Sizing People Up

Sizing People Up Plot Summary

Introduction

Have you ever been blindsided by someone's unexpected behavior? Whether it's a colleague who suddenly quits, a business partner who fails to deliver on promises, or a friend who betrays your trust, the inability to accurately predict how people will act can cause tremendous personal and professional damage. This fundamental challenge—sizing people up—lies at the heart of almost every significant relationship problem we encounter. The science of behavioral analysis offers a surprisingly straightforward solution to this age-old dilemma. Rather than relying on gut feelings, personal biases, or questionable intuition, we can learn to observe specific, observable patterns that reliably indicate how someone will behave in important situations. By understanding six key indicators of human behavior, we gain the ability to predict actions with remarkable accuracy, allowing us to make better decisions about whom to trust, collaborate with, hire, or rely upon. This systematic approach strips away the mystery of human behavior and replaces subjective impressions with objective, evidence-based assessment—transforming what once seemed like an art of reading people into a learnable, practical science that anyone can master.

Chapter 1: The Foundation of Trust: Understanding Human Predictability

At the core of sizing people up effectively lies a fundamental truth: people generally act in what they perceive to be their own best interests. This principle isn't cynical—it's simply human nature. Even when people make seemingly self-destructive choices, they're typically pursuing what they believe will benefit them most, whether that's immediate gratification, avoiding discomfort, or protecting their self-image. Understanding this basic driver of human behavior gives us a powerful starting point for prediction. This perspective challenges the common misconception that trust is primarily about morality. In reality, trust is about predictability. When we can accurately predict what someone will do in a given situation, we can determine whether to align our fate with theirs. The most trustworthy people aren't necessarily the most virtuous—they're the most consistent and transparent about their motivations and capabilities. The unpredictability that makes people so difficult to read stems from several key factors. First, people hide or disguise aspects of themselves they don't want others to see, particularly when something important is at stake. Second, circumstances change, and with them, people's behaviors can shift dramatically. Someone who is reliable in one context may be completely unreliable in another. Third, desperation—whether for something desired or something feared—can cause even good people to act in unpredictable ways. Fear represents perhaps the greatest enemy of accurate behavioral prediction. When we're emotionally hijacked by fear, our judgment becomes clouded, and we often misread others. This is why the most effective behavioral analysts maintain emotional detachment when evaluating others, focusing solely on observable data rather than feelings or intuitions. They understand that sizing people up isn't about liking or disliking them—it's about accurately assessing what they'll do when it matters most. Trust exists on a continuum rather than as a binary state. We can trust people in some areas but not others, and to varying degrees. This nuanced understanding allows us to build productive relationships even with those we can't trust completely. What matters is recognizing exactly where and how much someone can be relied upon, and adjusting our expectations accordingly. The most insightful behavioral analysts don't just examine what people say—they scrutinize what people do. Past patterns of behavior, particularly recent ones in similar situations, often provide the clearest indications of future actions. However, these patterns must be verified through objective sources rather than simply accepted at face value, as people frequently present selective or distorted narratives about their own history.

Chapter 2: Vesting: Identifying Mutual Success Alignment

Vesting—the belief that someone will benefit from your success—forms the cornerstone of trustworthy relationships. When people vest in your success, they see your achievements as directly tied to their own. This creates a powerful alignment of interests that drives consistent, predictable behavior. The beauty of vesting is its transparency: people who believe they will benefit from your success rarely hide that belief, making it one of the easiest behavioral signs to detect. In professional settings, vesting manifests in numerous observable ways. Colleagues who are vested in your success adapt their work style to complement yours, speak in terms of your interests rather than just their own, actively explore additional ways to collaborate, and willingly take on tasks they might otherwise avoid. They call in their own favors to help you, offer assistance without being asked, actively promote you to others, and demonstrate genuine excitement when you succeed. Conversely, the absence of vesting sends equally clear signals. Supervisors who pass you over for promotion, point out ways you differ from them, exclude you from key meetings, or magnify minor errors are typically not vested in your future. Similarly, colleagues who avoid eye contact during your presentations, walk away while you're speaking, or rarely acknowledge your contributions are sending unmistakable messages about their lack of investment in your success. The beauty of vesting is that it creates a virtuous cycle. When you demonstrate investment in someone else's success, they typically reciprocate by vesting in yours. This mutual reinforcement generates increasingly strong bonds of trust and collaboration over time. However, vesting cannot be forced or faked—it must be genuine to be effective. People instinctively sense insincerity, which destroys rather than builds trust. Vesting transcends mere cooperation. It represents a deeper commitment to shared outcomes that transforms the nature of relationships. In a vested relationship, both parties actively look for ways to advance each other's interests, creating a partnership that's far more powerful than the sum of its parts. This explains why some teams consistently outperform others despite similar talent levels—they've developed networks of vested relationships that amplify individual capabilities. For leaders, fostering environments where vesting can flourish represents one of the most powerful ways to build high-performing organizations. When people throughout an organization believe their success depends on helping others succeed, collaboration replaces competition, information flows freely, and resources are allocated optimally. The resulting alignment creates unprecedented stability and predictability in organizational behavior.

Chapter 3: Longevity and Reliability: Measuring Commitment and Competence

When people believe they'll have a long-term relationship with you, their behavior becomes dramatically more predictable. The perception of longevity fundamentally alters how people approach relationships. Those who see a future with you—whether as colleagues, partners, or friends—typically invest more heavily in building trust, maintaining transparency, and fulfilling commitments. They recognize that short-term gains from deception or manipulation would undermine much greater long-term benefits. Several observable indicators reveal whether someone anticipates a long-term relationship. They readily involve you in their long-term planning, establish traditions centered around your relationship, enthusiastically include you in their professional and social circles, and position you as someone difficult to replace. Organizations signal longevity through promotions, perks, educational investments, and inclusive language like "we" rather than "you" or "I." Conversely, supervisors who forget your name, leave you out of social events, or never discuss your long-term career aspirations clearly don't envision you in their future. Reliability—the combination of competence and diligence—constitutes another critical dimension of predictable behavior. Competence refers to having the necessary skills, knowledge, and experience to fulfill expectations, while diligence encompasses persistence, motivation, thoroughness, attention to detail, work ethic, self-responsibility, and consideration for others. Both elements must be present for someone to be truly reliable. A competent person lacking diligence will disappoint just as surely as a diligent person lacking competence. The tells of reliability are readily observable in daily interactions. Reliable people carry themselves with genuine confidence—not bravado but the quiet self-assurance that comes from mastery. They speak with specificity rather than vague generalities, are transparent about their limitations, welcome challenging assignments, work efficiently, ask thoughtful questions, accept responsibility for mistakes, focus on productivity rather than personal sacrifice, maintain composure under pressure, and generally maintain positive relationships with everyone. Conversely, unreliable people often micromanage without adding value, are chronically late or difficult to contact, take credit for others' work, appear careless about their presentation, depend on others to solve problems, struggle with new concepts, keep poor records, focus more on planning than execution, and minimize their mistakes. These behavioral patterns emerge consistently across different contexts, making reliability one of the most predictable aspects of human behavior. The interconnection between longevity and reliability creates a particularly powerful indicator of trustworthiness. People who anticipate a long-term relationship have strong incentives to demonstrate reliability, while those who consistently prove reliable tend to inspire others to commit to long-term relationships with them. This virtuous cycle explains why some professional and personal connections strengthen continuously over time while others deteriorate despite seemingly promising beginnings. Understanding these dynamics allows us to strategically foster relationships with greater stability and predictability. By communicating our intention to maintain long-term connections and consistently demonstrating reliability, we encourage reciprocal behavior from others. Similarly, by recognizing these qualities in others, we can identify the most promising candidates for important roles and relationships in our lives.

Chapter 4: Actions and Language: Observing Behavioral Patterns

Actions speak volumes about character and future behavior. Past patterns of consistent behavior—particularly in situations similar to those you're concerned about—often provide the clearest indication of how someone will act in the future. These patterns reveal core values and decision-making frameworks that tend to remain stable even as circumstances change. When assessing someone's likely future behavior, their demonstrated track record offers far more reliable insights than their stated intentions or promises. Several action patterns serve as particularly strong positive indicators. People who remain loyal when others criticize you, promptly provide requested documentation, maintain consistency in their narratives, avoid gossip, refrain from criticizing family members, sidestep divisive topics, maintain consistency between professional and personal behavior, reference moral principles in business decisions, align their social media presence with their professional persona, and fulfill their hiring promises typically demonstrate high predictability across multiple domains. Conversely, certain action patterns raise significant concerns. People who lack transparency about their past, treat powerful people better than others, have résumé inconsistencies, view competitors as enemies, display erratic personal behavior patterns, remain enigmatic despite prolonged contact, withhold information about former colleagues, criticize others' personal lives, behave inconsistently, or struggle to accept responsibility typically demonstrate unpredictability that makes them difficult to trust in important matters. Language patterns offer another rich source of behavioral prediction. How people communicate—not just what they say but how they say it—reveals their thinking patterns, emotional stability, and relationship approach. The language of trust displays several distinctive characteristics: thoughtful questions rather than hasty conclusions, making others feel valued, emphasizing similarities rather than differences, maintaining appropriate eye contact, avoiding polarizing rhetoric, seeking understanding rather than winning arguments, communicating clearly, demonstrating genuine moral concern beyond political correctness, focusing on others rather than themselves, and treating everyone with equal respect regardless of status. By contrast, the language of distrust includes subtle self-aggrandizement, criticizing others to curry favor, defensiveness when challenged, employing debating tactics rather than seeking understanding, speaking in absolutes like "always" or "never," using disclaimers before delivering criticism, excessive verbosity that obscures meaning, nonverbal contradictions of verbal messages, inability to apologize sincerely, and using psychological labels to avoid accountability. These patterns emerge with remarkable consistency across different contexts and relationships. The intersection of actions and language creates a particularly powerful predictive matrix. When someone's words and deeds align consistently over time, their future behavior becomes highly predictable. Conversely, disconnects between what someone says and what they do represent significant red flags. Pay special attention to these disconnects—they often reveal the greatest insights into someone's true character and likely future behavior. Importantly, evaluating action and language patterns requires suspending judgment about whether behaviors are good or bad. The goal isn't moral assessment but accurate prediction. Even people whose patterns include behaviors you might personally dislike can be highly predictable and therefore reliable in specific contexts. Conversely, people whose patterns seem admirable might still be unpredictable in ways that make collaboration difficult. Focus solely on consistency and alignment with stated intentions.

Chapter 5: Emotional Stability: The Critical Factor in Prediction

Emotional stability serves as perhaps the most fundamental predictor of human behavior. Without stability, a person's actions become erratic and unpredictable, regardless of their intentions, competence, or past patterns. Emotionally stable individuals maintain consistent behavior even under stress, allowing for reliable prediction across diverse situations. Conversely, unstable individuals often act against their own best interests, making their behavior virtually impossible to anticipate. Several indicators reliably signal emotional stability. Stable individuals demonstrate genuine appreciation for others, remain calm under pressure, maintain rational perspectives even in emotional situations, adhere to consistent behavioral codes, offer choices rather than imposing control, display self-acceptance, view power as responsibility rather than privilege, adapt flexibly to changing circumstances, maintain composure during conflicts, and focus on solutions rather than problems. These traits create a foundation of predictability that supports all other aspects of trustworthy behavior. Conversely, emotional instability manifests in equally recognizable patterns. Unstable individuals often exhibit learned helplessness, persistently negative perceptions, catastrophizing tendencies, self-blame for problems beyond their control, victim mentalities, entitlement attitudes, excessive dependence on others, blame-shifting, emotional volatility, and manipulative behaviors. While some of these traits may stem from genuine psychological challenges, they nevertheless undermine predictability and therefore trustworthiness. The distinction between stable and unstable individuals often emerges most clearly during crises or transitions. When faced with unexpected challenges, stable individuals maintain their core behavioral patterns while adapting appropriately to new circumstances. They experience emotions without being governed by them, allowing rational assessment to guide their responses. Unstable individuals, by contrast, often become reactive, impulsive, or paralyzed during challenging situations, departing dramatically from their typical behavior patterns. Understanding the roots of emotional stability can enhance prediction accuracy. Stability typically develops from a combination of secure attachments, healthy self-concept, effective emotional regulation skills, and accumulated experiences of successfully navigating challenges. People with these foundations generally demonstrate greater consistency across different contexts and relationships. However, even individuals with strong stability foundations may experience temporary instability during periods of extreme stress, significant life transitions, or health challenges. The relationship between emotional stability and the other predictive factors creates a comprehensive framework for behavioral assessment. Stability enables the consistent application of values that drive action patterns, facilitates the communication skills that support trust-building language, provides the foundation for long-term relationship orientation, and sustains the focus necessary for reliable performance. Without stability, these other factors become unpredictable and unreliable. When interacting with emotionally unstable individuals, modified prediction strategies become necessary. Rather than expecting consistency across all situations, establish situation-specific baselines that account for known triggers and response patterns. Recognize that unstable individuals may be highly predictable within certain domains while completely unpredictable in others. This nuanced approach allows for productive relationships even with those whose emotional stability is limited to specific contexts.

Chapter 6: Building Your Trust Assessment System

Developing your personal system for sizing people up requires integrating the six behavioral prediction signs into a coherent, practical framework. This system doesn't replace human judgment—it enhances it by providing objective criteria for evaluation and decision-making. With practice, you'll move from conscious application of these principles to intuitive recognition of behavioral patterns, allowing for increasingly accurate and efficient assessment. Begin by establishing clear priorities. Different situations require different emphasis among the six signs. For high-stakes professional decisions, reliability and action patterns might deserve greatest weight. For potential long-term personal relationships, emotional stability and language patterns might take precedence. For temporary collaborations, vesting might matter most. By determining which factors are most relevant to your specific context, you can focus your observation and analysis more effectively. Gather information systematically across multiple channels. Direct observation provides the richest data, but also incorporate third-party perspectives, documented history, and contextual factors. Pay particular attention to consistency across different environments and relationships—people who maintain consistent behavior patterns regardless of audience typically demonstrate greater predictability. Look for natural, unguarded moments that reveal authentic behavior rather than carefully managed impressions. Interpret behaviors with appropriate context. Everyone exists within cultural, professional, and personal frameworks that influence their actions and communications. What might appear as unreliability in one context might represent appropriate flexibility in another. Similarly, communication styles vary significantly across cultures and industries. Effective assessment requires understanding behaviors within their relevant contexts rather than applying universal standards indiscriminately. Implement verification strategies that balance trust with prudence. The Russian proverb "trust but verify" captures this balance perfectly. Even when initial assessment suggests high trustworthiness, maintain appropriate verification mechanisms, especially in high-stakes situations. These mechanisms need not signal distrust—they can be framed as standard processes that protect all parties. Clear agreements, documented expectations, phased commitments, and regular check-ins provide verification without undermining relationship quality. Refine your system through deliberate reflection. After important interactions or decisions, evaluate the accuracy of your predictions against actual outcomes. Identify patterns in your assessment errors—do you consistently overestimate certain factors or overlook important indicators? This reflective practice accelerates learning and prevents entrenchment of biased evaluation patterns. The most skilled behavioral analysts continuously refine their assessment frameworks based on real-world results. Recognize that trust exists on a spectrum rather than as a binary state. Few people are completely trustworthy or completely untrustworthy across all domains. Most demonstrate varying degrees of predictability in different contexts. By identifying specifically where and how much someone can be trusted, you can build appropriate relationships that maximize benefits while minimizing risks. This nuanced approach allows for productive engagement even with those who may not merit complete trust. Apply your assessment system with compassion and humility. Everyone has limitations, vulnerabilities, and blind spots—including you. The goal isn't to categorize people as worthy or unworthy, but to understand them accurately enough to make wise decisions about how to engage with them. Even when assessment reveals significant concerns, maintain respect for others' dignity and potential for growth. The most effective behavioral analysts combine uncompromising accuracy with genuine goodwill.

Summary

The ability to accurately predict human behavior represents one of life's most valuable skills, yet most people rely on instinct, appearance, or wishful thinking rather than systematic observation. By focusing on six key indicators—vesting, longevity, reliability, actions, language, and emotional stability—we can dramatically improve our ability to anticipate how others will behave when it matters most. This systematic approach transforms relationships from anxiety-producing gambles into calculated investments with predictable returns. What makes this approach particularly powerful is its foundation in observable behavior rather than subjective judgment. By shifting our focus from who people are to what they consistently do, we overcome the biases and emotional reactions that typically cloud behavioral assessment. The resulting clarity allows us to build relationships based on realistic expectations rather than idealized hopes, fostering genuine trust where appropriate while establishing sensible boundaries where necessary. In a world increasingly characterized by uncertainty and change, the ability to accurately size people up provides not just practical advantage but profound peace of mind—allowing us to navigate life's complexities with confidence rather than fear.

About Author

Loading...

Robin Dreeke

FROM RECRUITING SPIES FOR THE FBI TO RECRUITING ALLIES IN BUSINESS:Robin Dreeke is an accomplished Executive Coach, Best-Selling Author, and Professional Speaker with an impressive background. As a Marine Corps Officer and retired FBI Special Agent, he served as Chief of the Counterintelligence Behavioral Analysis Program where he honed his skills in Recruiting Spies and Behavioral Assessment. Today, Robin has translated his expertise into his unique Interpersonal Communication Strategies that focus on Recruiting Allies in business. Since 2010, he has been working with Executives, Corporations, Entrepreneurs, Military, and Law Enforcement to help them Forge Trust, Solve Challenges, and Lead. Robin's People Formula has helped countless individuals and teams achieve quick, measurable results and maximum success. Whether you're a newly promoted leader, executive, sales team member, or customer relations specialist, Robin's proven strategies will help you excel.

Read more