Positive Influence

Positive Influence Plot Summary

Introduction

The conference room fell silent as Sarah, a newly promoted team leader, finished presenting her ambitious project proposal. Despite her thorough preparation and compelling data, she could feel the skepticism hanging in the air. The senior executives exchanged glances, arms crossed, unconvinced. In that critical moment, Sarah didn't resort to more facts or desperate persuasion. Instead, she paused, acknowledged their concerns with genuine empathy, and shared a personal story about why this project mattered to the people they served. The energy in the room shifted. By connecting authentically rather than pushing harder, she transformed resistance into curiosity and eventual support. This scenario illustrates the essence of positive influence—the ability to connect meaningfully with others across differences in position, perspective, or power. Unlike manipulation or coercion, positive influence stems from a genuine desire to achieve outcomes beneficial for all involved. In our increasingly divided world, where differences often lead to disconnection, the capacity to influence positively has never been more crucial. When we develop this skill, we discover that leadership isn't about authority or title but about how we engage with others to create shared progress. The following chapters explore how to cultivate this vital capacity through understanding human connection, emotional dynamics, cultural differences, and the development of our unique influence craft.

Chapter 1: The Journey to Effective Influence: Beyond Technique

James had been struggling to gain traction with his sustainability initiative for months. As the environmental compliance officer at a manufacturing company, he had meticulously compiled data showing how reducing waste could save money while benefiting the environment. Yet his presentations to the operations team were consistently met with polite nods followed by inaction. Despite his technical expertise, something wasn't connecting. "I don't understand," James confided to his mentor. "The numbers clearly show this would benefit everyone. Why won't they implement these changes?" His mentor smiled knowingly and suggested they visit the factory floor together. As they walked among the machinery, James's mentor encouraged him to talk with the line supervisors—not about his initiative, but about their daily challenges and priorities. Through these conversations, James discovered that the operations team wasn't resistant to sustainability itself. Rather, they were overwhelmed by previous change initiatives that had disrupted production without delivering promised benefits. They felt unheard and skeptical of proposals coming from offices far from the factory floor. The barrier wasn't logical—it was relational and emotional. With this insight, James completely reimagined his approach. Instead of more presentations, he began spending time with the operations team, understanding their processes firsthand. He invited key supervisors to help design implementation plans that would minimize disruption. He shared stories of similar companies where workers had become champions of sustainability. Most importantly, he listened more than he spoke. Within three months, the operations team was voluntarily implementing James's recommendations, even suggesting improvements he hadn't considered. The waste reduction targets were not only met but exceeded, and James was astonished at how much more effectively influence flowed when he moved beyond technique to authentic connection. The journey to effective influence begins with recognizing that human connection precedes persuasion. When we focus exclusively on our message or methodology, we miss the fundamental truth that influence happens through relationship. Technical expertise matters, but understanding the human beings we hope to influence—their concerns, hopes, and experiences—creates the foundation for meaningful impact that transcends mere compliance.

Chapter 2: Connecting with Human Beings Behind Their Roles

When Dr. Elena Martínez arrived at the rural hospital as the new chief medical officer, she faced immediate resistance. The staff had been through three administrators in five years, each bringing disruptive changes before moving on to more prestigious positions. "Just another city doctor using us as a stepping stone," one veteran nurse muttered within her hearing. Elena realized that before she could implement any improvements to patient care, she needed to address the broken trust. Instead of asserting her authority or unveiling her strategic plan, Elena made an unexpected decision. She spent her first month shadowing different staff members—from janitors to senior physicians—for full shifts. She ate in the cafeteria, attended community events, and made home visits with the outreach team. She asked questions about their histories with the hospital and their hopes for its future. Most importantly, she listened without defensiveness when they shared frustrations. During a particularly difficult overnight shift in the emergency department, Elena rolled up her sleeves and worked alongside the nurses when they were short-staffed. At dawn, as they were finishing charting, a senior nurse named Margaret looked at her thoughtfully. "You know, you're the first administrator who's ever stayed the whole night with us. The others just didn't get what we face here." "I'm still learning," Elena replied honestly. "But I can't help if I don't understand what you're dealing with." That conversation marked a turning point. When Elena eventually introduced changes to hospital protocols, she found staff willing to give her ideas a chance. They knew she saw them as people, not just positions on an organizational chart. By seeking first to understand the humans behind the roles, Elena created the foundation for collaborative improvement that had eluded her predecessors. The most powerful influence comes not from authority but from authentic connection. When we engage with people as complex human beings with their own stories, fears, and aspirations—rather than as obstacles to our agenda or functions to be managed—we create the possibility for genuine collaboration. This requires the humility to temporarily set aside our own objectives and listen with curiosity and respect. By honoring the humanity in others, we invite them to see beyond our title or position to the person seeking to make a positive difference.

Chapter 3: Harnessing Emotions as Forces for Change

The tension in the boardroom was palpable as Wei, the sustainability director, prepared to present his proposal for carbon-neutral manufacturing processes. The company had recently missed quarterly earnings expectations, and the board was in no mood for initiatives that might further impact short-term profits. Wei had seen environmental proposals shot down before when they appealed solely to corporate responsibility or regulatory compliance. Instead of beginning with projections and timelines, Wei opened with a story. He shared how his teenage daughter had recently asked him a simple but profound question: "Dad, will your company still be around when I graduate college?" When he assured her it would, she replied, "But will anyone want to work for a company that didn't help when they could have?" Wei described how that conversation had kept him awake at night, contemplating not just quarterly results but generational legacy. As Wei spoke, he noticed the shift in the room. Several board members were parents or grandparents themselves. The CFO, normally the toughest critic of sustainability investments, nodded slightly when Wei mentioned that top engineering graduates were increasingly choosing employers based on environmental commitments. By acknowledging the emotional reality—that business decisions are made by humans with values, concerns about legacy, and desires for meaningful work—Wei created space for a different kind of conversation. "I'm not asking us to sacrifice profitability," he concluded. "I'm proposing we redefine what success looks like for our company over the next decade." The board didn't approve his entire proposal that day, but they authorized a pilot program and requested monthly updates—a breakthrough compared to previous attempts. Wei succeeded where others had failed because he recognized that decisions ostensibly made on "pure business logic" are inevitably shaped by emotions like pride, fear, hope, and the desire for legacy. By skillfully and respectfully engaging these emotional currents rather than pretending they didn't exist, he transformed potential resistance into productive exploration. Emotions are often treated as interference in professional settings, obstacles to rational decision-making that should be suppressed or ignored. Yet the most effective influencers understand that emotions are not distractions from the real work—they are essential forces that motivate or inhibit change. When we acknowledge and work with emotional realities instead of against them, we tap into deeper sources of motivation that mere logic cannot access.

Chapter 4: Navigating Cultural Divides Through Authenticity

Mira had spent her career in Silicon Valley startups before joining a century-old manufacturing company in the Midwest as head of digital transformation. On paper, she was perfectly qualified to lead the organization's technology modernization. In practice, she felt like she had landed on a different planet. Her direct communication style, casual dress, and emphasis on rapid iteration clashed with the company's more formal, deliberate culture. Six months in, her change initiatives were stalling as passive resistance mounted. The turning point came during a visit to one of the company's oldest plants. After a particularly frustrating meeting where her suggestions were met with polite but noncommittal responses, Mira stepped outside to clear her head. She found herself talking with Carl, a maintenance supervisor nearing retirement who had spent his entire 42-year career at the plant. "You know, folks around here aren't against change," Carl told her. "They've seen plenty of it. They're against being changed by people who don't respect what they've built." As they talked, Carl shared stories of the plant's history—the economic downturns they'd weathered, the safety improvements they'd pioneered, the families sustained over generations. For the first time, Mira saw the pride behind the caution she'd interpreted as stubbornness. "I've been trying to move too fast without understanding what matters here," Mira admitted. "I've been treating thirty years of wisdom like it's just resistance to my ideas." With this insight, Mira dramatically shifted her approach. She began framing digital transformation not as a replacement for existing expertise but as a tool to preserve and extend the company's legacy. She invited long-tenured employees to help identify which traditions should be preserved even as processes evolved. She adjusted her communication style without abandoning her authentic self, finding a middle ground that respected the culture while still bringing her unique perspective. Within a year, the same employees who had quietly obstructed her initiatives were becoming champions for thoughtful modernization. The cultural gap hadn't disappeared, but it had become a source of creative tension rather than deadlock. Cultural differences—whether organizational, regional, generational, or professional—often create invisible barriers to influence. We misinterpret behaviors through our own cultural lens, creating mutual incomprehension that blocks collaboration. The path through these divides isn't to abandon our authentic selves and completely adopt the other culture's norms. Rather, it's to approach differences with curiosity instead of judgment, finding ways to honor both where we come from and where we hope to go together.

Chapter 5: Developing Your Unique Influence Craft

Carlos had always admired colleagues who seemed naturally charismatic and persuasive. As a research scientist who had recently moved into a leadership role at his pharmaceutical company, he worried that his more reserved, analytical style would limit his effectiveness. He had even purchased several books on influence techniques, hoping to transform himself into the kind of magnetic personality he thought a leader should be. His mentor, Dr. Liu, observed Carlos's struggles and invited him for coffee. "I notice you're trying to completely reinvent how you communicate," she said. "But your authenticity is your strength, not a weakness to overcome." Carlos looked skeptical. "But no one gets excited when I explain our research priorities. I can't inspire people the way our CEO does with his big, energetic presentations." "You don't need to," Dr. Liu replied. "Think about Dr. Patel from the immunology team. She never raises her voice or makes grand gestures, but people trust her completely and follow her lead. She's influential because her quiet confidence and meticulous care for others align perfectly with who she is." This conversation sparked a revelation for Carlos. Rather than trying to adopt an ill-fitting persona, he began to identify and strengthen the authentic elements of his own influence style. He leveraged his deep technical knowledge by creating clear visualizations that made complex concepts accessible. He compensated for his discomfort with large group settings by excelling in one-on-one conversations where he could listen deeply and ask thoughtful questions. He discovered that his consistency and integrity created a different kind of impact than charisma, but one no less powerful. Over time, Carlos developed what his colleagues came to call his "quiet authority." By embracing and refining his natural approach rather than attempting to imitate others, he created a distinctive influence craft that earned both respect and results. Team members frequently sought his guidance precisely because his style differed from more dominant voices in the organization. There is no universal template for effective influence. The most powerful influencers develop their own unique craft—a distinctive blend of qualities, approaches, and principles that authentically express who they are while creating meaningful connection with others. This development isn't about adopting techniques that feel foreign to our nature, but rather about becoming more intentional with the strengths we already possess while thoughtfully addressing our limitations.

Chapter 6: From Influence to Leadership: The First and Last Mile

Anita had finally achieved her dream job as the new director of community programs for a national nonprofit. After years of hands-on work in local chapters, she arrived with ambitious plans to scale their most successful initiatives. Six months in, however, she was struggling. Her team seemed resistant to her vision, her boss was increasingly concerned about missed deadlines, and Anita felt her confidence eroding daily. "I don't understand what's happening," she confided to her former mentor. "I know these programs work. I've implemented them myself. Why can't I get traction?" Her mentor asked a surprising question: "Tell me about your first two weeks in the role. What did you do?" Anita described her efficient transition—reviewing program data, establishing priorities, and communicating her vision to the team. Her mentor nodded thoughtfully. "You covered the middle miles perfectly, but may have missed the first and last miles of leadership." The mentor explained that the "first mile" of any leadership role involves understanding the expectations, hopes, and concerns of key stakeholders—not just sharing your vision. It means building relationships before driving results. Similarly, the "last mile" isn't about announcing decisions but ensuring they're implemented in ways that work for the people who must carry them out. This perspective transformed Anita's approach. She scheduled individual conversations with team members, asking about their experiences and insights rather than explaining her plans. She discovered that previous initiatives had created burnout without adequate support, making her team wary of new programs regardless of their merit. She adjusted her timelines to build capacity first and expansion second. With her regional director, Anita had a candid conversation about expectations, discovering that her boss prioritized donor engagement more highly than she had realized. By recalibrating these relationships at both the first and last miles, Anita created the foundation for influence that had been missing despite her programmatic expertise. Leadership is fundamentally an exercise in sustained, purposeful influence. However skilled we may be at influencing in specific situations, effective leadership requires mastering both the first mile—where we establish trust and align expectations—and the last mile—where we ensure ideas become reality through others' willing participation. These bookends of the leadership journey are where many otherwise capable people stumble, focusing too narrowly on decisions and directives rather than the human connections that translate vision into action.

Chapter 7: Building Character Through Challenging Moments

The board meeting had gone disastrously wrong. Michael, CEO of a mid-sized technology company, had presented what he thought was a reasonable acquisition strategy, only to face unexpected and intense opposition from several directors. What should have been a straightforward approval had devolved into heated criticism of his leadership approach and strategic vision. As the room emptied, Michael felt a storm of emotions—anger at being blindsided, fear about his standing with the board, and an urgent desire to identify the directors who had undermined him. His instinct was to immediately call his allies on the board to strategize a counter-offensive and secure his position. Instead, Michael took a different path. He canceled his next meeting and walked alone in a nearby park, allowing himself to experience his emotions without immediately acting on them. He reflected on the board's concerns, looking for the legitimate issues beneath the uncomfortable delivery. He considered his own role in the situation—had he been listening deeply enough in recent months? Had he become defensive when receiving early signals of dissatisfaction? When he returned to his office, Michael did something that surprised his executive team. Instead of downplaying the conflict or assigning blame, he acknowledged the difficult meeting and invited honest feedback about how he might better align with the board's expectations while still advocating for what he believed was right for the company. He reached out personally to the most critical board members, not to convince them but to understand their perspectives more fully. This challenging moment became a defining one in Michael's leadership journey. By choosing reflection over reaction and curiosity over defensiveness, he demonstrated a quality of character that ultimately strengthened his influence with both the board and his team. The acquisition strategy was eventually approved with modifications that genuinely improved the plan. Our character—the consistent patterns of how we respond to difficulty, uncertainty, and conflict—ultimately determines our capacity for sustained positive influence. In challenging moments when our authority is questioned, our ideas are rejected, or our weaknesses are exposed, we face a choice. We can react from insecurity, seeking to protect our ego and status, or we can respond from a centered place that prioritizes learning and mutual benefit over being right or maintaining control.

Summary

Throughout these chapters, we've witnessed individuals like Elena, Wei, Mira, Carlos, Anita, and Michael navigating the complex terrain of human connection to create positive change. Their stories reveal a profound truth: influence isn't primarily about techniques or tactics but about how we engage authentically with others across differences in position, perspective, culture, and power. When we connect with the human beings behind their roles, harness emotions as forces for change, navigate cultural divides through authenticity, develop our unique influence craft, and build character through challenging moments, we transform our capacity to lead meaningfully in a divided world. The journey to becoming a person of positive influence begins with a simple but profound shift in perspective. Rather than asking, "How can I get others to do what I want?" we ask, "How can I connect with others to create outcomes that benefit us all?" This shift isn't just ethical—it's practical. In our interconnected world, sustainable progress rarely comes through domination or manipulation but through the patient work of building relationships across divides. By developing your capacity for positive influence, you create ripples of change that extend far beyond any single interaction or initiative. Whether you lead from a formal position of authority or through everyday interactions, your ability to influence positively may be the most significant contribution you make to your organization, community, and relationships.

About Author

Loading...

Tsun-Yan Hsieh

Read more