when we feel we don't matter, we withdraw from activities that give us a sense of social contribution, which further diminishes our sense of mattering. As we age, the quality of our emotional support increases even as the quantity may decline. We become less likely to respond to a friend in crisis with unsolicited advice or by shifting attention to ourselves. Instead, we develop better listening skills, perspective-taking abilities, patience, and unconditional acceptance. We also experience more balanced exchanges of support, leading to greater satisfaction in our relationships. We learn that when it comes to connection, quality truly matters more than quantity.

Chapter 6: Transcendence: Accepting Life's Inevitable Challenges

Transcendence involves practicing acceptance and directing kind attention toward ourselves and others. It doesn't necessarily require religious belief or spiritual practice, though these can be powerful vehicles. At its core, transcendence means understanding that we are part of something much bigger than ourselves—what Einstein called the realization that our sense of separateness is "a kind of optical delusion of consciousness." The serenity prayer captures this essence perfectly: "God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference." The only thing we truly have power over is ourselves—how we think, feel, and behave. We are powerless over pretty much everything else. When we accept this truth, we can respond to life's surprises based on our deeply held values rather than react out of fear, anger, or frustration. Self-acceptance forms the foundation for accepting others. Research shows that people who are flourishing have a higher disposition to apologize and greater self-compassion. When we make mistakes or hurt others, shame can prevent growth, while self-compassion allows us to be vulnerable, imperfect, and learn from our errors. As Shauna Shapiro, a psychologist who studies compassion, discovered, even small acts of self-kindness—like simply saying "Good morning" to yourself in the mirror—can foster greater tenderness toward yourself and others. Mental flexibility represents another key aspect of transcendence. A flexible mind remains in contact with negative experiences rather than avoiding them, and makes conscious choices based on values and goals. When faced with challenges—like a last-minute work request requiring a complete report rewrite—an inflexible reaction might be refusal, while a flexible response would involve acknowledging frustration but then collaboratively solving the problem. This approach aligns with Buddhist teachings that suffering exists but we can mitigate it by responding to adversity based on personal values. Spiritual and religious practices serve as "rehearsals" for developing these qualities. Whether through meditation, prayer, or other contemplative practices, we strengthen our mind's capacity to lead rather than be led by negative emotions. A transplant surgeon who began meditating before surgeries not only improved her relationships with colleagues but also achieved noticeably better surgical outcomes. The practice taught her to exist inside a moment—without allowing mistakes from the past or concerns about the future to intrude. Transcendence also involves connecting to something larger than ourselves, which makes us feel less alone. Religious attendance is associated with higher levels of social integration and support, which protect against loneliness. But even without formal religion, we can invite more mystery into our lives—mystery about ourselves, others, and the universe. When we feel connected to something bigger, we don't feel alone because we sense we're walking with a higher power.

Chapter 7: Finding Purpose: Where Joy Meets the World's Needs

Purpose emerges at the intersection of what brings you joy and what the world needs. Unlike happiness, which is fleeting and often self-focused, purpose provides a sustained sense of meaning by connecting your unique gifts with something larger than yourself. It answers the fundamental question: "Why am I here?" not with abstract philosophy, but with concrete direction for your energy and attention. Finding your purpose doesn't require grand ambitions or world-changing goals. It can be as simple as identifying an unmet need in your family, workplace, or community that you're uniquely positioned to address. A teacher who excels at explaining complex concepts might find purpose in helping struggling students. A naturally empathetic person might find purpose in supporting friends through difficult times. What matters isn't the scale of your contribution but the alignment between your authentic self and the needs you're addressing. Purpose serves as a powerful antidote to languishing by providing clarity amidst life's ambiguities. When you know why you're here and what matters most to you, decisions become easier and setbacks less devastating. Research shows that people with a strong sense of purpose recover more quickly from negative events, experience less stress during challenging times, and maintain better physical health as they age. Purpose creates resilience by anchoring us to something enduring when circumstances change. The search for purpose often begins with curiosity about your own patterns of engagement and energy. Notice when you lose track of time, when you feel most alive, or when you're willing to endure difficulties without complaint. These moments offer clues about what truly matters to you. Similarly, pay attention to what problems or injustices consistently catch your attention or stir your emotions. The intersection of these internal signals with external needs points toward your unique purpose. Purpose evolves throughout life, adapting to changing circumstances and capacities. What gives your life meaning at 25 may differ from what fulfills you at 50 or 75. This evolution doesn't indicate failure but growth—as you develop new skills, gain wisdom from experience, and face different life stages, your purpose naturally shifts. The retired executive who becomes a mentor to young professionals or the empty-nester who volunteers with community organizations isn't abandoning their purpose but refining it. Cultivating purpose requires both reflection and action. Reflection helps you identify what matters most, while action tests and refines your understanding through real-world experience. This cycle of reflection and action creates a virtuous spiral where purpose becomes increasingly clear and compelling over time. Even small steps toward purposeful living—volunteering an hour weekly, mentoring one person, or addressing one community need—can initiate this positive cycle and begin moving you from languishing toward flourishing.

Summary

The journey from languishing to flourishing represents one of the most important paths we can take for our mental wellness. By understanding that mental health isn't merely the absence of mental illness but the presence of positive functioning, we gain a powerful framework for improving our lives. The dual-continua model shows us that we can work on building our psychological, social, and emotional well-being even when facing challenges or mental health conditions. The five vitamins of flourishing—learning, connecting, transcending, helping, and playing—offer practical ways to move up the continuum from languishing to flourishing. These aren't quick fixes or temporary mood boosters but fundamental practices that build our capacity for meaningful engagement with life. When we learn new things that expand our self-narrative, cultivate deep reciprocal relationships, practice acceptance of life's inevitable challenges, find purpose in meeting the world's needs, and make time for play, we create a virtuous cycle of well-being that increases our resilience to stress and adversity. The most profound insight may be that flourishing isn't about perfection or constant happiness, but about functioning well across multiple dimensions of life. By shifting our focus from merely feeling good to functioning well, we discover that happiness arrives naturally as a by-product of living with purpose, connection, and growth.

About Author

Loading...

Corey Keyes

Corey Keyes is a sociologist and professor emeritus at Emory University whose research on mental health—including his pioneering work on the science of human flourishing—has had wide-reaching policy implications. Over the course of his career, he’s advised the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the World Happiness Forum, as well as governmental agencies in Canada, Northern Ireland, and Australia.

Read more