The Great Believers

The Great Believers Plot Summary

Introduction

# The Great Believers: Love's Endurance Through Time's Wreckage Chicago, 1985. Yale Tishman stands alone in Richard Campo's brownstone, calling out to empty rooms. Minutes before, the house buzzed with mourners celebrating Nico Marcus—the young artist who'd died of AIDS at twenty-three. Now everyone has vanished, leaving only abandoned drinks and the echo of Yale's voice against bare walls. They've gone to raid Nico's apartment before his homophobic parents can destroy what remains of their friend's life. Yale, forgotten in his moment of grief, discovers he's been left behind. Thirty years later, Fiona Marcus—Nico's sister—boards a plane to Paris with desperate hope clutched in her hands. Her daughter Claire vanished into a religious cult three years ago, and now a grainy YouTube video shows what might be Claire painting on a bridge, a small child playing at her feet. Between these two moments of searching stretches a decade of plague and memory, of art and survival, of the terrible mathematics of love in a world determined to destroy it. Two timelines converge around the same stubborn truth: some people refuse to let go, even when letting go might save them.

Chapter 1: The Collector's Gambit: Yale's Discovery of Hidden Treasures

The letter arrives like salvation wrapped in elegant cursive. Nora Marcus Lerner, Nico's great-aunt, writes to Yale about a collection she wishes to donate to Northwestern's gallery. Works by Modigliani, Soutine, Foujita—pieces obtained directly from the artists during her years in 1920s Paris. Yale stares at the letter, hardly daring to believe it. If authentic, this collection could transform his modest career into something significant. But complications arrive with the morning coffee. Chuck Donovan, a university trustee, has promised two million dollars—with the condition that they refuse Nora's gift. The donor is friends with Nora's son Frank, who wants the art sold rather than donated. Yale finds himself caught between competing greed, his job hanging in the balance of an old woman's generosity and a rich man's ego. The Polaroids scatter across Yale's desk like promises when they arrive in January. The Foujita drawings show a young woman in profile—Nora herself, he realizes. A Soutine portrait swirls with vertiginous energy. Four Modigliani sketches, simple but unmistakably authentic. Yale's hands shake as he examines each image, understanding that he holds either the find of his career or an elaborate hoax. In Wisconsin, Nora waits in her modest farmhouse, ninety years old and dying of heart failure. Her son Frank blocks their first attempt to meet her, threatening to call police if they don't leave his property. But Nora is sharper than her son credits, and she finds ways to communicate despite his interference. At the bank, surrounded by safety deposit boxes and fluorescent lighting, the art emerges like buried treasure. Each piece carries the weight of a life lived fully when the world was ending and beginning simultaneously.

Chapter 2: Betrayal and Diagnosis: When Trust Becomes Contagion

The words hit Yale like a physical blow delivered by Charlie's mother Teresa, standing in their apartment with tears streaming down her face. Charlie has the virus. But how? They'd been careful, monogamous—or so Yale believed. As the truth emerges, Yale's world crumbles with surgical precision. Charlie had been meeting strangers in train station bathrooms, cruising forest preserves, engaging in the very behaviors he condemned in his newspaper editorials. Worse still, Charlie had slept with Julian Ames, the beautiful but troubled actor in their circle. It happened the night of Nico's memorial service, when Yale had briefly disappeared upstairs at Richard's house. Charlie, drunk and paranoid about Yale's absence, found solace in Julian's arms. One night of betrayal, but it was enough to carry death between them. Yale moves out immediately, crashing on couches and in borrowed apartments. The weight of potential infection presses down on him—he must wait three months from his last exposure to Charlie before testing can give reliable results. Three months of not knowing if he will live or die. The irony cuts deep: he'd spent years terrified of this disease, only to be exposed by the person he trusted most. Charlie's mother Teresa tries to mediate, begging Yale to return and care for her son. But Yale cannot forgive the deception. Every safe sex article Charlie had written now feels like mockery. Every lecture about monogamy was revealed as projection. Yale had been living with a stranger who wore his lover's face, and now that stranger was dying while Yale waited to learn if he would follow.

Chapter 3: The Art of Survival: Fighting for Legacy Amid Loss

Homeless and heartbroken, Yale finds unexpected kindness from Cecily Pearce, a colleague who offers him her couch in Evanston. She lives there with her young son Kurt, and shows Yale a gentleness he desperately needs while fighting for respect in a male-dominated university system. Her apartment becomes his refuge as the art authentication process moves forward, each confirmed piece feeling like a small victory against the chaos consuming his personal life. Roman Novak, a shy graduate student assigned as Yale's intern, proves surprisingly helpful despite his nervous energy. There's something fragile about Roman, a repressed quality that reminds Yale of his younger self. Together they make another trip to Wisconsin to gather more details from Nora about the collection's provenance, staying at a bed and breakfast where something shifts between them in the darkness. The old woman tells them about Ranko Novak, her first love—a Serbian artist who had won the Prix de Rome in 1914 only to be destroyed by the war. His story of thwarted promise resonates deeply with Yale, another life cut short by forces beyond his control. Nora had loved this man for less than two years but mourned him for seven decades, preserving his work like sacred relics. During their stay, Roman's repression cracks in a moment of desperate loneliness. In a dark hotel room while news of the Challenger disaster plays on television, Yale's hand brings Roman to climax—hardly sex, but crossing a line nonetheless. It feels like taking advantage of someone vulnerable, yet also like offering comfort in a world that provides so little. The next morning they drive back to Chicago in awkward silence, both understanding that something irreversible has occurred.

Chapter 4: Resistance and Sacrifice: The Price of Preservation

Three months after his last contact with Charlie, Yale finally works up courage to get tested. Dr. Cheng, who had treated their friend Nico, draws the blood with gentle hands and promises to call with results in two weeks. Those fourteen days stretch like years, each morning bringing fresh terror about what the test might reveal. Yale throws himself into the art project with manic intensity, as if work might somehow influence the virus multiplying or dying in his bloodstream. The call from Dr. Cheng comes early on a Tuesday morning. Yale is negative. The relief overwhelms him, but it comes tinged with survivor's guilt that will never fully fade. Why had he been spared when so many others weren't? Julian is preparing to flee to Puerto Rico, convinced he will die alone and forgotten. Charlie is beginning the slow decline that will define his remaining years. Yale is free, but freedom feels like a burden he doesn't know how to carry. The art acquisition faces new challenges as Frank Lerner discovers the collection's true value—potentially three million dollars—and threatens legal action. Chuck Donovan storms into meetings, demanding the university reverse course and return the art to Nora's family. Yale finds himself at the center of the controversy, his career hanging in the balance while Nora's dream of a retrospective seems to slip away. Roman completes his internship and prepares to leave for other opportunities. The awkwardness between them never fully resolves, but Yale senses the young man has found something important in their brief encounter—a glimpse of who he might become once he stops hiding from himself. Some revelations, Yale reflects, are worth the complications they create, even when those complications follow you for decades.

Chapter 5: Across Time's Divide: Fiona's Parisian Quest

Thirty years later, Fiona steps off a plane at Charles de Gaulle Airport carrying nothing but desperate hope and a photograph of her missing daughter. Claire had vanished into the Hosanna Collective three years earlier, following Kurt Pearce—Cecily's son, now grown into a charismatic cult leader—into the Colorado wilderness. Now a YouTube video suggests she might be in Paris, painting on bridges with a small child at her feet. Richard Campo, the photographer who had documented their lost world, lives on Île Saint-Louis with his young French lover Serge. At eighty, Richard moves like a man carrying the weight of all the beautiful boys he'd outlived. His apartment is spare and elegant, nothing like the cluttered brownstone where Nico's memorial had dissolved into absence. Here, surrounded by books and light, Richard prepares for his retrospective at the Centre Pompidou while Fiona plans her search. The private investigator Arnaud is a sharp-faced man who eats fruit salad with surgical precision. He listens to Fiona's story without judgment—the cult, the disappearance, the years of silence. Within hours he has located Kurt Pearce in the Marais district, living with a woman who is not Claire. The photographs on his phone show Kurt older, softer, his hair pulled back in a man-bun that makes him look like a reformed hippie rather than a dangerous prophet. Fiona stares at the images of strangers and feels the familiar weight of failure pressing down on her chest. She had introduced Claire to Kurt, had trusted him with her daughter's summer plans when he was still Cecily's troubled teenager. Every decision she'd made seemed designed to push Claire further away, to transform love into the very thing her daughter needed to escape.

Chapter 6: Reunion and Reconciliation: Bridging Decades of Silence

The bar in Montmartre pulses with music and conversation when Fiona finally sees her daughter emerge from the crowd. Claire is thin but healthy, no longer the frightened teenager who had disappeared with her older boyfriend. The young woman who approaches carries herself with hard-won confidence, speaking French to the bartender before turning to face her mother with guarded eyes. Their conversation is awkward, tentative. Claire is no longer the child who had needed rescuing, but a woman who had survived horrors and emerged stronger. She works in the bar, speaks multiple languages, has built a life for herself and her daughter in this foreign city. Fiona's maternal instincts war with respect for Claire's independence—she wants to sweep them both back to Chicago, but she can see that Claire has found her own form of freedom. Claire tells her about Nicolette—named for the uncle she had never known—born after Claire's escape from the cult. The birth had nearly killed her, and the cult's refusal to seek medical help had finally broken Kurt's loyalty to the group. They had fled to Paris together, but Kurt's old patterns of theft and deception eventually destroyed their relationship, landing him in jail and leaving Claire to raise her daughter alone. The reunion unfolds in careful stages over several days. Fiona stays in Paris for Richard's gallery opening, giving them time to rebuild their relationship without the pressure of immediate decisions. The little girl remains a mystery, glimpsed only in photographs on Claire's phone, but there is hope now where before there had been only absence. Some forms of love, Fiona realizes, transcend geography and time, scattered across oceans and decades but still connected by invisible threads of devotion.

Chapter 7: Memory's Victory: What Love Leaves Behind

At Richard Campo's retrospective, Fiona watches footage of her younger self, of Yale and Charlie and Nico, all of them impossibly young and alive on the gallery screens. The camera captures them at the demolition of a gay club that had been their sanctuary in the early 1980s. As the wrecking ball swings and the building crumbles, Yale kneels in the rubble, claiming that the dust contains glitter from all the nights of dancing and celebration. Whether the glitter is real or imagined doesn't matter—what matters is the faith it represents, the belief that beauty persists even in destruction. Fiona understands now that this is what she's been carrying all these years: not just grief, but the glitter of memory, the fragments of love that survive even when everything else is lost. The virus had taken Nico, time had claimed most of their friends, but something essential remained. The Nora Lerner collection had indeed proved authentic, becoming one of Northwestern's most prized acquisitions. The exhibition opened in 1987 to critical acclaim, with Ranko Novak's humble sketches displayed alongside works by masters. It was a testament to the power of love to preserve beauty across decades of loss and forgetting. Yale had fought for this legacy even as his own health declined, understanding that some victories matter more than personal survival. In the end, Yale died in 1992, but not before seeing Nora's dream realized. Fiona had held his hand in those final weeks, watching him fade while new life grew in her belly. Her son Damian would grow up hearing stories about Uncle Yale, about the art collection he'd saved, about the community that had loved and lost and somehow endured. The great believers, Fiona realized, were those who continued to love and create and hope despite overwhelming evidence that such faith was foolish.

Summary

The great believers were united not by shared experience but by shared stubbornness—the determination to keep believing in connection even when connection seemed impossible. Yale and Charlie, clinging to each other as their world contracted around them. Nora, transforming her youthful adventures into lasting art. Fiona, refusing to stop searching for a daughter who might not want to be found. They understood that faith was not about certainty but about the willingness to act as if hope were reasonable, even when all evidence suggested otherwise. What survived in the end was not the people themselves but the traces they left behind. Art and photographs, letters and memories, the stubborn insistence that love mattered even when it could not save anyone. In a universe that seemed bent on erasure, the act of remembering became the most radical form of resistance. Whether it was Nora's seventy-year devotion to a dead lover, Yale's fight to preserve forgotten paintings, or Fiona's desperate attempt to rebuild her relationship with her daughter, the impulse remained the same: the refusal to let love disappear without a trace. In the end, that refusal was perhaps the only victory that truly mattered.

About Author

Loading

Rebecca Makkai

Makkai delves into the intricate interplay of memory, history, and art in her literary work, crafting narratives that illuminate the human experience. As an author, she is recognized for her rich prose and vividly drawn characters, with her books often exploring profound themes such as family history and the societal role of art. Her early book, "The Borrower," marked her entry into the literary world, while her acclaimed novel "The Great Believers" delves deeply into the impact of the AIDS epidemic, earning her numerous accolades and cementing her reputation in contemporary fiction.\n\nBeyond her novels, Makkai has made significant contributions as an educator, imparting her expertise to graduate students at institutions like Northwestern University and Middlebury College. Her involvement in the literary community extends to her role as Artistic Director of StoryStudio Chicago, where she nurtures aspiring writers. Readers benefit from her works not only through the narratives themselves but also through the insights they provide into societal and historical issues. Makkai's capacity to weave complex themes into compelling stories makes her bio notable for those seeking literature that challenges and enriches the reader's understanding of the world.\n\nHer achievements, including being a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize and the National Book Award, underscore the impact of her work. Makkai's bio highlights a career marked by both critical acclaim and a commitment to fostering literary talent, demonstrating her influence as both a writer and a mentor.

Read more