Why The West Rules – For Now

Why The West Rules – For Now Plot Summary

Introduction

In 1840, a British naval squadron approached the Chinese port of Tinghai. Within minutes, their superior firepower reduced the Chinese defenses to rubble. This dramatic encounter exemplified a stark reality: by the 19th century, Western powers could project military might across the globe in ways that Eastern powers simply could not match. Yet just a millennium earlier, China had been far more advanced than Europe in technology, governance, and economic development. How did this remarkable reversal occur? The story of East-West relations spans thousands of years, with each civilization experiencing remarkable periods of innovation, expansion, and occasional collapse. Throughout history, these two great centers of human achievement have sometimes developed in parallel, sometimes diverged dramatically, and occasionally learned from each other. By examining this grand historical pattern, we can better understand not just why certain regions dominated at different times, but also what forces drive civilizational development, how societies respond to challenges, and what this might tell us about our collective future. Whether you're a student of international relations, a business leader interested in global markets, or simply curious about the grand patterns of history, this exploration of the pendulum of power between East and West offers valuable insights into our interconnected world.

Chapter 1: Divergent Beginnings: Agricultural Revolutions and Early States

Around 14,000 BCE, as the last Ice Age began to wane, humans across the globe lived similarly as hunter-gatherers in small bands. Yet the warming climate would soon set different regions on divergent paths. In the region known as the "Hilly Flanks" of southwest Asia (modern Iraq, Syria, and Turkey), wild cereals flourished in the new climate, providing abundant food resources that allowed humans to settle in one place. By 9500 BCE, people in this Western region began domesticating plants and animals, creating the world's first agricultural revolution. Women likely pioneered the cultivation of wild grains, while men domesticated sheep, goats, and eventually cattle. This transition wasn't immediate or deliberate—it happened through countless small adjustments as people responded to their environment. In the East, particularly along China's Yellow and Yangzi river valleys, a similar process began around 7500 BCE, roughly two thousand years later. This timing difference proved crucial, giving Western civilizations a head start that would persist for millennia. The consequences of this agricultural revolution were profound and irreversible. As people settled down, they had more children, created more complex social hierarchies, and developed new technologies. At sites like 'Ain Mallaha in the Jordan Valley, people built substantial houses, stored food, and developed complex burial practices that suggest new beliefs about ancestors and the afterlife. Property became inheritable, gender roles became more defined, and religious specialists gained influence. By 5000 BCE, the Western advantage expanded dramatically as simple farming villages evolved into the world's first cities and states in Mesopotamia. The city of Uruk emerged as the world's first true metropolis, with perhaps 20,000 residents by 3300 BCE. Here, temple complexes dominated the landscape, and priests claimed special access to the gods. These religious specialists developed the world's first writing system to keep track of goods and organized labor on an unprecedented scale. Similar developments occurred in Egypt, where around 3100 BCE, King Narmer unified the Nile Valley into history's first territorial state. Egyptian pharaohs went further than Mesopotamian rulers, claiming not just to represent the gods but to be gods themselves. While the West experienced cycles of growth and collapse, Eastern civilization was steadily developing along a similar trajectory, though with a time lag. Around 2500 BCE, as Western states were already mature, the first signs of social stratification appeared in China's Yellow River valley. By 1900 BCE, the settlement of Erlitou had grown into a true city with approximately 25,000 residents, and by 1600 BCE, the Shang dynasty established dominance, building massive walled cities and developing a complex writing system preserved on "oracle bones" used in divination rituals. This early divergence between East and West established a pattern that would persist for millennia. The Western head start in agriculture led to earlier development of cities, writing, and complex political organizations. However, as we'll see, this advantage was not permanent. The pendulum of power would swing back and forth throughout history, as different regions found innovative solutions to the challenges of their time and place.

Chapter 2: Classical Empires: Rome and Han in Parallel Development

The first century BCE witnessed an extraordinary historical coincidence: the simultaneous emergence of two vast empires that would define their respective regions for centuries. In the West, Rome expanded from a city-state to control the entire Mediterranean basin. In the East, the Han dynasty consolidated power across China. These parallel empires reached remarkably similar levels of sophistication, with populations of 50-60 million people each, suggesting that the early Western advantage had significantly diminished. Rome's transformation from republic to empire under Augustus created a political system that would endure for centuries. The Pax Romana brought unprecedented stability, allowing trade to flourish from Britain to Egypt. Roman engineers built a network of roads, aqueducts, and public buildings that transformed the landscape. Similarly, the Han dynasty under Emperor Wu expanded Chinese territory, established the Silk Road connecting East and West, and institutionalized Confucianism as state doctrine. Both empires faced similar challenges: maintaining control over vast territories, defending long frontiers against nomadic peoples, and developing administrative systems that could effectively extract resources without provoking rebellion. These parallel empires reached their peak around 100-200 CE, achieving levels of social development that would not be surpassed for a millennium. Urban populations boomed, with Rome and Chang'an each housing around a million residents. Trade networks expanded, connecting distant regions and spreading technologies. Both societies produced remarkable cultural achievements in literature, philosophy, and the arts. The Han dynasty pioneered inventions like paper, the seismograph, and the rudder, while Rome excelled in engineering, law, and architectural innovations like the arch and concrete. Yet both empires also contained the seeds of their own decline. Their very success created new problems—environmental degradation, fiscal strain, social inequality, and external pressure. By the third century CE, both Rome and Han China faced crises that would ultimately lead to fragmentation. Climate change brought colder, drier conditions, reducing agricultural yields. Epidemic diseases—most notably the Antonine Plague in Rome and similar outbreaks in Han China—devastated populations already weakened by malnutrition. Civil wars drained resources, while corruption undermined effective governance. The collapse of these classical empires revealed a fundamental paradox of development: the very forces that drive civilizations to new heights—population growth, resource exploitation, military expansion—often contain the seeds of their downfall. The Han dynasty collapsed in 220 CE, plunging China into the "Three Kingdoms" period of division. Rome's collapse was more gradual, with the western half falling to Germanic invasions by 476 CE, while the eastern half survived as the Byzantine Empire. This parallel decline would set the stage for a dramatic reversal in the fortunes of East and West during the subsequent millennium. The legacy of these classical empires proved enduring. Both created cultural and institutional templates that would influence their regions for centuries to come. Roman law, language, and architecture shaped European civilization long after the empire's fall, while Confucian philosophy and Han administrative practices remained fundamental to Chinese society through numerous dynastic changes. Their parallel development and decline demonstrate that similar processes of social evolution were at work at opposite ends of Eurasia, despite limited direct contact between these civilizations.

Chapter 3: Medieval Reversal: Eastern Ascendance After Rome's Fall

The third through seventh centuries CE saw both Eastern and Western cores experience profound crises followed by divergent patterns of recovery. The Roman Empire fragmented under pressure from Germanic migrations and internal strife, while the Han dynasty collapsed into competing kingdoms. In both regions, urban populations declined, trade networks contracted, and central authority weakened. However, the paths these civilizations took after these parallel collapses diverged dramatically, creating a crucial turning point in world history. In the West, the collapse was more severe and recovery slower. After Rome fell in 476 CE, Western Europe fragmented into numerous small kingdoms ruled by Germanic warlords. Cities shrank dramatically—Rome itself declined from perhaps a million inhabitants to fewer than 50,000. Literacy rates fell as classical learning retreated to monasteries, and sophisticated technologies were lost or simplified. The Eastern Roman (Byzantine) Empire survived, preserving classical traditions, but lost significant territory to Arab conquests after the rise of Islam in the seventh century. While Christianity provided cultural continuity across Europe, the sophisticated administrative systems of Rome largely disappeared. The East recovered more quickly and completely. After a period of division known as the "Six Dynasties," China was reunified under the Sui dynasty in 589 CE and then the Tang in 618 CE. The Tang restored imperial administration, revived the examination system for selecting officials, and presided over a cultural flowering that historians often describe as China's golden age. Chang'an became the world's largest city, with perhaps a million residents, featuring cosmopolitan markets and visitors from across Asia. Buddhism spread throughout East Asia, creating a shared cultural sphere similar to Christendom in the West, while Tang poetry reached artistic heights that remain influential today. For the first time since the agricultural revolution, Eastern social development surpassed Western around 541 CE. While Europe struggled through what were once called the "Dark Ages," Tang China experienced remarkable technological innovation. The invention of woodblock printing in the 7th century and later movable type revolutionized information storage and transmission centuries before Gutenberg. Chinese engineers pioneered advances in metallurgy, textile production, and navigation. The Song dynasty (960-1279) further accelerated this development, creating the world's most sophisticated economy with paper money, proto-industrial manufacturing, and extensive trade networks. This medieval transformation demonstrates that development is not linear or predetermined. The advantages that had given the West its early lead did not guarantee permanent superiority. Geography, climate, disease, and cultural factors all influenced how societies responded to challenges, creating new patterns of development. The political fragmentation of Europe, once a weakness, would eventually become a strength by fostering competition and innovation. Meanwhile, China's unified empire provided stability and scale but sometimes discouraged radical innovation. By 1000 CE, the pendulum of power had swung decisively eastward, but the conditions for another reversal were already forming.

Chapter 4: Maritime Connections: Global Trade Networks Emerge

The period from 1000 to 1500 CE witnessed the emergence of the first truly global trade networks, connecting previously isolated regions and transforming economies across Eurasia. These connections would eventually set the stage for a dramatic shift in the global balance of power. While China remained the world's most advanced civilization during this period, European societies were gradually developing institutions and technologies that would later enable their remarkable expansion. The Silk Roads—a complex network of trade routes stretching from China to the Mediterranean—had existed since ancient times, but reached new heights during this period. Chinese silk, porcelain, and tea moved westward, while spices, precious metals, and horses traveled east. The Mongol conquests of the 13th century, though initially devastating, created the largest land empire in history and established the "Pax Mongolica"—a period when merchants could travel safely across Eurasia. Marco Polo's famous journey to Yuan dynasty China exemplified these new connections, though his descriptions of Hangzhou as "the finest and noblest city in the world" seemed almost unbelievable to his European contemporaries. Maritime trade expanded dramatically alongside these land routes. Arab and Persian merchants dominated Indian Ocean commerce, establishing trading networks that connected East Africa, India, Southeast Asia, and China. Chinese technological innovations in shipbuilding and navigation enabled the remarkable voyages of Admiral Zheng He between 1405 and 1433. His "treasure fleets," with ships five times larger than European vessels of the time, visited Southeast Asia, India, Arabia, and East Africa, demonstrating China's naval superiority. Meanwhile, Italian city-states like Venice and Genoa grew wealthy as intermediaries in Mediterranean trade, developing sophisticated financial instruments like double-entry bookkeeping and insurance. The Black Death, arriving in Europe in 1347 after spreading along trade routes from Asia, killed perhaps a third of Europe's population. While devastating, this catastrophe had unexpected consequences that would later prove advantageous. Labor shortages increased wages and disrupted feudal relationships, while the shock to established institutions created openings for innovation. European societies gradually developed banking systems, universities, and competitive states that would later drive expansion. Meanwhile, the Ming dynasty that replaced the Mongol Yuan in China turned increasingly inward after the Zheng He voyages, focusing on internal stability rather than external exploration. By 1500, a crucial inflection point was approaching. Portuguese navigators, seeking to bypass Muslim and Italian middlemen in the spice trade, developed new sailing techniques and vessels. Bartolomeu Dias rounded Africa's Cape of Good Hope in 1488, and Vasco da Gama reached India in 1498. Most consequentially, Christopher Columbus sailed west in 1492, accidentally encountering the Americas while seeking a route to Asia. These voyages initiated European colonial expansion and the Columbian Exchange—a massive transfer of plants, animals, people, and diseases between continents that would transform global ecology and economy. These emerging maritime connections would ultimately shift the pendulum of power back toward the West. While Ming China remained the world's largest economy in 1500, with sophisticated manufacturing and a population approaching 100 million, European societies were developing the navigational technologies, financial institutions, and competitive drive that would fuel their subsequent expansion. The stage was set for the most dramatic reversal in the long history of East-West relations—one that would reshape the global balance of power for centuries to come.

Chapter 5: Industrial Transformation: The Western Technological Leap

After trailing behind the East for over a millennium, the West began a remarkable resurgence around 1500 CE that accelerated dramatically after 1750, when Western social development skyrocketed to unprecedented levels. This "Great Divergence" between East and West represents one of history's most consequential shifts, creating patterns of inequality that persist to this day. Understanding this reversal requires examining both long-term patterns and immediate causes. Several factors contributed to the West's eventual advantage. Geographic fragmentation in Europe—with its peninsulas, islands, and mountain ranges—created political competition that drove innovation. When China's Ming dynasty abandoned oceanic exploration after 1433, European powers continued pushing outward, eventually discovering the Americas and establishing global trade networks. The Scientific Revolution and Enlightenment fostered intellectual environments that valued empirical observation and practical application. The printing press, though invented earlier in China, spread rapidly across Europe after Gutenberg, accelerating the exchange of ideas. The crucial breakthrough came with the Industrial Revolution, beginning in Britain around 1750. The fortuitous combination of coal deposits near manufacturing centers, colonial resources, accumulated capital, and scientific knowledge allowed Britain to harness fossil fuel energy on an unprecedented scale. James Watt's improved steam engine, patented in 1769, converted the energy stored in coal into mechanical motion that could power factories, locomotives, and steamships. As Matthew Boulton, Watt's business partner, famously told a visitor: "I sell here, Sir, what all the world desires to have—POWER." This power transformed production first in textiles, then in iron and steel, creating unprecedented wealth while also generating new social divisions and environmental damage. Industrialization spread from Britain to continental Europe and North America, creating an interconnected Western-dominated global economy. By 1840, when British gunboats forced open Chinese ports during the Opium War, the technology gap had become unbridgeable. The Qing dynasty, which had presided over China's territorial expansion and cultural flowering, suddenly found itself unable to resist Western military pressure. Eastern societies, particularly China and Japan, were not stagnant during this period. The Qing dynasty (1644-1912) oversaw territorial expansion and population growth, while Japan's Tokugawa shogunate maintained a sophisticated urban culture. Yet both empires increasingly turned inward, restricting foreign trade and technological adoption. When Emperor Qianlong dismissed British trade overtures in 1793, declaring "We have never valued ingenious articles, nor do we have the slightest need of your country's manufactures," he failed to recognize how dramatically the balance of power had shifted. By 1900, Western dominance seemed complete. European powers had carved up much of Africa and established spheres of influence in China. The United States had emerged as an industrial powerhouse, while Japan alone among non-Western powers had successfully industrialized after the Meiji Restoration of 1868. This dramatic reversal of fortunes between East and West demonstrated that technological innovation, rather than cultural or geographic determinism, ultimately drives shifts in global power. The pendulum had swung dramatically westward, but as the 20th century would reveal, this dominance would not be permanent.

Chapter 6: Modern Rebalancing: Asia's Rise in the Global Economy

The twentieth century witnessed the most dramatic power transitions in human history. It began with European empires at their zenith, controlling vast territories across Africa and Asia. It ended with those empires dissolved, the United States as the world's sole superpower, and China rapidly ascending as a potential rival. These shifts reflected not just military outcomes but fundamental changes in technology, economics, and ideology that continue to reshape our world. Two devastating world wars (1914-1918 and 1939-1945) marked the beginning of Europe's decline. These conflicts, which originated in European power struggles, became truly global as colonial subjects were drawn into imperial armies and resources from around the world fueled the war machines. The United States emerged from these wars economically strengthened, while the Soviet Union established itself as a competing superpower, creating a bipolar world divided by the Cold War. The collapse of European colonial empires accelerated after World War II, as independence movements across Asia and Africa succeeded in throwing off foreign rule. China's transformation represents perhaps the most significant power shift of recent decades. After the Communist victory in 1949, Mao Zedong attempted to rapidly industrialize through radical social engineering, with catastrophic results in the Great Leap Forward (1958-1962) and Cultural Revolution (1966-1976). Following Mao's death, Deng Xiaoping's market reforms unleashed China's economic potential while maintaining authoritarian political control. As Deng pragmatically declared, "To get rich is no sin," China embraced capitalism without democracy, challenging Western assumptions about development. The results have been spectacular—China sustained economic growth averaging nearly 10% annually for four decades, lifting 800 million people out of poverty and creating the world's largest manufacturing base. By 2010, China had surpassed Japan to become the world's second-largest economy, and projections suggest it will overtake the United States in total GDP (though not per capita wealth) by the 2030s. Other Asian economies have followed similar trajectories, with South Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore transforming from poor developing nations to advanced industrial economies within a single generation. This economic rebalancing has been accompanied by technological advancement. Asian nations have moved from imitating Western technologies to pioneering innovations in fields like artificial intelligence, renewable energy, and telecommunications. China's investments in quantum computing, biotechnology, and space exploration represent a bid to lead the next technological revolution rather than follow Western innovation as it did during industrialization. Meanwhile, India has emerged as a global center for software development and digital services, leveraging its large, educated workforce. The pendulum of power appears to be swinging back toward the East, though in a world far more interconnected than at any previous point in history. Rather than a simple reversal of fortune, we are witnessing the emergence of a multipolar world where power is more diffuse and complex. The United States remains the predominant military power with unmatched cultural influence, while China's economic weight continues to grow. Regional powers like India, Brazil, and Indonesia have gained influence, while transnational challenges including climate change, pandemics, and technological disruption require unprecedented global cooperation. The lessons of history suggest that this rebalancing will continue, though its ultimate shape remains to be determined by how societies respond to the challenges of our interconnected future.

Summary

Throughout human history, the relationship between Eastern and Western civilizations has followed a complex pattern of leads, lags, and parallels. The West gained an early advantage when agriculture developed first in the Fertile Crescent around 9500 BCE, roughly two thousand years before similar developments in China. This head start allowed Western societies to develop cities, states, and complex technologies earlier than their Eastern counterparts. Yet this advantage was not permanent—after the fall of Rome, Eastern development surpassed Western for over a millennium, only for the West to surge ahead again with the Industrial Revolution. Today, we appear to be witnessing another shift as Asian economies, led by China, reclaim their historical economic prominence. This historical pattern reveals that development is not predetermined by geography, culture, or genetics alone, but emerges from the interaction of all these factors with historical contingency. The most successful societies have been those that could adapt to changing circumstances, developing new institutions and technologies when faced with challenges. The pendulum of power swings not because of inherent superiority of East or West, but because different regions find innovative solutions to the problems of their time. As we face unprecedented global challenges—from climate change to technological disruption—this historical perspective offers valuable insight. Rather than viewing East-West relations as a zero-sum competition, we might recognize that both traditions have contributed essential innovations to human progress, and that future challenges will require drawing on the best of both traditions. The lesson of history is not that any civilization is destined to rule, but that adaptability, openness to new ideas, and institutional flexibility are the true foundations of lasting success.

About Author

Loading...

Ian Morris

Read more