The Hunger Habit

The Hunger Habit Plot Summary

Introduction

Have you ever found yourself mindlessly eating an entire bag of chips while watching TV, only to feel guilty and ashamed afterward? Or perhaps you've tried countless diets, each promising miraculous results, only to find yourself back where you started – or worse, trapped in an exhausting cycle of restriction and binge eating. You're not alone, and more importantly, it's not your fault. Our relationship with food is complex, deeply personal, and often driven by forces we don't fully understand. What if the key to breaking free from unhelpful eating patterns isn't more willpower or stricter rules, but rather understanding how your brain works? When we learn to work with our minds instead of against them, we can transform our relationship with food from one of struggle to one of peace and freedom. Through awareness, curiosity, and self-compassion, we can rewire our brains and develop new, healthier habits that serve our wellbeing rather than sabotage it.

Chapter 1: Mapping Your Food Habits: Recognize the Loops

At the heart of our eating behaviors are habit loops that our brains have established over time. These loops consist of three elements: a trigger (what prompts us to eat), a behavior (the actual eating), and a reward (how we feel afterward). Our brains are masterful at creating these loops, as they're designed to help us survive by repeating behaviors that provide rewards. Jack, a patient in his sixties, struggled with what he called "automatic eating." He would consume handfuls of Corn Nuts without thinking, saying, "I just shovel it in. I'm not processing. I'm just doing it." His brain had established a simple loop: see Corn Nuts, eat Corn Nuts, satisfy the urge. This happened with other foods too - pasta, ice cream, bagels. "If it was pasta and it was there, I'd just eat it," he explained. Jack would eat whether he was hungry or not, happy or sad, stressed or content. When Jack began mapping his eating habits, he noticed how disconnected he was from his body's signals. "I have a level of awareness but need to go more into my body," he reflected. "I can make the determination that I'm not really hungry, but I still have the urge to go and have some more food." During a car trip with his wife, he practiced checking in with himself before eating almonds she had packed. After about two hours, he noticed genuine hunger and ate just a few, rather than automatically consuming the entire container. To begin mapping your own habit loops, pay attention to the why, what, and how of your eating. The why is the urge or craving that drives you to eat - are you truly hungry, or eating from boredom, stress, or habit? The what is the type of food you choose. The how is the manner in which you eat - quickly and mindlessly, or with awareness and appreciation? Start by keeping a simple journal of your eating episodes. For each one, note what triggered you to eat, what you ate, and how you felt afterward. Don't judge yourself during this process - you're simply gathering information. This awareness alone can be transformative, as Jack discovered when he began reconnecting his brain with his body. Remember that mapping your habit loops isn't about criticizing yourself for "bad" habits. It's about shining a light on patterns that have been operating below your awareness, so you can make conscious choices rather than being driven by automatic behaviors.

Chapter 2: Understanding the Brain-Body Connection

Living disconnected from our bodies has become a modern epidemic. As author James Joyce once wrote about a character, he "lived at a little distance from his body" - a perfect description of how many of us experience life today. This disconnection makes it incredibly difficult to recognize true hunger and fullness signals, leading to problematic eating patterns. Anne's story exemplifies this disconnection perfectly. For decades, she lived in what she called "food jail" - a prison of rigid rules and restrictions she had created for herself. Anne's mother was a perfectionist reporter and gourmet cook who expected excellence in everything. Seeking control, Anne developed an extensive list of food rules in her twenties when she began gaining weight. "I had a list of seventy-four foods at one point," she revealed. "No oil, no salt, no sugar, no fast food, and you have to make everything at home." She would micromanage every morsel, carefully counting out seven almonds at exactly 11:00 a.m., weighing her kale salad, and scrupulously avoiding sugar until around 4:00 p.m., when her control would inevitably collapse. Then she would eat quickly and distractedly, often consuming foods she'd hidden away - "it had to be white-flour pasta to do the trick" - and afterward feel ashamed and out of control. Despite having stacks of nutrition and diet books in her basement, nothing helped her break this cycle. Anne had spent decades trying to control her body rather than listen to it. She focused on external rules from "experts" instead of tuning into her body's wisdom. The longer this disconnection continued, the harder it became for her to recognize and interpret her body's signals - hunger, fullness, satisfaction, or emotional needs. To begin rebuilding your brain-body connection, practice the body scan exercise regularly. Find a comfortable position, close your eyes, and systematically bring awareness to each part of your body, starting from your toes and moving upward. Notice sensations without judgment - tingling, warmth, tension, or even areas where you feel nothing at all. This practice helps rewire your brain to better detect subtle signals from your body. Another powerful practice is simply checking in with your body throughout the day. Before you eat, pause and ask, "Am I truly hungry?" Notice where and how you feel hunger in your body. While eating, periodically check how your body feels - are you approaching fullness? Afterward, observe how different foods affect your energy and mood. The more you strengthen this connection, the more you'll trust your body's wisdom about when, what, and how much to eat. This trust is the foundation for transforming your relationship with food from one of struggle to one of harmony.

Chapter 3: Cultivating Awareness: The Key to Change

Awareness is the most powerful tool for changing any habit, including problematic eating patterns. While you've likely heard "pay attention!" countless times in your life, you may not realize just how transformative mindful awareness can be when applied to your relationship with food. Consider the story of my own struggle with gummy worms. For years, I had an almost helpless addiction to these colorful, chewy candies. As soon as I thought of them, I had to have them. The urge would typically start after dinner, and if I tried to ignore it, my desire would only intensify throughout the evening. Eventually, I would cave and eat an entire bag, rationalizing, "Well, at least it's over. You feel crappy now, but at least they're out of the house." Then one day, I decided to try something different. Instead of mindlessly devouring the gummy worms, I paid careful attention as I ate them. I noticed that they weren't actually that great. The sweetness was sickly rather than satisfying, nothing like the complex flavor of good dark chocolate or honey. The texture was rubbery and unpleasant. When I truly became aware of these elements, they didn't add up to whatever had gotten me hooked in the first place. With each mindful eating experience, I became less enchanted with gummy worms. My brain was getting what scientists call a "negative prediction error" - the experience was worse than expected, which updated my brain's reward value for this food. Eventually, I lost all interest in them. The key wasn't willpower or restriction; it was simply paying attention. To cultivate this transformative awareness in your own life, begin with regular mindful eating practices. Choose a meal or snack to eat with full attention. Notice the appearance, aroma, and texture of the food before taking the first bite. As you eat, focus on the flavors, the changing texture, and your body's responses. You don't need to eat slowly (though that can help) - you just need to be present. Set reminders throughout your day to check in with yourself. Phone alarms, sticky notes, or regular activities (like walking through doorways) can serve as cues to pause and ask, "What am I aware of right now?" Notice if you're operating on autopilot or if you're present in your experience. These small moments of awareness, practiced consistently, gradually build your capacity for mindfulness. Remember that awareness isn't about judgment or control - it's about clear seeing. When you observe your eating habits with curiosity rather than criticism, you give your brain the information it needs to naturally adjust its reward values. This process doesn't require willpower; it harnesses your brain's natural learning mechanisms to change habits from the inside out.

Chapter 4: Using RAIN to Tame Your Cravings

Cravings can feel overwhelming, like a monster that grows bigger and louder the more we try to ignore or fight it. Jacqui described her cravings for Chinese takeout as something that would "just get bigger and bigger and bigger. It just starts to take over. It just eats away at you." After days of battling her craving monster, she would eventually give in, ordering "disgustingly vast amounts of carbs" - fried potatoes, rice, and rice noodles with curry dishes. But there's a powerful technique that can help you ride out cravings instead of being controlled by them. It's called RAIN, and it works by leveraging awareness rather than willpower to change your relationship with cravings. RAIN stands for Recognize, Accept, Investigate, and Note. First, you Recognize that a craving is arising and Relax into it instead of tensing up against it. Next, you Accept or Allow the wave of craving as it is, without trying to push it away or distract yourself. Then, you Investigate it with curiosity, asking "What is going on in my body right now?" Finally, you Note the experience with simple words or phrases like "tightness," "burning," "restlessness," or "thinking" as the feelings come and go. Jacqui tried RAIN one day after another difficult visit with her mother. She had pulled into a grocery store parking lot, where she would typically listen to loud music and "binge and binge." Skeptical but willing to try, she thought, "Well, I can always just binge afterward if I want to." She sat in her car and began noticing how the craving for Chinese food felt, allowing it to be present rather than fighting it. She investigated the sensations in her body and noted them - the anticipatory excitement, the eagerness to dive into takeout containers. To her surprise, the urgency of her craving began to fade. "I realized that I don't have to do that," she said. "I went into the grocery store and each time I picked something up, I asked myself, 'How am I going to feel if I eat this?'" She left with avocados and spinach, "laughing like a lunatic" at her newfound freedom. "It was like my first taste of freedom as an adult that I don't have to be scared of the craving... I see you [craving monster]. Yeah, you can't hurt me." To practice RAIN yourself, begin by setting aside a quiet moment when you feel a craving. Follow the steps of Recognize, Accept, Investigate, and Note. Don't rush the process - stay with each step, especially the investigation of bodily sensations. You might be surprised to discover that cravings typically last only a minute or two when you don't feed or fight them. Keep in mind that RAIN isn't about making cravings disappear forever. It's about changing your relationship with them so they no longer control your behavior. With practice, you'll develop the confidence that you can ride out any craving wave, no matter how intense it feels in the moment.

Chapter 5: Finding Your Pleasure Plateau

Have you ever noticed how the first few bites of a delicious dessert are heavenly, but by the end, you're hardly tasting it anymore? This phenomenon reflects what I call the "pleasure plateau" - the point at which our enjoyment of food naturally levels off before declining if we continue eating. Dr. Dana Small, a food researcher at Yale University, conducted a fascinating experiment on this subject. She had people eat their favorite chocolate, one piece at a time, while rating how much they wanted another piece after each bite. Initially, participants gave high ratings, eagerly wanting more. But as they continued eating, their desire for more chocolate gradually declined. Some participants hit their satiation point after just sixteen squares, while others took up to seventy-four, but eventually everyone reached a point where they didn't want any more. This experiment reveals a fundamental truth about how our brains process pleasure from food. When we're hungry and start eating something tasty, our pleasure increases as we climb the "hill" of satisfaction. Eventually, we reach a plateau where the food is still pleasant but not as rewarding as the first few bites. If we continue eating past this point, pleasure decreases until we potentially "crash" off the cliff into discomfort. Tracy described her experience with ice cream: "It was a matter of really learning over time how many bites do I really enjoy? At some point my mouth will get so cold, I stop tasting it after a while. At the end, it's not enjoyable anymore." Another person reported, "I really examined each mouthful and was able to leave food on my plate and walk away feeling satisfied!!!" To find your own pleasure plateau with different foods, start paying attention to how each bite tastes compared to the previous one. Ask yourself, "Is this more pleasurable, the same, or less pleasurable than the last bite?" When you notice the pleasure beginning to decrease, that's your signal that you've reached your plateau and future bites will be less rewarding. Begin practicing with snacks or desserts when you're not ravenously hungry, as extreme hunger can make it harder to detect subtle changes in pleasure. As you get more practiced, apply this awareness to full meals, noting when you've had enough to feel satisfied without being uncomfortably full. Remember that it takes about fifteen to twenty minutes for satiety signals to register fully, so eating slowly can help you detect your plateau more accurately. The beauty of finding your pleasure plateau is that it transforms eating from a mindless activity into a conscious choice. You're not depriving yourself or using willpower to stop eating - you're simply recognizing when the natural reward value of continuing to eat diminishes, making it easy to stop because your brain no longer desires more.

Chapter 6: Building Your Disenchantment Database

Over time, paying attention to how foods actually make you feel creates what I call a "disenchantment database" - a collection of memories that help your brain accurately assess the true reward value of different foods and eating behaviors. This database is crucial for breaking free from unhelpful eating habits. Each time you mindfully eat something and notice it's not as rewarding as you expected - perhaps it leaves you feeling sluggish, bloated, or unsatisfied - you're making a deposit in your disenchantment database. When you have enough of these experiences stored up, your cravings naturally begin to lose their power. Your brain starts to question, "Why would I do that?" when presented with foods or behaviors that have consistently disappointed. In one of our studies, we found it took only ten to fifteen mindful eating experiences for the reward value of problematic foods to drop significantly. That's good news - if you've had a habit of overeating for years or decades, you don't need that long to shift your brain's assessment of its value. However, there's a challenge: delay discounting. Our brains strongly prefer immediate rewards over future benefits, even when the future benefits are much greater. This is why it's so easy to choose candy now over better health later. The summer swimsuit season might be six months away, but the gummy worms are right in front of you! Tracy described how it took many Thanksgiving dinners before she became disenchanted with overeating at holiday meals: "This past Thanksgiving was the first Thanksgiving that I didn't feel ill because I had eaten too much. That was cool to see, because as I was taking my plate and going around the table as we were serving ourselves, I just knew how the food was going to impact me." She continued: "There are some times when you just notice something once and you're like, 'I don't want to do that again,' and then other times when it takes many trials. So this has been many trials, over time, because of how many Thanksgivings I needed to go through to notice that I'm crashing at the end." To build your own disenchantment database, choose a specific food or eating behavior that you struggle with. Each time you engage in it, pay careful attention to how it makes you feel physically, emotionally, and mentally - not just during eating but for hours afterward. Record these observations in a journal, noting any discrepancies between what you expected and what you actually experienced. You can also use retrospectives - looking back on past eating experiences - to add to your database without having to repeat the behavior. Vividly recall how your body felt after overeating or consuming a particular food that didn't serve you well. The more detailed and embodied this recollection, the more it reinforces the negative prediction error that helps your brain update its reward values. Remember that disenchantment isn't about forcing yourself to dislike foods you genuinely enjoy. It's about seeing clearly the true effects of foods and eating behaviors so your brain can make more accurate assessments of their reward value.

Chapter 7: Practicing Self-Kindness Instead of Judgment

Perhaps the most transformative aspect of changing your relationship with food is learning to replace harsh self-judgment with genuine self-kindness. Many of us have developed a habit of berating ourselves for our eating choices, believing that shame and criticism will somehow motivate better behavior. In reality, these patterns only keep us trapped in unhealthy cycles. Tasha, a woman in her thirties who struggled with Binge Eating Disorder, exemplifies this challenge. By the time she came to my clinic, she was bingeing on entire large pizzas twenty out of thirty days each month. She felt guilty when she binged, ashamed she couldn't stop, and somewhat hopeless about ever breaking free from this cycle. The harsh committee members in her head were constantly judging her, leading to a vicious cycle where shame triggered more bingeing to numb the pain. When we mapped out Tasha's habit loops, we discovered she had only one method for dealing with negative emotions: bingeing. And worse, her self-judgment about bingeing created more negative emotions, leading to what she called "binge on top of binge" behavior. To break this cycle, she needed to learn self-kindness as a new way of responding to difficulty. Alex, another participant in our program, provided a simple yet powerful example of practicing kindness. When I asked him to recall a time he had experienced kindness, he surprised me by saying, "I cooked my roommate an egg the other morning for breakfast." When asked how it felt to extend that kindness, he confirmed it felt very good. I then asked him to compare how self-judgment felt versus kindness, and the contrast was clear: judgment felt terrible, while kindness felt wonderful. Since Alex found it easier to practice kindness toward others than himself (as many of us do), I gave him this mission: when you notice self-judgment, remember what it felt like to cook an egg for your roommate, then mentally "cook yourself an egg" - extend that same care to yourself. Research led by psychologist Paul Gilbert has shown that kindness - especially toward ourselves - can feel scary for those with loud self-critical voices. We might fear that being kind to ourselves will lead to self-indulgence or loss of control. Yet the opposite is true: self-kindness empowers us to address the root causes of our distress rather than avoiding them through unhelpful behaviors like emotional eating. To practice self-kindness, start by noticing moments of self-judgment throughout your day. When you catch yourself being harsh or critical about your eating or your body, pause and ask, "Would I speak this way to someone I love?" Then try offering yourself the same compassion you would naturally extend to a dear friend facing the same situation. You might find it helpful to develop a few kind phrases you can repeat when struggling: "It is completely understandable for you to feel this way right now," "You're doing the best you can," or "You're good enough as you are." Place your hand on your heart as you say these words to enhance the feeling of self-care. With practice, you'll discover that kindness feels much better than judgment, and your brain will naturally begin to prefer this more rewarding response. As one participant in our program said, "With kindness, I've found that a lot of my old committee members' voices have completely disappeared. Instead of being plagued with constant what-ifs that drive me to despair, there is the constant voice of kindness. It has completely changed my life!"

Summary

Throughout this journey of transforming your relationship with food, you've discovered how your brain forms habits, how awareness can change those habits, and how kindness can heal the wounds that drive problematic eating patterns. The core message is beautifully captured in this insight: "When we learn to be at peace with ourselves, the war naturally stops." Freedom from food struggles doesn't come from more rules or greater willpower, but from understanding how your mind works so you can work with it rather than against it. Take a moment now to reflect on how far you've come. Whether you've begun mapping your eating habits, practiced mindful eating, used RAIN to ride out cravings, or extended kindness to yourself in moments of struggle, each step has built your capacity for awareness and self-compassion. Remember that this journey isn't about perfection but progress - small moments of awareness practiced consistently lead to profound transformation over time. Today, choose one practice from what you've learned and commit to it wholeheartedly, knowing that with curiosity and kindness as your companions, you're already on the path to freedom.

About Author

Loading...

Judson Brewer

Read more

Related Books by Judson Brewer

Loading...

Unwinding Anxiety

Judson Brewer

New Science Shows How to Break the Cycles of Worry and Fear to Heal Your Mind

★★★★½4.7