Vanguard

Vanguard Plot Summary

Introduction

In 1851, at a women's rights convention in Akron, Ohio, Sojourner Truth rose to speak amid a hostile audience. When white ministers argued that women were too fragile for political rights, Truth reportedly responded with her famous "Ain't I a Woman?" speech, challenging both racial and gender stereotypes with her powerful presence. This moment exemplifies how Black women throughout American history have navigated the double barriers of racism and sexism while fighting for full citizenship rights. Their political activism has consistently addressed multiple forms of oppression simultaneously, developing sophisticated strategies that white-led movements often failed to imagine. The story of Black women's political resilience reveals a different narrative of American democracy—one where rights were never simply granted but persistently claimed through organized resistance, intellectual innovation, and community building. From Maria Stewart's groundbreaking public lectures in the 1830s to Fannie Lou Hamer's testimony before the Democratic National Convention in 1964, Black women developed distinctive political theories and practices that transformed American politics. This historical journey offers crucial insights for anyone seeking to understand how marginalized groups build power against overwhelming odds, how social movements sustain themselves across generations, and how democracy expands through the persistent demands of those initially excluded from its promises.

Chapter 1: Early Voices: Breaking Barriers in Public Discourse (1820s-1850s)

The early 19th century was a time of profound contradiction in America. While the young nation celebrated its democratic ideals, millions remained enslaved, and free Black Americans faced severe restrictions on their rights. Yet even in this hostile environment, a remarkable group of Black women began to claim public space and voice their demands for freedom and equality. Maria Stewart emerged as a pioneering voice in 1832 when she delivered public lectures in Boston addressing mixed audiences of men and women—becoming the first American woman to do so. Stewart boldly declared: "O ye daughters of Africa, awake! Awake! Arise! No longer sleep nor slumber, but distinguish yourselves." Her speeches connected the oppression of African Americans to broader political and economic systems, making her America's first Black woman political theorist. Though her public speaking career lasted only three years due to fierce opposition, Stewart established a template for Black women's political discourse that combined religious language with radical demands for justice. In Philadelphia, Sarah Mapps Douglass founded the Female Literary Association in 1831, creating a space where Black women could develop their intellectual and political voices. Through reading, writing, and discussion, these women analyzed the conditions affecting their communities and developed strategies for resistance. Douglass herself wrote for abolitionist newspapers under the pen name "Zillah," addressing political matters like restrictive Black laws. The association demonstrated how Black women created alternative political spaces when excluded from formal politics, understanding that education was essential for political empowerment. Sojourner Truth, born enslaved as Isabella Baumfree, became one of the most famous orators of the era after gaining her freedom. Her 1851 "Ain't I a Woman?" speech at the Women's Rights Convention in Akron, Ohio challenged both racial and gender stereotypes. When white ministers argued that women were too fragile for political rights, Truth reportedly bared her muscular arm and referenced her years of hard labor, declaring: "I have plowed and planted, and gathered into barns, and no man could head me—and ain't I a woman?" Her intervention demonstrated how Black women's experiences contradicted prevailing gender ideologies and how their political consciousness addressed both racism and sexism simultaneously. The public presence of Black women provoked hostile reactions, including visual attacks. Edward Clay's popular lithograph series "Life in Philadelphia" caricatured Black women who participated in middle-class social activities, portraying them as ridiculous imitators of white customs. These demeaning images circulated widely, appearing in newspapers, books, and even on wallpaper. In response, women like Jarena Lee commissioned dignified portraits that emphasized their intellect and authority, understanding that visual representation was itself a political battleground. By the 1850s, these pioneering women had established important precedents that would influence generations to come. They demonstrated that Black women could be effective public speakers, writers, and organizational leaders despite overwhelming opposition. They developed distinctive arguments about freedom that encompassed both racial and gender equality. Most importantly, they refused to accept the narrow boundaries that society attempted to impose on them, creating a foundation for what would become a powerful political tradition characterized by intellectual courage and moral clarity.

Chapter 2: Dual Struggles: Race and Gender During Reconstruction (1865-1890)

The period following the Civil War presented unprecedented opportunities for Black Americans to participate in political life. The Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery in 1865, the Fourteenth Amendment granted citizenship to all persons born in the United States in 1868, and the Fifteenth Amendment prohibited denying voting rights based on race in 1870. This constitutional revolution created openings for Black Americans to claim political rights, though the Fifteenth Amendment's protection extended only to Black men, not women. Frances Ellen Watkins Harper emerged as one of the most influential voices of this era. Born free in Baltimore, Harper became a renowned poet and lecturer on the antislavery circuit. At the 1866 American Equal Rights Association meeting in New York, she delivered a pivotal address that challenged white suffragists to consider the intersecting oppressions faced by Black women. "You white women speak of rights," she declared, "I speak of wrongs." Harper insisted that Black women faced unique challenges that could not be reduced to either race or gender alone. Her speech highlighted the tensions that would soon fracture the fragile alliance between women's rights advocates and abolitionists. The debate over the Fifteenth Amendment revealed deep divisions within the women's rights movement. Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony opposed the amendment because it did not include women, with Stanton employing racist rhetoric about the dangers of giving "ignorant" Black men the vote while excluding educated white women. This betrayal forced Black women to develop independent political strategies that addressed both racism and sexism. Harper, along with many Black women activists, supported the amendment while continuing to advocate for women's suffrage, understanding that racial solidarity was essential in the face of growing white supremacist violence. Mary Ann Shadd Cary exemplified the political versatility required of Black women during this period. Born free in Delaware, Cary had fled to Canada after the passage of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, where she established herself as North America's first Black woman newspaper editor. Returning to the United States after the Civil War, Cary pursued legal education at Howard University and became a pioneering advocate for women's suffrage. In 1871, she led a group of 63 women who attempted to register to vote in Washington, DC, arguing that the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments, combined with local law, permitted women's suffrage. Though unsuccessful, this action demonstrated Black women's determination to claim political rights through creative legal strategies. The end of Reconstruction in 1877 brought devastating setbacks as white supremacist regimes regained control across the South. The Supreme Court's decision in Hall v. DeCuir (1877) struck down Louisiana's anti-segregation law, paving the way for the expansion of Jim Crow segregation. Black women faced increasing restrictions not only as voters but in public accommodations, with "ladies' cars" on trains becoming sites of humiliation where their womanhood was denied. Frances Ellen Watkins Harper described being ordered out of a ladies' car in 1858: "I did not move, but kept the same seat. When I was about to leave, he refused my money, and I threw it down on the car floor, and got out." Despite these setbacks, Black women continued to build political power through churches, mutual aid societies, and women's clubs. They developed a politics of respectability that emphasized education, moral character, and community service as paths to collective advancement. Women like Eliza Gardner in the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church pushed for women's ordination, understanding religious authority as a form of political power. By the 1880s, Black women had established a foundation for the organized political activism that would characterize the coming decades, demonstrating remarkable resilience in the face of betrayal and backlash.

Chapter 3: Building Power: The Black Women's Club Movement (1890-1920)

The 1890s marked a critical turning point for Black women's political organizing as they faced intensifying racial violence and segregation. Lynching became a terrifying tool of racial control, with over 2,500 Black Americans murdered by white mobs between 1882 and 1930. Simultaneously, Jim Crow laws formalized segregation across the South, while northern cities practiced de facto segregation. In response, Black women developed new organizational strategies centered on the club movement, creating a national infrastructure for political action. Ida B. Wells emerged as a fearless leader in the fight against lynching after three of her friends were murdered by a white mob in Memphis in 1892. Wells, a newspaper editor and co-owner of the Free Speech and Headlight, launched an international anti-lynching campaign that exposed the lie that lynching protected white women from Black male assault. Her meticulous documentation revealed that lynching functioned as economic and political terrorism aimed at maintaining white supremacy. After death threats forced her to leave Memphis, Wells continued her activism from Chicago, where she founded the Alpha Suffrage Club in 1913, the first Black women's suffrage organization in Illinois. The National Association of Colored Women (NACW) formed in 1896 under the leadership of Mary Church Terrell, uniting local Black women's clubs across the country under the motto "Lifting as We Climb." This federation brought together approximately 5,000 middle-class Black women committed to racial uplift through education, social services, and political advocacy. Terrell, educated at Oberlin College and fluent in several languages, embodied the NACW's emphasis on education and respectability while using her platform to condemn racism and sexism. The organization established kindergartens, homes for the elderly, health clinics, and settlement houses, addressing community needs while developing women's leadership skills. Anna Julia Cooper provided the intellectual framework for Black women's politics in her 1892 book "A Voice from the South." Cooper argued that Black women occupied a unique position that gave them insight into multiple forms of oppression: "Only the BLACK WOMAN can say when and where I enter, in the quiet, undisputed dignity of my womanhood, without violence and without suing or special patronage, then and there the whole Negro race enters with me." This intersectional analysis anticipated by nearly a century the theoretical frameworks that would later be formalized by Black feminist scholars. Cooper's work demonstrated how Black women's lived experiences generated sophisticated political theories that addressed the interconnections between race, gender, and class. The club movement created parallel institutions when Black women were excluded from white-led organizations. When the General Federation of Women's Clubs refused to admit Black women's clubs in 1900, Josephine St. Pierre Ruffin responded by strengthening independent Black women's organizations. She declared: "We are not drawing the color line; we are women, American women, as intensely interested in all that pertains to us as such as all other American women." This stance reflected Black women's commitment to universal principles of justice while recognizing the necessity of autonomous organizing in the face of exclusion. As the suffrage movement gained momentum in the early 20th century, Black women navigated complex relationships with white suffragists. When Alice Paul organized the 1913 women's suffrage parade in Washington, DC, she initially asked Black women to march in a segregated section. Ida B. Wells refused, joining the Illinois delegation instead. Mary Church Terrell participated despite such tensions, understanding that Black women needed to be visible in the movement. Through these organizations and strategic alliances, Black women built collective power that would sustain their political activism through the difficult decades ahead, demonstrating remarkable organizational sophistication and ideological clarity in the face of both racism and sexism.

Chapter 4: Hollow Victory: The Nineteenth Amendment's Limitations (1920-1940)

The ratification of the Nineteenth Amendment in August 1920 represented a significant but deeply uneven victory for women's suffrage. While the amendment declared that voting rights "shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex," its implementation revealed the limitations of constitutional guarantees in a nation structured by racial hierarchy. For white women, the amendment brought immediate access to the ballot box, but for Black women, especially in the South, the promise of suffrage remained largely unfulfilled. Black women approached the 1920 election with both determination and strategic preparation. In Savannah, Georgia, the Woman's Suffrage Club of Chatham County organized voter education programs and staged a "mock registration" to prepare women for the process. In St. Louis, Missouri, Black women formed a "Citizenship League" and ran suffrage schools where women and men readied themselves to face the scrutiny of local officials. These efforts reflected Black women's understanding that constitutional rights alone would not guarantee access to the ballot box. When registration opened in fall 1920, Black women throughout the South presented themselves to local officials, often with mixed results. In Richmond, Virginia, Maggie Lena Walker, the first Black woman to found a bank, led hundreds of women to the registrar's office. They were segregated and directed to the building's basement, where many waited for hours only to be told to return another day. In Staunton, Virginia, Black women outnumbered white women eighteen to one at registration on one particular day, which the local newspaper noted "came as a surprise to Democrats." In Alabama, however, officials simply refused to register Black women, leading them to organize through the AME Zion Church and appeal to the United States attorney. The barriers to voting were formidable. Poll taxes, literacy tests, and "understanding clauses" that required voters to interpret complex constitutional provisions were applied more stringently to Black applicants than to whites. In Mississippi, lawmakers changed poll tax requirements specifically to prevent Black women from registering. In Georgia, officials ruled that women could not vote in the 1920 election because state law required registration six months before an election—a requirement that could not be met since the Nineteenth Amendment had been ratified less than three months before Election Day. Charlotte Hawkins Brown, a prominent educator in North Carolina, experienced firsthand the political risks that Black women faced when they sought to exercise their new rights. In fall 1920, she was falsely accused of authoring a circular that urged Black women to register and vote while white women "sleep." The controversy threatened her school, the Palmer Memorial Institute, and forced Brown to publicly distance herself from voting rights activism to protect her institution and her reputation. Her experience illustrated how economic vulnerability compounded political disenfranchisement for Black women, who often depended on white patronage for their educational and charitable institutions. The aftermath of the Nineteenth Amendment also revealed deep fissures within the women's movement. White suffrage organizations like the National American Woman Suffrage Association transformed into the League of Women Voters, declaring their work complete despite the ongoing disenfranchisement of Black women. Alice Paul's National Woman's Party focused exclusively on an Equal Rights Amendment, rejecting appeals from Black women leaders like Hallie Quinn Brown to address racial barriers to voting. This abandonment forced Black women to carry forward the fight for universal suffrage largely on their own, continuing a pattern of betrayal that had characterized the relationship between white and Black women's movements since Reconstruction.

Chapter 5: New Pathways: Black Women in National Politics (1940-1960)

The period from 1940 to 1960 witnessed a significant transformation in Black women's political engagement as they navigated the opportunities and constraints of the New Deal era and the early civil rights movement. World War II created new economic opportunities while exposing the contradictions of fighting fascism abroad while maintaining segregation at home. The "Double V" campaign – victory over fascism abroad and racism at home – articulated by the Pittsburgh Courier became a rallying cry that resonated with Black women's dual consciousness of race and gender oppression. Mary McLeod Bethune emerged as the most influential Black woman in national politics during this period. Born to formerly enslaved parents in South Carolina in 1875, Bethune founded Bethune-Cookman College and organized Black women voters in Florida before being appointed to President Franklin Roosevelt's "Black Cabinet" in 1936. As Director of Negro Affairs in the National Youth Administration, she became the highest-ranking Black woman in the federal government. In 1935, Bethune founded the National Council of Negro Women (NCNW), which united existing Black women's organizations into a powerful coalition focused on civil rights, economic justice, and international affairs. Bethune's close relationship with First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt created unprecedented access to the White House for Black women leaders. When the NCNW held its 1940 conference in Washington, DC, Roosevelt hosted the delegates at the White House, where Frances Williams presented the organization's agenda. This meeting symbolized a new level of recognition for Black women's political leadership, though it did not translate into full inclusion in the benefits of New Deal programs, many of which excluded agricultural and domestic workers – occupations dominated by Black women. Bethune's strategy combined insider access with continued grassroots organizing, recognizing that formal political power needed to be complemented by community mobilization. Pauli Murray developed a groundbreaking analysis of what she termed "Jane Crow" – the specific discrimination faced by Black women at the intersection of racism and sexism. As a law student at Howard University in the early 1940s, Murray organized sit-ins at segregated restaurants in Washington, DC, and developed legal theories that would later influence both civil rights and feminist jurisprudence. Murray's 1950 book "States' Laws on Race and Color" became an essential resource for civil rights attorneys, while her concept of Jane Crow anticipated by decades the intersectional analyses that would later transform feminist theory. Her work demonstrated how Black women's lived experiences generated sophisticated legal and political theories that addressed multiple forms of discrimination simultaneously. The 1954 Brown v. Board of Education decision, which declared segregated schools unconstitutional, marked a turning point in the civil rights movement. Black women like Septima Clark developed citizenship schools that taught literacy and voting rights, preparing communities for the intensified struggle ahead. Clark, who had been fired from her teaching position in Charleston, South Carolina, for her NAACP membership, established an educational program on Johns Island that combined literacy instruction with political education. Her work demonstrated how Black women transformed educational spaces into sites of political mobilization, recognizing that access to the ballot required both legal rights and practical skills. By the late 1950s, Black women were making historic breakthroughs in elected and appointed positions. Jane Bolin became the first Black woman judge in the nation when she was appointed to New York City's Domestic Relations Court in 1939. Crystal Bird Fauset became the first Black woman elected to a state legislature when Pennsylvania voters sent her to the state house in 1938. These "firsts" represented important symbolic victories, but they also gave Black women direct influence over policy decisions affecting their communities. As the civil rights movement gained momentum, Black women's decades of organizing provided essential infrastructure, leadership training, and political analyses that would sustain the movement through the challenges of the 1960s.

Chapter 6: Voting Rights Revolution: From Protest to Electoral Power (1960-1975)

The early 1960s marked a dramatic escalation in the struggle for voting rights as Black Americans confronted the entrenched systems of disenfranchisement that had persisted despite constitutional amendments. In 1964, only 6.7 percent of eligible Black voters in Mississippi were registered, a statistic that revealed the gap between legal rights and political reality. Black women played crucial roles in the campaigns that would ultimately lead to the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, one of the most significant pieces of civil rights legislation in American history. Diane Nash emerged as a key strategist in the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC), organizing sit-ins in Nashville and coordinating the Freedom Rides when they were threatened with violence. After the 1963 bombing of Birmingham's 16th Street Baptist Church killed four young girls, Nash and her husband James Bevel developed the Selma voting rights campaign. Nash's approach combined meticulous planning with principled nonviolence, creating what she called "a way for people to express themselves and make change." Her leadership in Selma helped create the conditions that led to the Voting Rights Act, demonstrating how Black women's strategic vision shaped the civil rights movement's most successful campaigns. Fannie Lou Hamer transformed from a Mississippi sharecropper to a national political figure through her voting rights activism. After being fired from her plantation job for attempting to register to vote in 1962, Hamer became a field secretary for SNCC. Her testimony before the Credentials Committee at the 1964 Democratic National Convention, describing the brutal beating she endured in a Mississippi jail, shocked the nation. "I'm sick and tired of being sick and tired," she declared, articulating the exhaustion and determination that fueled the movement. Hamer's Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party challenged the all-white Mississippi delegation, exposing the Democratic Party's complicity with segregation and forcing a national reckoning with the contradictions of American democracy. The Voting Rights Act, signed into law by President Lyndon Johnson on August 6, 1965, prohibited literacy tests and other discriminatory voting practices and authorized federal examiners to register voters in counties with histories of discrimination. Its impact was immediate and dramatic: within months, 250,000 new Black voters were registered across the South. By 1968, 59 percent of eligible Black voters in Mississippi were registered, compared to 6.7 percent in 1964. This transformation in the electorate laid the groundwork for the election of thousands of Black officials in subsequent decades, including Unita Blackwell, who had been jailed for her voting rights activism before becoming Mississippi's first Black woman mayor in 1976. The period following the Voting Rights Act saw significant increases in Black political representation, though progress was uneven. In 1968, Shirley Chisholm became the first Black woman elected to Congress, representing a district in Brooklyn, New York. Four years later, she launched a historic campaign for the Democratic presidential nomination, declaring herself "unbought and unbossed." Though her candidacy was unsuccessful, Chisholm broke important barriers and inspired future generations of Black women politicians. Her campaign slogan captured the independent spirit that had characterized Black women's politics since the nineteenth century—a commitment to principle over expediency and a refusal to be controlled by political machines. By the mid-1970s, Black women had emerged as a distinct and increasingly influential voting bloc. Organizations like the National Coalition of 100 Black Women and the National Political Congress of Black Women worked to increase Black women's political participation and representation. In 1973, the National Black Feminist Organization was founded to address issues at the intersection of racism and sexism, building on the insights that Black women activists had developed over generations. These organizations reflected Black women's continued commitment to autonomous organizing even as they gained greater access to mainstream political institutions, recognizing that formal representation needed to be complemented by grassroots mobilization to achieve substantive policy changes.

Chapter 7: The Continuing Struggle: Black Women's Political Leadership Today

The decades following the Voting Rights Act have witnessed both remarkable progress and persistent challenges in Black women's political representation. By the 1990s, Black women were voting at higher rates than any other demographic group, demonstrating their commitment to electoral politics as a tool for social change. Yet their representation in elected office remained disproportionately low, reflecting the continuing impact of both racism and sexism in American politics. This paradox—high participation but limited representation—has shaped Black women's political strategies in the contemporary era. Carol Moseley Braun made history in 1992 when she became the first Black woman elected to the United States Senate, representing Illinois. Her campaign mobilized an unprecedented coalition of Black voters, women, and progressives, demonstrating the potential of Black women candidates to build broad support. Yet Moseley Braun served only one term, losing her reelection bid in 1998 amid controversies that reflected the heightened scrutiny faced by pioneering Black women in politics. It would be twenty years before another Black woman, Kamala Harris, was elected to the Senate in 2016, highlighting the persistent barriers to Black women's representation in the nation's highest legislative body. The 2008 election of Barack Obama as the first Black president represented a historic milestone, but it did not end the struggle for full political equality. Black women voters played a crucial role in Obama's victory, with 96 percent supporting him in the general election. Yet Black women remained underrepresented in elected office at all levels of government. In response, organizations like Higher Heights for America and the Black Women's Roundtable worked specifically to increase Black women's political representation, providing training, funding, and support networks for candidates. These efforts reflected Black women's continued commitment to building independent political infrastructure while also working within mainstream political institutions. The 2018 midterm elections marked a significant breakthrough, with a record number of Black women running for and winning elected office. Ayanna Pressley became Massachusetts' first Black congresswoman, while Jahana Hayes achieved the same milestone in Connecticut. In Georgia, Stacey Abrams came within 55,000 votes of becoming the nation's first Black woman governor, despite well-documented voter suppression tactics. After her narrow defeat, Abrams founded Fair Fight Action to combat voter suppression and increase civic engagement, continuing the long tradition of Black women transforming electoral defeats into opportunities for movement building. The 2020 election of Kamala Harris as the first Black and South Asian woman vice president represented another historic first, building on generations of Black women's political organizing. Harris acknowledged this legacy in her victory speech, citing Fannie Lou Hamer, Mary Church Terrell, and other pioneers who had "paved the way for this moment." Her election demonstrated how Black women's persistent demands for inclusion had gradually transformed American politics, creating possibilities that would have been unimaginable to earlier generations of activists. Yet significant challenges remain. The Supreme Court's 2013 decision in Shelby County v. Holder struck down key provisions of the Voting Rights Act, leading to a new wave of restrictive voting laws that disproportionately affect Black voters. Black women leaders like LaTosha Brown, co-founder of Black Voters Matter, have responded by building grassroots organizing campaigns that combine voter education, mobilization, and legal advocacy. These efforts continue the tradition established by Septima Clark, Fannie Lou Hamer, and other voting rights pioneers, adapting their strategies to contemporary challenges while maintaining their commitment to full political participation as essential for democracy.

Summary

The two-hundred-year struggle of Black women for political rights reveals a consistent pattern: each advance in rights was met with new forms of exclusion that required innovative responses. From Maria Stewart's groundbreaking public lectures in the 1830s to Stacey Abrams's voting rights activism today, Black women have developed distinctive political theories and practices that address their unique position at the intersection of race and gender oppression. They created parallel institutions when excluded from white-led organizations, built coalitions across differences when strategic, and persistently claimed the rights of full citizenship despite repeated betrayals and setbacks. This history demonstrates how Black women have functioned as what Abrams calls "the resilient vanguard" of American democracy, often leading movements for universal rights rather than narrow self-interest. This legacy offers crucial insights for contemporary politics. First, constitutional amendments and landmark legislation provide essential tools but insufficient guarantees; rights require ongoing organization and vigilance to maintain. The gutting of the Voting Rights Act in 2013 and subsequent waves of voter suppression laws demonstrate how quickly hard-won rights can be eroded without constant defense. Second, the most effective political movements address intersecting forms of oppression rather than treating race, gender, and class as separate issues. Black women's political tradition has consistently recognized these interconnections, developing analyses and strategies that address multiple dimensions of inequality simultaneously. Finally, genuine democracy requires both representation and participation—not just diverse faces in positions of power but ongoing engagement from communities historically excluded from political decision-making. As LaTosha Brown observes, "We're not just fighting for a vote. We're fighting for power, for agency, for the capacity to determine our own futures." This vision of democracy as collective self-determination connects contemporary struggles to the long tradition of Black women's political resistance and vision.

About Author

Loading...

Martha S. Jones

Read more