The Black Church

The Black Church Plot Summary

Introduction

The journey of the Black Church in America begins not with a single institution, but with fragments of faith carried across the Atlantic by enslaved Africans. As they faced the brutal realities of American slavery, these men and women forged spiritual practices that would become their foundation for survival, resistance, and ultimately freedom. From clandestine gatherings in "hush harbors" to magnificent urban sanctuaries, the development of Black religious institutions represents one of the most remarkable stories of resilience in American history. Through five centuries of struggle, the Black Church has been many things at once: a sanctuary from oppression, an incubator for Black leadership, a center of community organizing, and the birthplace of transformative music that would reshape American culture. This spiritual journey tells us not just about religious development, but about how African Americans created spaces of dignity and possibility in a society that repeatedly denied their humanity. Understanding this history illuminates how religious communities became powerful engines for social change, from abolitionism to civil rights to contemporary movements for racial justice. For anyone seeking to comprehend American history, the essential role of Black religious communities in shaping our national journey toward freedom and equality cannot be overlooked.

Chapter 1: Foundations: African Origins and Early Christianity (1619-1800)

When the first Africans arrived in North America, they brought with them diverse religious traditions. The people who would become African Americans originated from various regions in West and Central Africa, practicing indigenous religions alongside Islam, which had spread through West Africa since the tenth century, and in some cases Catholicism, which had taken root in parts of Central Africa by the fifteenth century. These spiritual practices did not simply disappear upon arrival in America but instead went underground, adapting to survive under the harsh conditions of enslavement. The early experience of Africans with Christianity in North America varied dramatically between colonies. In Spanish Florida, where enslaved Africans had been present since at least 1526, the Catholic Church actively sought to convert Africans, continuing a tradition of Black inclusion that stretched back to medieval Europe. In contrast, Protestant slaveholders in British colonies like Virginia initially resisted converting enslaved people, fearing that Christian baptism might lead to claims of freedom. This reluctance changed only after laws explicitly stated that baptism would not alter enslaved status. By the early eighteenth century, some Protestant missionaries began targeted efforts to convert enslaved Africans. Men like Morgan Godwyn and Francis Le Jau argued for bringing Christianity to enslaved communities, but they carefully framed their arguments to reassure slaveholders that conversion would make enslaved people more docile and obedient. Their version of Christianity deliberately omitted biblical narratives of liberation, particularly the story of Exodus, which described God freeing the enslaved Israelites from Egypt. Instead, they emphasized passages about serving earthly masters. Yet enslaved Africans proved remarkably adept at hearing a different message in Christian scripture. They recognized in biblical stories of deliverance and salvation parallels to their own circumstances. As the Reverend Jonathan Walton explains, "There's this Exodus motif of God siding with those who are enslaved, a God who rises up." When enslaved Africans encountered Christianity, they infused it with their own spirituality and understanding, creating religious practices that offered hope while preserving elements of their African heritage. The ring shout, for example, became a cornerstone of early Black worship, connecting African ritual movement with Christian expression. During this early period, some African Muslims maintained their religious practices despite overwhelming obstacles. Figures like Job Ben Solomon and Umar ibn Said preserved their Islamic faith through their literacy in Arabic, with Solomon even writing his way out of enslavement. On the Sea Islands of Georgia and South Carolina, evidence of Muslim practices persisted for generations, as seen in the testimony of Katie Brown about her great-grandfather Bilali Mohammed, who maintained his daily prayers and used prayer beads. The First Great Awakening of the 1730s and 1740s marked a turning point for African American Christianity. These revival meetings featured emotional preaching and worship styles that resonated with African spiritual traditions. Black attendance grew as evangelists welcomed all regardless of status or race. In this environment, African Americans began establishing their own religious traditions that would later blossom into independent Black churches – creating spaces where they could worship freely and interpret Christianity through their own cultural lens.

Chapter 2: The Freedom Faith: Abolition and Civil War Era (1800-1865)

The dawn of the nineteenth century witnessed the emergence of distinctly Black Christian denominations, fundamentally reshaping American religious life. When Richard Allen led the famous walkout from St. George's Methodist Church in Philadelphia after being forced to sit in segregated seating, he launched what would become the first independent African American denomination – the African Methodist Episcopal (AME) Church, formally established in 1816. Similarly, the AME Zion Church formed in New York in 1821. These institutions represented more than just places of worship; they embodied a revolutionary concept – African American religious self-determination. These early Black churches became centers of abolitionist activity, education, and mutual aid. The Methodist and Baptist traditions proved particularly appealing to Black Americans because of their emphasis on emotional expression in worship, their democratic organization, and initially, their anti-slavery stance. Church leaders like Richard Allen, Absalom Jones, and later Sojourner Truth and Frederick Douglass emerged as powerful voices against slavery, framing their arguments in the language of biblical justice. Douglass, who first developed his oratorical skills preaching at AME Zion Church in New Bedford, Massachusetts, famously declared that the Christianity of slaveholders had nothing in common with the Christianity of Christ. Black ministers approached abolition with various strategies. In 1843, at the National Negro Convention in Buffalo, two escaped slaves – Frederick Douglass and Henry Highland Garnet – represented opposing views on how to end slavery. Garnet called for direct resistance: "Brethren, arise, arise! Strike for your lives and liberties... Rather die freemen than live to be slaves." Douglass, concerned about antagonizing white allies, advocated working within the political system. Their debate highlighted the complex relationship between Black religious thought and political action that would continue throughout American history. The spiritual songs created during slavery – known as spirituals or "Sorrow Songs" – encoded messages of resistance and hope. Songs like "Steal Away to Jesus" could serve as signals for clandestine meetings or escapes. These songs expressed both profound suffering and unquenchable hope through biblical imagery. Frederick Douglass described them as "a testimony against slavery, and a prayer to God for deliverance from chains." When Union Colonel Thomas Wentworth Higginson heard these songs from Black soldiers during the Civil War, he recognized their deeper significance, writing that they were "more than a source of relaxation; they were a stimulus to courage and a tie to heaven." When the Civil War finally erupted in 1861, many Black Christians interpreted it as divine judgment against slavery. Black ministers like Henry McNeal Turner joined the Union Army as chaplains, providing spiritual guidance to Black troops. President Lincoln's evolving stance on emancipation culminated in the Emancipation Proclamation, which took effect January 1, 1863, prompting "Watch Night" services in Black churches across the North as congregations prayed for freedom. When news of emancipation spread, approximately half a million enslaved people fled to Union lines. The freedom faith that had sustained African Americans through centuries of bondage now propelled them toward citizenship. Black churches provided organizational structures, leadership training, and theological frameworks that would prove essential for the challenges of Reconstruction and beyond. What had begun as an "invisible institution" under slavery was poised to become the central pillar of Black community life in freedom – a transformation that would shape American religion, culture, and politics for generations to come.

Chapter 3: Nation Within a Nation: Reconstruction and Jim Crow (1865-1920)

In the aftermath of the Civil War, newly emancipated African Americans seized the opportunity to build institutions that would sustain their communities. Central among these was the independent Black Church, which experienced explosive growth throughout the South. As Evelyn Brooks Higginbotham noted, "The church formed a nation within a nation. The church was, then at least, the single most important institution in the Black community." While only about 10 percent of Black Christians belonged to independent Black denominations before the Civil War, by 1890, the vast majority worshipped in their own churches. Freedpeople began by claiming physical spaces for worship. Some took over church buildings abandoned by fleeing Confederate owners, while others built new structures from scratch. At Brick Baptist Church on St. Helena Island, South Carolina, the transition happened almost overnight. As deacon Joseph McDomick explains, "One Sunday, Brick Baptist was white. The next Sunday, it was Black." These buildings served multiple purposes – as schools, community centers, and political gathering spaces. Northern missionaries, both Black and white, flooded South during this period, but Black denominations like the AME Church took the lead in establishing congregations across the former Confederacy. The church became a primary vehicle for African Americans to exercise citizenship and political leadership during Reconstruction. Some 2,000 Black men held public office during this period, at least 243 of them ministers. Richard Harvey Cain, who rebuilt Charleston's Emanuel AME Church (later known as "Mother Emanuel"), was elected to Congress in 1872, where he eloquently appealed for civil rights: "I do not ask any legislation for the colored people of this country that is not applied to the white people. All that we ask is equal laws, equal legislation, and equal rights throughout the length and breadth of this land." Class and cultural tensions emerged within Black religious communities. Northern Black missionaries often promoted "respectable" Victorian worship styles that clashed with the more emotionally expressive traditions of rural Black Southerners. Bishop Daniel Payne of the AME Church dismissed spirituals as "cornfield ditties" and attempted to eliminate practices like the ring shout, calling them "heathenish." Meanwhile, charismatic preachers like John Jasper gained enormous popularity through traditional Black preaching styles. When the Fisk Jubilee Singers began performing spirituals for northern white audiences in the 1870s, they helped legitimate these songs as valuable cultural expressions rather than embarrassing remnants of slavery. With the collapse of Reconstruction and the rise of Jim Crow segregation in the 1880s and 1890s, Black churches became even more central to community survival. As white violence intensified and political rights were systematically stripped away, the church remained one place where African Americans could exercise autonomy and leadership. The founding of the National Baptist Convention in 1895 represented this vision of self-determination, quickly becoming the largest Black religious organization in America. Yet even as churches provided crucial support, new theological questions emerged. Bishop Henry McNeal Turner, once optimistic about American democracy, now proclaimed, "God is a Negro," challenging white supremacist theology that had depicted God as white. By the early twentieth century, Black churches had developed a wide array of institutions – schools, publishing houses, missionary societies, and mutual aid organizations – that sustained Black communities under segregation. Women like Nannie Helen Burroughs played crucial roles in these efforts despite being denied formal leadership positions. At the 1900 National Baptist Convention, Burroughs delivered her famous speech "How the Sisters Are Hindered from Helping," challenging male domination of church affairs. Women's auxiliaries became powerful vehicles for social reform, addressing not just spiritual needs but education, economic development, anti-lynching activism, and women's rights.

Chapter 4: Civil Rights and Social Gospel: The Church as Movement (1920-1968)

The Great Migration fundamentally transformed African American religious life as millions of Black Southerners moved to northern and western cities between 1916 and the 1970s. They brought their faith traditions with them, establishing churches that became anchors in new urban communities. Many of these churches embraced the social gospel movement, expanding their ministry beyond spiritual concerns to address poverty, housing discrimination, healthcare, and education. As Jonathan Walton explains, "Migrants did not have access to minimal services, whether it was healthcare, job employment... They would find these things in the church." Class tensions complicated this religious landscape. Established northern churches sometimes looked down on the expressive worship styles of southern migrants, leading to the creation of storefront churches that preserved traditional practices. The music of the church also evolved, with Thomas A. Dorsey pioneering gospel music by fusing sacred lyrics with blues and jazz influences. Initially controversial, gospel eventually became the dominant sound of Black sacred music, represented by artists like Mahalia Jackson, whose 1947 recording "Move On Up a Little Higher" launched what many consider the Golden Age of Gospel. During this period, some African Americans sought spiritual alternatives beyond Christianity. Marcus Garvey's Pan-African movement influenced religious thinking with its assertion of Black dignity and divine purpose. The Nation of Islam, founded in 1930, attracted followers through its message of Black self-determination, economic independence, and rejection of white supremacy. As anthropologist Donna Auston explains, "The Nation of Islam explicitly critiques white supremacy through its theology and practice... In other words, as a Black person, the way God made you is beautiful." The modern civil rights movement emerged directly from Black church traditions and leadership. When Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat in Montgomery in 1955, local ministers including the young Martin Luther King Jr. organized the bus boycott that launched the movement. King's theology of nonviolent resistance was influenced by his family's Baptist tradition, Howard Thurman's writings (especially Jesus and the Disinherited), and Gandhi's philosophy. King's fellow minister Andrew Young recalls, "Martin Luther King, Jr., always traveled with Jesus and the Disinherited... I mean, clean underwear, shirt, and he'd have Howard Thurman in his briefcase." Music remained central to the movement. Freedom songs adapted from spirituals and gospel provided courage and unity during protests. Rutha Mae Harris, one of the original Freedom Singers, explains their importance: "A song kept us from being afraid. Say you're walking down the street doing a march and this policeman tell you, 'You're gonna be hit,' or whatever. You start singing, 'Ain't gonna let nobody turn me 'round.'" Gospel artists like Mahalia Jackson not only inspired activists but helped fund the movement through benefit concerts. White supremacist violence repeatedly targeted Black churches during the civil rights era. In September 1963, the bombing of Birmingham's Sixteenth Street Baptist Church killed four young girls, galvanizing support for the Civil Rights Act of 1964. During Mississippi's Freedom Summer in 1964, thirty-seven Black churches were bombed or burned in a ten-week period. Despite this terror, the movement persisted, culminating in the Voting Rights Act of 1965. In his final years, King expanded his focus to economic justice and opposition to the Vietnam War. The Poor People's Campaign represented his vision of an interracial coalition demanding economic rights. His assassination in Memphis in 1968, where he had gone to support striking sanitation workers, marked a tragic end to this phase of the movement, leaving the Black Church at a crossroads as it faced new challenges in the post-civil rights era.

Chapter 5: Modern Challenges: From Black Power to Black Lives Matter (1968-Present)

King's assassination sent shock waves through Black communities and triggered a profound reassessment of the church's role in the freedom struggle. The rise of Black Power in the late 1960s challenged the church's traditional approach to civil rights, with young activists increasingly drawn to more militant, secular organizations like the Black Panther Party. Some questioned whether Christianity, historically used to justify slavery and oppression, could truly liberate African Americans. As Anthony Pinn notes, "With the killing of Martin Luther King, Jr., the ability of folks to see the Black Church as a strong force for transformation was brought into question." In response to these challenges, James Hal Cone developed Black liberation theology, publishing his groundbreaking "Black Theology and Black Power" in 1969. Cone argued that Jesus identified so completely with the oppressed that "God is Black" – not merely metaphorically but in essence. This theology profoundly influenced a generation of ministers, including Jeremiah Wright, who transformed Chicago's Trinity United Church of Christ into a center of Black liberation theology and community service. Wright's church would later gain national attention when his parishioner Barack Obama ran for president, revealing to many white Americans a Black Church tradition they had never encountered. The late twentieth century also saw growing challenges to sexism within Black churches. While women had always constituted the majority of church membership, they were largely excluded from leadership positions. The development of womanist theology in the 1980s, building on the work of earlier figures like Pauli Murray and extending from Alice Walker's concept of womanism, addressed the triple oppression Black women faced through race, gender, and class. Scholars and ministers like Kelly Brown Douglas and Jacquelyn Grant centered Black women's experiences in theological discourse. In 2000, this struggle achieved a significant milestone when Vashti Murphy McKenzie became the first woman elected bishop in the AME Church. Issues of sexuality similarly divided many Black congregations. The emergence of HIV/AIDS in the 1980s prompted varied responses from Black churches, from compassionate ministry to stigmatization. Leaders like Bishop Yvette Flunder, who founded the City of Refuge in 1991, created inclusive spaces for LGBTQ Christians. Flunder describes her mission: "What we don't have, we must create – a congregation that keeps the culture and the sound of the Black Church sans the homophobic and fragile patriarchy realities that exist in the churches that we came from." Economic shifts created new challenges and opportunities. The growth of the Black middle class during the post-civil rights era led to the rise of prosperity theology and megachurches. Bishop T.D. Jakes built The Potter's House in Dallas into a massive enterprise offering not just spiritual guidance but entrepreneurship training and financial literacy. Critics questioned whether this represented a departure from the church's social justice roots. William Barber II asks pointedly, "How did we go from 'I Have a Dream' to bling-bling? The Black Church has been very clear. To be a person of faith, to be a body of faith, is to be about the business of liberation." The twenty-first century has brought new reckonings with racial violence. The emergence of Black Lives Matter in 2013 following Trayvon Martin's killing sparked both intergenerational tensions and new opportunities for church engagement. When nine worshippers were murdered at Mother Emanuel AME Church in Charleston in 2015, the tragedy connected contemporary racial violence to the church's long history as both a target of white supremacy and a center of resistance. Most recently, the COVID-19 pandemic has devastated Black communities and their churches, while racial justice protests following George Floyd's murder in 2020 have again called churches to respond to systemic racism. Through all these changes, the Black Church has demonstrated remarkable adaptability. As Jakes observes, "There will always be moments that push us back to our faith, because life has a way of reminding you that you need something bigger than you to get through a season."

Chapter 6: Sacred Music: From Spirituals to Gospel and Beyond

The musical journey of the Black Church represents one of America's most profound cultural contributions, evolving from the coded messages of slave spirituals to the global influence of contemporary gospel. This musical tradition began when enslaved Africans combined their homeland's rhythms, call-and-response patterns, and communal expression with Christian hymns, creating something entirely new. As historian W.E.B. Du Bois described them, spirituals were "the most original and beautiful expression of human life and longing yet born on American soil." During slavery, these "Sorrow Songs" served multiple purposes – they provided comfort, preserved cultural identity, encoded messages of resistance, and expressed faith in ultimate deliverance. Songs like "Steal Away to Jesus" could signal secret meetings or escapes while maintaining plausible deniability before slaveholders. The musical structure of spirituals reflected African traditions – improvisation, blue notes (pitches falling between Western musical scales), and rhythmic complexity that white observers often failed to understand or appreciate. After emancipation, these songs gained wider recognition when the Fisk Jubilee Singers began performing formalized arrangements for northern white audiences in the 1870s. The Great Migration transformed Black sacred music as southern migrants brought their musical traditions to northern cities. In urban churches with more formal worship styles, this musical culture sometimes created tension. As Fredara Hadley explains, "The mainline churches across America were trying to get away from that sort of worship experience. They wanted a worship experience that was more urbane." This cultural clash led to the creation of storefront churches where more expressive worship styles flourished, especially in Holiness and Pentecostal traditions that embraced instruments previously considered "worldly," like drums and guitars. The 1920s and 1930s witnessed the birth of gospel music, led by pioneers like Charles Albert Tindley and Thomas A. Dorsey. Formerly a blues musician known as "Georgia Tom," Dorsey revolutionized church music by incorporating blues rhythms and jazz harmonies into religious compositions. His song "Take My Hand, Precious Lord," written after the tragic deaths of his wife and newborn child, became a gospel standard. Initially controversial, gospel music gained acceptance through performers like Mahalia Jackson, whose soaring contralto gave spiritual life to Dorsey's compositions. By the 1940s, gospel had become the predominant sound of the Black Church. The boundaries between sacred and secular music remained permeable, with influences flowing in both directions. Sister Rosetta Tharpe brought gospel music to nightclubs in the 1930s and 1940s, pioneering rock guitar techniques in the process. Meanwhile, secular artists from Sam Cooke to Aretha Franklin carried the feeling and techniques of gospel into popular music. As C.L. Franklin said of his daughter Aretha's secular career, "If you want to know the truth, Aretha has never left the church! All you have to do is have the ability to hear and the ability to feel, and you will know that Aretha is still a gospel singer." The civil rights movement demonstrated the power of sacred music as political inspiration. Freedom songs adapted from spirituals and gospel provided courage and unity during protests, while benefit concerts by gospel artists helped fund the movement. Music director Bernice Johnson Reagon described the Freedom Singers as "a singing newspaper," carrying the movement's message across the country. Mahalia Jackson not only raised funds for the cause but provided spiritual sustenance to Dr. King in his darkest moments. Contemporary gospel continues to evolve, incorporating influences from R&B, hip-hop, and rock. Kirk Franklin's 1997 hit "Stomp," featuring a rapper and sampling from Funkadelic, topped R&B charts and sparked debates about proper boundaries for sacred music. As Franklin explains, "Gospel music is not a sound; gospel music is a message." Today, hip-hop artists like Chance the Rapper and Kanye West incorporate gospel elements into mainstream music, while some churches integrate hip-hop into worship services. Throughout this evolution, the essence of Black sacred music has remained consistent – the ability to express both suffering and transcendence, to comfort the afflicted and challenge the comfortable, to preserve tradition while embracing innovation. As Shirley Caesar explains, "It's something about those songs that brings joy. It helps you to get over a lot of humps that you're going through in your life... Somebody in the choir might sing the old hymn 'Amazing Grace' or whatever, but once they sing it and it brings joy in your life, you might get up and go back home and the burden is much lighter."

Summary

The story of the Black Church reveals a remarkable journey of spiritual resilience and social transformation spanning five centuries of American history. From its origins in the fusion of African spiritual practices with Christianity during slavery, through its central role in abolition and civil rights, to its ongoing evolution in the face of contemporary challenges, the Black Church has consistently served as both sanctuary and springboard – offering protection from oppression while nurturing leadership for social change. This dual function as both spiritual home and engine of liberation represents the core tension that has defined the Black religious experience in America. The enduring power of the Black Church stems from its ability to adapt while maintaining core commitments to dignity and freedom. When white Christianity was used to justify slavery, Black Christians found in the same scripture a mandate for liberation. When political rights were denied, churches provided alternative structures for leadership development and community organization. When cultural expression was suppressed, sacred music and preaching created spaces for authentic voice and creativity. Even today, as traditional religious participation declines, Black churches continue reinventing themselves to address contemporary issues from economic inequality to racial violence. The wisdom this history offers for our present moment is profound: meaningful change requires both spiritual sustenance and practical action; cultural preservation matters as much as political engagement; and institutions built by and for marginalized communities remain essential to their survival and flourishing. As the Reverend William Barber reminds us, echoing an old African proverb cited by John Lewis: "When you pray, move your feet."

About Author

Loading...

Henry Louis Gates Jr.

Read more

Related Books by Henry Louis Gates Jr.

Loading...

What You Do Is Who You Are

Ben Horowitz

How to Create Your Business Culture

★★★★☆4.0