Say What You Mean

Say What You Mean Plot Summary

Introduction

Communication sits at the center of our lives, forming the foundation of our relationships, work, and well-being. Yet despite its fundamental importance, many of us struggle to express ourselves clearly or listen deeply to others. We find ourselves trapped in cycles of blame, defensiveness, or avoidance when facing difficult conversations. These patterns often leave us feeling misunderstood, disconnected, and unable to resolve even simple differences. What would it be like if you could navigate any conversation with presence, clarity, and compassion? Imagine having the tools to express your needs honestly while still maintaining connection, or the ability to listen deeply to someone with whom you strongly disagree. The path to transformative communication begins with three essential steps: leading with presence, approaching with curiosity and care, and focusing on what truly matters. Through mindful communication, we can create understanding that nurtures our relationships and allows us to engage more effectively with the world around us.

Chapter 1: Lead with Presence: Grounding Your Communication

Effective communication depends on our ability to be present. To say what we mean, we must first know what we mean, which requires listening inwardly and discerning what's true for us. Leading with presence means showing up as fully and completely as possible in our interactions with others. Oren Jay Sofer shares a poignant story about his father who grew up in 1940s British Palestine. His father told him how during his first weeks at a kibbutz at age thirteen, he would stand in his room each evening and watch the beautiful sunset over the fields. A few months later, he realized he had stopped noticing this daily spectacle. "It's always bothered me," his father said. "Why did I stop noticing it?" This simple story illustrates how easily we disconnect from our direct experience and the present moment. This disconnection affects our conversations profoundly. Have you ever tried talking with someone who was distracted or pulled out their smartphone mid-conversation? Or found yourself in an argument simply because one person wasn't listening? Many communication difficulties can be avoided by slowing down and being more present. When we're not here, we're probably on automatic. And if we're on automatic, we're less likely to remember the tools we've learned, access our own wisdom, or come from our best intentions. Mindfulness gives us a way to cultivate presence. It helps us recognize when we're on automatic and provides techniques to return to awareness. We can train ourselves to use reference points in the body—like feeling the weight of gravity, sensing our centerline, following our breath, or feeling our hands or feet—to anchor our attention. With practice, these simple methods help us maintain presence during conversations, even challenging ones. The benefits of presence extend beyond basic communication. It gives us back our lives, waking us up to experience the beauty of a sunset, the wonder of an old tree, or the mystery of human intimacy. It helps us remember to use communication tools we've learned and provides early warning signs when we feel activated or upset. Through presence, we develop the capacity to see others as autonomous individuals rather than extensions of our needs, opening new possibilities for dialogue and connection. Leading with presence is a skill that grows with practice. The more familiar we become with how it feels to be present, the more readily we can detect signs of being activated and create space to respond rather than react. This fundamental shift transforms how we navigate conversations and ultimately enhances the quality of our relationships.

Chapter 2: Approach with Curiosity and Care

Have you ever persevered through a challenging situation with a friend and emerged with deeper respect for one another? Or worked through a disagreement with a loved one and felt even closer afterward? Intimacy is often born in conflict. When we approach differences with curiosity and care, they can bring us together and help us know one another more fully. Daryl Davis, an African American musician, demonstrates the transformative power of approaching others with genuine curiosity. Growing up abroad, Davis didn't encounter racial prejudice until age ten when people threw rocks at him during a Cub Scout parade. This experience sparked a lifelong question: "How can you hate me when you don't know me?" Years later, after playing in an all-white bar, Davis befriended a white man who turned out to be connected to the KKK. Through patient, friendly conversation and a sincere desire to understand, Davis eventually formed relationships with many Klansmen. Over time, more than two hundred members left the organization after getting to know Davis. Though he never took formal communication training, Davis intuitively understood the power of approaching others with curiosity and care. This intention to understand represents a fundamental shift in how we orient ourselves in dialogue. It involves weeding out blame, defensiveness, and manipulation from our consciousness and instead focusing on creating a quality of connection that supports collaboration. When someone trusts that we're genuinely interested in understanding them—that we're not trying to win or prove them wrong—they can stop defending themselves and truly hear what we're saying. Coming from curiosity and care doesn't mean abandoning our own perspective or needs. Rather, it recognizes a simple truth: the more mutual understanding exists, the easier it is to work together and find creative solutions. When we comprehend the deeper reasons behind what each person wants, we can start to collaborate effectively. This approach rests on the view that beneath our behaviors, preferences, and desires lie fundamental human needs that we all share—for safety, belonging, connection, meaning, and contribution. To cultivate this approach in conversations, we need to build our capacity for curiosity and care. We practice honing in on what it feels like to have a genuine intention to understand so we can return to that place at will. We train ourselves to notice when we're operating from habitual tendencies of blame or defense, and we learn how to find our way back to openness and interest. This shift allows us to see conflict not as a dangerous situation where someone must win and someone must lose, but as an opportunity for greater understanding and creative problem-solving. Remember that the quality of your intention shapes both verbal and nonverbal communication. Your body language, tone of voice, and facial expressions all convey whether you're genuinely interested or merely going through the motions. By practicing curiosity and care even in simple everyday interactions, you develop the capacity to maintain this orientation even in challenging situations.

Chapter 3: Focus on What Matters: Identify Core Needs

Human beings are complex, and so is our communication. In any interaction, how do we determine what's relevant and what's not? How do we decide what to address first? The third step to effective communication is focusing on what matters—training our attention to identify the core needs and values at play. Marshall Rosenberg, the creator of Nonviolent Communication, identifies four key components that help us stay connected to our humanity and support collaboration: observations, feelings, needs, and requests. Instead of getting caught in blame or reactive judgment, we learn to discern what actually happened, how we feel about it, why those feelings arose, and what specific actions might address the situation. Amanda, a student of Sofer's, faced this challenge when her friend offered unsolicited parenting advice after witnessing Amanda's four-year-old son have a meltdown. The friend later emailed Amanda with more advice, leaving Amanda frustrated and unsure how to respond. When Amanda sought guidance, Sofer first offered empathy for her frustration and her longing for respect as a parent. Then they identified the different layers at play: their friendship, the friend's genuine desire to contribute, and Amanda's need to receive support in a way that worked for her. By focusing on these core needs rather than getting caught in the details of who said what, Amanda was able to approach the conversation more effectively. At the heart of this approach is understanding that all human actions are attempts to meet fundamental needs. Whether we want safety, connection, autonomy, or meaning, our strategies to meet these needs can differ dramatically, but the underlying needs themselves are universal. This perspective helps us transcend surface disagreements to find common ground. Conflict generally occurs at the level of strategies—what we want—while finding the needs behind those strategies reveals our shared humanity. Learning to identify needs takes practice. We start by expanding our vocabulary for needs and training our attention to see life through this lens. The more we can differentiate between our strategies (specific actions tied to particular times, places, or people) and our needs (universal human values), the more clarity and choice we have. A retreat participant realized her adult daughter was uncomfortable receiving holiday gifts because she couldn't afford to give as much in return. By exploring the deeper needs at play—the daughter's self-respect and autonomy alongside her parents' desire to contribute—they found a way to give and receive with more freedom. To practice identifying needs, we can ask ourselves: "What matters about this to me?" or "If I had that, then what would I have?" We continue asking until we arrive at something that feels like a core value or need. When we identify a core need, something shifts inside—we often experience a somatic feeling of being settled, grounded, or clear. There can be a sense of open spaciousness, inner alignment, or renewed energy. This skill transforms our relationships by helping us express ourselves clearly and listen to others more deeply. When we understand what matters most, we can de-escalate tension, nurture empathy, and support collaboration. The more we know our own needs and trust our ability to meet them, the more space we have to hear others. At the same time, identifying others' needs allows us to make heartfelt connections across differences. We gain the ability to sense the deeper values behind positions quite different from our own.

Chapter 4: Express Emotions with Agility and Balance

Human life is a tapestry of changing emotions. Our ability to relate wisely to this flow of emotions is among the most important skills we can develop. When understood, emotions provide valuable information about our needs, key input about our environment, and robust guidance for navigating conversations. In his mid-thirties, feeling unfulfilled, Sofer stepped out of his routine to focus more intensively on his spiritual practice. He decided to take temporary ordination as an anagarika, the first step of Buddhist monastic training. When he told his Jewish mother about his decision, things didn't go well. The thought of her son "renouncing the world" with shaved head and white robes was more than she could handle. At this important moment in his life, she was aghast, bereft with anger and mourning. Both felt deeply hurt. To his mother, Sofer seemed to be rejecting everything she believed and had raised him to value: ethical action to make the world a better place. For him, her rejection cut to the core. He desperately wanted her to see the true intentions behind his choice. Despite his attempts to hear her, the pain between them was too much to bear. She withdrew completely, refusing to speak with him for almost a year. This painful situation illustrates how we typically relate to emotions in two extreme ways. At one end, we get swept up and speak impulsively, potentially harming those we love. At the other extreme, we suppress emotions, afraid they'll overwhelm us or damage relationships. But there is a middle path between reactive expression and habitual suppression. Emotional agility involves three capacities: identifying emotions, finding balance with our internal experience of them, and expressing them openly without blame. The first component—emotional recognition—begins with noticing and naming what we're feeling. Many of us start with a limited vocabulary: happy, sad, mad, confused. It's like trying to paint with only a few colors. Through mindfulness, we can expand this palette and develop a richer emotional vocabulary. We learn to feel emotions in our bodies: sadness may include pressure in our chest or a lump in our throat; joy feels expansive, warm, or light. The second component—emotion regulation—involves learning to manage our emotions in a non-reactive way. Rather than clamping down or cutting ourselves off from our emotions, we develop the patience and spaciousness to let waves of emotion wash through us without being toppled by them. We can use mindfulness to notice different components of our emotions: their location in the body, their physical sensations, their overall tone, and any associated meanings or beliefs. The third component—expressing emotions without blame—involves training ourselves to connect feelings to our own needs rather than blaming others. Instead of saying "I feel angry because you..." we learn to say "I feel angry because I need/value/want..." This shift undercuts the blame game and gives us more freedom and choice in how we respond. During his time as a monastic, Sofer had plenty of opportunity to contemplate his relationship with his mother, to cry, forgive, and heal. Eventually they reconciled. They talked about their views and feelings, and over time, his mother saw how his Buddhist training enabled him to help others. In the end, they grew even closer. The process called forth powerful qualities in both of them: courage, honest vulnerability, patience, and humility. Emotional agility allows emotions to flow through us as an integral part of being human. We can receive the information they offer about our heart, our deeper needs and values, without getting caught in cycles of reaction or suppression that damage our relationships.

Chapter 5: Make Clear Requests That Inspire Connection

A meditation student named Laela approached Sofer for advice. She lived with her parents, who were in the process of moving. She needed to pack her belongings but was experiencing chronic pain—her joints and muscles burning so intensely that even lying down hurt, let alone packing boxes or lifting things. After listening and offering empathy, Sofer asked her a simple question: "Why don't you ask for some help from your folks or a friend?" Strange as it may seem, she had never thought to ask. Being able to make requests is the last core component of focusing on what matters. In conversations, requests move things forward one step at a time, building understanding and proposing solutions that may work for everyone. Yet for many of us, asking for what we need can feel uncomfortable or even impossible. Our reluctance often stems from complex and confusing relationships with giving and receiving. We may think, "I don't want to impose" or "I can handle it myself" or "They're too busy." These thoughts can reflect cultural myths of self-sufficiency or beliefs that our needs are somehow burdensome to others. In reality, contributing to one another is one of our most fundamental drives, and doing so brings joy. Think about the last time you helped a friend in need—not because you had to, but simply because you could. It probably felt pretty good. Rather than being burdens, our needs can be gifts—invitations to experience the joy of giving and receiving. When we negotiate the dance of choice and willingness, respecting the limits of one another's time and energy, all needs become opportunities for connection. As Sofer's friend once told him, "If you want something, ask for it." This simple advice captures the central principle behind making requests. To make effective requests, we need to formulate them with three qualities in mind. First, they should be positive, stating what we do want rather than what we don't want. Instead of saying "Don't talk to me that way!" we might ask, "Would you be willing to lower your voice, or can we take a break?" Second, requests should be specific and concrete rather than vague or abstract. Rather than asking someone to "love me more," we might say, "When you come home, can you try to remember to look me in the eyes and say hello?" Third, requests should be flexible, offering a suggestion for how to move forward while remaining open to other ideas. The most essential component of a request is the intention behind it. A request contains an inner orientation of flexibility that takes another's needs into account, while a demand is essentially the end of a conversation. Rosenberg captured this spirit poetically: "Ask others to meet your needs like flowers for your table, not air for your lungs." If we ask with desperation, how much choice will others feel? How much joy in agreeing? If instead we ask with openness and ease, as if to say, "Wouldn't this be nice?" we create space for genuine willingness. Laura, another student, discovered the power of reframing her approach to her grandmother. Whenever Laura tried to express appreciation, her grandmother would grow uncomfortable and change the subject. Instead of seeing herself as giving something to her grandmother, Laura made a request: "Grandma, there are some things I'd really like to share with you. It would be so meaningful to me to have you listen. Would you be willing to sit with me for a bit?" Her grandmother was delighted to offer this simple gift of presence. By making a request, Laura had helped her grandmother see how receiving appreciation was a gift to both of them. Making clear requests helps others know how they can contribute to us and offers concrete ideas for where to go next in a conversation. When done with authenticity and care, requests inspire connection rather than obligation, creating opportunities for the joy of giving and receiving that nourishes all our relationships.

Chapter 6: Navigate Difficult Conversations with Grace

Difficult, tense conversations are a normal part of life. Skillful communication doesn't necessarily prevent these situations—rather, it helps us handle them when they arise and try again when we fall short. The difference between ordinary conversations and challenging ones is like the difference between canoeing on open water and running rapids. Both involve paddling with balance, but the stakes are higher and the skills more demanding in white water. Sarah, a friend of Sofer's, faced this challenge when her mother died suddenly. During this difficult time, Sarah had moved back to her hometown to look after her elderly father and sort through her mother's belongings. Tensions began to surface between Sarah and her brother. Their initial conversation started off rocky, with Sarah's feelings of helplessness and anger showing up as blame and reactivity. Having taken some of Sofer's classes, she recognized what was happening, apologized, and stated her desire to work together. She listened, reflecting her brother's feelings and needs. At one point, when things got tense, she asked if he would give her a minute to breathe and handle her feelings, to which he agreed. That pause transformed the conversation. Sarah considered her own needs and spoke openly about the issue, sharing that she wanted to clear up any conflict quickly because it was important that they be able to trust each other during this difficult period. Her sincerity touched him; he wanted the same thing. As they worked through the details, Sarah summarized their conversation and agreements for future interactions. They ended by appreciating each other and how they'd navigated a difficult conversation together. Preparing ahead for challenging conversations helps clarify what's important, reduces reactivity, and increases the likelihood that we'll engage in ways aligned with our intentions. This preparation includes three key elements. First, we nourish ourselves by seeking empathy for any pain, anger, or upset we feel. This creates space to hear the other person. Second, we investigate what's at stake, examining our judgments as valuable information about our heart and considering if our goals are realistic. Third, we humanize the other person through empathy, stepping outside our own story to consider their perspective. During difficult conversations, attending to our nervous system is crucial. Conflict can send a cascade of physiological effects through our body, altering our breathing, releasing stress hormones, and even reducing our cognitive function. Working with our nervous system involves recognizing activation (the stimulation of energy in our body), riding the waves of that activation without reacting, and supporting deactivation (the settling of that energy). We can use mindfulness to notice signs of activation—changes in breathing, heart rate, muscle tension, or other bodily sensations. When we catch these signals early, we have more choice about how to respond. The paired practices of pausing and grounding are especially helpful. Pausing—anything from a deep breath to a break in the conversation—creates space to recognize activation. Grounding in the body provides an anchor to steady our attention. Another practical way to prepare for difficult conversations is to rehearse through role-play. Though it may feel awkward at first, this practice can help us stay balanced, yield insights, and support healing. We can also practice with a friend or imagine having the conversation with a respected mentor present. How would it feel to have them witness the exchange? How might you speak differently? During the actual conversation, do your best to start things off positively. Consider how you can lay a foundation of curiosity and care before the conversation begins. Frame the discussion in terms of shared goals or needs. Lead with presence, paying special attention to pausing and the pace of the conversation. Come from curiosity and care, showing this through your body language and tone of voice. Focus on what matters, keeping your attention flexible and listening for the needs beneath the surface. Life is messy, and despite our preparations and intentions, we all make mistakes. When you find yourself off track, remember that it's rarely too late to recover. Ask for a do-over: "That didn't come out right. Can I try again?" or "Things didn't go the way I hoped. Could we rewind and have this conversation again?" Most people appreciate this honesty and willingness to reconnect. The most essential tools for difficult conversations are empathy and reflecting before you respond. These build trust, understanding, and connection. Be prepared to offer empathy multiple times before someone feels adequately understood. Balance this with commitment to your own authenticity, shifting carefully between listening and expressing your side of things.

Summary

The journey to mindful communication begins with three powerful steps that transform how we relate to ourselves and others. By leading with presence, we ground our interactions in awareness rather than automatic patterns. When we approach conversations with genuine curiosity and care, we create space for understanding beyond our differences. And by focusing on what truly matters—our observations, emotions, needs, and requests—we build connections that nurture both individuals. As Sofer reminds us, "Communication is by definition relational, and the more opportunities we have to practice it in real time, the more we learn." The most important insight is that mindful communication is not about what we say. It's not in the words. All the tools and principles are designed to help you create more understanding in yourself and with those around you. If you get too hung up on saying things right, the magic of human connection gets lost. Look inside to find what's true for you, how you feel, what you need, and what matters most. From this authentic place, your communication will naturally become more clear, honest, and connected. Start today by choosing just one practice from this journey to integrate into your daily interactions. Perhaps you'll pause before responding in conversation, or listen for the needs beneath someone's words. Whatever you choose, remember that small, consistent shifts create powerful transformation over time. Like turning a large ship at sea, a mere two-degree change in your communication now will alter your destination dramatically, bringing you to a place of deeper connection, understanding, and authentic self-expression.

About Author

Loading...

Oren Jay Sofer

Read more