The Order of Time

The Order of Time Plot Summary

Introduction

We all experience time passing. The clock ticks forward, seasons change, we grow older—time seems so fundamental that we rarely question its nature. Yet what exactly is this thing we call "time"? Is it flowing uniformly throughout the universe as we intuitively believe, or is our everyday understanding of time merely a useful approximation? Physics has revealed startling truths about time that challenge our deepest intuitions. Time is not a simple river flowing equally for everyone everywhere. Instead, it's a complex phenomenon that behaves differently depending on gravity, speed, and perspective. In this exploration, we'll discover that time slows down near massive objects, that the universal "now" doesn't exist, and that at the most fundamental level of physics, time might not exist at all. These revelations not only revolutionize our scientific understanding but also invite us to reconsider our relationship with the most precious dimension of our existence.

Chapter 1: The Illusion of Unified Time

Time isn't what we think it is. The most startling discovery of modern physics is that time doesn't flow at the same rate everywhere. It actually passes more slowly in places with stronger gravity. This isn't science fiction—it's measurable reality. If you place one clock at sea level and another on a mountain, the mountain clock will tick faster. The difference is small but real and can be measured with precision instruments. Time literally passes more slowly as you get closer to Earth's surface because our planet's mass curves spacetime around it. This isn't just about clocks running differently—all processes slow down. A person living at sea level would age slightly less than someone living at high altitude. Albert Einstein predicted this phenomenon in his theory of general relativity long before we could measure it. He realized that gravity isn't a mysterious force acting at a distance but rather the effect of mass curving the fabric of spacetime. Objects fall toward Earth not because they're pulled by some invisible force, but because Earth's mass creates a curvature that shapes how things move through spacetime. This understanding completely transforms our concept of time. What we thought was a universal, absolute backdrop to reality turns out to be dynamic and relative. There isn't one "true time" flowing equally throughout the universe—instead, there are countless proper times, each flowing at its own rate depending on local conditions. The universe isn't like a marching band keeping step to a single drummer but rather like thousands of dancers moving to their own rhythms. When we realize that time isn't unified, we begin to question what else about our intuitive understanding of reality might be incorrect. This first crack in our common-sense view of time opens the door to even more profound revelations about the nature of our universe.

Chapter 2: Past and Future: A Matter of Entropy

The difference between past and future seems obvious. We remember the past but not the future. Eggs break but never reassemble. Coffee cools down but doesn't spontaneously heat up. But why does time have this unmistakable direction? Surprisingly, this arrow of time is absent from the fundamental laws of physics. The equations governing basic physical processes work perfectly well whether run forward or backward in time. Drop a ball, and Newton's laws describe its fall. Play this scenario in reverse—a ball rising from the ground—and the same laws apply. At the elementary level, physics shows no preference for one time direction over another. The key to understanding time's arrow lies in a concept called entropy—essentially a measure of disorder or randomness. In the 1850s, Rudolf Clausius formulated the second law of thermodynamics, which states that in an isolated system, entropy always increases or stays the same but never decreases. This law explains why heat flows from hot objects to cold ones and never the reverse. Ludwig Boltzmann later revealed the deeper meaning of entropy: it's related to probability. There are vastly more ways for things to be disordered than ordered. A deck of cards has only one perfectly ordered arrangement but countless disordered ones. The universe naturally evolves toward more probable (higher entropy) states simply because there are more of them. What's truly remarkable is that this directional flow of time—from low entropy to high entropy—appears to be the only fundamental difference between past and future. Our perception of time's arrow doesn't reflect some deep property of time itself but rather the fact that the universe began in an unusually low entropy state. The mystery isn't why entropy increases, but why it was so low to begin with. This perspective completely reframes our understanding of causality, memory, and the flow of time. What we experience as the passage of time is ultimately tied to this statistical tendency toward disorder—a tendency that emerges from our blurred, macroscopic view of the world rather than from time's fundamental nature.

Chapter 3: The Present Moment Doesn't Exist

The concept of "now"—a universal present moment shared across the entire universe—is perhaps our most cherished intuition about time. Yet Einstein's theory of relativity demolishes this notion entirely, revealing it to be nothing more than a persistent illusion. According to special relativity, moving objects experience time at different rates. If you travel at high speed relative to someone else, time passes more slowly for you than for them. This isn't just theoretical—it's been confirmed by experiments with precision atomic clocks on airplanes. The faster you move, the more time slows down for you. This time dilation leads to a profound consequence: different observers disagree about whether events are simultaneous. Imagine your friend is on a distant planet four light-years away. What is she doing "right now"? The question makes no sense. If you're moving toward her planet, your "now" might include her eating breakfast, but for someone moving away from her planet, "now" might be her eating dinner. These aren't different perspectives on the same present—they're equally valid but contradictory determinations of what exists "now." The universe isn't neatly sliced into universal moments of "past," "present," and "future." Instead, it has a more complex structure where each observer has their own cone-shaped past and future, with an expanded region between them that is neither past nor future from their perspective. The "present" is merely local—like a bubble around us extending only as far as the imprecision with which we determine time. This complete dismantling of the universal present has profound philosophical implications. Our entire conception of what "exists now" throughout the cosmos collapses. The present that extends throughout the universe, which seems so obvious to our intuition, turns out to be as illusory as the idea that the Earth is flat. Reality has a more complex temporal structure than our minds evolved to perceive.

Chapter 4: Time as Interaction, Not an Independent Entity

For centuries, philosophers debated the true nature of time. Aristotle argued that time is merely the measurement of change—if nothing changes, there is no time. Newton countered that "true" time flows uniformly by itself, independently of all things. This clash of titans presented two radically different conceptions of time. Einstein's revolutionary synthesis resolved this ancient debate. His general theory of relativity showed that Newton was right in intuiting that something like "time" exists as a real entity, but Aristotle was right that it's inseparable from change and the rest of the physical world. Time isn't an independent background against which physics unfolds—it's a dynamic part of the physical universe itself. What we call "time" is actually an aspect of the gravitational field, which is as real and physical as any other field in nature. This gravitational field can stretch, contract, and bend. When we say that time runs slower near a massive object, what's actually happening is that the gravitational field is modified there. Clocks measure the local properties of this field, just as thermometers measure temperature. This insight completely transforms our understanding of time's nature. Time isn't the rigid, immutable backdrop Newton imagined, nor is it merely a human construct for measuring change. It's a physical entity that interacts with matter and energy, bending and flexing in response to them. The gravitational field—spacetime itself—is a participant in physics, not just its stage. This loss of time's independence is intellectually liberating. Rather than being trapped in the inexorable flow of an absolute time, we live in a universe of interacting fields where what we call "time" emerges from these interactions. Time doesn't govern physics; it's part of physics—one aspect of the cosmic dance of fields and particles that constitutes our reality.

Chapter 5: Quantum Time: When Uncertainty Rules

At extremely small scales, time becomes even stranger. Quantum mechanics—our best theory of the subatomic world—introduces three fundamental discoveries that further dissolve our conception of time: granularity, indeterminacy, and relationality. Granularity means that time comes in tiny indivisible units, rather than flowing continuously. At the smallest scale—the Planck time, approximately 10^-44 seconds—time becomes discrete, not continuous. We can't divide time infinitely; it comes in tiny "atoms" of duration. This challenges millennia of philosophical debate about time's continuity—the world is fundamentally discrete, made of tiny dots like a pointillist painting rather than continuous lines. Indeterminacy introduces even more strangeness. In quantum mechanics, particles like electrons don't have definite positions until measured—they exist in probability clouds of possible locations. This fundamental uncertainty applies to time as well. The gravitational field that constitutes spacetime also fluctuates quantum mechanically. This means that the distinction between past, present, and future itself becomes blurry and indeterminate at the quantum level. Finally, relationality reveals that quantum properties only become definite in relation to other physical systems. An electron only has a definite position when it interacts with something else—like a detector screen. Similarly, time at the quantum level isn't absolute but materializes only through interactions. Duration becomes concrete only in relation to something else, remaining indefinite with respect to everything else. When these quantum aspects are applied to gravity and spacetime, we're left with a picture where time at its most fundamental level isn't a smooth flow but a seething quantum foam—a network of elementary events and interactions without any overarching time variable. The equations of quantum gravity—the cutting edge of theoretical physics—don't even include time as a basic variable. Instead, they describe how physical quantities change in relation to each other. This quantum perspective completes the dissolution of time as we intuitively understand it. Time emerges from more fundamental phenomena rather than being fundamental itself.

Chapter 6: The World as Events, Not Things

If time isn't fundamental, how should we conceptualize reality? Physics suggests we should think of the world not as a collection of objects persisting through time, but as a network of events—happenings, occurrences, processes. This shift from "things" to "events" aligns with relativity, which shows that the world is better understood through relationships between events rather than through some independent notion of time. Even what we consider the most solid "things"—like stones—are actually processes when viewed properly. A stone is a temporary configuration of atoms, a momentary equilibrium of forces, a chapter in the ongoing interaction of elements. The distinction matters: things persist in time; events have limited duration. A stone is a "thing" because we can ask where it will be tomorrow. A kiss is an "event"—it makes no sense to ask where the kiss will be tomorrow. Yet on closer inspection, even the stone is a long event: a complex vibration of quantum fields that momentarily maintains its shape before eventually disintegrating. The world consists of networks of events, not collections of objects. This event-based perspective resolves many conceptual problems. Without an independent time ordering everything, we can understand the world as a vast network of interconnected occurrences. These events don't form an orderly queue like the English; they crowd around chaotically like Italians. They connect and influence each other according to physical laws, but without requiring a master "time" variable coordinating everything. Scientists who tried to understand the world in terms of timeless "things" often went astray. Plato attempted to describe atoms as perfect geometric shapes rather than focusing on their interactions. The young Kepler initially tried to explain planetary orbits through static geometric relationships rather than dynamic laws of motion. Both approached physics through static structures rather than processes—and both were wrong. Understanding reality as a network of events rather than a collection of things doesn't mean the world is static. On the contrary, it acknowledges that change is fundamental—the world is nothing but change, just not change organized along a universal timeline. This perspective not only aligns with modern physics but also helps us better understand our place in the cosmic web of happenings.

Chapter 7: Memory and Identity: How We Experience Time

If fundamental physics doesn't include time as we experience it, where does our powerful sense of time's flow come from? The answer lies within us—in the structure of our minds, our memories, and the peculiar way we interact with the world. Our brains are essentially prediction machines that evolved to track changes in the environment. They collect memories of past events to predict future ones, enhancing our survival chances. This bridging between past and future is central to our mental structure and creates our sense of time's flow. We perceive time's passage because our brains are constantly comparing current states with remembered past states and projected future ones. Memory plays the crucial role in this process. We aren't merely collections of independent moments but beings whose present is saturated with traces of our past. Every moment of our existence is linked to previous moments through memory. Our identity itself depends on this temporal continuity—we are narratives unfolding through time. As Saint Augustine observed in the 4th century, our awareness of time's passage isn't external but internal, residing in the mind's ability to hold the past and anticipate the future. This perspective helps explain why time seems to flow. The direction of this flow—from past to future—aligns with entropy's increase. In regions of the universe where entropy increases, complex structures like brains can form, memories can be recorded, and beings like us can develop time consciousness. We exist in a part of the universe where entropy flows in a particular direction, allowing traces of the past to accumulate while the future remains open. Our subjective experience of time ultimately emerges from these physical processes. The emotion of time—the ache of nostalgia, the anxiety about the future, the fleeting intensity of the present—isn't an illusion hiding time's true nature. Rather, these emotions might be precisely what time is for us. Time is how memory-bearing, future-anticipating beings like ourselves experience a universe of events. This doesn't mean time is merely psychological. Our experience of time is grounded in real physical processes—the accumulation of traces, the increase of entropy, the quantum interactions that constitute memory. But it does mean that time as we experience it emerges from the particular way our consciousness interacts with the physical world rather than being fundamental to that world.

Summary

Time, as revealed by modern physics, is not the uniform, independent flow we intuitively believe in, but rather a complex, multifaceted phenomenon that emerges from more fundamental processes. The most profound insight is that what we experience as time's passage arises largely from our perspective as memory-bearing, entropy-sensitive beings interacting with a tiny slice of the universe. When we look deeply enough, we find that time doesn't govern reality—it emerges from it, just as our consciousness emerges from neural activity rather than existing independently. This transformed understanding of time invites us to reconsider our relationship with temporality. If time isn't a tyrannical external force but rather an aspect of how we engage with the world, how might this change our approach to life's finite duration? Perhaps we might learn to appreciate more fully the precious clearing that memory and anticipation open up for us—the brief window of experience that constitutes our lives. Though physics has disassembled our naive concept of time, it has given us something more profound: a deeper appreciation for the extraordinary fact that we exist at all in this vast network of events that constitutes our universe.

About Author

Loading...

Carlo Rovelli

Carlo Rovelli is an Italian theoretical physicist and writer who has worked in Italy and the USA, and currently works in France. His work is mainly in the field of quantum gravity, where he is among the founders of the loop quantum gravity theory. He has also worked in the history and philosophy of science. He collaborates regularly with several Italian newspapers, in particular the cultural supplements of Il Sole 24 Ore and La Repubblica.

Read more

Related Books by Carlo Rovelli

Loading...

Seven Brief Lessons on Physics

Carlo Rovelli

A mind-bending introduction to modern physics

★★★½☆4.0

Loading...

Reality Is Not What It Seems

Carlo Rovelli

The Journey to Quantum Gravity

★★★★☆4.3