Masters of Scale

Masters of Scale Plot Summary

Introduction

Have you ever faced a moment when your brilliant idea was met with a resounding "no"? Perhaps you've pitched a concept to your boss, only to watch their eyes glaze over. Or maybe you've poured your heart into a project, only to have it rejected by those who simply didn't get your vision. These moments of rejection can feel devastating—but what if they're actually the foundation of something extraordinary? The most successful entrepreneurs in the world share a counterintuitive secret: they don't just survive rejection—they transform it into their competitive advantage. Through intimate stories from founders who built billion-dollar enterprises, we discover how rejection becomes the refining fire for truly revolutionary ideas. You'll learn how to extract valuable insights from every "no," how to identify when to persist versus when to pivot, and most importantly, how to develop the resilience that turns setbacks into stepping stones. The path to scaling any vision isn't a straight line upward—it's a winding journey of adaptation, where the ability to transform obstacles into opportunities separates those who merely start from those who ultimately succeed.

Chapter 1: The Gold in Rejection: Kathryn Minshew's 148 No's

When she first pitched her idea for a new kind of career development website to investors, Kathryn Minshew was turned down 148 times...not that she was counting. "There were literally days where I had a 'No' over breakfast, a 'No' over a 10:30 a.m. coffee, a 'No' over lunch," Kathryn says. And the "Nos" kept coming: "Disinterest at 2 p.m. Someone who left the meeting early at 4. And then I would go to drinks and feel like I was being laughed out of the room." Kathryn is co-founder and CEO of The Muse, and her idea sprang from her own frustrating job search experience. After working at McKinsey & Company for three years, she found the process of finding a new job disappointing and dehumanizing. "It wasn't uncommon to type in a keyword on a job-listing site like Monster.com and get 5,724 results—and they all looked functionally identical to each other," she recalls. She and her co-founder Alex Cavoulacos envisioned a career site that would put individuals at the center, allowing them to see inside offices before applying and connecting them with experts for career advice. The rejections from investors came in various forms. Some said it was "too early" for them. Others called it "a fool's errand" or questioned whether women outside coastal cities would even care about their careers. One particularly memorable response came when a venture capitalist pulled up Monster.com after her pitch and said, "I don't understand, this looks great to me." Kathryn thought to herself, "You haven't used that product in two decades. How do you know whether it serves the needs of a thirty-one-year-old woman in the early to mid-stages of her career?" Despite the constant rejection, Kathryn persisted. She trusted her instincts and the positive feedback from actual users who were saying "I love this. This solves my problem, this is exactly what I need." Eventually, her persistence paid off. Today, The Muse serves nearly one hundred million users, has raised more than $28 million, and employs a staff of two hundred. The most overlooked opportunity among early-stage entrepreneurs is the information to be gathered from different kinds of "Nos." A "No" can turn a good idea into a game-changing one. A "No" can clue you in to the size of your idea. A "No" can help you refine your strategy and your goals. In short, the gold is buried in the "Nos."

Chapter 2: Do Things That Don't Scale: Brian Chesky's User Obsession

In 2009, Brian Chesky, a young entrepreneur with a big idea, was meeting with Paul Graham, co-founder of Y Combinator, the renowned Silicon Valley startup accelerator. Brian's company, Airbnb, was partway through the Y Combinator program, and he was ready to wow Paul with his vision of a bright future for an unconventional new business that enabled people to rent out their spare rooms to total strangers. When Brian proudly shared his ambitious plans and rosy projections, Paul's response was unexpected. He asked, "So where's your business?" When Brian admitted they didn't have much traction yet, with just a few users in New York, Paul was blunt: "What are you still doing here in Mountain View? Go to your users. Get to know them. One by one." Brian protested, "But that won't scale. If we're huge and we have millions of customers, we can't meet every customer." Paul's reply became legendary advice for entrepreneurs everywhere: "That's exactly why you should do it now." Taking this advice to heart, Brian and his co-founder Joe Gebbia flew to New York and began photographing their hosts' apartments themselves. During one memorable visit, a host disappeared into a back room and returned with a binder full of detailed suggestions for improving Airbnb. "It was like he created a roadmap for us," Brian recalls. "I think that always stuck in our mind. The roadmap often exists in the minds of the users you're designing things for." Brian and Joe didn't just meet their users; they lived with them. "I used to joke that when you bought an iPhone, Steve Jobs didn't come sleep on your couch, but I did," Brian says. These deep interactions helped them understand what would make the Airbnb experience truly special. Brian developed a technique for extracting valuable feedback by asking bold questions like "What would it take for me to design something that you would literally tell every single person you've ever encountered?" This handcrafting approach extended to later innovations like Airbnb Trips. Before launching this feature, Brian's team followed a single traveler named Ricardo through his lonely, tourist-trap-filled trip to San Francisco. Then they invited him back and designed a transformative experience with local connections and authentic adventures. "We applied this to Trips and spent the last couple of years figuring out how to scale it," Brian explains. The lesson is clear: To build something people truly love, you must first understand them deeply, one by one. As Brian often tells entrepreneurs who are still small: "I miss those times. Yes, it's great to have a company that has traction—but the biggest leaps, the greatest innovations you're ever going to get, will happen when you're small."

Chapter 3: Strategic Patience: Tory Burch's Doorless Opening Day

It was opening day for Tory Burch's startup—her big opportunity to debut her new clothing line at her new store during New York Fashion Week. Tory was ready. She had found an affordable downtown space. She had racks of clothes she'd designed herself—lots of them. She had family and friends milling about, as well as members of the press. And most important, she had customers starting to show up that morning. The only thing missing was...a front door. "The doors just didn't arrive," Tory says. "It was cold out. It was February." Tory could have hit the pause button and delayed her opening until she could receive customers with the kind of dramatic entrance (and reasonable temperature) she had imagined. But like most entrepreneurs, Tory has a bias for action. She knew she had a moment in time during Fashion Week when she could capture attention—and if she hesitated, it might be gone forever. So she went full speed ahead. She literally opened the doors of her business without any doors. The result: explosive. "It was amazing," Tory recalls, "almost as if we were giving the product away. I started seeing people changing clothes in the middle of the store. We sold through most of our inventory that day. So we kind of realized that we were on to something." When Tory first hatched the plan for her fashion company, hers wasn't the typical entrepreneurial dream. She imagined an organization with two complementary sides: one for profit, and one not-for-profit. "I wanted to start a company in order to build a foundation—that was my business plan," she says. Making money and giving back were intertwined from the start. But when she tried to raise money for her business and soon-to-be foundation, "I was basically laughed at and told never to say 'business' and 'social responsibility' in the same sentence," she says. Tory was equally passionate about both halves of her idea. But after hearing consistent, immovable feedback from funders, she changed strategies. She moved full speed ahead on her idea for a business offering distinctive, casual, yet stylish clothing at affordable prices, and selling direct to consumer. And she set the idea of the foundation aside—for the moment. In 2009, five years after the famous "day of no doors," Tory quietly launched her foundation. Ten years later, Bank of America committed $100 million to the foundation's Capital Program, which connects women entrepreneurs to affordable loans. Throughout these years of rapid growth, Tory relied on her instincts to tell her when to push ahead and when to slow down—which, in some cases, meant saying no to growth opportunities, or at least putting them on a slower track. For example, she was very selective about opening outlet stores, knowing they could dilute her brand. "The outlet business is like a drug," Tory says. "It's a very easy fix, but it's not a long-term solution."

Chapter 4: Learning to Unlearn: How Phil Knight Reinvented Nike

It started with a pair of homemade shoes. As a student at the University of Oregon, Phil Knight ran track, under Bill Bowerman, the Hall of Fame coach. And running with Bill meant field-testing his hand-sewn, Frankensteined sneakers. "He was always experimenting with shoes," Phil recalls. "He felt that getting lighter shoes was important." "Everybody in those days—all the really great runners—were wearing either Adidas or Puma shoes, and it was a real eye-opener for me when Otis Davis won the Pacific Coast Conference Championship in the 400 meters wearing a pair of Bowerman homemade shoes—which I had been experimenting with before he wore them." Phil was struck by the way this lightweight, handmade shoe powered a high-profile win. But he was equally struck by the influence that win had on amateur athletes. Everyone wanted that shoe. "And that planted a seed." Phil Knight co-founded Nike (under the name Blue Ribbon Sports) in 1964—with an investment of $500 each from Bill and Phil. Their laser focus: making ultra-high-performance sneakers. "The world needs a better running shoe. That was the thought behind it." Branding? Advertising? None of that mattered to Phil. "I never thought I was a 'sales personality.'" His winning formula: Build sneakers that drive winning performances—and the rest will follow. And it did. Thanks to endorsements from Steve Prefontaine and other elite runners, the nation's track coaches and joggers latched on to Nike's lightweight shoes—built for speed, not style. "We hadn't really focused on the appearance of the shoes," says Phil. "We said: If a shoe performs, and a great athlete wears it, it'll sell." And that worked, until it didn't. Nike as we know it today—the culture-driving, style-setting Nike—exists only because Nike lost its footing. The craze for high-performance athletic gear was overtaken by another craze—high-fashion athletic gear. Nike was losing this race—badly. As Phil puts it: "In the '80s, we got our brains beat out by an upstart company called Reebok." Reebok's Velcro-powered high-tops were built for the new exercise trend: aerobics. And stylish women started wearing their aerobics shoes with business suits on their way to work. All of a sudden, athletic wear was streetwear. Phil had spent almost two decades building a dominant business doing what he knew how to do: designing, testing, and selling high-performance sports gear to athletes. But the game had changed around him, and he'd have to unlearn everything he thought he knew about how to win. After a particularly dismal quarterly sales report, "We said, 'Well, maybe we should try some advertising after all,'" Phil remembers. "So we walked into an office that had four guys and a card table. Their names were David Kennedy and Dan Wieden." Phil was willing to set aside two-plus decades of his own hard-won expertise to help Nike shift gears from a shoe company to a brand. He understood that the market for shoes underwent a step-change in the early 1980s—and if he and Nike didn't adapt, they wouldn't survive. It's a transition every leader of an innovative, fast-growing organization will face, often multiple times. It's not enough to learn the ropes. To truly scale an organization, you have to learn to unlearn.

Chapter 5: Watch What They Do: Google's Search Results Revelation

It was early days at Google, long before Google Docs or Google Maps or Gmail made their way onto the world's screens. The company's founding team had just launched their fledgling search engine, and they were singularly, obsessively focused on what they called "excellence in search." The problem was, they didn't know what "excellence in search" actually looked like. Their home page was brilliantly simple—just a search box and two buttons, one of which said, "I'm feeling lucky." It was a radical departure from cluttered portals like Yahoo! that were popular at the time. The search results page was just as contrarian. No ads. No news headlines. Just really good search results. But how many should they have? And what should they look like? Co-founder Larry Page wanted Google's design to be based on objective data, rather than subjective design sensibilities. So he had his engineers build something they called the "experiment framework." Marissa Mayer, a key engineer on the Google Search team, implemented the first of these experiments, designed to determine the ideal number of search results to display after a user typed in a query. As a first step, Marissa surveyed users, asking how many search results they wanted to see per page. Was it twenty? Twenty-five? The answer was thirty. Users' feedback was clear: The more results you showed people per page the better. Based on what people said, at least. But something unexpected happened during the next test, when they watched how users actually behaved. Google deployed different versions of the search results page, each identical except showing a different number of results, and counted: How many searches did a user perform? How many pages deep did they go? And how many users abandoned the site altogether? It became clear that in reality, less was actually more. The magic number was ten results per page, rather than the thirty the survey data had indicated. "When we looked at first-page search results requested per user," Marissa says, "it fell off dramatically between ten and twenty; twenty-five was even worse; thirty was worst of all." What accounted for this dramatic gap between users' perceptions and their actions? It turned out more results per page came at a cost—one that was extremely important to users, even if they didn't realize it consciously: speed. A page with twenty or thirty results loaded more slowly than a page with ten. The difference in load time was barely perceptible, but the impact was undeniable. This discovery had a huge impact on Google—it was a formative lesson not only on the specific question of how many search results to display, but also on the process of truly understanding user feedback. Surveys are great when you need to understand nuanced sentiment and feelings. But if you want to understand what your users will actually do, you need to watch them do things.

Chapter 6: The Purposeful Pivot: Ev Williams' Journey from Odeo to Twitter

In 2004, a new word entered our vocabulary: podcast. It described a new kind of media that allowed anyone to record and distribute audio content without radio's broadcast rules or gatekeepers. The catchy name created a swell of interest among early adopters and audiophiles, and Ev Williams had a plan to ride that wave. Ev had already made a name for himself with Blogger, a trailblazing service that enabled users to easily set up their own blogs. Though Blogger captured the cultural zeitgeist, it had a bumpy run as a business; in its last year as an independent company, Ev worked on the site alone, without staff or salary, before eventually selling to Google. Now, Ev was ready to try a different form of communication. His underlying passion was connecting people—or rather, connecting their ideas—through technology. Growing up on a farm in Nebraska, he had always felt like an outsider in his football-oriented town. Computer programming and online bulletin boards became his way to connect with people beyond his small town. When he read an article in the first issue of Wired magazine about "connecting all the brains on the planet," it set his imagination ablaze, leading him to Silicon Valley, then to Blogger, and now to podcasting. Ev secured $5 million in funding and built Odeo, a platform that made it easy for podcasters to publish their work and listeners to discover content. He envisioned it as the premier platform for podcasting. Then, just as Odeo was getting off the ground, he discovered that a competitor was entering the field—and not just any competitor. Apple. In 2005, Apple announced it would integrate podcasts into iTunes, making it infinitely easier for iPod users to access podcasts. Since iPod owners represented the vast majority of Odeo's potential audience, this was devastating. "It kind of blew our minds," Ev says. He went to his board and asked, "Should we shut down? Should we give the money back?" To Ev's surprise, the board asked if he had any other ideas to pursue. "And I thought, 'Sure, I've got ideas. I always have ideas.'" Ev turned to his team and said, "I don't know if podcasting is still our thing. Who's got ideas?" They held a hackathon—a marathon work session where employees develop new ideas—and co-founder Biz Stone and web designer Jack Dorsey came up with a winning concept: a group texting product that grew out of side tinkering they'd been doing with text messaging. Ev quickly warmed to the idea because it reminded him of something he'd done at Blogger. "I built a blog for status updates, and shared it with my Blogger team," says Ev. "Then I went on a family trip and during the trip, I was sending status updates to a blog. It felt like something interesting—sharing this thing that you didn't normally share." Those "status updates" would later be known as tweets, and the product would become Twitter. The team sensed very quickly that Twitter had great potential, raising the difficult question: Was it time to pivot away from Odeo entirely? It wasn't an easy call. At board meetings, Ev presented updates on both Twitter and Odeo—which wasn't quite ready to die. It wasn't growing, but it did have engaged users. This is often the most painful kind of decision for a leader: it's easy to kill a product that's failing; it's much harder to kill one that lacks the potential to truly scale.

Chapter 7: Leading Through Transformation: Angela Ahrendts at Apple

She wasn't expecting the call. Angela Ahrendts had hit her stride as the CEO of Burberry. In just eight years, she had led the British heritage brand through a high-profile turnaround. The stock price had risen 200 percent. Revenues and operating income had both doubled. She was declared by the British press to be the highest-paid executive in the United Kingdom. Angela and her family had settled happily into life in the UK, and she had just shared a five-year plan with her board to double revenue again. And then Apple called. CEO Tim Cook wanted her to become Apple's next Head of Retail. "And I said, 'I'm honored, absolutely honored to be considered, but I have the greatest job in the world and I'm on a mission. So, no, thank you.'" Six months later, they called again. "And I said, 'Look, it's only been six months and nothing has changed. There is no reason for me to have a conversation. And oh, by the way, I had two kids in university in London, right? And a husband who thinks we're living there the rest of our life. So, leave me alone. Thank you, but no thank you.'" Apple persisted, asking her to have coffee with Tim Cook. Reluctantly, she agreed. But even face-to-face with the world's most powerful CEO, she turned him down repeatedly. "I told Tim, I said, 'Trust me, I'm not the right person. You don't know me. I'm instinctive. I'm creative. I'm not a store operator.'" Tim calmly replied, "We run the most productive stores in the world. I think we've got a lot of good operators." When she protested that she wasn't a "techie" and didn't code, he simply said, "We have enough of those." What he was looking for was leadership—someone who could unite the teams again. After much soul-searching, Angela decided to accept. It was Apple, after all. But when she arrived? "I hated it." The transition was jarring. "It was actually like going to Mars," Angela says. "It's like it's a different language. I got so insecure the first three or four months." But then she had a talk with herself: "There's no way in the world I could possibly learn everything. And they didn't bring me in to learn all of that. They brought me in because I have gifts and I'm supposed to focus on applying those." About three months into her new role, someone suggested she send an introductory email to Apple's seventy thousand retail employees. Angela had other ideas. "I picture my three teens in these Apple Stores and they don't read email," she says. "So I said, 'I'm going to do a video instead.'" She was told, "We don't do videos." Angela insisted: "I'm going to do a video, and I don't want a studio and I don't want hair and makeup. We'll use an iPhone. It's going to be three thoughts in three minutes or less, no editing, nothing." She recorded her first video memo from her desk using an iPhone. About a minute in, her phone rang—it was her daughter. With the camera still rolling, Angela excused herself, took the call and said, "Angelina, Mommy will call you back in two minutes." Then she resumed her message. Someone suggested editing out the phone call "because Apple's got to be perfect." Angela refused: "No, it does not have to be perfect. They have to see that I am authentic. They also should see that I put my kids first." The next day, she received hundreds of messages from employees thanking her for taking her daughter's call.

Summary

The journey of scaling a vision is not about avoiding rejection, but transforming it into your greatest asset. The most successful entrepreneurs don't just persist through "no"—they mine those rejections for insights that refine their ideas into something truly revolutionary. They understand when to move with lightning speed and when to exercise strategic patience. They recognize that scaling requires both doing things that don't scale (like personally meeting every early customer) and learning to unlearn deeply ingrained habits when markets shift. Start by embracing rejection as valuable feedback rather than personal failure. Watch what your users actually do instead of just listening to what they say they want. Be prepared to pivot purposefully when circumstances demand it, but don't abandon your core mission. Remember that authentic leadership—showing your humanity rather than projecting perfection—creates the strongest connections with your team. And perhaps most importantly, recognize that the most meaningful scale isn't just measured in revenue or users, but in the positive impact you create in the world. Your vision, properly scaled, can transform not just an industry, but countless lives.

About Author

Loading...

Reid Hoffman

An accomplished entrepreneur, executive, and investor, Reid Hoffman has played an integral role in building many of today’s leading consumer technology businesses, including LinkedIn and PayPal. He possesses a unique understanding of consumer behavior and the dynamics of viral businesses, as well as deep experience in driving companies from the earliest stages through periods of explosive, “blitzscale” growth. Ranging from LinkedIn to PayPal, from Airbnb to Convoy to Facebook, he invests in businesses with network effects and collaborates on building their product ecosystems.Hoffman co-founded LinkedIn, the world’s largest professional networking service, in 2003. LinkedIn is thriving with more than 700 million members around the world and a diversified revenue model that includes subscriptions, advertising, and software licensing. He led LinkedIn through its first four years and to profitability as Chief Executive Officer. In 2016 LinkedIn was acquired by Microsoft, and he became a board member of Microsoft.Prior to LinkedIn, Hoffman served as executive vice president at PayPal, where he was also a founding board member.Hoffman joined Greylock in 2009. He focuses on building products that can reach hundreds of millions of participants and businesses that have network effects. He currently serves on the boards of Aurora, Coda, Convoy, Entrepreneur First, Joby, Microsoft, Nauto, Neeva, and a few early stage companies still in stealth. In addition, he serves on a number of not-for-profit boards, including Kiva, Endeavor, CZ Biohub, New America, Berggruen Institute, Opportunity@Work, the Stanford Institute for Human-Centered AI, and the MacArthur Foundation’s Lever for Change. Prior to joining Greylock, he invested personally in many influential Internet companies, including Facebook, Flickr, Last.fm, and Zynga.In 2022, Hoffman co-founded Inflection AI, an artificial intelligence company that aims to create software products that make it easier for humans to communicate with computers.Hoffman is the host of Masters of Scale, an original podcast series and the first American media program to commit to a 50-50 gender balance for featured guests as well as Possible, a podcast that sketches out the brightest version of the future—and what it will take to get there. He is the co-author of five best-selling books: The Startup of You, The Alliance, Blitzscaling, Masters of Scale, and Impromptu.Hoffman earned a master’s degree in philosophy from Oxford University, where he was a Marshall Scholar, and a bachelor’s degree with distinction in symbolic systems from Stanford University. In 2010 he was the recipient of an SD Forum Visionary Award and named a Henry Crown Fellow by The Aspen Institute. In 2012, he was honored by the Martin Luther King center’s Salute to Greatness Award. Also in 2012, he received the David Packard Medal of Achievement from TechAmerica and an honorary doctor of law from Babson University. In 2017, he was appointed as a CBE by her majesty Queen Elizabeth II. He received an honorary doctorate from the University of Oulu, an international science university, in 2020. In 2022, Reid received Vanderbilt University's prestigious Nichols-Chancellor's Medal and delivered the Graduates Day address to the Class of 2022 on the importance and power of friendship.

Read more