Killing Lincoln

Killing Lincoln Plot Summary

Introduction

April 14, 1865 was a day that would forever change the course of American history. As citizens across the Northern states celebrated the end of the Civil War, a far more sinister plot was unfolding in Washington D.C. The assassination of President Abraham Lincoln marked not just the tragic end of a remarkable leader's life, but also a critical turning point in America's path toward reconstruction and reunification. The final hours of Lincoln's life and the dramatic twelve-day manhunt that followed represent one of the most intensely studied yet persistently misunderstood periods in American history. What drove actor John Wilkes Booth to commit such a heinous act? How did this meticulous conspiracy unfold and nearly decapitate the entire federal government? And perhaps most importantly, how might American history have unfolded differently had Lincoln lived to oversee the reconstruction of a shattered nation? These questions continue to fascinate historians and ordinary citizens alike, as the assassination's aftermath still reverberates through American politics and society more than 150 years later.

Chapter 1: The Final Days of War: Lee's Retreat and Surrender

In early April 1865, the end of the Civil War was drawing near, yet the outcome remained perilous and uncertain. General Robert E. Lee's Army of Northern Virginia was desperately retreating westward from Petersburg, pursued relentlessly by Union forces under General Ulysses S. Grant. The Confederate army, once a formidable fighting force, was now reduced to approximately 30,000 starving, exhausted men, many without proper footwear or adequate clothing. The retreat was nothing short of catastrophic for the Confederates. Lee had hoped to reach supplies stockpiled at Amelia Court House, but upon arrival on April 4th, he discovered to his horror that the 350,000 expected rations were not there—instead, the boxcars contained only ammunition and artillery harnesses. This devastating setback forced his weakened army to forage in an already depleted countryside, losing precious time as Grant's forces closed in. The decisive moment came at Sayler's Creek on April 6th, in what Confederate officers would later call "Black Thursday." In this brutal battle, nearly 8,000 Confederate soldiers were killed or captured, including several of Lee's top generals and even his own son, Custis Lee. The fighting was described by witnesses as some of the most vicious of the entire war, with men engaging in desperate hand-to-hand combat. One Confederate officer recalled seeing soldiers "kill each other with bayonets and the butts of muskets, and even bite each other's throats and ears and noses, rolling on the ground like wild beasts." With his army effectively cut in half and his retreat routes diminishing, Lee finally recognized the inevitability of defeat. On April 9th, Palm Sunday, he surrendered to Grant at Appomattox Court House. Grant's terms were remarkably lenient—Confederate soldiers could return home with their personal effects and horses, with no fear of prosecution. This generosity reflected Lincoln's own wishes for a healing rather than punitive approach to the defeated South. As Lee rode back to his troops after the surrender, soldiers wept openly, knowing their long struggle had ended in defeat. The formal end of the bloodiest conflict in American history was at hand, but the assassination that would forever alter its aftermath was just five days away.

Chapter 2: A Nation's Brief Celebration: Victory and Hope

The week following Lee's surrender at Appomattox was one of unprecedented jubilation throughout the Northern states. Washington D.C. erupted in spontaneous celebrations—church bells tolled continuously, fireworks exploded in the night sky, and massive crowds gathered in front of the White House calling for Lincoln to speak. The President, however, remained characteristically thoughtful and forward-looking amid the revelry, his mind already focused on the monumental task of national reconstruction. On April 11, Lincoln delivered what would be his final public address from the White House balcony. Rather than offering the celebratory rhetoric the crowd expected, Lincoln spoke soberly about the challenges ahead, particularly regarding the extension of voting rights to educated Black men and those who had fought for the Union. This was not what many in the crowd wanted to hear, and some, including John Wilkes Booth who was present that night, were enraged by Lincoln's vision of expanded Black citizenship. Behind the scenes, the President was actively working to implement his reconciliatory approach to the defeated South. He met repeatedly with his Cabinet to discuss reconstruction plans, telling them, "We must extinguish our resentments if we expect harmony and union." Lincoln's vision for post-war America was remarkably free of vengeance, focusing instead on quickly reintegrating Southern states back into the Union with minimal punishment for former Confederates except their leaders. The celebration of victory was also a time of deep personal happiness for Lincoln. He was observed by his wife Mary to be in better spirits than he had been since before their son Willie's death three years earlier. On April 14, Good Friday, the Lincolns took an afternoon carriage ride together, during which the President spoke optimistically about their future. "We have had a hard time of it since we came to Washington," he told Mary, "but the war is over, and with God's blessing we may hope for four years of peace and happiness, and then we will go back to Illinois and pass the rest of our lives in quiet." This brief period of personal contentment and national celebration would tragically be cut short within hours, creating one of history's most poignant examples of how quickly triumph can turn to tragedy.

Chapter 3: The Conspiracy: Booth's Plot Takes Shape

John Wilkes Booth was not merely a deranged lone assassin but the mastermind of an elaborate conspiracy that aimed to decapitate the entire Union government in a single night. Booth, a famous 26-year-old actor from a renowned theatrical family, harbored deep Confederate sympathies and an intense, almost pathological hatred for Abraham Lincoln. He viewed the President not as a legitimate leader but as a tyrant who had destroyed the Southern way of life and was now proposing radical changes like voting rights for Black Americans. Originally, Booth had planned to kidnap Lincoln rather than kill him. Beginning in August 1864, he had recruited a small group of co-conspirators including Lewis Powell, David Herold, George Atzerodt, and others. The group had already made at least two failed kidnapping attempts. However, as the Confederacy's military situation deteriorated and Lincoln began speaking about Black suffrage, Booth's plans evolved from abduction to assassination. By April 1865, evidence suggests Booth was receiving funding and possibly direction from the Confederate Secret Service, with some money transfers being channeled through Montreal, Canada. What made Booth particularly dangerous was his combination of celebrity status, theatrical charisma, and intimate knowledge of Washington's geography. As a famous actor, he could move freely around the capital without suspicion, had access to theaters and prominent buildings, and knew the city's escape routes. He was also intimately familiar with Ford's Theatre, where he had performed many times and was treated like family by the staff. This allowed him to carefully scout the building and plan his attack with precision. The conspiracy that ultimately unfolded on April 14 was far more extensive than many Americans realize. While Booth himself would assassinate Lincoln at Ford's Theatre, he assigned Lewis Powell to murder Secretary of State William Seward and George Atzerodt to kill Vice President Andrew Johnson. The simultaneous elimination of these leaders would create unprecedented governmental chaos, potentially reviving Confederate hopes. The plot represented what some historians consider the first major terrorist conspiracy in American history—a coordinated attack against multiple government leaders designed to create maximum political instability. Though Booth successfully assassinated Lincoln, the failure of the other components of his plan would ultimately limit its impact on the course of Reconstruction, even as it profoundly changed America's political trajectory.

Chapter 4: April 14, 1865: Lincoln's Last Day

The final day of Abraham Lincoln's life began with surprising normality and even optimism. After four years of wartime strain, the 56-year-old President appeared more relaxed than he had in years. Rising early that Good Friday morning, Lincoln followed his custom of reading from the Bible before reviewing official correspondence. At breakfast with his family, he listened enthusiastically as his son Robert, who had just returned from witnessing Lee's surrender, described the historic events at Appomattox. Throughout the day, Lincoln balanced routine governmental business with forward-looking plans. He held a Cabinet meeting where Reconstruction policies were discussed, met with several political visitors including Speaker of the House Schuyler Colfax, and telegraphed orders to Virginia rescinding permission for the rebel legislature to convene. Though Lincoln's workday was filled with such business, his mood remained light. He even wrote a playful, romantic note to Mary inviting her for an afternoon carriage ride—a rare moment of levity for the often-melancholy President. That afternoon, Lincoln and Mary took their promised carriage ride, during which Lincoln spoke optimistically about their future. "Mary," he said, "we have had a hard time of it since we came to Washington, but the war is over, and with God's blessing we may hope for four years of peace and happiness, and then we will go back to Illinois and pass the rest of our lives in quiet." This rare glimpse of Lincoln imagining life beyond the presidency underscores the tragedy of what was to come. The decision to attend Ford's Theatre that evening was somewhat impromptu. General and Mrs. Grant had initially planned to join the Lincolns, but cancelled their plans, partly because Julia Grant disliked Mary Lincoln. Instead, Major Henry Rathbone and his fiancée Clara Harris were invited to join the presidential party. Lincoln himself was reportedly reluctant to go, telling his bodyguard William Crook, "I do not want to go," but felt obligated since it had been publicly announced. When Crook's shift ended that evening, Lincoln departed from their usual exchange of "Good night" with an unusual "Good-bye, Crook"—a detail that would later seem eerily prescient. Meanwhile, as Lincoln prepared for his evening at the theater, John Wilkes Booth was finalizing the details of his deadly conspiracy. He visited Ford's Theatre multiple times that day, preparing his escape route and even boring a peephole into the presidential box. By nightfall, Booth had confirmed his plans with his co-conspirators and was preparing to commit an act that would forever change American history. As Lincoln's carriage departed for Ford's Theatre shortly after 8:00 PM, the tragic collision course of these two men was set in motion.

Chapter 5: The Fatal Shot: Murder at Ford's Theatre

At approximately 10:15 PM on Good Friday, John Wilkes Booth slipped quietly into the presidential box at Ford's Theatre. The play, "Our American Cousin," was in its third act, and Lincoln sat in a rocking chair, his wife Mary beside him, both enjoying the performance. Taking advantage of incredibly lax security—Lincoln's assigned bodyguard John Parker had abandoned his post to get a drink at a nearby tavern—Booth faced no resistance as he entered the box. The moment Booth chose for his attack was calculated for maximum effect. He waited for a specific line in the play that always drew uproarious laughter: "Don't know the manners of good society, eh? Well, I guess I know enough to turn you inside out, old gal—you sockdologizing old man-trap." As the audience erupted in laughter, Booth pressed his derringer pistol to the back of Lincoln's head and pulled the trigger. The sound of the gunshot was partially masked by the audience's reaction, and many initially thought it was part of the performance. What happened next unfolded with shocking rapidity. After shooting Lincoln, Booth stabbed Major Rathbone in the arm when he attempted to intervene. The assassin then leapt from the box to the stage below, shouting "Sic semper tyrannis!"—"Thus always to tyrants!"—the Virginia state motto. In making his dramatic jump, Booth's spur caught on the Treasury Guard flag decorating the box, causing him to land awkwardly and break his left fibula. Despite this injury, he managed to limp across the stage and escape through the rear door to his waiting horse. Inside the theater, pandemonium erupted as the reality of what had happened became clear. Dr. Charles Leale, a 23-year-old army surgeon who happened to be in the audience, was the first physician to reach Lincoln. Finding the President unresponsive with a small bullet wound behind his left ear, Dr. Leale quickly determined that the wound was mortal, declaring, "His wound is impossible for him to recover." Lincoln was carefully carried across the street to the Petersen boarding house, where he was placed diagonally across a bed too small for his 6'4" frame. The scene at Lincoln's deathbed was one of profound emotion and historical significance. Mary Lincoln was overcome with grief, repeatedly entering the room to embrace her dying husband before being led away. Cabinet members, military officers, and Lincoln's son Robert gathered around the bed as the President's breathing grew increasingly labored. Throughout the night, Dr. Leale maintained a vigil, occasionally relieving pressure on Lincoln's brain by removing blood clots from the wound. At 7:22 AM on April 15, Abraham Lincoln drew his final breath. Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, who had been coordinating the government's response throughout the night, uttered the now-famous words: "Now he belongs to the ages."

Chapter 6: The Manhunt: Capturing America's Most Wanted

The manhunt for John Wilkes Booth and his co-conspirators became the largest in American history up to that time, combining military forces, detective work, and civilian participation in an unprecedented nationwide dragnet. Secretary of War Edwin Stanton personally took charge of the investigation, converting the War Department into a command center for the operation. Within hours of Lincoln's death, thousands of soldiers and federal agents were mobilized, checkpoints were established at bridges and roads leading out of Washington, and telegraph lines buzzed with descriptions of the suspects. Despite these measures, Booth managed to escape the immediate vicinity of Washington. After shooting Lincoln, he fled across the Navy Yard Bridge into Maryland with a companion, David Herold. The sentry at the bridge, unaware of the assassination, allowed them to pass despite a curfew being in effect. This critical security failure gave Booth valuable time to distance himself from the capital. For the next twelve days, Booth and Herold would navigate through southern Maryland's swamps and countryside, relying on a network of Confederate sympathizers for shelter and assistance. While Booth evaded capture, his co-conspirators faced different fates. Lewis Powell, who had brutally attacked Secretary of State William Seward and his family, wandered lost through Washington for three days before being captured when he unwittingly returned to Mary Surratt's boardinghouse while police were present. George Atzerodt, who had been assigned to kill Vice President Johnson but lost his nerve and got drunk instead, was captured at his cousin's farm in Maryland. Mary Surratt, owner of the boardinghouse where the conspirators had met, was also arrested, despite questions about her level of involvement. The chase narrowed as detective Lafayette Baker, a controversial figure with a shadowy past, joined the investigation. Using a combination of intelligence gathering and intuition, Baker correctly deduced that Booth was heading toward the Potomac River to cross into Virginia. On April 26, a detachment of the 16th New York Cavalry surrounded the Garrett farm near Port Royal, Virginia, where Booth and Herold had taken refuge in a tobacco barn. While Herold surrendered, Booth refused to come out, leading the soldiers to set the barn on fire. As the flames spread, Sergeant Boston Corbett shot Booth through a crack in the barn wall, severing his spinal cord. The assassin was dragged from the burning structure but died on the farmhouse porch a few hours later, reportedly looking at his hands and murmuring his final words: "Useless, useless." The manhunt concluded with eight alleged conspirators in custody, all of whom would be tried by a military commission rather than a civilian court—a controversial decision reflecting the extraordinary circumstances of wartime and assassination. This relentless pursuit not only brought Lincoln's killers to justice but also demonstrated the federal government's growing investigative capabilities, setting precedents for future national security operations.

Chapter 7: A Country in Mourning: Legacy and Impact

The assassination of Abraham Lincoln transformed what should have been a moment of national healing into a period of profound grief and political upheaval. The funeral arrangements for the fallen president became an unprecedented public spectacle, as Lincoln's body was transported by train from Washington to Springfield, Illinois, stopping in major cities along a 1,700-mile journey. An estimated 7 million Americans—roughly one-third of the Northern population—viewed Lincoln's body during this solemn procession, making it the most widely witnessed funeral in American history to that point. In the immediate aftermath, Northern anger toward the South intensified dramatically. Many Northerners, including some government officials, believed the assassination had been ordered by the Confederate leadership, though this was never proven. This suspicion fueled demands for harsh punishment of the South, undermining Lincoln's vision of a gentle reconciliation. Vice President Andrew Johnson, who succeeded Lincoln, initially adopted a more punitive stance toward the former Confederate states, famously declaring, "Treason must be made infamous, and traitors must be impoverished." The trial of the assassination conspirators reflected this shift toward severity. Eight defendants were tried before a military commission rather than a civilian court—a controversial decision that remains debated by legal scholars. After a trial lasting seven weeks, four conspirators—Lewis Powell, David Herold, George Atzerodt, and Mary Surratt—were sentenced to death and hanged on July 7, 1865. Surratt became the first woman ever executed by the federal government, despite pleas for clemency that never reached President Johnson. Perhaps the most profound impact of Lincoln's assassination was its effect on Reconstruction. Without Lincoln's moderating influence, the process of reuniting the nation became more contentious and ultimately less successful. Historian Eric Foner has argued that Lincoln's death "fundamentally altered the course of Reconstruction," removing the one leader with both the moral authority and political skill to guide the nation through this delicate transition. The harsh policies that eventually emerged under Radical Republican leadership created lasting resentments in the South, while failing to adequately protect the rights of freed slaves. The long shadow of Lincoln's assassination extends even to modern times. It fundamentally altered the security protocols surrounding American presidents, beginning a evolution toward the comprehensive protection provided by today's Secret Service. More subtly, Lincoln's martyrdom elevated him to a sacred figure in American memory, transforming a controversial wartime president into a nearly untouchable icon. His death at the moment of victory sealed his historical legacy as the savior of the Union, while forever leaving unanswered the question of what might have been had he lived to heal the nation he had preserved.

Summary

The assassination of Abraham Lincoln represents a pivotal moment when American history could have taken numerous alternative paths. Throughout the dramatic events of April 1865, we see the constant tension between forces of reconciliation and retribution, unity and division. Lincoln embodied a vision of healing and reintegration for the defeated South, famously declaring in his Second Inaugural Address, "With malice toward none, with charity for all." His murder effectively silenced this moderate voice at precisely the moment when it was most needed, allowing more radical voices to dominate the Reconstruction era. This historical watershed offers profound lessons for modern America. First, it demonstrates how individual actions can dramatically alter a nation's trajectory—Booth's bullet not only killed a president but also derailed a particular approach to national reconciliation. Second, it illustrates the fragility of democratic transitions, even in established republics. The peaceful transfer of power, which Americans often take for granted, was severely tested by both the Civil War and the assassination that followed it. Finally, Lincoln's assassination reminds us that the work of national unity is never fully complete; each generation must recommit to the principles of democratic governance and equal justice that Lincoln championed. As contemporary America continues to wrestle with issues of racial justice, political polarization, and the meaning of citizenship, the events of April 1865 offer both a cautionary tale and an inspiration for those seeking to perfect our union.

About Author

Loading...

Bill O'Reilly

Read more

Related Books by Bill O'Reilly

Loading...

Killing the Mob

Bill O'Reilly

The Fight Against Organized Crime in America

★★★★☆4.3

Loading...

Killing the Killers

Bill O'Reilly

The Secret War Against Terrorists

★★★★☆4.2

Loading...

Killing the Rising Sun

Bill O'Reilly

How America Vanquished World War II Japan

★★★★☆4.3