Start Making Sense

Start Making Sense Plot Summary

Introduction

The café was unusually quiet that morning as Sarah stared into her untouched coffee. "I have everything I'm supposed to want," she whispered, "the career, the apartment, the relationship—but something feels missing." Her words hung in the air between us, heavy with a sentiment I've heard echoed by countless others navigating our uncertain times. This sense of disconnection—of having checked all the right boxes yet feeling an inexplicable emptiness—has become increasingly common in our age of anxiety, where traditional sources of meaning seem to dissolve before our eyes. We are living through an unprecedented era of disruption. Technological acceleration, social fragmentation, climate uncertainty, and global pandemics have shaken our collective sense of coherence and purpose. Yet within this chaos lies an opportunity to rediscover what truly gives our lives meaning. Through compelling stories of individuals who have found purpose amid uncertainty, this exploration reveals how humans create meaning through narrative, confront existential questions, rebuild after trauma, and cultivate lives of significance even in the most challenging circumstances. The journey ahead isn't about eliminating uncertainty but about embracing it as part of what makes us human and using it as a catalyst for creating more authentic, connected, and meaningful lives.

Chapter 1: The Existential Ape: How Humans Create Meaning

The morning sun filtered through the canopy as Jane Goodall observed a young chimpanzee named Flint. Unlike other animals that seemed content with their immediate surroundings, Flint displayed something uniquely profound – he was using a stick to extract termites from a mound, a tool his mother had taught him to use. This wasn't merely instinctual behavior; it represented cultural learning, a transmission of knowledge that required Flint to understand his world in ways that went beyond mere survival. As Goodall watched, she witnessed not just an animal using a tool, but a creature making sense of its environment through frameworks of meaning passed down through generations. This capacity to create and transmit meaning frameworks separates humans from our closest primate relatives. While chimpanzees like Flint can learn simple tool use, humans have developed elaborate systems of meaning that shape our understanding of ourselves and our world. We are, as the author describes, "existential apes" – creatures who not only exist but who constantly seek to understand our existence. This search for meaning isn't a luxury; it's fundamental to our nature. We create intricate webs of meaning through language, culture, religion, and social structures, all of which help us navigate the complexities of life. When these frameworks are threatened or broken, we experience profound discomfort and work tirelessly to restore our sense of meaning. Our meaning-making abilities evolved for good reason. As social creatures, humans needed to coordinate their activities and understand each other's intentions. This required developing shared frameworks of meaning – common understandings about how the world works and how we should behave within it. These frameworks allowed our ancestors to cooperate in hunting, gathering, and defending themselves against predators. They enabled the development of complex societies with shared values, beliefs, and goals. Without these meaning frameworks, human civilization as we know it would be impossible. The power of these meaning frameworks becomes evident when we observe how they shape our perceptions. Two people can witness the same event yet interpret it entirely differently based on their cultural backgrounds. A thunderstorm might be seen as a natural weather phenomenon by one person and as an expression of divine anger by another. Neither interpretation is inherently right or wrong; they simply reflect different meaning frameworks. This diversity of meaning-making is both a source of richness in human experience and a potential source of conflict when different frameworks clash. What makes humans truly unique is not just our ability to create meaning frameworks but our capacity to reflect on them. We can step back and question our assumptions, challenge our beliefs, and revise our understanding of the world. This meta-cognitive ability allows us to adapt our meaning frameworks as we encounter new information or experiences. It's what enables scientific progress, cultural evolution, and personal growth. The journey of human existence is, in many ways, a journey of continuously refining and expanding our frameworks of meaning.

Chapter 2: Narrative Identity: The Stories We Tell Ourselves

When Maria's grandmother passed away, she inherited a small wooden box filled with handwritten recipes. At first, Maria set it aside, too busy with work to give it much thought. Months later, during a particularly difficult weekend when she felt disconnected from everything, she opened the box. As she read through the faded cards covered in her grandmother's elegant script, something unexpected happened. Each recipe came with a story—who taught her grandmother to make this dish, when it was served, what celebrations it marked. Maria found herself cooking these recipes, sharing them with friends, telling the stories behind them. Without realizing it, she was weaving herself into a narrative that stretched back generations. This process of meaning-making through narrative is fundamental to human existence. Unlike other species, humans are storytelling creatures. We don't just experience life as a series of disconnected events; we constantly organize our experiences into coherent narratives with beginnings, middles, and ends. These stories help us make sense of who we are, where we came from, and where we're going. They connect us to something larger than ourselves—to family histories, cultural traditions, shared values, and collective purposes. Our brains are actually wired for this narrative meaning-making. Research in neuroscience shows that when we encounter random information, our minds automatically work to find patterns and create coherent stories to explain them. This isn't just a psychological quirk—it's an evolutionary adaptation that helps us navigate complex social environments and plan for uncertain futures. The anthropologist Clifford Geertz famously described humans as animals "suspended in webs of significance" that we ourselves have spun. The stories we tell ourselves aren't just passive reflections of reality; they actively shape how we experience the world. When someone describes themselves as "a survivor" rather than "a victim," or frames a job loss as "an opportunity for reinvention" rather than "a personal failure," they're engaging in narrative reconstruction that profoundly influences their emotional response and future actions. These meaning-making narratives serve as bridges between our inner and outer worlds, helping us transform raw experience into something comprehensible and purposeful. As we navigate our increasingly complex and fragmented modern landscape, our ability to construct meaningful narratives becomes both more challenging and more essential. When traditional sources of meaning weaken, we must become more intentional about crafting stories that connect us to something enduring and significant beyond ourselves. The human capacity for narrative meaning-making isn't just a psychological curiosity—it's our most powerful tool for finding purpose in an age of anxiety.

Chapter 3: When Meaning Breaks: How Our Brains Process Absurdity

The psychology professor entered the lecture hall and began his usual routine—setting down his notes, adjusting his glasses, clearing his throat. But then, without warning, he pulled out a red six of spades playing card and held it up for the class to see. "What card is this?" he asked. Students called out various answers—some said six of hearts, others insisted it was a six of spades. As the demonstration continued with more altered cards, students became visibly uncomfortable. One finally exclaimed, "I can't make the suit out, whatever it is. It didn't even look like a card that time. I don't know what color it is now or whether it's a spade or heart. I'm not even sure what a spade looks like!" This famous experiment by cognitive psychologists Jerome Bruner and Leo Postman revealed something profound about how our brains process information that doesn't fit our expectations. When confronted with anomalies—like red spades in a deck of cards—we first try to force them into existing mental frameworks. We see what we expect to see. Only when this strategy fails do we experience what researchers call "disruption"—that unsettling feeling when our meaning frameworks collapse and we tumble into the absurd. Our brains have evolved what some researchers call a "sense-making system" that works constantly to maintain coherence in our understanding of the world. When this system encounters something that doesn't fit—whether it's a red spade, a philosophical contradiction, or a traumatic event that shatters our assumptions—it triggers a neural alarm centered in the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). This same brain region activates when we experience physical pain or social rejection, suggesting that meaning disruption is processed as a genuine threat to our wellbeing. In laboratory studies, researchers have found fascinating ways people respond to these meaning threats. In one experiment, participants were unknowingly part of a magic trick where one experimenter was secretly replaced by another during a brief interruption. Though the two experimenters looked quite different, fewer than 10% of participants consciously noticed the switch. However, brain scans revealed their ACC was highly activated, and afterward, they showed stronger commitment to their existing belief systems—becoming more punitive toward rule-breakers, more patriotic, or more religious. This reveals our remarkable capacity to defend against meaninglessness. When our sense-making system is threatened, we typically respond in one of three ways: faking meaning (forcing anomalies into existing frameworks), making meaning (creating new frameworks to accommodate the anomaly), or regrounding ourselves by strengthening commitment to other meaning frameworks in our lives. These responses aren't just psychological curiosities—they're essential survival mechanisms that help us maintain the coherence we need to function in an increasingly complex and sometimes absurd world.

Chapter 4: The Burden of Choice: Freedom and Its Anxieties

John Bolton, former US national security adviser, faced a momentous decision in 1969. As a young man during the Vietnam War, he had to decide whether to enlist in the National Guard to avoid potentially being drafted and sent to the frontlines. This choice came with significant costs—committing to four years of service—but might save his life if his draft number came up low. Bolton made his decision to enlist before knowing his lottery number. When the lottery was held, he received number 185—just low enough that he would have been drafted had he not enlisted. His gamble had paid off. But contrast Bolton's experience with a fascinating study of men who had enrolled in the Reserve Officers' Training Corps (ROTC) before the same draft lottery. When surveyed months after the lottery results were announced, those who received high numbers (meaning they never would have been drafted) reported being more satisfied with their ROTC experience than those who received low numbers (who would have been drafted without ROTC). This counterintuitive finding reveals something profound about how we relate to our choices. Those who "unnecessarily" joined ROTC needed to rationalize their decision by convincing themselves they were enjoying the experience. This psychological phenomenon, known as cognitive dissonance, represents one of our most powerful meaning-making mechanisms. When our actions conflict with our beliefs or when we face evidence that we've made poor choices, we experience an uncomfortable state of tension. To resolve this tension, we often change our beliefs rather than admit we made a mistake. The ROTC members with high lottery numbers couldn't change their enrollment decision, so they changed their perception of the experience instead—finding more value in their training and working harder in their courses. Our rationalizations aren't just mental tricks—they fundamentally shape how we experience our lives. As one character in the film The Big Chill observed: "Don't knock rationalization. Where would we be without it? I don't know anyone who could get through the day without one or two juicy rationalizations." These meaning-making processes help us maintain the coherent life narratives we need to function. Without them, we would be constantly paralyzed by the weight of our choices and their consequences. The existential philosopher Søren Kierkegaard recognized this burden of freedom when he described anxiety as "the dizziness of freedom." In modern Western societies, particularly the United States, we face unprecedented levels of choice in nearly every domain—careers, relationships, identities, even spiritual beliefs. While these freedoms are celebrated, they also create what Kierkegaard called our position at "the edge of an abyss," where we must make consequential decisions without knowing how they'll unfold. This freedom to choose brings with it the responsibility for our choices—a responsibility that lies at the root of much existential anxiety in our age of seemingly limitless options.

Chapter 5: Facing Mortality: Death as a Source of Meaning

On a frigid December morning in 1849, Fyodor Dostoevsky stood on a platform in St. Petersburg, awaiting execution by firing squad. The rifles were raised, the drumroll began, and Dostoevsky experienced what he later described as the most excruciating minute of his life. Then, at the last possible moment, a messenger arrived with a reprieve from the czar. This mock execution—a calculated psychological torture—transformed Dostoevsky's outlook on life. In a letter written that same day, he declared: "Life is a gift, life is happiness, every minute can be an eternity of happiness!" Far from breaking his spirit, this confrontation with death inspired him to embrace life with renewed vigor. This pattern of posttraumatic growth following near-death experiences appears with remarkable consistency across cultures and historical periods. Hamilton Jordan, former chief of staff to President Jimmy Carter, described how his battle with cancer changed his perspective: "After my first cancer, even the smallest joys in life took on a special meaning—watching a beautiful sunset, a hug from my child, a laugh with Dorothy." Research confirms that approximately one-quarter of people who survive life-threatening dangers report similar positive psychological changes—a deeper appreciation for life, clearer priorities, and often increased spirituality. Our awareness of mortality shapes our lives in subtle ways even when we're not consciously thinking about it. As people age and perceive their remaining time as increasingly scarce, they typically shift from pursuing new experiences and relationships to savoring existing ones. Their social networks become smaller but more meaningful. Perhaps most encouragingly, research consistently finds that after middle age, people's general life satisfaction tends to increase—a pattern observed across diverse cultures worldwide. The recognition of life's finitude appears to help people focus on what truly matters. Yet our mortality awareness also creates a fundamental existential challenge. As the anthropologist Ernest Becker observed, humans face a unique predicament: we have evolved the cognitive capacity to recognize our inevitable death, yet we depend on meaning frameworks that connect us to something enduring. This creates what Becker called "the terror of death"—the awareness that everything we value will someday end. How can we build meaningful lives on a foundation we know will collapse? Terror management theory, inspired by Becker's work, suggests that humans respond to this dilemma by seeking symbolic immortality—connecting ourselves to something that will outlast our physical bodies. This might be through our children, creative works, religious beliefs, cultural identities, or contributions to causes larger than ourselves. Hundreds of studies have shown that when people are reminded of their mortality, they tend to more strongly embrace their cultural worldviews, defend their group identities, and seek reassurance that their lives matter in the grand scheme of things. Our mortality isn't just a biological fact—it's the existential backdrop against which all our meaning-making occurs. By acknowledging rather than avoiding this fundamental truth, we can paradoxically find greater freedom to live authentically and purposefully in the time we have. As Albert Camus declared: "Come to terms with death. Thereafter anything is possible."

Chapter 6: Rebuilding After Trauma: Reconstructing Shattered Frameworks

Sarah was driving home from work when her car was struck by a drunk driver. She survived, but with severe injuries that left her unable to continue her career as a physical therapist. In the months that followed, she sank into depression. "Everything I'd built my identity around was gone," she explained. "My career, my independence, my athletic hobbies—all of it vanished overnight." But something unexpected happened during her recovery. As she struggled to make sense of her new reality, Sarah began volunteering at a support group for accident survivors. "At first, I just needed to be around people who understood," she said. "But then I realized I had something valuable to offer them because of what I'd been through." Three years later, Sarah had retrained as a trauma counselor and described her life as more meaningful than before the accident. Sarah's journey illustrates what researchers call "meaning reconstruction" after trauma. When traumatic events shatter our fundamental assumptions about ourselves and the world—that life is predictable, that good things happen to good people, that we are in control of our futures—we face not just physical or emotional pain but a profound meaning crisis. Our existing frameworks for making sense of life no longer work, leaving us disoriented and distressed. Studies of trauma survivors reveal three key processes in successful meaning reconstruction. First is sense-making—the cognitive effort to understand why the trauma happened and how it fits into one's broader life narrative. Second is benefit-finding—identifying positive changes or growth that emerged from the suffering. Third is identity reconstruction—revising one's self-understanding to incorporate the traumatic experience into a coherent sense of who one is becoming. This meaning reconstruction isn't just psychological comfort—it appears essential for recovery. Research shows that trauma survivors who are able to construct coherent narratives about their experiences show better psychological and physical health outcomes than those who cannot. One landmark study of bereaved parents found that those who could articulate some meaning in their child's death showed fewer symptoms of complicated grief five years later than those who reported "no sense can be made of this loss." Perhaps most remarkably, many trauma survivors report what psychologists call "posttraumatic growth"—positive psychological changes resulting from the struggle with highly challenging life circumstances. These include deeper relationships, greater personal strength, recognition of new possibilities, spiritual development, and increased appreciation for life. One study of cancer survivors found that 83% reported at least one positive change they attributed to their illness experience. This doesn't mean trauma is good or necessary for growth—only that humans possess remarkable capacities for meaning reconstruction even in the face of profound suffering. As we navigate an age marked by collective traumas—pandemic, climate disasters, political upheaval—these insights about meaning reconstruction offer valuable guidance. They remind us that meaning isn't something we find but something we actively create, even when—perhaps especially when—our existing frameworks have been shattered by loss or change.

Chapter 7: Practical Pathways: Cultivating a Meaningful Life

Miguel worked sixty-hour weeks at a prestigious law firm, earning an impressive salary but feeling increasingly hollow. "I kept waiting to feel fulfilled," he recalled. "I had the career, the apartment, the lifestyle everyone seemed to envy. But I felt like I was just going through motions someone else had scripted for me." The turning point came unexpectedly during a pro bono case helping immigrants navigate the legal system. "For the first time in years, I felt fully present and engaged. These people's stories mattered to me in a way my corporate cases never did." Miguel didn't quit his job immediately, but he began restructuring his practice to include more immigration work. "I still handle corporate cases to pay the bills," he explained, "but now my work connects to values I genuinely care about. The difference in how I feel is night and day." Miguel's experience reflects what researchers have identified as the three core dimensions of a meaningful life: coherence (life makes sense), purpose (life has direction), and significance (life matters). While meaning is deeply personal, certain pathways consistently emerge in both philosophical traditions and empirical research as reliable sources of these meaning dimensions. Connection with others stands as perhaps the most robust source of meaning across cultures and throughout history. Studies consistently show that people who have strong, supportive relationships report higher levels of meaning in their lives. These connections don't require vast social networks—even a few deep, authentic relationships can provide a profound sense that our lives matter to others. Research shows that acts of kindness and service to others particularly enhance meaning by helping us transcend self-focus and connect to something larger than ourselves. Engagement in activities that align with our values and utilize our strengths represents another reliable path to meaning. Psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi's research on "flow"—that state of complete absorption in a challenging but manageable activity—shows that people who regularly experience flow report higher levels of meaning. Importantly, these activities need not be extraordinary or publicly recognized to provide meaning. A gardener tending plants, a teacher helping a student grasp a difficult concept, or an artist lost in the creative process can all experience profound meaning through their engagement. Narrative coherence—our ability to tell a story about our lives that makes sense—also emerges as crucial for meaning. Research shows that people who can integrate difficult experiences into a coherent life narrative report higher well-being than those who cannot. This doesn't require seeing everything as "happening for a reason," but rather developing what psychologist Dan McAdams calls "narrative identity"—a story that connects our past, present, and anticipated future in ways that provide continuity and purpose. Perhaps most fundamentally, meaning emerges from transcendence—connecting to something that extends beyond our individual existence. For many, this comes through spiritual or religious beliefs, but secular sources of transcendence also abound: commitment to social causes, appreciation of nature's vastness, participation in cultural traditions, or contributing to knowledge that will outlast us. What matters isn't the specific source of transcendence but the experience of being part of something larger and more enduring than ourselves. The search for meaning isn't a luxury—it's a fundamental human need that becomes especially crucial during times of uncertainty and change. By intentionally cultivating these pathways to meaning, we can navigate even the most challenging circumstances with greater resilience, purpose, and fulfillment.

Summary

Throughout human history, periods of profound uncertainty have triggered existential crises—moments when traditional sources of meaning no longer seem adequate to explain our experiences or guide our lives. Our current age of anxiety represents such a moment, as technological disruption, social fragmentation, climate change, and pandemic have combined to shake our collective sense of coherence and purpose. Yet within this crisis lies an opportunity to rediscover what truly gives our lives meaning and to build more intentional, authentic connections to sources of significance that can withstand uncertainty. The insights explored throughout these chapters point toward a fundamental truth: meaning isn't something we find but something we actively create through the stories we tell, the connections we nurture, the values we embody, and the ways we respond to life's inevitable challenges. Whether facing personal trauma, confronting our mortality, wrestling with difficult choices, or simply navigating daily life in uncertain times, we have remarkable capacities for meaning-making that can transform even suffering into sources of growth and purpose. By understanding these processes—how our brains respond to meaninglessness, how we rationalize our choices, how we reconstruct meaning after loss, how we connect to something transcendent—we gain practical wisdom for cultivating lives of greater coherence, purpose, and significance, even in the most challenging circumstances. The path forward isn't about eliminating anxiety but about embracing it as part of what makes us human and using it as a catalyst for creating more authentic, connected, and meaningful lives.

About Author

Loading...

Steven J. Heine

Read more