The Business of Belonging

The Business of Belonging Plot Summary

Introduction

In today's digital landscape, businesses face an unprecedented challenge: building genuine connections with customers in an increasingly competitive market. Traditional marketing approaches often fall short, leaving companies searching for more effective ways to stand out and foster loyalty. This is where community building emerges as a transformative strategy—a structured approach to creating spaces where customers, users, and advocates can connect not just with a brand, but with each other. The concept of community building represents a fundamental shift in business thinking. Rather than focusing solely on one-to-one customer relationships or broadcasting messages to passive audiences, community-driven businesses activate the collective energy of their most passionate stakeholders. When implemented strategically, community becomes more than a nice-to-have; it transforms into a competitive advantage that drives measurable business outcomes while simultaneously creating authentic belonging for members. The frameworks and methodologies presented here provide a systematic approach to designing, launching, and scaling communities that serve both business goals and human needs—revealing how the most successful organizations are reimagining customer relationships through the lens of community.

Chapter 1: The Competitive Advantage of Community

Community has emerged as a powerful business strategy that transcends traditional marketing and customer service approaches. At its core, a community-driven business creates spaces and experiences where customers, users, or other stakeholders can meaningfully connect with each other, not just with the brand. This represents a fundamental shift from one-directional or transactional relationships to multi-dimensional engagement that unlocks exponential value. The evolution toward community-driven business has been gradual but profound. In earlier eras, companies maintained control over customer relationships, with limited channels for customers to communicate with each other. The internet fundamentally changed this dynamic, giving customers unprecedented ability to share experiences and opinions. Forward-thinking companies like Apple recognized this shift early, with Apple's User Group Connection in the 1980s representing one of the first formal customer community programs. As social networks proliferated, customer service leaders like Zappos invested heavily in community-focused approaches rather than traditional advertising, letting satisfied customers become their most effective marketers. What makes community such a potent competitive advantage is its unrivaled scalability. While traditional business functions face inherent scaling limitations, communities can expand exponentially through member contributions. Consider Duolingo, which leverages community to develop nearly 100 language courses with just 300 employees, compared to competitor Rosetta Stone's 23 courses with 1,300 staff. The secret lies in how communities extend your team's capacity by activating members who voluntarily contribute their energy, knowledge, and skills. Perhaps most importantly, community creates something competitors simply cannot copy. Anyone can replicate your product features or pricing structure, but they cannot replicate the relationships, trust, and emotional investment members have in your community. When customers join the Salesforce Trailblazer community, for instance, they gain access to a valuable network that has helped them grow in their careers and form meaningful connections. This creates a powerful switching cost beyond the product itself—leaving would mean abandoning those relationships and social capital they've built. This approach also aligns business success with human well-being. Companies practicing community-building aren't just driving metrics; they're creating spaces where people feel valued, connected, and empowered. The most successful organizations understand that their values and mission are why they exist, with profit serving as the means to achieve impact. By viewing business through a community lens, companies create sustainable growth engines that benefit all stakeholders.

Chapter 2: SPACES: The Six Business Outcomes of Community

The SPACES model provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the distinct business outcomes that community can drive for an organization. This powerful model identifies six specific ways community initiatives can impact the bottom line, helping companies move beyond vague notions of "engagement" to concrete, measurable objectives. Each letter in SPACES represents a different business outcome: Support, Product, Acquisition, Contribution, Engagement, and Success. Support communities empower customers to answer questions and solve problems for each other, reducing support costs while improving satisfaction. These communities typically take the form of forums where expert users share knowledge with newer members. Product communities gather feedback, ideas, and insights that accelerate innovation and product development. Acquisition communities drive growth by connecting potential customers with existing ones, often through ambassador programs or public-facing spaces built around shared interests. Contribution communities motivate members to add content, products, or services to platforms and marketplaces. Engagement communities strengthen customer relationships and loyalty through meaningful experiences. Finally, Success communities help customers become more skilled and successful with products, driving retention and expansion. When implementing the SPACES model, it's crucial to focus initially on just one or two primary objectives rather than attempting to address all six simultaneously. Companies that try to pursue all objectives at once typically spread their resources too thin, making meaningful impact difficult to achieve. Each objective requires working with different teams, measuring different metrics, and often organizing different groups of members. A thoughtful approach involves prioritizing areas most important to your current business phase—whether that's growth, retention, or customer success. Choosing the right measurement framework is essential for tracking community impact across these objectives. All strategic frameworks aim to translate nebulous goals into specific actions and measures. Whether using OKRs, 4DX, V2MOM, or another system, the core elements remain consistent: defining clear goals, establishing measures that indicate success, and identifying specific actions to achieve those goals. This structured approach ensures community initiatives align with broader business strategy. The community investment journey typically follows a lifecycle with distinct stages: seed, growth, maturity, and pollination. During the seed stage, the community is fragile and requires intensive nurturing with minimal focus on business metrics. In the growth stage, organic engagement begins to emerge, and measurement systems become more structured. Mature communities have established norms, roles, and operational processes, with clearly defined metrics tied to business outcomes. Finally, in the pollination stage, the community becomes so large that sub-communities naturally form, creating new growth opportunities.

Chapter 3: Creating a Powerful Social Identity

At the heart of every thriving community lies a clear and compelling social identity that draws members together and gives them a sense of belonging. This identity serves as the foundation upon which all community engagement is built, determining who feels welcome, how members interact, and what motivates their participation. Understanding how social identity forms and evolves is essential for community builders seeking to create spaces where people feel genuinely connected. The Social Identity Cycle illustrates how members move from casual participation to deep investment in a community. This three-stage cycle begins with identification, where a person recognizes alignment with the community's values or purpose. Next comes participation, where they take action within the community. Finally, validation occurs when that participation is acknowledged and rewarded, strengthening their connection to the group's identity. As members cycle through these stages repeatedly, they progress from basic social categorization ("I fit in this category") to social identification ("I am a member of this group") to social comparison ("Our group is special compared to others"). When designing a community identity, specificity is crucial. The more specific the social identity, the more likely people who share it will have common needs and challenges. Rather than creating a broad community for "people who ride bikes," a community for "competitive cyclists who are parents in Austin, Texas" creates a much stronger foundation for connection. This specificity helps members recognize themselves in the community's purpose and feel that it was created specifically for them. It's also important to identify who doesn't belong—not to be exclusionary, but to create safety and clarity for those who do belong. Investing in diversity, equity, and inclusion from day one is vital for creating a truly powerful community identity. Without intentional effort, communities tend to replicate existing societal biases and exclusions. As Naj Austin of Ethel's Club explains, "It's extremely difficult to change the culture of a community once it's already established." By thoughtfully considering whose voices are present and whose are missing, community builders can create spaces that feel genuinely welcoming to all who should belong, rather than perpetuating existing power structures. The personality and aesthetic of your community also significantly impact how members relate to its identity. Just as Product Hunt became known for Ryan Hoover's humble, supportive, and unapologetically positive approach to new products, your community's tone and feel should reflect the values and culture you wish to foster. When members feel that the community makes them "cool"—not in a superficial sense, but by validating authentic parts of themselves they cannot express elsewhere—they develop deeper connections and stronger identification with the group.

Chapter 4: Designing the Member Participation Journey

The participation journey represents the path members take as they become increasingly invested in your community. Understanding this journey allows you to create intentional experiences that move members from initial curiosity to deep commitment. The commitment curve illustrates how a member's willingness to contribute grows over time as their sense of belonging strengthens, providing a roadmap for designing participation opportunities that meet members where they are. Every mature community naturally develops different levels of participation, from passive members who mostly observe, to active contributors, to power users, and finally to leaders who take ownership of community spaces and experiences. These participation layers form naturally as members move through the Social Identity Cycle and become more identified with the community. Rather than trying to convert all passive members into active ones, successful communities recognize that each level plays a vital role in the ecosystem. Without passive members providing an audience, active members would have no one to create for; without power users and leaders facilitating engagement, the community would lack the energy needed to thrive. Attracting new members requires different approaches depending on your community's stage of development. In the early seed stage, organic growth is rare, and personal outreach is essential. As David Spinks discovered when launching CMX Summit, or as NextDoor's founders experienced when literally knocking on neighbors' doors, building a community foundation takes deliberate, hands-on effort. Once a community reaches the growth stage, word-of-mouth begins driving engagement, but this doesn't happen magically—it comes after establishing a strong foundation of quality interactions and valuable experiences. Creating intentional barriers to entry might seem counterintuitive, but can significantly strengthen member commitment. This psychological principle, known as effort justification, explains why people value experiences they had to work for. Communities with meaningful requirements for membership—whether it's Yelp Elite's review thresholds or Airbnb's Superhost criteria—often develop stronger member loyalty. These barriers create a sense of achievement and signal to members that they're joining something valuable and exclusive. Once members join, a thoughtful onboarding experience helps them successfully navigate their first cycle of identification, participation, and validation. Effective onboarding considers what you want new members to know, feel, and do when they first arrive. Rather than overwhelming them with options or making big asks immediately, the best onboarding experiences provide clear first steps that deliver immediate value. For CMX, this means asking new members to introduce themselves and share a challenge they're facing, immediately creating opportunities for connection and problem-solving. Moving members up the commitment curve requires understanding the obstacles preventing participation and designing experiences that address these barriers. The "Love Our Lurkers" campaign by DigitalMarketer's community team exemplifies this approach. By dedicating a week to showing passive members how to contribute, explaining the value of participation, and highlighting successful community members, they activated 44 percent of previously silent members. Similar campaigns can target any level of participation, helping members overcome hesitation and take their next step in the community journey.

Chapter 5: Validation and Rewards for Member Engagement

Validation represents the critical third stage in the Social Identity Cycle, determining whether members will continue participating in your community. When members feel rewarded for their contributions, it reinforces their identification with the community and motivates them to engage again in the future. Understanding the psychology of rewards and developing effective validation systems are therefore essential aspects of community building. The habit loop—consisting of cue, routine, and reward—explains how community participation becomes automatic over time. Initially, external triggers like notifications or emails prompt members to visit your community. After repeated positive experiences, these external cues gradually transform into internal triggers, where members automatically think of your community whenever they have a relevant need or question. This is why validation is so crucial—without experiencing rewards for their participation, members won't develop these habitual pathways that bring them back consistently. When designing reward systems, it's important to understand the distinction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation comes from genuine enjoyment and internal satisfaction, while extrinsic motivation stems from external rewards or punishments. While communities thrive on intrinsic motivation, extrinsic rewards can effectively reinforce participation when used thoughtfully. However, the overjustification effect warns that introducing extrinsic rewards for intrinsically motivated behaviors can actually reduce motivation by shifting members' focus from internal satisfaction to external validation. The SNAP framework—Status, Networking, Access, and Perks—provides a comprehensive approach to designing extrinsic rewards that complement rather than replace intrinsic motivation. Status rewards include badges, points, or recognition that signal a member's standing in the community. Networking rewards connect members with valuable contacts through curated experiences. Access rewards provide exclusive information or influence, such as beta testing opportunities or executive roundtables. Perks include tangible benefits like discounts, free training, or branded merchandise that members value. Gamification—the use of game-like elements such as points, levels, and leaderboards—represents a specific type of status-based reward system. However, many community builders misunderstand its purpose. Gamification doesn't create engagement where none exists; rather, it accelerates existing engagement by providing visible proof of status. As Amy Jo Kim explains, "Well-crafted games are an artful blend of intrinsic pleasure and extrinsic scaffolding." Effective gamification aligns with members' intrinsic motivations and amplifies their natural desire to contribute. When measuring community health through the validation lens, it's essential to look beyond simple activity metrics to understand the quality of members' experiences. Through surveys and interviews, you can determine whether members feel their participation is valued and whether they're receiving the benefits they expected. Metrics like Net Promoter Score provide standardized measures of member satisfaction, while cohort analysis helps track how engagement evolves over time for different member groups. By connecting these engagement metrics to specific business outcomes—such as support questions answered or referrals generated—you can demonstrate how community validation directly impacts your bottom line.

Chapter 6: Building Effective Community Spaces and Experiences

Creating environments where members can meaningfully connect is a fundamental aspect of community building. Whether digital or physical, synchronous or asynchronous, these spaces form the stages upon which community experiences unfold. Understanding how to design these environments with intention ensures that members feel welcome, know how to participate, and experience the belonging that keeps them coming back. Community experiences generally fall into two categories: synchronous experiences where members interact in real-time (like events or video calls), and asynchronous experiences where participation happens over time (like forums or messaging groups). While asynchronous spaces provide accessibility and breadth, allowing members to engage at their convenience, synchronous experiences create depth through more intimate, focused interactions. Most successful communities incorporate both types of experiences, recognizing that each serves different needs and creates different kinds of connections. Consistency and repetition play crucial roles in building community habits and traditions. Like music with its steady beats, choruses, and crescendos, great communities establish regular rhythms that members can anticipate and participate in. Daily discussion prompts, weekly themed threads, monthly meetups, quarterly initiatives, and annual flagship events create a cadence that helps members develop participation habits. These recurring experiences become rituals that deepen members' sense of identity and belonging, while still leaving room for creativity and surprise within established formats. The 7Ps framework—People, Purpose, Place, Participation, Policy, Promotion, and Performance—provides a comprehensive approach to designing community spaces and experiences. Each element requires thoughtful consideration: Who exactly are you gathering and why? What size space best serves your purpose? How will members participate, and what rules will guide their interactions? How will you invite members and measure success? By addressing each of these questions intentionally, you create experiences that feel cohesive, meaningful, and aligned with both member needs and business objectives. Selecting the right software platforms for your community involves weighing numerous factors, from user experience and data ownership to engagement features and budget constraints. While free social platforms offer built-in network effects and familiarity, they limit customization and data access. Dedicated community platforms provide more control but require members to adopt new tools. The key is choosing technology that serves your specific community purpose—whether that's facilitating support questions, driving collaborative innovation, or fostering deep relationships—while providing the data needed to measure business impact. Throughout all community spaces, creating peak moments—memorable experiences that stand out from routine interactions—significantly enhances member attachment. As Dan and Chip Heath explain in The Power of Moments, people primarily remember the high points and low points of experiences, not the average. By intentionally designing moments of elevation (high energy), pride (accomplishment), insight (learning), or connection (relationship building), community builders create the emotional anchors that make their spaces meaningful. These peak experiences, whether a standing ovation at an event or a vulnerable small-group discussion, form the memories that keep members emotionally invested in the community.

Chapter 7: Activating and Sustaining Community Engagement

Creating an engaged community requires more than just building spaces and hoping members will participate. It demands active facilitation, persistent experimentation, and a genuine commitment to fostering interaction. The art of community activation encompasses everything from crafting compelling content to modeling the behaviors you wish to see, ultimately creating an environment where meaningful engagement naturally flourishes. Engagement is fundamentally an experimental process that requires continuous iteration. Even experienced community builders can't predict with certainty what will resonate with members. Some carefully crafted discussion prompts might receive no response, while spontaneous conversations generate tremendous energy. This uncertainty makes persistent experimentation essential—trying different approaches, learning from what works and what doesn't, and continually evolving your engagement strategy. Rather than becoming discouraged by initiatives that don't immediately succeed, view each attempt as valuable data that informs your next experiment. Personal invitations represent one of the most powerful tools for activating participation, especially in a community's early stages. While mass communications can be easily overlooked, direct personal outreach creates social accountability and makes members feel seen. This approach applies to everything from welcoming new members to encouraging participation in discussions. When someone posts a question that receives no response, privately asking specific members to share their expertise not only ensures the poster receives help but also makes the invited members feel valued for their knowledge. Though labor-intensive, these personalized interactions build the foundation for organic engagement. Creating spaces where members feel comfortable being open and vulnerable requires careful attention to structure and facilitation. Small, private groups with clear guidelines create the psychological safety needed for authentic sharing. The Inside Circle Foundation demonstrates this principle powerfully through their work in maximum security prisons, where inmates who normally suppress emotions can openly process trauma in carefully facilitated circles. By establishing rituals like "taking off armor" before discussions and maintaining strict confidentiality, they create containers where genuine vulnerability becomes possible. Similar principles apply in business communities, where thoughtfully structured experiences can help members connect on deeper levels. The energy and tone you bring as a community leader profoundly influences your community's culture. Your actions and communication style set the standard for what's acceptable and expected within your spaces. If you maintain a positive, supportive presence, members will likely mirror that energy; if you respond negatively or dismissively, that behavior will spread as well. This principle applies even when addressing challenging situations. When faced with negative feedback or trolling behavior, responding with empathy and positivity rather than defensiveness often diffuses tension and creates opportunities for constructive dialogue. Transparency builds trust, particularly when navigating difficult decisions or acknowledging mistakes. Rather than hiding challenges from your community, involving members in problem-solving strengthens their investment. When considering whether CMX should be acquired by Bevy, David Spinks openly shared his concerns about maintaining the community's objectivity, inviting members to discuss this important transition. This vulnerability led to thoughtful conversations that ultimately strengthened trust rather than diminishing it. By defaulting to transparency in your communications and decision-making processes, you demonstrate respect for your members and build a more resilient community relationship.

Summary

The Business of Belonging ultimately reveals a profound truth: community is not just a marketing tactic or engagement strategy—it is a fundamental shift in how businesses create value and build relationships. When implemented effectively, community transforms every aspect of an organization, extending team capacity, accelerating innovation, driving acquisition, enhancing customer success, and creating emotional connections that competitors simply cannot replicate. The frameworks presented here—from the SPACES model to the Social Identity Cycle—provide practical guidance for turning community from an abstract concept into a strategic business asset. Yet perhaps the most important insight is that successful community building requires balance: between business objectives and human needs, between structure and authenticity, between guiding and empowering. Organizations that master this balance create spaces where people genuinely belong while simultaneously driving measurable business outcomes that ensure sustainable growth. As digital transformation continues to reshape how we connect and engage, the principles of community building will only become more central to business success, offering a path forward that aligns profit with purpose and transforms transactions into relationships.

About Author

Loading...

David Spinks

Read more