From Conflict to Courage

From Conflict to Courage Plot Summary

Introduction

Leadership today requires more than simply managing teams and delivering results. In our increasingly complex world, one of the most demanding aspects of leadership is effectively navigating conflict. When we face disagreements, personality clashes, or challenging conversations, many of us instinctively retreat into avoidance, aggression, or appeasing behaviors—all of which ultimately undermine our leadership effectiveness and organizational health. The reality is that conflict itself isn't the problem; it's how we respond to it that matters. Throughout these pages, you'll discover how conflict can actually serve as your greatest teacher and a catalyst for profound leadership growth. By reframing conflict as an opportunity rather than a threat, you'll develop the capacity to transform tense situations into moments of clarity, connection, and positive change. This journey requires courage—the willingness to face difficult truths about ourselves and others—but the rewards extend far beyond merely resolving disagreements to fundamentally reshaping your leadership identity and impact.

Chapter 1: Expand Your Conflict Capacity

Conflict capacity is the ability to stay engaged in difficult conversations, remain present with high-conflict personalities, and create enough self-awareness to set boundaries before getting triggered into dysfunctional patterns. Like expanding your physical capabilities, building conflict capacity requires conditioning, discipline, and deliberate practice that enables you to withstand storms rather than avoiding, appeasing, or becoming aggressive. Consider Alisha, a newly promoted executive director struggling with her transition from peer to leader. She found it challenging to address performance issues with Tony, a seasoned employee who wielded significant influence over the team. "I've talked to Tony a thousand times, and nothing changes," Alisha complained. Her statement revealed more than she realized—she had allowed Tony's behavior 999 times, creating a pattern where Tony saw no reason to change. This illustrates a fundamental truth: "The behavior allowed becomes the standard." Alisha's struggle stemmed from three common dysfunctional behaviors leaders use to avoid discomfort: avoidance ("We're all adults, I shouldn't have to tell them"), appeasing ("They're a high performer, so I make exceptions"), and aggression ("I didn't ask you to work here, find another job"). At their core, these behaviors represent the avoidance of feelings, personal responsibility, and growth. To build true conflict capacity, leaders need to develop three distinct but overlapping elements: the inner game (self-awareness, self-regulation, emotional integrity), the outer game (skills, techniques, deliberate practice), and culture (values alignment, leadership example, accountability systems). The sweet spot occurs when all three elements overlap, creating expansive capacity for managing and overcoming conflict. The first step to building conflict capacity is addressing inner conflict. This means resolving misalignment when you have a divided mind—wanting to have a conversation but not wanting to upset an employee, wanting to promote a key player but facing company seniority policies. Winning the inner game requires self-awareness, a strong values system, and discernment about when certain behaviors serve you and when they don't. As you develop your conflict capacity, you'll notice improvements in three stages: first recognizing your reactions after they happen, then catching yourself during the reaction but not controlling it, and finally seeing triggers before they happen, creating enough space to make different choices. Remember, when it comes to building conflict capacity, comfort is not a requirement—but the resulting leadership growth is well worth the discomfort.

Chapter 2: Build a Strong Leadership Identity

Leadership identity—who you think you are and how you see yourself—fundamentally shapes your workplace relationships and how you lead others. When Alisha struggled with Tony's disruptive behavior, her challenge wasn't just about handling a difficult employee; it was about her own leadership identity crisis. She hadn't made the mental shift from "one of us" to "one of them," leaving her caught in a pattern of being too nice, covering for employees' mistakes, and making exceptions. Overly nice leaders often create unintended drama through three dysfunctional identities. Best-friend leaders care more about being liked than aligning with organizational mission, getting distracted by hearsay and avoiding direct conversations. Hero leaders create dependency by always having the answer, taking credit rather than giving it, and fostering overly dependent employees. Hands-off leaders brush complaints under the carpet, change structures without addressing individuals, and miss drama until it's out of control. Why do people like Tony continue problematic behaviors? Simply put, because it works for them. They continue patterns until there's a reason to change. When Alisha called for a workshop to fix her employee problems, she revealed her belief that the issue lay outside herself. In reality, her leadership identity needed transformation first. Your narrative—the story you tell yourself about who you are—drives your behaviors and is influenced by culture. Listen to how people describe themselves: "I am very particular" or "I'm conflict averse" or "That's just the way I am." These statements reveal narratives that justify behaviors. Our narratives form over time, starting with childhood messages from authority figures that become embedded during our highly suggestible early years. The good news is that identity isn't fixed. By shifting from a past-based narrative to a future vision, you can become the leader you aspire to be. This transformation requires five steps: First, know your story—become aware of your current narrative identity. Second, create a personal definition of leadership—for example, "leadership is about alignment, and alignment is about focusing energy." Third, claim your values as a compass for decision-making. Fourth, create a new future self through visualization techniques. Finally, build self-trust by doing what you say you'll do. When your leadership identity aligns with how others see you, you achieve congruence that enables authentic leadership. This is far more powerful than superficial techniques or scripts. Leadership always trumps drama, bullying, avoidance, and niceness. As your leadership identity strengthens, you'll naturally face conflict head-on, guided by principles and values rather than fear or the need for approval.

Chapter 3: Develop Clear Leadership Vision

Leadership identity concerns how you see yourself, while leadership clarity focuses on how you see the situation. Without leadership clarity, it's easy to get distracted by conflict, overreact to internal tensions, or smooth things over to feel better rather than addressing real issues. The path to clarity requires understanding three core components: the current situation, the desired outcome, and the obstacles between them. Barbara exemplified how a lack of leadership clarity can derail a professional group. As a member of a peer collaboration group, Barbara constantly caused disruption by disagreeing with nearly every idea, interrupting to correct grammar, and insisting her way was always better. Though everyone in the group considered themselves leaders, they struggled with leadership clarity about how to address Barbara's behaviors. Instead of focusing on their shared purpose, members became fixated on Barbara as the problem. When you find yourself complaining, distracted or unhappy about a situation, ask three essential questions: "What do I want?" "How does this desire align with my values and the organization's values?" and "What would achieving this give me that I don't have now?" These questions redirect you from problem-solving to clarity-seeking. For instance, rather than thinking, "I want Barbara to leave this group," you might realize, "I want more mutual respect and a positive, supportive experience." Inner peace serves as a reliable indicator of clarity. If you're experiencing disturbing emotions like resentment or vengeful thoughts, you lack the clarity needed for good decision-making. Clarity isn't certainty—it's a feeling of peace that comes from weighing a situation, knowing your next step, and accepting the risks and consequences without hidden agendas. A practical model for gaining leadership clarity is the "language of the island" metaphor: Point A (the boat) represents your current situation, Point B (the island) is your desired outcome, and the shark symbolizes obstacles. Leaders often make the mistake of focusing exclusively on obstacles rather than clearly defining points A and B. For instance, if a toxic work environment is causing unwanted turnover (Point A), your desire might be job satisfaction (Point B). To implement leadership clarity, practice two key skills. First, represent yourself instead of speaking for others. Rather than saying, "Everyone is tired of you interrupting," say, "Barbara, I want you to let me finish speaking." Second, speak to the vision rather than the problem. Instead of dwelling on what's wrong, articulate what success looks like. Even in heated discussions, redirect with statements like, "What I want is for us to help each other achieve our goals." Leadership clarity isn't about eliminating all conflict but about navigating it with purpose and alignment to reach your desired destination.

Chapter 4: Master Emotional Integrity

Emotional integrity doesn't mean achieving perfect stability, avoiding anger, or staying quiet to keep peace. It requires three courageous components: taking responsibility for your experience, facing your dark side, and representing yourself authentically to others. This balance helps prevent the dysfunctional patterns seen in the relationship between Jack and his father Leroy. Jack joined his father's struggling construction business, bringing fresh ideas to improve profitability. Instead of appreciating Jack's contributions, Leroy felt threatened, responding with anger, door-slamming, and criticism: "You think you know more than me? I've worked in construction longer than you've been alive." Jack walked on eggshells, hiding information and apologizing for things that weren't his fault. Neither was winning the inner game—Jack compensated for dysfunction while Leroy lost control of his emotions. Understanding how the brain processes emotions can help us develop better self-regulation. When triggered, the amygdala (part of the limbic system controlling emotion and survival) overrides the prefrontal cortex (responsible for executive function and good decision-making). Building emotional integrity requires strengthening your prefrontal cortex so you aren't victimized by subconscious programming and triggers. Our interpretations of emotions often work against us. When anger arises, we typically view it as justification for lashing out rather than a signal that we need more information before acting. Consider being stuck in traffic behind an unmoving car at a green light. Your initial angry interpretation changes completely upon discovering the driver is experiencing a medical emergency. The situation remains the same, but your understanding transforms your response. To build emotional integrity, practice four key steps. First, stand on the bridge and watch the movie—observe your behavior patterns when emotions take over rather than being swept away by them. Second, feel without acting—notice bodily sensations when triggered (hot neck, racing heart) but resist the urge to react impulsively. Third, stop blaming and making excuses—recognize that blame is simply a shortcut for avoiding responsibility. Fourth, tell yourself the truth about your feelings while challenging your narrative—question your assumptions about others' intentions. When working with others who lack emotional regulation, remember these three rules: you are responsible for your thoughts, feelings and actions; others are responsible for theirs; and disagreement doesn't ruin relationships—disrespect does. This perspective frees you from taking on everyone else's emotional work while still allowing for empathy and understanding. Emotional integrity doesn't emerge from reading about it but through consistent practice and courage. The evidence of improvement comes when you maintain composure in situations that previously triggered you, set appropriate boundaries, and recognize when you're at capacity. By mastering emotional integrity, you'll spend less time gossiping, holding grudges, or feeling taken advantage of, and more time addressing issues directly with those involved.

Chapter 5: Create Supportive Structures

Structure determines behavior in profound ways that often go unrecognized. Consider the story of graffiti artist JonOne, whose painting was vandalized by a young couple at an exhibition in South Korea. The couple added their own strokes to the artwork, resulting in damage to a painting valued at $400,000. But what if they weren't intentionally vandalizing? What if they misunderstood the artist's intention, interpreting the paint cans and brushes displayed in front of the mural as an invitation to participate? This illustrates how visible structures (the painting, location, open paint cans) and invisible structures (understandings, interpretations, expectations) shape behavior. Our perceptions create "structures of knowing" that differ based on our experiences, education, and influences. When these structures clash without clarity, conflict naturally emerges. The physical environment significantly impacts workplace behavior and conflict. LinkedIn Learning in Santa Barbara exemplifies intentional structure design that supports employee well-being and productivity. Their environment includes catered meals, snack stations, game areas, and flexible work schedules. This abundance mentality creates a culture where employees help each other and collaborate effectively. The result isn't just happy workers; it's a workplace where conflict is manageable because basic needs are met, allowing cognitive resources to focus on higher-level concerns. Leaders can work with both visible and invisible structures to reduce unnecessary conflict. During the COVID-19 pandemic, those with stable work environments generally experienced less stress despite global uncertainty. Even small environmental improvements can make substantial differences—a rotation system for workers in high-temperature areas, additional chairs for comfortable work, or flexible schedules for employees with childcare challenges. Decision-making itself functions as a powerful structure that shapes behavior. Consider how Aldi grocery stores prevent shopping carts from being abandoned in parking lots by requiring a quarter deposit that customers get back upon returning the cart. This simple structural decision eliminates conflicts over cart retrieval and reduces staffing needs. In contrast, stores without this system struggle with scattered carts and frustrated customers. Leadership behavior constitutes perhaps the most influential structure in any organization. When senior leaders avoid addressing issues or make excuses for their own behavior, they create a shadow that extends throughout the organization. One executive justified consistently showing up late while expecting punctuality from others, creating a structure of inconsistency and misalignment. Similarly, a senior leader named Thomas received a pass for his harsh, insensitive communication style because of his industry knowledge and connections, while others faced consequences for similar behavior. The most effective leaders understand that every decision creates structures that either facilitate collaboration or generate conflict. By intentionally designing both physical environments and invisible systems like decision-making processes, communication protocols, and accountability mechanisms, leaders can create conditions where productive work naturally flourishes and unnecessary conflict diminishes.

Chapter 6: Practice Resistance Training

Working with difficult, aggressive, or high-conflict individuals requires resistance training—the capacity to remain composed and focused despite challenging behaviors. Sherri B., a consultant in the male-dominated public safety industry, demonstrated this skill when presenting costly recommendations to a board of county commissioners. As she outlined needed improvements for an outdated 911 center, Mr. Mason, a notoriously contrarian commissioner, threw his pen on the table, pointed his finger at her, and demanded, "Well, where do you think we're going to get this big pot of gold?" Without missing a beat, Sherri responded, "Mr. Mason, that's your decision. My job was to do the investigation and deliver the information to you." By staying grounded and focused despite feeling frustrated, Sherri avoided taking the bait that would have derailed the conversation. Her training had taught her to stay within project scope and remain dispassionate. Resistance training begins with understanding what resistance actually is: the nonacceptance of what is and the inability or unwillingness to make powerful choices. When we can't make peace with reality and continue wanting something or someone else to change without seeing our own choices, we remain stuck. Resistance manifests as complaining, negativity, blaming, resentment, game-playing, noncompliance, disrespect, excuses, and innuendos. An easy way to identify resistance is through the SAND patterns: being Stuck, Attached, Negative, and Distracted. Being stuck means wasting time in indecision without resolution. Attachment occurs when we can't let go of how things used to be or should be. Negativity spreads like a virus, with negative comments sticking while positive ones slide off. Distraction takes us off course, particularly in conversations where we engage in verbal ping-pong rather than addressing core issues. There are three forms of resistance: your resistance, their resistance, and your resistance to their resistance. You can only work on the first and third types. Your own resistance diminishes when you recognize your choices in any situation. When facing a difficult person like Mr. Mason, you must accept them as they are rather than wishing they would change. Most importantly, avoid resisting their resistance—taking on their success more than they do or trying too hard to create change—which drains your energy without productive results. The fulcrum point of change is willingness. When someone says, "I would, but it takes too long" or "Yes, but I don't have time," they're displaying resistance. Rather than arguing with their reality, use the magic phrase: "Are you willing?" This shifts the conversation from excuses to possibilities. For example: Employee: "But it's going to be difficult." Leader: "Yes, it might be. Are you willing to do it anyway?" Employee: "Well, the real issue is that it's time-consuming." Leader: "I understand. Are you willing to allot the time?" This technique unearths the real barriers, which are often buried three or more objections deep. Alternatively, reduce the obstacle: "If I could reduce the difficulty by 10 percent, would you be willing?" The courage of willingness means accepting potential discomfort, misunderstanding, or difficult consequences. When you achieve this state, your energy changes, and you communicate both care and determination. You take ownership of your choices based on your values, not others' behaviors, just as Sherri did with Mr. Mason.

Chapter 7: Master Difficult Conversations

Many leaders avoid difficult conversations because they don't know how to start or fear negative emotional outcomes. Latisha, a healthcare administrator, delayed addressing her receptionist Janelle's performance issues: "Janelle is a good employee, and we love her, but lately her performance is slipping. She's constantly running to the restroom or checking her phone." Latisha's hesitation reflected a common truth—we avoid conversations not because we don't want to hurt others' feelings, but because we don't like how we feel when others get upset. Fortunately, there's a comprehensive blueprint for conducting these crucial conversations. The process begins with leadership clarity—defining the current situation, desired outcome, and obstacles before initiating any discussion. This preparation phase prevents reactive, emotion-driven approaches that often backfire. The first skill in the blueprint is setting a clear intention. Unlike goals focused solely on outcomes, intentions consider both outcomes and emotional experience. Compare "My intention is to talk about how we can elevate your sales numbers" (forward-moving, providing emotional safety) with "My intention is to find out why your sales are lagging" (problem-focused, potentially accusatory). Before setting intentions, ensure you've processed any lingering resentment or anger that might sabotage the conversation. Next, state observed behavior rather than making assumptions or generalizations. Instead of saying "You have a bad attitude," specify "You have missed three deadlines this month." Instead of "She is rude and obnoxious," say "She interrupts at meetings." This technique creates space for genuine dialogue without triggering defensiveness. The third skill involves speaking to the vision rather than focusing on problems. Rather than saying "I don't want you to keep rolling your eyes," say "What I want is to have an open dialogue when you disagree." This subtle shift directs energy toward solutions instead of dwelling on frustrations. Making a business case for the conversation connects individual behavior to organizational outcomes. For example: "This behavior affects engagement at important team meetings and makes others afraid to speak up as well." This demonstrates the conversation isn't personal preference but has real business implications. Once you've established this foundation, shift to employee clarity through curiosity and consultant-like thinking. Ask open questions like "Walk me through your thought process" or "What changed over the last three weeks?" Listen objectively for issues related to clarity, skills, priorities, resources, or willingness. Often what appears to be attitude or motivation problems actually stems from misunderstood expectations or inadequate training. Practice radical listening—the ability to hear difficult feedback without interrupting, defending, or explaining. This requires self-discipline but creates space for real understanding. Use phrases like "I see" or "That sounds frustrating" to acknowledge feelings without getting derailed. If you encounter resistance, use the magic phrase "Would you be willing..." to test commitment rather than arguing. Finally, establish clear agreement and accountability by scheduling follow-up meetings to review progress and provide additional coaching. The blueprint might seem straightforward on paper, but implementing it takes practice. Start with preparation, be patient with yourself, and remember that real skill development happens through application, not just reading. With consistent practice, these conversations become not just manageable but opportunities for growth and improved performance.

Summary

Throughout these pages, we've explored how conflict can transform from a dreaded challenge into a powerful catalyst for leadership growth. The journey from conflict to courage isn't about eliminating disagreement but about expanding your capacity to navigate it with clarity, emotional integrity, and purpose. As the book wisely reminds us, "The story that's been resolved no longer needs to be told." When we release old narratives of avoidance or aggression, we create space for new leadership identities based on values and vision rather than fear. Your leadership journey begins with a single courageous step—perhaps initiating that difficult conversation you've been avoiding, questioning an assumption about a challenging colleague, or examining your own resistance patterns. Remember that building courage happens through practice, not perfection. You'll know your efforts are worthwhile when you no longer get triggered by the person who once drove you crazy, when you summon the strength to listen radically instead of winning arguments, and when you see improved performance because you addressed issues promptly and respectfully. The path from conflict to courage may require climbing your own "Mud Hill," but the view from the top—of enhanced relationships, clearer communication, and empowered leadership—is absolutely worth the climb.

About Author

Loading...

Marlene Chism

High-level leaders seek Marlene’s expertise as a thought partner, advisor or coach when going through periods of transition or change. Organizations seek Marlene’s leadership development courses to teach mid-level and senior leaders the strategic communication skills to initiate conversations that get results and increase accountability.She’s the author of four books, including Stop Workplace Drama; No-Drama Leadership; 7 Ways to Stop Drama in Your Healthcare Practice, and From Conflict to Courage: How to Stop Avoiding and Start Leading.Marlene is an expert on the LinkedIn Learning platform offering courses in Anger Management; Difficult Conversations; Difficult Conversations for Managers, and Working with High Conflict People as a Manager.Marlene has a degree in Communications from Drury University and a master’s degree in Human Resources Development from Webster University. She’s an advanced practitioner in Narrative Coaching.To inquire about working with Marlene please contact [email protected]

Read more