The Soft Edge

The Soft Edge Plot Summary

Introduction

Roberto Espinosa was riding high as a restaurant owner in San Antonio's River Walk district until a devastating accident changed everything. One day in 2001, he stepped onto his restaurant's service elevator platform, which suddenly gave way, plunging thirty feet to the basement. Though he survived, the ensuing economic downturn forced him to close his beloved restaurant. At his lowest point, a trusted insurance representative invited him to try working as an agent at Northwestern Mutual. The transition wasn't easy - Espinosa struggled for three years, nearly quitting multiple times. Then came a profound moment of transformation at a client's funeral, when he heard the deceased man's eight-year-old daughter say her family would be okay because of the insurance her father had provided. Suddenly, Espinosa found his conviction. His productivity increased fivefold, and he went on to become one of Northwestern Mutual's top recruiters. This story illustrates what author Rich Karlgaard calls the "soft edge" - those intangible qualities like trust, grit, and purpose that drive sustainable business advantage. While many companies focus exclusively on strategy and hard-edge execution metrics, the soft edge encompasses the human elements that foster resilience, creativity, and long-term success. These qualities don't appear on balance sheets but are essential for navigating disruptive change and fostering innovation. Throughout these pages, we'll explore how enduring organizations like Northwestern Mutual, FedEx, Mayo Clinic, and others have built their soft edges through trust, smarts, teams, taste, and story - creating an unfair advantage that competitors struggle to replicate, even as technology and market conditions continuously evolve around them.

Chapter 1: Trust: The Foundation of Sustainable Business Advantage

Not long ago at the Four Seasons Hotel in Palo Alto, California, Karlgaard overheard a conversation between two venture capitalists discussing how their cloud strategy was merely a "Trojan Horse" to lock in customers. Their cynical language mirrored their predatory tactics. This snarky business language, which became common during the dot-com era, trivializes questionable behavior. It stands in stark contrast to what Karlgaard observed at the insurance giant Northwestern Mutual, where executives speak earnestly about helping customers and making a difference in communities. During a gathering of 8,400 financial representatives in Milwaukee's BMO Harris Bradley Center, CEO John Schlifske spoke about values with a sincerity that would draw mockery in Silicon Valley boardrooms. Yet this earnestness has helped Northwestern Mutual become America's largest life insurer, with $25 billion in annual revenue. Trust operates in two dimensions: externally between an organization and its customers, and internally among employees and management. Northwestern Mutual excels at both. The company has survived since 1857, spanning a civil war, two world wars, and numerous recessions. As a mutual company owned by policyholders rather than shareholders, it can make decisions that prioritize customer interests over short-term profits. Its strong balance sheet, with $215 billion in assets backing $1.5 trillion in life insurance contracts, provides additional security. Internally, Northwestern Mutual invests heavily in onboarding representatives, spending roughly $100,000 on each successful recruit. These representatives undergo rigorous training and follow simple but effective practices like the "10-3-1 rule": make ten calls to get three meetings which typically results in one new customer. The importance of trust extends far beyond insurance. Research shows that trust underlies effective working relationships, improves organizational performance, and fuels innovation by facilitating learning and experimentation. In fact, a PricewaterhouseCoopers study of corporate innovation found that the number one differentiating factor between top innovators and bottom innovators was trust. Ideas can't be pulled from people's heads - they must be offered willingly, and they're only given to those we trust. When employees trust their organization, they're more engaged and productive. When customers trust a brand, they're willing to pay premium prices and remain loyal through difficult times. Trust seems like a soft, fuzzy concept, but it drives hard financial results. In today's hypercompetitive market, the ability to build and maintain trust - with both customers and employees - may be your most sustainable advantage. As Northwestern Mutual's example shows, trust isn't just nice to have; it's essential for lasting success in any enterprise that relies on human relationships and innovation.

Chapter 2: Smarts: Accelerating Learning and Adapting to Change

In 2012, CBS Sports ranked the 1975-76 Indiana University Hoosiers basketball team as the greatest college team of all time. They went 32-0 that season and were coached by Bobby Knight, notorious for his harsh methods and colorful language. What's less known is that one person - a female student - watched Knight coach every single home game and practice that season. She sat a few rows behind the bench, studying Knight's techniques and taking extensive notes. Her name was Tara VanDerveer, and she would go on to become one of the most successful coaches in NCAA women's basketball history, with multiple championships at Stanford University and an Olympic gold medal to her name. VanDerveer didn't just watch Knight. Throughout her career, she sought out mentors everywhere. At the University of Idaho, she learned from men's coach Don Monson. At Ohio State, she took coaching classes from Fred Taylor, who had been Knight's former coach. Later at Stanford, she collaborated with Pete Newell, a legendary basketball mind who ran specialized training camps. VanDerveer's story illustrates a crucial aspect of smarts in business: the willingness to learn from others, especially the very best in your field. As she put it, "I always say some of the simplest things are some of the hardest to do. I watch football practice. I watch water polo practice. I get ideas, I talk to coaches, I try to learn how to do my job better." The Mayo Clinic faces a different challenge in staying smart. Founded in 1863 by Dr. William W. Mayo in Rochester, Minnesota, the clinic now employs 32,000 healthcare professionals who must stay current in rapidly evolving fields. The knowledge explosion in medicine is staggering - what once was three cardiology journals published monthly has expanded to eleven journals, some published biweekly. In 1960, approximately 100 articles were published on randomized control trials; today, more than 10,000 such articles appear annually. How can anyone keep up? Mayo's response has been to create multiple schools for continuous education, from medical school to graduate programs to specialized training for non-physicians and ongoing professional development. But smarts in business isn't just about IQ or academic credentials. As NetApp CEO Tom Georgens observed, "Once you're at a certain point in your career - and it's not that far out, maybe five years - all the grades and academic credentials in the world don't mean anything anymore. It's all about accomplishment from that point forward." What matters more is grit - the willingness to face challenges, learn from mistakes, and persist through difficulties. Restaurant entrepreneur David Chang of Momofuku fame believes success comes from "who learns from their mistakes the fastest." He practices the Japanese principles of Kaizen (continuous improvement) and Hansei (acknowledging mistakes). The most effective path to getting smarter combines several approaches: seeking out mentors who excel in your field, embracing rather than hiding from mistakes, thinking laterally by borrowing ideas from other disciplines, and developing the grit to keep pushing forward despite setbacks. This approach to organizational smarts creates a powerful adaptive capacity - the ability to learn and change quickly in response to new challenges. In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, this may be the most valuable form of intelligence of all.

Chapter 3: Teams: Building High-Performance Groups That Innovate

In 1989, Jim Barksdale, then COO of FedEx, faced a major technology challenge. Throughout the 1980s, FedEx had invested heavily in IBM mainframe computers to manage its package tracking - at one point running the world's largest single database. But now the technology landscape was shifting toward networked computing, potentially leaving FedEx with outdated systems. Barksdale needed fresh perspective, so he and board member Phil Greer made a radical proposal to founder Fred Smith: add Judy Estrin, a 36-year-old Silicon Valley tech entrepreneur with no board experience, to FedEx's board of directors. Despite her youth and unconventional background, Smith recognized Estrin's brilliance and appointed her to head FedEx's Information Technology and Oversight Committee. She served on the board from 1989 to 2010, helping guide FedEx through critical technological transitions. Today, FedEx operates one of the world's most complex logistics networks, with 300,000 employees worldwide, 630 aircraft, and 45,000 trucks. Each night at its Memphis hub alone, the company processes 1.5 million packages. How does FedEx maintain focus amid such complexity? Smith revealed that the company organizes itself around small teams. His own leadership team consists of just eleven direct reports, including the CEOs of FedEx's four major operating companies. This approach reflects what Amazon's Jeff Bezos calls the "two-pizza rule" - teams should be small enough to be fed by two pizzas. When teams grow beyond about a dozen people, members become less likely to share information and help each other. As Smith explains, "In a big organization like FedEx, we can throw our weight around. We have scale. But with scale comes a huge risk. And that is loss of focus." German software giant SAP faced a similar challenge with its 20,000-person development department. To stay competitive against smaller, nimbler software-as-a-service companies, SAP's leadership set an ambitious goal of cutting product development time from 14.8 months to 6 months. Former co-CEO Jim Snabe completely reorganized the department into small, autonomous teams of about ten people each. "By acting like this, we're basically a bunch of start-ups, but we work under one master plan," Snabe explained. The result? SAP cut development time to 7.8 months within three years while improving software quality. What makes small teams work so well? One key factor is cognitive diversity - differences in how team members think, feel, and see the world. This goes beyond gender and racial diversity to include variations in thinking styles, educational backgrounds, and life experiences. Nest Labs founder Tony Fadell, who worked with Steve Jobs to launch the iPod, brings different types of thinkers together in meetings: "We have user-experience people, management, product management, and the algorithms and algorithms-analysis people." By combining varied perspectives, Fadell ensures Nest's products will satisfy a wide variety of customers. Another essential element is creating what Northwestern Mutual executive Todd Schoon calls "the gift of high expectations." Great teams thrive on demanding cultures that push members beyond their comfort zones, but balance this with reassurance and support. As Tony Fadell noted, "If you're not slightly scared or slightly worried, you're not pushing hard enough." Finally, effective teams need autonomy within boundaries - freedom to make decisions within a clear framework of accountability. This balance between freedom and structure allows teams to innovate rapidly while maintaining alignment with organizational goals. The future of teamwork includes exciting developments in data and analytics. Sociometrics - the measurement of how people interact - can now capture the communication patterns that predict team success. Research by MIT professor Alex Pentland shows that productive teams have specific "data signatures" involving energy, engagement, and exploration. Such insights may eventually help leaders assemble more effective teams based on complementary communication styles. In today's collaborative economy, mastering the art of building and leading high-performance teams isn't just nice to have - it's essential for organizational success.

Chapter 4: Taste: Creating Products That Evoke Emotional Connection

Two miles west of Stanford University lies Old La Honda Road (OLH), a steep 3.2-mile climb that rises 1,290 feet through redwood trees. For local cyclists, it's the ultimate test of ability and endurance. Using the social fitness app Strava, riders can compare their times with thousands of others who have tackled this legendary climb. Karlgaard, an occasional cyclist, once clocked a personal best of 25:18 on OLH. Then, in July 2013, he shattered this record with an astonishing time of 11:42, beating the existing record by three minutes. His secret? A new electric-assisted bicycle from Specialized called the Turbo. Within 24 hours, his record was flagged as suspicious by the Strava community. What made the Specialized Turbo special wasn't just its motor, but how that motor was integrated into the bicycle's form and function. The battery was cleverly concealed in the down-tube, while the motor was built into the rear wheel hub. Most importantly, the software controlling the motor's assistance was designed to feel completely natural. As Specialized software expert Amber Lucas explained: "You shouldn't have to think about a throttle or pushing buttons. We designed the torque sensor inside of the rear hub so that it reads torque off of the cassette. The sensor knows what gear you're in." This seamless experience required years of development to perfect, with countless refinements to both hardware and software. Steve Jobs used the word "taste" to describe this quality of seamless integration that creates emotional connection. It goes beyond mere design to create what Specialized's chief designer Robert Egger called "the elusive sweet spot between data truth and human truth." Taste isn't just making something beautiful - it's creating a product that speaks to deeper human needs and aspirations. Take the Nest Learning Thermostat, created by former Apple executive Tony Fadell. When designing Nest, Fadell did things that defied business logic, like creating custom screws that cost a hundred times more than standard ones. "Every business school in the world would flunk you if you came up with a business plan that said, 'Oh, and we're going to design and fabricate our own screws at an exponentially higher cost,'" Fadell admitted. But these weren't just screws - they were part of a total experience designed to make customers feel smart and capable. What principles guide the creation of products with taste? Several patterns emerge from studying companies like Specialized, Apple, and Nest. First, function must come before form - a beautiful product that doesn't work well will fail. Second, form matters enormously once functional requirements are met. Simple geometry like the "golden rectangle" (with proportions of 1.618:1) and rounded corners rather than sharp edges appeal to our evolved aesthetic preferences. Third, familiarity creates comfort - even revolutionary products need to connect to things we already understand. The original Apple Macintosh was designed to look vaguely human, with a high forehead and a handle for carrying your "genius friend." Fourth, successful products often reflect their creators' personal desires and standards. As Egger said, "Some of it is based on our selfishness. I want to have the most beautiful bike. I want to have the fastest bike." Creating products with taste requires balancing data-driven decisions with intuitive, opinion-based judgments. Data can validate functional requirements and measure user responses, but it can't substitute for a strong point of view. As Nest's Fadell observed, "There's data that can inform the opinion, but at the end of the day, when you create new designs, you're still sitting in the mind of the customer." This blend of quantitative analysis and qualitative judgment creates products that don't just perform well but evoke emotional responses - delight, wonder, pride, and even love. In today's crowded marketplace, this emotional connection may be your most powerful competitive advantage.

Chapter 5: Story: Crafting Narratives That Drive Purpose and Brand

On January 12, 2010, a devastating 7.0 earthquake struck Haiti, killing approximately 150,000 people and leaving the country's infrastructure in ruins. Alabama gastroenterologist Richard McGlaughlin felt compelled to help, flying his single-engine Cirrus SR22 airplane from Florida to Haiti loaded with medical supplies. He made monthly flights thereafter, and in January 2012, brought his daughter Elaine along. About an hour into their flight to Haiti, McGlaughlin noticed the oil pressure gauge dropping. The engine soon seized completely, leaving them gliding toward the ocean with no chance of reaching land. In this crisis moment, McGlaughlin reached for a red handle on the ceiling of his Cirrus - activating a whole-airframe parachute that lowered the entire plane safely into the water. McGlaughlin and his daughter were rescued unharmed. What's remarkable isn't just that the Cirrus had a parachute, but that McGlaughlin actually pulled it. Many Cirrus pilots had died in preventable crashes because they hesitated to use this innovative safety feature. The aircraft manufacturer, Cirrus, had been legally cautious about advocating parachute deployment except in specific circumstances. Enter the Cirrus Owners and Pilots Association (COPA), an independent group of passionate Cirrus pilots. COPA member Rick Beach analyzed accident data and began advocating a simple mantra: "Pull early, pull often." Thanks to COPA's campaign, the Cirrus safety record improved dramatically - but only among active COPA members who engaged with this community knowledge. Since then, forty parachute pulls have saved more than ninety lives. This story illustrates a profound shift in how companies relate to their brands and stories. No longer do organizations control their narratives completely - customers now actively shape, extend, and sometimes correct company stories. As venture capitalist Margit Wennmachers explains, "The story - leaders often relegate it to marketing or a PR function. It's really something that the founder or the CEO needs to own. You can't outsource the narrative of your company... Essentially, the story is the company and the company is the story, and they can't be divorced from each other." Stories matter because they're how humans make sense of the world. From the ancient cave paintings of Lascaux to today's corporate boardrooms, stories help us process information, remember key points, and connect emotionally with ideas. In business, stories serve multiple functions: they articulate purpose, build brands, train employees, and inspire action. Stories are particularly effective at communicating purpose - why a company exists beyond making money. When Dell defined its story primarily in terms of financial goals ("We're a $30 billion company planning to become a $60 billion company"), it created vulnerability. "If your story is about money and about the stock price, that always changes," Wennmachers noted. "There's nothing else of substance to make an employee stay longer or a customer stick with you when those numbers change." Effective business storytelling follows several principles. First, keep it simple - the clearest stories have the most impact. Second, know your audience and adjust your approach accordingly. Third, make it real by including authentic details and origin stories that transport listeners. Fourth, don't hide the struggles - share how you've overcome obstacles. As Nancy Duarte, a story expert, explained: "I would follow a leader that has tried and failed (and he's willing to talk about it) much sooner than I would follow a leader who pretends he's never failed." Finally, practice relentlessly. Even Steve Jobs, renowned for his seemingly effortless presentations, rehearsed exhaustively before appearing on stage. In today's digital world, storytelling has expanded beyond traditional channels. Social media creates what Cisco's John Earnhardt calls a "fourth space" for corporate narrative - distinct from marketing, PR, or investor relations. On platforms like Twitter, Facebook, and online forums, brands must engage in ongoing conversation rather than one-way communication. Data visualization and analytics are also transforming storytelling, making complex information accessible through visual narratives. The data scientist of the future will combine statistical expertise with storytelling skills to extract meaningful insights from mountains of information. The most powerful stories connect facts with emotion, creating narratives that inspire both understanding and action. As leaders face increasingly complex challenges, storytelling may become the most essential leadership competency of the 21st century - the key to navigating through uncertainty while maintaining trust, purpose, and alignment.

Summary

Throughout our exploration of the soft edge - those intangible qualities that give great companies lasting advantage - we've seen how the five pillars of trust, smarts, teams, taste, and story create a foundation for sustained excellence. From Northwestern Mutual's culture of trust that delivers $25 billion in annual revenue to Mayo Clinic's relentless pursuit of learning in the face of knowledge explosion; from FedEx's small, focused teams navigating global complexity to Specialized and Nest creating products that evoke emotional connection; from Cirrus Aircraft's customer-driven safety narratives to the power of purpose-driven storytelling - these elements work together to form what Karlgaard calls "the sweet spot of high performance." What makes this sweet spot so powerful is that while strategy can be copied and hard-edge execution advantages inevitably erode, the soft edge creates sustainable differentiation. Formula One racing offers a perfect metaphor - as Sauber Motorsports CEO Monisha Kaltenborn explains, success requires finding balance between hard data and human intuition: "You have to trust the driver, get the most detailed explanation of the problem that you can get from him, even though he's under stress circling the track at two hundred miles per hour. Then you work with the team to find a deeper level of data." This dance between human truth and data truth is the essence of long-term excellence. As technology and competition constantly raise the performance bar, the ancient values of trust and grit, teamwork and taste, and authentic storytelling become not less important but more essential. The companies that master this delicate balance are the ones that will continue to innovate and thrive through whatever disruptions lie ahead.

About Author

Loading...

Rich Karlgaard

Read more

Related Books by Rich Karlgaard

Loading...

Late Bloomers

Rich Karlgaard

The Power of Patience in a World Obsessed with Early Achievement

★★★★☆4.0

Loading...

Team Genius

Rich Karlgaard

The New Science of High-Performing Organizations

★★★☆☆3.4