Questions I Am Asked About The Holocaust

Questions I Am Asked About The Holocaust Plot Summary

Introduction

In the heart of Europe's darkest chapter, a young woman's life was forever altered when Nazi forces invaded Hungary in March 1944. Hédi Fried, a Jewish girl from Sighet, Transylvania, would endure unspeakable horrors in Auschwitz and other concentration camps before finding a path not only to survival but to becoming one of the most compelling voices for Holocaust remembrance. Her journey from the cattle cars of deportation to becoming a psychologist and tireless educator represents the extraordinary resilience of the human spirit in the face of systematic dehumanization. Hédi's story transcends the typical narrative of Holocaust survival, revealing a woman who transformed her trauma into a mission of education and reconciliation. Through her eyes, we witness the gradual erosion of normalcy as anti-Semitic laws stripped away rights before leading to genocide, offering crucial insights into how hatred metastasizes within societies. We encounter her profound bond with her sister Livi, which sustained them both through the camps and beyond. Most importantly, we discover how Hédi's later commitment to educating younger generations about the Holocaust emerged not from bitterness, but from her unwavering belief that remembrance and understanding are the strongest bulwarks against hatred's return.

Chapter 1: Childhood in Sighet: Life Before the Darkness

Hédi Fried was born in 1924 in the small town of Sighet, located in Northern Transylvania, a region that alternated between Romanian and Hungarian control throughout its tumultuous history. Her childhood unfolded in a diverse community of approximately 30,000 people, comprising various ethnic minorities, with Jews forming the largest group. The Fried family belonged to the modestly affluent middle class, which afforded them certain comforts like domestic help, yet their life remained centered around education, culture, and Jewish traditions. Growing up, young Hédi gradually became aware of the differences that defined her community—language, religion, customs—but these distinctions initially posed no barriers to childhood friendships. She attended school, played the piano, kept diaries, and cultivated a love for literature, particularly poetry. Her family nurtured her intellectual curiosity, with her father serving as a significant influence on her worldview. The Fried household buzzed with political discussions, particularly about the growing anti-Semitism in Europe, though the family, like many, believed themselves relatively insulated from the rising tide of hatred engulfing neighboring countries. The first profound shock to Hédi's sense of belonging came at age fourteen when she was barred from a postal service training program solely because she was Jewish. Returning home in tears, she begged her parents to leave the country that viewed her as a second-class citizen. Her parents, trying to console her, explained the harsh reality that anti-Semitism existed everywhere, and without a country of their own, Jews had no choice but to endure such discrimination. This early awakening to prejudice marked the beginning of Hédi's understanding that being Jewish carried consequences beyond religious practice. By 1940, as the geopolitical landscape shifted and Northern Transylvania was transferred from Romania to Hungary, the Fried family initially felt relieved, believing Hungarian rule might prove less hostile than the Romanian authorities who were deporting Jews to Ukraine. This false sense of security allowed them to adapt to increasingly restrictive circumstances while clinging to normality. Hédi continued her studies, dreaming of becoming a pediatrician, studying medicine, and someday helping children in Africa—aspirations that reflected her humanitarian spirit, even as the world around her grew increasingly hostile. As anti-Jewish measures intensified under Hungarian rule, the Frieds, like many Jewish families, convinced themselves that these were temporary hardships that would pass. This capacity for adaptation—what Hédi would later identify as the dangerous human tendency to "get used to" injustice—allowed them to maintain hope even as their rights eroded. They could not imagine the catastrophe that awaited them with the German invasion of Hungary in March 1944, when the relative safety they had assumed under Hungarian rule would collapse entirely, and their world would change beyond recognition.

Chapter 2: The Holocaust Experience: Surviving the Unimaginable

The German occupation of Hungary in March 1944 precipitated a swift and devastating series of events for Hédi and her family. Within weeks, all Jews were forced to wear yellow stars, barred from public spaces, and ultimately relocated to a hastily established ghetto in the northern part of Sighet. The Fried family, being on one of the first streets selected for relocation, had mere days to gather what possessions they could carry. Before leaving her childhood home, Hédi hid her diaries under the roof ridge, played her piano one last time, and bid farewell to her books and family photographs, naively believing they would return after the war. Barely a month later, in May 1944, the ghetto's inhabitants received orders to prepare for deportation. Despite her mother's tearful premonition that "they will kill us," Hédi clung to hope, convinced they were merely being sent to work in the Hungarian countryside. Each person was permitted just twenty kilograms of belongings. The family donned multiple layers of clothing, packed food, and a few precious personal items before being marched to the train station. There, they were crammed into cattle cars—a hundred people per car designed for eight horses—beginning a three-day journey of unimaginable suffering, without adequate water, food, or sanitation. The night of May 17, 1944, marked Hédi's arrival at Auschwitz, a moment seared into her memory by the chaos, brutality, and disorientation that ensued. As the train doors were flung open, prisoners were separated by gender and ordered to leave all possessions behind. In the confusion, Hédi briefly spoke with a Jewish prisoner who whispered a chilling truth: they had arrived at an "extermination camp." Under blinding floodlights and amid the cacophony of shouting guards and barking dogs, Hédi, her mother, and sister Livi approached the selection point where Dr. Mengele, with a casual flick of his whip, sent her mother to the right and the sisters to the left—a separation that would be permanent. Hédi never had the chance to say goodbye to her parents before they were sent to the gas chambers. The initial hours in Auschwitz were a whirlwind of dehumanization. Stripped of their clothing and possessions, their heads shaved, and dressed in ill-fitting gray uniforms, the prisoners were reduced to numbers. Hédi described Auschwitz as "living in a grey bubble" where time lost meaning. The ground, barracks, clothing, and even the sky—perpetually filled with ash from the crematoriums—existed in varying shades of gray. Daily existence revolved around meager rations of bread and watery soup, calculated to sustain a person for only three months, brutal roll calls regardless of weather, and the constant fear of selection for the gas chambers. After a period in Auschwitz, Hédi and Livi were transferred to several labor camps, including Eidelstedt near Hamburg, where they cleared rubble from bombed buildings. The work was grueling, performed under the watchful eyes of SS guards ready to beat anyone who faltered. In this environment, small acts took on enormous significance: the theft of a few stalks of vegetables from a field they passed, despite the risk of punishment; the momentary joy of seeing a green birch tree after months in the gray desolation of Auschwitz; the evening gatherings where prisoners would recite poetry and share recipes to distract themselves from hunger and fear. As the Allied forces advanced in early 1945, the prisoners were transported to Bergen-Belsen, arriving to conditions even more desperate than those they had left behind. With no food and little water, they lay on their bunks, growing increasingly weak and apathetic. Liberation finally came on April 15, 1945, when British troops discovered the camp. By then, Hédi was critically ill with typhoid fever, contracted while searching for her father among the male prisoners. Her survival through this final ordeal would depend entirely on her sister's devoted care.

Chapter 3: Sister Bonds: How Familial Love Enabled Survival

The moment Hédi and Livi were separated from their mother at Auschwitz marked a profound transformation in their relationship. Having been like "cat and dog" throughout childhood—sibling rivals prone to jealousy and squabbles—they suddenly found themselves clinging to each other as their sole remaining family connection. "From that moment on, we were glued together," Hédi recalled. "We did not let go of each other's hands, one did not move without the other, we slept side by side." This instantaneous shift from rivalry to mutual protection demonstrated how the extreme circumstances of the camps could fundamentally reshape even the most entrenched family dynamics. The psychological impact of having a sibling in the camps cannot be overstated. As Hédi observed, many longtime prisoners told them that those who were alone often lost their will to live more easily than those who had someone to care for. The responsibility felt for each other became a powerful anchor to life itself. When one sister felt despair, the other would offer encouragement. When Hédi was too despondent to eat during her first days at Auschwitz, she gave her bread rations to Livi until realizing that she too needed strength to survive. This pattern of mutual support established a rhythm that sustained them through countless moments of crisis. Their bond was tested most severely during a selection process at Auschwitz when Hédi was chosen for a work detail while Livi was to remain behind. Facing the prospect of separation—which often meant death for one or both parties—Hédi took an enormous risk by sneaking back to her sister's barracks. Against overwhelming odds, they managed to stay together, a crucial factor in their survival. Throughout their subsequent transfers to different labor camps, they remained inseparable, their unity providing a psychological fortress against the isolation and despair that claimed so many lives. The sisters' relationship embodied different but complementary strengths. Hédi, the elder, assumed a protective role, determined to defend her younger sister "with everything I had." Yet this was not a one-sided arrangement—Hédi acknowledged that "on several occasions, she would be the one who helped me, even saving my life." This reciprocal care reached its apex after liberation at Bergen-Belsen, when Hédi contracted typhoid fever and fell unconscious for weeks. It was Livi who found a doctor among the liberated prisoners, nursed her sister back from the brink of death, and literally taught her to walk again during her recovery. Beyond physical care, the sisters provided each other with the equally essential nourishment of hope and human connection. In the evenings, they would join other prisoners in what Hédi called their "literary salon," where they recited poetry, shared stories, and exchanged recipes—talking in detail about dishes they longed for until they could "almost smell the stuffed cabbage rolls and taste the meatballs." These moments of shared imagination created small pockets of psychological freedom within their imprisonment, allowing them to momentarily transcend their circumstances through memory and creativity. The bond forged between Hédi and Livi in the camps would endure for the rest of their lives. After coming to Sweden in 1945, they remained closely connected, speaking daily even into their nineties when mobility became difficult. Their survival illustrates how family ties could become not just emotional comfort but practical survival strategies in the face of systematic dehumanization—a testament to love's capacity to sustain life even in humanity's darkest hours.

Chapter 4: Finding Refuge in Sweden: Building a New Life

Liberation from Bergen-Belsen on April 15, 1945, marked the beginning of another challenging journey for Hédi and Livi. While freedom had arrived, Hédi was critically ill with typhoid fever and unable to experience the jubilation many might expect. Her first lucid memory after weeks of unconsciousness was seeing Livi at her bedside, realizing she would need to learn to walk again. During this precarious recovery period, a Swedish delegation arrived at Bergen-Belsen with a mission to bring 10,000 survivors to Sweden for six months of convalescence. The sisters were among those selected, boarding the cargo ship Rönnskär after disinfection in Lübeck. The voyage to Sweden represented Hédi's first glimpse of a different future. Despite never having seen the ocean before, she found herself enjoying the journey despite restrictions on deck time due to ongoing war conditions and mines in the North Sea. The ship's paper sheets made her "feel special, like a praline wrapped in silver tissue," a poignant illustration of how even small dignities could feel extraordinary after such profound dehumanization. After three days at sea, they arrived in Malmö, where they were greeted by members of the Swedish Home Guard offering cocoa and sandwiches—a welcome that made Hédi feel as though they "had ended up in paradise." Adaptation to life in Sweden brought both comforts and challenges. Initially housed at the Linnaeus School in Malmö, the survivors were quarantined for six weeks before being allowed to integrate with the wider Swedish society. Food became a central preoccupation for Hédi and her fellow survivors—despite being served five meals daily, many, including Hédi, hoarded food under their pillows, unable to trust that sustenance would remain available. This insatiable hunger and fear of scarcity would affect her relationship with food for the rest of her life, manifesting in an "overstocked fridge" that served as a psychological buffer against remembered deprivation. The process of building a new identity proved complex. Having arrived as a Hungarian-Jewish refugee from a region with constantly shifting borders, Hédi struggled to define herself. "I was nothing. Would I be able to become Swedish? I hoped so. As long as I learned the language, and found work, I thought perhaps I could," she recalled. This search for belonging was complicated by the realization that the initial welcome she experienced stemmed more from pity than acceptance. Though Swedish society showed surface-level kindness, true integration would require years of effort, including the seven-year wait for citizenship that officially designated one as "Swedish." Work became a crucial path toward rebuilding identity and purpose. Despite trauma and lingering questions about why she had survived when so many others perished, Hédi devoted herself to practical matters. With her first paycheck, she purchased a black woolen dress that cost her entire month's salary—100 kronor—an investment in normalcy that gave her "confidence when meeting friends at a café on Sunday afternoon." These small steps toward ordinary life represented profound acts of reclamation after years of having her humanity denied. Gradually, Sweden became home. Hédi married and had three children, establishing roots in her adopted country while contributing to its development. Yet the question of belonging remained sensitive; even decades later, she admitted, "I consider myself to be Swedish, but still don't dare to say it out loud in front of people I do not know, as it is all too painful to be rejected with a look that says, 'You're not one of us.'" This lingering uncertainty about acceptance reflects the complex, often incomplete nature of refugee integration, even in societies generally considered welcoming. Nevertheless, Hédi observed positive changes over time, noting that "more and more people have let go of their prejudices," offering hope for truly inclusive societies where, as she put it, "immigrants and Swedes can meet halfway."

Chapter 5: The Imperative to Remember: Becoming a Holocaust Educator

The path from survivor to educator was neither immediate nor straightforward for Hédi Fried. In the years following liberation, she grappled with profound loss—her parents, extended family, home, and the future she had once envisioned. Like many survivors, she initially found that Swedish society, while welcoming on a superficial level, showed little interest in hearing about the atrocities she had endured. The focus was on moving forward, not looking back at uncomfortable truths. During this period, Hédi worked, married, raised children, and tried to build a normal life while carrying the weight of her experiences largely in private. The crucial turning point came when Hédi finally understood the purpose behind her survival. "I had survived so that someone could tell of what happened during the Holocaust," she realized. "If no one tells the story of the Holocaust, it will be forgotten, and what is forgotten may easily be repeated." This epiphany crystallized when a teacher called asking her to speak at a school—a simple request that would launch her into decades of educational work. Upon retirement in the early 1980s, Hédi began writing books about her experiences, starting with her autobiography "Fragments of a Life: The Road to Auschwitz." This literary work expanded into an extraordinary commitment to in-person testimony, with Hédi speaking almost daily at schools and universities across Sweden. Her approach to Holocaust education was distinctive in its emphasis on answering questions rather than simply recounting events. Hédi structured her school lectures in three parts: contextualizing the historical conditions that made the Holocaust possible, sharing her personal experiences, and—most importantly—devoting ample time to answering students' questions. "I stress that there are no stupid questions, nor any forbidden ones," she explained, "but that some questions have no answer." This questioning framework allowed young people to engage actively with history rather than passively receiving information, creating space for both intellectual understanding and emotional connection. Hédi's commitment to education extended beyond simply recounting historical facts. She consistently emphasized the contemporary relevance of Holocaust memory, drawing parallels between past and present forms of prejudice, discrimination, and refugee crises. When addressing rising xenophobia in Europe, she would remind audiences: "I can see myself sitting there," referring to refugees in overcrowded boats crossing the Mediterranean. By connecting her historical experience to current events, she made Holocaust education not just about commemorating the past but about actively shaping a more humane future. The process of speaking about her trauma so frequently had an unexpected personal benefit—it became a form of healing. "Because I work with it daily, talk about it, and write books about it, it is no longer there when I let go of my work," Hédi explained. Unlike many survivors who found their trauma lingering as "a constant ache," her educational mission provided a framework for processing her experiences. This demonstrates how finding meaning and purpose in trauma can contribute to resilience and recovery, even decades after the events themselves. As she entered her nineties, Hédi continued her educational work with remarkable vigor, reaching new generations of students whose great-grandparents had not yet been born during the Holocaust. She took particular encouragement from the increasing engagement she observed in young people over the years, noting they had "gone from showing little interest to becoming more and more inquisitive." Many students would assure her, "Don't worry, we will pass on what you've told us, we don't want it to happen again"—affirmations that strengthened her conviction that memory could be effectively transmitted across generations as a safeguard against hatred's return.

Chapter 6: Confronting Hatred: Reconciliation Without Forgetting

The journey from victim to advocate required Hédi to navigate the complex landscape of hatred, forgiveness, and reconciliation. In the camps, she experienced a visceral hatred toward her captors—a natural response to brutality and injustice. She vividly recalled being slapped to the ground by a camp guard after simply asking for new shoes, feeling "a raging hatred; I wanted to pounce on him and hit him over and over again." Yet as time passed, Hédi underwent a remarkable psychological transformation, discovering that sustained hatred harmed the bearer more than its target: "Hatred does not affect the hated, but the one who hates feels terrible." This realization did not come easily or quickly. Hédi initially refused to speak German or travel to Germany, viewing everyone of a certain age as a potential perpetrator. She described her unconscious fear persisting years after liberation, once waking in panic from a nightmare while traveling by train through Germany. The breakthrough in her thinking came with the understanding that prejudging all Germans as guilty was itself a form of the same categorical thinking that had fueled anti-Semitism. "I finally freed myself from suspicion and hatred," she recalled, a process that allowed her to eventually accept invitations to speak in Germany and even form meaningful friendships there. Among the most remarkable aspects of Hédi's approach was her willingness to engage with the children of perpetrators, including Martin Bormann Jr., son of Hitler's right-hand man. Rather than avoiding such potentially fraught connections, she recognized that many in the younger generation were actively wrestling with their parents' crimes and striving to build a different future. Hédi came to believe that "only if former enemies can unite and fight together for the same goal can we hope for a better future." This perspective represented neither easy forgiveness nor amnesia about past crimes, but rather a pragmatic commitment to breaking cycles of hatred. When frequently asked whether she could forgive those responsible for the Holocaust, Hédi developed a nuanced response that distinguished between forgiveness and reconciliation. "I cannot forgive on behalf of those who were murdered," she would say, echoing Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal. Instead, she advocated living "without bitterness" while working to prevent history from repeating. This position acknowledged the impossibility of conventional forgiveness for genocide while rejecting vengeance as a solution that would only "make us sink to the same level as the murderers." Hédi's approach to confronting neo-Nazism and Holocaust denial revealed similar wisdom. Rather than engaging directly with committed deniers—"I can only speak of what I have been through; I cannot convince those who do not believe me"—she focused her energy on reaching young people before extremist ideologies could take root. When a school principal called about students drawing swastikas, Hédi's testimony proved powerful enough that female students decided to stop associating with the troublemakers, effectively isolating them and diminishing their influence. This strategic focus on prevention rather than confrontation characterized her practical approach to countering hatred. Perhaps most profound was Hédi's recognition that the capacity for both good and evil exists in everyone, including herself. She openly wondered how she might have behaved had she been born a German child in Berlin rather than a Jewish girl in Sighet, acknowledging that she too would have been subject to indoctrination in the League of German Girls. This radical empathy did not excuse perpetrators' choices but recognized the human complexity behind them. "We all have a choice," she insisted, maintaining that awareness of this choice was the essential first step toward choosing good over evil—a message that resonated powerfully with students contemplating their own moral agency in an imperfect world.

Chapter 7: Passing the Torch: Teaching Future Generations

As Hédi Fried entered her ninth decade of life, the urgency of transmitting Holocaust memory to younger generations became increasingly apparent. With survivors dwindling in number, she understood that direct testimony would soon be impossible, making education the critical bridge between lived experience and historical memory. "Soon, there will be no eyewitnesses left," she observed, "and in order to try to prevent these horrors from happening again, our stories must be passed on." This awareness infused her educational work with both urgency and hope—a race against time balanced by faith in young people's capacity to become carriers of memory. Hédi identified a crucial distinction in Holocaust education between intellectual and emotional understanding. Knowledge that "only addresses the mind," she noted, "is easily forgotten. It must also reach the heart, where it can awaken emotional learning." This insight shaped her approach to testimony, which combined factual accounts with deeply personal stories that helped students connect emotionally to historical events that might otherwise remain abstract. When describing her separation from her mother at Auschwitz, for instance, she shared not just what happened but how it felt: "I never got to say goodbye to Mama and Papa, never got to hug them one last time"—words that made the human dimension of genocide viscerally real to young listeners. The educational philosophy Hédi developed recognized that meaningful Holocaust remembrance required more than simply recounting historical atrocities. She consistently drew connections between past and present, helping students recognize patterns of prejudice, scapegoating, and dehumanization in contemporary contexts. By explaining how the Nazis gradually implemented anti-Jewish measures—"You never knew what the next change would be or when it would come"—she illuminated the incremental nature of rights erosion that can occur in any society. Her warning that "injustices must be nipped in the bud" offered practical guidance for recognizing and resisting early signs of discrimination. Hédi placed particular emphasis on personal responsibility as the cornerstone of preventing future atrocities. She drew parallels between playground dynamics and broader societal roles: "There are the perpetrators, the bullies who deliver the blows, and the victims, and the ones who simply watch without stepping in, the bystanders." By framing these as active choices rather than inevitable positions, she encouraged students to recognize their agency in confronting injustice. Her message was clear: "That you should not be a perpetrator is self-evident, but neither must you be a bystander; it makes you just as guilty." Despite witnessing troubling social and political developments—rising nationalism, xenophobia, and anti-Semitism across Europe—Hédi maintained a fundamentally hopeful view of younger generations. "When I look at the young people of today, I feel optimistic," she declared. "They have become much more self-aware, well informed, and interested in the world than we were at their age." This assessment wasn't merely wishful thinking but based on decades of direct engagement with students, observing their evolving responses to her testimony. While acknowledging the serious challenges facing contemporary societies, she expressed "an unshakeable belief that they have the will and the potential to solve today's problems." In her final years, Hédi continued to emphasize that Holocaust remembrance must serve as a catalyst for action rather than becoming ritualized commemoration detached from contemporary ethical choices. She advocated for January 27th—the anniversary of Auschwitz's liberation—to become "a long-lived tradition, through which new generations can pass on the story and tell it in a way that reaches their listeners' hearts." Her vision for Holocaust education was thus not merely preserving the past but activating its lessons to shape a more humane future—transforming memory into a living ethical framework that could guide society long after the last survivors had departed.

Summary

Hédi Fried's remarkable journey from the ghetto of Sighet to becoming one of Sweden's most respected Holocaust educators embodies the profound truth that the human spirit can transform even the most devastating trauma into a force for positive change. Her life illustrates not merely survival against overwhelming odds, but the conscious choice to extract meaning from suffering by ensuring that the Holocaust's lessons would not perish with its victims. Through her tireless educational work, Hédi offered a model of resilience that balanced unflinching honesty about humanity's darkest capabilities with enduring faith in our capacity for moral growth and collective learning. What makes Hédi's legacy particularly relevant for contemporary societies is her nuanced understanding of how prejudice, hatred, and genocide develop not through sudden ruptures but through gradual erosions of empathy and civic courage. Her warning that "injustices must be nipped in the bud" speaks directly to our responsibility to recognize and resist dehumanization in its earliest manifestations, whether in playground bullying or political scapegoating. For those seeking to navigate an increasingly polarized world, Hédi's example offers a pathway that rejects both naive optimism and cynical despair in favor of clear-eyed engagement with both historical truths and present possibilities. Her life stands as testament to the proposition that while we cannot change the past, our relationship to it—how we remember, what we learn, and what actions those lessons inspire—remains entirely within our power to determine.

About Author

Loading...

Hédi Fried

Read more