Home/Business/Inclusion on Purpose
Loading...
Inclusion on Purpose cover

Inclusion on Purpose

An Intersectional Approach to Creating a Culture of Belonging at Work

4.3 (778 ratings)
19 minutes read | Text | 8 key ideas
In a world where the buzzwords "diversity" and "inclusion" often echo without action, Ruchika Tulshyan's "Inclusion on Purpose" stands as a clarion call for real change. This transformative guide doesn't just spotlight the systemic hurdles faced by women of color in the workplace; it challenges leaders to dismantle them with deliberate, impactful strategies. Tulshyan dismantles the myth of a "level playing field," advocating for bold moves beyond mere lip service—it's time to embrace "culture add" over "culture fit," to ensure that every voice not only joins the chorus but leads it. Here, inclusion is a practiced discipline, not a passive promise, offering a blueprint for workplaces that don't just survive on diversity but thrive because of it. This book is a must-read for those ready to make inclusion a relentless pursuit rather than a reluctant afterthought.

Categories

Business, Nonfiction, Self Help, Leadership, Audiobook, Management, Feminism, Historical Romance, Society, Social Justice

Content Type

Book

Binding

Hardcover

Year

2022

Publisher

The MIT Press

Language

English

ASIN

0262046555

ISBN

0262046555

ISBN13

9780262046558

File Download

PDF | EPUB

Inclusion on Purpose Plot Summary

Introduction

Workplace inclusion is more than a buzzword—it's a leadership imperative that fundamentally transforms how organizations function and thrive in our diverse world. Creating environments where everyone, particularly women of color, can bring their authentic selves to work requires intentional effort, not passive hope. This intersectional approach challenges conventional leadership frameworks by examining how overlapping identities create unique barriers to advancement and belonging in professional settings. The pursuit of inclusion demands both personal awareness and systemic change. Leaders must first recognize their own privilege and biases before they can effectively dismantle exclusionary practices embedded within organizational structures. By centering the experiences of those most marginalized, especially women who navigate both racial and gender discrimination simultaneously, we gain insights that benefit everyone in the workplace. The subsequent chapters explore both individual behaviors and organizational policies that cultivate genuine inclusion—from developing empathy as a leadership skill to creating equitable hiring practices that recognize talent in all its forms.

Chapter 1: The Intersection of Race and Gender in Workplace Exclusion

Intersectionality fundamentally reshapes our understanding of workplace dynamics by illuminating how overlapping identities create unique challenges. When race and gender converge, women of color experience something greater than the sum of separate discriminations—they navigate a workplace designed neither for their gender nor their racial identity. This intersection creates blindspots in traditional diversity initiatives that address either race or gender separately, but fail to recognize their combined impact. Statistical evidence consistently demonstrates this intersectional disadvantage. Women of color experience the steepest drop-off between entry-level representation and leadership positions compared to all other demographic groups. They face "prove-it-again" bias where they must repeatedly demonstrate their competence, while simultaneously navigating "tightrope bias" that penalizes them whether they appear too assertive or too passive. This double bind creates significant barriers to advancement that neither white women nor men of color face to the same degree. The concrete ceiling—more impenetrable than the glass ceiling—manifests through both subtle microaggressions and systemic barriers. Women of color report feeling simultaneously hypervisible yet invisible in workplace settings. Their mistakes receive disproportionate scrutiny while their accomplishments often go unrecognized or are attributed to others. When they speak up about experiencing bias, they face higher risks of retaliation than their white counterparts, creating a silencing effect that preserves the status quo. Understanding this intersectional dynamic requires examining privilege—the unearned advantages certain identities confer in professional settings. Privilege isn't something people choose, but recognizing it creates responsibility. When leaders acknowledge how their race, gender, education, or socioeconomic status has shaped their professional journey, they develop crucial awareness that enables meaningful change. This acknowledgment isn't about shame but about understanding different lived experiences and leveraging one's advantages to create more equitable workplaces. Challenging meritocracy myths forms another cornerstone of addressing intersectional exclusion. The notion that hard work alone determines success ignores systemic barriers that disproportionately impact women of color. When organizations truly examine their "objective" evaluation criteria, they often discover these standards were designed with dominant groups in mind. Inclusive leadership requires questioning assumptions about what constitutes excellence, professionalism, or leadership potential.

Chapter 2: Developing an Inclusion Mindset Through Personal Awareness

An inclusion mindset represents a fundamental shift in how leaders approach diversity and workplace culture. Unlike passive statements of support for inclusion, this mindset requires active engagement, continuous learning, and willingness to examine personal biases. It shares characteristics with Carol Dweck's growth mindset concept—believing that inclusive behaviors can be cultivated rather than viewing them as fixed traits that some possess and others don't. The BRIDGE framework offers practical guidance for developing this mindset. The acronym stands for: Be uncomfortable, Reflect on what you don't know, Invite feedback, Defensiveness doesn't help, Grow from mistakes, and Expect that change takes time. This framework acknowledges that inclusion work inevitably creates discomfort as leaders confront their own biases and privilege. Rather than avoiding this discomfort, inclusive leaders lean into it, recognizing it as essential to growth. Self-reflection forms the cornerstone of inclusive leadership development. This means honestly assessing gaps in understanding about communities different from one's own. White leaders, for instance, might need to examine their understanding of racial discrimination, while male leaders might need to deepen their knowledge of gender bias. Without this reflection, even well-meaning inclusion efforts can inadvertently reinforce harmful stereotypes or fail to address the most significant barriers. Actively soliciting feedback—particularly from those with marginalized identities—proves essential to developing an inclusion mindset. However, this comes with responsibilities. Leaders must create psychological safety for honest feedback, ensure this emotional labor is acknowledged and compensated, and most importantly, demonstrate they've listened by taking concrete action. When women of color see that sharing their experiences leads to meaningful change rather than defensive reactions, trust gradually builds. Overcoming defensiveness represents perhaps the greatest challenge in developing an inclusion mindset. When confronted with evidence of bias or exclusion, the natural human response often involves denial, justification, or deflection. Inclusive leaders recognize these defensive reactions within themselves and consciously work to overcome them. They understand that intent doesn't negate impact—well-meaning actions can still cause harm when they stem from unconscious bias or lack of awareness. Viewing inclusion as a continuous journey rather than a destination characterizes leaders with this mindset. They recognize that creating inclusive workplaces requires ongoing commitment, not one-time initiatives or diversity statements. This perspective allows for learning from inevitable mistakes without abandoning the larger goal of creating workplaces where everyone, especially those with intersecting marginalized identities, can thrive authentically.

Chapter 3: Creating Equitable Organizational Structures and Practices

Equitable organizations require intentional design rather than hoping inclusion will naturally emerge from good intentions. Hiring processes present a critical starting point, as they determine who enters the organization and their initial experiences. Traditional practices around "culture fit" often perpetuate homogeneity by favoring candidates who resemble existing team members. Shifting toward "culture add" reframes diversity as a competitive advantage that brings fresh perspectives rather than a compliance requirement. Job descriptions and candidate requirements frequently contain hidden biases that disproportionately screen out women of color. Requirements for specific educational credentials, industry experience, or "leadership presence" often serve as proxies for race and gender without predicting actual performance. Removing unnecessary degree requirements, emphasizing skills over pedigree, and creating transparent, structured interview processes helps mitigate these biases. Organizations leading in this area deliberately interrupt bias by requiring diverse candidate slates and interview panels. Pay equity represents another structural pillar of inclusive organizations. Women of color experience the most significant wage gaps—a manifestation of both gender and racial discrimination. This results not just from negotiation differences but from systemic undervaluation of their contributions and concentration in lower-paid roles. Effective approaches include regular pay audits disaggregated by both race and gender, transparent salary bands, elimination of salary history questions, and proactive adjustments when disparities are identified. Distribution of opportunities beyond compensation also requires scrutiny. Research shows that women of color receive less access to "glamour work"—high-visibility assignments that lead to advancement—and more "office housework" that consumes time without recognition. Inclusive organizations track assignment patterns, create rotation systems for administrative tasks, and ensure women of color receive sponsorship for career-enhancing projects. Promotion and advancement systems often contain subtle biases in how potential is evaluated. Women of color frequently face higher standards while receiving less specific, development-oriented feedback than their white male counterparts. Organizations committed to equity implement structured promotion criteria, analyze patterns in performance reviews for bias, and hold managers accountable for developing diverse talent. They recognize that potential often looks different across demographic groups due to varying opportunities and expectations. Physical and cultural workplace environments also require examination through an equity lens. From office layouts to meeting protocols, many standard practices unintentionally exclude. Networking events centered around alcohol, unstated expectations about work hours that disadvantage caregivers, and cultural norms that value certain communication styles over others can all create barriers. Inclusive organizations proactively consider how policies impact different groups and make accommodations that benefit everyone.

Chapter 4: From Feedback to Psychological Safety: Building Trust

Psychological safety—the belief that one can speak up without fear of punishment or humiliation—forms the foundation of inclusive workplaces. For women of color, this safety cannot be assumed but must be deliberately cultivated. When team members feel psychologically safe, they contribute more ideas, take appropriate risks, and acknowledge mistakes—all essential behaviors for innovation and growth. Without it, valuable perspectives remain unheard and organizations lose talent. Effective feedback systems play a crucial role in building psychological safety. When women of color receive vague, style-focused feedback rather than specific, actionable guidance on their work, they cannot develop professionally. Research shows this happens frequently—women of color receive comments about their tone or demeanor while men receive substantive feedback on work product. Implementing structured feedback frameworks like Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI) helps address this disparity by focusing evaluation on specific actions and outcomes rather than subjective impressions. Organizations must also create clear, accessible channels for reporting bias and discrimination. Many women of color describe feeling trapped when experiencing exclusion—formal reporting processes often expose them to retaliation, while remaining silent damages their well-being and career progression. Some organizations have successfully implemented confidential reporting systems, ombuds offices, or transformative justice approaches that address harm without automatically escalating to punitive measures. Examining how criticism and dissent are handled reveals much about an organization's psychological safety. When women of color raise concerns about exclusionary practices, their feedback is often dismissed as "complaining" or they're labeled as "difficult." Organizations with high psychological safety recognize this pattern and train leaders to receive feedback about bias non-defensively. They understand that women of color often serve as canaries in the coal mine—identifying problems that affect many but that others have the privilege to ignore. Active bystandership represents another crucial element of psychological safety. When women of color experience exclusion or bias, the response of colleagues shapes their sense of belonging. Too often, witnesses remain silent out of discomfort or fear of getting involved. Organizations building psychological safety explicitly teach intervention strategies and celebrate those who speak up against exclusion. They recognize that responsibility for inclusion cannot rest solely on those experiencing marginalization. Trust ultimately emerges from consistency between stated values and actual behaviors. Organizations may claim to value diversity while continuing practices that disadvantage women of color. This misalignment damages psychological safety more than having no diversity statements at all. Building trust requires leaders to acknowledge gaps between aspirations and reality, take accountability for harm when it occurs, and demonstrate commitment to change through concrete actions rather than symbolic gestures.

Chapter 5: Inclusive Technology and Global Market Considerations

Technology both reflects and reinforces societal biases, creating particular challenges for inclusive workplaces. The technology industry itself demonstrates significant exclusion—women of color remain dramatically underrepresented, especially in technical and leadership roles. This homogeneity has consequences beyond the industry itself, as the technologies created shape everyone's experiences. When teams lack diversity, they build products that work well for some groups while failing others, sometimes with serious consequences. Algorithmic bias exemplifies how exclusion becomes embedded in technology. Facial recognition systems that fail to identify darker-skinned faces, recruitment algorithms that penalize women's resumes, and healthcare algorithms that allocate fewer resources to Black patients all demonstrate how technology can amplify rather than mitigate discrimination. These biases stem not from malicious intent but from homogeneous development teams failing to consider experiences different from their own and training systems on non-representative data. Social media platforms and communication technologies present particular challenges for women of color. Online harassment disproportionately targets women of color, yet platforms have been slow to implement effective protections. Within workplace collaboration tools, patterns from in-person interactions often reproduce—women of color get interrupted more frequently, their contributions receive less acknowledgment, and their communication styles may be misinterpreted through dominant cultural lenses. Inclusive organizations actively counter these dynamics. In global contexts, inclusion requires cultural humility rather than applying Western frameworks universally. Different societies have varying histories of colonization, migration, and social hierarchies that shape how exclusion manifests. What constitutes a marginalized identity varies significantly across contexts—caste in India, tribal affiliation in parts of Africa, or religion in many regions may create barriers similar to race in Western contexts. Global organizations must engage local knowledge rather than imposing standardized approaches. Immigration status adds another dimension to workplace inclusion globally. Immigrant women of color often navigate multiple layers of vulnerability—visa restrictions that tie them to employers, language barriers, credential recognition challenges, and disconnection from support networks. Organizations that recognize these challenges implement tailored support systems rather than treating all employees as if they face identical circumstances. Creating inclusive technology and global workplaces requires both diverse representation and inclusive processes. When women of color participate meaningfully in design and decision-making, they identify potential harms and opportunities that homogeneous teams miss. This participation must occur throughout the product lifecycle—from conception through development, testing, and monitoring post-launch impacts. Similar principles apply to policy development in global organizations—inclusion must be substantive rather than symbolic.

Chapter 6: The Economic and Moral Case for Purposeful Inclusion

Inclusive workplaces deliver measurable economic benefits alongside moral imperatives. Research consistently demonstrates that organizations with diverse leadership outperform their more homogeneous counterparts on profitability, innovation, and risk management. These advantages emerge not from diversity itself but from inclusion that allows diverse perspectives to meaningfully influence decisions. When women of color can fully contribute their insights without assimilation pressure, organizations access previously untapped sources of competitive advantage. Innovation thrives in environments where divergent thinking meets psychological safety. When team members feel safe to challenge assumptions and propose unconventional approaches, creative solutions emerge. Women of color often bring valuable perspectives informed by navigating multiple cultural contexts and solving problems with limited resources. Organizations that include these perspectives access broader solution spaces than those relying on homogeneous thinking. Studies in fields from scientific research to product development confirm this innovation advantage. Talent acquisition and retention represent another economic dimension of inclusion. Organizations known for inclusive cultures attract broader candidate pools and retain valuable talent that competitors lose. For women of color who experience exclusion, leaving organizations often presents their only viable option for career advancement. The resulting turnover creates significant costs—recruitment expenses, lost institutional knowledge, and productivity declines during transitions. Inclusive organizations avoid these costs while building reputational advantages in competitive talent markets. Beyond economic calculations, purposeful inclusion addresses fundamental questions of fairness and human dignity. Systems that systematically disadvantage people based on identity characteristics violate basic ethical principles of justice and equal opportunity. As workplaces increasingly influence access to economic security, professional fulfillment, and social connection, their inclusivity directly impacts social equity. Organizations that recognize this moral dimension understand inclusion not as optional but as essential to responsible business practice. Climate change, global health challenges, and technological disruption all require diverse perspectives for effective solutions. The complex problems facing organizations and societies cannot be solved through homogeneous thinking. Women of color, with experiences navigating multiple systems and bridging diverse communities, bring particularly valuable perspectives to these challenges. By including these perspectives, organizations not only advance their own interests but contribute to broader social resilience. Ultimately, purposeful inclusion requires sustained commitment rather than performative gestures. Organizations demonstrating genuine inclusion integrate it throughout their operations rather than relegating it to specialized departments or isolated initiatives. Their leaders understand that inclusion is never "finished" but requires ongoing attention as contexts evolve. They measure progress through substantive metrics while recognizing that numbers alone cannot capture the quality of inclusion. Most importantly, they recognize that inclusion benefits everyone, creating workplaces where all employees can contribute their full potential.

Summary

The intersectional approach to workplace inclusion transcends traditional diversity initiatives by addressing how overlapping identities create unique barriers for women of color. By examining both individual mindsets and organizational structures, this framework provides a comprehensive path toward workplaces where everyone can authentically belong. The most powerful insight emerges from centering the experiences of those at the margins—when organizations design for the most excluded, they create environments that benefit everyone. Creating truly inclusive workplaces requires sustained commitment at both personal and systemic levels. Leaders must develop awareness of their own privilege and biases while implementing equitable hiring, compensation, and advancement practices. By cultivating psychological safety and embracing diverse perspectives in technology development and global operations, organizations unlock both moral and economic benefits. The journey toward inclusion remains ongoing, but each intentional step builds workplaces where diverse talent can flourish rather than merely survive—ultimately transforming not just organizations but society itself.

Best Quote

“The problem isn’t men, it’s patriarchy. The problem isn’t white people, it’s white supremacy. The problem isn’t straight people, it’s homophobia. Recognize systems of oppression before letting individual defensiveness stop you from dismantling them.” ― Ruchika Tulshyan, Inclusion on Purpose: An Intersectional Approach to Creating a Culture of Belonging at Work

Review Summary

Strengths: The book is praised for its necessity in promoting inclusivity, offering strategic actions to build an inclusive workplace culture, and providing practical tools and resources. The author is commended for inspiring action and realism about the time and collective effort required for inclusivity.\nWeaknesses: The review notes a slow start and a general struggle with non-fiction, although these are not major criticisms of the book itself.\nOverall Sentiment: Enthusiastic\nKey Takeaway: The book is considered essential reading for fostering inclusivity in the workplace, particularly for managerial leadership, and is valued for its actionable advice and realistic approach to creating an inclusive environment.

About Author

Loading...
Ijeoma Oluo Avatar

Ijeoma Oluo

Ijeoma Oluo is a Seattle-based writer, speaker, and Internet Yeller. She’s the author of the New York Times Best-Seller So You Want to Talk about Race, published in January by Seal Press. Named one of the The Root’s 100 Most Influential African Americans in 2017, one of the Most Influential People in Seattle by Seattle Magazine, one of the 50 Most Influential Women in Seattle by Seattle Met, and winner of the of the 2018 Feminist Humanist Award by the American Humanist Society, Oluo’s work focuses primarily on issues of race and identity, feminism, social and mental health, social justice, the arts, and personal essay. Her writing has been featured in The Washington Post, NBC News, Elle Magazine, TIME, The Stranger, and the Guardian, among other outlets.

Read more

Download PDF & EPUB

To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.

Book Cover

Inclusion on Purpose

By Ijeoma Oluo

0:00/0:00

Build Your Library

Select titles that spark your interest. We'll find bite-sized summaries you'll love.