The Grid

The Grid Plot Summary

Introduction

Every day, business leaders make countless decisions that shape the future of their organizations. Yet many approach these decisions in a fragmented manner, focusing on optimizing individual aspects without seeing how they interconnect. This reductionist approach often leads to unintended consequences, as decisions that seem logical in isolation can interact in complex ways that undermine overall business performance. The Grid offers a revolutionary holistic framework for decision-making that addresses this fundamental problem. By viewing a business as an interconnected system rather than a collection of separate parts, this framework helps leaders understand how changes in one area inevitably affect others. The Grid provides a structured approach to evaluate business ideas, identify root causes of challenges, anticipate market shifts, and foster more effective collaboration across teams. Through this systemic lens, decision-makers can finally see both the forest and the trees, making choices that strengthen the entire business rather than sacrificing long-term adaptability for short-term gains.

Chapter 1: The Three Pillars: Desirability, Profitability, and Longevity

At the heart of The Grid framework are three fundamental pillars that determine business success: desirability, profitability, and longevity. Each pillar represents a crucial dimension that must be considered when making strategic decisions. Desirability addresses whether customers want or need what a business offers. No matter how innovative or well-executed a product or service might be, if it doesn't satisfy a genuine customer need or desire, the business has a fundamental problem. Desirability encompasses understanding customer values and beliefs, identifying their goals, and recognizing the barriers that prevent them from achieving those goals. Many businesses fail because they build solutions looking for problems rather than addressing real customer needs. Profitability focuses on the financial viability of the business model. Even if customers love what a company provides, if it costs more to produce than customers are willing to pay, the business won't survive. This pillar includes revenue models, pricing strategies, bargaining power with suppliers and customers, and cost structures. A seemingly small change in pricing can dramatically impact profitability, while reducing costs in one area might inadvertently affect desirability or longevity. Longevity concerns a business's ability to endure over time. There's little value in creating a profitable business today if it can't adapt to changing conditions tomorrow. This pillar examines how businesses build and maintain a sustainable customer base, protect themselves from imitation, and preserve their adaptive capacity. Many organizations sacrifice adaptability for short-term efficiency, only to find themselves unable to respond when market conditions change. These three pillars don't exist in isolation—they're deeply interconnected. A decision that enhances desirability might compromise profitability. Cost-cutting measures might improve short-term profits but damage longevity. The magic happens when leaders make decisions that strengthen all three pillars simultaneously, or at least make conscious trade-offs between them. This holistic approach helps avoid the common trap of optimizing one dimension at the expense of others, leading to more sustainable business success.

Chapter 2: Constructing the Grid Framework

The Grid framework expands beyond the three foundational pillars by incorporating the dynamic nature of business environments. It recognizes that change occurs across three distinct layers: customers, markets, and the organization itself. When these layers interact with the three pillars, they create a nine-box matrix that provides a comprehensive view of any business. The construction begins by acknowledging that customers' wants and needs constantly evolve. New technologies emerge, social trends shift, and customer expectations change accordingly. Similarly, market conditions fluctuate as competitors enter or exit, regulations change, or economic factors shift. Finally, the organization itself transforms as it grows, develops new capabilities, or faces internal challenges. Each of these changing layers affects each of the three pillars in different ways. By plotting these interactions on a matrix, The Grid creates nine distinct boxes, each representing a critical factor in business success. For example, the intersection of customers and desirability focuses on understanding wants and needs. The intersection of markets and profitability examines bargaining power with suppliers and customers. The intersection of organization and longevity explores adaptability. Each box provides a unique perspective that, when combined with the others, creates a holistic view of the business. The power of The Grid lies in its ability to reveal connections between seemingly unrelated aspects of a business. A decision to reduce costs might seem straightforward when viewed in isolation, but The Grid reveals how it might affect customer experience, bargaining power with suppliers, or the organization's ability to adapt to future changes. This interconnected view helps leaders anticipate unintended consequences before they occur. Consider how Tesla approached electric vehicles. Rather than focusing solely on the environmental benefits (desirability), they built a comprehensive charging infrastructure (longevity) and gradually expanded from luxury to mass-market vehicles (profitability). By addressing all nine boxes of The Grid, they created a cohesive strategy that has disrupted the automotive industry. The Grid provides a structure for thinking through such complex decisions, ensuring that all relevant factors are considered and balanced.

Chapter 3: Understanding Customer Wants and Needs

Understanding customer wants and needs forms the foundation of business success. This element sits at the intersection of customers and desirability in The Grid, serving as the starting point for any viable business venture. The framework breaks this understanding into three critical components: values and beliefs, goals, and barriers. Values and beliefs shape how customers perceive the world and what they find desirable. These include their self-identity, personal principles, and the social groups they associate with. For example, some customers might identify as environmentally conscious, viewing themselves as stewards of the planet. Others might prioritize luxury and status, using products as expressions of their achievement. Understanding these values allows businesses to create offerings that resonate on a deeper level than mere functionality. Consider how Patagonia's commitment to environmental sustainability attracts customers who share those values, or how Apple's design aesthetic appeals to those who value creativity and innovation. Customer goals represent what they're trying to accomplish. The framework distinguishes between surface-level goals and deeper "super objectives." A customer might say they want a drill, but their actual goal is to make a hole in the wall, and their super objective might be to create a beautiful living space or demonstrate self-sufficiency. By understanding these layered goals, businesses can develop solutions that address the deeper needs. Netflix recognized that customers' goal wasn't to rent DVDs but to be entertained, allowing them to pivot successfully to streaming when technology evolved. Barriers are obstacles that prevent customers from achieving their goals or adopting new solutions. These might be operational (like compatibility issues), experiential (requiring too much effort or expertise), or financial (high costs or payment structures). Successful businesses actively identify and eliminate these barriers. Airbnb overcame the trust barrier in home-sharing by implementing review systems and insurance protections. Spotify removed the barrier of high upfront costs by offering a subscription model instead of requiring customers to purchase individual songs. Real-world application of this framework involves deeply engaging with customers through multiple research methods. It means observing behaviors rather than just asking questions, since customers often struggle to articulate their deeper motivations. It requires distinguishing between what customers say, what they think, and what they actually do. When businesses truly understand customer wants and needs across all three dimensions, they can develop offerings that feel almost inevitable – solutions that customers might not have been able to describe in advance but immediately recognize as exactly what they needed.

Chapter 4: Managing Competitive Rivalry

Competitive rivalry sits at the intersection of market conditions and desirability in The Grid framework. Rather than viewing competition as a straightforward battle to be won, The Grid offers a more nuanced ecological perspective, showing how businesses can thrive by finding their distinct place in the competitive landscape. Competition in business, like in nature, involves interactions that reduce access to resources needed to survive. These resources include customer attention, market share, and profits. However, direct confrontation—locking horns with competitors—is usually a last resort in nature because even the victor suffers. Similarly, head-to-head competition in business often leads to price wars and diminished profits for all players. Instead, successful businesses find ways to differentiate themselves, occupying unique positions that allow them to coexist and thrive alongside competitors. The framework examines competition through three lenses: category, territory, and alternatives/substitutes. Category refers to the class of product or service that customers understand. Clear category membership is essential because it helps customers comprehend what a product is for and how it works. Products that don't fit into recognizable categories often fail because customers can't be bothered to figure them out. Consider how the iPhone was marketed as a phone with additional features rather than a revolutionary pocket computer, making it immediately understandable to consumers. Territory encompasses both geographical location and market positioning. A business must identify where it will operate and how it will position itself relative to competitors on dimensions like price and quality. The framework presents a nine-position market map that plots offerings from budget to premium and from functional to aspirational. This mapping reveals crowded positions where competition is intense and vacant positions that represent opportunities. Jim Jannard demonstrated mastery of positioning by creating two successful businesses in different positions: Oakley as a premium brand offering "more for more," and RED Digital Cinema offering "more for less." Alternatives and substitutes represent the options customers consider when making purchasing decisions. Alternatives are direct competitors within the same category, while substitutes are offerings from outside the category that satisfy the same fundamental need. For example, a ferry, train, and airplane are substitutes for crossing the English Channel. Businesses often focus narrowly on direct competitors while ignoring substitutes, which can be a fatal mistake. Kodak focused on competing with Fujifilm while ignoring the rise of digital photography, eventually leading to their bankruptcy. This ecological view of competition encourages businesses to find their unique niche rather than competing head-on with established players. It suggests that success comes not from being marginally better than competitors at the same thing, but from being distinctively different in ways that matter to specific customer segments. Just as species in nature evolve to use resources in unique ways, businesses can differentiate themselves to create space where they can thrive with reduced competitive pressure.

Chapter 5: Creating Compelling Offerings

Creating compelling offerings represents the intersection of organizational capabilities and desirability in The Grid framework. This critical element integrates three interdependent components: proposition, brand appeal, and customer experience, which together determine whether customers will choose your product or service over alternatives. The proposition is the concept customers buy into—a concise expression of what your product or service is and why it's a good choice. A strong proposition must be relevant to customer needs, distinctive from alternatives, and focused on a small number of compelling rationales. Geoffrey Moore's framework suggests expressing propositions in a simple format: "For [target customer] who has [goals], our product is a [category] that unlike [specific alternatives] provides [compelling rationales]." For example, "For busy professionals who want to stay fit, Peloton is an exercise bike that unlike traditional gym equipment provides instructor-led classes from the comfort of home." The proposition must pass the relevance test (do customers care?), the differentiation test (is it distinct from alternatives?), and the superiority test (is it meaningfully better in specific ways?). Brand appeal encompasses the associations people have with your business. These associations form through both deliberate marketing efforts and customers' actual experiences. Successful brands choose a distinctive set of associations to promote consistently, whether related to values, quality, price point, or experiential factors. When brand image and reality align, customers develop trust and loyalty. When they don't, the consequences can be severe. The Mast Brothers chocolate company built a successful business on bean-to-bar craftsmanship, but when it emerged they had initially used melted commercial chocolate, sales plummeted despite the product tasting the same. The disconnect between brand image and reality damaged customer trust. Customer experience covers the full spectrum of interactions customers have with your offering. Research by psychologist Daniel Kahneman reveals that satisfaction isn't determined by the average quality of these interactions but by their peaks (the most intense moments) and how they end. This "peak-end rule" explains why a single outstanding or terrible interaction can disproportionately influence overall satisfaction. Successful businesses identify and improve interactions that fall below adequate expectations, create occasional positive peaks that exceed expectations, and ensure experiences end on a high note. For example, Air New Zealand transformed the typically boring safety video into an unexpected delight, creating a memorable peak that influences overall satisfaction with their service. The power of these three elements becomes evident when they reinforce each other. Domino's Pizza demonstrated this synergy when they improved their recipe (proposition), maintained their fast-delivery brand promise, and enhanced the ordering experience with innovations like their Pizza Tracker app. By aligning proposition, brand, and experience, they achieved eight consecutive quarters of double-digit sales growth. Conversely, when these elements contradict each other—like a luxury brand with poor customer service or an "easy-to-use" product with a frustrating experience—the offering fails to resonate with customers regardless of its technical merits.

Chapter 6: Revenue Models and Pricing Strategies

Revenue models and pricing strategies exist at the intersection of market conditions and profitability in The Grid framework. This component examines how businesses capture value from their offerings, demonstrating that the mechanisms by which companies make money are as important as what they sell. A revenue model consists of two components: the revenue stream (source of income) and the revenue mechanism (how customers are charged). Common mechanisms include auctions, fixed prices, pay-as-you-go, licensing, performance-based models, razor-and-blade approaches, and subscriptions. The choice of revenue model fundamentally shapes both customer experience and organizational structure. For example, subscription models like Netflix provide customers with predictable expenses and continuous access, while giving the business recurring revenue and valuable data on customer preferences. In contrast, licensing models like ARM's computer chip designs allow the company to earn royalties without manufacturing costs, enabling them to focus on research and development. The importance of revenue models becomes clear when examining Burberry's transformation under CEO Angela Ahrendts. The luxury brand had licensed its name to 23 different companies worldwide, losing control over product quality and pricing. Ahrendts identified this fractured revenue model as the root cause of brand dilution and bought back all licenses to regain control. Within six years, sales and share price doubled. This illustrates how revenue models aren't merely financial arrangements but strategic decisions that affect brand perception, product quality, and long-term viability. Pricing strategy represents another critical element of capturing value. A McKinsey study found that a 1% price increase, assuming demand remains constant, yields an 11% profit increase on average. This leverage explains why pricing deserves significant attention. Yet many businesses lack a coherent pricing strategy, relying on cost-plus approaches that ignore customer perceptions of value, or making emotional decisions based on fear of losing customers. The framework advocates for value-based pricing—setting prices based on what customers are willing to pay rather than internal costs. Implementing effective pricing requires understanding several factors: the next best alternative (what customers would choose instead), price sensitivity (how much price affects buying decisions), and the symbolic significance of price points. See's Candies demonstrates the power of strategic pricing by raising prices approximately 5% annually since 1972, increasing profit margins by one percentage point each year. This approach has generated $1.35 billion in profit over 35 years from an initial $25 million investment, without significantly increasing sales volume. The framework also addresses the common trap of discounting. Short-term price reductions often train customers to wait for sales, permanently devalue products, and require massive volume increases to maintain profitability. A 4% price reduction typically requires a 25% volume increase to generate the same profit—a threshold few businesses achieve. Instead of reflexive discounting, companies should clearly communicate their value, incentivize based on profit rather than revenue, and avoid obsessing over market share at the expense of profitability. By integrating revenue models and pricing strategies into the broader business system, The Grid reveals how these decisions extend beyond the finance department to influence product development, brand perception, and competitive positioning. The most successful businesses design their revenue approaches to enhance rather than undermine their overall strategic direction.

Chapter 7: Building a Sustainable Customer Base

Building a sustainable customer base represents the intersection of customers and longevity in The Grid framework. This critical element focuses on how businesses acquire and retain customers over time, recognizing that without a steady flow of customers, even the most innovative products or efficient operations cannot sustain a business. The framework divides this process into three interconnected components: awareness, acquisition, and retention. Awareness represents the foundational step—customers cannot buy what they don't know exists. Effective awareness-building requires clear objectives, a well-defined target audience, and distinctive brand assets. Businesses must craft simple, emotionally engaging messages that remind customers of their product category and brand. Marc Barros, founder of Contour (a GoPro competitor), learned this lesson the hard way: "We spent our money on great product and distribution, leaving nothing left to compete against GoPro in the marketing arms race... The best product doesn't always win, the product everyone knows about does." Acquisition focuses on converting awareness into first-time purchases. Research by Byron Sharp reveals that for most businesses, the potential gains from acquisition far outweigh those from reducing defection. In a market where half of all customers switch brands when buying a new product, focusing solely on retention might increase market share by 1%, while effectively targeting the 50% of customers considering a switch offers fifty times greater potential growth. New customers also drive word of mouth more powerfully than existing ones because the brand or product is novel to them—they're more likely to discuss it with others. Retention strategies aim to keep customers once they've been acquired. While acquisition is essential for growth, retention offers advantages in terms of cost-efficiency and increased customer value over time. The framework outlines multiple approaches to retention: loyalty programs that reward repeat purchases; contractual terms that penalize switching; personalization that increases switching costs; cross-selling complementary products; creating product ecosystems where components work better together; and designing habit-forming experiences that bring customers back automatically. Measuring the health of your customer base requires tracking multiple metrics: overall customer numbers, retention rates, customer profitability, lifetime value, and acquisition/retention costs. The Net Promoter Score (asking how likely customers are to recommend your business) has become a popular metric, though the framework suggests supplementing it with additional measurements like the Word of Mouth Index to gain a more complete picture. The framework emphasizes that different businesses should prioritize different aspects of customer base development. For some, particularly those in highly competitive markets with limited differentiation, aggressive acquisition may be most important. For others, especially those with high switching costs or network effects, retention deserves more attention. The key insight is that businesses must consciously design their acquisition and retention strategies based on their specific market position, customer characteristics, and long-term goals—not simply follow generic best practices that might be inappropriate for their situation. By viewing customer relationships as a dynamic system rather than a series of transactions, The Grid helps businesses build sustainable customer bases that provide both immediate profits and long-term viability. The most successful organizations maintain a delicate balance between attracting new customers and nurturing existing ones, creating a self-reinforcing cycle of growth and loyalty.

Summary

The Grid offers a transformative lens through which to view business decision-making: see your business as an interconnected system, not isolated parts. This fundamental shift in perspective reveals how changes in one area inevitably ripple through the entire organization, often with unexpected consequences. By considering all nine elements of The Grid simultaneously, leaders can make more balanced decisions that strengthen the business as a whole. Beyond its practical application to specific business challenges, The Grid represents a broader evolution in management thinking. Just as fields like physics, biology, and economics have embraced systems thinking, business theory must also move beyond reductionist approaches that have dominated for decades. The Grid provides not just a decision-making tool but a new paradigm that acknowledges the complex, dynamic nature of modern business environments. By learning to think in wholes rather than parts, leaders can navigate uncertainty more effectively, make decisions with greater confidence, and build organizations that remain adaptable in the face of constant change.

About Author

Loading...

Matt Watkinson

Read more