Tell Me More

Tell Me More Plot Summary

Introduction

In a world inundated with quick fixes and life hacks, Kelly Corrigan offers something refreshingly different: an honest exploration of the conversations that truly matter. Through her raw, humorous, and deeply touching narratives, she invites us to examine the phrases that shape our closest relationships. From the simple but powerful "tell me more" to the liberating admission "I don't know," Corrigan demonstrates how our most meaningful connections are built on words that often feel difficult to say. What makes Corrigan's insights so compelling is her unwavering commitment to authenticity. Whether describing family chaos at breakfast, complex grief after losing her father, or the bittersweet experience of watching her teenage daughters grow up, she approaches life's messiness with equal parts humor and grace. Through her journey, we discover the transformative power of language—how certain phrases can defuse tension, repair damage, and create space for deeper understanding. As Corrigan navigates the terrain of marriage, parenthood, friendship, and loss, she reminds us that our willingness to embrace difficult conversations might be our greatest source of connection and healing in an increasingly disconnected world.

Chapter 1: Life's Imperfect Dance: Embracing Family Chaos

Kelly Corrigan's mornings unfold like a carefully choreographed dance of chaos. Her household includes two teenage daughters—Georgia, sixteen, independent and cool on the dance floor, and Claire, fourteen, a creative soul with a passion for baking and theme parties. Their interactions range from comfortable silences watching TV reruns to heated arguments over Harry Potter pronunciation. Add to this mix Edward, her rational husband obsessed with swimming and The Wire, and Hershey, the family dog whom the children promised to care for but rarely do. One particular morning captures the essence of family turbulence when a dispute erupts over a shirt. Georgia accuses Claire of wearing her clothing without permission, unaware that their mother had redirected the barely-worn item to her younger daughter. The argument escalates until Corrigan intervenes with exasperation, her threats punctuated with colorful language that she immediately regrets. The phone rings, the dog whimpers near eggshells emptying slime onto the counter, and Edward prepares to leave for work, seemingly untouched by the morning's tensions. The intensity of Corrigan's reaction puzzles her. Why does she get so disproportionately upset over small infractions? Part of it might be grief—her beloved father had died just sixty-eight days before. The profound loss had left her oscillating between mature acceptance and childish rebellion against life's realities. But she recognizes that her emotional volatility predates this loss; she has always teetered between perspective and overreaction. Her meditation instructor Will offered wisdom that stays with her: "It's like this." This simple phrase encompasses acceptance that life's ups and downs, irritations and joys, are universal experiences—this is simply how life unfolds. Hidden in the morning's frustrations is something deeper: the awareness of mortality. Having witnessed death up close—twice—has recalibrated her understanding of pain and loss. She knows her friend Liz would have given anything for one more morning of teenage bickering, and her father had approached life as a "happiness genius" despite its challenges. Through the mundane chaos of family life, Corrigan grapples with a fundamental question: shouldn't loss change a person for the better, forever? Yet she finds herself sliding back into smallness and irritability despite knowing better. Will's phrase becomes her mantra for accepting life's imperfect rhythm: "It's like this. Minds don't rest; they reel and wander and fixate... Hearts don't idle; they swell and constrict and break and forgive... Lives don't last; they thrill and confound and circle and overflow and disappear because it's like this, having a life."

Chapter 2: The Power of Listening: When 'Tell Me More' Changes Everything

Kelly Corrigan's encounter with Tish, a perceptive esthetician during a facial appointment, revealed the transformative power of genuine listening. As Tish examined her skin, Corrigan began explaining her reluctance to purchase expensive skincare products, citing her frugal background and lack of self-discipline. Instead of dismissing these concerns or launching into a sales pitch, Tish simply said, "Tell me more." This invitation opened the floodgates, allowing Corrigan to share her struggles with daily routines and self-improvement. When Corrigan finally asked what single product might help her forehead wrinkles, Tish's perfect response—"Bangs"—showed she had truly heard what Corrigan needed, not what she could be sold. This experience contrasted sharply with Corrigan's natural tendencies as a parent. When her daughter Georgia called crying about middle school friendship drama, Corrigan's instinct was to jump in with solutions or corrections. However, her friend Tracy, sitting beside her during the call, coached her to simply echo Georgia's feelings and ask "What else?" instead of trying to fix the problem. This approach yielded remarkable results—Georgia calmed down and felt truly heard, without Corrigan having offered a single piece of advice. The practice of saying "Tell me more" creates space for deeper understanding. Corrigan recounts how Edward once described a dinner where he initially felt stuck next to an uninteresting man in an oversized blazer. After asking a few questions, he discovered the man had been a political prisoner in Madagascar, filed forty patents, and was suing the Dallas Cowboys over a retractable roof design. George Clooney had optioned his life story. Their exchange highlighted how much remains undiscovered when we fail to ask questions and truly listen. Perhaps the most poignant example comes from Corrigan's final conversations with her dying father. When he expressed regret, saying "I blew it, Lovey," she resisted the urge to immediately comfort him or change the subject. Instead, she asked, "Tell me more, Green Man." This opened a profound exchange where he shared his remorse about not naming a child after an influential coach and not taking better care of his brother-in-law during his illness. By creating space for these reflections, Corrigan allowed her father to express and process regrets that had weighed on him for decades. Through these experiences, Corrigan discovered that listening often accomplishes more than advising. When we say "Tell me more," we shift from trying to solve problems to seeking to understand them. We acknowledge that what initially appears to be the issue—a shirt, a mean classmate, forehead wrinkles—might mask deeper needs: to be understood, to feel supported, to be truly seen. As Tracy explained, "You know you're doing it right when you hear 'exactly.'" The most meaningful help we can offer isn't our wisdom, but our attention.

Chapter 3: Embracing Uncertainty: The Freedom of 'I Don't Know'

Kelly Corrigan admits to a personal tendency that many share—the compulsion to simplify complex matters. She can reduce a twenty-year marriage to "he's a narcissist," or attribute national problems to a single Supreme Court case. This habit of quick categorization extends to people: teachers are saints, administrators are bureaucrats, women apologize too much, men mansplain. These mental shortcuts provide comfort but often miss the nuanced reality of human experience. When Corrigan had cancer at thirty-six, she observed how people tried to fit her experience into familiar narratives. She was labeled "brave" despite her fear and dependence on medication to manage pain. People asked if cancer ran in her family, hoping perhaps that their own genes might protect them. Many suggested her illness must have been a "wake-up call," though Corrigan felt fully awake to life's preciousness long before her diagnosis. These simplifications, while well-intentioned, failed to capture the messy, inexplicable nature of her experience. Her friend Sarah, a pediatrician, shared a similar frustration with parents who demand immediate diagnoses for their children's behavioral issues. Sarah described a mother who had self-diagnosed her son with ADD after researching online and wanted confirmation and medication. "It's a very cool feature of the human mind that we keep hoping that our interactions are going to be different," Sarah's colleague had noted, highlighting our persistent expectation of certainty despite evidence to the contrary. Sarah explained that learning to say "I don't know" and dealing with parents' disappointment had become a crucial skill in her practice. The most profound uncertainties often surround life's biggest questions. Corrigan describes her evolving relationship with faith, having grown up Catholic in 1940s Baltimore where doubt "either didn't exist or was not discussed." While her parents maintained unwavering belief, Corrigan's path has been more circuitous. She appreciates the rituals and community of faith but cannot claim the certainty her parents possess. When her children ask about God, she tells them "people believe all kinds of things and no one really knows, including me, but that I hope for God." Corrigan's cousin Kathy offered perhaps the most powerful insight about embracing uncertainty. After losing her son Aaron in a car accident, Kathy spent years asking, "Why did this happen?" She tried numerous explanations, but nothing fit until she finally accepted the simplest truth: "It happened because it can." Cars flip, glass breaks, bodies are fragile. Seeing this reality clearly, embracing the unadulterated truth rather than constructing a comforting narrative, finally allowed her to breathe. Through these experiences, Corrigan has come to value intellectual honesty over easy answers. She strives to be "one of the exceptional people who can live with the complexity of things, who are at peace with the unknown and the unknowable." In a world that rewards certainty, acknowledging "I don't know" requires courage but offers freedom—freedom from the exhausting pretense of omniscience, and space to experience life's mysteries without reducing them to tidy conclusions.

Chapter 4: Setting Boundaries: The Strength in Saying No

Kelly Corrigan's relationship with the word "no" began with a childhood rebellion against her mother. At age ten, she boycotted cheese for an entire decade after her mother denied her request for individual hoagies at her birthday party, insisting on pizza instead. Young Kelly declared she hated cheese (a lie) and maintained her position through years of picking Parmesan off pasta and ordering plain hamburgers, a testament to her stubborn nature. Yet her mother never capitulated, showing Kelly a model of unwavering boundaries that would eventually influence her own parenting. Unlike her mother, Corrigan often finds herself seduced by the temporary popularity that comes with saying yes. She recounts a shopping mall incident where, wanting to make her daughters happy, she succumbed to an expensive hair-styling demonstration, spending $200 on impulse. She recognizes that this pattern of yielding undermines her authority: "A cheap yes is a cigarette buzz, passing in minutes, leaving you sour-stomached and polluted, somewhere you don't want to be, doing something you don't want to do, with no one but y-o-u to blame." Corrigan's mother, Mary, modeled a remarkable ability to set boundaries without apology. While other wives felt obligated to accompany their husbands everywhere, Mary would simply say, "I think I'll take a pass" or "How 'bout I catch you on the flip side?" She skipped ice hockey games in dumpy locales and distant lacrosse matches, creating a marriage that worked on her terms. Her independence wasn't a rejection of her husband but rather an honest acknowledgment of her preferences and limits. She operated from a philosophy that "people should take serious—if not total—responsibility for their own happiness." The most profound boundary-setting example came from Edward, Corrigan's husband. After recovering from cancer treatment that left her unable to have more children, Corrigan developed elaborate plans for expanding their family through adoption or surrogacy. On a flight, she presented Edward with spreadsheets detailing options, expecting his enthusiastic support. Instead, he gently but firmly declined: "I'm happy, Kelly. My wife is back to full strength. My kids are good. I can afford my life. I have no battles to wage. And I don't want a new one." Though heartbroken, Corrigan recognized the integrity in his response—rather than placating her, he had honored their relationship by expressing his authentic limits. Through these experiences, Corrigan has learned that "little noes prepare us for the big noes that define the major movements of our lives." Saying no to forgotten lunches, back-to-back sleepovers, or unpaid work builds the muscle needed for more consequential boundaries: declining a problematic job, leaving an unhealthy relationship, or refusing extreme life-saving measures. Though our culture associates "no" with negativity, Corrigan has come to see its essential role in self-preservation and authentic connection. The paradox Corrigan discovered is that boundaries actually strengthen relationships rather than weakening them. "No makes room for yes," she concludes, "and who doesn't want more room for that?" By clearly defining our limits, we create the conditions for genuine consent and enthusiastic participation in the aspects of life we truly value.

Chapter 5: Making Peace with Imperfection: Good Enough is Enough

Ariel Trost, a psychotherapist and Kelly Corrigan's walking partner, shared a pivotal moment from her training that transformed Corrigan's understanding of self-acceptance. As a twenty-four-year-old doctoral student, Ariel felt utterly unprepared to begin counseling actual patients. She confessed to her mentor, Laura: "What does twenty-four-year-old, well-educated, well-fed, well-loved me have to draw on? Books? Class exercises? Why should these people trust me with their stories, their suffering?" Laura's response was profound in its simplicity: "Because you're trustworthy, and being trustworthy is enough." This concept of "enoughness" resonated deeply with Corrigan, who had spent much of her life doubting her adequacy. She recalls her teenage years marked by a series of failures: being fired from Villanova Pizza, getting caught shoplifting at Sears, receiving an in-school suspension for drinking at a school dance. While her mother aged "a decade" during this turbulent period, her father Greenie maintained an unwavering faith in her potential. "You're good enough," he'd reassure her, patting her knee. "Trust me." His confidence seemed misplaced against the mounting evidence of her deficiencies, yet he persisted. The Jewish tradition of bat mitzvah offers another powerful illustration of declaring someone "good enough." Attending her friend Ariel's daughter Ruby's ceremony, Corrigan witnessed the community officially welcoming a thirteen-year-old into adult responsibility. Rabbi Michael explained the significance: "There's no greater gift than to help a child see their enoughness, their might." The ceremony tells young people they are ready for the journey ahead—not perfect, but sufficient for the task of living meaningfully. Corrigan's own mother, typically sparing with praise, once offered an assessment that transformed Corrigan's self-perception. After visiting California and observing her daughter manage household tasks, she remarked, "Well, Kelly, I'll tell you this: you're nothing if not competent." Though far from effusive, this practical acknowledgment of capability—coming from her most discerning critic—affected Corrigan profoundly. "If you want to know the truth, I've never thought of myself quite the same since," she writes. "Me: nothing if not competent. Me and my little life: good enough." This gradual acceptance of "good enough" represents a significant shift from Corrigan's earlier perfectionism. She recognizes that excellence isn't required in every domain—some wins "here and there" suffice. The freedom in this realization lies not in lowering standards but in understanding that worth isn't contingent on flawlessness. As Greenie suggested, resilience matters more than consistent success: "You were never down for long. You'd get cut from field hockey and try out for cheerleading... You don't need to get it right every time." The pattern repeats across generations and relationships: someone important believes in us "loudly and with conviction and against all substantiation," and eventually, we begin to believe too—"not in our shot at perfection, mind you, but in the good enough version of us that they have reflected." This is perhaps life's greatest gift: the conviction that our "hopeful, honorable intent to keep at it" is sufficient, that we are enough exactly as we are.

Chapter 6: Grief and Moving Forward: Honoring Lost Connections

Kelly Corrigan's understanding of grief was transformed through two profound losses: her father Greenie and her dear friend Liz. Greenie died at eighty-four after battling cancer, while Liz passed away at forty-six following a seven-year struggle with ovarian cancer. Though separated by nearly four decades in age, both deaths left Corrigan wrestling with the same question: how do we honor those we've lost while continuing to live? The intensity of Corrigan's grief for her father surprised even her. Three months after his death, she found herself crying so hard while driving that she had to pull over. "This is incredible," she thought. "An eighty-five-year-old man died, and here I am, fifty years old, with a full life, and I am crying so hard I have to blow my nose." What struck her wasn't shame but astonishment at the depth of human connection possible. Their relationship had been "so simple. Totally pure. Effortless. There was no tension, nothing unsaid, nothing I would have wanted more or less of." Liz's death presented different challenges. As a friend whose children were still young, Liz worried about their future without her. In one of their final conversations, she shared a dream about mothers who "had to leave early" watching over their children from seats arranged on a glass floor. Each mother could intervene only once, but as Liz watched her children navigate life's difficulties, she never needed to: "They had heartaches and regret and fights and broken bones... but they didn't need me. I never had to say anything or stop anything." After Liz died, Corrigan maintained close contact with Andy, Liz's husband, and their three children. She observed Andy's journey through grief with admiration, noting how he balanced honoring Liz's memory with moving forward. He created a new tradition on the anniversary of Liz's death, asking five people who loved her to contribute a photo and story for albums he made for each child. "That's how your family will spend the day you died," Corrigan writes in an imagined letter to Liz, "because Andy wants to remind them of things they might have forgotten... and as they get older and can understand the more complex adult parts of you, he wants them to keep getting to know you." At Liz's memorial service, Andy delivered a speech comparing their family to the Apollo 13 mission. The spacecraft, damaged and unable to complete its original mission of landing on the moon, had to use the moon's gravitational pull to propel it back toward Earth. "The kids and I are the astronauts," he explained. "We are in the ship, a little damaged, trying to figure out what to do next in the face of extreme uncertainty. Liz plays two roles. First, she's the moon... providing us with the power to propel us back toward earth." This metaphor captures the essence of moving forward after loss—not leaving the deceased behind, but using the force of their love to chart a new course. Corrigan observes that Andy and his children are "moving onward, not away from you but with you, the way I do with Greenie." This is perhaps the most profound lesson about grief: those we've loved remain woven into our lives, their influence continuing to shape us long after they're gone. We honor them not by remaining static in our sorrow, but by carrying their wisdom, love, and values forward as we navigate our altered world.

Chapter 7: Finding Meaning in the Ordinary: This Is It

Kelly Corrigan once aspired to a life of adventure and novelty. In her twenties, her motto was "Things happen when you leave the house," with "the house" symbolizing everything familiar. She saved money, filled a fanny pack with traveler's checks, and set off to see the world with her friend Tracy Tuttle. But after working as a nanny for children whose mother had recently died, her perspective shifted. She began to recognize that "the coolest thing about the coolest people I knew was that they had made real families, families with inside jokes and nicknames and weird pets they'd be talking about into their eighties." This realization set her on a path toward creating her own family, though it took longer than expected. Now, sixteen years into motherhood, she finds herself in a complex relationship with domestic life. The reality of daily existence—"moldy towels and muddy cleats," siblings clashing, teenagers absorbed in their phones—often falls short of the warm ideal she once envisioned. Yet she reminds herself that "this abstract performance art called Family Life is our one run at the ultimate improv. Our chance to be great for someone, to give another person enough of what they need to be happy." After losing her friend Liz, who was "pulled away from" family life "against her every fiber," Corrigan gained a sharper appreciation for what she has. Even when family moments seem mundane or frustrating, she recognizes them as precious: "It's happening right now, whether we attend to it or not." The most ordinary moments—a child singing in the shower—become extraordinary when viewed through the lens of gratitude and awareness. This perspective extends to her volunteer work at a children's hospital NICU, where she holds babies for two hours each week. Following the guidance of a longtime staffer named Bette, she practices the art of "close silence"—being fully present without needing to fill the space with words or activity. She notices the finest details of each infant: "swirls of hair, on their heads and cheeks and arms, little Starry Nights of the finest silk." This practice of attentive presence carries over to her relationship with her teenage daughter Georgia, who once asked if they "really needed to talk so much on the ride home from school." Corrigan realized that sometimes the most profound connection happens in shared silence, "moving quietly, even reverently, through its spaces, awed by the way two people—even a gung-ho mother and her tapped-out teenager—can hold each other without touching and cheer each other without saying a word." The title of this chapter—"This Is It"—captures Corrigan's central insight: the life we're living right now, with all its imperfections and ordinary moments, is not a rehearsal or a stepping stone to something better. It is the main event. By fully embracing this understanding, Corrigan transforms routine into revelation, finding profound meaning in the simplest aspects of human connection.

Summary

Kelly Corrigan's exploration of life's hardest conversations ultimately reveals a profound truth: our words shape our connections, and certain phrases have the power to heal, transform, and deepen our relationships. Through her candid examination of phrases like "tell me more," "I don't know," "no," "I was wrong," and "good enough," she illuminates how authentic communication creates the foundation for meaningful human bonds. Her journey through grief, parenting challenges, marriage, and self-acceptance demonstrates that embracing life's complexities—rather than seeking simple narratives or easy answers—allows us to experience our relationships with greater depth and appreciation. The wisdom Corrigan offers isn't about achieving perfection but about showing up fully in our messy, complicated lives. From her father Greenie's unfailing belief in her potential to her friend Liz's courageous journey through terminal illness, Corrigan draws lessons about resilience, authenticity, and the courage to be vulnerable. Her insights invite us to examine our own communication patterns and consider how small shifts in language might transform our relationships. Whether we're parents navigating the turbulent waters of raising teenagers, partners trying to resolve conflicts, or individuals confronting loss, Corrigan reminds us that our willingness to engage in difficult conversations—to listen deeply, admit uncertainty, set boundaries, acknowledge mistakes, and accept "good enough"—may be our greatest legacy and source of connection in an increasingly disconnected world.

About Author

Loading...

Kelly Corrigan

Kelly Corrigan is a New York Times bestselling author whose writing has appeared in O Magazine, Glamour and Good Housekeeping. Her newspaper columns for the Bay Area News Group cover everyday matters from the power of an unequivocal apology to the contagious nature of weight gain, extramarital affairs and going green."

Read more