The Advice Trap

The Advice Trap Plot Summary

Introduction

Have you ever found yourself in a conversation where you're doing all the talking, offering solutions, and yet nothing seems to change? We've all been there. That moment when we realize our well-intentioned advice isn't landing, our brilliant solutions aren't being implemented, and our expertise isn't creating the impact we hoped for. This is the advice trap that keeps us stuck in patterns of ineffective leadership. The truth is, the most powerful tool in your leadership arsenal isn't having all the answers—it's asking the right questions. When we shift from telling to asking, we unlock hidden potential, foster deeper engagement, and create sustainable change. Throughout these pages, you'll discover how to tame your natural tendency to jump to solutions and instead cultivate the art of curiosity that transforms both your leadership approach and the people around you.

Chapter 1: Recognize When Advice Becomes a Trap

Advice is seductive. It feels good to give it. It positions us as experts, as valuable contributors, as people who know what they're talking about. But advice, even when well-intentioned, often becomes a trap that limits both the giver and receiver. The problem isn't that advice is inherently bad—it's that we've become addicted to dispensing it, even when it's not what's needed. Michael Bungay Stanier calls this the "Advice Monster," that voice inside that convinces us we must have the answer, we must save the situation, we must maintain control. This monster shows up in three distinct personas: Tell-It (who believes you add value by having answers), Save-It (who believes you're responsible for fixing everything), and Control-It (who believes letting go leads to disaster). Each persona serves our ego but undermines our effectiveness as leaders. Consider Sarah, a senior manager at a technology firm who prided herself on being available to her team with solutions. Whenever team members approached her with problems, she'd quickly offer detailed advice on how to proceed. She believed this demonstrated her expertise and value. Yet over time, she noticed her team seemed increasingly dependent on her input, rarely taking initiative, and showing signs of disengagement. Her advice, meant to help, had created a cycle of dependency that was exhausting her and limiting her team's growth. The turning point came during a leadership workshop when Sarah realized her constant advice-giving wasn't empowering her team but rather teaching them to rely on her thinking instead of developing their own. She began to experiment with asking questions instead of immediately offering solutions. When a team member came with a problem about a difficult client, instead of jumping to her usual "Here's what you should do," she asked, "What have you tried so far?" and "What do you think might work?" To break free from the advice trap, start by noticing when your Advice Monster appears. Pay attention to trigger situations—perhaps when someone is struggling, when time is short, or when you know the subject well. Then pause before responding. This brief moment allows you to choose curiosity over immediate advice. Practice phrases like "Tell me more about that" or "What's the real challenge here for you?" instead of launching into solutions. Remember that taming your Advice Monster doesn't mean never giving advice. It means becoming more intentional about when and how you offer it. The goal is to create space for others to think, grow, and own their challenges rather than becoming dependent on your solutions. When you recognize advice as a potential trap rather than an automatic good, you open the door to more effective leadership conversations that build capability rather than dependency.

Chapter 2: Tame Your Advice Monster

At the heart of becoming a more effective leader lies the challenge of taming your Advice Monster. This isn't about eliminating advice entirely—it's about gaining control over when and how you dispense it, so you can create space for others to think for themselves. The Advice Monster thrives on the belief that you're better than the other person—smarter, more experienced, more capable. This belief, often unconscious, drives the compulsion to jump in with solutions. Recognizing this dynamic is the first step toward change. As Bungay Stanier explains, "When you're in the grip of your Advice Monster, you're saying they're not smart enough, wise enough, resilient enough, capable enough... You're saying they're not good enough." John, a marketing director at a consumer goods company, struggled with this pattern. His team would present ideas, and he'd immediately point out flaws and suggest improvements. He believed he was helping, but his team gradually stopped bringing creative concepts to meetings. During a coaching session, John realized his behavior sent the message that he didn't trust his team's thinking. This insight hit him hard—he'd never intended to undermine their confidence. John committed to taming his Advice Monster through a four-step process. First, he identified his triggers—particularly when presentations involved high-stakes clients or tight deadlines. Second, he acknowledged his specific behaviors, like interrupting with "a better approach would be..." Third, he examined the short-term rewards (feeling important, maintaining control) and long-term costs (disengaged team, limited innovation) of these behaviors. Finally, he clarified the benefits of changing—developing a more capable team and freeing himself to focus on strategic work. To implement this change, start by identifying which Advice Monster persona dominates your leadership style. For Tell-It, practice asking "What's your perspective?" before sharing yours. For Save-It, try asking "How would you like to handle this?" instead of jumping in to fix problems. For Control-It, experiment with "What would you do if I wasn't available?" to encourage independent thinking. Remember that this is what Bungay Stanier calls "Hard Change"—it requires rewiring deep habits rather than simply adding new skills. You'll need to practice consistently and forgive yourself when you slip back into old patterns. The key is to keep returning to curiosity. The reward for taming your Advice Monster is substantial: you'll develop more capable team members, reduce your workload, and create a culture of innovation and engagement. Most importantly, you'll shift from a leadership approach based on having all the answers to one based on unlocking the potential in others.

Chapter 3: Master the Art of Curiosity

Curiosity is the engine that powers meaningful conversations and unlocks hidden potential. When we're genuinely curious, we suspend judgment, listen deeply, and create space for new insights to emerge. But being curious isn't just about asking any questions—it's about asking the right questions in the right way. The foundation of masterful curiosity lies in what Bungay Stanier calls "staying curious a little longer" and "rushing to action and advice-giving a little more slowly." This simple but profound shift creates the conditions for others to think more clearly and creatively about their challenges. It's about creating a container for thought rather than filling that container with your ideas. Consider the case of Elena, a financial advisor who struggled to help clients make meaningful changes in their spending habits. Despite providing detailed financial plans and clear advice, her clients rarely followed through. During a professional development workshop, Elena realized she was spending most of her client meetings talking rather than listening. She decided to experiment with a more curious approach. In her next client meeting with a couple struggling with debt, instead of immediately outlining a budget plan, she asked, "What's the real challenge here for you?" This simple question led to a revelation—the husband and wife had fundamentally different attitudes toward money that they'd never fully discussed. This insight, which might never have surfaced if Elena had followed her usual advice-giving approach, became the foundation for meaningful financial change. To develop your curiosity muscle, start with what Bungay Stanier calls the "seven essential questions": "What's on your mind?" "And what else?" "What's the real challenge here for you?" "What do you want?" "How can I help?" "If you're saying yes to this, what must you say no to?" and "What was most useful for you?" These questions work in almost any situation and can be mixed and matched as needed. How you ask is as important as what you ask. Ask one question at a time, then wait. Resist the urge to fill silence or to ask rhetorical questions that are really just advice in disguise. Focus on questions that start with "what" rather than "why" (which can trigger defensiveness) or "how" (which moves too quickly to solutions). The art of curiosity also involves learning to recognize when conversations get foggy. Watch for patterns like "Settling" (avoiding the real issue), "Popcorning" (jumping between multiple problems), or "Coaching the Ghost" (focusing on other people rather than the person you're talking to). When you notice these patterns, gently redirect with "What's the real challenge here for you?" Mastering curiosity transforms not just your conversations but your entire approach to leadership. You'll find that by asking powerful questions, you often contribute more value than you ever did by having all the answers.

Chapter 4: Ask Questions That Uncover Real Challenges

The most valuable service you can provide as a leader isn't solving problems—it's helping others identify which problems actually need solving. Too often, we waste time and resources working on the wrong challenges because we rush to address the first issue mentioned rather than digging deeper to find the real obstacle. The key to uncovering real challenges lies in what Bungay Stanier calls the "Focus Question": "What's the real challenge here for you?" This seemingly simple question has remarkable power to cut through confusion and surface the core issues that matter most. The emphasis on "real" acknowledges that what's initially presented is often just the tip of the iceberg, while "for you" ensures the conversation stays personal and relevant. David, a project manager at an engineering firm, was frustrated by recurring delays in his team's deliverables. In team meetings, he'd spend hours troubleshooting specific technical issues that team members raised, yet the overall pattern of delays continued. During a leadership development program, David learned about the Focus Question and decided to try a different approach. At his next team meeting, when an engineer mentioned problems with a particular component, David resisted his urge to immediately solve that specific issue. Instead, he asked, "I hear that's a problem, but what's the real challenge here for you?" After a moment of silence, the engineer admitted that the technical problems were manageable—the bigger issue was unclear priorities from senior leadership that kept shifting the team's focus. This revelation led to a completely different conversation about how to manage changing requirements, which ultimately addressed the pattern of delays more effectively than any technical fix could have. To implement this approach, watch for what Bungay Stanier calls "Foggy-fiers"—patterns that obscure real challenges. These include "Twirling" (accepting the first problem mentioned), "Big-Picturing" (staying at an abstract level), and "Yarning" (getting lost in excessive details). When you notice these patterns, gently redirect the conversation by saying what you see: "I notice we're talking about a lot of different issues. What's the real challenge here for you?" Remember that finding the real challenge doesn't mean you immediately jump to solving it. Once you've identified it, check whether you've truly reached the heart of the matter by asking, "Is this the real challenge, or is there something else underneath this?" Then ask what help they actually need from you, rather than assuming you know. By consistently focusing on uncovering real challenges rather than rushing to solve the first problem presented, you'll help others develop clearer thinking, save time and resources, and address the issues that truly matter. This shift from being the answer-provider to being the challenge-clarifier is one of the most valuable contributions you can make as a leader.

Chapter 5: Create Engagement Through Meaningful Conversations

Engagement isn't something you can demand or manufacture—it emerges naturally when people feel psychologically safe, valued, and connected to meaningful work. The key to creating this engagement lies in how you structure your conversations to address the brain's fundamental social needs. Bungay Stanier introduces the TERA model (Tribe, Expectation, Rank, Autonomy) as a framework for understanding what makes conversations engaging or disengaging. When the TERA Quotient is high, people lean in, access their creative thinking, and bring their best selves to the interaction. When it's low, they disengage, become defensive, or simply comply without commitment. Mark, a newly promoted team leader in customer service, struggled with low team morale and high turnover. His one-on-one meetings felt stilted, with team members giving minimal responses and showing little initiative. After learning about the TERA model, Mark realized his conversation style was undermining engagement rather than enhancing it. He began experimenting with small changes. For Tribe (are you with me or against me?), he started meetings by checking in personally before diving into work topics. For Expectation (do I know what's happening?), he explained his process: "I'd like to spend the first ten minutes hearing your priorities, then we'll discuss resources you need." For Rank (are you more or less important than me?), he asked for their input before sharing his own ideas. For Autonomy (do I have a choice?), he shifted from telling them what to do to asking what approach they thought would work best. The transformation wasn't immediate, but over several weeks, Mark noticed team members speaking up more, sharing challenges more openly, and taking more initiative between meetings. One team member commented that she finally felt like her ideas mattered, which had made her more invested in her role. To increase engagement in your conversations, start by focusing on one TERA element at a time. For Tribe, use inclusive language like "we" and "us," and acknowledge others' perspectives even when you disagree. For Expectation, create clarity about the conversation process: "Here's what I'm thinking for our discussion today..." For Rank, ask questions that elevate others' status: "You've been working on this longer than I have—what patterns have you noticed?" For Autonomy, create choice wherever possible: "Would you prefer to tackle this challenge by yourself first or brainstorm together?" Pay attention to which TERA element might be most lacking in your typical conversations. If you tend to control discussions tightly, focus on increasing Autonomy. If you jump straight to business without connection, emphasize Tribe. The goal isn't perfect balance but an overall increase in the TERA Quotient. Remember that engagement isn't just about making people feel good—it's about creating the conditions where people can think clearly, contribute fully, and take ownership of their work. When you structure conversations with TERA in mind, you tap into intrinsic motivation rather than relying on external pressure or incentives.

Chapter 6: Transform Leadership Through Humble Inquiry

Leadership transformation begins when we shift from seeing ourselves as the expert with answers to the explorer with questions. This shift requires what Edgar Schein calls "humble inquiry"—the art of asking questions to which you don't already know the answer, from a place of genuine curiosity rather than testing or leading. Humble inquiry is founded on three leadership qualities that Bungay Stanier identifies as essential: empathy (understanding others' experiences), mindfulness (being present rather than reactive), and humility (knowing your strengths and limitations). These qualities don't make you weaker as a leader—they make you more human and more effective. Rachel, a hospital administrator, prided herself on her decisive leadership style. When problems arose, she quickly assessed the situation and directed staff on how to proceed. While this approach worked in true emergencies, she noticed increasing resistance from her experienced nursing staff during regular operations. During a leadership retreat, Rachel realized her directive style was sending the message that she didn't trust her team's judgment. Rachel began practicing humble inquiry by asking questions like "What are you seeing that I might be missing?" and "What would you do in this situation?" At first, staff seemed surprised by her questions and gave cautious responses. But as Rachel consistently demonstrated genuine interest in their perspectives, the quality of conversation transformed. Nurses began sharing insights about patient care patterns that Rachel, from her administrative position, couldn't see. These insights led to several process improvements that reduced readmission rates. To practice humble inquiry in your leadership, start by examining your beliefs about what makes a good leader. Many of us carry the unconscious belief that leaders should be decisive, confident, and quick with answers. Challenge this belief by asking yourself: "When have I been most influenced by another leader? Was it when they told me what to do, or when they helped me think more clearly?" Create opportunities for humble inquiry by establishing regular one-on-one conversations that begin with open questions: "What's on your mind?" "What's working well?" "What's challenging you right now?" When someone brings you a problem, resist the urge to immediately offer solutions. Instead, ask "What have you thought about so far?" and "What do you think is the best approach?" Pay attention to your body language and tone when asking questions. Humble inquiry isn't an interrogation—it's an invitation to think together. Maintain eye contact, lean in slightly, and demonstrate through your presence that you're genuinely interested in the response, not just waiting for your turn to speak. Remember that humble inquiry doesn't mean abdicating your responsibility as a leader. There are times when direction is needed. The transformation comes from making conscious choices about when to direct and when to inquire, rather than defaulting to advice-giving in every situation. By practicing humble inquiry consistently, you create a culture where thinking is valued, diverse perspectives are sought, and people at all levels contribute their best ideas. This is the foundation of adaptive, innovative organizations that can thrive in complex environments.

Chapter 7: Practice Generosity in Coaching Conversations

True coaching conversations are acts of generosity—giving your full attention, creating space for others to think, and believing in their capacity to grow. This generosity manifests in three powerful ways that transform ordinary interactions into extraordinary opportunities for development. The first form of generosity is what Bungay Stanier calls "generous silence." Most of us are uncomfortable with silence in conversation—we rush to fill it with words, advice, or reassurance. Yet silence is often where the deepest thinking happens. Generous silence isn't awkward or pressuring; it's a gift of space that says, "I'm here, I'm not going anywhere, and I believe you have something valuable to discover." The second form is "generous transparency," where you share your process and even your uncertainty. Rather than hiding behind a facade of perfect knowledge, you might say, "I'm not sure where this conversation is going, but I'm curious to explore it with you." This vulnerability creates authenticity and invites others to bring their whole selves to the interaction. The third form is "generous appreciation," which goes beyond praising accomplishments to recognizing someone's essential qualities. Instead of just saying "Good job on the presentation," you might say, "I appreciate your courage in tackling such a complex topic and your clarity in making it accessible." Thomas, a marketing director, struggled with a talented but underperforming team member named Alicia. Despite having technical skills, Alicia seemed hesitant to take initiative or share ideas in meetings. Thomas had tried motivational talks and clear direction, but nothing seemed to help. After learning about generous coaching conversations, he decided to try a different approach. In their next one-on-one, Thomas asked Alicia what she found most challenging about her current projects, then practiced generous silence after she gave a brief answer. The silence felt uncomfortable at first, but after several seconds, Alicia began sharing deeper concerns about not wanting to disappoint the team. Thomas practiced transparent coaching by acknowledging, "I sometimes feel I'm not giving you the right support, and I'm curious what would help you thrive." This openness led to Alicia revealing that her previous manager had criticized her ideas so harshly that she'd become afraid to speak up. The conversation ended with Thomas expressing genuine appreciation for Alicia's perfectionism and attention to detail, while also encouraging her to trust her creative instincts. To practice generosity in your coaching conversations, start by becoming comfortable with silence. Count to five in your head before responding to a question or comment. Notice your urge to fill the silence, and practice restraint. When the person does respond, listen fully rather than planning your next question. Experiment with transparency by sharing your thinking process: "Here's what I'm noticing in our conversation..." or "I'm wondering if we're getting to the heart of the matter." This invites the other person to be a partner in the conversation rather than just a recipient of your questions. Finally, look for opportunities to offer specific, genuine appreciation that speaks to who the person is, not just what they've done. This isn't about empty praise but about seeing and acknowledging their unique strengths and qualities. Remember that generosity in coaching conversations isn't just nice—it's effective. When people feel genuinely seen, heard, and valued, they bring their best thinking to the table and develop the confidence to act on their insights.

Summary

Throughout these pages, we've explored how the simple act of asking powerful questions can transform your leadership and unlock potential in those around you. By taming your Advice Monster, mastering curiosity, uncovering real challenges, creating engagement, practicing humble inquiry, and approaching conversations with generosity, you create the conditions for others to think more clearly, act more confidently, and grow more consistently. As Bungay Stanier reminds us, "The leaders of the future will know how to ask." This isn't just a prediction—it's an invitation to become that leader today. Start small by choosing one conversation tomorrow where you'll stay curious a little longer and rush to advice-giving a little more slowly. Notice what changes, both in the quality of thinking that emerges and in how you feel as a leader. The art of asking isn't just a skill to develop—it's a way of being that honors the wisdom and potential in everyone you lead.

About Author

Loading...

Michael Bungay Stanier

Hi - I'm a book reader, writer and lover.I'm best known for *The Coaching Habit*, the best-selling book on coaching this century. (Close to a million copies sold!)I'm also the host of the podcast *2 Pages with MBS* where brilliant people read the best two pages of a favourite book.

Read more

Related Books by Michael Bungay Stanier

Loading...

The Coaching Habit

Michael Bungay Stanier

Say Less, Ask More &amp, Change the Way You Lead Forever

★★★★½4.5

Loading...

How to Begin

Michael Bungay Stanier

A Proven Plan to Start Something That Matters

★★★★☆4.4