Outer Order, Inner Calm

Outer Order, Inner Calm Plot Summary

Introduction

Have you ever noticed how your mood lifts when you finally clear off that cluttered kitchen counter or organize your overflowing closet? It's an almost magical feeling - that disproportionate burst of energy and clarity that comes from creating order in your physical environment. While a messy desk or crowded coat closet might seem like trivial problems in the context of a happy life, getting control of the stuff around us often makes it easier to feel more in control of our lives generally. For most of us, outer order contributes to inner calm more than it should. When we eliminate the things we don't use, need, or love, as well as things that don't work, don't fit, or don't suit, we free both our physical space and our minds for what we truly value. This pathway to creating order isn't about perfection or minimalism - it's about fashioning surroundings that support our best selves and enhance our happiness. By thoughtfully curating our spaces and maintaining helpful systems, we can boost our energy, focus, creativity, and peace of mind.

Chapter 1: Identify What Truly Matters in Your Space

Creating outer order begins with making choices about what stays and what goes in our lives. This process requires us to be honest about which possessions truly add value to our existence. The foundation of this sorting process relies on three essential questions: Do I need it? Do I love it? Do I use it? Sometimes you might keep something you don't love but genuinely need, or an item you rarely use but deeply treasure. That's perfectly fine - the goal isn't minimalism, but mindfulness about what deserves space in your life. Gretchen Rubin shares how she once maintained a large notebook filled with meticulously organized business cards. She'd taken great satisfaction in how perfectly the cards fit into their slots and how nicely the notebook fit on her shelf. One day, she realized she hadn't consulted a single business card in the past two years. The notebook and cards had become what she calls "deep clutter" - items that are well-organized and neatly stored but are essentially useless in her daily life. After recognizing this pattern, Rubin cleared out the notebook and gave it away. This experience taught her that sometimes the most insidious clutter isn't the obvious mess on countertops but the perfectly organized possessions that serve no real purpose. These items occupy valuable physical and mental space without providing corresponding value. When deciding what to keep, it helps to recognize the emotional patterns behind our attachments. Rubin notes that some people keep things for backward-looking reasons ("This reminds me of my childhood") while others hold onto items for forward-looking reasons ("I might need this someday"). Understanding your particular pattern can help you make more conscious decisions about what deserves space in your life. The process becomes easier when we identify organizations or people who could benefit from our unneeded items. Rubin found it much simpler to part with board games and puzzles once she realized her daughter's summer camp would appreciate them for rainy days. Knowing these items would get good use elsewhere made the separation less painful and more purposeful. Remember that creating outer order isn't about achieving some abstract standard of perfection. It's about wanting what you have and having what you want. The goal is to surround yourself with possessions that genuinely support your life as it is today - not as it was in the past or might hypothetically be in some distant future.

Chapter 2: Declutter with Purpose, Not Perfection

Decluttering doesn't mean stripping your space of personality or achieving some minimalist ideal. Instead, it's about thoughtfully curating your surroundings to reflect who you are and what matters most to you. The process works best when approached with purpose rather than perfectionism, focusing on progress over flawlessness. One of Rubin's readers shared a powerful story about tackling her basement. "I woke up one morning and on impulse decided to tackle my basement," she wrote. "I spent my entire Sunday down there, and I was so pumped by the end that I wanted to keep going all night. I got up early on Monday morning just to sit there and gloat. It gave me such a lift at the start of a tough workweek." This woman discovered what many find - that the satisfaction of creating order provides energy that extends far beyond the physical transformation. Rather than waiting for the "perfect" time to begin decluttering, Rubin recommends starting immediately with whatever time you have available. She suggests the "shelf-by-shelf" approach - whenever you have a few idle minutes, evaluate some small area. This method has two advantages: it doesn't require setting aside large blocks of time, and the results become visible quickly. You might throw out wrinkly grapes from the refrigerator, discard a hairbrush with a broken handle, or place a stray camera cord in its proper basket. For those overwhelmed by the prospect of decluttering, Rubin recommends taking photos of the spaces you want to tackle. Something about seeing a room or shelf in a photograph helps us view it with fresh eyes and greater objectivity. Then, after clearing the space, take "after" photos to see the visual proof of what you've accomplished - a powerful motivation to continue the process elsewhere. One of the most practical strategies Rubin suggests is the "ten-minute closer" at the end of each workday or evening. Before leaving work, take ten minutes to put things in order: glance at tomorrow's calendar, throw away trash, file or discard papers, close drawers, and pack up anything that belongs at home. Before bed, spend ten minutes putting away shoes, hanging up coats, loading the dishwasher, and setting things right. These brief sessions prevent clutter from accumulating to overwhelming levels. Remember that the decluttering process doesn't need to be perfect to be valuable. As Rubin emphasizes, "Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good." Actually spending ten minutes clearing one shelf is better than fantasizing about spending a weekend cleaning the basement. Practical progress always trumps imaginary perfection.

Chapter 3: Design Systems That Work for Your Tendencies

The most effective organizing systems are those that align with your natural tendencies and preferences. No single approach works for everyone, which is why it's crucial to design personalized systems that feel intuitive rather than fighting against your natural inclinations. In her framework called The Four Tendencies, Rubin describes how people respond differently to expectations, which influences how they approach organization. For instance, when clearing clutter, Upholders (who readily respond to both outer and inner expectations) thrive with to-do lists and schedules. Questioners (who question all expectations) need clear reasons for why organizing matters. Obligers (who meet outer expectations but struggle with inner ones) require external accountability, like inviting a friend to help or promising someone they'll deliver donations. Rebels (who resist all expectations) succeed when they frame decluttering as something they want to do, not something they should do. Rubin also distinguishes between "overbuyers" and "underbuyers." Overbuyers tend to stockpile items like shampoo and cough medicine, often throwing things away when they expire. They feel stressed by having too much stuff and insufficient storage. Underbuyers, meanwhile, often scramble to purchase necessities like winter coats after they're needed and resist buying specialized items. Interestingly, underbuyers can still accumulate clutter because they're reluctant to discard anything that might be useful someday. A friend of Rubin's represents another important distinction - she maintains a beautifully organized house except for the entryway, which is chaotic with shoes, backpacks, and sports equipment. The reason? She simply doesn't care about that particular area. This illustrates an essential principle: focus your organizing efforts on the spaces that matter most to your happiness. For couples or families sharing space, Rubin notes that people often have different clutter thresholds. Some are genuinely "clutter-blind" - they don't notice or care about disorder that drives others crazy. Understanding these differences can reduce conflict and lead to more effective solutions, like creating designated spaces for each person's belongings or establishing "holding bins" where items can be temporarily corralled. When designing your systems, consider whether you're a "counter-filler" who likes to keep items visible and accessible, or a "counter-clearer" who prefers surfaces bare with items hidden away. Neither approach is inherently superior - what matters is that your system aligns with your preferences while still maintaining function and order. The most sustainable organizing systems don't force you to become someone else; they work with who you already are. By recognizing and honoring your tendencies, you can create lasting order without constant struggle.

Chapter 4: Establish Daily Habits That Maintain Order

The key to lasting order isn't heroic cleaning sessions but small, consistent habits that prevent clutter from accumulating in the first place. When these behaviors become automatic, maintaining order requires minimal conscious effort, freeing your mind and energy for more important matters. One of Rubin's most popular and effective strategies is the "one-minute rule" - do any task that can be finished in less than one minute without delay. Hang up a coat, read a letter and toss it, put the toothpaste back in the medicine cabinet, throw away a pen that doesn't work. Because these tasks are so quick, following this rule isn't particularly burdensome, yet the cumulative effect is remarkable. As Rubin observes, "It's amazing how much can get done, in one-minute increments, over the course of a few weeks." Another simple yet transformative habit is what Rubin calls "walking from room to room? Take one thing with you." Whenever you move between rooms, carry at least one item that belongs somewhere along your path. You don't even need to take it all the way to its final destination - just move it closer. When leaving the kitchen, take your sweater with you; don't take it all the way to your closet right now, just move it nearer to where it belongs. Little by little, things naturally migrate to their proper places. Rubin shares the story of a friend who was furious with her father and channeled that energy into cleaning her office. The gentle activity of sorting, tossing, and organizing helped calm her down. This illustrates how establishing order can function as an emotional regulation tool - when you're feeling angry, anxious, or unhappy, creating order in your surroundings often creates a sense of calm within. For those who struggle with sleep, Rubin suggests clearing clutter during wakeful periods. Rather than tossing and turning, get up and spend twenty minutes putting things away. This quiet activity often proves calming enough to help you return to sleep, and even if you wake up tired the next morning, at least your space looks better. Perhaps the most fundamental habit is simply putting things away rather than putting them down. When you hear yourself saying, "I'll put this here and deal with it later," that's a warning sign. Those temporary placements often become permanent, creating the very clutter you're trying to avoid. Making the extra effort to put items in their proper homes immediately prevents the accumulation of random piles throughout your space. Remember Rubin's essential insight: "It's easier to keep up than catch up." By embedding these small habits into your daily routine, you maintain order with minimal effort, preventing the need for exhausting catch-up sessions later.

Chapter 5: Transform Cleared Spaces into Places of Beauty

Once you've cleared the clutter from your space, you have a wonderful opportunity to transform it into something truly beautiful and meaningful. Adding beauty isn't about expensive renovations or designer furnishings - it's about thoughtfully curating your environment to reflect your values and preferences. Rubin shares how she'd saved her delicate white wedding china for special occasions, using it only a handful of times during the first twenty years of her married life. She was afraid of breaking a plate or chipping a bowl. Finally, she decided to face her fear, use the china, and enjoy it as long as it lasted. This illustrates what she calls "spending out" - putting beautiful possessions to use rather than saving them for some hypothetical future occasion that may never arrive. A college friend of Rubin's had a similar realization about her apartment. After frantically cleaning to get her security deposit back, she told Rubin, "Don't wait to clean your apartment. I thought I didn't really like this place. But now that it's in such good shape, I realize how nice it was all along." Often, we think we need a drastic change like moving somewhere new, when simply creating order and beauty in our current space would dramatically improve our experience. Adding beauty can be as simple as arranging related items on a tray. Perfume bottles, spice jars, coffee-making supplies - nearly everything looks better when grouped together on a tray, basket, or plate. This simple technique pulls individual items into a pleasing collection and contains potential clutter in an aesthetically pleasing way. Bringing elements of nature indoors is another powerful way to enhance your space. Shells, pebbles, flowers, driftwood, or pinecones add a touch of organic beauty and remind us of the natural world's inherent order. Similarly, lighting candles creates instant elegance at minimal expense, with the flickering motion adding a sense of life and warmth to any room. Rubin also suggests creating a "signature color" that appears throughout your space. Cultivating a certain shade of chartreuse, aquamarine, olive, or slate makes decision-making easier and adds visual harmony to your home. Seeing splashes of a color you love naturally elevates your spirits and creates a sense of cohesion across different areas. Remember that transforming your space isn't about achieving some perfect Instagram-worthy aesthetic - it's about creating an environment that genuinely supports your happiness. As Rubin writes, quoting Isak Dinesen: "Probably one can say that all beautiful, noble, or brilliant works are of use, or that everything that proves to be useful or beneficial has its own beauty."

Chapter 6: Harness the Power of Visual Serenity

Visual noise affects us more profoundly than we realize. When our eyes constantly encounter disorder, our minds struggle to find peace. Creating visual serenity in our surroundings allows our attention to rest and our thoughts to clarify, contributing significantly to our sense of inner calm. Rubin observes how certain areas become "clutter magnets" - places where disorder naturally accumulates. In her childhood home, it was the dining room table; in her current apartment, it's the chest of drawers in the hallway, a certain chair in the bedroom, and the kitchen table. She's learned that clutter attracts more clutter, so once things begin to accumulate in an area, the situation tends to worsen rapidly. By identifying your personal clutter magnets and clearing them regularly, you prevent the slow creep of visual chaos. When sharing space with others, visual clutter can become a source of tension. Rubin describes what she calls the "tragedy of the messy commons" - when several people use one space and no one person is responsible for maintaining order, people tend to become careless. This pattern is particularly problematic in office kitchens, mail areas, and conference rooms. The most effective solution is to officially assign specific responsibility for maintaining order in each area. For areas that inevitably accumulate necessary items, Rubin suggests bringing "quiet to visual noise." A refrigerator door plastered with school schedules, children's artwork, expired coupons, and rubbery magnets creates visual cacophony even if the rest of the kitchen is immaculate. Similarly, a computer screen framed with dozens of sticky notes produces mental static. Reducing this visual noise creates a more serene environment. Rubin shares her personal practice of maintaining both "an empty shelf" and "a junk drawer" somewhere in her home. The empty shelf provides the luxury of space - room for new things to enter her life and a visually restful area that feels almost decadent. The junk drawer, meanwhile, accommodates items without obvious homes, preventing them from cluttering visible surfaces. This balance between pristine order and practical accommodation creates a livable harmony. When establishing visual serenity, protecting what Rubin calls "prime real estate" becomes essential. A desk represents extremely valuable territory, so be selective about what occupies its surface and easily accessible drawers. Unless you consult a book daily, don't leave it on your desk. If you have three boxes of favorite pens, don't store them in your top drawer. Reserving prime locations for truly essential items creates functional efficiency and visual calm. The power of visual serenity extends beyond aesthetics - it fundamentally affects how we think and feel. As Rubin notes, "Our rooms shape our thoughts, and our possessions change our moods." By creating environments with less visual noise, we give our minds the space to focus, create, and rest.

Chapter 7: Find Joy in What You Choose to Keep

The ultimate goal of creating outer order isn't simply having less stuff - it's surrounding yourself with possessions that genuinely enhance your life and bring you joy. When everything you own serves a purpose or sparks happiness, your relationship with your possessions transforms from burden to blessing. Marie Kondo's question "Does this spark joy?" resonated with many of Rubin's readers. While Rubin personally found the concept of "joy" somewhat confusing when applied to practical items like a vegetable peeler, she suggests an alternative question that might work better for some people: "Does this energize me?" Both questions aim at the same essential truth - our possessions should add value to our lives rather than draining our energy. Rubin shares a poignant insight about why we sometimes struggle to part with certain possessions. Quoting philosopher Adam Smith, she notes that when an object has done us great service, we become reluctant to discard it. She experienced this herself with her old laptops: "They worked so hard for me; we've had so many good times together." To honor these faithful servants while still moving forward, she took photographs of them as mementos before sending them on their way. This practice of taking photographs can be particularly helpful with children's mementos. Rather than keeping every finger painting your child ever created, you might frame one favorite masterpiece and photograph the rest. This allows you to preserve the memories without the physical clutter, and often, having fewer mementos actually helps us hold onto more memories than having many mementos does. Rubin emphasizes that mementos should be carefully chosen - they should actually hold memories for you personally. Sometimes we keep items out of obligation: a mug with photos of colleagues from ten years ago whose names we no longer remember, or family photographs of people we don't recognize. Don't save mementos that hold no meaning; keep only those keepsakes that genuinely evoke important memories. The most profound insight Rubin offers about our possessions comes in her conclusion: "When your parents are driving you crazy because they've kept every piece of your schoolwork back to kindergarten, or when you're driving yourself crazy because you can't bring yourself to toss your husband's ragged college T-shirts, remember: All this junk is an expression of love." This compassionate perspective helps us approach our own clutter - and others' - with greater kindness and understanding. By choosing to keep only what truly matters and letting go of the rest with gratitude, we create spaces that reflect our authentic selves and support our highest aspirations. The joy comes not from having perfect spaces, but from having spaces perfectly suited to who we are.

Summary

Outer order contributes to inner calm in ways that seem disproportionate to its importance. When we clear the physical clutter from our surroundings, we often experience a remarkable shift in our mental and emotional landscapes. As Rubin eloquently puts it, "Getting control of our possessions makes us feel more in control of our fates. If this is an illusion, it's a helpful illusion—and it's a more pleasant way to live." The process of making thoughtful choices about our possessions, creating systems that work with our tendencies, establishing helpful habits, and adding beauty to our spaces creates a virtuous cycle where order fosters calm and calm fosters order. The journey to outer order isn't about achieving some arbitrary standard of minimalism or perfection—it's about wanting what we have and having what we want. Take a moment today to tackle just one small area of disorder in your surroundings. Clear a drawer, organize a shelf, or simply follow the one-minute rule for the next few hours. Notice how this small action affects your mood and energy. Remember that creating outer order isn't an end in itself but a pathway to greater happiness and fulfillment—a means of creating space for what truly matters in your life.

About Author

Loading...

Gretchen Rubin

Out now: "Secrets of Adulthood"The #1 New York Times bestselling author of The Happiness Project and Better Than Before distills her key insights into simple truths for living with greater satisfaction, clarity, and happiness. Order your copy of "Secrets of Adulthood" today. Author BioGretchen Rubin is one of today’s most influential and thought-provoking observers of happiness and human nature. She’s the author of many New York Times bestselling books, such as The Happiness Project, Better Than Before, and The Four Tendencies, Life in Five Senses, and Secrets of Adulthood, which have sold millions of copies in more than thirty languages. Her next book Secrets of Adulthood comes out April 2025.She’s the host of the popular, award-winning podcast Happier with Gretchen Rubin, where she and her co-host (and sister) Elizabeth Craft explore strategies and insights about how to make life happier. As the founder of The Happiness Project, she has helped create imaginative products for people to use in their own happiness projects.She has been interviewed by Oprah, eaten dinner with Nobel Prize-winner Daniel Kahneman, walked arm-in-arm with the Dalai Lama, had her work reported on in a medical journal, been written up in the New Yorker, and been an answer on Jeopardy!Gretchen Rubin started her career in law, and she realized she wanted to be a writer while she was clerking for Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor. Raised in Kansas City, she lives in New York City with her family.

Read more

Related Books by Gretchen Rubin

Loading...

Better Than Before

Gretchen Rubin

Mastering the Habits of Our Everyday Lives

★★★½☆3.8

Loading...

The Happiness Project

Gretchen Rubin

Or, Why I Spent a Year Trying to Sing in the Morning, Clean My Closets, Fight Right, Read Aristotle, and Generally Have More Fun

★★★½☆3.6

Loading...

The Four Tendencies

Gretchen Rubin

The Indispensable Personality Profiles That Reveal How to Make Your Life Better (and Other People’s Lives Better, Too)

★★★½☆3.8