Why Simple Wins

Why Simple Wins Plot Summary

Introduction

In today's fast-paced business world, complexity has become the silent killer of productivity, innovation, and employee satisfaction. Organizations of all sizes struggle under the weight of endless meetings, overflowing inboxes, redundant processes, and bureaucratic red tape. This mounting complexity doesn't just waste time and resources—it actively prevents people from doing meaningful work that creates real value. Think about your own experience. How much of your workday is consumed by activities that feel unnecessary or inefficient? How often do you leave the office feeling like you've been busy all day but haven't accomplished anything meaningful? The good news is that there's a powerful alternative. By embracing simplicity as a strategic advantage, individuals and organizations can cut through the noise, focus on what truly matters, and unlock unprecedented levels of creativity, engagement, and performance. The pages ahead will show you how to identify complexity in your work environment, provide practical tools to eliminate it, and guide you toward creating a culture where valuable work can thrive.

Chapter 1: Recognize the Complexity Trap

Complexity has silently infiltrated nearly every aspect of our working lives. It manifests in endless email chains, needlessly long meetings, convoluted approval processes, and intricate systems that seem designed to frustrate rather than facilitate. What makes complexity so insidious is that it often creeps in with good intentions. Organizations add layers of review to prevent mistakes, create detailed documentation to ensure consistency, and implement comprehensive processes to maintain control. Mike McCall's story illustrates this perfectly. As a VP of product management at a global technology company, Mike was hired for his strategic thinking and ability to develop innovative products. But despite his skills and dedication, he found himself trapped in a web of complexity that prevented him from doing the work he was hired to do. His days were consumed by unnecessary meetings where his presence wasn't even required. In one instance, he sat through a two-hour milestone meeting where most of the time was spent bringing people up to speed because the agenda had been vague and colleagues came unprepared. Between meetings, Mike would frantically try to respond to the hundreds of emails flooding his inbox daily. Every evening, he would take work home, responding to messages from colleagues in different time zones while trying to balance family responsibilities. Despite working 80-hour weeks, Mike felt he was making no headway on developing the long-term product strategy his company desperately needed. His work had become reactive rather than strategic, responding to urgent requests rather than creating value. The complexity trap doesn't just affect individuals like Mike—it creates systemic problems for organizations. Research from Boston Consulting Group found that over the past fifteen years, the amount of procedures, layers, interface structures, and coordination needed in typical companies has increased by 50% to 350%. According to SAP's Global Simplicity Index, complexity destroys a full tenth of company profits annually—or a combined $237 billion for the top two hundred firms worldwide. To escape this trap, you must first recognize that complexity isn't inevitable—it's created, often unintentionally, through daily decisions and habits. Identifying the sources of complexity in your organization is the crucial first step. Look for warning signs: excessive approval processes, frustrated customers, coordination overload, too many rule changes, mystery procedures nobody can explain, and an explosion of acronyms and jargon. The diagnostic survey provided in this chapter will help you measure complexity in your organization across two dimensions: organizational complexity (structural issues mandated by policy) and individual complexity (complications created within teams or by specific behaviors). By understanding where complexity lurks, you can begin to target your simplification efforts where they'll have the greatest impact.

Chapter 2: Measure Your Organization's Complexity

Complexity isn't just a feeling—it can be quantified, analyzed, and systematically addressed. Organizations often sense they have a problem with unnecessary complication but struggle to pinpoint exactly where the issues lie or how severe they've become. Without this clarity, simplification efforts tend to be scattered and ineffective. Measuring complexity provides the necessary foundation for targeted action. At Scripps Health in Southern California, leadership recognized this challenge when they examined their emergency departments. They discovered twenty-five different functions all reporting to different people within the hospital bureaucracy. Many staff working with the same patients never communicated with one another. When patients came to the ER, they were typically interviewed by an access representative, then a nurse, then another nurse, and finally a doctor. The process could drag on for hours—non-emergency patients sometimes waited more than eight hours for care, and one in eight patients would leave before being seen. What team members discovered upon studying this complexity was revealing: the patient experience wasn't the central organizing principle at the ER. Backroom operating systems and routines were holding healthcare providers hostage, stealing their time and energy. These dedicated professionals were too busy filling out forms, following outdated procedures, and navigating bureaucratic demands to focus on the patients themselves. To address this problem, Scripps first needed to measure exactly where and how complexity was impacting their operations. They examined each step of the patient journey, identified redundancies, and quantified the impact of their byzantine processes on wait times, patient satisfaction, and staff effectiveness. The diagnostic tool presented in this chapter follows a similar approach. It helps you determine your organization's complexity level across eleven key business areas, from organizational structure and strategy to meetings and reports. The comprehensive diagnostic provides scores for individual complexity (emails, meetings, presentations) and organizational complexity (vision, structure, operations), giving you a complete picture of your situation. By completing this diagnostic, you'll discover whether your organization is "strongly simplified," has "opportunities for simplification," is "complex," suffers from "serious complexity," or is paralyzed by "crippling complexity." Each diagnosis comes with specific recommendations for moving forward. The process isn't just about scoring—it's about creating awareness and spurring conversation. When one multinational company in a regulated industry completed the diagnostic, employees initially believed organizational complexity was inevitable. "Legal contracts are over fifty pages long no matter what I'm working on. Why?! The lawyers always tell me it's their job to be thorough. I'll never get them to make things simpler," one employee complained. But the diagnostic revealed that many of the most significant pain points stemmed from individual behaviors—too many meetings, needless emails, and redundant reports. This awareness is transformative. By measuring complexity objectively, organizations can move beyond vague frustrations to pinpoint specific problems and develop targeted solutions. The diagnostic becomes a powerful communication tool that builds consensus around simplification priorities and creates momentum for change.

Chapter 3: Identify What Truly Matters

At the heart of simplification lies a fundamental question: what work truly matters? Complexity steals time and energy from high-value activities, leaving employees feeling busy but unproductive. To reclaim meaningful work, organizations must clearly identify what creates genuine value and ruthlessly eliminate or streamline everything else. This principle came alive at CVS when senior managers discovered that customer satisfaction was dropping precipitously. Investigating the problem, they learned that one in five prescriptions was delayed by the "insurance check"—the moment when pharmacists confirmed that customers had the same insurance policy that CVS had in its database. Pharmacists typically performed this check after customers had left the store, making it impossible to resolve discrepancies immediately. As a result, customers faced long waits and major inconvenience. The solution wasn't complicated. CVS leaders realized that by moving the insurance check to the beginning of the process, right before the safety review, pharmacists could identify and resolve insurance issues while customers were still present. This simple change was implemented across four thousand pharmacies within twelve months, boosting customer satisfaction from 86% to 91%. What made this simplification successful was the clear focus on what truly mattered: the customer experience. CVS leaders recognized that behind all the processes, paperwork, and procedures, their fundamental purpose was helping customers get their medications conveniently and reliably. By keeping this core value at the center of their thinking, they could distinguish between essential complexity (necessary safety protocols) and unnecessary complexity (inefficient process sequencing). To identify what truly matters in your own work, try this thought experiment: Draw a line down the center of a piece of paper, creating two columns. In the left column, list what you would spend your day doing if you could rework your role to make it more effective and meaningful. In the right column, list what tasks actually occupy most of your time. Compare the two lists, then circle the items in the right column that add genuine value. This simple exercise reveals the gap between aspiration and reality—between work that matters and work that merely keeps you busy. What constitutes meaningful work? Research shows that people find fulfillment when their efforts connect to a larger purpose, utilize their skills effectively, and make a tangible difference. For some, this might mean strategic thinking or creative problem-solving. For others, it could be directly helping customers or mentoring colleagues. The specifics vary, but the principle remains: meaningful work creates value that people can see and feel. Organizations that help employees spend more time on meaningful work reap significant benefits. Productivity increases, innovation flourishes, engagement rises, and retention improves. More importantly, people experience greater satisfaction and purpose, making the workplace more humane and fulfilling.

Chapter 4: Apply the Simplification Toolkit

Knowing you have a complexity problem isn't enough; you need practical tools to tackle it. Most simplification initiatives fail because well-intentioned employees lack effective frameworks to guide them from intention to action. They get bogged down in ambiguity or end up merely reorganizing complexity rather than eliminating it. This challenge became clear when a division of a major consumer goods company attempted to simplify their operations. They assembled a cross-functional team of twelve people who surveyed colleagues, defined simplification, and identified twenty areas to tackle. Despite this promising start, the initiative stalled. The team spent valuable time debating definitions rather than taking action. When they finally prioritized areas to simplify, their brainstorming sessions generated vague solutions that didn't address root causes. Within a year, the initiative had died. What was missing? A structured approach with specific tools for each stage of simplification. The Simplification Toolkit presented in this chapter fills this gap, providing practical exercises for every step of the journey: awareness, identification, prioritization, execution, and habit formation. Consider the "Kill a Stupid Rule" tool, which Liz Tinkham, a senior managing director at Accenture, used with her leadership team. The exercise is straightforward: participants identify rules that frustrate them or slow productivity, then determine whether these rules should be killed or modified. After just fifteen minutes of discussion, Tinkham's team generated forty-one rules to eliminate or change. Remarkably, many weren't rules at all but misunderstandings that no one had examined. For instance, many employees wrongly assumed they were required to attend certain meetings, when in fact Tinkham only needed them at three meetings per month. Another powerful tool is the "Simplification Worksheet," which helps teams identify quick wins for immediate implementation. When used during a staff meeting at a mid-sized company, this tool helped the team change seventeen work processes in just one hour. Some tasks were eliminated entirely, others were outsourced, and several were streamlined through simple adjustments. For more comprehensive assessment, the "Killing Complexity" tool guides teams through evaluating their most time-consuming tasks using a Simplicity versus Value Matrix. Tasks are plotted according to their value and complexity level, creating a visual roadmap for action. High-value, simple tasks are preserved; low-value, complex tasks are eliminated; and high-value, complex tasks are targeted for streamlining. These tools share important characteristics that make them effective. They break simplification into manageable steps, focus on specific pain points rather than abstract concepts, and generate concrete actions rather than vague recommendations. Most importantly, they empower employees at all levels to take ownership of simplification rather than waiting for top-down directives. By applying these tools systematically, organizations can make tangible progress toward simpler, more efficient operations. The key is moving beyond awareness to structured action, transforming good intentions into meaningful change.

Chapter 5: Become Your Team's Simplification Champion

Simplification doesn't just happen on its own—it requires champions who lead by example and inspire others to embrace simpler ways of working. Whether you're a C-suite executive or a frontline manager, you can play this crucial role within your sphere of influence, becoming what might be called a "Chief Simplification Officer" for your team or organization. Dave Lewis demonstrated this leadership when he became CEO at European grocery giant Tesco. The company was struggling with changing consumer behaviors and recovering from an accounting scandal. Lewis quickly identified a core problem: shopping at Tesco had become unnecessarily complicated. While competitors like Aldi offered a streamlined selection (one type of ketchup versus Tesco's twenty-eight varieties), Tesco's overwhelming array of options was alienating customers rather than pleasing them. Lewis made a bold decision: cut the variety of products by as much as 30%, from over ninety thousand unique items to as few as sixty-five thousand. This wasn't an easy call. He anticipated pushback from customers who might complain about losing their favorite brands and from suppliers whose products would be eliminated. Yet Lewis stayed committed to his simplification mission, understanding that the short-term pain would yield long-term benefits in efficiency, customer experience, and profitability. To follow Lewis's example and become an effective simplification champion, you need to develop six key characteristics. First is courage—the willingness to challenge the status quo and make difficult decisions despite resistance. Second is a minimalist sensibility that appreciates the value of "less." Third is a results orientation that views simplification as a means to better performance, not just cost-cutting. Fourth is focus—the determination to stay the course despite distractions. Fifth is personal engagement—walking the walk by simplifying your own work first. Finally, decisiveness—making clear choices without getting bogged down in consensus-building. Beyond these personal qualities, effective simplification champions employ specific strategies to build momentum. They create a compelling vision for simplification that inspires others. They integrate simplicity into long-term strategy rather than treating it as a one-off initiative. They streamline management layers to speed decision-making. They establish clear metrics to track progress and demonstrate value. They create codes of conduct that set behavioral expectations around simplicity. And they assemble diverse teams to lead simplification efforts across the organization. Perhaps most importantly, simplification champions lead by example. They conduct their own "time inventories" to identify low-value activities. They practice saying no to unnecessary commitments. They delete or unsubscribe from digital distractions. They experiment with eliminating tasks to see what truly matters. Through these personal practices, they demonstrate that simplicity isn't just a corporate initiative but a better way of working and living. The journey to becoming an effective simplification champion isn't always smooth. You'll encounter resistance, skepticism, and occasional setbacks. But by maintaining focus and demonstrating tangible benefits, you can gradually shift your team's culture toward greater simplicity and meaning.

Chapter 6: Create a Culture of Simplicity

Simplification can't be a one-time event; it must become part of your organization's DNA—a way of thinking and working that permeates every level. Creating this cultural transformation requires sustained effort, but the payoff is immense: an organization that can respond quickly to market changes, innovate freely, and consistently deliver exceptional value. Vancouver City Savings Credit Union (Vancity), Canada's largest community credit union with $19.8 billion in assets and 2,500 employees, offers a compelling example of this journey. Despite its commitment to serving members effectively, Vancity had accumulated layers of complexity over decades of growth. Previous attempts at process improvement had yielded disappointing results, with changes in one area often creating new complications elsewhere. Under the leadership of Jay-Ann Gilfoy, Senior Vice President for Banking Applications Renewal, Vancity took a fresh approach. Rather than focusing exclusively on technology or processes, they addressed the foundation of complexity: the credit union's policies and procedures. Gilfoy described their situation as "like an episode of Hoarders—you gotta start by getting rid of some stuff." What made Vancity's approach successful was their innovative "rapid cycling" methodology. Small, cross-functional groups of employees who actually performed the work gathered in two-day workshops to identify and fix specific complications. Every two weeks, a new cycle began, creating continuous momentum. Importantly, these weren't consultants or specialists but the very people who dealt with complexity daily. Each workshop followed a structured format. On day one, participants generated broad simplification ideas and "acid tested" them by calling colleagues whose work would be affected. On day two, they refined specific solutions for immediate implementation. Senior leaders attended the end of each session to hear recommendations and approve changes, often implementing solutions within one to two weeks. To maintain focus, Vancity established clear metrics: the number of processes simplified or removed, forms eliminated, and steps streamlined. They also created a small "simplicity team" led by a director of simplicity, but deliberately rotated employees through this team rather than creating a permanent department that would "own" simplification. The goal was to embed simplification thinking throughout the organization, not isolate it in a specialized function. The results were remarkable. Within a year, Vancity had executed twenty-five rapid cycles, simplifying or removing 133 processes and procedures, eliminating 53 forms, and streamlining 80 operational steps. For example, when employees in the call center wanted to help someone open a new account, they previously had to call each branch to check when an account manager would be available. Through rapid cycling, they implemented a simple solution: giving call center staff direct access to account managers' calendars. This single change cut processing time by nearly 50% for some transactions. Beyond these operational improvements, Vancity experienced a cultural shift. Employees felt empowered to question unnecessary complexity rather than accepting it as inevitable. Teams collaborated across traditional boundaries to solve problems. And the organization developed what Gilfoy called an "innovation competency"—the ability to continuously identify and eliminate complications that inhibited their mission of serving members. The Vancity story teaches us that creating a simplicity culture requires more than just tools and techniques—it demands leadership commitment, employee engagement, clear focus, and systematic reinforcement. By integrating these elements, any organization can transform complexity from a limiting factor into a competitive advantage.

Summary

Throughout these pages, we've explored how complexity silently undermines organizations and individuals, stealing time from meaningful work and eroding engagement, innovation, and performance. The journey from complexity to simplicity isn't easy, but it's essential for creating lasting value in today's fast-paced environment. As Jeff Immelt, former CEO of GE, succinctly put it: "Simplification is the strategy we're driving in every business every day." Your path forward begins with recognizing where complexity has crept into your work and organization. Use the diagnostic tools to measure its impact, then apply the practical frameworks to eliminate unnecessary complications. Focus relentlessly on what truly matters—the work that creates genuine value for customers, colleagues, and your mission. Remember that simplicity isn't about cutting corners or doing less; it's about doing better by removing the barriers that prevent excellence. The power is in your hands to escape complexity and create a working environment where people can thrive doing work that matters. Start today by eliminating one unnecessary meeting, simplifying one overly complex process, or declining one low-value commitment. Small actions, consistently applied, create powerful transformations.

About Author

Loading...

Lisa Bodell

Lisa Bodell is the founder and CEO of futurethink, an internationally recognized innovation research and training firm. Lisa founded her company on the principle that with the right knowledge and tools, everyone has the power to innovate. As a leading innovator and cognitive learning expert, she has devised training programs for hundreds of innovators at leading companies such as 3M, GE, and Johnson & Johnson. A respected thought leader on innovation topics, Bodell has appeared on FOX News, and in publications such as Crain’s, Business Week, The New York Times, WIRED, Investor’s Business Daily, Successful Meetings, Harvard Business Review, and The Futurist. She serves as an advisor on the boards of the Institute of Direct Marketing in London, The Women’s Congress, the Association of Professional Futurists, and the prestigious Institute of Triple Helix Innovation think tank. She has also taught at American University, Fordham University, and the American Management Association.

Read more