Rethinking Positive Thinking

Rethinking Positive Thinking Plot Summary

Introduction

We've all heard the advice: "Think positive!" From self-help books to motivational speakers, we're constantly told that positive thinking is the key to success. Dream big, visualize your goals, and believe they'll come true—this is the mantra of our optimism-obsessed culture. But what if decades of scientific research showed that this common wisdom isn't just incomplete, but might actually be holding us back? Gabriele Oettingen, through twenty years of rigorous research, has uncovered a surprising truth about positive thinking. Her studies across diverse populations—from dieters and job seekers to students and recovering patients—reveal that simply fantasizing about a rosy future makes people less likely to achieve their goals. Instead, she discovered a more effective approach: mental contrasting, a technique that involves juxtaposing positive visions of the future with the obstacles that stand in our way. This approach, later developed into a practical tool called WOOP (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan), has been scientifically proven to help people achieve their goals in health, relationships, work, and education. By rethinking positive thinking, we can transform how we pursue our dreams and unlock our full potential for personal growth and achievement.

Chapter 1: The Limits of Positive Fantasies

Positive thinking has become a cornerstone of modern culture. From corporate boardrooms to classrooms, we're encouraged to visualize success, dream big, and imagine our ideal futures. This approach seems intuitively correct—after all, how can focusing on positive outcomes possibly be harmful? The surprising answer emerged from Dr. Oettingen's research: merely dreaming about success often makes us less likely to achieve it. In one of her earliest studies, Oettingen tracked obese women in a weight-loss program. Those who had more positive fantasies about slimming down actually lost 24 pounds less than those who had more realistic or even negative thoughts about their weight-loss journey. This counterintuitive pattern repeated across numerous studies. College students with crushes who positively fantasized about starting relationships were less likely to actually initiate those relationships. Job seekers who vividly imagined landing their dream positions sent out fewer applications and ultimately received fewer job offers. Students who fantasized positively about acing their exams studied less and scored lower grades. The physiological explanation for this phenomenon proved equally surprising. When researchers measured participants' blood pressure after they engaged in positive fantasies, they found it actually decreased, indicating reduced energy and motivation. Rather than energizing us for action, positive fantasies appear to provide a premature sense of achievement—as if we've already attained our goals. Our brains experience the pleasant emotions of success without having done the necessary work, leaving us relaxed but ultimately unmotivated. This relaxation effect might be beneficial when we need to reduce anxiety or when a situation is truly beyond our control. However, for goals requiring sustained effort and action, pure positive thinking becomes a hindrance rather than a help. By inducing a pleasant, low-energy state, positive fantasies can actually prevent us from mobilizing the resources necessary to overcome obstacles and achieve our aims. This explains why so many well-intentioned New Year's resolutions, visualized with great optimism, fail to materialize. The economic and social costs of excessive optimism extend beyond personal goals. Oettingen's analysis of optimistic language in presidential speeches and financial news correlated with subsequent economic downturns. The more positive the language, the worse the economic indicators that followed. This suggests that society-wide positive thinking might contribute to complacency and poor decision-making on a larger scale.

Chapter 2: Mental Contrasting: Connecting Dreams and Reality

Mental contrasting represents a fundamental shift in how we approach goal achievement. Rather than simply visualizing a rosy future or dwelling exclusively on obstacles, this technique involves first imagining a desired future outcome and then immediately considering the obstacles standing in our way. This sequence is critical—by first establishing what we want before identifying impediments, we create a meaningful cognitive connection between dreams and reality. The power of mental contrasting lies in its ability to help us selectively pursue goals. When applied to wishes we believe are attainable, mental contrasting increases our energy and commitment to taking action. However, when applied to wishes we subconsciously recognize as unrealistic, it helps us disengage and redirect our efforts toward more feasible goals. This discernment prevents us from wasting time and energy on pursuits unlikely to succeed, while strengthening our resolve toward achievable aims. In one revealing study, female students were asked to identify personal interpersonal concerns and then performed either mental contrasting, pure positive fantasizing (called "indulging"), or merely focusing on obstacles (called "dwelling"). Those who mentally contrasted and believed their wishes were achievable took action sooner than any other group. Those who mentally contrasted but had low expectations of success actually took less action—they appropriately disengaged from unrealistic pursuits. The control groups showed no such pattern; their actions weren't connected to the feasibility of their goals. This selective engagement makes mental contrasting uniquely valuable as a self-regulation tool. Unlike motivational approaches that push people toward any goal regardless of its feasibility, mental contrasting helps us allocate our limited energy and resources wisely. It's like having an internal navigation system that strengthens commitment to worthwhile pursuits while steering us away from dead ends. The technique works across various domains—from academic achievement and creativity to health behaviors and relationship concerns. Mental contrasting even proves effective for managing fears and anxieties. By first imagining a feared negative future and then considering positive aspects of reality that make this fear unlikely, people can reduce irrational anxieties and approach challenging situations with greater confidence. This approach helped German teenagers overcome xenophobic fears about immigrants and become more willing to engage with foreign peers. Perhaps most remarkably, mental contrasting achieves these effects without extensive training or time commitment. In many studies, participants showed significant behavioral changes after just a single brief session of mental contrasting. This efficiency makes it an exceptionally practical tool for everyday life.

Chapter 3: How Mental Contrasting Works in Our Minds

Mental contrasting operates through sophisticated psychological mechanisms that extend far beyond conscious awareness. When we juxtapose our desired future with present obstacles, we activate cognitive processes that fundamentally alter how we perceive reality and respond to challenges. Understanding these mechanisms helps explain why such a seemingly simple technique can produce such powerful results. At the core of mental contrasting is the creation of strong cognitive associations between future goals and present obstacles. Researchers demonstrated this through experiments measuring reaction times in milliseconds. When people mentally contrasted about a wish they considered achievable, they showed significantly faster responses when presented with obstacle-related words after being subliminally primed with goal-related words. This indicates their minds had formed automatic connections between goals and obstacles. Importantly, these connections appeared only for feasible wishes and only in the specific order of goal-to-obstacle, not obstacle-to-goal. This explains why reverse contrasting (considering obstacles before goals) doesn't produce the same motivational effects. Mental contrasting also changes how we perceive obstacles. For attainable wishes, obstacles take on greater significance and negativity after mental contrasting, making them more noticeable and demanding of our attention. This heightened awareness prepares us to recognize and address challenges as they arise. Studies showed that children who mentally contrasted about winning a chess competition became significantly better at detecting moves where their own pieces blocked their path to checkmate—but only if they believed winning was feasible. Another remarkable effect of mental contrasting is the formation of automatic associations between obstacles and the behaviors needed to overcome them. In one experiment, participants who mentally contrasted about getting fitter showed stronger cognitive connections between "elevator" (an obstacle to fitness) and "exercise" (the solution). These participants were also more likely to actually take the stairs instead of the elevator when given the choice. The technique essentially prepares our nonconscious mind to automatically activate helpful behaviors when obstacles appear. Mental contrasting also enhances our ability to process negative feedback constructively. Those who mentally contrast become more attuned to critique relevant to their goals and more likely to use that information to improve. Rather than dismissing uncomfortable feedback, they integrate it into their understanding and planning. This explains why the technique helps people persist through challenges that might otherwise discourage them. Perhaps most fascinatingly, these cognitive associations dissolve naturally once a goal is achieved. In laboratory studies, the strong mental links between goals and obstacles disappeared after participants successfully completed their tasks. This automatic "cleanup" of our mental associations allows us to move on to new challenges without remaining fixated on completed goals.

Chapter 4: WOOP: A Practical Tool for Behavior Change

WOOP—which stands for Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan—transforms mental contrasting into a practical, everyday tool anyone can use. By adding implementation intentions (specific if-then plans) to mental contrasting, WOOP creates a complete system for pursuing goals effectively. This science-based technique has been refined through years of research to maximize its accessibility and impact. The WOOP process begins with identifying a Wish—something challenging but achievable that you genuinely want to accomplish. This could be a health goal like exercising more, a professional aim like improving presentation skills, or a personal objective like spending quality time with family. The key is selecting something meaningful that you believe is within your capability, albeit requiring effort. Next comes visualizing the best Outcome of fulfilling this wish. This step involves vividly imagining how it would feel to achieve your goal—the satisfaction, relief, or joy you'd experience. Unlike simple positive thinking, however, this pleasant visualization serves as a setup for the critical step that follows. The third step involves identifying the main Obstacle within yourself that stands in your way. This internal focus is crucial—rather than blaming external circumstances, WOOP directs attention to personal barriers like procrastination, fear, or self-doubt. For example, someone wishing to exercise might recognize that feeling tired after work is their primary obstacle, not lack of equipment or gym access. This honest self-examination creates the cognitive tension needed for motivation. Finally, you create a Plan in the specific format: "If [obstacle] occurs, then I will [take specific action]." This if-then planning leverages decades of research showing that such statements program our minds to respond automatically when obstacles appear. A person might plan: "If I feel tired after work, then I will remind myself that exercise will actually boost my energy." This final step converts insight into actionable strategy. What makes WOOP particularly powerful is how it engages both conscious and nonconscious mental processes. The technique doesn't require constant willpower; instead, it creates automatic mental connections that guide behavior when obstacles arise. In studies comparing WOOP with mental contrasting or implementation intentions alone, the combined approach consistently produced superior results. WOOP can be performed mentally in just a few minutes or written down for greater impact. It works for immediate goals (like managing stress during an upcoming meeting) and long-term objectives (like changing career paths). The flexibility of WOOP allows it to be applied across virtually any domain where behavior change is desired.

Chapter 5: Applying WOOP to Health, Relationships and Work

WOOP's versatility makes it an effective tool across numerous life domains, with particularly strong evidence supporting its application to health, relationships, and professional performance. In each area, scientific studies have demonstrated measurable improvements from implementing this simple four-step technique. In health contexts, WOOP has proven remarkably effective for increasing physical activity and improving diet. In one study with women trying to exercise more, those who learned WOOP nearly doubled their weekly physical activity compared to a control group receiving only health information. These benefits persisted four months later. Similarly, WOOP participants significantly increased their fruit and vegetable consumption, with benefits still evident two years after a single intervention session. WOOP has also helped chronic back pain patients recover faster by increasing their physical capacity, helped stroke survivors maintain higher activity levels, and reduced problem drinking among college students. WOOP's effectiveness extends to relationships as well. Researchers found that college students with relationship insecurities who used WOOP for one week showed nearly twice the reduction in insecurity-based behaviors (like excessive calling or checking social media accounts) compared to control groups. They also reported feeling more committed to their relationships. By identifying internal obstacles like fear of abandonment or jealousy, participants could create specific plans to manage these emotions productively rather than engaging in counterproductive behaviors. In professional and academic settings, WOOP has consistently improved performance across age groups and socioeconomic backgrounds. High school students who used WOOP completed 60% more practice questions for standardized tests over summer break than control groups. Middle school students with ADHD symptoms completed more homework when using WOOP. Healthcare professionals reported less stress and greater work engagement after applying the technique to workplace challenges. These improvements occur because WOOP helps people identify and overcome internal barriers to productivity, such as procrastination, perfectionism, or poor time management. What makes WOOP particularly valuable is its accessibility to diverse populations. Unlike many behavior change strategies that require extensive resources or support, WOOP can be implemented independently after minimal instruction. Studies with low-income students, chronically ill patients, and people from various cultural backgrounds all show similar positive outcomes. This makes WOOP an exceptionally democratic tool for personal improvement. The common thread across these applications is WOOP's ability to bypass the usual obstacles to behavior change. Rather than relying solely on conscious intentions or willpower—which often fail in the face of ingrained habits—WOOP creates automatic mental associations that guide behavior when challenges arise. By working with both conscious and nonconscious aspects of motivation, it addresses the full complexity of human behavior change.

Chapter 6: Developing Your WOOP Practice for Life

Integrating WOOP into your daily routine creates a powerful framework for ongoing personal growth and effective goal pursuit. Unlike one-off interventions, consistent WOOP practice builds a self-regulation skill that becomes increasingly intuitive and beneficial over time. With practice, you'll develop greater insight into your wishes, obstacles, and effective strategies for overcoming them. Begin by establishing a regular WOOP ritual. Many people find it helpful to perform WOOP first thing in the morning to set intentions for the day, or in the evening to prepare for tomorrow. Others practice during commutes or lunch breaks. The key is consistency—even just 5-10 minutes daily can produce significant results. Creating a specific trigger (like finishing your morning coffee) helps establish the habit. As you become more familiar with the process, you can complete a WOOP cycle in just a few minutes whenever needed. Start with short-term, 24-hour wishes while learning the technique. These provide quick feedback about what works for you and build confidence in the process. As you become comfortable with WOOP, gradually incorporate longer-term goals alongside daily wishes. This multilevel approach ensures you're making progress on immediate concerns while also advancing toward broader life aspirations. Be patient with the discovery process that WOOP facilitates. Often, the obstacles you initially identify will lead to deeper insights about what truly blocks your progress. Someone might first identify "lack of time" as their obstacle to exercise, but through repeated WOOP practice, realize their fundamental barrier is anxiety about being judged at the gym. This progressive deepening of self-awareness is one of WOOP's most valuable benefits. WOOP becomes particularly valuable during stressful situations or moments of decision. Before an important presentation, difficult conversation, or tempting circumstance, taking a few minutes for WOOP can dramatically improve outcomes. The technique helps manage anxiety, clarify priorities, and prepare specific responses to challenges before they arise. Many practitioners report that this "just-in-time" application of WOOP provides immediate relief and improved performance. For maximum benefit, use WOOP across different life domains rather than focusing exclusively on one area. This comprehensive approach often reveals connections between obstacles in different contexts. Someone struggling with both work deadlines and family relationships might discover that people-pleasing tendencies underlie both challenges, allowing them to address the core issue more effectively. Remember that WOOP is fundamentally about connecting with reality, not positive fantasizing. The process sometimes reveals that certain wishes aren't feasible or aligned with your true priorities. This clarity is valuable—allowing you to redirect energy toward more meaningful and attainable goals rather than persisting in frustration. The wisdom to disengage from unproductive pursuits is as important as the motivation to achieve viable ones. With consistent practice, WOOP becomes more than a technique—it develops into a mindset of honest self-reflection, realistic goal-setting, and effective action. This mental framework enables you to navigate life's challenges with greater resilience and purpose, continuously evolving toward your most meaningful aspirations.

Summary

The science of motivation reveals a profound truth: positive thinking alone doesn't lead to achievement. Twenty years of research demonstrates that merely fantasizing about desired outcomes actually decreases our likelihood of taking effective action. The problem isn't optimism itself, but rather how positive fantasies provide a premature sense of attainment that saps our energy and motivation. Instead, the most effective approach combines positive visions with clear-eyed recognition of obstacles—a technique called mental contrasting. WOOP (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan) transforms this scientific insight into an accessible tool for daily life. By identifying a meaningful wish, vividly imagining its positive outcome, honestly confronting internal obstacles, and creating specific if-then plans, we engage both conscious and nonconscious mental processes in service of our goals. This approach doesn't just increase motivation—it helps us discern which goals are worth pursuing and which we should abandon, allowing for wiser allocation of our limited time and energy. The technique's versatility and effectiveness across health, relationships, work, and personal development make it uniquely valuable in our complex world. Rather than pursuing the temporary comfort of positive fantasies, we achieve lasting fulfillment by connecting our dreams with reality through the simple yet powerful practice of WOOP.

About Author

Loading...

Gabriele Oettingen

Gabriele Oettingen is a Professor of Psychology at New York University and the University of Hamburg. Her research focuses on how people think about the future, and how this impacts cognition, emotion, and behavior.Oettingen studied biology in Munich and subsequently worked at the Max Planck Institute for Behavioral Physiology in Seewiesen, Germany, and at the Medical Research Council, Unit on the Development and Integration of Behaviour, Madingley, Cambridge, England. Simultaneously she did her PhD at the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich. She was funded by the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation to conduct research at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, USA. She worked at the Max Planck Institute for Human Development in Berlin while also gaining a Dr. habil. degree in psychology at the Free University Berlin. She accepted a professor of psychology position at University of Hamburg in 2000, and since 2002 is a professor of psychology at New York University. She lives in New York City and in Hamburg, Germany.

Read more