The Prodigal God

The Prodigal God Plot Summary

Introduction

The evening was warm as the young man stood at the edge of his father's property, looking back at the house one last time. He had demanded his inheritance early—a shocking request that essentially said, "I wish you were dead"—yet his father had given it to him anyway. Now, with money in hand, he was leaving for a distant country, eager to experience life on his own terms. Little did he know that this journey would lead him to a spiritual awakening that would reveal not just his own brokenness, but illuminate the very heart of divine love. This parable of the prodigal son is perhaps the most misunderstood story in religious literature. Timothy Keller reveals that focusing solely on the wayward younger brother misses half the message. The elder brother—outwardly moral, dutiful, and righteous—is equally lost, though in a more subtle and dangerous way. By examining both brothers, Keller unveils a revolutionary understanding of sin, grace, and redemption that challenges conventional religious thinking. This exploration offers a profound roadmap for anyone seeking to understand true spirituality beyond both irreligious self-discovery and religious moralism, pointing toward a relationship with God characterized by grace rather than performance.

Chapter 1: Understanding the Parable: The Two Lost Sons

In the opening scene of the parable, a younger son approaches his father with an unprecedented request: "Father, give me my share of the estate." In Jesus's time, this was tantamount to saying, "I wish you were dead." Inheritance was only divided when the father died. The audience would have gasped at such disrespect. Yet rather than disowning his son, the father divides his property, giving the younger son his portion—likely one-third of the estate, with the elder receiving two-thirds. The younger son promptly liquidates his share, a painful process that would have required selling land that had been in the family for generations. In that culture, land wasn't just property; it was identity and legacy. For the father to allow this represented an extraordinary sacrifice. Soon after, the son leaves for a "far country" where he squanders everything on wild living. When a famine hits, he finds himself feeding pigs—an especially degrading job for a Jewish man—and longing to eat the pods given to the animals. Coming to his senses, the son rehearses a speech: "Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you. I am no longer worthy to be called your son; make me like one of your hired men." His plan wasn't merely to apologize but to work as a hired craftsman to pay back his debt. But as he approaches home, his father sees him from a distance and runs to him—an undignified act for an elderly Middle Eastern patriarch. Before the son can finish his speech, the father calls for the best robe, a ring, and sandals—symbols of full restoration to the family. Meanwhile, the elder brother, hearing about the celebration, refuses to enter the feast. He confronts his father, saying, "Look! All these years I've been slaving for you and never disobeyed your orders." His complaint reveals not dutiful love but underlying resentment. The father pleads with him to join the celebration, but the story ends without revealing whether he enters or not. The parable's genius lies in how it addresses both the irreligious and the religious. Jesus shows that both brothers are lost—one through breaking the rules, the other through keeping them for the wrong reasons. Both miss the father's heart of grace, though in very different ways. This story invites us to move beyond both rebellion and rule-keeping to discover the transformative power of the father's unconditional love.

Chapter 2: The Elder Brother: Moral Conformity and Its Dangers

When the prodigal son returns home and the celebration begins, the elder brother's true character emerges. Hearing music and dancing, he inquires what's happening. Upon learning of his brother's return and the lavish welcome, he becomes furious. "Look!" he says to his father, disrespectfully omitting any honorific address, "All these years I've been slaving for you and never disobeyed your orders." He refuses to call the prodigal "my brother," instead saying "this son of yours." His anger reveals a heart filled with resentment despite his outward obedience. The elder brother highlights the cost of the celebration—"you never gave me even a young goat"—while overlooking the greater cost: by reinstating the younger brother, the father is essentially taking from the elder brother's inheritance again. Every robe, ring, and fatted calf now came at the elder son's expense. His complaint about "slaving" for the father reveals that his obedience was never motivated by love but by calculated self-interest. In one theater production of this parable, an actor playing the elder brother delivered his lines with quiet, cold fury, making his rage all the more chilling. When the father pleaded with him to join the feast, the actor turned his back and walked slowly away. The audience sat in stunned silence, feeling the devastating weight of his choice. This character represents what Keller calls "elder-brother lostness"—a condition marked by moral superiority, joyless duty, and an inability to celebrate grace extended to others. The elder brother believes his goodness entitles him to blessing and control. His resentment stems from a fundamental misunderstanding: he sees his relationship with his father as transactional rather than loving. His obedience is a form of self-salvation, a way to put God in his debt. The danger of elder-brother righteousness is its subtlety. While the younger brother knows he's alienated from the father, the elder brother doesn't recognize his condition. His moral rectitude blinds him to his own spiritual poverty. This is why Jesus directs this parable primarily at the Pharisees—to show religious people that their self-righteousness might be keeping them further from God's heart than those whose sins are more obvious. The most devastating form of lostness is not knowing you're lost at all.

Chapter 3: The Younger Brother: Self-Discovery and Its Emptiness

The younger brother embodies what many modern people consider freedom—breaking away from tradition, authority, and moral constraints to "find oneself." His demand for inheritance represents a deep desire for autonomy without accountability. With money in hand, he travels to a "far country," symbolic of not just geographical distance but spiritual and moral separation. There, he pursues what philosophers might call a life of "self-actualization" or what our culture might celebrate as "living authentically." His subsequent journey illustrates the emptiness of this path. The text tells us he "squandered his wealth in wild living." Initially, this lifestyle seemed to deliver what it promised—pleasure, friends, and freedom from constraints. We can imagine him surrounded by companions, celebrated for his generosity and spontaneity. But when his money runs out, so do his friends. The famine that follows serves as a powerful metaphor—external circumstances expose the poverty of a life built on self-gratification. Consider the scene of the son feeding pigs—animals considered unclean in Jewish culture. The text says, "He longed to fill his stomach with the pods that the pigs were eating, but no one gave him anything." This haunting image captures the isolation that often follows a life of self-indulgence. The son who demanded "give me" now discovers that in a world built on consumption, no one gives anything freely. A modern parallel might be the countless stories of celebrities who achieve everything our culture values—wealth, fame, admiration—only to find themselves battling addiction, loneliness, or depression. As one famous actor put it: "I had everything a man could want, and I still woke up every morning with a sick feeling in my stomach." The younger brother's awakening comes not through self-discovery but self-surrender. His "coming to his senses" represents a profound recognition that autonomy has led to alienation, not fulfillment. His plan to return as a hired servant reveals his understanding that even the lowest position in his father's household offers more dignity than his current freedom. The emptiness of self-discovery without relationship teaches us something profound: human flourishing isn't found in the absence of boundaries but within them. True freedom isn't the ability to do whatever we want, but the capacity to become what we were designed to be. The younger brother's journey reminds us that sometimes we must come to the end of ourselves before we can discover what we truly need.

Chapter 4: Redefining Sin and Lostness in Jesus's Teaching

The parable radically redefines our understanding of sin. Most people think of sin primarily as breaking rules—immoral behavior, harmful actions, or rebellion against established standards. By this definition, the younger brother is clearly the sinner. He disrespects his father, wastes his inheritance, and engages in "wild living." His sins are obvious and measurable. Yet Jesus does something revolutionary with this story. He shows that the elder brother—moral, obedient, and dutiful—is equally lost, perhaps more dangerously so. When the elder brother says, "All these years I've been slaving for you," he reveals that his obedience wasn't motivated by love but by a desire for reward and recognition. His anger at the celebration exposes his true heart: he has been serving his father not out of devotion but out of calculated self-interest. Imagine two children giving their mother gifts on her birthday. One child saves his allowance and buys something his mother will love. The other child gives a gift hoping to be praised as the "better child" or to receive something in return. The actions appear identical, but the heart motivations couldn't be more different. This is the distinction Jesus is highlighting between true righteousness and elder-brother righteousness. Keller illustrates this through the character of Salieri in Peter Shaffer's play Amadeus. Salieri makes a vow to God: "I will give you my chastity, my industry, my deepest humility, every hour of my life" in exchange for musical greatness. When God instead blesses the immoral Mozart with superior talent, Salieri becomes bitter and eventually declares God his enemy. His "righteousness" is revealed as a bargaining tool, not true devotion. This redefines lostness as well. Both brothers are lost because both miss the father's heart. The younger brother initially sees the father as a source of provision rather than relationship. The elder brother sees the father as an employer to be pleased rather than a parent to be loved. Both are using the father for what they can get from him. One does it by breaking the rules, the other by keeping them—but their fundamental orientation is the same. Jesus's teaching confronts us with a profound truth: sin is not merely breaking rules but living for ourselves rather than for God and others. It's replacing God as the center of our universe. This means we can be lost while looking perfectly found, alienated from God while appearing religiously devoted. This redefinition challenges both the irreligious and the religious to examine not just their actions but the true state of their hearts.

Chapter 5: The True Elder Brother: Finding Jesus in the Story

The parable of the two lost sons contains a striking omission that invites reflection. Jesus tells three consecutive parables in Luke 15: the lost sheep, the lost coin, and the two lost sons. In the first two stories, someone actively searches for what is lost—the shepherd leaves the ninety-nine to find one sheep; the woman sweeps her house diligently looking for her coin. But in the third parable, no one goes searching for the younger son. The father waits, hoping for his return, but doesn't pursue him. This absence creates a narrative tension. Who should have gone searching for the lost brother? In ancient Near Eastern culture, this responsibility would have fallen to the elder brother. He should have said, "Father, my brother has disgraced our family, but I will find him and bring him home. If necessary, I will pay his debts and restore him at my own expense." Instead, he remains at home, secretly pleased at his brother's failure, which only magnifies his own righteousness by comparison. A true elder brother would have searched relentlessly. Edmund Clowney tells the true story of a young American soldier missing in action during the Vietnam War. When official channels provided no information, his older brother flew to Vietnam and, risking his life, searched the jungles and battlefields for him. People on both sides of the conflict, hearing of his dedication, called him simply "the brother." The parable lacks this true elder brother—but Jesus himself fills this role. He left the ultimate "home" of heaven to search for us in our distant country of rebellion and sin. Unlike the elder brother in the story, Jesus paid the ultimate price to bring us back to the Father. As Keller powerfully states: "Our true elder brother paid our debt, on the cross, in our place." This sheds new light on the father's statement: "Everything I have is yours." The elder son's objection to the feast wasn't just pettiness—it was financially valid. Every robe, ring, and fatted calf for the celebration came at his expense. Similarly, our restoration to God's family came at Jesus's expense. On the cross, Jesus was stripped of his robe so we could be clothed with dignity. He was treated as an outcast so we could be welcomed as family members. He drank the cup of justice so we might have the cup of joy. This insight transforms how we understand salvation. It wasn't simply that the father forgave the younger son—someone had to pay. Forgiveness always comes at a cost to the one granting it. The elder brother should have borne this cost willingly out of love, but couldn't. Jesus, our true elder brother, did what the elder brother in the parable wouldn't do—he sought us at immeasurable personal cost. This sacrificial love has the power to transform both younger and elder brothers, freeing us from both rebellion and religious performance.

Chapter 6: Experiencing the Feast: Living Out Gospel Transformation

When the prodigal son returns home, his father throws an extravagant feast with music, dancing, and the fattened calf—the ancient equivalent of the finest gourmet meal. This celebration represents more than just happiness at a son's return; it symbolizes the transformative nature of grace. Throughout the gospels, Jesus consistently portrays salvation as a feast, describing the kingdom of God as a great banquet to which many are invited. A feast engages all our senses—taste, smell, sight, sound—suggesting that salvation is not merely intellectual assent but a fully experiential reality. Jonathan Edwards distinguished between merely believing God is gracious and actually tasting his grace, comparing it to the difference between believing honey is sweet and experiencing its sweetness. When grace becomes experiential, it transforms us from the inside out. Consider the story of a successful attorney who attended Redeemer Presbyterian Church. For years she had been a dutiful church member, believing all the right doctrines, but her faith felt academic and lifeless. During a sermon series on this parable, she realized she had been relating to God as an elder brother—doing everything right but missing the joy of grace. "I suddenly understood," she said, "that God wasn't interested in my performance but in my presence at his table." This insight transformed her relationship with God from obligation to delight. A feast is also communal—no one celebrates alone. The gospel creates a new community where former enemies become family. This is why Jesus left us the Lord's Supper as a tangible reminder of his grace. When we share this meal, we experience both vertical reconciliation with God and horizontal reconciliation with others. As C.S. Lewis noted, in true friendship and community, we experience more of God than we could alone: "Every soul, seeing Him in her own way, doubtless communicates that unique vision to all the rest." Gospel transformation must be continually renewed. Martin Luther observed that religion is the "default mode" of the human heart—we naturally revert to trying to earn God's favor through performance. That's why we must "feed on the gospel," regularly returning to the truth that we are more sinful than we dare believe, yet more loved than we dare hope. This rhythmic return to grace prevents both license (younger brother) and legalism (elder brother). The father's feast teaches us that the gospel isn't just about getting to heaven someday—it's about experiencing the joy of God's presence now. As we taste his grace, we find ourselves naturally becoming more generous, forgiving, and compassionate—not to earn anything, but because we've been transformed by love. The ultimate sign that we understand the gospel is not perfect behavior but a growing capacity to celebrate when the lost are found.

Chapter 7: The Homecoming We All Seek: Hope and Community

Deep within every human heart lies a profound longing for home. C.S. Lewis called it "Sehnsucht"—a German word conveying spiritual homesickness, a yearning for something we've never experienced yet somehow recognize. We see this in how powerfully certain places, music, or memories can evoke this aching sense of belonging just beyond our reach. Lewis wrote that these moments are "good images of what we really desire; but if they are mistaken for the thing itself they turn into dumb idols, breaking the hearts of their worshippers." The biblical narrative frames human history as a story of exile and homecoming. Genesis tells us we were created to live in God's garden—a place of perfect relationship, purpose, and peace. Our rebellion sent us into exile, making us spiritual wanderers seeking to recreate what we've lost. The younger brother's journey to a "far country" and subsequent return mirrors this universal human experience. A woman in her seventies shared her story at a church retreat. As a child during World War II, she had been evacuated from London to the countryside. Though safe, she felt profoundly displaced. "For decades," she said, "I've had recurring dreams of trying to get home but never arriving." With tears, she added, "Understanding this parable helped me see that my lifelong homesickness was pointing to something real—God has been calling me home all along." The father in the parable represents our heavenly Father who runs to meet us—not with condemnation but with compassion. While we expect judgment, he offers a feast. This upends our expectations about God and ourselves. The extravagant welcome extended to the younger son and offered to the elder brother reveals that God's arms are open to both the openly rebellious and the secretly resentful. Isaiah describes this ultimate homecoming: "On this mountain the Lord Almighty will prepare a feast of rich food for all peoples... He will swallow up death forever. The Sovereign Lord will wipe away the tears from all faces." This vision of cosmic restoration gives us hope that our deepest longings aren't illusory but prophetic—pointers to what awaits us. The father's feast in the parable is just a foretaste of this final homecoming. Yet we need not wait for heaven to begin experiencing this reality. When we understand and accept grace, we become part of a new community—the family of God where both younger and elder brothers are welcomed, where forgiveness replaces judgment, and celebration replaces competition. This community, though imperfect, offers a genuine foretaste of home. In a world of isolation and division, such belonging speaks powerfully to our deepest human need.

Summary

The Prodigal God reveals a startling truth: the familiar parable of the lost son is actually about two lost sons. Jesus wasn't merely describing a wayward sinner who returns home to a loving father. He was exposing two fundamental ways humans try to find happiness—the younger brother's path of self-discovery and the elder brother's path of moral conformity—and showing how both ultimately fall short. The younger brother's rebellion is obvious, but the elder brother's resentful obedience reveals a heart equally distant from the father. Jesus challenges the assumption that religious rule-keeping makes one close to God, suggesting instead that it can be a sophisticated form of rebellion. The transformative power of this parable lies in its revelation of a third way: the way of grace. The father in the story represents God, who welcomes home both the openly rebellious and the secretly resentful. But the parable contains a deliberate omission—there is no true elder brother who goes searching for the lost son. Jesus himself fills this role, becoming our true elder brother who sacrificed everything to bring us home. Understanding this gospel of grace changes us from the inside out, freeing us from both the emptiness of self-indulgence and the burden of self-righteousness. It creates a new community where former enemies become family and celebrations replace competition. This vision offers hope that our deepest longing for home will ultimately be fulfilled, not through our own efforts but through the extravagant love of a Father who runs to meet us while we are still a long way off.

About Author

Loading...

Timothy J. Keller

Read more

Related Books by Timothy J. Keller

Loading...

Forgive

Timothy J. Keller

Why Should I and How Can I?

★★★★½4.6

Loading...

The Reason For God

Timothy J. Keller

Belief In An Age Of Skepticism

★★★★☆4.2

Loading...

The Freedom of Self-Forgetfulness

Timothy J. Keller

The Path to True Christian Joy

★★★★½4.5