We Were Eight Years in Power

We Were Eight Years in Power Plot Summary

Introduction

The story of race in America is etched into the very landscape of the nation—from plantation homes in the South to segregated neighborhoods in Northern cities, from Civil War battlefields to the streets where modern protests unfold. This journey through America's racial history reveals how deeply racial hierarchies have shaped the country's institutions and identity. The struggle for racial justice has been neither linear nor inevitable, but rather a series of advances and retreats, of promises made and broken, of hard-won progress and fierce backlash. Through examining key historical periods, we discover how racial inequality has been systematically created and maintained through deliberate policies rather than mere accident or cultural differences. We see how slavery's economic legacy continues to shape wealth distribution today, how housing discrimination created segregated cities that persist decades after such practices were outlawed, and how systems of control have evolved from explicit racial subjugation to more subtle but equally effective forms of exclusion. This exploration is essential for anyone seeking to understand not just America's past, but its present challenges—and what might be required to create a more equitable future.

Chapter 1: The Unfulfilled Promise: Civil War and Reconstruction (1861-1877)

The American Civil War erupted in 1861 after decades of mounting tensions over slavery's place in an expanding nation. While Northern rhetoric often emphasized preserving the Union, the Confederacy made no secret of its primary motivation—Confederate Vice President Alexander Stephens explicitly declared slavery the "cornerstone" of their new government. The conflict would become the bloodiest in American history, claiming over 750,000 lives before concluding in 1865 with Union victory. The war's aftermath brought unprecedented possibilities for racial justice. The Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery, while the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments established citizenship rights and male suffrage regardless of race. During the Reconstruction era that followed, Black Americans exercised political power in remarkable ways. Over 1,500 Black men held public office, including sixteen congressmen and two senators. Black communities established schools, churches, and businesses, laying foundations for economic independence and social advancement. This progress provoked a violent backlash from white Southerners determined to restore racial hierarchy. Paramilitary groups like the Ku Klux Klan terrorized Black communities and assassinated political leaders. Meanwhile, the federal government's commitment to protecting Black rights gradually waned. The Compromise of 1877, which resolved the disputed presidential election of 1876, effectively ended Reconstruction as federal troops withdrew from the South, leaving Black citizens vulnerable to intimidation and violence. What followed was the establishment of Jim Crow segregation—a comprehensive system of racial subjugation enforced through both law and violence. Voting rights were systematically stripped away through poll taxes, literacy tests, and outright intimidation. Segregation was imposed in public accommodations, housing, education, and employment. Lynching became a tool of racial control, with over 4,000 documented cases between 1877 and 1950, creating a climate of terror for Black communities. The unfulfilled promise of Reconstruction represents one of America's great historical tragedies. As W.E.B. Du Bois eloquently observed, "The slave went free; stood a brief moment in the sun; then moved back again toward slavery." This retreat from racial justice would shape American society for generations to come, establishing patterns of segregation and inequality that continue to influence American life today. The period demonstrates how racial progress in America has consistently been met with resistance and retrenchment—a pattern that would repeat throughout the nation's history.

Chapter 2: Structural Racism: Housing and Economic Discrimination (1930s-1960s)

The mid-20th century witnessed the transformation of racial inequality from explicit legal codes to structural barriers embedded in seemingly neutral policies. Following the Great Depression, the federal government launched unprecedented initiatives to rebuild the American economy and expand the middle class. However, these programs systematically excluded Black Americans or provided them with unequal benefits, creating structural disadvantages that would persist for generations. Housing discrimination became particularly consequential during this period. The Federal Housing Administration (FHA), established in 1934, revolutionized homeownership by guaranteeing mortgages with lower down payments and longer terms. However, the FHA explicitly practiced "redlining," drawing maps with red lines around predominantly Black neighborhoods and designating them as high-risk areas ineligible for federally backed mortgages. Simultaneously, new suburban developments often included restrictive covenants that legally prohibited selling homes to Black families. These policies created a massive transfer of wealth as white families built equity through homeownership while Black families remained largely confined to deteriorating rental properties. The GI Bill, which provided returning World War II veterans with college tuition, low-cost mortgages, and business loans, similarly failed Black veterans. While technically color-blind, its benefits were administered locally, allowing discrimination to flourish. In the South, Black veterans were routinely denied educational benefits or steered toward vocational training rather than college. Nationwide, they were frequently rejected for housing loans despite their service to the country. This differential access to education and housing created advantages for white Americans that would compound over generations. Urban renewal programs of the 1950s and 1960s further damaged Black communities. Often labeled "Negro removal" by critics like James Baldwin, these initiatives demolished established Black neighborhoods to make way for highways, public housing projects, or commercial developments. Families displaced by these projects frequently found themselves in segregated public housing with fewer economic opportunities and deteriorating conditions. Meanwhile, employment discrimination confined Black workers to the lowest-paying jobs with limited advancement opportunities, even as unions helped white workers secure middle-class wages and benefits. By the time civil rights legislation formally outlawed discrimination in the 1960s, these structural inequalities were deeply embedded in American society. The wealth gap, educational disparities, and residential segregation created during this period proved remarkably persistent. Even as legal barriers fell, the accumulated advantages and disadvantages continued to shape life outcomes along racial lines. This era demonstrates how racism evolved beyond explicit legal codes into institutional arrangements that could produce racially disparate outcomes without requiring individual prejudice—a more subtle but equally powerful form of racial hierarchy.

Chapter 3: From Civil Rights to Mass Incarceration (1960s-1990s)

The civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s achieved remarkable legal victories, dismantling the formal apparatus of Jim Crow segregation. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibited discrimination in public accommodations and employment, while the Voting Rights Act of 1965 restored ballot access for millions of Black Americans. These hard-won achievements represented the culmination of decades of organizing, protest, and sacrifice. Yet even as these legal barriers fell, new systems of racial control were already taking shape. The late 1960s and early 1970s saw rising concerns about crime and urban unrest, fueled partly by genuine increases in crime rates but amplified by media coverage that often portrayed criminality in racialized terms. Politicians responded with increasingly punitive approaches to law enforcement and criminal justice. President Nixon's declaration of a "War on Drugs" in 1971 set the stage, but it was during the Reagan administration in the 1980s that this war escalated dramatically, with harsh new sentencing laws for drug offenses. The crack cocaine epidemic that hit many urban communities in the mid-1980s became a focal point for these punitive policies. The 1986 Anti-Drug Abuse Act established a 100-to-1 sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine, despite their pharmacological similarity. Since crack was more prevalent in Black communities while powder cocaine was more common among white users, this disparity led to vastly different consequences for similar behavior based on race. A person caught with just five grams of crack received the same mandatory minimum sentence as someone with 500 grams of powder cocaine. The consequences were profound and far-reaching. Between 1970 and 2000, the American prison population increased more than fivefold, from about 300,000 to over 1.5 million people, with Black Americans incarcerated at nearly six times the rate of whites. This mass incarceration extended beyond prison walls through probation, parole, and the collateral consequences of conviction—including restrictions on voting, employment, housing, and education. Legal scholar Michelle Alexander has termed this system the "New Jim Crow," arguing that it functions as a comprehensive system of racial control comparable to its predecessors. The politics of crime and punishment became thoroughly bipartisan by the 1990s. The 1994 Crime Bill, signed by President Clinton, provided funding for 100,000 new police officers and billions for new prisons while expanding the federal death penalty and imposing longer sentences. Though crime rates began falling in the early 1990s—a trend that would continue for decades—the machinery of mass incarceration continued to grow, demonstrating how disconnected the system had become from its ostensible purpose of public safety. This transformation of the criminal justice system reveals how systems of racial control in America have evolved rather than disappeared. As legal scholar Reva Siegel has noted, this represents a pattern of "preservation through transformation," where the formal dismantling of one system of racial hierarchy gives rise to new mechanisms that serve similar functions but operate through different means. The challenge for contemporary reformers lies in recognizing and addressing these evolved forms of racial inequality.

Chapter 4: The Obama Paradox: Progress and Backlash (2008-2016)

The election of Barack Obama as America's first Black president in 2008 represented a watershed moment in the nation's history. His victory seemed to signal a new era of racial progress, with many Americans across racial lines celebrating what appeared to be a fulfillment of Martin Luther King Jr.'s dream. Obama's personal story—raised by a single white mother and his grandparents, educated at Columbia and Harvard, rising through community organizing and politics—embodied the American ideal of meritocracy and suggested that the country had entered what some optimistically called a "post-racial" era. Reality proved more complicated. Obama inherited a nation in economic crisis, with the 2008 financial collapse disproportionately affecting Black and Latino communities. The foreclosure crisis hit minority neighborhoods hardest, erasing decades of hard-won economic gains. While Obama's administration implemented policies like the Affordable Care Act that benefited many disadvantaged Americans, the economic recovery was uneven, with wealth inequality continuing to grow along racial lines. By the end of Obama's presidency, the Black-white wealth gap had reached record levels, with the median white family possessing nearly ten times the wealth of the median Black family. From the beginning, Obama faced unprecedented levels of political obstruction and racial animus. Republican Senate Leader Mitch McConnell famously declared that his primary goal was making Obama a one-term president. The Tea Party movement emerged ostensibly in response to economic policies but frequently featured racist imagery and rhetoric targeting the president. Conspiracy theories questioning Obama's citizenship gained traction, with future president Donald Trump becoming a leading proponent of this "birther" movement that sought to delegitimize the first Black president by casting him as foreign and un-American. The racial backlash extended beyond politics. During Obama's presidency, a series of high-profile killings of unarmed Black Americans—Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown, Eric Garner, Sandra Bland, and many others—sparked national outrage and gave rise to the Black Lives Matter movement. These incidents exposed the persistent reality of racial inequality in policing and criminal justice, contradicting the narrative of post-racial progress. When Obama spoke about these issues, even in measured terms, he was often criticized for "dividing the country" or taking sides against law enforcement. Obama's cautious approach to racial issues reflected the constraints facing a Black president in a majority-white nation. He typically avoided explicit discussions of racism in favor of universal policies, knowing that more direct engagement with racial inequality would trigger backlash. This caution frustrated some supporters who hoped for more aggressive action on racial justice, while still provoking fierce resistance from those threatened by his very presence in the White House. The Obama years thus revealed a fundamental paradox in American race relations: significant progress coexisting with entrenched inequality and resistance. His election demonstrated that many Americans could indeed look beyond race in the voting booth, yet the backlash against him revealed how threatening this progress was to others. This tension would ultimately set the stage for the 2016 election, where appeals to racial anxiety and nostalgia for an earlier America would prove politically powerful.

Chapter 5: The Economic Cost of Racial Injustice

The economic dimensions of racial inequality represent one of the most persistent and consequential aspects of America's racial hierarchy. From slavery through Jim Crow and into the present, systematic policies have transferred wealth from Black communities to white institutions and individuals, creating economic disparities that persist across generations. Understanding these economic mechanisms is essential for comprehending both the historical development of racial inequality and its contemporary manifestations. Slavery itself was fundamentally an economic system, one that generated enormous wealth through unpaid labor. Economists estimate that the value of this stolen labor would amount to trillions in today's currency. After emancipation, the promised "forty acres and a mule" that might have provided economic foundation for formerly enslaved people was quickly abandoned. Instead, Black Americans faced sharecropping, convict leasing, and other forms of economic exploitation that prevented wealth accumulation. The destruction of prosperous Black business districts like Tulsa's "Black Wall Street" through racial violence further undermined economic development in Black communities. The mid-20th century saw the implementation of policies that created the modern American middle class while systematically excluding Black Americans. Housing discrimination through redlining and restrictive covenants prevented Black families from building wealth through homeownership during the crucial post-war boom years. Discrimination in education, from segregated schools to unequal access to GI Bill benefits, limited economic mobility. Labor market discrimination confined Black workers to lower-paying jobs with fewer benefits and protections, even as unions helped white workers secure middle-class wages. These historical policies have created contemporary disparities that continue to shape economic outcomes. Today, the median white family has approximately ten times the wealth of the median Black family—a gap that has actually widened since the civil rights era. This disparity affects everything from educational opportunities to healthcare access, from housing security to entrepreneurship. Black Americans face higher unemployment rates, lower wages for comparable work, and greater vulnerability to economic downturns, as demonstrated during both the 2008 financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic. The economic cost extends beyond Black communities to affect the entire American economy. Economists estimate that racial gaps in income and opportunity reduce the nation's GDP by trillions of dollars over time through lost productivity, reduced consumer spending, and unrealized human potential. Addressing these disparities would benefit not only those directly affected but the broader economy as well. Proposed solutions range from targeted investments in education, housing, and healthcare to more comprehensive approaches like reparations. These policies recognize that the racial wealth gap reflects not individual choices but systematic exclusion over generations. Just as government policies created these disparities, deliberate policy interventions are required to address them. The economic dimension of racial justice thus represents not merely a moral imperative but a practical necessity for building a more prosperous and equitable society.

Chapter 6: White Identity Politics and American Democracy

Throughout American history, white identity has functioned as a powerful political force, shaping electoral outcomes and policy priorities in ways that often undermine democratic principles. While rarely acknowledged explicitly in mainstream discourse, appeals to white racial solidarity have been a consistent feature of American politics, evolving in form but maintaining their essential function of protecting white advantage. The most explicit manifestation of white identity politics appeared during the Jim Crow era, when Southern Democrats openly campaigned on platforms of white supremacy and Black disenfranchisement. As explicit racism became less socially acceptable following the civil rights movement, these appeals evolved into more coded language. Richard Nixon's "Southern Strategy" used terms like "law and order" and opposition to "forced busing" to signal racial positions without overtly racist rhetoric. This approach proved remarkably effective, reshaping the electoral map as white Southern voters shifted from the Democratic to the Republican Party. The election of Barack Obama as America's first Black president triggered a significant intensification of white identity politics. The Tea Party movement, while ostensibly focused on economic issues, frequently featured racist imagery and rhetoric targeting Obama. Research has consistently shown that racial attitudes were stronger predictors of Tea Party support than economic concerns. This period saw increasing partisan polarization along racial lines, with the Republican Party becoming increasingly dependent on white voters while the Democratic coalition grew more diverse. The 2016 election of Donald Trump represented a further evolution of white identity politics. Trump's campaign explicitly appealed to white grievance and anxiety about demographic change, from his characterization of Mexican immigrants as criminals to his promise to ban Muslim immigration. His slogan "Make America Great Again" resonated with many white voters who felt threatened by the country's increasing diversity and changing cultural norms. Exit polls revealed that Trump won white voters across education levels, income brackets, and genders, suggesting that racial identity had become more salient than traditional voting determinants for many Americans. This politics of white identity poses significant challenges for American democracy. When racial identity becomes the primary organizing principle for political behavior, it undermines the possibility of coalition-building across racial lines to address shared economic and social concerns. It encourages zero-sum thinking, where advances for racial minorities are perceived as threats to white Americans rather than as progress toward the nation's professed ideals of equality and justice. Most fundamentally, it contradicts the democratic principle that all citizens deserve equal voice and consideration regardless of race. The persistence of white identity politics reflects America's unresolved racial history and the material and psychological advantages that whiteness has conferred. Many white Americans have come to see their racial identity as under threat, responding with increased political mobilization to maintain traditional hierarchies. Addressing this challenge requires not only policy changes but a fundamental reimagining of American identity—one that embraces the nation's multiracial reality rather than clinging to an idealized past when whiteness defined American belonging.

Chapter 7: The Case for Reparations: Addressing Historical Wrongs

The question of reparations for slavery and its aftermath represents one of the most challenging and necessary conversations in American public life. Far from being a radical new proposal, the concept of reparations has deep historical roots in American history, dating back to the Civil War era when General William Sherman's Special Field Order No. 15 promised "forty acres and a mule" to formerly enslaved families—a promise quickly reversed after Abraham Lincoln's assassination. The moral case for reparations rests on the recognition that slavery was not merely a regrettable chapter in American history but a system of organized theft—of labor, of family bonds, of cultural heritage, and of human dignity. This theft did not end with emancipation but continued through Jim Crow, redlining, mass incarceration, and other systems that extracted wealth and opportunity from Black communities. The economic value of enslaved labor alone has been estimated in the trillions of dollars, while the subsequent century of legal discrimination multiplied these losses. Contrary to common objections, reparations need not involve direct payments to individuals based on ancestry. Proposals range from community investments in education, housing, and healthcare to truth and reconciliation commissions that would document the full scope of historical injustices. The fundamental principle is not punishment but repair—acknowledging harm and taking concrete steps to address its ongoing effects. Such programs could target the specific mechanisms through which racial inequality has been perpetuated, from housing discrimination to unequal education funding. International precedents exist for such programs. Germany has paid over $89 billion in reparations to Holocaust survivors and their descendants. Japan compensated Korean "comfort women" forced into sexual slavery during World War II. The United States itself has acknowledged historical wrongs through reparations to Japanese Americans interned during World War II and to several Native American tribes for land seizures. These examples demonstrate that meaningful reparations are both practically possible and morally necessary for societies seeking to address historical injustices. The resistance to reparations for slavery reflects not practical obstacles but America's reluctance to fully confront its racial history. Acknowledging the scale and persistence of anti-Black racism challenges cherished national narratives about equality and opportunity. It requires recognizing that racial disparities in wealth, health, education, and criminal justice are not accidental or attributable primarily to individual choices, but the predictable results of deliberate policies. As writer Ta-Nehisi Coates argues, reparations represent not just financial compensation but "a national reckoning that would lead to spiritual renewal." Such a reckoning would require abandoning comforting myths about American exceptionalism and confronting the central role of racial exploitation in building national wealth and power. This process would be painful but potentially transformative, allowing the country to address its unresolved history and move toward a more just future. The case for reparations ultimately rests on the recognition that genuine reconciliation requires more than symbolic gestures—it requires concrete action to address specific harms.

Summary

America's racial journey reveals a persistent pattern where progress toward equality has consistently been met with backlash and retrenchment. From the brief flowering of Reconstruction to the crushing response of Jim Crow, from civil rights victories to the rise of mass incarceration, from Obama's historic presidency to the politics of racial resentment that followed, this cycle has defined American history. The core tension throughout has been between America's professed ideals of equality and the reality of systems designed to maintain racial hierarchy. These systems have evolved from explicit legal discrimination to more subtle structural barriers, adapting to preserve white advantage even as formal equality was established in law. The path forward requires acknowledging that racial inequality is not merely a regrettable deviation from American ideals but has been woven into the nation's institutions from the beginning. This recognition demands more than symbolic gestures or individual attitude changes; it requires fundamental restructuring of systems that continue to produce disparate outcomes. Economic policies must address the wealth gap created by centuries of exclusion. Criminal justice reform must dismantle the apparatus of mass incarceration. Housing and education policies must actively promote integration rather than reinforcing segregation. Most importantly, Americans must reject the politics of racial division that has repeatedly undermined progress toward a more perfect union. Only by confronting this history honestly and pursuing structural change can America finally fulfill its promise of equal justice and opportunity for all its citizens.

About Author

Loading...

Ta-Nehisi Coates

Read more

Related Books by Ta-Nehisi Coates

Loading...

Between the World and Me

Ta-Nehisi Coates

The 2015 National Book Award Winner is a deep look at being black in America today

★★★★☆4.4

Loading...

The Message

Ta-Nehisi Coates

Exploring Myths that Shape our Identity and Reality

★★★★½4.5