The Volunteer

The Volunteer Plot Summary

Introduction

In the darkest chapter of human history, one man voluntarily walked into hell. September 1940: as Nazi Germany tightened its grip on occupied Poland, cavalry officer Witold Pilecki made an extraordinary decision that defies comprehension - he deliberately got himself arrested and sent to Auschwitz. His mission was unprecedented: infiltrate the notorious concentration camp, gather intelligence on Nazi atrocities, build a resistance network among prisoners, and alert the world to what would become the epicenter of the Holocaust. What followed was one of the most remarkable acts of courage in World War II, a story that remained largely unknown for decades. Through Pilecki's journey, we confront haunting questions about moral courage, the world's response to genocide, and the politics of historical memory. How could one man maintain his humanity in a place designed to destroy it? Why did Allied powers, despite receiving detailed reports about mass murder, fail to take direct action against Auschwitz? And how did Cold War politics lead to the persecution and erasure of a hero who should have been celebrated? This account illuminates not just the mechanics of Nazi genocide but also the complex moral choices faced by individuals and nations confronting unprecedented evil - essential reading for anyone seeking to understand both the depths of human cruelty and the heights of human courage.

Chapter 1: Voluntary Imprisonment: Pilecki's Infiltration of Auschwitz (1940)

The summer of 1940 marked a grim turning point in occupied Poland. After the swift defeat of Polish forces in September 1939, the Nazi occupation had established a brutal new order. Polish intellectuals, military officers, and political leaders were being systematically arrested and sent to a new concentration camp established near the town of Oświęcim, which the Germans renamed Auschwitz. Reports filtering back through the underground resistance suggested something terrible was happening there, but reliable information was scarce. The Polish resistance needed someone on the inside. In a Warsaw apartment in August 1940, cavalry officer Witold Pilecki proposed something unprecedented - he would deliberately get himself arrested and sent to Auschwitz to gather intelligence and organize resistance from within. At 39, Pilecki was a decorated veteran, gentleman farmer, and devoted family man with a wife and two young children. His superiors in the underground were initially skeptical of this seemingly suicidal mission, but Pilecki insisted. On September 19, during a German roundup in Warsaw's Żoliborz district, he stepped forward deliberately, carrying false identification papers under the name Tomasz Serafiński to protect his family. The reality of Auschwitz exceeded even the worst expectations. After a brutal journey in sealed cattle cars, Pilecki arrived at the camp on September 21, becoming prisoner number 4859. New arrivals were beaten, stripped, shaved, and issued thin striped uniforms wholly inadequate for the approaching winter. Deputy Commandant Karl Fritzsch addressed them with chilling clarity: "Your Poland is dead forever. The chimney of the crematorium is your only way to freedom." The camp operated on systematic terror - arbitrary executions, starvation rations of about 1,300 calories daily, and exhausting labor. Prisoners who collapsed from weakness were beaten to death or shot. Despite these horrific conditions, Pilecki immediately began his mission. He carefully observed camp operations while enduring the same privations as other prisoners. Within weeks, he identified potential recruits for his resistance network, focusing on military officers, professionals, and men who demonstrated moral strength even in dehumanizing conditions. By December 1940, he had established the first cells of an underground organization he called the Union of Military Organization (ZOW). The network expanded cautiously, using a cell structure where each member knew only a few others, protecting the organization if someone broke under torture. The infiltration of Auschwitz represented an unprecedented act of voluntary sacrifice. While most prisoners focused solely on survival, Pilecki deliberately entered this hell to serve as witness and organizer. His early reports, smuggled out through released prisoners, provided the first reliable accounts of conditions inside the camp. These reports reached the Polish government-in-exile in London by early 1941, becoming some of the earliest verified intelligence about Nazi concentration camps to reach Western Allies. Though the full horror of Auschwitz was still evolving - its transformation into a death factory would accelerate in 1942 - Pilecki had established a critical foothold for resistance and documentation that would prove invaluable as the Holocaust unfolded. Pilecki's infiltration demonstrated that even in the most extreme circumstances, human agency and moral choice remained possible. As he later wrote: "I volunteered for Auschwitz to discover the truth and make it known to the world." This mission would test the limits of human endurance and reveal both the depths of Nazi evil and the world's complicated response to evidence of genocide. The volunteer had entered the camp, but the most difficult challenges still lay ahead.

Chapter 2: Building Resistance: The Underground Network (1940-1941)

By early 1941, Pilecki had established the foundations of what would become an extraordinary resistance network inside Auschwitz. Working methodically despite constant danger, he organized his underground structure around "fives" - cells of five men who knew each other but not members of other cells, a classic resistance technique to prevent mass exposure if one group was caught. Pilecki personally vetted each recruit, looking beyond their pre-war status to assess their character under the camp's brutal conditions. "Some slithered into a moral swamp," he observed in his reports, "while others chiseled themselves a character of finest crystal." The network expanded strategically across all sectors of the camp. Pilecki placed men in critical positions: the hospital, where Dr. Władysław Dering gained influence with SS doctors; the construction office, where surveyors could smuggle messages outside; the kitchens, where extra food could be diverted to the weakest prisoners; and the camp records office, where clerks could access vital information and sometimes alter documents to save lives. By spring 1941, the organization had grown to several hundred members. They established contact with the outside world through civilian workers and local Polish residents who left food packages containing hidden messages in fields where work details operated. A major breakthrough came when resistance members managed to steal radio parts from SS storerooms and workshops. Hidden beneath the floorboards of the camp hospital, a makeshift receiver allowed Pilecki's men to listen to BBC broadcasts and distribute news throughout the camp, providing crucial psychological support. "People were living on this news," recalled one prisoner. "From this we took fresh energy." The radio confirmed that Britain still stood against Germany, though the war news was often grim. Pilecki's network also began collecting evidence of Nazi crimes, meticulously documenting prisoner numbers and death rates encoded in the camp's registration system. The resistance network faced constant threats from within and without. The SS periodically executed prisoners suspected of underground activity, and informers were ever-present. When Pilecki discovered a Gestapo spy had infiltrated his organization, he arranged for the man to be eliminated - a harsh but necessary measure to protect hundreds of lives. The underground also fought against typhus epidemics by stealing medication from SS supplies and distributing it to the sickest prisoners. Most importantly, they created a system of mutual aid where stronger prisoners would help weaker ones through illness or despair, directly countering the Nazi strategy of turning prisoners against each other in the struggle for survival. By mid-1941, Auschwitz was expanding dramatically. SS-Reichsführer Heinrich Himmler visited in March to order an enlargement from 10,000 to 30,000 prisoners. Construction began on a massive new section called Birkenau (Auschwitz II) that would eventually become the center of the Holocaust. The underground adapted to these changes, extending its reach into new areas and continuing to smuggle information to the Polish resistance in Warsaw. Pilecki's first comprehensive report on camp conditions reached Warsaw in late 1940 through a released prisoner, and the Polish underground published details in its clandestine newspaper, providing the first public account of Auschwitz. The resistance network's achievements by 1941 were remarkable given the impossible conditions. They had established a functioning organization, created communication channels with the outside world, documented Nazi crimes, and saved countless lives through mutual aid. Perhaps most importantly, they had preserved human dignity in a system designed to destroy it. As Pilecki instructed his men: "We are not allowed to break down mentally in any circumstances." This spiritual resistance - maintaining humanity in a place designed to eradicate it - was possibly their greatest achievement, creating a foundation for the even greater challenges that would come as Auschwitz transformed from a concentration camp into the epicenter of genocide.

Chapter 3: Documenting the Holocaust: First Evidence of Genocide (1941-1942)

The summer of 1941 marked a pivotal shift in Auschwitz's function, one that Pilecki's underground network was uniquely positioned to document. Following Germany's invasion of the Soviet Union in June, the first Soviet prisoners of war arrived at the camp. Pilecki observed a new level of brutality - these prisoners received no registration numbers and were worked to death or executed en masse. Through his network, Pilecki documented that of approximately 12,000 Soviet POWs sent to Auschwitz, barely 150 remained alive by early 1942. This systematic elimination foreshadowed what was to come. The most shocking development occurred in September 1941, when the SS conducted their first experimental gassing. Pilecki learned from hospital orderlies in his network that approximately 850 Soviet prisoners and sick Polish inmates had been locked in the basement cells of Block 11, where SS men in gas masks dropped crystals of Zyklon B, a commercial pesticide, through specially drilled holes. The victims' screams gradually subsided, and the next morning, prisoner workers found the dead "still standing, limbs locked together, eyes bulging, mouths gaping." Pilecki immediately recognized the significance of this new killing method and ensured this information reached Warsaw through released prisoners. By early 1942, the Nazis' genocidal intentions became unmistakable as Jewish transports began arriving from across Europe. Initially, some Jews were registered as camp inmates, but in May 1942, Pilecki witnessed a fundamental shift: entire Jewish families, including women, children, and the elderly, were marched directly to a converted farmhouse (known as the "little red house") without registration. Through his contacts in the Sonderkommando - prisoners forced to handle corpses - Pilecki learned these groups were being gassed using Zyklon B, then stripped of valuables before cremation. His underground documented how Auschwitz was transforming from a brutal prison into a death factory. The documentation efforts grew more sophisticated as the killing accelerated. Pilecki's men in the camp records office secretly copied the Stärkebuch (daily count book), which recorded arrivals, transfers, and deaths. By March 1942, they calculated that of 30,000 Poles registered in the camp, only 11,132 remained alive. Most critically, they documented that approximately 10,000 Jews had been gassed by May 1942, with the killing rate increasing rapidly as transports arrived from France, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Slovakia. The evidence was overwhelming: Auschwitz had become the epicenter of genocide. Pilecki struggled to comprehend the Nazis' motives for this unprecedented slaughter. Without knowledge of the Wannsee Conference of January 1942, where the "Final Solution" had been formalized, he initially theorized that the Soviets were killed due to overcrowding, and later that Jews were murdered for plunder. Yet he recognized that this evil surpassed anything previously witnessed. "We have strayed dreadfully," he wrote. "I would say that we have become animals... but no, we are a whole level of hell worse than animals." This moral clarity distinguished Pilecki's documentation - he recognized the unique character of the Holocaust even without understanding its full ideological underpinnings. The documentation of genocide created an urgent moral imperative for action. By summer 1942, Pilecki's reports explicitly requested Allied bombing of the camp to destroy the killing facilities and give prisoners a chance to escape during the chaos. "Bombard this camp!" implored one message. "The prisoners beg the Polish Government, for the love of God, to bombard these warehouses," stated another report. These pleas reflected Pilecki's growing realization that conventional victory might come too late for millions of European Jews. His documentation efforts had evolved from intelligence gathering to desperate attempts to halt genocide in progress - a moral witness that would prove crucial for posterity, even as it failed to provoke immediate intervention.

Chapter 4: Desperate Communications: Alerting the World (1942-1943)

As the scale of atrocities in Auschwitz escalated through 1942, Pilecki intensified his efforts to alert the outside world. The underground had established several communication channels with Warsaw, each fraught with danger. Released prisoners carried memorized reports, civilian workers smuggled written documents, and camp surveyors exchanged messages with local resistance members at drop points around the perimeter. These communications became increasingly urgent as Pilecki documented the industrialization of mass murder - the completion of four large crematorium-gas chamber complexes at Birkenau by early 1943, capable of killing and cremating up to 4,400 people daily. Pilecki's most ambitious communication project was constructing a secret radio transmitter. With help from engineering prisoners, he orchestrated the theft of radio parts from SS storerooms and workshops. The operation involved elaborate distractions and required precise timing to avoid detection. By spring 1942, they had assembled a rudimentary shortwave transmitter hidden in the hospital basement, capable of sending brief Morse code messages to the Polish underground. Though technical difficulties limited its effectiveness, the very existence of this transmitter demonstrated the extraordinary resourcefulness of Pilecki's network in the face of seemingly impossible odds. The underground also organized escapes specifically to deliver critical intelligence. In April 1942, Pilecki arranged for three men to escape from a farm detail at Harmęże. One carried detailed sketches of the camp layout and gas chambers. Their successful escape delivered vital evidence of the mass murder to Warsaw. In June 1942, another dramatic escape saw four prisoners, including Pilecki's courier Stanisław Jaster, steal SS uniforms and drive out through the main gate in a car belonging to the camp commandant. Jaster carried microfilm containing comprehensive documentation of the killing operations, which eventually reached London through the Polish underground. These communications became increasingly desperate as the Holocaust accelerated. Pilecki's reports documented the arrival of Jewish transports from across Europe and the selections that sent most directly to gas chambers. He emphasized that women, children, and the elderly were being murdered immediately upon arrival, while the young and strong were worked to death. By July 1942, his underground had compiled figures showing approximately 35,000 Jews had been gassed in just two months, with transports arriving daily. The reports explicitly requested Allied bombing of the gas chambers and crematoria, arguing that destroying these facilities would save countless lives even if some prisoners died in the raids. The most significant communication opportunity came when Jan Karski, a courier for the Polish government-in-exile, gathered evidence near Auschwitz in 1942. Local resistance members connected Karski with Pilecki's underground, providing him with detailed reports on camp mortality statistics, the gas chambers, and mass cremations. Karski was shocked by the scale of killing and recognized he possessed a major Nazi secret: Auschwitz had become the epicenter of the European-wide extermination of Jews. He eventually reached Washington, where he personally briefed President Roosevelt about the Holocaust in July 1943, drawing partly on Pilecki's documentation. Despite these desperate efforts to communicate the truth, Pilecki grew increasingly frustrated by the lack of response. His reports reached London through multiple channels and were transmitted to Allied governments. Yet the requested bombing raids never materialized. Allied officials cited various reasons - the extreme distance for bombers, the risk to prisoners, the priority of military targets. Some historians suggest more troubling factors played a role: antisemitism among decision-makers, bureaucratic compartmentalization, or simply the inability to comprehend genocide of such magnitude. As transports continued arriving and the crematorium chimneys belched smoke day and night, Pilecki confronted a devastating possibility - that even irrefutable evidence of genocide might not spur the world to direct intervention.

Chapter 5: Escape and Testimony: The Fight for Recognition (1943-1944)

After nearly three years in Auschwitz, Pilecki made the difficult decision to escape. By spring 1943, his position had become increasingly precarious. The Gestapo was closing in on the resistance network, and several key members had been caught and executed. More importantly, Pilecki believed he could accomplish more by reporting directly to Warsaw and advocating personally for action against the camp. Working with two trusted colleagues, Edward Ciesielski and Jan Redzej, he meticulously planned their breakout from the camp bakery where they had secured work positions outside the main perimeter. On the night of April 26-27, 1943, the three men executed their daring plan. They cut through a back door, disabled the alarm, and slipped away during the night shift. They crossed the Soła River and trekked through forests and villages, evading German patrols. The physical toll of nearly three years in Auschwitz was evident - Pilecki had lost nearly half his body weight and suffered from numerous ailments. Yet after a harrowing journey, they reached Warsaw, where Pilecki immediately prepared a comprehensive report on Auschwitz. This 100-page document, later known as "Witold's Report," provided the most detailed account of the camp's operations and the Holocaust to date, including precise descriptions of the gas chambers, crematoria, and selection process. Pilecki's escape coincided with a critical turning point in the war. The German defeat at Stalingrad in February 1943 had shifted momentum toward the Allies. Yet even as military prospects improved, Pilecki was dismayed to find that his previous reports had failed to provoke meaningful action. The Polish underground had transmitted his intelligence to London, but the Allies remained focused on conventional military objectives rather than humanitarian intervention at Auschwitz. In Warsaw, Pilecki continued advocating for a coordinated attack on the camp. He proposed that Allied bombers target the gas chambers and crematoria while Polish paratroopers landed to arm the prisoners for an uprising. His plan received serious consideration from the Polish Home Army but was ultimately rejected as militarily unfeasible without Allied support. Meanwhile, the killing at Auschwitz reached its peak intensity in 1944, with over 400,000 Hungarian Jews murdered in just a few months. During this period, Allied bombers were actually flying missions near Auschwitz, striking industrial targets like the I.G. Farben factory just five miles from the gas chambers. These raids demonstrated that bombing the killing facilities was technically possible, making the decision not to target them all the more controversial among historians. Pilecki's testimony gained additional support in April 1944 when two Slovak Jewish prisoners, Rudolf Vrba and Alfred Wetzler, escaped from Auschwitz carrying detailed information about the camp's operations. Their report, combined with Pilecki's earlier documentation, formed what became known as the "Auschwitz Protocols" - the definitive Allied intelligence on the death camp. These documents circulated among Allied leaders and Jewish organizations, finally prompting some diplomatic responses. By summer 1944, pressure from Jewish organizations and the War Refugee Board led President Roosevelt to warn Hungary about continuing deportations, while Swedish diplomat Raoul Wallenberg began his heroic efforts to save Budapest's remaining Jews. Throughout this period, Pilecki continued his resistance activities in Warsaw. When the Warsaw Uprising erupted in August 1944, he fought as a company commander, displaying the same courage that had characterized his Auschwitz mission. After the uprising's brutal suppression, he was captured and sent to a German POW camp. Meanwhile, as Soviet forces approached Auschwitz in January 1945, the SS began evacuating prisoners on death marches westward and dismantling the killing facilities to hide evidence of genocide. When the camp was liberated on January 27, 1945, only about 7,000 prisoners remained alive to greet Soviet troops. The full horror of what had occurred at Auschwitz would gradually emerge during the Nuremberg Trials, with Pilecki's documentation providing crucial evidence of the camp's evolution from concentration camp to death factory.

Chapter 6: Betrayal and Legacy: From Hero to Martyr (1945-1948)

The end of World War II brought no peace for Witold Pilecki. After being liberated from a German POW camp in April 1945, he faced a critical decision as Poland fell under Soviet domination. While many Polish officers chose exile in the West, Pilecki made the fateful choice to return to his homeland, now controlled by a Communist regime backed by Stalin. Despite warnings from colleagues, he volunteered for a dangerous mission to gather intelligence on Soviet atrocities and the systematic elimination of democratic opposition. Using false identity papers, he returned to Warsaw in December 1945, entering a city transformed by war, with over 85% of its buildings in ruins. In Soviet-controlled Poland, Pilecki's wartime resistance credentials made him both a potential symbol and a threat. The new regime was rapidly consolidating power, arresting former Home Army members and anyone connected to the London-based government-in-exile. Pilecki established a small intelligence network to document these abuses, sending reports to Polish military authorities in the West. He was particularly concerned with preserving the truth about Poland's wartime struggle, as the Communist government began rewriting history to minimize the role of non-Communist resistance fighters and emphasize Soviet "liberation." On May 8, 1947, Pilecki was arrested by the UB, Poland's Communist security service. What followed was a brutal interrogation lasting several months, during which he was subjected to sophisticated torture methods. Despite this treatment, he maintained remarkable dignity and refused to implicate others in his network. In March 1948, he was put on trial for espionage and "planning to assassinate Polish officials." The proceedings were a mockery of justice - evidence was fabricated, witnesses were intimidated, and the outcome was predetermined. Most perversely, his Auschwitz mission was deliberately erased from the record, as it contradicted the regime's narrative about resistance in the camp. On May 25, 1948, Witold Pilecki was executed by gunshot to the back of the head in Warsaw's Mokotów Prison. His final words were reported to be: "Long live free Poland." The Communist authorities buried his body in an unmarked grave, likely in a garbage dump used for disposing of political prisoners. His final resting place remains unknown to this day. The regime then set about erasing Pilecki from history - his name was forbidden in publications, his reports were sealed in secret archives, and his family was subjected to harassment and discrimination for decades. The silencing of Pilecki's story was tragically effective. For decades, his extraordinary courage remained largely unknown outside a small circle of Polish émigrés. His Auschwitz reports, which constituted some of the earliest and most comprehensive documentation of the Holocaust, were suppressed. In Communist-era textbooks, the Auschwitz resistance was attributed exclusively to Communist prisoners, while Pilecki's name was never mentioned. His family preserved his memory in private, unable to publicly honor him or even acknowledge the true circumstances of his death. It wasn't until the collapse of Communism in 1989 that Pilecki's legacy began to emerge from the shadows. The opening of archives revealed the full extent of his achievements and the shameful treatment he received at the hands of the postwar regime. In 1990, he was posthumously exonerated of all charges, and in subsequent years, he has received Poland's highest decorations. His complete Auschwitz report was finally published in English in 2012, seventy years after he wrote it. Today, Pilecki is increasingly recognized internationally as one of the greatest heroes of World War II - a man who voluntarily entered hell to bear witness to the unimaginable, only to be betrayed by the postwar settlement that sacrificed Eastern Europe to Soviet domination. Pilecki's journey from volunteer prisoner to executed hero encapsulates the tragic complexity of 20th-century European history. His story challenges us to consider not just the horrors of the Holocaust but also the moral compromises of the Cold War era that allowed his sacrifice to be forgotten. As historian Timothy Snyder observed, Pilecki was "a man who volunteered to be imprisoned in Auschwitz, and then volunteered to remain there, all in service of the values that Hitler sought to destroy." His legacy stands as a testament to the power of moral witness against the twin totalitarianisms that devastated Europe - and to the human capacity for extraordinary courage in the darkest of times.

Summary

The story of Witold Pilecki illuminates the central moral paradox of the Holocaust: while one man voluntarily entered Auschwitz and risked everything to document genocide, the world's response to his evidence remained tragically inadequate. Pilecki's journey traces the evolution of Nazi extermination policies from their early implementation to industrial-scale murder, providing a unique chronological witness to the Holocaust's development. His meticulous documentation efforts, transmitted through an underground network he built from nothing, created an unprecedented real-time record of genocide that reached Allied governments while there was still time to act. Yet his increasingly desperate pleas for military intervention - bombing the gas chambers, supporting a prisoner uprising - went unheeded as Allied leaders prioritized conventional warfare over humanitarian rescue. This disconnect between knowledge and action challenges comfortable post-war narratives about the Holocaust being discovered only after it was too late to intervene. Pilecki's legacy offers profound lessons for our contemporary world, where genocide and mass atrocities continue to challenge international response. First, his example demonstrates that moral witness matters even when immediate intervention fails - his documentation ensured the truth could not be denied, providing crucial evidence for postwar justice and historical understanding. Second, his story highlights how bureaucratic compartmentalization, political calculations, and simple failure of imagination can prevent effective response to atrocities even when evidence is abundant. Finally, his postwar persecution reminds us that historical memory itself is political - his Communist executioners understood that controlling the narrative about Auschwitz meant erasing its most powerful witness. In an era of rising authoritarianism and historical revisionism, Pilecki's courage challenges us to recognize that bearing witness to truth, preserving accurate historical memory, and acting on moral knowledge are interconnected responsibilities that no society can abandon without grave consequences.

About Author

Loading...

Jack Fairweather

Jack Fairweather has been a correspondent for the Washington Post and the Daily Telegraph, where he served as the Baghdad and Persian Gulf bureau chief. His reporting during the Iraq War earned him Britain’s top press award. The author of A War of Choice and The Good War, he lives in Charlotte, Vermont.

Read more