Primal Leadership

Primal Leadership Plot Summary

Introduction

Imagine a busy hospital emergency room on a chaotic Friday night. Dr. Sarah Chen, chief of the ER, remains extraordinarily calm amid the chaos. With a steady voice and reassuring presence, she guides her team through one crisis after another. When a young resident freezes during a complicated procedure, Dr. Chen doesn't criticize or take over immediately. Instead, she stands beside him, quietly coaching, her hand occasionally steadying his, her voice conveying absolute confidence in his abilities. By the end of the shift, the resident has not only completed the procedure successfully but has also gained invaluable confidence that will serve him throughout his career. At its heart, this book explores how the way leaders manage their emotions and those of others profoundly impacts the people around them. The authors unveil how leaders like Dr. Chen create what they call "resonance" - a positive emotional environment that brings out the best in everyone. Through groundbreaking research in neuroscience and organizational behavior, they demonstrate that the primal job of leadership operates at an emotional level. When leaders positively direct the feelings of those they lead - through self-awareness, empathy, and relationship management - they unlock tremendous energy and commitment. This emotional dimension of leadership often goes unrecognized yet holds the key to exceptional performance and sustainable results in any organization.

Chapter 1: The Power of Emotions in Leadership

The BBC news division was closing down, and management had sent an executive to deliver the difficult news to the assembled staff. From the moment he began speaking, everything went wrong. He started by boasting about how well rival operations were doing and mentioned he had just returned from a wonderful trip to Cannes. The actual announcement about the division's closure came across as brusque and even confrontational. The room's atmosphere grew increasingly hostile, with staff becoming so enraged that security nearly had to be called to escort the executive safely out. The next day, another executive visited the same staff. His approach was dramatically different. Speaking from his heart, he talked about journalism's crucial importance to society's vibrancy and acknowledged the calling that had drawn them all to this field. He reminded them that journalism has always faced financial challenges and expressed genuine appreciation for their dedication and passion. When this leader finished speaking, the staff – the very same people who had nearly revolted the day before – applauded him. This tale of two executives illustrates what the authors call the "primal dimension" of leadership. The difference between these leaders wasn't in the message they delivered – both had to announce the same difficult news. The difference lay in how they connected emotionally with their audience. The first executive generated dissonance by being tone-deaf to the group's emotional state, while the second created resonance by acknowledging their feelings and speaking to their values and identities. At its core, leadership works through emotions. While strategy, vision, and powerful ideas are certainly important, the reality is more fundamental: great leadership engages people at an emotional level. Leaders serve as emotional guides for groups, functioning as what the authors describe as an "open loop" that can either elevate or diminish the emotional state of those around them. Research in neuroscience reveals that our emotions are not entirely self-contained but are constantly influenced by others – especially those in positions of authority. The most effective leaders understand this emotional dimension and use it wisely. They recognize that their mood affects the mood of their organization, and they take responsibility for managing the emotional climate. In times of crisis, uncertainty, or when important work needs to be done, people naturally look to their leaders for emotional cues about how to respond. This primal aspect of leadership, the authors argue, is the foundation upon which all other leadership skills build, creating ripples of positive energy that spread throughout the entire organization.

Chapter 2: Resonant vs. Dissonant Leadership Styles

Jack was head of marketing for a division of a global food company. Driven and talented, he had a laser focus on excellence, always seeking better ways to achieve results. However, whenever someone missed a deadline or failed to meet his exacting standards, Jack would step in immediately, taking over the task himself or unleashing his frustration on the unfortunate team member. His direct reports described him behind his back as "a control freak," and morale in the division was plummeting. Despite his technical expertise, Jack had created what the authors call a "dissonant" environment - one where people felt emotionally disconnected from their leader and increasingly paralyzed in their roles. In contrast, consider Shawana Leroy, who took over as director of a struggling social work agency. From her first week, she focused on building connections with her team. She had lunch and dinner with each management team member, exploring not just the organization's problems but their lives, dreams, and aspirations as individuals. She listened deeply to their frustrations and validated their commitment to the agency's mission. Through these conversations, she identified both what was broken and what inspired people about their work. Rather than dictating solutions, she facilitated a collaborative process where the team identified priorities and created action plans together. Within seven months, the division was $5 million ahead of its yearly profit target - the first time in five years it had met its goals. These contrasting scenarios illustrate what the authors define as resonant versus dissonant leadership. Resonant leaders, like Shawana, create emotional synchrony with those around them. They attune to people's feelings and move them in a positive emotional direction. This resonance acts as an amplifier, prolonging positive emotional impact and creating what the authors describe as "more signal, less noise" in human interactions. People feel understood, valued, and emotionally connected to both their work and their leader. Dissonant leaders, like Jack, create emotional disharmony. They're out of tune with others' feelings, sending messages that drive collective distress rather than inspiration. Even when technically competent, such leaders leave people feeling off-balance, unappreciated, and emotionally depleted. The authors' research reveals that such dissonance doesn't just feel bad - it measurably diminishes performance. The key distinction isn't simply about being "nice" versus "tough." Rather, it's about emotional intelligence - specifically the abilities to understand one's own emotions, manage them effectively, recognize emotions in others, and handle relationships skillfully. These capabilities allow leaders to apply the right approach at the right time, creating an environment where people feel energized and capable of doing their best work. When leaders build resonance, they create emotional climate conditions that evoke positive feelings like enthusiasm, optimism, and commitment. These emotions don't just make work more pleasant - they literally change how the brain functions, enhancing creative thinking, problem-solving, and collaboration. The emotional dimension of leadership thus becomes not just a "soft" nicety but a hard-edged necessity for sustainable organizational success.

Chapter 3: The Neuroanatomy Behind Leadership

When Mark Loehr, CEO of SoundView Technology, learned that several employees had lost friends and family members in the September 11th tragedy, his response was immediate and deeply human. Instead of focusing on business as usual, he invited all employees to gather the next day - not to work, but to share their feelings and talk through what to do. He created space for people to weep together and process their emotions. Every night at 9:45, he sent an email to the entire company addressing the personal side of the ongoing events. Loehr went beyond just acknowledging emotions; he guided his team toward meaningful action. He encouraged discussions about how they could help, which led to the company donating one day's trading proceeds to those affected by the tragedy. What might typically generate half a million dollars ultimately raised more than $6 million as clients responded to the company's initiative. Loehr also asked employees to compile a "memory book" of thoughts and reflections that could be shared with future generations. The result was an outpouring of poems, stories, and deeply personal expressions from people speaking from their hearts. This example illustrates what neuroscience reveals about effective leadership: the critical connection between emotion and action occurs in our brain circuitry. The authors explain that leadership engages both the emotional centers of the brain (the limbic system) and the rational thinking centers (the neocortex). When leaders like Loehr respond to crisis by addressing emotional needs first, they're working with, rather than against, the brain's design. Research shows that emotions aren't secondary to rational decision-making - they're essential to it. The brain's emotional centers connect directly to the prefrontal cortex, where planning and decision-making occur. This connection means that emotional states profoundly influence thinking quality. When leaders generate negative emotions like fear or anger, they essentially hijack followers' brains, making clear thinking difficult and diminishing performance. Conversely, positive emotional states enhance cognitive flexibility, creativity, and problem-solving abilities. The authors explain that this brain circuitry operates in what they call an "open-loop system." Unlike closed-loop systems like the circulatory system that operate independently, our emotional centers are continuously influenced by signals from people around us - especially authority figures. Leaders therefore have disproportionate power to influence the emotional states of others, creating either emotional uplift or emotional distress that literally changes how followers' brains function. One powerful finding from neuroscience is that emotions are contagious, spreading from person to person through automatic mimicry of facial expressions, body language, and tone. Leaders, because they're watched more closely, are super-spreaders of emotional contagion. This explains why emotionally intelligent leadership isn't just about individual skills but about creating the right emotional climate for an entire group or organization. Understanding this neuroanatomy reveals why the most effective leaders cultivate the ability to manage their own emotions first. Self-awareness and self-regulation become fundamental leadership skills because they allow leaders to monitor and adjust their own emotional states before those states spread to others. The capacity for empathy - understanding others' emotional realities - then enables leaders to respond in ways that create resonance rather than dissonance. This explains why emotional intelligence, rather than just technical expertise or raw intellect, distinguishes truly extraordinary leaders from merely adequate ones.

Chapter 4: The Five Discoveries of Self-Directed Learning

Bill, the human resources manager at a retail chain undergoing significant transition, was constantly inserting himself into every conversation and debate. He positioned himself as "the guy in the know," confidently expressing strong opinions and spreading rumors about organizational changes. When his boss heard about one particularly problematic conversation, he remarked, "Bill is ignorance on fire." Yet neither that boss nor any other leader had ever given Bill honest feedback about how his behavior was perceived. Bill continued seeing himself as a respected, go-to team member, completely unaware of how others actually viewed him. This scenario illustrates what the authors identify as "CEO disease" - the information vacuum that forms around leaders when people withhold important (and usually unpleasant) information from them. While this affliction is named for chief executives, it affects leaders at all levels. The higher people climb in organizations, the less accurate feedback they typically receive about their performance and impact. Research shows that the poorest performers often have the most inflated view of their abilities, while leaders of the highest-performing organizations tend to have the most accurate self-perceptions. Breaking through this feedback barrier requires a process the authors call "self-directed learning" - a journey of personal change involving five critical discoveries. The first discovery involves uncovering your "ideal self" - the person you truly aspire to be, including your deepest values and dreams. This vision acts as emotional fuel for change. The second discovery requires facing your "real self" - accurately seeing who you are now, including strengths to preserve and gaps to address. This reality check often involves seeking honest feedback from multiple sources to overcome blind spots. The third discovery entails developing a specific learning agenda that builds on strengths while addressing gaps. Unlike generic performance improvement plans, effective learning agendas connect to personal dreams and aspirations. The fourth discovery involves experimenting with and practicing new behaviors, thoughts, and feelings until they become natural. This requires recognizing that meaningful change happens gradually through consistent practice over time. The fifth discovery acknowledges that we need supportive relationships to grow and change. Despite being called "self-directed," this learning process requires others who provide feedback, encouragement, and accountability. The authors' research found that people who practiced new skills with many different people across various life contexts showed the greatest and most sustainable improvements. This approach contrasts sharply with conventional leadership development programs, which often fail to produce lasting change. Traditional training typically targets the neocortex - the thinking brain - delivering concepts and information. But emotional intelligence abilities reside primarily in the limbic brain, which learns differently. It requires motivation, extended practice, and emotional engagement. The authors' longitudinal studies found that MBA students who went through this five-discovery process showed remarkable improvements in emotional intelligence competencies - gains that remained evident years later, long after traditional training effects would have faded. By understanding and applying these five discoveries, leaders like Bill could transform not just their behaviors but their fundamental capabilities as leaders. The process isn't easy or quick, but it offers a science-based path to developing the emotional intelligence that distinguishes truly effective leadership. The journey of self-directed learning creates not just better individual leaders, but ultimately more resonant and effective organizations.

Chapter 5: Creating Emotionally Intelligent Teams

The top management team of a manufacturing firm was chronically unable to make important decisions. Despite facing critical strategic issues, team members avoided topics on which they knew they disagreed. They sometimes pretended to reach consensus in meetings, only to quietly undermine decisions afterward. Meanwhile, the company fell further behind in implementing crucial strategy changes needed for growth. When the team underwent a leadership audit, the truth emerged: virtually every member scored low on conflict management. They were collectively uncomfortable with interpersonal disagreements, mistakenly equating any conflict with personal attacks. This shared emotional gap had created an unspoken norm that paralyzed decision-making. Once the team recognized this emotional reality, they could see what needed to change - not just their behaviors, but their collective mindset about productive conflict. This example illustrates what the authors identify as a critical insight: teams, like individuals, have emotional realities that powerfully shape their effectiveness. Even brilliant individuals will make poor decisions when their group lacks emotional intelligence. The authors' research shows that a team's collective emotional intelligence determines its ability to manage emotions productively, creating trust, identity, and efficacy that maximize cooperation and collaboration. Just as individual emotional intelligence encompasses self-awareness, self-management, social awareness, and relationship management, teams need similar capabilities operating at both individual and group levels. Self-aware teams monitor their collective emotional states and the feelings of individual members. They recognize when the group is anxious, frustrated, or enthusiastic, and they develop norms that support mutual understanding. When one team member storms into a meeting visibly upset, for instance, an emotionally intelligent team acknowledges the emotion rather than ignoring it. Self-management at the team level involves creating norms that foster focus, accountability, and constructive interaction. For example, research teams at one laboratory established a tradition that whenever someone shares a creative idea, the next person to speak must act as an "angel's advocate," offering support before any criticism emerges. This norm protects fragile new ideas and creates positive emotions around innovation. When such healthy norms become embedded, teams can manage themselves effectively even when formal leaders aren't present. Empathy at the team level means understanding how other groups in the organization function and finding ways to create mutually beneficial relationships. The authors describe a manufacturing team that nominated their maintenance team for a "Team of the Quarter" award, recognizing that their own success depended on maintenance giving their equipment priority. This empathic act created goodwill between the teams, ultimately enhancing both groups' performance. Leaders play a crucial role in building team emotional intelligence by modeling desired behaviors and establishing ground rules that maximize harmony and collaboration. This might involve conducting check-ins at the beginning of meetings to ensure emotional concerns don't derail the group, or creating explicit norms about how members will communicate and handle disagreements. Over time, these practices become part of the team's emotional operating system. By recognizing and developing these team-level emotional capabilities, organizations can harness the collective wisdom and energy of their people more effectively. When teams become emotionally intelligent, they create environments where innovation flourishes, challenges become opportunities, and people bring their best selves to work each day. The result is not just better decisions, but more sustainable performance and greater fulfillment for team members.

Chapter 6: Building Organizations with Emotional Intelligence

Lang Chen faced a daunting challenge when he took leadership of the Asian division of an international NGO dedicated to improving women's and children's health. Despite its inspiring mission, the organization was mired in bureaucracy and complacency. Its 220 employees served a customer base of 150 million people, yet the pace of work was sluggish, quality mediocre, and staff disconnected from the mission that had initially drawn them to the work. The organization operated at a loss, and staff seemed comfortable with a status quo that no longer served its purpose. Rather than imposing change from above, Chen used a process called "dynamic inquiry" to uncover the organization's emotional reality. Through open-ended conversations across all levels, he discovered that while the NGO's core values of compassion and integrity remained strong, they had become clouded by misunderstanding and outdated policies. Most importantly, he learned that staff felt disconnected from the actual impact of their work - the life-saving health services provided to villages. Chen's solution was elegant and transformative: he arranged for every office-bound employee, from accountants to administrators, to spend time working in village immunization clinics. For the first time, staff could see firsthand the difference their work made in children's lives. One driver, who previously saw his job as merely shuttling health teams between locations, began gathering groups of mothers around his car during clinic visits, explaining the importance of immunizations and helping calm their fears. When vaccine supplies ran short in one village, this same driver - formerly indifferent to outcomes - took initiative to locate supplies in a distant location, motivated by his new connection to the mission. To sustain this emotional engagement, Chen created forums where people could share experiences and coach each other. The emotional climate transformed as staff reconnected with the purpose behind their work. Years later, many employees still described this initiative as the most inspiring period of their professional lives. This example illustrates what the authors identify as the critical path to building emotionally intelligent organizations: Leaders must first uncover the current emotional reality, then help people connect with an inspiring vision that aligns with their personal values. Rather than merely seeking "alignment" with strategy, effective leaders create what the authors call "attunement" - an emotional connection that engages hearts as well as minds. The authors contrast this approach with conventional change efforts that focus solely on restructuring, systems, or strategy while ignoring the emotional dimension. Research consistently shows that such technically-focused changes often fail because they don't address the feelings and cultural norms that drive behavior. By contrast, when leaders take on the emotional reality first - acknowledging what's working and what isn't - they create the foundation for sustainable transformation. Building an emotionally intelligent organization requires several key elements. Leaders must respect the organization's core values while clearly identifying what needs to change. They need to slow down enough to engage people in honest conversations about culture and emotional climate. Change efforts must simultaneously come from the top (with clear commitment from senior leadership) and from the bottom (involving people throughout the organization in the process). Ultimately, transforming an organization's emotional reality isn't just about making people feel better - it's about creating the conditions where people can perform at their best. When individuals feel connected to purpose, valued for their contributions, and emotionally engaged with their work, they bring discretionary effort, creativity, and commitment that technical systems alone cannot inspire. The result is an organization that doesn't just execute strategy more effectively, but continuously adapts and thrives amid changing circumstances.

Chapter 7: Sustainable Change Through Leadership Development

The CEO of a Pacific Rim bank had personally experienced the benefits of emotional intelligence coaching. After working with an executive coach on developing EI competencies and undergoing 360-degree feedback, he had dramatically transformed his leadership style. Where once he had been a compulsively focused, pacesetting leader, he now employed a broader repertoire - becoming more affiliative, visionary, and coaching-oriented. Seeing the positive impact on his own effectiveness, he instructed his HR department to create a similar program for his top 600 executives. The result was disappointing. Few people signed up for the program, and those who did were mainly the curious and courageous - not those who might have benefited most. Despite the CEO's personal transformation, the leadership development initiative failed to gain traction. The problem? The CEO had kept his own development process quiet. People could see changes in him but didn't understand the learning experience behind them. By funneling the program through HR training, he unintentionally signaled it was a low priority, just another offering in the company's growing menu of development options. This scenario illustrates what the authors identify as a fundamental truth: to create sustainable leadership change throughout an organization, the development process must be seen as a strategic priority driven from the top, not just an HR initiative. Leadership development that transforms people and organizations must address three pivotal levels: the individuals in the organization, the teams in which they work, and the organization's culture. When any of these dimensions is neglected, change efforts typically falter. The authors contrast this comprehensive approach with traditional leadership programs that focus solely on classroom training in business topics like strategy, marketing, or finance. While these subjects matter, such programs rarely create transformation. Instead, effective leadership development creates what the authors call a "safe space for learning" - challenging but not too risky - where leaders can experience both intellectual and emotional growth. Rather than one-time events, sustainable development requires a multifaceted process spanning time, combining experiential learning, coaching, action learning on real business problems, and team-based simulations. At Unilever, for instance, a transformative leadership development process began with the company's chairmen, Niall FitzGerald and Antony Burgmans, personally leading retreats where top executives explored their personal dreams and values alongside the company's vision. This created what they called "Costa Rica" - a type of authentic conversation and emotional connection that continued back at the office. By starting with passion and deep personal engagement rather than traditional strategic planning exercises, Unilever created momentum for change that rippled throughout the organization. Similarly, at Merrill Lynch's U.S. Private Client business, Linda Pittari recognized that developing leaders required understanding both individual needs and the organizational culture. Through careful inquiry into the firm's norms and practices, she identified which aspects of the culture enhanced leadership effectiveness and which hampered it. Her team then designed development processes that counteracted limiting cultural patterns while supporting positive values, resulting in 40 percent of participants being promoted to more responsible positions within two years. The authors emphasize that such comprehensive approaches maximize what they call "the half-life of learning" - creating stickiness so that development continues long after formal programs end. When leadership development connects to individuals' deepest values and aspirations, addresses team dynamics, and tackles organizational culture simultaneously, it creates a self-reinforcing cycle of growth. Leaders learn how to learn, fostering an enhanced capacity for ongoing adaptation and change throughout the organization. Ultimately, this approach to leadership development doesn't just produce better individual leaders - it transforms the very nature of work and leadership throughout the organization. By cultivating emotional intelligence at all levels, companies create environments where resonance becomes the norm rather than the exception, enabling sustainable performance in an increasingly complex and changing world.

Summary

Throughout this exploration of emotional intelligence in leadership, we've witnessed how the most effective leaders operate at a primal level - connecting deeply with others' emotions while skillfully managing their own. From Mark Loehr guiding his company through the aftermath of tragedy, to Lang Chen rekindling passion in a bureaucratic NGO, to Shawana Leroy transforming a struggling agency, these leaders demonstrate that resonance - the emotional synchrony between leader and followers - isn't a soft nicety but a hard-edged necessity for sustained excellence. The neurological research presented makes clear that emotions aren't secondary to rational leadership but fundamental to it, literally changing how our brains function and determining whether people can access their full capabilities. The journey toward emotionally intelligent leadership begins with self-awareness - honestly facing both our ideal vision and our current reality - and continues through deliberate practice that transforms our neural pathways over time. Yet it extends beyond individual change to reshape teams and entire organizations. When leaders commit to this journey, they create environments where people feel understood, valued, and connected to meaningful purpose. They establish norms that support healthy conflict, genuine collaboration, and continuous learning. Most importantly, they unleash the full potential of those they lead, creating organizations that don't just perform better but also nurture the human spirit. In a world of accelerating change and complexity, this capacity to build resonance at all levels may be the most essential leadership skill of all - one that enables not just financial success but also workplaces where people thrive and find meaning in what they do each day.

About Author

Loading...

Daniel Goleman

Author of Emotional Intelligence and psychologist Daniel Goleman has transformed the way the world educates children, relates to family and friends, and conducts business. The Wall Street Journal ranked him one of the 10 most influential business thinkers. Goleman’s Emotional Intelligence was on The New York Times best sellers list for a year-and-a-half. Named one of the 25 "Most Influential Business Management Books" by TIME, it has been translated into 40 languages. The Harvard Business Review called emotional intelligence (EI) “a revolutionary, paradigm-shattering idea.” Goleman’s new book, Focus: The Hidden Driver of Excellence, argues that attention — a fundamental mental ability for success — has come under siege. Leadership that gets results demands a triple focus: on our inner world so we can manage ourselves; on others, for our relationships; and on the outer forces that shape our organizations and society itself. His more recent books include The Brain and Emotional Intelligence, and Leadership: The Power of Emotional Intelligence - Selected Writings.

Read more

Related Books by Daniel Goleman

Loading...

Emotional Intelligence

Daniel Goleman

Redefining "smart"

★★★★☆4.3

Loading...

Focus

Daniel Goleman

The Hidden Driver of Excellence

★★★★☆4.3

Loading...

Search Inside Yourself

Jon Kabat-Zinn

The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success, Happiness (and World Peace)

★★★★☆4.0

Loading...

Social Intelligence

Daniel Goleman

The New Science of Human Relationships

★★★½☆4.0

Loading...

Altered Traits

Daniel Goleman

Science Reveals How Meditation Changes Your Mind, Brain, and Body

★★★½☆3.9

Loading...

Happiness

Daniel Goleman

A Guide to Developing Life’s Most Important Skill

★★★★☆4.1